Results of the ASTM Nuclear Methods intercomparison on NIST apple and peack leaves standard reference materials

The ASTM Task Group on Nuclear Methods of Chemical Analysis (E10.05.12) has conducted a trace element intercomparison among some of its members over the past two years. Eight non-NIST laboratories submitted data using nuclear techniques, with a total of 111 values for the apple leaves and 116 values for the peach leaves, on 46 and 50 elements, respectively. This intercomparison provided a unique opportunity for the analytical laboratories, because the analytical values submitted could be later compared to the NIST certified values. For the seven elements which were certified by NIST and had three or more intercomparison values, the results showed that: 1) 61% of all 56 intercomparison values submitted had results whose stated uncertainty overlapped the uncertainty limits of the NIST certified values, and 2) less than 6% of the intercomparison values had means which fell outside ±20% of the NIST values. In general, the intercomparison values submitted showed excellent agreement with the NIST values. However, many reported uncertainties accompanying intercomparison values appeared overly optimistic.     

Interlaboratory comparison study for the determination of halogenated hydrocarbons in water

Sixty laboratories of five different countries participated in a large-scale interlaboratory comparison test for the determination of halogenated hydrocarbons in water. Participants used their in-house method with 44 laboratories applying head space GC ECD analysis and 5 using liquid/liquid extraction. A set of two artificially produced samples was prepared; the halogenated hydrocarbons investigated were trichloroethylene, tetrachloroethylene, 1,1,1-trichloroethane, trichloromethane, tetrachloromethane, 1,1-dichloroethylene, dichloromethane, dibromochloromethane, bromodichloromethane, 1,2-dichloroethane and tribromomethane. The procedure of sample preparation, storage and distribution was monitored by an extensive quality assurance system including homogeneity tests, stability tests, and trend analysis of the submitted data. The analytical results submitted by the participants exhibited RSD values of up to 35% and outlier rates of up to 19%. The percentage of false positive and false negative results was at the highest 12% for selected substances. Recovery rates varying from 86% to 106% proved the correctness of the analytical results submitted by the participants and showed that the procedure developed in this study for sample preparation and distribution is well suited for the performance of large-scale interlaboratory comparison tests of halogenated hydrocarbons in water.     

Interlaboratory comparison study for the determination of halogenated hydrocarbons in water

Sixty laboratories of five different countries participated in a large-scale interlaboratory comparison test for the determination of halogenated hydrocarbons in water. Participants used their in-house method with 44 laboratories applying head space GC ECD analysis and 5 using liquid/liquid extraction. A set of two artificially produced samples was prepared; the halogenated hydrocarbons investigated were trichloroethylene, tetrachloroethylene, 1,1,1-trichloroethane, trichloromethane, tetrachloromethane, 1,1-dichloroethylene, dichloromethane, dibromochloromethane, bromodichloromethane, 1,2-dichloroethane and tribromomethane. The procedure of sample preparation, storage and distribution was monitored by an extensive quality assurance system including homogeneity tests, stability tests, and trend analysis of the submitted data. The analytical results submitted by the participants exhibited RSD values of up to 35% and outlier rates of up to 19%. The percentage of false positive and false negative results was at the highest 12% for selected substances. Recovery rates varying from 86% to 106% proved the correctness of the analytical results submitted by the participants and showed that the procedure developed in this study for sample preparation and distribution is well suited for the performance of large-scale interlaboratory comparison tests of halogenated hydrocarbons in water. Received: 7 December 1998 / Revised: 23 March 1999 / Accepted: 24 March 1999     

Assessment of the ICP-MS method using the interlaboratory QA study of two Polish soil RMs

 Under an international collaborative certification programme, two new Polish soil reference materials, PL-1 (loess) and BPGM-1 (sandy loam soil), were analysed for 34 trace elements including all the rare earth elements using the acid decomposition method and inductively coupled plasma - mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). After the certification by the organisers, the analytical data obtained at our institute were compared with the certified data. 'Z-score' values calculated for individual trace elements helped in the assessment of the quality of the data. While the majority of the data obtained on ICP-MS was very precise and accurate, some of the data especially for elements such as Zr, Hf and Nb suffered from incomplete dissolution of the sample and spectroscopic interferences. For some trace elements, certified data are not available for comparison. These features together with the usefulness of interlaboratory collaborative programmes and ICP-MS for the certification of soil reference materials are discussed. Received: 6 August 1999 / Accepted: 28 February 2000     

Performance of total reflection and grazing emission X-ray fluorescence spectrometry for the determination of trace metals in drinking water in relation to other analytical techniques

An intercomparison survey has been carried out in order to evaluate the performance of two related X-ray fluorescence techniques as compared to the achievements of several other analytical techniques applied for trace elements determination in drinking water. A relatively new technique, total reflection X-ray fluorescence (TXRF) and a novel related technique, grazing emission X-ray fluorescence (GEXRF) have been used for the analysis of a mineral water sample. The concentrations of the following elements have been determined: Na, Mg, K, Ca, Ni, Cu, Zn and Sr. The mineral water sample has also been analyzed by a number of other analytical techniques, routinely utilized in drinking water quality control. The analyses were performed in eleven laboratories which reported 286 individual determinations producing 75 laboratory means. From the obtained results, it can be concluded that the TXRF technique is suitable for a direct determination of heavy elements in drinking water (above potassium, Z = 19). This technique can compete with other analytical techniques routinely used in water quality monitoring. First results obtained with GEXRF spectrometry show that this technique can be successfully applied for the determination of low-Z elements in drinking water. However, results for sodium and magnesium were systematically too low, indicating that modifications of the quantification procedure may be required to improve the accuracy of determination for these light elements. Received: 5 January 1998 / Revised: 17 February 1998 / Accepted: 18 February 1998     

Inter-laboratory comparisons: Determination of actinides in excreta

Inter-laboratory tests are a means of assessing the analytical coherence of medical laboratories. In radiotoxicology, this kind of exercise makes it possible to keep up with laboratory know-how and with the evolution and relative performances of analytical techniques (precision and reproducibility). However, the goal of the laboratories taking part in these annual exercises is not only to check the accuracy of their results. The analytical discussions and the chance to compare experiences enrich the group's general competence.French biologists have been organizing annual radiotoxicology intercomparison exercises since 1978. The exercises are carried out within the framework of a working group (GT1) operating under the aegis of the French Atomic Energy Commission's (CEA) Medical Coordinator. Using reports and diagrams which present the results obtained by the participants in the form of syntheses, the authors describe how the exercises for determining actinides in excreta (urine and faeces) are organized, how the results are evaluated in terms of the analytical methods used, and the improvements made in analytical and metrological performance.Up until 1985, these exercises were limited to French laboratories. Since then, the exercises have acquired an international dimension, opening up to include interested foreign radiochemists, initially from European laboratories, and now from laboratories worldwide. At the present time, 35 laboratories representing 9 countries take part regularly in these intercomparison exercises.     

Focused microwave-assisted digestion of vegetal materials for the determination of essential mineral nutrients

An open focused microwave-assisted digestion procedure has been developed to decompose and dissolve vegetal matrices for subsequent macro- and micronutrients analysis. The parameters of the microwave oven were evaluated using an experimental design. Sulfuric acid (5 mL) and hydrogen peroxide (3 mL) were found to be suitable for quantitative determination of Ca, Cu, Fe, K, Mg, Mn, N, P, and Zn in 0.100-0.500 g of vegetal sample. The precision was better than 6% for all elements at different concentrations. Results for reference and laboratory control materials are in agreement with certified and indicative values. In addition, the sample digest could be used for ICP-OES of all the elements mentioned. The proposed microwave-assisted digestion procedure offers the ability to determine the most important essential plant nutrients in one unique solution by means of analytical techniques usually found in most laboratories.     

Performance of total reflection and grazing emission X-ray fluorescence spectrometry for the determination of trace metals in drinking water in relation to other analytical techniques

An intercomparison survey has been carried out in order to evaluate the performance of two related X-ray fluorescence techniques as compared to the achievements of several other analytical techniques applied for trace elements determination in drinking water. A relatively new technique, total reflection X-ray fluorescence (TXRF) and a novel related technique, grazing emission X-ray fluorescence (GEXRF) have been used for the analysis of a mineral water sample. The concentrations of the following elements have been determined: Na, Mg, K, Ca, Ni, Cu, Zn and Sr. The mineral water sample has also been analyzed by a number of other analytical techniques, routinely utilized in drinking water quality control. The analyses were performed in eleven laboratories which reported 286 individual determinations producing 75 laboratory means. From the obtained results, it can be concluded that the TXRF technique is suitable for a direct determination of heavy elements in drinking water (above potassium, Z = 19). This technique can compete with other analytical techniques routinely used in water quality monitoring. First results obtained with GEXRF spectrometry show that this technique can be successfully applied for the determination of low-Z elements in drinking water. However, results for sodium and magnesium were systematically too low, indicating that modifications of the quantification procedure may be required to improve the accuracy of determination for these light elements.     

Determination of volatile elements in biological materials by isotopic dilution ETV-ICP-MS after dissolution with tetramethylammonium hydroxide or acid digestion

Isotopic dilution for the determination of Ag, Cd, Hg, Pb and Tl in biological materials by ETV-ICP-MS is proposed. The sample was simply dissolved with tetramethylammonium hydroxide (TMAH) or acid digested in a microwave furnace, with an on line matrix separation. When the dissolution was employed, Ir was used as a chemical modifier for Hg and Pb and Pd was used for Cd and Tl. No modifier was used for Ag. The pyrolysis temperatures were taken from pyrolysis temperature curves. The on line preconcentration was performed in a flow injection system with solenoid valves and was based on the analyte complexation with ammonium diethyldithiophosphate and sorption of the complexes on C(18) bonded to silica gel in a minicolumn. For the digested sample submitted to the analyte preconcentration procedure, a modifier, Ir, was only used for Hg. For the other analytes, since a low pyrolysis temperature, 300 degrees C, was employed, no modifier was added. The isotopic dilution calibration was applied to two certified materials, bovine liver and dog fish muscle, dissolved with TMAH or acid digested, and to another two certified materials, corn bran and rice flour, acid digested and submitted to analyte preconcentration. The obtained concentration values agree with the certified ones, showing that this calibration procedure leads to accurate results in the determination of low concentrations of volatile elements. Due to simplicity, the dissolution with TMAH is very attractive.     

Interlaboratory study to improve the quality of trace element determinations in rainwater

This is the first publication which describes the development of a reference material (RM) for the determination of 11 trace elements (Cu, Pb, Mn, Ni, Zn, Fe, Cd, Co, V, As and Al) in rainwater at microgram per liter concentrations. An interlaboratory comparison study for the determination of trace elements in rainwater was carried out for material performance studies to establish analyte concentrations with a stated uncertainty. Fifteen reputed laboratories from Asia, Europe and North America participated in the study. These laboratories used their regular in-house methods to analyze the rainwater samples. The aim of this study is to establish concentration levels of trace elements in rainwater based on interlaboratory study results. Details of the production, homogeneity and stability of the reference sample are given in this article. The organization of the study and the quality assurance measures undertaken at the organizer's laboratory are described. The analytical results obtained from individual laboratories and the analytical methods used for the determination of trace elements in rainwater are discussed. Based on the results obtained from the intercomparison study, certified values as well as informative values are assigned to the 11 trace elements in rainwater.     

Analysis of interlaboratory performance in the determination of total selenium in water

This study explored the performance of experienced laboratories in the analysis for total selenium in water by a variety of analytical methods. The goal of the study was to examine intra- and interlaboratory variability. Replicates (n = 7) of 7 sample types that included a reference material of known Se concentration, natural waters, and treated wastewaters were submitted to 7 laboratories with prequalified Se analytical experience. Results of the study indicated wide ranges in minimum and maximum results, distinct differences in laboratory precision, and routine reporting of numerical results below statistical limits of quantitation. Hydride generation as a sample introduction technique demonstrated superior performance. In general, the study supports a caution advisory about using low-level Se data, especially results lower than about 10 micrograms Se/L, without quantitating the statistical uncertainty of the data. Because this study used data from samples that were submitted in bulk to participating laboratories prequalified for Se analytical expertise and experience, it can be considered a best-case demonstration of performance.     

Analysis of sample of highly water-soluble Th-symmetric fullerenehexamalonic acid C66(COOH)12 by ion-chromatography and capillary electrophoresis

Ion chromatography (IC) was used to establish isomer purity of the highly water-soluble sample of fullerenehexamalonic acid, Th-symmetric hexakis-adduct C66(COOH)12. Sharp and symmetric peaks were obtained by IC using 1.0 M potassium hydroxide as eluent and applying gradient elution program. The identity of the two largest peaks in the chromatogram was assigned to Th-C66(COOH)12 and C66H(COOH)11. The developed IC procedure can be used for the semi-quantitative determination of the extent of the partial decarboxylation of the sample. As an alternative analytical technique, a CE procedure was introduced and its performance against IC was compared for this particular case.     

Analysis of pure copper – a comparison of analytical methods

The reliability and performance of various analytical methods for the determination of 22 trace elements in pure copper is compared and discussed. The work was performed in the framework of an interlaboratory comparison for the preparation of four pure copper reference materials with graded element mass fractions of Ag, Al, As, Bi, Cd, Co, Cr, Fe, Mg, Mn, Ni, P, Pb, S, Sb, Se, Si, Sn, Te, Ti, Zn, and Zr. Special analytical results (ET-AAS, ICP-MS) obtained by the authors were described in more detail and were compared to the certified values. Special regard was paid to the influence of the copper matrix on performance and sensitivity of each analytical method and to the dissolution procedure of copper matrix and interferences from insoluble residues. For a generalized evaluation of the figures of merit for each applied elemental analytical method results from several independent laboratories were included in the discussion. Correspondence: Britta Lange, Department of Analytical Chemistry, Reference Materials, Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM), Richard-Willstaetter-Str. 11, D-12489 Berlin, Germany     

Multielement analysis of coal by ICP techniques using solution nebulization and laser ablation

The combination of inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry and high resolution inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry for the determination of 70 elements in coal were studied. Four microwave-assisted digestion procedures with different dissolution mixtures (nitric and hydrofluoric acids, aqua regia and hydrogen peroxide), lithium metaborate fusion with and without previous sample ashing as well as direct sampling by laser ablation (LA) have been tested. Examples of spectral interferences are given and different correction procedures are discussed. Detection limits in the low ng g(-1) range were obtained for most of the elements investigated by using high-purity reagents and by taking special care to prevent sample contamination during preparation. The precision was assessed from replicate analysis (including sample preparation) of coal samples and was found to be, as average values far all elements, 4-5% RSD and 10-15% RSD for procedures including sample digestion and LA sampling, respectively. The accuracy of the overall analytical procedures was estimated by analysis of certified reference materials and of a coal sample obtained from the Interlab Trace round robin test. Among the dissolution mixtures tested, the combination of nitric and hydrofluoric acids with hydrogen peroxide provide the best agreement with certified, recommended, literature-compiled or consensus values, though fusion is necessary to obtain quantitative recoveries for Si, Cr, Hf, W, Zr, Y. In general, results obtained by LA fall within +/-20% of those obtained after digestion.     

Certification of a new selenized yeast reference material (SELM-1) for methionine, selenomethinone and total selenium content and its use in an intercomparison exercise for quantifying these analytes

A new selenized yeast reference material (SELM-1) produced by the Institute for National Measurement Standards, National Research Council of Canada (INMS, NRC) certified for total selenium (2,059±64 mg kg⁻¹), methionine (Met, 5,758±277 mg kg⁻¹) and selenomethionine (SeMet, 3,431±157 mg kg⁻¹) content is described. The ±value represents an expanded uncertainty with a coverage factor of 2. SeMet and Met amount contents were established following a methanesulfonic acid digestion of the yeast using GC-MS and LC-MS quantitation. Isotope dilution (ID) calibration was used for both compounds, using ¹³C-labelled SeMet and Met. Total Se was determined after complete microwave acid digestion based on ID ICP-MS using a ⁸²Se spike or ICP-OES spectrometry using external calibration. An international intercomparison exercise was piloted by NRC to assess the state-of-the-art of measurement of selenomethione in SELM-1. Determination of total Se and methionine was also attempted. Seven laboratories submitted results (2 National Metrology Institutes (NMIs) and 5 university/government laboratories). For SeMet, ten independent mean values were generated. Various acid digestion and enzymatic procedures followed by LC ICP-MS, LC AFS or GC-MS quantitation were used. Four values were based on species-specific ID calibration, one on non-species-specific ID with the remainder using standard addition (SA) or external calibration (EC). For total selenium, laboratories employed various acid digestion procedures followed by ICP-MS, AFS or GC-MS quantitation. Four laboratories employed ID calibration, the remaining used SA or EC. A total of seven independent results were submitted. Results for methionine were reported by only three laboratories, all of which used various acid digestion protocols combined with determination by GC-MS and LC UV. The majority of participants submitted values within the certified range for SeMet and total Se, whereas the intercomparison was judged unsuccessful for Met because only two external laboratories provided values, both of which were outside the certified range.     

Dissolution problems with botanical reference materials

Summary As part of the analytical research leading to the certification of the new Apple and Peach Leaves Standard Reference Materials (SRMs), a study was undertaken to evaluate different sample dissolution techniques for losses of analyte species. Possible loss mechanisms include absorption or adsorption of analyte elements at the walls of the sample decomposition vessels, and the formation or persistence of insoluble particulate material during sample dissolution. Results of this study indicated that significant fractions of some elements were present on particles after acid dissolution, despite visual indications that dissolution was complete. In addition, large amounts of some elements remained in the platinum crucibles used to fuse samples with lithium metaborate.     

International Measurement Evaluation Programme: IMEP-9, trace elements in water

The International Measurement Evaluation Programme (IMEP) is an interlaboratory comparison scheme, founded, owned and coordinated by the Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM) since 1988. IMEP-9 is the third round of trace elements in water evaluation following IMEP-3 and IMEP-6. Reference values for 15 elements stating total concentrations and combined uncertainties (according to GUM) were established. The reference values were established mainly by isotope dilution mass spectrometry (IDMS) as a primary method of measurement, and values traceable to the SI were obtained. The four elements that could not be certified by IDMS were assigned values by means of other measurement techniques. Results from 201 laboratories from 35 countries and four continents were evaluated against the reference values and the comparability between the laboratories is presented graphically.     

In vivo evaluation of CYP1A2, CYP2A6, NAT-2 and xanthine oxidase activities in a Greek population sample by the RP-HPLC monitoring of caffeine metabolic ratios

A RP-HPLC method was developed for the assessment of caffeine and its metabolites in urine and was used for the evaluation of the CYP1A2, CYP2A6, xanthine oxidase (XO) and N-acetyl-transferase-2 (NAT-2) in vivo activities in 44 Greek volunteers (21 men, 23 women). Spot urine samples were analyzed 6 h after 200 mg caffeine consumption, following a 30 h methylxantine-free diet. The major urinary caffeine metabolites are 1-methyluric acid (1U), 5-acetylamino-6-formylamino-3-methyluracil (AFMU), 1-methylxanthine (1X), 1,7-dimethyluric acid (17U) and 1,7-dimethylxanthine (17X). CYP1A2, CYP2A6, XO and NAT-2 activities were estimated from the metabolic ratios (AFMU + 1U + 1X)/17U, 17U/17X, 1U/(1X + 1U) and AFMU/(AFMU + 1U + 1X), respectively. Metabolites and internal standard were extracted with chloroform/isopropanol (85:15, v/v) and separated on a C18 column by an isocratic HPLC system using a two-step elution with manual switch from solvent A (0.1% acetic acid-methanol-acetonitrile, 92:4:5 v/v) to solvent B (0.1% acetic acid-methanol, 60:40, v/v), and detected at 280 nm. The method exhibited adequate metabolite separation (resolution factors >1.48), accuracy (94.1-106.3%) and intraday and interday precision <8.02 and <8.78%, respectively (n = 6). Smoking affected only CYP1A2, whereas gender had no effect in any enzyme activity. NAT-2 exhibited bimodal distribution, 63.6% of volunteers being slow acetylators. The developed RP-HPLC method was fully validated and successfully applied for the evaluation of CYP1A2, CYP2A6, XO and NAT-2 activities.     

Certification of trace and major elements and methylmercury concentrations in a macroalgae (Fucus sp.) reference material, IAEA-140

A marine reference material, IAEA-140, prepared with a macroalgae (Fucus sp.) was recently produced by the International Atomic Energy Agency and certified for trace and major elements and for methylmercury (MeHg). Certification of this material was achieved as an outcome of an international analytical intercomparison study which resulted in 116 independent sets of results reported by participants from 54 countries. The statistical evaluation of the collected data and the criteria used for assignment of the mean and uncertainty values are described. The analysis of data allowed to certify concentration values for 24 elements and MeHg, and to provide information values for another 10 elements. Regarding the elements which could be given certified values, between two and eight different instrumental methods were used to measure metal concentrations, and four independent analytical procedures were used to measure MeHg concentrations. In order to assess the results of the certification procedure, a comparison was made between the certified values obtained from the world-wide intercomparison results and the values obtained from a small subgroup of well-qualified laboratories. The means and 95% confidence intervals for reference values obtained by the two methods are similar for most elements showing that the usual method of certification used by the IAEA, based on large groups of participants, is indeed pertinent.     

Analysis of a copper alloy: Comité Consultatif pour la Quantite de Matière (CCQM) pilot study P76 international intercomparison

The capabilities of National Metrology Institutes (NMIs) and selected outside “expert” laboratories of determining the mass fractions of the main and minor elements Cu, Pb, Sn, Fe, and Ni in a lead-containing brass were assessed. This pilot study P76 was organized as an activity of the Inorganic Analysis Working Group of CCQM and was piloted by the Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM). In total 12 laboratories (four NMIs and eight outside labs) submitted results, some of them more than one set of results per element. The laboratories were free to choose any analytical method they wanted to use for the analysis. Consequently various methods of measurement were employed: inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP–OES), inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP–MS), instrumental neutron-activation analysis (INAA), titrimetry, flame atomic-absorption spectrometry (FAAS), spectrophotometry (MAS), electrogravimetry, and gravimetric analysis. After testing for homogeneity within BAM, a certified reference material of lead-containing brass was used as test sample without informing the participants about the source of the material. The agreement of the results for all elements investigated was acceptable and mean values calculated from the results of all participants were close to the certified mass fractions of the CRM used as test sample. No statistically significant differences between the results of the NMIs and those of the non-NMIs could be observed.