Measurement of relaxation times in extensional flow of weakly viscoelastic polymer solutions

The characterization of the extensional rheology of polymeric solutions is important in several applications and industrial processes. Filament stretching and capillary breakup rheometers have been developed to characterize the extensional properties of polymeric solutions, mostly for high-viscosity fluids. However, for low concentration polymer solutions, the measurements are difficult using available devices, in terms of the minimum viscosity and relaxation times that can be measured accurately. In addition, when the slow retraction method is used, solvent evaporation can affect the measurements for volatile solvents. In this work, a new setup was tested for filament breakup experiments using the slow retraction method, high-speed imaging techniques, and an immiscible oil bath to reduce solvent evaporation and facilitate particle tracking in the thinning filament. Extensional relaxation times above around 100 μs were measured with the device for dilute and semi-dilute polymer solutions. Particle tracking velocimetry was also used to measure the velocity in the filament and the corresponding elongation rate, and to compare with the values obtained from the measured exponential decay of the filament diameter.     

Dynamics of worm-like micelles: the Cox–Merz rule

The viscoelastic behaviour of worm-like micelles in small-amplitude oscillatory, steady simple shear and uniaxial extensional flows are analyzed with a model that couples the Oldroyd-B constitutive equation with a kinetic equation that accounts for the structural changes induced by the flow. In some cases, the constitutive equation predicts a viscoelastic behaviour that is consistent with the Cox–Merz rule. Departures from this rule are also predicted. Experimental data obtained for two worm-like micellar systems indicate that in these solutions, the Cox–Merz rule is not usually followed, in agreement with the predictions of our model. In uniaxial extensional flow, the model predicts a strain hardening in the extensional viscosity at low extensional rates and a strain-thinning at high extensional rates.     

The rheology of bread dough made from four commercial flours

 A selection of four commercial flours has been subjected to extensive rheological measurements as part of a comprehensive program of wheat improvement. The results have been used to determine which of the many types of rheological measurements provide significant discrimination between various types of modern baker's flours (including biscuit flours) and to procure data suitable for use in mathematical models describing the dough rheology. The rheological measurements undertaken include oscillatory shear at low amplitude, steady shear at a low shear rate, stress relaxation and extensional viscosity testing. Although oscillatory shear data show minor differences between these flours, the other tests show significant variations and these provide very good discrimination between the different flour types in comparison with conventional dough testing (e.g. by the extensograph). The current dough rheological measurements provide further insight into molecular structure. In the future, mathematical (constitutive) models are expected to provide a means of predicting processing and baking behaviour of bread dough. Received: 27 June 2001 Accepted: 28 August 2001     

A new look at extensional rheology of low-density polyethylene

The nonlinear rheology of three selected commercial low-density polyethylenes (LDPE) is measured in uniaxial extensional flow. The measurements are performed using three different devices including an extensional viscosity fixture (EVF), a homemade filament stretching rheometer (DTU-FSR) and a commercial filament stretching rheometer (VADER-1000). We show that the measurements from the EVF are limited by a maximum Hencky strain of 4, while the two filament stretching rheometers are able to probe the nonlinear behavior at larger Hencky strain values where the steady state is reached. With the capability of the filament stretching rheometers, we show that LDPEs with quite different linear viscoelastic properties can have very similar steady extensional viscosity. This points to the potential for independently controlling shear and extensional rheology in certain rate ranges.     

Is there a relation between the relaxation time measured in CaBER experiments and the first normal stress coefficient?

We investigate a variety of different semidilute polymer solutions in shear and elongational flow. The shear flow is created in the cone-plate-geometry of a commercial rheometer. We use capillary thinning of a filament that is formed by a polymer solution in the Capillary Breakup Extensional Rheometer (CaBER) as an elongational flow. We compare the relaxation time measured in the CaBER with relaxation times based on the first normal stress difference and the zero shear polymer viscosity that we measure in our rheometer. All of these three measurable quantities depend on different fluid parameters—the viscosity of the solvent, the polymer concentration within the solution, and the molecular weight of the polymers—and on the shear rate (in the shear flow measurements). Nevertheless, we find that the first normal stress coefficient depends quadratically on the CaBER relaxation time. Several scaling laws are presented that could help to explain this empirical relation.     

Microsecond relaxation processes in shear and extensional flows of weakly elastic polymer solutions

In this paper, we introduce an experimental protocol to reliably determine extensional relaxation times from capillary thinning experiments of weakly elastic dilute polymer solutions. Relaxation times for polystyrene in diethyl phthalate solutions as low as 80?μ s are reported: the lowest relaxation times in uniaxial extensional flows that have been assessed so far. These data are compared to the linear viscoelastic relaxation times that are obtained from fitting the Zimm spectrum to high frequency oscillatory squeeze flow data measured with a piezo-axial vibrator (PAV). This comparison demonstrates that the extensional relaxation time reduced by the Zimm time, λ _ext/λ _z, is not solely a function of the reduced concentration c/c*, as is commonly stated in the literature: an additional dependence on the molecular weight is observed.     

The effect of step-stretch parameters on capillary breakup extensional rheology (CaBER) measurements

Extensional rheometry has only recently been developed into a commercially available tool with the introduction of the capillary breakup extensional rheometer (CaBER). CaBER is currently being used to measure the transient extensional viscosity evolution of mid to low-viscosity viscoelastic fluids. The elegance of capillary breakup extensional experiments lies in the simplicity of the procedure. An initial step-stretch is applied to generate a fluid filament. What follows is a self-driven uniaxial extensional flow in which surface tension is balanced by the extensional stresses resulting from the capillary thinning of the liquid bridge. In this paper, we describe the results from a series of experiments in which the step-stretch parameters of final length, and the extension rate of the stretch were varied and their effects on the measured extensional viscosity and extensional relaxation time were recorded. To focus on the parameter effects, well-characterized surfactant wormlike micelle solutions, polymer solutions, and immiscible polymer blends were used to include a range of characteristic relaxation times and morphologies. Our experimental results demonstrate a strong dependence of extensional rheology on step-stretch conditions for both wormlike micelle solutions and immiscible polymer blends. Both the extensional viscosity and extensional relaxation time of the wormlike micelle solutions were found to decrease with increasing extension rate and strain of the step-stretch. For the case of the immiscible polymer blends, fast step-stretches were found to result in droplet deformation and an overshoot in the extensional viscosity which increased with increasing strain rates. Conversely, the polymer solutions tested were found to be insensitive to step-stretch parameters. In addition, numerical simulations were performed using the appropriate constitutive models to assist in both the interpretation of the CaBER results and the optimization of the experimental protocol. From our results, it is clear that any rheological results obtained using the CaBER technique must be properly considered in the context of the stretch parameters and the effects that preconditioning has on viscoelastic fluids.     

Fiber spinning of very dilute solutions of polyacrylamide in water

The extensional viscometer developed earlier by the authors was refined and used to extend very dilute (50 ppm) solutions of polyacrylamide in distilled water. A slender liquid filament was stretched by the use of a suction device, and this resulted in the spinning of the fiber. By varying the volumetric flow rate and the filament length, stretch rates in the 100–1000 s⁻¹ range were easily obtained. The corresponding tensile stresses were very large, and these gave apparent extensional viscosities of the order of 200 P (20 Pa s). In contrast to this, the material functions in shear were difficult to measure, except for the shear viscosity which showed pronounced shear thinning. It was found that all the measurements, in shear as well as extension, could be explained based on the four constant Johnson-Segalman constitutive equation.     

Extensional rheology of concentrated poly(ethylene oxide) solutions

The shear and extensional rheology of three concentrated poly(ethylene oxide) solutions is examined. Shear theology including steady shear viscosity, normal stress difference and linear viscoelastic material functions all collapse onto master curves independent of concentration and temperature. Extensional flow experiments are performed in fiber spinning and opposed nozzles geometries. The concentration dependence of extensional behavior measured using both techniques is presented. The zero-shear viscosity and apparent extensional viscosities measured with both extensional rheometers exhibit a power law dependence with polymer concentration. Strain hardening in the fiber spinning device is found to be of similar magnitude for all test fluids, irrespective of strain rate. The opposed nozzle device measures an apparent extensional viscosity which is one order of magnitude smaller than the value determined with the fiber spinline device. This could be attributed to errors caused by shear, dynamic pressure, and the relatively small strains developed in the opposed nozzle device. This instrument cannot measure local kinematics or stresses, but averages these values over the non-homogenous flow field. These results show that it is not possible to measure the extensional viscosity of non-Newtonian and shear thinning fluids with this device. Fiber spin-line experiments are coupled with a momentum balance and constitutive model to predict stress growth and diameter profiles. A one-mode Giesekus model accurately captures the plateau values of steady and dynamic shear properties, but fails to capture the gradual shear thinning of viscosity. Giesekus model parameters determined from shear rheology are not capable of quantitatively predicting fiber spinline kinematics. However, model parameters fit to a single spinline experiment accurately predict stress growth behavior for different applied spinline tensions.     

Experimental investigations into an isothermal spinning threadline: Extensional rheology of a Separan AP 30 solution in glycerol and water

Summary Experimental observations on a steady isothermally extending filament of a water/glycerol solution of Separan AP 30 are presented. Photographic records were analysed to give filament diameter (and hence filament speed) as a function of distance below the extrusion die (a glass capillary). Measurements of inline tension were also made. When effects of weight, surface tension and air drag were accounted for, the extensional stress at every point along the filament could be calculated. Results for stress versus extension rate are presented for various flow situations.Independent rheogoniometric measurements of simple shear viscosity, first and second normal stress differences, and of a crude relaxation time were also made at comparable rates of deformation.Comparison shows that apparent extensional viscosities are several orders of magnitude larger than corresponding simple shear viscosities. After discussion, no conclusion can be drawn about what constitutive equation is most suitable to describe the results.An analysis to predict air drag is given.With 18 figures     

Shear and elongational flow behavior of acrylic thickener solutions. Part II: effect of gel content

We have investigated the effect of crosslink density on shear and elongational flow properties of alkali-swellable acrylic thickener solutions using a mixing series of the two commercial thickeners Sterocoll FD and Sterocoll D as model system. Linear viscoelastic moduli show a smooth transition from weakly elastic to gel-like behavior. Steady shear data are very well described by a single mode Giesekus model at all mixing ratios. Extensional flow behavior has been characterized using the CaBER technique. Corresponding decay of filament diameter is also well fitted by the Giesekus model, except for the highest crosslink densities, when filament deformation is highly non-uniform, but the non-linearity parameter α, which is independent of the mixing ratio, is two orders of magnitude higher in shear compared to elongational flow. Shear relaxation times increase by orders of magnitude, but the characteristic elongational relaxation time decreases weakly, as gel content increases. Accordingly, variation of gel content is a valuable tool to adjust the low shear viscosity in a wide range while keeping extensional flow resistance essentially constant.     

An intriguing empirical rule for computing the first normal stress difference from steady shear viscosity data for concentrated polymer solutions and melts

The Cox–Merz rule and Laun’s rule are two empirical relations that allow the estimation of steady shear viscosity and first normal stress difference, respectively, using small amplitude oscillatory shear measurements. The validity of the Cox–Merz rule and Laun’s rule imply an agreement between the linear viscoelastic response measured in small amplitude oscillatory shear and the nonlinear response measured in steady shear flow measurements. We show that by using a lesser-known relationship also proposed by Cox and Merz, in conjunction with Laun’s rule, a relationship between the rate-dependent steady shear viscosity and the first normal stress difference can be deduced. The new empirical relation enables a priori estimation of the first normal stress difference using only the steady flow curve (i.e., viscosity vs shear rate data). Comparison of the estimated first normal stress difference with the measured values for six different polymer solutions and melts show that the empirical rule provides values that are in reasonable agreement with measurements over a wide range of shear rates, thus deepening the intriguing connection between linear and nonlinear viscoelastic response of entangled polymeric materials.     

Numerical modelling of step–strain for stretched filaments

This article addresses the modelling of filament-stretching/step–strain deformation under viscoelastic capillary break-up configurations of the CaBER-type. Start-up, prior to step–strain, is conducted under constant stretch-rate synchronous plate retraction with impulsive sessation of plate motion. The study encompasses variation in material rheology, appealing to Oldroyd, Geisekus and Phan-Thien/Tanner-type models, which display differences in shear and extensional viscosity properties (shear thinning/extension hardening). Two different viscosity ratio settings are considered to reflect high- and low-solvent viscosity constituent components; the former representing typical Boger fluids, the latter high-polymer concentration fluids. We compare and contrast results for three alternative filament aspect ratios at the onset of step–strain. Throughout the step–strain period, we have been able to successfully capture such physical features as drainage to the filament feet, necking at the filament centre, and periods with travelling waves through the axial filament length. In addition, we have identified the suppressive influence that larger capillary forces have upon radial fluctuations, and the minor impact that gravitational forces have upon the ensuing deformation. From this study, estimates for rheometrical data have been derived in terms of characteristic material relaxation time and apparent extensional viscosity. The computational techniques employed include a compressed-mesh (CM) procedure, an Arbitrary Lagrangian–Eulerian scheme (ALE) and a free-surface particle tracking technique. Spatial discretisation of the problem is accomplished through a hybrid finite element/finite volume algorithm implemented in the form of a time-stepping incremental pressure-correction formulation.     

Extensional flow resistance of dilute polyacrylamide and surfactant solutions

The extensional flow behaviour of dilute aqueous solutions of a partiallyhy-drolyzed polyacrylamide and a surfactant were investigated in an extensional flow cell. The cell was designed such that fluids were subjected to steady shear before undergoing extensional motion in a converging channel. Extensional resistance was monitored by measuring the pressure drop through the channel. Such measurements were made over a range of extensional rates at fixed values of the upstream shear rate. Solutions of different concentrations were tested — up to 40 ppm of polyacrylamide and 450 ppm of surfactant — at various temperatures in the case of surfactant and for different types and amounts of salt in the case of polyacrylamide. Of the results, the more notable are that the extensional resistance of polyacrylamide solutions is affected much more by CaCl₂ than by NaCl and that surfactant solutions do not exhibit extensional resistance unless they are pre-sheared.     

Rheological behaviour of vitreous humour

The vitreous humour (VH) is a complex biofluid that occupies a large portion of the eyeball between the lens and the retina, and exhibits non-Newtonian rheological properties that are key for its function in the eye. It is often possible to distinguish two different phases in VH, known as liquid and gel phases (Sebag J Eye 1: 254–262, 1987). In this work, we present a detailed rheological characterisation of the two phases of the VH under shear and extensional flow conditions. Healthy New Zealand rabbit eyes were used to measure the surface tension and the shear and extensional rheological properties of VH in different phase conformations and at different times after dissection. The results show that VH liquid phase exhibits a surface tension of 47.8 mN/m, a shear thinning behaviour reaching a viscosity plateau around 10^?3 Pa s for shear rates above ~1000 s^?1, and an average relaxation time of 9.7 ms in extensional flow. Interestingly, both VH phases present higher storage modulus than loss modulus, and the measurements performed with VH gel phase 4?±?1 h after dissection exhibit the highest moduli values. The compliance measurements for the gel phase show a viscoelastic gel behaviour and that compliance values decrease substantially with time after dissection. Our results show that the two VH phases exhibit viscoelastic behaviour, but with distinct rheological characteristics, consistent with a gel phase mostly composed of collagen entangled by hyaluronan and a second phase mainly composed of hyaluronan in aqueous solution.     

Shear and extensional flow of polyacrylamide solutions

As part of an EEC Science Stimulation programme on extensional viscosity two major conferences were organised on the subject. The second of these was devoted to the results obtained on a standard fluid, M 1. The data obtained in shear flow was remarkably consistent from laboratory to laboratory. Extensional flow results presented quite a different picture. Using a series of nonequilibrium techniques such as the spinline rheometer, opposing jet, falling drop and converging flow, extensional viscosity results were obtained which differed by as much as two to three orders of magnitude. Nevertheless, it was apparent that consistancy did exist between similar techniques. It is in the context of this information that the measurements described below have been made.The shear and extensional flow properties of partially ionised polyacrylamide in solution at concentrations ranging from 5 ppm were measured. The method of solution preparation was found to have a profound effect on the behaviour of the solutions in shear flow. The influence of salt concentration and pH was investigated and is discussed in the context of molecular shape in solution.Extensional flow measurements, using the spinline rheometer, show that the solutions are strongly strain thickening even at concentrations as low as 5 ppm. These results are considered in the light of polymer entanglement and association in the strong flow field.Delivered as a Keynote Lecture at the Golden Jubilee Conference of the British Society of Rheology and Third European Rheology Conference, Edinburgh, 3–7 September, 1990.     

An experimental study on the flow behavior of micellar solutions

At higher concentration levels, the inner structure of micellar solutions cannot be detected directly by optical means. Nevertheless, the flow behavior of the micellar solutions reflects their micellar structures. Hence, in this study the material behavior of micellar surfactant solutions was investigated by rheometrical means in steady and oscillatory shear flows. The flow behavior of the solutions was found to be strongly dependent on the concentration of the surfactants. At very low concentrations, the surfactant solution shows Newtonian behavior. With increasing concentration, a transition to shear thinning behavior and increasing viscoelasticity was found. The complex material structure is modeled according to the flow behavior by discrete and continuous relaxation time spectra, depending on the concentration. Received: 3 May 2000/Accepted: 18 September 2000     

The triple jet: influence of shear history on the stretching of polymer solutions

A kerosene-based aircraft safety fuel and aqueous solutions of poly (ethylene oxide) and polyacrylamide are examined using the “triple jet” system. This device allows the solution to be stretched as it flows from a capillary tube and the axial stress, strain and strain rate in the liquid are measured.The shear history of the solution is altered by placing cylindrical inserts in the capillary tube. This is shown to have a large effect on the extensional behaviour of aircraft safety fuel, a moderate effect on the extensional behaviour of poly (ethylene oxide) solution and little effect on the behaviour of polyacrylamide solution. The extensional viscosity of the aircraft fuel is raised by an order of magnitude when a long period of high shear is used; the effects last for periods of up to one second, though traditional methods suggest a relaxation time of the order of 10^?3 seconds. A liquid of shear viscosity 4 centipoise may have an extensional viscosity of over 100 poise.Plots of the extensional modulus of the jet as a function of distance along the jet emphasize the importance of shear history for the first two types of solution and suggest that the latter stages of the stretching process are elastic in character. Typical extensional moduli for the solutions tested are in the range 1.3–5.0 × 10⁴ dyn.cm^?2.The relevance of the interplay between shearing and stretching flow to the phenomena of lubrication and turbulence suppression is mentioned.     

Experimental study on the capillary thinning of entangled polymer solutions

The transient elongation behavior of entangled polymer and wormlike micelles (WLM) solutions has been investigated using capillary breakup extensional rheometry (CaBER). The transient force ratio X = 0.713 reveals the existence of an intermediate Newtonian thinning region for polystyrene and WLM solutions prior to the viscoelastic thinning. The exponential decay of X(t) in the first period of thinning defines an elongational relaxation time λ _x which is equal to elongational relaxation time λ _e obtained from exponential diameter decay D(t) indicating that the initial stress decay is controlled by the same molecular relaxation process as the strain hardening observed in the terminal regime of filament thinning. Deviations in true and apparent elongational viscosity are discussed in terms of X(t). A minimum Trouton ratio is observed which decreases exponentially with increasing polymer concentration leveling off at Tr_min = 3 for the solutions exhibiting intermediate Newtonian thinning and Tr_min ≈ 10 otherwise. The relaxation time ratio λ _e/ λ _s, where λ _s is the terminal shear relaxation time, decreases exponentially with increasing polymer concentration and the data for all investigated solutions collapse onto a master curve irrespective of polymer molecular weight or solvent viscosity when plotted versus the reduced concentration c[ η], with [ η] being the intrinsic viscosity. This confirms the strong effect of the nonlinear deformation in CaBER experiments on entangled polymer solutions as suggested earlier. On the other hand, λ _e ≈λ _s is found for all WLM solutions clearly indicating that these nonlinear deformations do not affect the capillary thinning process of these living polymer systems.     

Rheological behaviour of nano-composites based on polyamide 6 under shear and elongational flow at high strain rates

In this work, the rheological behaviour of high molecular mass polyamide 6 (PA6)/organo-montmorillonite nano-composites, obtained via melt blending, was investigated under shear and extensional flow. Capillary rheometry was used for the measurement of high shear rate steady state shear viscosity and die entrance pressure losses; further, by the application of a converging flow method (Cogswell model) to these experimental results, elongational viscosity data were indirectly calculated. The extensional behaviour was directly investigated by means of melt spinning experiments, and data of apparent elongational viscosity were determined. The results evidenced that the presence of the organo-clay in filled PA6 melts modifies the rheological behaviour of the material, with respect to the unfilled polymer, in dependence on the type of flow experienced by the fluid. In shear flow, the nano-composites showed a slightly lower viscosity than neat PA6, whereas in elongation, they appeared much more viscous, in dependence on the organo-clay content.