Stress relaxation in polymer networks: equilibrium behavior and dynamics

The elastic and relaxational properties of a polymer network have been calculated using a stress based formulation based on the Rouse mode expansion [W. L. Vandoolaeghe and E. M. Terentjev, J. Chem. Phys. 123, 34902 (2005)]. In this article, we propose an improved Rouse mode expansion incorporating appropriate boundary conditions. In contrast to the previous work, this improved formulation provides a smooth crossover from the classical equilibrium result of rubber elasticity to the shorter-time-scale Rouse relaxation of a polymer melt. Our results are compared with the classical phantom network approach in equilibrium, as well as both equilibrium and dynamic elongation experiments. The model captures the qualitative features of the data well and some of the quantitative aspects, such as the exponents seen in the dynamic modulus G(omega).     

Equilibrium and dynamical properties of gaussian stiff chain molecules

We present a novel analytically tractable model for stiff chain molecules. The equilibrium distribution function of the chain is derived using the maximum-entropy principle. For that purpose, we first formulate a discrete chain model, where the connections of the points and the restriction on bending are taken into account via constraints. We then perform the limit to a continuous chain and show that the mean-square end-to-end distance and the radius of gyration of the continuous chain are identical with the same quantities of the Kratky-Porod wormlike chain. The dynamics of our chain is investigated in dilute solution without hydrodynamic interactions. The linear dynamical equation is solved by a normal mode analysis. We discuss the dependence of the relaxation times on the single parameter of the model, the persistence length. For small persistence lengths we obtain the well known relaxation times of the Rouse model. In the stiff-chain limit, we find the pure bending relaxation times and, in addition, the rotational relaxation time.     

Linear viscoelastic properties of transient networks formed by associating polymers with multiple stickers

We have developed a single-chain theory that describes dynamics of associating polymer chains carrying multiple associative groups (or stickers) in the transient network formed by themselves and studied linear viscoelastic properties of this network. It is shown that if the average number N of stickers associated with the network junction per chain is large, the terminal relaxation time τ(A) that is proportional to τ(X)N(2) appears. The time τ(X) is the interval during which an associated sticker goes back to its equilibrium position by one or more dissociation steps. In this lower frequency regime ω<1/τ(X), the moduli are well described in terms of the Rouse model with the longest relaxation time τ(A). The large value of N is realized for chains carrying many stickers whose rate of association with the network junction is much larger than the dissociation rate. This associative Rouse behavior stems from the association/dissociation processes of stickers and is different from the ordinary Rouse behavior in the higher frequency regime, which is originated from the thermal segmental motion between stickers. If N is not large, the dynamic shear moduli are well described in terms of the Maxwell model characterized by a single relaxation time τ(X) in the moderate and lower frequency regimes. Thus, the transition occurs in the viscoelastic relaxation behavior from the Maxwell-type to the Rouse-type in ω<1/τ(X) as N increases. All these results are obtained under the affine deformation assumption for junction points. We also studied the effect of the junction fluctuations from the affine motion on the plateau modulus by introducing the virtual spring for bound stickers. It is shown that the plateau modulus is not affected by the junction fluctuations.     

Theory of relaxation properties of two‐dimensional polymer networks, 2. Local dynamic characteristics

Using normal mode transformation obtained in Part 1 of this series^[1], the exact analytical expressions for the mean‐square displacements of junctions and non‐junction beads, the autocorrelation functions of the end‐to‐end chain vectors between neighboring junctions, and those of subchain vectors of a two‐dimensional regular network consisting of "bead and spring" Rouse chains are obtained. Contributions of intra‐ and interchain relaxation processes to the local dynamic characteristics considered are compared. The time behavior of dynamic quantities obtained is estimated for different scales of motions. The possibility of describing long‐time relaxation of a two‐dimensional network by a simplified coarse‐grained network model is demonstrated. It is shown that the local relaxation properties of a two‐dimensional polymer network (as well as a three‐dimensional network) on scales smaller than the average distance between cross‐links are very close to those of a single Rouse chain. The large‐scale collective relaxation of the polymer networks having a two‐dimensional connectivity differs considerably from that of the three‐dimensional networks.     

Theory of relaxation properties of two‐dimensional polymer networks, 1. Normal modes and relaxation times

The local relaxation properties of polymer networks with a two‐dimensional connectivity are considered. We use the mesh‐like network model in which the average positions of junctions form the regular spatial structure consisting of square repeating units (network cells). The two‐dimensional polymer network consisting of “bead and spring” Rouse chains and the simplified coarse‐grained network model describing only the large‐scale collective relaxation of a network are studied. For both dynamic network models the set of relaxation times and the transformation from Cartesian coordinates of network elements to normal modes are obtained. Using the normal mode transformation obtained, in Part 2 of this series the exact analytical expressions for various local dynamic characteristics of the polymer network having a two‐dimensional connectivity will be calculated.     

From caging to Rouse dynamics in polymer melts with intramolecular barriers: a critical test of the mode coupling theory

By means of computer simulations and solution of the equations of the mode coupling theory (MCT), we investigate the role of the intramolecular barriers on several dynamic aspects of nonentangled polymers. The investigated dynamic range extends from the caging regime characteristic of glass-formers to the relaxation of the chain Rouse modes. We review our recent work on this question, provide new results, and critically discuss the limitations of the theory. Solutions of the MCT for the structural relaxation reproduce qualitative trends of simulations for weak and moderate barriers. However, a progressive discrepancy is revealed as the limit of stiff chains is approached. This disagreement does not seem related with dynamic heterogeneities, which indeed are not enhanced by increasing barrier strength. It is not connected either with the breakdown of the convolution approximation for three-point static correlations, which retains its validity for stiff chains. These findings suggest the need of an improvement of the MCT equations for polymer melts. Concerning the relaxation of the chain degrees of freedom, MCT provides a microscopic basis for time scales from chain reorientation down to the caging regime. It rationalizes, from first principles, the observed deviations from the Rouse model on increasing the barrier strength. These include anomalous scaling of relaxation times, long-time plateaux, and nonmonotonous wavelength dependence of the mode correlators.     

Hierarchical Modeling of Entangled Polymers

Summary : We demonstrate that it is possible to link multi-chain molecular dynamics simulations with the tube model using a single chain slip-links model as a bridge. This hierarchical approach allows significant speed up of simulations, permitting us to span the time scales relevant for a comparison with the tube theory. Fitting the mean-square displacement of individual monomers in molecular dynamics simulations with the slip-spring model, we show that it is possible to predict the stress relaxation. Then, we analyze the stress relaxation from slip-spring simulations in the framework of the tube theory. In the absence of constraint release, we establish that the relaxation modulus can be decomposed as the sum of contributions from fast and longitudinal Rouse modes, and tube survival. Finally, we discuss some open questions regarding possible future directions that could be profitable in rendering the tube model quantitative, even for mildly entangled polymers.     

Monte Carlo simulations of stress relaxation of entanglement-free Fraenkel chains. I. Linear polymer viscoelasticity

Shear stress relaxation modulus GS(t) curves of entanglement-free Fraenkel chains have been calculated using Monte Carlo simulations based on the Langevin equation, carrying out both in the equilibrium state and following the application of a step shear deformation. While the fluctuation-dissipation theorem is perfectly demonstrated in the Rouse-chain model, a quasiversion of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem is observed in the Fraenkel-chain model. In both types of simulations on the Fraenkel-chain model, two distinct modes of dynamics emerge in GS(t), giving a line shape similar to that typically observed experimentally. Analyses show that the fast mode arises from the segment-tension fluctuations or reflects the relaxation of the segment tension created by segments being stretched by the applied step strain-an energetic-interactions-driven process-while the slow mode arises from the fluctuations in segmental orientation or represents the randomization of the segmental-orientation anisotropy induced by the step deformation-an entropy-driven process. Furthermore, it is demonstrated that the slow mode is well described by the Rouse theory in all aspects: the magnitude of modulus, the line shape of the relaxation curve, and the number-of-beads (N) dependence of the relaxation times. In other words, one Fraenkel segment substituting for one Rouse segment, it has been shown that the entropic-force constant on each segment is not a required element to give rise to the Rouse modes of motion, which describe the relaxation modulus of an entanglement-free polymer over the long-time region very well. This conclusion provides an explanation resolving a long-standing fundamental paradox in the success of Rouse-segment-based molecular theories for polymer viscoelasticity-namely, the paradox between the Rouse segment size being of the same order of magnitude as that of the Kuhn segment (each Fraenkel segment with a large force constant HF can be regarded as basically equivalent to a Kuhn segment) and the meaning of the Rouse segment as defined in the Rouse-chain model. The general agreement observed in the comparison of the simulation and experimental results indicates that the Fraenkel-chain model, while being still relatively simple, has captured the key element in energetic interactions--the rigidity on the segment--in a polymer system.     

Two tube models of rubber elasticity

Polymer entanglements lead to complicated topological constraints and interactions between neighboring chains in a dense solution or melt. Entanglements can be treated in a mean field approach, within the famous reptation model, since they effectively confine each individual chain in a tube-like geometry. In polymer networks, due to crosslinks preventing the global reptation and constraint release, entanglements acquire a different topological meaning and have a much stronger effect on the resulting mechanical response. In this article we discuss two different models of rubber elasticity, both utilizing the reptation ideas. First, we apply the classical ideas of reptation statistics to calculate the effective rubber-elastic free energy of an entangled rubbery network. In the second approach, we examine the classical Rouse dynamics of chains with quenched constraints at their ends by crosslinks, and along the primitive path by entanglements. We then proceed to average a microscopic stress tensor for the network system and present it in a manageable form in the equilibrium t → ∞ limit. Particular attention is paid to the treatment of compressibility and hydrostatic pressure in a sample with open boundaries. © 2006 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym Phys 44: 2679–2697, 2006     

Relaxation of flexible chains in dilute and non‐dilute systems. Dynamic Monte Carlo results for linear and star chains

A dynamic Monte Carlo algorithm is employed to investigate the dynamics of flexible linear and star chains on a cubic lattice at different concentrations. Some results for similar systems are also obtained with an off‐lattice algorithm. Diffusion coefficient, relaxation times and mean size data are combined into friction‐independent ratios in good agreement with the theoretical predictions from the Rouse theory. The relaxation times and amplitudes corresponding to the Rouse normal modes are analyzed in terms of their variation with the mode order. The end‐to‐end vector correlation times obtained from the simulations for linear chains are compared with the theoretical expression obtained from the Rouse theory. Deviations from this theory are observed for the contribution of the different modes in the non‐dilute systems. Finally, the time correlation function corresponding to a subchain's end‐to‐end vector is investigated. The results also show deviations from the Rouse theory, which are in qualitative agreement with the features observed in data from dielectric relaxation experiments of block copolymers.     

Generalized Rouse–Zimm theory for polymer solutions

Generalized Rouse–Zimm equations are derived using a local equilibrium ansatz for the segment distribution function. The relaxation frequencies depend on excluded-volume effects and other interactions such as entanglement in semidilute solutions through exact static correlation functions. For the case of ring polymers general expressions are given for diffusion coefficients and mean-square displacements. By use of the “blob” model, explicit results are presented for a dilute good-solvent system.     

Molecular rheology of concentrated polymer systems. I

The primitive chain model of Doi and Edwards is generalized to include the short-time relaxation process. Stress relaxation after a sudden imposition of strain is studied in detail. It is shown that in the linear region (small strain) stress relaxation occurs in two steps, the relaxation of chain segments between the fixed entanglement points, and the relaxation of the entanglement points, in accordance with the conventional picture, whereas in the nonlinear region (large strain) there appears a new relaxation process between the above two. The characteristic time of this process is the Rouse relaxation time which the entire chain would have if there were no entanglements, and increases with the square of the molecular weight. This result is consistent with experimental observations.     

Evidence for the time-temperature superposition principle from Monte-Carlo simulations of the glass transition in two-dimensional polymer melts

The bond fluctuation model on a square lattice with a bond-length dependent potential exhibits in simulations of slow cooling a kinetic glass transition where the system falls out of equilibrium. Extending previous work, the relaxation functions of gyration radius and end-to-end distance, and the bond autocorrelation function of the polymers are presented and related to the time-dependent displacements of inner monomeric units and center of gravity of the whole chains, respectively. Over a wide temperature range the data can be collapsed on master curves satisfying the time-temperature superposition principle for Rouse dynamics.     

Influence of molecular stiffness on the dynamic structure factor

Characteristic features of the influence of molecular stiffness on the dynamic structure factor of macromolecules are briefly outlined. The relaxation times characterizing the internal dynamics of the macro‐molecules exhibit a crossover from Rouse‐Zimm to bending modes with increasing mode number. As a consequence the dynamic structure factor is strongly influenced by the molecular stiffness. In particular, a stretched exponential relaxation of the dynamic structure factor at scattering vectors larger than the inverse persistence length is predicted and confirmed by a comparison with experimental data. Moreover, the influence of polydispersity is discussed.     

Proprietes viscoelastiques des reseaux a l'etat caoutchoutique

The dynamic properties and the stress relaxation of vulcanisates of natural rubber, cis-polybutadiene and a butadiene (76,5)-styrene (23,5) copolymer are analysed in order to determine the influence of some structural parameters on the shape and position on the time scales of the rheological functions characterizing their viscoelasticity.The persistence of the energy loss at low frequencies and the corresponding high level of the distribution of relaxation times are all the more marked as these polymer networks are less cross-linked or contain a larger amount of carbon black HAF. Undoubtedly closely related to the “viscoelastic plateau” of linear polymers, this anomaly is interpreted in terms of an extension of the Rouse theory derived for bulk polymers or their concentrated solutions.     

Interchain coupled chain dynamics of poly(ethylene oxide) in blends with poly(methyl methacrylate): coupling model analysis

Quasielastic neutron scattering and molecular dynamics simulation data from poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO)/poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) blends found that for short times the self-dynamics of PEO chain follows the Rouse model, but at longer times past t(c) = 1-2 ns it becomes slower and departs from the Rouse model in dependences on time, momentum transfer, and temperature. To explain the anomalies, others had proposed the random Rouse model (RRM) in which each monomer has different mobility taken from a broad log-normal distribution. Despite the success of the RRM, Diddens et al. [Eur. Phys. Lett. 95, 56003 (2011)] extracted the distribution of friction coefficients from the MD simulations of a PEO/PMMA blend and found that the distribution is much narrower than expected from the RRM. We propose a simpler alternative explanation of the data by utilizing alone the observed crossover of PEO chain dynamics at t(c). The present problem is just a special case of a general property of relaxation in interacting systems, which is the crossover from independent relaxation to coupled many-body relaxation at some t(c) determined by the interaction potential and intermolecular coupling/constraints. The generality is brought out vividly by pointing out that the crossover also had been observed by neutron scattering from entangled chains relaxation in monodisperse homopolymers, and from the segmental α-relaxation of PEO in blends with PMMA. The properties of all the relaxation processes in connection with the crossover are similar, despite the length scales of the relaxation in these systems are widely different.     

Stiffness and excluded volume effects on conformation and dynamics of polymers: A simulation study

This work investigates the effects of the excluded volume and especially those of the chain stiffness on the structural and dynamical properties of a model polymer chain.The theoretical framework is the same as in the recent works by Steinhauser et al.,where a Rouse approach is adopted.Our model differs in that our chains have a finite average bending angle.As in the works by Steinhauser et al.,Langevin dynamic simulations were performed without hydrodynamic interactions.Whereas this doesn’t impact the static properties we obtain,it also allows us to compare our results on dynamic properties to those predicted by Rouse theory,where hydrodynamic interactions are also neglected.Our results show that the structural properties are very sensitive to the chain stiffness,whereas the dynamic scaling laws remain the same as those by Rouse theory,with the prefactor depending on the persistence length.     

Scaling of mesoscale simulations of polymer melts with the bare friction coefficient

Both the Rouse and reptation model predict that the dynamics of a polymer melt scale inversely proportional with the Langevin friction coefficient xi. Mesoscale Brownian dynamics simulations of polyethylene validate these scaling predictions, providing the reptational friction xi(R)=xi+xi(C) is used, where xi(C) reflects the fundamental difference between a deterministic and a stochastic propagator even in the limit of xi to zero. The simulations have been performed with Langevin background friction and with pairwise friction, as in dissipative particle dynamics. Both simulation methods lead to equal scaling behavior with xi(C) having almost the same value in both cases. The scaling is tested for the diffusion g(t), the shear relaxation modulus G(t), and the Rouse mode autocorrelations of melts of C(120)H(242), C(400)H(802), and C(1000)H(2002). The derived dynamical scaling procedure is very useful to reduce run-time in mesoscale computer simulations, especially if pairwise friction is applied.     

Monte carlo study of the dynamics of star-branched polymers

A uniform star-branched polymer model with f = 3 arms based on a simple cubic lattice was studied by means of the dynamic Monte Carlo method. The model chain is athermal with excluded-volume interactions and it is flexible. A new type of local micromodification was introduced to make the branching point movable. Static properties of the star polymer are in accordance with other theoretical predictions and experimental evidence. Scaling of the self diffusion constant and the terminal relaxation times is close to those of the Rouse theory and to simulation results of linear chains.