The effect of fixed charge modifications on electron capture dissociation

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) studies of two modified amyloid beta peptides (20-29 and 25-35) were performed to investigate the role of H* radicals in the ECD of peptide ions and the free-radical cascade (FRC) mechanism. 2,4,6-Trimethylpyridinium (TMP) was used as the fixed charge tag, which is postulated to both trap the originally formed radical upon electron capture and inhibit the H* generation. It was found that both the number and locations of the fixed charge groups influenced the backbone and side-chain cleavages of these peptides in ECD. In general, the frequency and extent of backbone cleavages decreased and those of side-chain cleavages increased with the addition of fixed charge tags. A singly labeled peptide with the tag group farther away from the protonated site experienced a smaller abundance decrease in backbone cleavage fragments than the one with the tag group closer to the protonated site. Despite the nonprotonated nature of all charge carriers in doubly labeled peptide ions, several c and z* ions were still observed in their ECD spectra. Thus, although H* transfer may be important for the NC(alpha) bond cleavage, there also exist other pathways, which would require a radical migration via H* abstraction through space or via an amide superbase mechanism. Finally, internal fragment ions were observed in the ECD of these linear peptides, indicating that the important role of the FRC in backbone cleavages is not limited to the ECD of cyclic peptides.     

The relative charge ratio between C and N atoms in amide bond acts as a key factor to determine peptide fragment efficiency in different charge states

The influence of charge state on the peptide dissociation behavior in tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) is worthy of discussion. Comparative studies of singly- and doubly-protonated peptide molecules are performed to explore the effect and mechanism of charge state on peptide fragmentation. In view of the charge-directed cleavage of protonated peptides described in the mobile proton model, radiolytic oxidation was applied to change the charge distribution of peptides but retain the sequence. Experimental studies of collision energy-dependent fragmentation efficiencies coupled with quantum chemical calculations indicated that the cleavage of ARRA and its side-chain oxidation products with oxygen atoms added followed a trend that doubly-protonated peptides fragment more easily than singly-protonated forms, while the oxidation product with the guanidine group deleted showed the opposite trend. By analyzing the charge distribution around the amide bonds, we found that the relative charge ratios between C and N atoms (Q_C/Q_N) in the amide bonds provided a reasonable explanation for peptide fragmentation efficiencies. An increase of the Q_C/Q_N value of the amide bond means that a peptide fragments more easily, and vice versa. The results described in this paper provide an experimental and calculation strategy for predicting peptide fragmentation efficiency.     

Charge-separation reactions of doubly-protonated peptides: Effect of peptide chain length

The collision induced dissociation of doubly-protonated (Ala)_xHis (x=5, 6, 7, 8, 10) peptides have been studied. The major fragmentation reactions observed are symmetrical amide bond cleavages to give the complementary b_m and y_N-m ions, where N is the total number of residues in the peptide. Minor asymmetric cleavage to give doubly-protonated y ions also is observed, involving cleavage near the N-terminus. The shorter peptides (x=5, 6, 7) show major cleavage of the second amide bond to yield b₂ and y_N-2 ions, while (Ala)₁₀His shows major symmetrical cleavage at the fourth and fifth amide bonds. (Ala)₈His appears to be a transitional peptide in showing substantial symmetrical cleavage at the second, fourth, and fifth amide bonds. The results are in general agreement with the bifurcating nature of charge separation noted by Zubarev (J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom. 2008, 19, 1755–1763) from a statistical analysis of a large body of doubly-protonated tryptic peptide CID mass spectra. It is shown that the b₂ ion derived from doubly-protonated (Ala)₅His has a protonated oxazolone structure.     

Aspartic acid side chain effect—Experimental and theoretical insight

Gas-phase H/D exchange and density functional theory study of the Asp and Glu side-chain carboxylic group intrinsic reactivity is reported. H/D exchange site specific treatment and some additional theoretical calculations showed that a side-chain carboxylic group may initiate proton transfer along with bond formation to one of its oxygens, i.e., possibility to initiate selective of cleavage peptide bond ("aspartic acid effect"). That finding is used to select aspartic acid cleavage mechanisms (side-chain proton transfer either to backbone carbonyl or to amide nitrogen) for further computational study. B3LYP/6-31G(d) and G3(MP2)//B3LYP potential energy profiles of both mechanisms on a model system CH3CO-Asp-NHCH3 were constructed. Although energy employed in low-energy collision induced dissociation suffices for both mechanisms thresholds, energy transferred to specific modes suggests a complex one-step mechanism of proton transfer (from the side-chain carboxylic group to the backbone amide group), bond formation (between deprotonated carboxylic group and carbon atom of the backbone carbonyl), and peptide bond cleavage as favorable.     

The role of basic residues in the fragmentation process of the lysine rich cell‐penetrating peptide TP10

Selective cleavage effect of basic residues in the fragmentation of short peptides has been studied intensively. In contrast, the role of basic residues in the degradation of large peptides, such as cell‐penetrating peptides, is largely unknown. In this work, the fragmentation of a 21 residues cell‐penetrating peptide TP10 containing four lysine residues was studied by collision‐induced dissociation mass spectrometry and computation methods. The influence of lysine residues on amide bond cleavage and fragmentation products was investigated. The results revealed that the selective cleavage effect of lysine residue did not present when the adjacent lysine residues in TP10 were both protonated. The localized high positive charge density might be the reason of preventing the mobile proton from migrating to the amide bonds in this part of the peptide. In contrast, the mobile proton preferred to reside in the N‐terminal part of TP10 which had less positive charge. This preference gave more information of the peptide sequence in the mass spectrometry study and was helpful for stabilizing the C‐terminal part of TP10, in which the basic lysine residues were preserved and crucial to the cell‐penetrating process. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Electron capture induced dissociation of doubly protonated pentapeptides: dependence on molecular structure and charge separation

We have studied electron capture induced dissociation of a set of doubly protonated pentapeptides, all composed of one lysine (K) and either four glycine (G) or four alanine (A) residues, as a function of the sequence of these building blocks. Thereby the separation of the two charges, sequestered on the N-terminal amino group and the lysine side chain, is varied. The characteristic cleavage of N-C(α) bonds is observed for all peptides over the whole backbone length, with the charge carrying fragments always containing K. The resulting fragmentation patterns are very similar if G is replaced by A. In the case of [XKXXX+2H](2+) (X=A or G), a distinct feature is observed in the distribution of backbone cleavage fragments and the probability for ammonia loss is drastically reduced. This may be due to an isomer with an amide oxygen as protonation site giving rise to the observed increase in breakage at a specific site in the molecule. For the other peptides, a correlation with the distance between amide oxygen and the charge at the lysine side chain has been found. This may be an indication that it is only the contribution from this site to the charge stabilization of the amide π(*) orbitals which determines relative fragment intensities. For comparison, complexes with two crown ether molecules have been studied as well. The crown ether provides a shielding of the charge and prevents the peptide from folding and internal hydrogen bonding, which leads to a more uniform fragmentation behavior.     

Effects of acidic peptide size and sequence on trivalent praseodymium adduction and electron transfer dissociation mass spectrometry

Using the lanthanide ion praseodymium, Pr(III), metallated ion formation and electron transfer dissociation (ETD) were studied for 25 biological and model acidic peptides. For chain lengths of seven or more residues, even highly acidic peptides that can be difficult to protonate by electrospray ionization will metallate and undergo abundant ETD fragmentation. Peptides composed of predominantly acidic residues form only the deprotonated ion, [M + Pr ‐ H]²⁺; this ion yields near complete ETD sequence coverage for larger peptides. Peptides with a mixture of acidic and neutral residues generate [M + Pr]³⁺, which cleaves between every residue for many peptides. Acidic peptides that contain at least one residue with a basic side chain also produce the protonated ion, [M + Pr + H]⁴⁺; this ion undergoes the most extensive sequence coverage by ETD. Primarily metallated and non‐metallated c‐ and z‐ions form for all peptides investigated. Metal adducted product ions are only present when at least half of the peptide sequence can be incorporated into the ion; this suggests that the metal ion simultaneously attaches to more than one acidic site. The only site consistently lacking dissociation is at the N‐terminal side of a proline residue. Increasing peptide chain length generates more backbone cleavage for metal‐peptide complexes with the same charge state. For acidic peptides with the same length, increasing the precursor ion charge state from 2+ to 3+ also leads to more cleavage. The results of this study indicate that highly acidic peptides can be sequenced by ETD of complexes formed with Pr(III). Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Bifurcating fragmentation behavior of gas-phase tryptic peptide dications in collisional activation

Collision-activated dissociation (CAD) of tryptic peptides is a cornerstone of mass spectrometry-based proteomics research. Principal component analysis of a database containing 15,000 high-resolution CAD mass spectra of gas-phase tryptic peptide dications revealed that they fall into two classes with a good separation between the classes. The main factor determining the class identity is the relative abundance of the peptide bond cleavage after the first two N-terminal residues. A possible scenario explaining this bifurcation involves trans- to cis-isomerization of the N-terminal peptide bond, which facilitates solvation of the N-terminal charge on the second backbone amide and formation of stable b(2) ions in the form of protonated diketopiperazines. Evidence supporting this scenario is derived from statistical analysis of the high-resolution CAD MS/MS database. It includes the observation of the strong deficit of a(3) ions and anomalous amino acid preferences for b(2) ion formation.     

Stereospecific control of peptide gas‐phase ion chemistry with cis and trans cyclo ornithine residues

We report non‐chiral amino acid residues cis‐ and trans‐1,4‐diaminocyclohexane‐1‐carboxylic acid (cyclo‐ornithine, cO) that exhibit unprecedented stereospecific control of backbone dissociations of singly charged peptide cations and hydrogen‐rich cation radicals produced by electron‐transfer dissociation. Upon collision‐induced dissociation (CID) in the slow heating regime, peptide cations containing trans‐cO residues undergo facile backbone cleavages of amide bonds C‐terminal to trans‐cO. By contrast, peptides with cis‐cO residues undergo dissociations at several amide bonds along the peptide ion backbone. Diastereoisomeric cO‐containing peptides thus provide remarkably distinct tandem mass spectra. The stereospecific effect in CID of the trans‐cO residue is explained by syn‐facially directed proton transfer from the 4‐ammonium group at cO to the C‐terminal amide followed by neighboring group participation in the cleavage of the CO―NH bond, analogous to the aspartic acid and ornithine effects. Backbone dissociations of diastereoisomeric cO‐containing peptide ions generate distinct [b_n]⁺‐type fragment ions that were characterized by CID‐MS³ spectra. Stereospecific control is also reported for electron‐transfer dissociation of cis‐ and trans‐cO containing doubly charged peptide ions. The stereospecific effect upon electron transfer is related to the different conformations of doubly charged peptide ions that affect the electron attachment sites and ensuing N―C_α bond dissociations.     

The dehydroalanine effect in the fragmentation of ions derived from polypeptides

The fragmentation of peptides and proteins upon collision‐induced dissociation (CID) is highly dependent on sequence and ion type (e.g. protonated, deprotonated, sodiated, odd electron, etc.). Some amino acids, for example aspartic acid and proline, have been found to enhance certain cleavages along the backbone. Here, we show that peptides and proteins containing dehydroalanine, a non‐proteinogenic amino acid with an unsaturated side‐chain, undergo enhanced cleavage of the N—Cα bond of the dehydroalanine residue to generate c‐ and z‐ions. Because these fragment ion types are not commonly observed upon activation of positively charged even‐electron species, they can be used to identify dehydroalanine residues and localize them within the peptide or protein chain. While dehydroalanine can be generated in solution, it can also be generated in the gas phase upon CID of various species. Oxidized S‐alkyl cysteine residues generate dehydroalanine upon activation via highly efficient loss of the alkyl sulfenic acid. Asymmetric cleavage of disulfide bonds upon collisional activation of systems with limited proton mobility also generates dehydroalanine. Furthermore, we show that gas‐phase ion/ion reactions can be used to facilitate the generation of dehydroalanine residues via, for example, oxidation of S‐alkyl cysteine residues and conversion of multiply‐protonated peptides to radical cations. In the latter case, loss of radical side‐chains to generate dehydroalanine from some amino acids gives rise to the possibility for residue‐specific backbone cleavage of polypeptide ions. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

The arginine anomaly: arginine radicals are poor hydrogen atom donors in electron transfer induced dissociations

Arginine amide radicals are generated by femtosecond electron transfer to protonated arginine amide cations in the gas phase. A fraction of the arginine radicals formed (2-amino-5-dihydroguanid-1'-yl-pentanamide, 1H) is stable on the 6.7 micros time scale and is detected after collisional reionization. The main dissociation of 1H is loss of a guanidine molecule from the side chain followed by consecutive dissociations of the 2-aminopentanamid-5-yl radical intermediate. Intramolecular hydrogen atom transfer from the guanidinium group onto the amide group is not observed. These results are explained by ab initio and density functional theory calculations of dissociation and transition state energies. Loss of guanidine from 1H is calculated to require a transition state energy of 68 kJ mol(-)(1), which is substantially lower than that for hydrogen atom migration from the guanidine group. The loss of guanidine competes with the reverse migration of the arginine alpha-hydrogen atom onto the guanidyl radical. RRKM calculations of dissociation kinetics predict the loss of guanidine to account for >95% of 1H dissociations. The anomalous behavior of protonated arginine amide upon electron transfer provides an insight into electron capture and transfer dissociations of peptide cations containing arginine residues as charge carriers. The absence of efficient hydrogen atom transfer from charge-reduced arginine onto sterically proximate amide group blocks one of the current mechanisms for electron capture dissociation. Conversely, charge-reduced guanidine groups in arginine residues may function as radical traps and induce side-chain dissociations. In light of the current findings, backbone dissociations in arginine-containing peptides are predicted to involve excited electronic states and proceed by the amide superbase mechanism that involves electron capture in an amide pi* orbital, which is stabilized by through-space coulomb interaction with the remote charge carriers.     

Abundant <Emphasis Type="Italic">b</Emphasis>-type ions produced in electron capture dissociation of peptides without basic amino acid residues

We have investigated electron capture dissociation (ECD) of doubly protonated peptides with few or no basic amino acid residues (BAARs). For peptides containing one His, abundant b-type ions were only found when His was located adjacent to the N-terminus. Interestingly, b-type ions, particularly b(5)(+), were found to be the dominant product ions in ECD of peptides without BAARs. Fragmentation patterns of luteinizing hormone releasing hormone (LHRH) and vasopressin (VP), containing one Arg and one His, respectively, were compared to those of Q(8)-LHRH and oxytocin (OT) in which the BAAR is replaced with a non-BAAR. More b-type ions were found for Q(8)-LHRH and OT than for LHRH and VP. We also performed ECD of melittin and found no b-type ions from ECD of the 4+ charge state; however, many low abundance b-type ions were produced in ECD of the 5+ charge state. Possible mechanisms for the formation of b-type ions are discussed and we propose that such ions are formed as a consequence of protons being located at backbone amide nitrogens.     

Origin and Prediction of Highly Specific Bond Cleavage Sites in the Thermal Activation of Intact Protein Ions

Predicting the fragmentation patterns of proteins would be beneficial for the reliable identification of intact proteins by mass spectrometry. However, the ability to accurately make such predictions remains elusive. An approach to predict the specific cleavage sites in whole proteins resulting from collision-induced dissociation by use of an improved electrostatic model for calculating the proton configurations of highly-charged protein ions is reported. Using ubiquitin, cytochrome c, lysozyme and β-lactoglobulin as prototypical proteins, this approach can be used to predict the fragmentation patterns of intact proteins. For sufficiently highly charged proteins, specific cleavages occur near the first low-basicity amino acid residues that are protonated with increasing charge state. Hybrid QM/QM′ (QM=quantum mechanics) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and energy-resolved collision-induced dissociation measurements indicated that the barrier to the specific dissociation of the protonated amide backbone bond is significantly lower than competitive charge remote fragmentation. Unlike highly charged peptides, the protons at low-basicity sites in highly charged protein ions can be confined to a limited sequence of low-basicity amino acid residues by electrostatic repulsion, which results in highly specific fragmentation near the site of protonation. This research suggests that the optimal charge states to form specific sequence ions of intact proteins in higher abundances than the use of less specific ion dissociation methods can be predicted a priori.     

Energetic switch of the proline effect in collision‐induced dissociation of singly and doubly protonated peptide Ala‐Ala‐Arg‐Pro‐Ala‐Ala

Suppression of the selective cleavage at N‐terminal of proline is observed in the peptide cleavage by proteolytic enzyme trypsin and in the fragment ion mass spectra of peptides containing Arg‐Pro sequence. An insight into the fragmentation mechanism of the influence of arginine residue on the proline effect can help in prediction of mass spectra and in protein structure analysis. In this work, collision‐induced dissociation spectra of singly and doubly charged peptide AARPAA were studied by ESI MS/MS and theoretical calculation methods. The proline effect was evaluated by comparing the experimental ratio of fragments originated from cleavage of different amide bonds. The results revealed that the backbone amide bond cleavage was selected by the energy barrier height of the fragmentation pathway although the strong proton affinity of the Arg side chain affected the stereostructure of the peptide and the dissociation mechanism. The thermodynamic stability of the fragment ions played a secondary role in the abundance ratio of fragments generated via different pathways. Fragmentation studies of protonated peptide AACitPAA supported the energy‐dependent hypothesis. The results provide an explanation to the long‐term arguments between the steric conflict and the proton mobility mechanisms of proline effect.     

Role of the site of protonation in the low-energy decompositions of gas-phase peptide ions

The dissociation of singly or multiply protonated peptide ions by using low-energy collisional activation (CA) is highly dependent on the sites of protonation. The presence of strongly basic amino acid residues in the peptide primary structure dictates the sites of protonation, which generates a precursor ion population that is largely homogeneous with respect to charge sites. Attempts to dissociate this type of precursor ion population by low-energy CA result in poor fragmentation via few pathways. The work described here represents a systematic investigation of the effects of charge heterogeneity in the precursor ion population of a series of model peptides in low-energy CA experiments. Incorporation of acidic residues in the peptide RLC*IFSC*FR (where C* indicates a cysteic acid residue), for example, balances the charge on the basic arginine residues, which enables the ionizing protons to reside on a number of less basic sites along the peptide backbone. This results in a precursor ion population that is heterogeneous with respect to charge site. Low-energy CA of these ions results in diverse and efficient fragmentation. Molecular modeling has been utilized to demonstrate that energetically preferred conformations incorporate an intraionic interaction between arginine and cysteic acid residues.     

Gas-phase fragmentation characteristics of benzyl-aminated lysyl-containing tryptic peptides

The fragmentation characteristics of peptides derivatized at the side-chain ε-amino group of lysyl residues via reductive amination with benzaldehyde have been examined using collision-induced dissociation (CID) tandem mass spectrometry. The resulting MS/MS spectra exhibit peaks representing product ions formed from two independent fragmentation pathways. One pathway results in backbone fragmentation and commonly observed sequence ion peaks. The other pathway corresponds to the unsymmetrical, heterolytic cleavage of the C_ζ-N_ε bond that links the benzyl derivative to the side-chain lysyl residue. This results in the elimination of the derivative as a benzylic or tropylium carbocation and a (n − l)⁺-charged peptide product (where n is the precursor ion charge state). The frequency of occurrence of the elimination pathway increases with increasing charge of the precursor ion. For the benzylmodified tryptic peptides analyzed in this study, peaks representing products from both of these pathways are observed in the MS/MS spectra of doubly-charged precursor ions, but the carbocation elimination pathway occurs almost exclusively for triply-charged precursor ions. The experimental evidence presented herein, combined with molecular orbital calculations, suggests that the elimination pathway is a charge-directed reaction contingent upon protonation of the secondary ε-amino group of the benzyl-derivatized lysyl side chain. If the secondary ε-amine is protonated, the elimination of the carbocation is observed. If the precursor is not protonated at the secondary ε-amine, backbone fragmentation persists. The application of appropriately substituted benzyl analogs may allow for selective control over the relative abundance of product ions generated from the two pathways.     

Gln-Gly cleavage: a dominant dissociation site in the fragmentation of protonated peptides

An understanding of the gas-phase dissociation of protonated peptides within the mass spectrometer is essential for automated high-throughput protein identification. In this communication we describe a facile cleavage of the Gln-Gly peptide bond under low-collisional energy conditions. A variety of synthetic peptides have been analysed where key amino acids have been substituted within the sequence PQGPPQQGGR, which is a consensus repeat present in the tryptic peptides of acidic proline-rich protein 1 (PRP-1). The collision-induced dissociation spectra obtained from the PRP-1 tryptic peptides and the synthetic peptides indicate that facile Gln-Gly cleavage occurs when an X-Gln-Gly-Y sequence is present in a peptide, where X is any amino acid and Y any amino acid other than Gly.     

Side-chain fragmentation of alkylated cysteine residues in electron capture dissociation mass spectrometry

The recent development of novel fragmentation processes based on either electron capture directly or transfer from an anion show great potential for solving problems in proteomics that are intractable by the more widely employed thermal-based fragmentation processes such as collision induced dissociation. The dominant fragmentation occurring upon electron capture dissociation of peptides is cleavage of N-C alpha bonds in the peptide backbone to form c and z* ions. In the case of disulfide-linked peptides, it has also been shown that electron capture on one of the cystine sulfur atoms is favored, resulting in cleavage of the disulfide bond. In this study, we report that electron capture on the sulfur of alkylated cysteine residues is also a dominant process, causing cysteine side-chain loss from z* ions.     

Charge remote fragmentation in electron capture and electron transfer dissociation

Secondary fragmentations of three synthetic peptides (human αA crystallin peptide 1-11, the deamidated form of human βB2 crystallin peptide 4-14, and amyloid β peptide 25-35) were studied in both electron capture dissociation (ECD) and electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) mode. In ECD, in addition to c and z· ion formations, charge remote fragmentations (CRF) of z· ions were abundant, resulting in internal fragment formation or partial/entire side-chain losses from amino acids, sometimes several residues away from the backbone cleavage site, and to some extent multiple side-chain losses. The internal fragments were observed in peptides with basic residues located in the middle of the sequences, which was different from most tryptic peptides with basic residues located at the C-terminus. These secondary cleavages were initiated by hydrogen abstraction at the α-, β-, or γ-position of the amino acid side chain. In comparison, ETD generates fewer CRF fragments than ECD. This secondary cleavage study will facilitate ECD/ETD spectra interpretation, and help de novo sequencing and database searching.     

Cascade Dissociations of Peptide Cation-Radicals. Part 1. Scope and Effects of Amino Acid Residues in Penta-, Nona-, and Decapeptides

Amino acid residue-specific backbone and side-chain dissociations of peptide z ions in MS(3) spectra were elucidated for over 40 pentapeptides with arginine C-terminated sequences of the AAXAR and AAHXR type, nonapeptides of the AAHAAXX"AR and AAHAXAX"AR type, and AAHAAXX"AAR decapeptides. Peptide z(n) ions containing amino acid residues with readily transferrable benzylic or tertiary β-hydrogen atoms (Phe, Tyr, His, Trp, Val) underwent facile backbone cleavages to form dominant z(n-2) or z(n-3) ions. These backbone cleavages are thought to be triggered by a side-chain β-hydrogen atom transfer to the z ion C(α) radical site followed by homolytic dissociation of the adjacent C(α)-CO bond, forming x(n-2) cation-radicals that spontaneously dissociate by loss of HNCO. Amino acid residues that do not have readily transferrable β-hydrogen atoms (Gly, Ala) do not undergo the z(n) → z(n-2) dissociations. The backbone cleavages compete with side-chain dissociations in z ions containing Asp and Asn residues. Side-chain dissociations are thought to be triggered by α-hydrogen atom transfers that activate the C(β)-C(γ) or C(β)-heteroatom bonds for dissociations that dominate the MS(3) spectra of z ions from peptides containing Leu, Cys, Lys, Met, Ser, Arg, Glu, and Gln residues. The Lys, Arg, Gln, and Glu residues also participate in γ-hydrogen atom transfers that trigger other side-chain dissociations.