Comparing Positively and Negatively Charged Distonic Radical Ions in Phenylperoxyl Forming Reactions

In the gas phase, arylperoxyl forming reactions play a significant role in low-temperature combustion and atmospheric processing of volatile organic compounds. We have previously demonstrated the application of charge-tagged phenyl radicals to explore the outcomes of these reactions using ion trap mass spectrometry. Here, we present a side-by-side comparison of rates and product distributions from the reaction of positively and negatively charge tagged phenyl radicals with dioxygen. The negatively charged distonic radical ions are found to react with significantly greater efficiency than their positively charged analogues. The product distributions of the anion reactions favor products of phenylperoxyl radical decomposition (e.g., phenoxyl radicals and cyclopentadienone), while the comparable fixed-charge cations yield the stabilized phenylperoxyl radical. Electronic structure calculations rationalize these differences as arising from the influence of the charged moiety on the energetics of rate-determining transition states and reaction intermediates within the phenylperoxyl reaction manifold and predict that this influence could extend to intra-molecular charge-radical separations of up to 14.5 Å. Experimental observations of reactions of the novel 4-(1-carboxylatoadamantyl)phenyl radical anion confirm that the influence of the charge on both rate and product distribution can be modulated by increasing the rigidly imposed separation between charge and radical sites. These findings provide a generalizable framework for predicting the influence of charged groups on polarizable radicals in gas phase distonic radical ions.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract

     

An N-Heterocyclic-Carbene-Derived Distonic Radical Cation

We present the discovery of a novel radical cation formed through one-electron oxidation of an N-heterocyclic carbene–carbodiimide (NHC–CDI) zwitterionic adduct. This compound possesses a distonic electronic structure (spatially separate spin and charge regions) and displays persistence under ambient conditions. We demonstrate its application in a redox-flow battery exhibiting minimal voltage hysteresis, a flat voltage plateau, high Coulombic efficiency, and no performance decay for at least 100 cycles. The chemical tunability of NHCs and CDIs suggests that this approach could provide a general entry to redox-active NHC–CDI adducts and their persistent radical ions for various applications.     

Using Distonic Radical Ions to Probe the Chemistry of Key Combustion Intermediates: The Case of the Benzoxyl Radical Anion

The benzoxyl radical is a key intermediate in the combustion of toluene and other aromatic hydrocarbons, yet relatively little experimental work has been performed on this species. Here, a combination of electrospray ionization (ESI), multistage mass spectrometry experiments, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations are used to examine the formation and fragmentation of a benzoxyl (benzyloxyl) distonic radical anion. Excited 4-carboxylatobenzoxyl radical anions were produced via two methods: (1) collision induced dissociation (CID) of the nitrate ester 4-(nitrooxymethyl)benzoate, ^–O₂CC₆H₄CH₂ONO₂, and (2) reaction of ozone with the 4-carboxylatobenzyl radical anion, ^–O₂CC₆H₄CH₂ ^?. In neither case was the stabilized ^–O₂CC₆H₄CH₂O^? radical anion intermediate detected. Instead, dissociation products at m/z 121 and 149 were observed. These products are attributed to benzaldehyde (O₂ ^-CC₆H₄CHO) and benzene (^–O₂CC₆H₅) products from respective loss of H and HCO radicals in the vibrationally excited benzoxyl intermediate. In no experiments was a product at m/z 120 (i.e., ^–O₂CC₆H₄ ^?) detected, corresponding to absence of the commonly assumed phenyl radical + CH₂=O channel. The results reported suggest that distonic ions are useful surrogates for reactive intermediates formed in combustion chemistry.

A Room-Temperature Stable Distonic Radical Cation

Distonic radical cations (DRCs) with spatially separated charge and radical sites have, so far, largely been observed by gas-phase mass spectrometry and/or matrix isolation spectroscopy work. Herein, we disclose the isolation of a crystalline dicarbondiphosphide-based β-distonic radical cation salt 3^.+ (BARF) (BARF=[B(3,5-(CF₃)₂C₆H₃)₄)]⁻) stable at room temperature and formed by a one-electron-oxidation-induced intramolecular skeletal rearrangement reaction. Such a species has been validated by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, single-crystal X-ray diffraction, UV/Vis spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Compound 3^.+ (BARF) exhibits a large majority of spin density at a two-coordinate phosphorus atom (0.74 a.u.) and a cationic charge located predominantly at the four-coordinate phosphorus atom (1.53 a.u.), which are separated by one carbon atom. This species represents an isolable entity of a phosphorus radical cation that is the closest to a genuine phosphorus DRC to date.     

Distonic radical cations : Guidelines for the assessment of their stability

Ab initio molecular orbital calculations on the distonic radical cations CH₂(CH₂)_nN⁺H₃ and their conventional isomers CH₃(CH₂)_nNH₂+ (n = 0,1, 2 and 3) indicate a preference in each case for the distonic isomer. The energy difference appears to converge with increasing n towards a limit which is close to the energy difference between the component systems CH₃·H₂+CH₃^+NH₃ (representing the distonic isomer) and CH₃CH₃+CH₃NH₂+ (representing the conventional isomer). The generality of this result is assessed by using results for the component systems CH₃·Y+CH₃X⁺H and CH₃YH+CH₃X^+. (or CH₃YH^+. + CH₃X) to predict the relative energies of the distonic ions ·Y(CH₂)_nX⁺H and their conventional isomers HY(CH₂)nX^+. (X = NH₂, OH, F, PH₂, SH, Cl; Y = CH₂, NH, O) and testing the predictions through explicit calculations for systems with n = 0,1 and 2. Although the predictions based on component systems are often close to the results of direct calculations, there are substantial discrepancies in a number of cases; the reasons for such discrepancies are discussed. Caution must be exercised in applying this and related predictive schemes. For the systems examined in the present study, the conventional radical cation is predicted in most cases to lie lower in energy than its distonic isomer. It is found that the more important factors contributing to a preference for distonic over conventional radical cations are the presence in the system of a group(X) with high proton affinity and the absence of a group (X, Y or perturbed (C—C) with low ionization energy.     

Distonic ions of the “ate” class

The gas phase synthesis, structure, and reactivity of distonic negative ions of the “ate” class are described. “Ate”-class negative ions are readily prepared in the gas phase by addition of neutral Lewis acids, such as BF₃, BH₃, and AlMe₃, to molecular anions, carbene negative ions, and radical anions of biradicals. The ions contain either localized σ- or delocalized π-type radical moieties remote from relatively inert borate and aluminate charge sites. The free radical reactivity displayed by these ions appears to be independent of the charge site. As an example, the distonic alkynyl radical (·C≡CBF₃⁻) is highly reactive and undergoes radical coupling reactions with NO₂, NO, H₂C=CH-CN, and H₂C=CH-CH₃. Radical-mediated group and atom transfers are observed with O₂, CS₂, and CH₃SSCH₃. Furthermore, H-atom abstraction reactions are observed, in accordance with the predicted high C-H bond strength of this species [DH₂₉₈(H-C₂BF₃⁻)=130.8 kcal mol⁻¹]. High level ab initio molecular orbital calculations on the prototype “ate”-class distonic ion · CH₂BH₃⁻ and its conventional isomer CH₃BH₂^·− reveal that CH₃BH₂^·− is 3.2 kcal/mol more stable than the α-distonic form. However, the calculations also show that CH₃BH₂^·− is unstable with respect to electron detachment, and only the α-distonic form ·CH₂BH₃⁻ should be experimentally observed in the gas phase.     

Structure and Reactivity of the Distonic and Aromatic Radical Cations of Tryptophan

In this work, we regiospecifically generate and compare the gas-phase properties of two isomeric forms of tryptophan radical cations—a distonic indolyl N-radical (H₃N⁺ - TrpN^?) and a canonical aromatic π (Trp^?+) radical cation. The distonic radical cation was generated by nitrosylating the indole nitrogen of tryptophan in solution followed by collision-induced dissociation (CID) of the resulting protonated N-nitroso tryptophan. The π-radical cation was produced via CID of the ternary [Cu^II(terpy)(Trp)] ^?2+ complex. CID spectra of the two isomeric species were found to be very different, suggesting no interconversion between the isomers. In gas-phase ion-molecule reactions, the distonic radical cation was unreactive towards n-propylsulfide, whereas the π radical cation reacted by hydrogen atom abstraction. DFT calculations revealed that the distonic indolyl radical cation is about 82 kJ/mol higher in energy than the π radical cation of tryptophan. The low reactivity of the distonic nitrogen radical cation was explained by spin delocalization of the radical over the aromatic ring and the remote, localized charge (at the amino nitrogen). The lack of interconversion between the isomers under both trapping and CID conditions was explained by the high rearrangement barrier of ca.137 kJ/mol. Finally, the two isomers were characterized by infrared multiple-photon dissociation (IRMPD) spectroscopy in the ~1000–1800 cm^–1 region. It was found that some of the main experimental IR features overlap between the two species, making their distinction by IRMPD spectroscopy in this region problematic. In addition, DFT theoretical calculations showed that the IR spectra are strongly conformation-dependent.      

An N‐Heterocyclic‐Carbene‐Derived Distonic Radical Cation

We present the discovery of a novel radical cation formed through one‐electron oxidation of an N‐heterocyclic carbene–carbodiimide (NHC–CDI) zwitterionic adduct. This compound possesses a distonic electronic structure (spatially separate spin and charge regions) and displays persistence under ambient conditions. We demonstrate its application in a redox‐flow battery exhibiting minimal voltage hysteresis, a flat voltage plateau, high Coulombic efficiency, and no performance decay for at least 100 cycles. The chemical tunability of NHCs and CDIs suggests that this approach could provide a general entry to redox‐active NHC–CDI adducts and their persistent radical ions for various applications.     

Reaction of Aromatic Peroxyl Radicals with Alkynes: A Mass Spectrometric and Computational Study Using the Distonic Radical Ion Approach

The reaction of the aromatic distonic peroxyl radical cations N‐methyl pyridinium‐4‐peroxyl (PyrOO^.+) and 4‐(N,N,N‐trimethyl ammonium)‐phenyl peroxyl (AnOO^.+), with symmetrical dialkyl alkynes 10a – c was studied in the gas phase by mass spectrometry. PyrOO^.+ and AnOO^.+ were produced through reaction of the respective distonic aryl radical cations Pyr^.+ and An^.+ with oxygen, O₂. For the reaction of Pyr^.+ with O₂ an absolute rate coefficient of k₁=7.1×10^?12 cm³ molecule^?1 s^?1 and a collision efficiency of 1.2 % was determined at 298 K. The strongly electrophilic PyrOO^.+ reacts with 3‐hexyne and 4‐octyne with absolute rate coefficients of k_hexyne=1.5×10^?10 cm³ molecule^?1 s^?1 and k_octyne=2.8×10^?10 cm³ molecule^?1 s^?1, respectively, at 298 K. The reaction of both PyrOO^.+ and AnOO^.+ proceeds by radical addition to the alkyne, whereas propargylic hydrogen abstraction was observed as a very minor pathway only in the reactions involving PyrOO^.+. A major reaction pathway of the vinyl radicals 11 formed upon PyrOO^.+ addition to the alkynes involves γ‐fragmentation of the peroxy O? O bond and formation of PyrO^.+. The PyrO^.+ is rapidly trapped by intermolecular hydrogen abstraction, presumably from a propargylic methylene group in the alkyne. The reaction of the less electrophilic AnOO^.+ with alkynes is considerably slower and resulted in formation of AnO^.+ as the only charged product. These findings suggest that electrophilic aromatic peroxyl radicals act as oxygen atom donors, which can be used to generate α‐oxo carbenes 13 (or isomeric species) from alkynes in a single step. Besides γ‐fragmentation, a number of competing unimolecular dissociative reactions also occur in vinyl radicals 11 . The potential energy diagrams of these reactions were explored with density functional theory and ab initio methods, which enabled identification of the chemical structures of the most important products.     

Molecular Ions of Transient Species: Vinylamine-Cation

Vinylamine 1 was prepared by thermolysis of cyclobutylamine and its photoelectron spectrum was measured. I = 8.20 eV and I = 8.65 eV were found, the dominant vibrational progression (? = 725 cm^?1) indicating that in the course of 1(X)→1 ⁺( X? ) flattening around the N-atom occurs. The Franck-Condon profile of this band, however, suggests that a skeletal mode of ? ≈ 1400 cm^?1 (observed also in the iso-π-electronic systems vinyl-alcohol-cation and allyl radical) may also be excited. Comparison with the data for the isomer acetaldehyde-imine 2 and its cation s ⁺ shows that the isomer couple 1/2 constitutes a further notable example for a relative thermochemical stability inversion on going from the neutrals to the cations.     

Generation and Characterization of a Distonic Biradical Anion Formed from an Enediynone Prodrug in the Gas Phase

A negatively charged biradical intermediate was successfully generated in the gas phase via cyclization of the deprotonated bicyclo[8.3.0]trideca-12-ene-2,7-diyn-1-one precursor. The inherent negative charge of this biradical allows its characterization via collision-activated dissociation and reactions with a variety of neutral substrates in an FT-ICR mass spectrometer. Although the biradical is unreactive toward reagents that usually react rapidly with positively charged biradicals, such as dimethyl disulfide, it reacts with the halogen-containing substrates carbon tetrachloride, carbon tetrabromide, and bromotrichloromethane via bromine or chlorine atom abstraction, which supports its biradical structure. The results presented in this study indicate that cyclizations commonly used in solution to form biradical intermediates from enediyne compounds may also occur in the gas phase.      

Electroreduction of Molybdate Ions in Solutions Containing Ammonium Ions

An incomplete reduction of molybdate ions in solutions of pH 3.0–9.0 is shown to be accelerated by ammonium ions: a film of hydrated oxides of molybdenum in lower oxidation states forms on the cathode in their presence. Products of the incomplete reduction adsorbed at the cathode block its working surface.     

The Hydrolysis of Hydroxamic Acid Complexants in the Presence of Non-oxidizing Metal Ions 1: Ferric Ions

Hydroxamic acids (XHAs) are organic compounds with affinities for cations such as Fe³⁺, Np⁴⁺ and Pu⁴⁺ and have been identified as useful reagents in nuclear fuel reprocessing. Acid catalyzed hydrolysis of free XHAs is well known and may impact negatively on reprocessing applications. The hydrolysis of metal-bound XHAs within metal ion-XHA complexes is less understood. With the aid of speciation diagrams, we have modelled UV-visible spectrophotometric kinetic studies of the acid-catalyzed hydrolysis of acetohydroxamic acid (AHA) bound to the model ion Fe(III). These studies have yielded the following information for the hydrolysis of AHA in the Fe(AHA)²⁺ complex at 293 K: (i) the order with respect to [H⁺] during the rate determining step, m=0.97, is the same as for the free ligand, indicating a similarity of mechanisms; and (ii) the kinetic rate parameter, k ₁=1.02×10⁻⁴ dm³⋅mol⁻¹⋅s⁻¹, is greater than that for the free ligand, k ₀=1.84×10⁻⁵ dm³⋅mol⁻¹⋅s⁻¹ for pH>−0.5, a result that is consistent with a Hammett analysis of the system.     

Molecular Ions of Transient Species: Vinyl-Alcohol Cation

Vinyl alcohol 1 was prepared by thermolysis of cyclobutanol and its photoelectron spectrum was determined. I = 9.18 eV and I = 9.52 eV were found, the vibrations progression (? = 1400 cm^?1) for this lowest energy transition 1(X)→1⁺(X?) indicating significant skeletal changes in the ion. The question of the relative stability of the syn ( 1 )- vs. anti-ions ( 1 ) is discussed in the light of theoretical calculations. The energy of the second π-state of 1 ⁺ is estimated at 13.6–14.1 eV above the ground state of 1 .     

Nitrogen as Leaving Group: Aliphatic Diazonium Ions

Nitrogen is one of the best known leaving groups. Decomposition of aliphatic diazonium ions has rendered carbocations (carbon cations) accessible in cases where the solvolysis of halides or sulfonic esters follows different pathways. The limits of unassisted decomposition are seen in primary diazonium ions, where the participation of external nucleophiles and of neighboring groups in the elimination of nitrogen becomes noticeable. Cyclopropanediazonium ions occupy a position intermediate between aliphatic and aromatic diazonium ions. New versatile methods of generating aliphatic diazonium ions facilitate their preparative use.     

Sulfite Oxidation Catalyzed by Manganese(II) Ions: Reaction Kinetics in Excess of Metal Ions

Kinetics and Catalysis - The paper gives a summary of data on the kinetics of oxygen oxidation of sulfite in the presence of manganese(II) salts at ambient temperature in a medium with pH...