Electrodipping force acting on solid particles at a fluid interface

We report experimental results which show that the interfacial deformation around glass particles (radius, 200-300 microm) at an oil-water (or air-water) interface is dominated by an electric force, rather than by gravity. It turns out that this force, called for brevity "electrodipping," is independent of the electrolyte concentration in the water phase. The force is greater for oil-water than for air-water interfaces. Under our experimental conditions, it is due to charges at the particle-oil (instead of particle-water) boundary. The derived theoretical expressions, and the experiment, indicate that this electric force pushes the particles into water. To compute exactly the electric stresses, we solved numerically the electrostatic boundary problem, which reduces to a set of differential equations. Convenient analytical expressions are also derived. Both the experimental and the calculated meniscus profile, which are in excellent agreement, exhibit a logarithmic dependence at long distances. This gives rise to a long-range electric-field-induced capillary attraction between the particles, detected by other authors. Deviation from the logarithmic dependence is observed at short distances from the particle surface due to the electric pressure difference across the meniscus. The latter effect gives rise to an additional short-range contribution to the capillary interaction between two floating particles. The above conclusions are valid for either planar or spherical fluid interfaces, including emulsion drops. The electrodipping force, and the related long-range capillary attraction, can engender two-dimensional aggregation and self-assembly of colloidal particles. These effects could have implications for colloid science and the development of new materials.     

Direct measurement of the viscous force between two spherical particles trapped in a thin wetting film

Here we present the first direct measurement of the viscous drag force between two spherical particles of millimeter size trapped in a thin wetting film. Each particle is constrained by the liquid/air interface and the solid substrate. The viscous force is counterbalanced by another known force, the attractive capillary immersion force between identical particles protruding from the film surface. The results of the measurements provide evidence for an increased hydrodynamic force due to a non-Stokesian resistance to the particle motion. Our findings can be applied to the self-assembly of colloidal particles in a two-dimensional array for coating and to the friction between small species and a solid. Received: 19 March 1999 Accepted in revised form: 11 May 1999     

Structure and stability of silica particle monolayers at horizontal and vertical octane-water interfaces

Monolayers of silica particles at horizontal and vertical octane-water interfaces have been studied by microscopy. It is found that their structure and stability depend strongly on the particle hydrophobicity. Very hydrophobic silica particles, with a contact angle of 152 degrees measured through the water, give well-ordered monolayers at interparticle distances larger than 5 particle diameters which are stable toward aggregation and sedimentation. In contrast, monolayers of less-hydrophobic particles are disordered and unstable. Two-dimensional particle sedimentation has been observed in the case of vertical monolayers. The results have been analyzed with a simple two-particle model considering the sedimentation equilibrium as a balance between the long-range electrostatic repulsion through the oil, the gravity force, and the capillary attraction due to deformation of the fluid interface around particles. The value of the charge density at the particle-octane interface, 14.1 muC/m(2), found for the most hydrophobic particles is reasonable. It drastically decreases for particles with lower hydrophobicity, which is consistent with the order-disorder transition in monolayer structure reported by us before. The pair interactions between particles at a horizontal octane-water interface have been analyzed including the capillary attraction due to undulated three-phase contact line caused by nonuniform wetting (the contact angle hysteresis). The results are in agreement with the great stability of very hydrophobic silica particle monolayers detected experimentally, even at low pH at the point of zero charge of the particle-water interface, and with the aggregated structure of hydrophilic particle monolayers.     

Particle bridging between oil and water interfaces

Particle bridging between a water drop and a flat oil-water interface has been observed when the drop is brought into contact with the interface, leading to the formation of a dense particle monolayer of disc shape (namely, particle disc) that prevents the drop from coalescing into the bulk water phase. Unlike previous observations where particles from opposite interfaces appear to register with each other before bridging, the present experiment demonstrates that the particle registry is not a necessity for bridging. In many cases, the particles from one of the interfaces were repelled away from the contact region, leaving behind the particles from the other interface to bridge the two interfaces. This is confirmed by particle bridging experiments between two interfaces covered with different sized particles, and between a particle-covered interface and a clean interface. The dynamics associated with the growth of the particle disc due to particle bridging follows a power law relationship between the radius of the disc and time: r proportional, variant t0.32+/-0.03. A scaling analysis assuming capillary attraction as the driving force and a hydrodynamic resistance leads to the power law r proportional, variant t1/3, in good agreement with the experiment. In addition, we found that binary mixtures of two different sized particles can undergo phase segregation driven by the particle bridging process.     

Capillary forces between spherical particles floating at a liquid-liquid interface

We study the capillary forces acting on sub-millimeter particles (0.02-0.6 mm) trapped at a liquid-liquid interface due to gravity-induced interface deformations. An analytical procedure is developed to solve the linearized capillary (Young-Laplace) equation and calculate the forces for an arbitrary number of particles, allowing also for a background curvature of the interface. The full solution is expressed in a series of Bessel functions with coefficients determined by the contact angle at the particle surface. For sub-millimeter spherical particles, it is shown that the forces calculated using the lowest order term of the full solution (linear superposition approximation; LSA) are accurate to within a few percents. Consequently the many particle capillary force is simply the sum of the isolated pair interactions. To test these theoretical results, we use video microscopy to follow the motion of individual particles and pairs of interacting particles at a liquid-liquid interface with a slight macroscopic background curvature. Particle velocities are determined by the balance of capillary forces and viscous drag. The measured velocities (and thus the capillary forces) are well described by the LSA solution with a single fitting parameter.     

Dielectric force and relative motion between two spherical particles in electrophoresis

When two particles close to each other are in electrophoretic motion, each particle is under the influence of the nonuniform electric field generated by the other particle. Two particles may attract or repel each other due to the dielectric force, depending on their positions in the nonuniform electric field. In this work, the dielectric interaction and the subsequent relative motion of the two arbitrarily oriented spherical particles are analyzed. The dielectric force is obtained by integrating the Maxwell stress. The result is valid for arbitrary orientations of the particles under the thin electrical-double-layer assumption. The magnitude of the dielectric force is compared to the so-called inertia-induced force, which shows that the dielectric force is normally much greater than the inertia-induced force. The relative velocity of particles is determined by the force balance between the dielectric force and the Stokes drag. The regions of attraction and repulsion are defined. It is shown that a pair of particles eventually aligns parallel to the externally applied electric field, except in the case where the two particles are initially oriented perpendicular to the electric field. A closed-form analytical solution is obtained for the particle trajectory by using the approximate expression for the dielectric force valid for not-too-closely located particles.     

Interactions between particles with an undulated contact line at a fluid interface: capillary multipoles of arbitrary order

A colloidal particle adsorbed at a fluid interface could have an undulated, or irregular contact line in the presence of surface roughness and/or chemical inhomogeneity. The contact-line undulations produce distortions in the surrounding liquid interface, whose overlap engenders capillary interaction between the particles. The convex and concave local deviations of the meniscus shape from planarity can be formally treated as positive and negative "capillary charges," which form "capillary multipoles." Here, we derive theoretical expressions for the interaction between two capillary multipoles of arbitrary order. Depending on the angle of mutual orientation, the interaction energy could exhibit a minimum, or it could represent a monotonic attraction. For undulation amplitudes larger than 5 nm, the interaction energy is typically much greater than the thermal energy kT. As a consequence, a monolayer from capillary multipoles exhibits considerable shear elasticity, and such monolayer is expected to behave as a two-dimensional elastic solid. These theoretical results could be helpful for the understanding of phenomena related to aggregation and ordering of particles adsorbed at a fluid interface, and for the interpretation of rheological properties of particulate monolayers. Related research fields are the particle-stabilized (Pickering) emulsions and the two-dimensional self-assembly of microscopic particles.     

Electrostatic double-layer interaction between spherical particles inside a rough capillary

Predictions of electrostatic double-layer interaction forces between two similarly charged spherical colloidal particles inside an infinitely long "rough" capillary are presented. A simple model of a rough cylindrical surface is proposed, which assumes the capillary wall to be a periodic function of axial position. The periodic roughness of the wall is characterized by the wavelength and amplitude of the undulations. The electrostatic double-layer interaction force between two spherical particles located axially inside this rough capillary is determined by solving the nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann equation employing finite element analysis. The effect of surface roughness of the cylindrical enclosure on the interaction force between two particles is extensively studied on the basis of this model. The simulations are carried out for dimensionless amplitudes (amplitude/particle radii) ranging from 0.05 to 0.15 and scaled wavelengths (wavelength/particle radii) ranging from 0.4 to 4.0. The interaction force between the particles is significantly modified by the proximity of the rough capillary wall. Generally, the interaction force for rough capillaries oscillates around the corresponding interaction force in a smooth capillary depending on the magnitudes of the scaled amplitude and wavelength of the roughness. The influence of roughness on the electrostatic interactions becomes more pronounced when the surface potential of the cylinder wall is different from the sphere surface potentials. When the cylinder and the particle surfaces have large potential differences, the axial force experienced by a particle is dominated by the capillary roughness. There are dramatic oscillations of the force, which alternately becomes repulsive and attractive as the particle moves from the crest to the trough of the rough capillary wall. These results suggest that manipulation of colloidal particles in narrow microchannels may be subject to significant force variations owing to the roughness inherent in microfabricated channels etched on metal films.     

Capillary force required to detach micron-sized particles from solid surfaces—Validation with bubbles circulating in water and 2 μm-diameter latex spheres

The adhesion forces holding micron-sized particles to solid surfaces can be studied through the detachment forces developed by the transit of an air–liquid interface in a capillary. Two key variables affect the direction and magnitude of the capillary detachment force: (i) the thickness of the liquid film between the bubble and the capillary walls, and (ii) the effective angle of the triple phase contact between the particles and the interface. Variations in film thickness were calculated using a two-phase flow model. Film thickness was used to determine the time-variation of the capillary force during transit of the bubble. The curve for particle detachment was predicted from the calculated force. This curve proved to be non-linear and gave in situ information on the effective contact angle developing at the particle–bubble interface during detachment. This approach allowed an accurate determination of the detachment force. This theoretical approach was validated using latex particles 2 μm in diameter.     

Molecular dynamics simulation of optically trapped colloidal particles at an oil-water interface

Using molecular dynamics simulations, we calculate the net force on a colloidal particle trapped by an optical tweezer and confined within a particle monolayer which is in motion relative to the trapped particle. The calculations are compared with recent experimental data on polystyrene particles located at an oil-water interface. Good agreement between theory and experiment is obtained over the investigated range of lattice constants for an interaction mechanism between the polystyrene particles which is dominated by an effective dipole-dipole potential. The assumed interaction mechanism is consistent with the formation of surface charge dipoles at the particle-oil interface due to the dissociaton of the hydrophilic sulfate headgroups at the surface of the polystyrene particles. A possible physical mechanism for the formation of the surface charge dipoles, involving a diffuse cloud of fully hydrated counterions, is described, and the fraction of surface groups contributing to the formation of surface charge dipoles is estimated to be of the order of 10(-1) for the present system.     

Force balance of particles trapped at fluid interfaces

We study the effective forces acting between colloidal particles trapped at a fluid interface which itself is exposed to a pressure field. To this end, we apply what we call the "force approach," which relies solely on the condition of mechanical equilibrium and turns to be in a certain sense less restrictive than the more frequently used "energy approach," which is based on the minimization of a free energy functional. The goals are (i) to elucidate the advantages and disadvantages of the force approach as compared to the energy approach, and (ii) to disentangle which features of the interfacial deformation and of the capillary-induced forces between the particles follow from the gross feature of mechanical equilibrium alone, as opposed to features which depend on the details of, e.g., the interaction of the interface with the particles or the boundaries of the system. First, we derive a general stress-tensor formulation of the forces at the interface. On that basis we work out a useful analogy with two-dimensional electrostatics in the particular case of small deformations of the interface relative to its flat configuration. We apply this analogy in order to compute the asymptotic decay of the effective force between particles trapped at a fluid interface, extending the validity of the previous results and revealing the advantages and limitations of the force approach compared to the energy approach. It follows the application of the force approach to the case of deformations of a nonflat interface. In this context, we first compute the deformation of a spherical droplet due to the electric field of a charged particle trapped at its surface and conclude that the interparticle capillary force is unlikely to explain certain recent experimental observations within such a configuration. We finally discuss the application of our approach to a generally curved interface and show as an illustrative example that a nonspherical particle deposited on an interface forming a minimal surface is pulled to regions of larger curvature.     

Electric forces induced by a charged colloid particle attached to the water-nonpolar fluid interface

Here, we solve the problem about the electric field of a charged dielectric particle, which is adsorbed at the water-nonpolar fluid (oil, air) boundary. The solution of this problem is a necessary step for the theoretical prediction of the electrodipping force acting on such particle, as well as of the electrostatic repulsion and capillary attraction between two adsorbed particles. In accordance with the experimental observations, we consider the important case when the surface charges are located at the particle-nonpolar fluid boundary. To solve the electrostatic problem, the Mehler-Fock integral transform is applied. In the special case when the dielectric constants of the particle and the nonpolar fluid are equal, the solution is obtained in a closed analytical form. In the general case of different dielectric constants, the problem is reduced to the numerical solution of an integral equation, which is carried out by iterations. The long-range asymptotics of the solution indicates that two similar particles repel each other as dipoles, whose dipole moments are related to the particle radius, contact angle, dielectric constant and surface charge density. The investigated short-range asymptotics ensures accurate calculation of the electrodipping force. For a fast and convenient application of the obtained results, the derived physical dependencies are tabulated as functions of the contact angle and the dielectric constants.     

Spontaneous formation of mesostructures in colloidal monolayers trapped at the air-water interface: a simple explanation

The spontaneous formation of loosely bound ordered aggregates, foam, voids, chains, striations, and loops (see Figure 1a), called mesostructures hereafter, has been observed in colloidal monolayers trapped at the air-water interface. The distance between particles in these mesostructures is of the order of the particle radius (micrometers), implying that the colloidal interaction potential has a minimum at such distances, which could induce the phase separation of colloidal monolayers in dense and dilute regions. This is at odds with the accepted theory (Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO)) of colloidal interactions, which predicts a secondary minimum at distances of nanometers between pairs of interacting particles. Moreover, the introduction of capillary, hydrophobic, and dipolar interactions between particles in an extended DLVO theory is not able to explain the spontaneous formation of mesostructures either. Recently, a great deal of effort has focused on understanding the mechanism behind the phenomenon of long-range attraction between colloidal particles confined in interfaces. In particular, this attraction has been employed to explain the spontaneous formation of mesostructures. Here, we show that the appearance of our mesostructures is due to the contamination of colloidal monolayers by silicone oil (poly(dimethylsiloxane)), which arises from the coating of the needles and syringes used to deposit and spread the particle solution at the air-water interface. The difference in the interfacial tension of water and silicone oil accounts for the formation of the experimentally observed mesostructures.     

Capillary and van der Waals forces between uncharged colloidal particles linked by a liquid bridge

This work presents a theoretical study of the forces established between colloidal particles connected by means of a concave liquid bridge, where the solid particles are partially wetted by a certain amount of liquid also possessing a dry portion of their surfaces. In our analysis, we adopt a two-particle model assuming that the solids are spherical and with the same sizes and properties and that the liquid meniscus features an arc-of-circumference contour. The forces considered are the typical capillary ones, namely, wetting and Laplace forces, as well as the van der Waals force, assuming the particles uncharged. We analyze different parameters which govern the liquid bridge: interparticle separation, wetting angle, and liquid volume, which later determine the value of the forces. Due to the dual characteristic of the particles' surfaces, wet and dry, the forces are to be determined numerically in each case. The results indicate that the capillary forces are dominant in most of the situations meanwhile the van der Waals force is noticeable at very short distances between the particles.     

Electrohydrodynamic Velocity and Pumping Measurements in Water and Alcohols

Bubble and particle velocities in water and alcohols, under the influence of an electric field, were investigated in this work. Air bubbles were injected into the liquids through an electrified metal capillary insulated by glass with its tip left exposed. The end of the capillary from which the bubbles were released was conical in shape. Due to an electric field formed between the noninsulated capillary tip and a ground electrode immersed in the solvent, small bubbles were formed and used as tracers for the electrohydrodynamic (EHD) flow field. The pressure inside the capillary was measured for all liquids used in this study. For water, ethanol, and n-propanol, it was found that, at relatively low applied voltage, the pressure increases with voltage, reaches a maximum (pressure breakpoint), and then sharply decreases. This behavior is a result of the competition between the electric force appearing at the interface and the force due to the EHD flow near the capillary tip. The electric force tends to increase the pressure inside the capillary, while the EHD flow tends to decrease this pressure. For isopropanol and butanol, the pressure breakpoint was not observed in the range of voltage applied in the experiments. The EHD flow velocity was measured by using microbubbles and particles as flow tracers. An adaptive phase-Doppler velocimeter was employed to measure the velocity of bubbles, while the velocity of particles was measured by trajectory visualization of fluorescent particles. A discrepancy was observed between the two methods because of the location at which the measurements were made. It was found that average velocities of both bubbles and particles increase linearly with applied voltage. Experiments were also conducted to investigate pumping of water, which is a result of the EHD velocity near the capillary tip. The pumping flow rate was linearly related to the applied voltage and agreed well with EHD velocity measurements obtained from particle trajectories. Copyright 2000 Academic Press.     

Influence of surface topography on the interactions between nanostructured hydrophobic surfaces

Nanostructured particle coated surfaces, with hydrophobized particles arranged in close to hexagonal order and of specific diameters ranging from 30 nm up to 800 nm, were prepared by Langmuir-Blodgett deposition followed by silanization. These surfaces have been used to study interactions between hydrophobic surfaces and a hydrophobic probe using the AFM colloidal probe technique. The different particle coated surfaces exhibit similar water contact angles, independent of particle size, which facilitates studies of how the roughness length scale affects capillary forces (previously often referred to as "hydrophobic interactions") in aqueous solutions. For surfaces with smaller particles (diameter < 200 nm), an increase in roughness length scale is accompanied by a decrease in adhesion force and bubble rupture distance. It is suggested that this is caused by energy barriers that prevent the motion of the three-phase (vapor/liquid/solid) line over the surface features, which counteracts capillary growth. Some of the measured force curves display extremely long-range interaction behavior with rupture distances of several micrometers and capillary growth with an increase in volume during retraction. This is thought to be a consequence of nanobubbles resting on top of the surface features and an influx of air from the crevices between the particles on the surface.     

Optical trapping forces for colloids at the oil-water interface

We calculate the optical trapping forces exerted by a single laser beam strongly focused on a dielectric sphere located at a two-dimensional (2D) oil-water interface. The calculated lateral trapping forces, based on the geometrical optics approximation (GOA), agree with experimental measurements of the trapping force. Importantly, the calculations verify that the radiation force exerted on particles perpendicular to the interface is not sufficient to induce capillary interactions between particle pairs, which could be mistaken for particle-particle interactions. Finally, we find that the trapping forces depend on the three-phase contact angle of the particle at the interface.     

Forces between a hard surface and an air–aqueous interface with and without films

The adsorption of particles to air–aqueous interfaces is vital in many applications, such as mineral flotation and the stabilization of food foams. The forces in the system determine whether a particle will attach to an air–aqueous interface. The forces between a particle and an air–aqueous interface are influenced by Derjaguin–Landau–Verwey–Overbeek forces (i.e. van der Waals and electrostatic forces), non–Derjaguin–Landau–Verwey–Overbeek forces (e.g. hydrophobic, hydrodynamic, structural, and capillary forces), liquid drainage, and liquid flow. As an air–aqueous interface can be deformed by a particle, the forces measured between an air–aqueous interface and a particle can differ from those measured between two hard surfaces separated by liquid. The presence of a film at an air–aqueous interface can also change the forces.