Strategies Towards Capturing Nitrogenase Substrates and Intermediates via Controlled Alteration of Electron Fluxes

Nitrogenase utilizes an ATP-dependent reductase to deliver electrons to its catalytic component to enable two important reactions: the reduction of N₂ to NH₄⁺, and the reduction of CO to hydrocarbons. The two nitrogenase-based reactions parallel the industrial Haber–Bosch and Fischer–Tropsch processes, yet they occur under ambient conditions. As such, understanding the enzymatic mechanism of nitrogenase is crucial for the future development of biomimetic strategies for energy-efficient production of valuable chemical commodities. Mechanistic investigations of nitrogenase has long been hampered by the difficulty to trap substrates and intermediates relevant to the nitrogenase reactions. Recently, we have successfully captured CO on the Azotobacter vinelandii V-nitrogenase via two approaches that alter the electron fluxes in a controlled manner: one approach utilizes an artificial electron donor to trap CO on the catalytic component of V-nitrogenase in the resting state; whereas the other employs a mismatched reductase component to reduce the electron flux through the system and consequently accumulate CO on the catalytic component of V-nitrogenase. Here we summarize the major outcome of these recent studies, which not only clarified the catalytic relevance of the one-CO (lo-CO) and multi-CO (hi-CO) bound states of nitrogenase, but also pointed to a potential competition between N₂ and CO for binding to the same pair of reactive Fe sites across the sulfur belt of the cofactor. Together, these results highlight the utility of these strategies in poising the cofactor at a well-defined state for substrate- or intermediate-trapping via controlled alteration of electron fluxes, which could prove beneficial for further elucidation of the mechanistic details of nitrogenase-catalyzed reactions.     

Structure and Reactivity of an Asymmetric Synthetic Mimic of Nitrogenase Cofactor

The Mo nitrogenase catalyzes the ambient reduction of N₂ to NH₃ at its M‐cluster site. A complex metallocofactor with a core composition of [MoFe₇S₉C], the M‐cluster, can be extracted from the protein scaffold and used to facilitate the catalytic reduction of CN^?, CO, and CO₂ into hydrocarbons in the isolated state. Herein, we report the synthesis, structure, and reactivity of an asymmetric M‐cluster analogue with a core composition of [MoFe₅S₉]. This analogue, referred to as the Mo‐cluster, is the first synthetic example of an M‐cluster mimic with Fe and Mo positioned at opposite ends of the cluster. Moreover, the ability of the Mo‐cluster to reduce C₁ substrates to hydrocarbons suggests the feasibility of developing nitrogenase‐based biomimetic approaches to recycle C₁ waste into fuel products.     

Differential Reduction of CO2 by Molybdenum and Vanadium Nitrogenases

The molybdenum and vanadium nitrogenases are two homologous enzymes with distinct structural and catalytic features. Previously, it was demonstrated that the V nitrogenase was nearly 700 times more active than its Mo counterpart in reducing CO to hydrocarbons. Herein, a similar discrepancy between the two nitrogenases in the reduction of CO₂ is reported, with the V nitrogenase being capable of reducing CO₂ to CO, CD₄, C₂D₄, and C₂D₆, and its Mo counterpart only capable of reducing CO₂ to CO. Furthermore, it is shown that the V nitrogenase may direct the formation of CD₄ in part via CO₂‐derived CO, but that it does not catalyze the formation of C₂D₄ and C₂D₆ along this route. The exciting observation of a V nitrogenase‐catalyzed C? C coupling with CO₂ as the origin of the building blocks adds another interesting reaction to the catalytic repertoire of this unique enzyme system. The differential activities of the V and Mo nitrogenases in CO₂ reduction provide an important framework for systematic investigations of this reaction in the future.     

Shielding of Electron Acceptors Coordinated to Rhenium(I) by Carboxylato Groups. Intraligand and Charge‐Transfer Excited‐State Properties of fac‐(‘Anthraquinone‐2‐carboxylato')(2,2′‐bipyridine)tricarbonylrhenium (fac‐[ReI(aq‐2‐CO2)(2,2′‐bipy)(CO)3])

The photophysical and photochemical properties of (OC‐6‐33)‐(2,2′‐bipyridine‐κN¹,κN¹′)tricarbonyl(9,10‐dihydro‐9,10‐dioxoanthracene‐2‐carboxylato‐κO)rhenium (fac‐[Re^I(aq‐2‐CO₂)(2,2′‐bipy)(CO)₃]) were investigated and compared to those of the free ligand 9,10‐dihydro‐9,10‐dioxoanthracene‐2‐carboxylate (=anthraquinone‐2‐carboxylate) and other carboxylato complexes containing the (2,2′‐bipyridine)tricarbonylrhenium ([Re(2,2′‐bipy)(CO)₃]) moiety. Flash and steady‐state irradiations of the anthraquinone‐derived ligand (λ_exc 337 or 351 nm) and of its complex reveal that the photophysics of the latter is dominated by processes initiated in the Re‐to‐(2,2′‐bipyridine) charge‐transfer excited state and 2,2′‐bipyridine‐ and (anthraquinone‐2‐carboxylato)‐centered intraligand excited states. In the reductive quenching by N,N‐diethylethanamine (TEA) or 2,2′,2″‐nitrilotris[ethanol] TEOA, the reactive states are the 2,2′‐bipyridine‐centered and/or the charge‐transfer excited states. The species with a reduced anthraquinone moiety is formed by the following intramolecular electron transfer, after the redox quenching of the excited state: [Re^I(aq−2−CO₂)(2,2′‐bipy^.)(CO)₃]⁻⇌[Re^I(aq−2−CO₂^.)(2,2′‐bipy)(CO)₃]⁻ The photophysics, particularly the absence of a Re^I‐to‐anthraquinone charge‐transfer excited state photochemistry, is discussed in terms of the electrochemical and photochemical results.     

Controlled Synthesis of a Vacancy‐Defect Single‐Atom Catalyst for Boosting CO2 Electroreduction

The reaction of precursors containing both nitrogen and oxygen atoms with Ni^II under 500 °C can generate a N/O mixing coordinated Ni‐N₃O single‐atom catalyst (SAC) in which the oxygen atom can be gradually removed under high temperature due to the weaker Ni?O interaction, resulting in a vacancy‐defect Ni‐N₃‐V SAC at Ni site under 800 °C. For the reaction of Ni^II with the precursor simply containing nitrogen atoms, only a no‐vacancy‐defect Ni‐N₄ SAC was obtained. Experimental and DFT calculations reveal that the presence of a vacancy‐defect in Ni‐N₃‐V SAC can dramatically boost the electrocatalytic activity for CO₂ reduction, with extremely high CO₂ reduction current density of 65 mA cm^?2 and high Faradaic efficiency over 90 % at ?0.9 V vs. RHE, as well as a record high turnover frequency of 1.35×10⁵ h^?1, much higher than those of Ni‐N₄ SAC, and being one of the best reported electrocatalysts for CO₂‐to‐CO conversion to date.     

Activation of CO2 by Vanadium Nitrogenase

The reduction of CO₂ into useful products, including hydrocarbon fuels, is an ongoing area of particular interest due to efforts to mitigate buildup of this greenhouse gas. While the industrial Fischer–Tropsch process can facilitate the hydrogenation of CO₂ with H₂ to form short‐chain hydrocarbon products under high temperatures and pressures, a desire to perform these reactions under ambient conditions has inspired the use of biological approaches. Particularly, enzymes offer insight into how to activate and reduce CO₂, but only one enzyme, nitrogenase, can perform the multielectron, multiproton reduction of CO₂ into hydrocarbons. The vanadium‐containing variant, V‐nitrogenase, displays especial reactivity towards the hydrogenation of CO and CO₂. This Focus Review discusses recent progress towards the activation and reduction of CO₂ with three primary V‐nitrogenase systems. These systems span both ATP‐dependent and ATP‐independent processes and utilize approaches with whole cells, isolated proteins, and extracted cofactors.     

The Origin of the Selectivity and Activity of Ruthenium‐Cluster Catalysts for Fuel‐Cell Feed‐Gas Purification: A Gas‐Phase Approach

Gas‐phase ruthenium clusters Ru_n⁺ (n=2–6) are employed as model systems to discover the origin of the outstanding performance of supported sub‐nanometer ruthenium particles in the catalytic CO methanation reaction with relevance to the hydrogen feed‐gas purification for advanced fuel‐cell applications. Using ion‐trap mass spectrometry in conjunction with first‐principles density functional theory calculations three fundamental properties of these clusters are identified which determine the selectivity and catalytic activity: high reactivity toward CO in contrast to inertness in the reaction with CO₂; promotion of cooperatively enhanced H₂ coadsorption and dissociation on pre‐formed ruthenium carbonyl clusters, that is, no CO poisoning occurs; and the presence of Ru‐atom sites with a low number of metal–metal bonds, which are particularly active for H₂ coadsorption and activation. Furthermore, comprehensive theoretical investigations provide mechanistic insight into the CO methanation reaction and discover a reaction route involving the formation of a formyl‐type intermediate.     

N2‐to‐NH3 Conversion by a triphos–Iron Catalyst and Enhanced Turnover under Photolysis

Bridging iron hydrides are proposed to form at the active site of MoFe‐nitrogenase during catalytic dinitrogen reduction to ammonia and may be key in the binding and activation of N₂ via reductive elimination of H₂. This possibility inspires the investigation of well‐defined molecular iron hydrides as precursors for catalytic N₂‐to‐NH₃ conversion. Herein, we describe the synthesis and characterization of new P₂^P′PhFe(N₂)(H)_x systems that are active for catalytic N₂‐to‐NH₃ conversion. Most interestingly, we show that the yields of ammonia can be significantly increased if the catalysis is performed in the presence of mercury lamp irradiation. Evidence is provided to suggest that photo‐elimination of H₂ is one means by which the enhanced activity may arise.     

Catalytic Reduction of CN−, CO,and CO2 by Nitrogenase Cofactors in Lanthanide‐Driven Reactions

Nitrogenase cofactors can be extracted into an organic solvent to catalyze the reduction of cyanide (CN^?), carbon monoxide (CO), and carbon dioxide (CO₂) without using adenosine triphosphate (ATP), when samarium(II) iodide (SmI₂) and 2,6‐lutidinium triflate (Lut‐H) are employed as a reductant and a proton source, respectively. Driven by SmI₂, the cofactors catalytically reduce CN^? or CO to C₁–C₄ hydrocarbons, and CO₂ to CO and C₁–C₃ hydrocarbons. The C? C coupling from CO₂ indicates a unique Fischer–Tropsch‐like reaction with an atypical carbonaceous substrate, whereas the catalytic turnover of CN^?, CO, and CO₂ by isolated cofactors suggests the possibility to develop nitrogenase‐based electrocatalysts for the production of hydrocarbons from these carbon‐containing compounds.     

Catalytic Reduction of CN−, CO,and CO2 by Nitrogenase Cofactors in Lanthanide‐Driven Reactions

Nitrogenase cofactors can be extracted into an organic solvent to catalyze the reduction of cyanide (CN⁻), carbon monoxide (CO), and carbon dioxide (CO₂) without using adenosine triphosphate (ATP), when samarium(II) iodide (SmI₂) and 2,6‐lutidinium triflate (Lut‐H) are employed as a reductant and a proton source, respectively. Driven by SmI₂, the cofactors catalytically reduce CN⁻ or CO to C₁–C₄ hydrocarbons, and CO₂ to CO and C₁–C₃ hydrocarbons. The C C coupling from CO₂ indicates a unique Fischer–Tropsch‐like reaction with an atypical carbonaceous substrate, whereas the catalytic turnover of CN⁻, CO, and CO₂ by isolated cofactors suggests the possibility to develop nitrogenase‐based electrocatalysts for the production of hydrocarbons from these carbon‐containing compounds.     

Correlating Oxidation State and Surface Ligand Motifs with the Selectivity of CO2 Photoreduction to C2 Products

The design for non-Cu-based catalysts with the function of producing C₂₊ products requires systematic knowledge of the intrinsic connection between the surface state as well as the catalytic activity and selectivity. In this work, photochemical in situ spectral surface characterization techniques combined with the first principle calculations (DFT) were applied to investigate the relationships between the composition of surface states, coordinated motifs, and catalytic selectivity of a titanium oxynitride catalyst. When the catalyst mediates CO₂ photoreduction, C₂ product selectivity is positively correlated with the surface Ti²⁺/Ti³⁺ ratio and the surface oxidation state is regulated and controlled by coordinated motifs of N−Ti-O/V[O], which can reduce the potential dimerization energy barriers of *CO−CO* and promote spontaneous formation of the subsequent *CO−CH₂* intermediate. This phenomenon provides a new perspective for the design of heterogeneous catalysts for photoreduction of CO₂ into useful products.     

Non-Interacting Ni and Fe Dual-Atom Pair Sites in N-Doped Carbon Catalysts for Efficient Concentrating Solar-Driven Photothermal CO2 Reduction

Solar-to-chemical energy conversion under weak solar irradiation is generally difficult to meet the heat demand of CO₂ reduction. Herein, a new concentrated solar-driven photothermal system coupling a dual-metal single-atom catalyst (DSAC) with adjacent Ni−N₄ and Fe−N₄ pair sites is designed for boosting gas-solid CO₂ reduction with H₂O under simulated solar irradiation, even under ambient sunlight. As expected, the (Ni, Fe)−N−C DSAC exhibits a superior photothermal catalytic performance for CO₂ reduction to CO (86.16 μmol g⁻¹ h⁻¹), CH₄ (135.35 μmol g⁻¹ h⁻¹) and CH₃OH (59.81 μmol g⁻¹ h⁻¹), which are equivalent to 1.70-fold, 1.27-fold and 1.23-fold higher than those of the Fe−N−C catalyst, respectively. Based on theoretical simulations, the Fermi level and d-band center of Fe atom is efficiently regulated in non-interacting Ni and Fe dual-atom pair sites with electronic interaction through electron orbital hybridization on (Ni, Fe)−N−C DSAC. Crucially, the distance between adjacent Ni and Fe atoms of the Ni−N−N−Fe configuration means that the additional Ni atom as a new active site contributes to the main *COOH and *HCO₃ dissociation to optimize the corresponding energy barriers in the reaction process, leading to specific dual reaction pathways (COOH and HCO₃ pathways) for solar-driven photothermal CO₂ reduction to initial CO production.     

NHC‐Containing Manganese(I) Electrocatalysts for the Two‐Electron Reduction of CO2

The synthesis and characterization of the first catalytic manganese N‐heterocyclic carbene complexes are reported: MnBr(N‐methyl‐N′‐2‐pyridylbenzimidazol‐2‐ylidine)(CO)₃ and MnBr(N‐methyl‐N′‐2‐pyridylimidazol‐2‐ylidine)(CO)₃. Both new species mediate the reduction of CO₂ to CO following two‐electron reduction of the Mn^I center, as observed with preparative scale electrolysis and verified with ¹³CO₂. The two‐electron reduction of these species occurs at a single potential, rather than in two sequential steps separated by hundreds of millivolts, as is the case for previously reported MnBr(2,2′‐bipyridine)(CO)₃. Catalytic current enhancement is observed at voltages similar to MnBr(2,2′‐bipyridine)(CO)₃.     

Understanding of Strain Effects in the Electrochemical Reduction of CO2: Using Pd Nanostructures as an Ideal Platform

Tuning the surface strain of heterogeneous catalysts represents a powerful strategy to engineer their catalytic properties by altering the electronic structures. However, a clear and systematic understanding of strain effect in electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide is still lacking, which restricts the use of surface strain as a tool to optimize the performance of electrocatalysts. Herein, we demonstrate the strain effect in electrochemical reduction of CO₂ by using Pd octahedra and icosahedra with similar sizes as a well‐defined platform. The Pd icosahedra/C catalyst shows a maximum Faradaic efficiency for CO production of 91.1 % at −0.8 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode (vs. RHE), 1.7‐fold higher than the maximum Faradaic efficiency of Pd octahedra/C catalyst at −0.7 V (vs. RHE). The combination of molecular dynamic simulations and density functional theory calculations reveals that the tensile strain on the surface of icosahedra boosts the catalytic activity by shifting up the d ‐band center and thus strengthening the adsorption of key intermediate COOH*. This strain effect was further verified directly by the surface valence‐band photoemission spectra and electrochemical analysis.     

Investigation of Fe−Ni Mixed‐Oxide Catalysts for the Reduction of NO by CO: Physicochemical Properties and Catalytic Performance

A series of Fe?Ni mixed‐oxide catalysts were synthesized by using the sol–gel method for the reduction of NO by CO. These Fe?Ni mixed‐oxide catalysts exhibited tremendously enhanced catalytic performance compared to monometallic catalysts that were prepared by using the same method. The effects of Fe/Ni molar ratio and calcination temperature on the catalytic activity were examined and the physicochemical properties of the catalysts were characterized by using XRD, Raman spectroscopy, N₂‐adsorption/‐desorption isotherms, temperature‐programmed reduction with hydrogen (H₂‐TPR), temperature‐programmed desorption of nitric oxide (NO‐TPD), and X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The results indicated that the reduction behavior, surface oxygen species, and surface chemical valence states of iron and nickel in the catalysts were the key factors in the NO elimination. Fe_0.5Ni_0.5O_x that was calcined at 250 °C exhibited excellent catalytic activity of 100 % NO conversion at 130 °C and a lifetime of more than 40 hours. A plausible mechanism for the reduction of NO by CO over the Fe?Ni mixed‐oxide catalysts is proposed, based on XPS and in situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) analyses.     

Partial Deoxygenative CO Homocoupling by a Diiron Complex

One route to address climate change is converting carbon dioxide to synthetic carbon-neutral fuels. Whereas carbon dioxide to CO conversion has precedent in homo- and heterogeneous catalysis, deoxygenative coupling of CO to products with C−C bonds—as in liquid fuels—remains challenging. Here, we report coupling of two CO molecules by a diiron complex. Reduction of Fe₂(CO)₂ L ( 2 ), where L ²⁻ is a bis(β-diketiminate) cyclophane, gives [K(THF)₅][Fe₂(CO)₂ L ] ( 3 ), which undergoes silylation to Fe₂(CO)(COSiMe₃) L ( 4 ). Subsequent C-OSiMe₃ bond cleavage and C=C bond formation occurs upon reduction of 4 , yielding Fe₂(μ-CCO) L . CO derived ligands in this series mediate weak exchange interactions with the ketenylidene affording the smallest J value, with changes to local metal ion spin states and coupling schemes (ferro- vs. antiferromagnetism) based on DFT calculations, Mössbauer and EPR spectroscopy. Finally, reaction of 5 with KEt₃BH or methanol releases the C₂O²⁻ ligand with retention of the diiron core     

Highly Efficient CO2 Electroreduction on ZnN4‐based Single‐Atom Catalyst

The electrochemical reduction reaction of carbon dioxide (CO2RR) to carbon monoxide (CO) is the basis for the further synthesis of more complex carbon‐based fuels or attractive feedstock. Single‐atom catalysts have unique electronic and geometric structures with respect to their bulk counterparts, thus exhibiting unexpected catalytic activities. A nitrogen‐anchored Zn single‐atom catalyst is presented for CO formation from CO2RR with high catalytic activity (onset overpotential down to 24 mV), high selectivity (Faradaic efficiency for CO (FE_CO) up to 95 % at ?0.43 V), remarkable durability (>75 h without decay of FE_CO), and large turnover frequency (TOF, up to 9969 h^?1). Further experimental and DFT results indicate that the four‐nitrogen‐anchored Zn single atom (Zn‐N₄) is the main active site for CO2RR with low free energy barrier for the formation of *COOH as the rate‐limiting step.     

The Transition‐Metal‐Like Behavior of B2(NHC)2 in the Activation of CO: HOMO–LUMO Swap Without Photoinduction

It is a current trend to explore multi‐bonded and unsaturated main group compounds that can interact with small molecules, in order to find non‐metal catalysts. Notably, Braunschweig et al. found that diboryne stabilized by N‐heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs) can bind and activate CO. Here we explore the bonding nature of B₂(NHC)₂ and its activation mechanism for CO from a novel theoretical perspective. While the ground state of B₂ is of a single bond, the approach of NHCs excites B₂ to its third excited state of a triple bond with two significant σ‐holes at the two ends. The subsequent electrostatic attraction drives the formation of B₂(NHC)₂. However, only one of the two π bonds (HOMOs) of B₂(NHC)₂ fits to one of the degenerate LUMOs of CO. Interestingly, the strong steric repulsion between CO and B₂(NHC)₂ leads to the HOMO–LUMO swap in the latter. Subsequently, both HOMO and HOMO?1 of B₂(NHC)₂ can effectively interact with the two π* anti‐bonding orbitals (LUMO and LUMO+1) of CO, resulting in substantial electron back‐donation and the ultimate activation of CO.     

Plasma-Assisted Coupling Reactions of Dinitrogen and Carbon Dioxide Mediated by Monometallic YB1–4−⋅Anions: Carbon−Nitrogen Bond Formation

Transition-metal catalyzed coupling to form C−N bonds is significant in chemical science. However, the inert nature of N₂ and CO₂ renders their coupling quite challenging. Herein, we report the activation of dinitrogen in the mild plasma atmosphere by the gas-phase monometallic YB_1–4⁻ anions and further coupling of CO₂ to form C−N bonds by using mass spectrometry and theoretical calculation. The observed product anions are NCNBO⁻ and N(BO)₂⁻, accompanied by the formation of neutral products YO and YB_0–2NC, respectively. We can tune the reactivity and the type of products by manipulating the number of B atoms. The B atoms in YB_1–4N₂⁻ act as electron donors in CO₂ reduction reactions, and the carbon atom originating from CO₂ serves as an electron reservoir. This is the first example of gas-phase monometallic anions, which are capable to realize the functionalization of N₂ with CO₂ through C−N bond formation and N−N and C−O bond cleavage.     

Single Si atom supported on defective boron nitride nanosheet as a promising metal‐free catalyst for N2O reduction by CO or SO2 molecule: A computational study

The low‐temperature reduction of N₂O plays a significant role for solving the growing environmental and health issues caused by emission of this greenhouse gas. The aim of this study is to investigate the possible reaction pathways for the reduction of N₂O by CO or SO₂ molecule over Si‐doped boron nitride nanosheet (Si‐BNNS). According to our results, a B or N‐vacancy defect in BN sheet could be able to greatly stabilize the single Si adatom. The relatively large diffusion barrier for the Si atom over the defective BN sheet also indicates Si‐BNNS is stable enough to be utilized in catalytic reduction of N₂O. The large charge‐transfer from the surface to N₂O leads to the spontaneous dissociation of this molecule into N₂ molecule and an activated oxygen atom (O_ads). The O_ads moiety is then eliminated by CO or SO₂ molecule. The calculated activation energies and reaction energies reveal that the Si atom located on top of the B‐vacancy site has a large catalytic activity toward the reduction of N₂O by CO or SO₂.