Practice parameter: laryngeal electromyography (an evidence-based review)

This paper reports on an evidence-based review of laryngeal electromyography (EMG) as a technique for use in the diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment of laryngeal movement disorders, including the laryngeal dystonias, vocal fold paralysis, and other neurolaryngological disorders. The authors performed a systematic review of the medical literature from 1944 through 2001 on the clinical application of EMG to laryngeal disorders. Thirty-three of the 584 articles met the predefined inclusion criteria. The evidence demonstrated that in a double-blind treatment trial of botulinum toxin versus saline, laryngeal EMG used to guide injections into the thyroarytenoid muscle in persons with adductor spasmodic dysphonia was beneficial. A cross-over comparison between laryngeal EMG-guided injection and endoscopic injection of botulinum toxin into the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle in abductor spasmodic dysphonia found no significant difference between the two techniques and no significant treatment benefit. Based on the evidence, laryngeal EMG is possibly useful for the injection of botulinum toxin into the thyroarytenoid muscle in the treatment of adductor spasmodic dysphonia. There were no evidence-based data sufficient to support or refute the value of laryngeal EMG for the other uses investigated, although there is extensive anecdotal literature suggesting that it is useful for each of them. There is an urgent need for evidence-based research addressing other applications in the use of laryngeal EMG for other applications.     

Acoustic roles of the laryngeal cavity in vocal tract resonance

The acoustic effects of the laryngeal cavity on the vocal tract resonance were investigated by using vocal tract area functions for the five Japanese vowels obtained from an adult male speaker. Transfer functions were examined with the laryngeal cavity eliminated from the whole vocal tract, volume velocity distribution patterns were calculated, and susceptance matching analysis was performed between the laryngeal cavity and the vocal tract excluding the laryngeal cavity (vocal tract proper). It was revealed that the laryngeal cavity generates one of the formants of the vocal tract, which is the fourth in the present study. At this formant, the resonance of the laryngeal cavity (the 1/4 wavelength resonance) induces the open-tube resonance of the vocal tract proper (the 3/2 wavelength resonance). At the other formants, on the other hand, the vocal tract proper acts as a closed tube, because the laryngeal cavity has only a small contribution to generating these formants and the effective closed end of the whole vocal tract is the junction between the laryngeal cavity and the vocal tract proper.     

The Value of Laryngeal Electromyography in the Evaluation of Laryngeal Motion Abnormalities

SUMMARY: Laryngeal electromyography (EMG) functions routinely as a prognostic tool in the evaluation of vocal fold paralysis, as a guide for therapeutic injections into the laryngeal muscles, and more recently as an assessment tool in the evaluation of vocal fold paresis. This study investigates the clinical utility of laryngeal EMG as a diagnostic aid in the evaluation of movement disorders of the larynx in patients complaining of dysphonia. A retrospective chart review of all laryngeal EMGs performed at a tertiary laryngology referral center over a 13-month period was performed. All laryngeal EMGs were performed to evaluate laryngeal motion abnormalities in dysphonic patients. Thirty-seven laryngeal EMGs were completed during this study period. Analysis of the data revealed that the medical treatment plan changed as a result of findings on laryngeal EMG in 10/37 patients (27.0%); laryngeal EMG guided and/or confirmed the course of treatment in 12/37 patients (32.4%) and did not change the treatment plan in 15/37 patients (40.5%). Laryngeal EMG is a useful diagnostic tool that, in this study, contributed significantly to and helped guide the evaluation and management of motion disorders in the larynx of dysphonic patients.     

Acoustic characteristics of Mandarin esophageal speech

The present study attempted to investigate the acoustic characteristics of Mandarin laryngeal and esophageal speech. Eight normal laryngeal and seven esophageal speakers participated in the acoustic experiments. Results from acoustic analyses of syllables /ma/and /ba/ indicated that, F0, intensity, and signal-to-noise ratio of laryngeal speech were significantly higher than those of esophageal speech. However, opposite results were found for vowel duration, jitter, and shimmer. Mean F0, intensity, and word per minute in reading were greater but number of pauses was smaller in laryngeal speech than those in esophageal speech. Similar patterns of F0 contours and vowel duration as a function of tone were found between laryngeal and esophageal speakers. Long-time spectra analysis indicated that higher first and second formant frequencies were associated with esophageal speech than that with normal laryngeal speech.     

Odor Provocation Test for Laryngeal Hypersensitivity

This study was to present an odor provocation/challenge test for laryngeal hypersensitivity in a suspected odor induced dysphonic patient. The second aim was to rule out secondary gain from organic laryngeal hypersensitivity. Two steps were taken for this purpose. First, because the evaluation of hypersensitivity may be affected by the perception of odor, the study investigated laryngeal hypersensitivity during nasal and oral breathing separately to disentangle possible cognitive reactions to odors. Second, a healthy control (HC) participant was used with the identical testing protocol for nasal breathing to minimize unbiased results. The HC's response to nasal breathing of the odors showed no response to all the stimuli. The participant with possible secondary gain issues responded differently to the odors when presented nasally versus orally. Oral breathing showed less severe and less frequent laryngeal hypersensitive reactions. This suggests that laryngeal hypersensitivity was either due to the odor, cognitive information, sensory changes in olfaction leading to psychological conditioning, or for any possible secondary gain. Hence, it is difficult to indicate the precise reason (cause and effect) for the participant's laryngeal hypersensitivity; however, this study describes the first structured, controlled, repeatable, and randomized design to investigate odor induced laryngeal hypersensitivity and decipher possible secondary gain from true laryngeal hypersensitivity.     

Objective Voice Measures in Nonsinging Patients With Unilateral Superior Laryngeal Nerve Paresis

The clinical value of objective voice measures in nonsinging patients with superior laryngeal nerve dysfunction is unknown. In this study, patients with symptomatic unilateral superior nerve paresis were evaluated for maximum phonation time, frequency range of phonation, and mean flow rate. Patients with coexisting pathology, bilateral superior nerve paresis, and those with recurrent laryngeal nerve paresis were excluded from this analysis. A total of 35 nonsinging patients, 14 men and 21 women, with unilateral superior laryngeal nerve paresis were examined between 1999 and 2002. The severity of superior laryngeal nerve paresis ranged from 25% to 85% of normal recruitment with a mean of 70% superior laryngeal nerve recruitment in men and 65% in women by electromyography. In both men and women with superior laryngeal nerve paresis, the maximum phonation time and frequency range of phonation were decreased and the mean air flow rate was increased when compared with normal population values. The jitter percent, shimmer percent, and noise-to-harmonic ratio were also increased in patients when compared with normative data. Selected objective voice measures are abnormal in voice patients with superior laryngeal nerve paresis, which suggests that the measures may be useful as outcomes measures after therapy. More research is encouraged.     

Interrelation of mandibular laryngeal functions

The purpose of the experiment was to explore relations between jaw and laryngeal functions. The general question was whether laryngeal adduction was affected by jaw opening or by jaw biting. Twelve untrained, vocally healthy male and female adults participated as subjects. Subjects produced repeated tokens of /uh/ in each of 12 experimental conditions involving combinations of 3 jaw openings (10 mm, 25 mm, 40 mm), 2 jaw biting pressures (10 kPa, 200 kPa), and 2 fundamental frequencies (conversational and high). For each token, laryngeal adduction was estimated from the electroglottographic closed quotient. The most straightforward results were that (1) laryngeal adduction increased as jaw opening increased at the conversational pitch, for all subjects, independent of biting pressure, and (2) laryngeal adduction increased as biting pressure increased, at the conversational pitch, for males, independent of jaw opening. Other relations between estimated laryngeal adduction and jaw manipulations were more complex, varying with fundamental frequency and gender. Speculations are made about possible biomechanical and neurological explanations for the findings.     

Symptoms of Extraesophageal Reflux in a Community-Dwelling Sample

OBJECTIVES: Extraesophageal reflux disease (EERD) is linked with serious and varied health concerns. The authors' goal was to determine the prevalence of EERD and the effect on health-related quality of life in adults within a large community-based sample. STUDY DESIGN: Survey study conducted in a community setting. METHODS: In the Madison, Wisconsin area, 1845 adult subjects were surveyed. Main outcome measures were frequently of GERD and laryngeal symptoms, the Medical Outcomes Trust Short Form 12 (SF-12), Voice Handicap Index (VHI), and Quality of Life in Reflux and Dyspepsia (QOLRAD) questionnaires. RESULTS: More than 66% of subjects reported either GERD or laryngeal symptoms, and 26% reported both GERD and laryngeal symptoms (which reflect symptoms commonly reported for EERD). In addition, 39% of our sample took medicine for heartburn. Forty-four percent of subjects with both GERD and laryngeal symptoms reported occasional breathing difficulties, and 38% of these subjects reported a voice disorder. Significant reductions in perceived quality of general health, digestive health, and voice-related quality of life were found in subjects with both GERD and laryngeal symptoms, in comparison with subjects manifesting each symptom group alone, or in subjects with no symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: The presence of GERD and laryngeal symptoms, and their concurrence, was identified in a substantial number of subjects. The GERD and laryngeal symptoms surveyed represent those most commonly reported for EERD. Because EERD has been linked with tissue damage and reductions in health-related quality of life, it is important to identify these persons and provide treatment before progression of the condition.     

Objective measures of voice production in patients complaining of laryngeal fatigue

The purpose of this retrospective study is to describe results of acoustic, aerodynamic, and videostroboscopic measures in patients complaining of laryngeal fatigue. Data were collected from 88 patients whose primary complaint was chronic laryngeal fatigue in the absence of visible laryngeal pathologies. The results revealed an abnormally high airflow rate and decreased maximum phonation time. An anterior glottal chink, anterior and posterior glottal chinks, or spindle-shaped glottal closure were found in 61% of the subjects.     

Strobovideolaryngoscopy in the management of acute laryngeal trauma

Surgical intervention in the management of acute laryngeal trauma can sometimes pose a difficult decision. The objective of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of strobovideolaryngoscopy (SVL) in determining the course of management for patients sustaining acute laryngeal trauma. A 20-year retrospective study of patients presenting with acute laryngeal trauma was performed in order to determine if the addition of SVL during the study period changed the management of certain acute laryngeal injuries. Patients sustaining blunt laryngeal trauma evaluated at our institution from 1981 to the present were reviewed. There were 40 patients identified that were grouped by severity according to the Schaefer classification. Analysis included mechanism of injury, clinical presentation, assessment, treatment, and outcome. Group 1 injuries were the most common, with motor vehicle accident (MVA) the most frequent mechanism of injury. Initial assessment included fiberoptic laryngoscopy and computed tomography (CT) imaging in all patients not requiring immediate exploration. SVL was used in 20 patients, with 7 undergoing stroboscopy within 24 hours of presentation. All 7 patients were managed conservatively without surgical intervention or the need to establish an alternative airway. SVL improves the clinical assessment of patients with acute laryngeal injury. This study supports its use and found it to be an important factor in determining the need for surgical intervention. SVL may also shorten the hospital stay in these patients.     

A study on the mechanism of functional dysphonia

A total of 333 patients with a diagnosis of functional dysphonia were studied by both laryngeal electromyography (EMG) and spectral analysis. EMG and acoustic analysis revealed that some patients with so-called functional dysphonia diagnosed by physical examination alone in fact suffered from a variable degree of laryngeal nerve paralysis. Laryngeal EMG plays an important role in determining whether patients with a diagnosis of functional dysphonia have organic disease of the laryngeal nerves.     

Neuromuscular control of fundamental frequency and glottal posture at phonation onset

The laryngeal neuromuscular mechanisms for modulating glottal posture and fundamental frequency are of interest in understanding normal laryngeal physiology and treating vocal pathology. The intrinsic laryngeal muscles in an in vivo canine model were electrically activated in a graded fashion to investigate their effects on onset frequency, phonation onset pressure, vocal fold strain, and glottal distance at the vocal processes. Muscle activation plots for these laryngeal parameters were evaluated for the interaction of following pairs of muscle activation conditions: (1) cricothyroid (CT) versus all laryngeal adductors (TA/LCA/IA), (2) CT versus LCA/IA, (3) CT versus thyroarytenoid (TA) and, (4) TA versus LCA/IA (LCA: lateral cricoarytenoid muscle, IA: interarytenoid). Increases in onset frequency and strain were primarily affected by CT activation. Onset pressure correlated with activation of all adductors in activation condition 1, but primarily with CT activation in conditions 2 and 3. TA and CT were antagonistic for strain. LCA/IA activation primarily closed the cartilaginous glottis while TA activation closed the mid-membranous glottis.     

Treatment of spasmodic dysphonia (laryngeal dystonia) with local injections of Botulinum toxin

In 1984 the authors performed the first laryngeal injection of Botulinum toxin for laryngeal dystonia via percutaneous, electromyographically guided technique. Since that time we have treated 450 patients with adductor spasmodic dysphonia, abductor spasmodic dysphonia, and adductor breathing dystonia. In general, the adductor patients received bilateral injections of 1.25 U to 3.75 U, obtaining greater than 90% of normal voice. The abductor patients received unilateral or staged bilateral injections of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscles with 0.6 to 3.75 U, obtaining 70% of normal function. We have found laryngeal injections of Botulinum toxin to be safe and effective therapy for the symptoms of laryngeal dystonia (spasmodic dysphonia).     

Vocal Process Avulsion

Vocal process avulsion is a rare condition in which laryngeal trauma causes a separation of the vocal process from the body of the arytenoid cartilage. Typically symptoms are dysphonia and shortness of breath during phonation. Strobovideolaryngoscopy, laryngeal electromyography, and laryngeal computed tomography are helpful in establishing this important and sometimes elusive diagnosis. Several treatment modalities have been reported with varying success. We report four new cases, review four cases reported previously by the senior author, and suggest approaches to diagnosis and optimal treatment of vocal process avulsion.     

Laryngeal Manifestations of Postpoliomyelitis Syndrome

Postpoliomyelitis syndrome (PPS) is a disease that may occur in survivors of acute poliomyelitis several decades after their initial infection. It can present as dysphonia, with vocal weakness and fatigue. Swallowing, respiratory, and other laryngopharyngeal symptoms may be manifestations of the disease or they may represent worsening of previously stable and compensated deficits. Three cases of laryngeal changes in PPS with videostroboscopic and laryngeal electromyography findings highlight the features of this disorder. We review possible etiologies of laryngeal PPS, diagnostic criteria, and treatment, as well as the current literature.     

Transoral laryngeal surgeryunder flexible laryngovideostroboscopy

Although direct microlaryngoscopic surgery is universally accepted as the standard procedure for endolaryngeal surgery, general anesthesia and direct laryngoscopy are necessary during the procedure. Suspended laryngeal position also impedes intraoperative functional monitoring. Transoral laryngeal surgery under indirect laryngeal mirror or telescope has the advantage of sparing general anesthesia and direct laryngoscopy, but lower precision, difficult manipulation, and a high patient cooperation requirement make the procedure of limited application. Trying to overcome the above shortcomings, transoral laryngeal surgery under flexible laryngovideostroboscopy (FLVS) is undertaken at our institute. The surgery is performed at an outpatient office under topical anesthesia, with the help of high-resolution fiberoptic stroboscopy, high-quality CCD videocamera, and monitor. From October, 1993 to March, 1996, 157 patients with selected laryngeal problems were operated upon using this technique, and 150 patients smoothly completed the procedure with satisfactory results. The technique is highly effective, especially for limited-manipulation, lower precision procedures and for patients who are not candidates for general anesthesia. With proper patient selection, this is a cost-effective surgery of low invasiveness and high applicability.     

From Voice Clinic to Operating Room: Are We Out of Tune?

Introduction: To determine the consistency and accuracy of preoperative diagnosis in the voice clinic with intraoperative diagnosis and to suggest a standardized laryngeal examination protocol in the UK that is supported by evidence-based findings.Method: From January 2011-September 2014, 164 patients were referred to the Multidisciplinary Team voice clinic and diagnosed with laryngeal pathology that required phonosurgery. The visualization (videostrobolaryngoscopy) in clinic was performed using either rigid laryngoscope or a video-naso-laryngoscope. Intraoperatively, laryngeal visualization and surgical procedure was conducted using Storz Aida HD system, 10-mm rigid laryngoscope 0° or 5-mm rigid laryngoscope 0°/30° and a Zeiss S7 microscope.Results: Of the 164 patients seen in the multidisciplinary voice clinic, 86 clinic diagnoses were confirmed intraoperatively (52.4%), 15 patients had the diagnosis confirmed intraoperatively with additional lesion found (9.1%). The clinic diagnosis changed intraoperatively in 63 cases (38.4%). 61 (37.2%) patients seen in the voice clinic were diagnosed with cyst, in 39.3% the diagnosis was confirmed intraoperatively with 5 cases (8.2%) having an additional diagnosis. Twenty (12.2%) patients were diagnosed with polyps, with 80% confirmation intraoperatively; 3 patients (10%) had an additional diagnosis.Conclusion: Videolaryngostroboscopy imaging of the larynx provides an outpatient tool for accurately diagnosing more than 50% of laryngeal pathologies when interpreted by multidisciplinary voice clinicians. However direct laryngeal examination under general anesthesia remains the gold standard when obtaining accurate diagnoses of laryngeal pathology. Patients diagnosed with nonorganic voice disorders should be considered for direct laryngoscopy under general anesthetic should they fail to respond to conservative management.     

Glottal behavior in the high soprano range and the transition to the whistle register

The high soprano range was investigated by acoustic and electroglottographic measurements of 12 sopranos and high-speed endoscopy of one of these. A single laryngeal transition was observed on glissandi above the primo passaggio. It supports the existence of two distinct laryngeal mechanisms in the high soprano range: M2 and M3, underlying head and whistle registers. The laryngeal transition occurred gradually over several tones within the interval D#5-D6. It occurred over a wider range and was completed at a higher pitch for trained than untrained sopranos. The upper limit of the laryngeal transition during glissandi was accompanied by pitch jumps or instabilities, but, for most singers, it did not coincide with the upper limit of R1:f(0) tuning (i.e., tuning the first resonance to the fundamental frequency). However, pitch jumps could also be associated with changes in resonance tuning. Four singers demonstrated an overlap range over which they could sing with a full head or fluty resonant quality. Glottal behaviors underlying these two qualities were similar to the M2 and M3 mechanisms respectively. Pitch jumps and discontinuous glottal and spectral changes characteristic of a M2-M3 laryngeal transition were observed on decrescendi produced within this overlap range.     

Direct measurement of subglottic pressure and laryngealresistance in normal subjects and in spasmodic dysphonia

This study tested the accuracy of indirect methods of measurementof laryngeal airway resistance in normal subjects and in spasmodic dysphonia (SD). The indirect method assumes that subglottic air pressure remains constant during the voiced segment of a syllable. In this study subglottic air pressure was directly measured via puncture of the cricothyroid membrane in seven normal subjects and seven subjects with SD. The true laryngeal airway resistance was calculated and compared with airway resistance measured using indirect techniques based on intraoral air pressure. In five of the seven normal subjects, subglottic air pressure did not remain constant during the voiced segment. As a result, the error produced using indirect method of calculating average laryngeal resistance for the normal subjects varied from −44% to +50%. For SD subjects the error ranged from −49% to +22%. In general, the indirect technique over-estimated laryngeal airway resistance in normal subjects and underestimated the resistance in subjects with SD.     

Anatomy and cell biology of the laryngeal motor neurons: Implications for the treatment of spasmodic dysphonia

Changes in neuroanatomical pathways in the central nervous system presumably play key roles in the pathogenetic mechanism underlying spasmodic dysphonia. However, practical considerations of accessibility to clinical intervention have focused efforts on treatments based on manipulations of laryngeal motor neurons, the most peripheral extent of these pathways. This review discusses aspects of the anatomy and cell biology of the laryngeal motor neurons, which provide a basis for the understanding of current techniques for the treatment of this disorder. In addition, consideration is given to the significance of unusual morphological characteristics of the laryngeal motor neurons and to cellular processes, which may ultimately offer potential for more selective clinical strategies.