20 years of DNA-encoded chemical libraries

The identification of specific binding molecules is a central problem in chemistry, biology and medicine. Therefore, technologies, which facilitate ligand discovery, may substantially contribute to a better understanding of biological processes and to drug discovery. DNA-encoded chemical libraries represent a new inexpensive tool for the fast and efficient identification of ligands to target proteins of choice. Such libraries consist of collections of organic molecules, covalently linked to a unique DNA tag serving as an amplifiable identification bar code. DNA-encoding enables the in vitro selection of ligands by affinity capture at sub-picomolar concentrations on virtually any target protein of interest, in analogy to established selection methodologies like antibody phage display. Multiple strategies have been investigated by several academic and industrial laboratories for the construction of DNA-encoded chemical libraries comprising up to millions of DNA-encoded compounds. The implementation of next generation high-throughput sequencing enabled the rapid identification of binding molecules from DNA-encoded libraries of unprecedented size. This article reviews the development of DNA-encoded library technology and its evolution into a novel drug discovery tool, commenting on challenges, perspectives and opportunities for the different experimental approaches.     

Discovery of small-molecule interleukin-2 inhibitors from a DNA-encoded chemical library

Libraries of chemical compounds individually coupled to encoding DNA tags (DNA-encoded chemical libraries) hold promise to facilitate exceptionally efficient ligand discovery. We constructed a high-quality DNA-encoded chemical library comprising 30,000 drug-like compounds; this was screened in 170 different affinity capture experiments. High-throughput sequencing allowed the evaluation of 120?million DNA codes for a systematic analysis of selection strategies and statistically robust identification of binding molecules. Selections performed against the tumor-associated antigen carbonic anhydrase?IX (CA?IX) and the pro-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-2 (IL-2) yielded potent inhibitors with exquisite target specificity. The binding mode of the revealed pharmacophore against IL-2 was confirmed by molecular docking. Our findings suggest that DNA-encoded chemical libraries allow the facile identification of drug-like ligands principally to any protein of choice, including molecules capable of disrupting high-affinity protein-protein interactions.     

Translation of DNA into a library of 13,000 synthetic small-molecule macrocycles suitable for in vitro selection

DNA-templated organic synthesis enables the translation, selection, and amplification of DNA sequences encoding synthetic small-molecule libraries. Previously we described the DNA-templated multistep synthesis and model in vitro selection of a pilot library of 65 macrocycles. In this work, we report several key developments that enable the DNA-templated synthesis of much larger (>10,000-membered) small-molecule libraries. We developed and validated a capping-based approach to DNA-templated library synthesis that increases final product yields, simplifies the structure and preparation of reagents, and reduces the number of required manipulations. To expand the size and structural diversity of the macrocycle library, we augmented the number of building blocks in each DNA-templated step from 4 to 12, selected 8 different starting scaffolds which result in 4 macrocycle ring sizes and 2 building-block orientations, and confirmed the ability of the 36 building blocks and 8 scaffolds to generate DNA-templated macrocycle products. We computationally generated and experimentally validated an expanded set of codons sufficient to support 1728 combinations of step 1, step 2, and step 3 building blocks. Finally, we developed new high-resolution LC/MS analysis methods to assess the quality of large DNA-templated small-molecule libraries. Integrating these four developments, we executed the translation of 13,824 DNA templates into their corresponding small-molecule macrocycles. Analysis of the resulting libraries is consistent with excellent (>90%) representation of desired macrocycle products and a stringent test of sequence specificity suggests a high degree of sequence fidelity during translation. The quality and structural diversity of this expanded DNA-templated library provides a rich starting point for the discovery of functional synthetic small-molecule macrocycles.     

Diversified strategy for the synthesis of DNA-encoded oxindole libraries

DNA-encoded library technology (DELT) employs DNA as a barcode to track the sequence of chemical reactions and enables the design and synthesis of libraries with billions of small molecules through combinatorial expansion. This powerful technology platform has been successfully demonstrated for hit identification and target validation for many types of diseases. As a highly integrated technology platform, DEL is capable of accelerating the translation of synthetic chemistry by using on-DNA compatible reactions or off-DNA scaffold synthesis. Herein, we report the development of a series of novel on-DNA transformations based on oxindole scaffolds for the design and synthesis of diversity-oriented DNA-encoded libraries for screening. Specifically, we have developed 1,3-dipolar cyclizations, cyclopropanations, ring-opening of reactions of aziridines and Claisen–Schmidt condensations to construct diverse oxindole derivatives. The majority of these transformations enable a diversity-oriented synthesis of DNA-encoded oxindole libraries which have been used in the successful hit identification for three protein targets. We have demonstrated that a diversified strategy for DEL synthesis could accelerate the application of synthetic chemistry for drug discovery.

Constructing DNA-encoded oxindole libraries by a diversified strategy.     

Second-generation DNA-encoded multiple display on a constant macrocyclic scaffold enabled by an orthogonal protecting group strategy

DNA-encoded chemical library(DEL) represents an emerging drug discovery technology to construct compound libraries with abundant chemical combinations. While drug-like small molecule DELs facilitate the discovery of binders against targets with defined pockets, macrocyclic DELs harboring extended scaffolds enable targeting of the protein–protein interaction(PPI) interface. We previously demonstrated the design of the first-generation DNA-encoded multiple display based on a constant macrocyclic s...     

Solution-phase combinatorial libraries: modulating cellular signaling by targeting protein-protein or protein-DNA interactions

The high-throughput synthesis and screening of compound libraries hold tremendous promise for drug discovery and powerful methods for both solid-phase and solution-phase library preparation have been introduced. The question of which approach (solution-phase versus solid-phase) is best for the preparation of chemical libraries has been replaced by which approach is most appropriate for a particular target or screen. Herein we highlight distinctions in the two approaches that might serve as useful considerations at the onset of new programs. This is followed by a more personal account of our own focus on solution-phase techniques for the preparation of libraries designed to modulate cellular signaling by targeting protein-protein or protein-DNA interactions. The screening of our libraries against a prototypical set of extracellular and intracellular targets, using a wide range of assay formats, provided the first small-molecule modulators of the protein-protein interactions studied, and a generalized approach for conducting such studies.     

Library design practices for success in lead generation with small molecule libraries

The generation of novel structures amenable to rapid and efficient lead optimization comprises an emerging strategy for success in modern drug discovery. Small molecule libraries of sufficient size and diversity to increase the chances of discovery of novel structures make the high throughput synthesis approach the method of choice for lead generation. Despite an industry trend for smaller, more focused libraries, the need to generate novel lead structures makes larger libraries a necessary strategy. For libraries of a several thousand or more members, solid phase synthesis approaches are the most suitable. While the technology and chemistry necessary for small molecule library synthesis continue to advance, success in lead generation requires rigorous consideration in the library design process to ensure the synthesis of molecules possessing the proper characteristics for subsequent lead optimization. Without proper selection of library templates and building blocks, solid phase synthesis methods often generate molecules which are too heavy, too lipophilic and too complex to be useful for lead optimization. The appropriate filtering of virtual library designs with multiple computational tools allows the generation of information-rich libraries within a drug-like molecular property space. An understanding of the hit-to-lead process provides a practical guide to molecular design characteristics. Examples of leads generated from library approaches also provide a benchmarking of successes as well as aspects for continued development of library design practices.     

In-solution direct oxidative coupling for the integration of sulfur/selenium into DNA-encoded chemical libraries

Sulfur/selenium-containing electron-rich arenes (ERAs) exist in a wide range of both approved and investigational drugs with diverse pharmacological activities. These unique chemical structures and bioactive properties, if combined with the emerging DNA-encoded chemical library (DEL) technique, would facilitate drug and chemical probe discovery. However, it remains challenging, as there is no general DNA-compatible synthetic methodology available for the formation of C–S and C–Se bonds in aqueous solution. Herein, an in-solution direct oxidative coupling procedure that could efficiently integrate sulfur/selenium into the ERA under mild conditions is presented. This method features simple DNA-conjugated electron-rich arenes with a broad substrate scope and a transition-metal free process. Furthermore, this synthetic methodology, examined by a scale-up reaction test and late-stage precise modification in a mock peptide-like DEL synthesis, will enable its utility for the synthesis of sulfur/selenium-containing DNA-encoded libraries and the discovery of bioactive agents.

DNA-compatible direct oxidative coupling using various sulfur/selenium sources has been achieved, featuring pre-functionalization-free substrates and transition metal-free condition.     

Improved Diazo-Transfer Reaction for DNA-Encoded Chemistry and Its Potential Application for Macrocyclic DEL-Libraries

DNA-encoded libraries (DEL) are increasingly being used to identify new starting points for medicinal chemistry in drug discovery. Herein, we discuss the development of methods that allow the conversion of both primary amines and anilines, attached to DNA, to their corresponding azides in excellent yields. The scope of these diazo-transfer reactions was investigated, and a proof-of-concept has been devised to allow for the synthesis of macrocycles on DNA.     

DNA-templated organic synthesis: nature's strategy for controlling chemical reactivity applied to synthetic molecules

In contrast to the approach commonly taken by chemists, nature controls chemical reactivity by modulating the effective molarity of highly dilute reactants through macromolecule-templated synthesis. Nature's approach enables complex mixtures in a single solution to react with efficiencies and selectivities that cannot be achieved in conventional laboratory synthesis. DNA-templated organic synthesis (DTS) is emerging as a surprisingly general way to control the reactivity of synthetic molecules by using nature's effective-molarity-based approach. Recent developments have expanded the scope and capabilities of DTS from its origins as a model of prebiotic nucleic acid replication to its current ability to translate DNA sequences into complex small-molecule and polymer products of multistep organic synthesis. An understanding of fundamental principles underlying DTS has played an important role in these developments. Early applications of DTS include nucleic acid sensing, small-molecule discovery, and reaction discovery with the help of translation, selection, and amplification methods previously available only to biological molecules.     

Affinity Selections of DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries on Carbonic Anhydrase IX-Expressing Tumor Cells Reveal a Dependence on Ligand Valence

DNA-encoded chemical libraries are typically screened against purified protein targets. Recently, cell-based selections with encoded chemical libraries have been described, commonly revealing suboptimal performance due to insufficient recovery of binding molecules. We used carbonic anhydrase IX (CAIX)-expressing tumor cells as a model system to optimize selection procedures with code-specific quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) as selection readout. Salt concentration and performing PCR on cell suspension had the biggest impact on selection performance, leading to 15-fold enrichment factors for high-affinity monovalent CAIX binders (acetazolamide; K_D=8.7 nM). Surprisingly, the homobivalent display of acetazolamide at the extremities of both complementary DNA strands led to a substantial improvement of both ligand recovery and enrichment factors (above 100-fold). The optimized procedures were used for selections with a DNA-encoded chemical library comprising 1 million members against tumor cell lines expressing CAIX, leading to a preferential recovery of known and new ligands against this validated tumor-associated target. This work may facilitate future affinity selections on cells against target proteins which might be difficult to express otherwise.     

Effects of template sequence and secondary structure on DNA-templated reactivity

DNA-templated organic synthesis enables the translation, selection, and amplification of DNA sequences encoding synthetic small-molecule libraries. As the size of DNA-templated libraries increases, the possibility of forming intramolecularly base-paired structures within templates that impede templated reactions increases as well. To achieve uniform reactivity across many template sequences and to computationally predict and remove any problematic sequences from DNA-templated libraries, we have systematically examined the effects of template sequence and secondary structure on DNA-templated reactivity. By testing a series of template sequences computationally designed to contain different degrees of internal secondary structure, we observed that high levels of predicted secondary structure involving the reagent binding site within a DNA template interfere with reagent hybridization and impair reactivity, as expected. Unexpectedly, we also discovered that templates containing virtually no predicted internal secondary structure also exhibit poor reaction efficiencies. Further studies revealed that a modest degree of internal secondary structure is required to maximize effective molarities between reactants, possibly by compacting intervening template nucleotides that separate the hybridized reactants. Therefore, ideal sequences for DNA-templated synthesis lie between two undesirable extremes of too much or too little internal secondary structure. The relationship between effective molarity and intervening nucleic acid secondary structure described in this work may also apply to nucleic acid sequences in living systems that separate interacting biological molecules.     

DNA‐Encoded Dynamic Combinatorial Chemical Libraries

Dynamic combinatorial chemistry (DCC) explores the thermodynamic equilibrium of reversible reactions. Its application in the discovery of protein binders is largely limited by difficulties in the analysis of complex reaction mixtures. DNA‐encoded chemical library (DECL) technology allows the selection of binders from a mixture of up to billions of different compounds; however, experimental results often show low a signal‐to‐noise ratio and poor correlation between enrichment factor and binding affinity. Herein we describe the design and application of DNA‐encoded dynamic combinatorial chemical libraries (EDCCLs). Our experiments have shown that the EDCCL approach can be used not only to convert monovalent binders into high‐affinity bivalent binders, but also to cause remarkably enhanced enrichment of potent bivalent binders by driving their in situ synthesis. We also demonstrate the application of EDCCLs in DNA‐templated chemical reactions.     

Selection of DNA-Encoded Dynamic Chemical Libraries for Direct Inhibitor Discovery

Dynamic combinatorial libraries (DCLs) is a powerful tool for ligand discovery in biomedical research; however, the application of DCLs has been hampered by their low diversity. Recently, the concept of DNA encoding has been employed in DCLs to create DNA-encoded dynamic libraries (DEDLs); however, all current DEDLs are limited to fragment identification, and a challenging process of fragment linking is required after selection. We report an anchor-directed DEDL approach that can identify full ligand structures from large-scale DEDLs. This method is also able to convert unbiased libraries into focused ones targeting specific protein classes. We demonstrated this method by selecting DEDLs against five proteins, and novel inhibitors were identified for all targets. Notably, several selective BD1/BD2 inhibitors were identified from the selections against bromodomain 4 (BRD4), an important anti-cancer drug target. This work may provide a broadly applicable method for inhibitor discovery.     

Discovery of Small‐Molecule Interleukin‐2 Inhibitors from a DNA‐Encoded Chemical Library

Libraries of chemical compounds individually coupled to encoding DNA tags (DNA‐encoded chemical libraries) hold promise to facilitate exceptionally efficient ligand discovery. We constructed a high‐quality DNA‐encoded chemical library comprising 30 000 drug‐like compounds; this was screened in 170 different affinity capture experiments. High‐throughput sequencing allowed the evaluation of 120 million DNA codes for a systematic analysis of selection strategies and statistically robust identification of binding molecules. Selections performed against the tumor‐associated antigen carbonic anhydrase IX (CA IX) and the pro‐inflammatory cytokine interleukin‐2 (IL‐2) yielded potent inhibitors with exquisite target specificity. The binding mode of the revealed pharmacophore against IL‐2 was confirmed by molecular docking. Our findings suggest that DNA‐encoded chemical libraries allow the facile identification of drug‐like ligands principally to any protein of choice, including molecules capable of disrupting high‐affinity protein–protein interactions.     

Recent developments in protein–ligand affinity mass spectrometry

This review provides an overview of direct and indirect technologies to screen protein–ligand interactions with mass spectrometry. These technologies have as a key feature the selection or affinity purification of ligands in mixtures prior to detection. Specific fields of interest for these technologies are metabolic profiling of bioactive metabolites, natural extract screening, and the screening of libraries for bioactives, such as parallel synthesis libraries and small combichem libraries. The review addresses the principles of each of the methods discussed, with a focus on developments in recent years, and the applicability of the methods to lead generation and development in drug discovery.     

The combined solid/solution-phase synthesis of nitrosamines: the evolution of the "libraries from libraries" concept

The generation of diverse chemical libraries using the "libraries from libraries" concept by combining solid-phase and solution-phase methods is described. The central features of the approaches presented are the use of solid-phase synthesis methods for the generation of a combinatorial polyamine library. Following cleavage from the resin with HF, the polyamine library was reacted with ethyl nitrite in the solution phase to yield the desired nitrosamine library in good yield and purity. The approaches described enable the efficient syntheses of individual nitrosamines as well as mixture-based nitrosamine libraries.     

Design,preparation, and selection of DNA-encoded dynamic libraries

We report a method for the preparation and selection of DNA-encoded dynamic libraries (DEDLs). The library is composed of two sets of DNA-linked small molecules that are under dynamic exchange through DNA hybridization. Addition of the protein target shifted the equilibrium, favouring the assembly of high affinity bivalent binders. Notably, we introduced a novel locking mechanism to stop the dynamic exchange and “freeze” the equilibrium, thereby enabling downstream hit isolation and decoding by PCR amplification and DNA sequencing. Our DEDL approach has circumvented the limitation of library size and realized the analysis and selection of large dynamic libraries. In addition, this method also eliminates the requirement for modified and immobilized target proteins.     

Synthesis and Analysis of Natural-Product-Like Macrocycles by Tandem Oxidation/Oxa-Conjugate Addition Reactions

As traditional small-molecule drug discovery programs focus on a relatively narrow range of chemical space, most human proteins are viewed as unreachable targets. Consequently, there is a strong interest in expanding the chemical space in drug discovery beyond traditional small molecules. Here, a strategy for the preparation of a broad natural-product-like macrocyclic library by using the tandem allylic oxidation/oxa-conjugate addition and macrocyclization reactions is reported. Cheminformatic analyses demonstrate that this tetrahydropyran-containing macrocyclic library shows a significant overlap with natural products in the chemical space. This approach can be used for designing libraries that may probe more deeply into natural-product-like space.     

The Potential of Micellar Media in the Synthesis of DNA-Encoded Libraries

DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology has become widely used in drug discovery research. The construction of DELs requires robust organic transformations that proceed in aqueous media under mild conditions. Unfortunately, the application of water as reaction medium for organic synthesis is not evident due to the generally limited solubility of organic reagents. However, the use of surfactants can offer a solution to this issue. Oil-in-water microemulsions formed by surfactant micelles are able to localize hydrophobic reagents inside them, resulting in high local concentrations of the organic substances in an otherwise poorly solvated environment. This review provides a conceptual and critical summary of micellar synthesis possibilities that are well suited to DEL synthesis. Existing examples of micellar DEL approaches, together with a selection of micellar organic transformations fundamentally suitable for DEL are discussed.