A review of the zone broadening contributions in free-flow electrophoresis

The broadening of analyte streams, as they migrate through a free-flow electrophoresis (FFE) channel, often limits the resolving power of FFE separations. Under laminar flow conditions, such zonal spreading occurs due to analyte diffusion perpendicular to the direction of streamflow and variations in the lateral distance electrokinetically migrated by the analyte molecules. Although some of the factors that give rise to these contributions are inherent to the FFE method, others originate from non-idealities in the system, such as Joule heating, pressure-driven crossflows, and a difference between the electrical conductivities of the sample stream and background electrolyte. The injection process can further increase the stream width in FFE separations but normally influencing all analyte zones to an equal extent. Recently, several experimental and theoretical works have been reported that thoroughly investigate the various contributions to stream variance in an FFE device for better understanding, and potentially minimizing their magnitudes. In this review article, we carefully examine the findings from these studies and discuss areas in which more work is needed to advance our comprehension of the zone broadening contributions in FFE assays.     

Reduced surface adsorption in 3D printed acrylonitrile butadiene styrene micro free-flow electrophoresis devices

We have 3D printed and fabricated micro free-flow electrophoresis (µFFE) devices in acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) that exhibit minimal surface adsorption without requiring additional surface coatings or specialized buffer additives. 2D, nano LC–micro free flow electrophoresis (2D nLC × µFFE) separations were used to assess both spatial and temporal broadening as peaks eluted through the separation channel. Minimal broadening due to wall adsorption was observed in either the spatial or temporal dimensions during separations of rhodamine 110, rhodamine 123, and fluorescein. Surface adsorption was observed in separations of Chromeo P503 labeled myoglobin and cytochrome c but was significantly reduced compared to previously reported glass devices. Peak widths of < 30 s were observed for both proteins. For comparison, Chromeo P503 labeled myoglobin and cytochrome c adsorb strongly to the surface of glass µFFE devices resulting in peak widths >20 min. A 2D nLC × µFFE separation of a Chromeo P503 labeled tryptic digest of BSA was performed to demonstrate the high peak capacity possible due to the low surface adsorption in the 3D printed ABS devices, even in the absence of surface coatings or buffer additives.     

Miniaturizing free-flow electrophoresis - a critical review

Free-flow electrophoresis (FFE) separation methods have been developed and investigated for around 50 years and have been applied not only to many types of analytes for various biomedical applications, but also for the separation of inorganic and organic substances. Its continuous sample preparation and mild separation conditions make it also interesting for online monitoring and detection applications. Since 1994 several microfluidic, miniaturized FFE devices were developed and experimentally characterized. In contrast to their large-scale counterparts microfluidic FFE (mu-FFE) devices offer new possibilities due to the very rapid separations within several seconds or below and the requirement for sample volumes in the microliter range. Eventually, these mu-FFE systems might find application in so-called lab-on-a-chip devices for real-time monitoring and separation applications. This review gives detailed information on the results so far published on mu-FFE chips, comprising its four main modes, namely free-flow zone electrophoresis (FFZE), free-flow IEF (FFIEF), free-flow ITP (FFITP), and free-flow field-step electrophoresis (FFFSE). The principles of the different FFE modes and the basic underlying theory are given and discussed with special emphasis on miniaturization. Different designs as well as fabrication methods and applied materials are discussed and evaluated. Furthermore, the separation results shown indicate that similar separation quality with respect to conventional FFE systems, as defined by the resolution and peak capacity, can be achieved with mu-FFE separations when applying much lower electrical voltages. Furthermore, innovations still occur and several approaches for hyphenated, more integrated systems have been proposed so far, some of which are discussed here. This review is intended as an introduction and early compendium for research and development within this field.     

Mid-scale free-flow electrophoresis with gravity-induced uniform flow of background buffer in chamber for the separation of cells and proteins

A large-scale free-flow electrophoresis (LS-FFE) is often too large for cell separation of lab scale, whereas micro-FFE (μFFE) has great difficulty in cell isolation due to easy blockage by cell accumulation in μFFE. In this study, a mid-scale FFE (MS-FFE) is developed for cell and protein separations. The volume of the separation chamber (70×40×0.1-0.8 mm) is from 280 μL to 2.24 mL, much lower than that in an LS-FFE but higher than that in a μFFE. Gravity is used for uniform flow of the background buffer only via a single pump with 16 channels and the sample is injected via an adjuster originally used for clinical intravenous injection. The experiments reveal that the hydrodynamic and electrohydrodynamic flows are much stable, and the Joule heat can be effectively dispersed without obvious positive or negative deviation as shown by the omega plots. By the device, Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus, which easily accumulate to block μFFE and are separated with difficulty due to their same negative charges carried, can be well isolated under the conditions of 4.5 mM pH 8.5 Tris-boric buffer (4.5 mM Tris, 4.5 mM boric acid) with 0.10 mM ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid and 5% m/v sucrose, 200 μL/min, 800 V, and sample injection via inlet 4. The mid-scale FFE device could also be used for the separation of three model proteins of horse heart cytochrome c, myoglobin and bovine serum albumin. The device has clear significance for mid-scale separation of cells and proteins.     

A free-flow electrophoresis chip device for interfacing capillary isoelectric focusing on-line with electrospray mass spectrometry

When electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) is used on-line with capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF), the presence of the carrier ampholytes creating the IEF pH gradient is not desirable. With the purpose of removing these ampholytes, we have developed a free-flow electrophoresis (FFE) device and coupled it to CIEF. The different parameters inherent to the resulting CIEF/FFE system were optimised using ultraviolet absorbance (UV) detection. The on-line coupling of this system with ESI-MS was successfully realised for three model proteins (myoglobin, carbonic anhydrase I and beta-lactoglobulin B).     

Unsteady transport phenomena in free-flow electrophoresis--prerequisite of ultrafast sample cleaning in microfluidic devices

The evolution partial differential equations describing the transport processes induced by hydrodynamic flow in free-flow electrophoresis (FFE) are solved by the generalized dispersion theory. Our theoretical analysis demonstrates that the central injection of solutes into a relatively fast hydrodynamic flow enables to transport them to the channel outlet well before they are spread through the width of the channel and their migration is negatively affected by a contact with walls. In this case, the axial zone spreading decreases by increasing the linear velocity of hydrodynamic flow. The resulting dependencies of convective and dispersion coefficients on the velocity of flow and parameters of the separation channel show the optimum separation conditions with respect to resolution and analysis time. Due to the unsteady character of transport processes, effective FFE separations can potentially be performed in a microfluidic device in seconds. This is a reasonable time to separate low-molecular mass impurities in the electric field. Thus, a fast and efficient sample cleaning before subsequent analysis by electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) or another separation method can be performed.     

Investigating peak dispersion in free-flow counterflow gradient focusing

Free-flow electrophoresis (FFE) enables the continuous separation and collection of charged solutes, and as a result, it has drawn interest as both a preparative and an analytical tool for biological applications. Recently, a free-flow counterflow gradient focusing (FF-CGF) mechanism has been proposed with the goal of improving the resolution and versatility of FFE. To realize this potential, the factors that influence solute dispersion deserve further attention, including the gradient strength and the parabolic profile of the counterflow. Therefore, the goal of this work is to develop a theoretical model to study the interplay between these factors and molecular diffusion. Overall, an asymmetric solute distribution emerges for a wide range of parameters, and this behavior can be characterized with an exponentially modified Gaussian function. Results show that FF-CGF can achieve high-resolution separations, with the potential for high-throughput protein purification. Moreover, this work provides a practical guide for optimizing experimental conditions, as well as a strong framework for understanding and developing FF-CGF further.     

Up-scaling capillary zone electrophoresis separations of polydisperse anionic polyelectrolytes with preparative free-flow electrophoresis exemplified with a soil fulvic acid

A scale-up of analytical capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) to preparative free-flow electrophoresis (FFE) is described. FFE allows fractionations based on charge densities in larger amounts than in CZE, enabling further off-line analysis of the fractions. Model compounds (carboxylic acids and polystyrene sulfonates) showed a similar behavior in FFE as in CZE. Diffusion and electrodynamic distortion effects are more pronounced in FFE than in CZE. A soil fulvic acid was analyzed by CZE and fractionated by FFE. A comparison of the FFE fractions with CZE measurements of the same sample using the effective mobility scale showed good agreement of the two methods.     

Micro free-flow electrophoresis: theory and applications

Free-flow electrophoresis (FFE) is a technique that performs an electrophoretic separation on a continuous stream of analyte as it flows through a planar flow channel. The electric field is applied perpendicularly to the flow to deflect analytes laterally according to their mobility as they flow through the separation channel. Miniaturization of FFE (μFFE) over the past 15 years has allowed analytical and preparative separation of small volume samples. Advances in chip design have improved separations by reducing interference from bubbles generated by electrolysis. Mechanisms of band broadening have been examined theoretically and experimentally to improve resolution in μFFE. Separations using various modes such as zone electrophoresis, isoelectric focusing, isotachophoresis, and field-step electrophoresis have been demonstrated.

Miniaturized free-flow electrophoresis: production,optimization, and application using 3D printing technology

The increasing resolution of three-dimensional (3D) printing offers simplified access to, and development of, microfluidic devices with complex 3D structures. Therefore, this technology is increasingly used for rapid prototyping in laboratories and industry. Microfluidic free flow electrophoresis (μFFE) is a versatile tool to separate and concentrate different samples (such as DNA, proteins, and cells) to different outlets in a time range measured in mere tens of seconds and offers great potential for use in downstream processing, for example. However, the production of μFFE devices is usually rather elaborate. Many designs are based on chemical pretreatment or manual alignment for the setup. Especially for the separation chamber of a μFFE device, this is a crucial step which should be automatized. We have developed a smart 3D design of a μFFE to pave the way for a simpler production. This study presents (1) a robust and reproducible way to build up critical parts of a μFFE device based on high-resolution MultiJet 3D printing; (2) a simplified insertion of commercial polycarbonate membranes to segregate separation and electrode chambers; and (3) integrated, 3D-printed wells that enable a defined sample fractionation (chip-to-world interface). In proof of concept experiments both a mixture of fluorescence dyes and a mixture of amino acids were successfully separated in our 3D-printed μFFE device.     

A simple preparative free‐flow electrophoresis joined with gratis gravity: I. Gas cushion injector and self‐balance collector instead of multiple channel pump

This paper describes a novel free‐flow electrophoresis (FFE), which is joined with gratis gravity, gas cushion injector (GCI) and self‐balance collector instead of multiple channel pump, for the purpose of preparative purification. The FFE was evaluated by systemic experiments. The results manifest that (i) even though one‐channel peristaltic pump is used for the driving of background buffer, there is still stable flow in the FFE chamber; (ii) the stable flow is induced by the gravity‐induced pressure due to the difference of buffer surfaces in the GCI and self‐balance collector; (iii) the pulse flow of background buffer induced by the peristaltic pump is greatly reduced by the GCI with good compressibility of included air; (iv) the FFE can be well used for zone electrophoretic separation of amino acids; (v) up to 20 inlets simultaneous sample injection and up to five to tenfold condensation of amino acid can be achieved by combining the FFE device with the method of moving reaction boundary. To the best of authors' knowledge, FFE has not been used for such separation and condensation of amino acids. The relevant results achieved in the paper have evident significance for the development of preparative FFE.     

Isolation of DNA aptamers using micro free flow electrophoresis

A micro free flow electrophoresis (μFFE) device was used to select DNA aptamers for human immunoglobulin E (IgE). The continuous nature of μFFE allowed 1.8 × 10(14) sequences to be introduced over a period of 30 min, a 300-fold improvement in library size over capillary electrophoresis based selections (CE-SELEX). Four rounds of selection were performed within four days. Aptamers with low nM dissociation constants for IgE were identified after a single round of μFFE selection.     

Negative‐pressure‐induced collector for a self‐balance free‐flow electrophoresis device

Uneven flow in free‐flow electrophoresis (FFE) with a gravity‐induced fraction collector caused by air bubbles in outlets and/or imbalance of the surface tension of collecting tubes would result in a poor separation. To solve these issues, this work describes a novel collector for FFE. The collector is composed of a self‐balance unit, multisoft pipe flow controller, fraction collector, and vacuum pump. A negative pressure induced continuous air flow rapidly flowed through the self‐balance unit, taking the background electrolyte and samples into the fraction collector. The developed collector has the following advantages: (i) supplying a stable and harmonious hydrodynamic environment in the separation chamber for FFE separation, (ii) effectively preventing background electrolyte and sample flow‐back at the outlet of the chamber and improving the resolution, (iii) increasing the preparative scale of the separation, and (iv) simplifying the operation. In addition, the cost of the FFE device was reduced without using a multichannel peristaltic pump for sample collection. Finally, comparative FFE experiments on dyes, proteins, and cells were carried out. It is evident that the new developed collector could overcome the problems inherent in the previous gravity‐induced self‐balance collector.     

A simple chip free‐flow electrophoresis for monosaccharide sensing via supermolecule interaction of boronic acid functionalized quencher and fluorescent dye

Here, a simple micro free‐flow electrophoresis (μFFE) was developed for fluorescence sensing of monosaccharide via supermolecule interaction of synthesized boronic acid functionalized benzyl viologen (ο‐BBV) and fluorescent dye. The μFFE contained two open electrode cavities and an ion‐exchange membrane was sandwiched between two polymethylmethacrylate plates. The experiments demonstrated the following merits of developed μFFE: (i) up to 90.5% of voltage efficiency due to high conductivity of ion‐exchange membrane; (ii) a strong ability against influence of bubble produced in two electrodes due to open design of electrode cavities; and (iii) reusable and washable separation chamber (45 mm × 17 mm × 100 μm, 77 μL) avoiding the discard of μFFE due to blockage of solute precipitation in chamber. Remarkably, the μFFE was first designed for the sensing of monosaccharide via the supermolecule interaction of synthesized ο‐BBV, fluorescent dye, and monosaccharide. Under the optimized conditions, the minimum concentration of monosaccharide that could be detected was 1 × 10^?11 M. Finally, the developed device was used for the detection of 0.3 mM glucose spiked in human urine. All of the results demonstrated the feasibility of monosaccharide detection via the μFFE.     

Capillary electrophoresis of hemoglobins and globin chains.

Capillary isoelectric focusing (cIEF) and free zone capillary electrophoresis were evaluated for separation of native hemoglobins and globin chains. High-resolution separations of adult human hemoglobin A, fetal human hemoglobin F, and hemoglobin variants S and C were obtained using cIEF with cathodic mobilization. Absorbance detection in the UV and visible regions were compared, and on-line fast UV or visible-wavelength scanning detection was used to obtain spectral information on separated components. Globin chain analysis was performed on the same hemoglobin species by free zone capillary electrophoresis following precipitation of the protein with acidic acetone. Free zone separations were carried out at low pH in the presence of 7 M urea.     

Absorbance detector based on a deep UV light emitting diode for narrow‐column HPLC

A detector for miniaturized HPLC based on deep UV emitting diodes and UV photodiodes was constructed. The measurement is accomplished by the transverse passage of the radiation from the light‐emitting diode (LED) through fused‐silica tubing with an internal diameter of 250 μm. The optical cell allows flexible alignment of the LED, tubing, and photodiode for optimization of the light throughput and has an aperture to block stray light. A beam splitter was employed to direct part of the emitted light to a reference photodiode and the Lambert–Beer law was emulated with a log‐ratio amplifier circuitry. The detector was tested with two LEDs with emission bands at 280 and 255 nm and showed noise levels as low as 0.25 and 0.22 mAU, respectively. The photometric device was employed successfully in separations using a column of 1 mm inner diameter in isocratic as well as gradient elution. Good linearities over three orders of magnitude in concentration were achieved, and the precision of the measurements was better than 1% in all cases. Detection down to the low micromolar range was possible.     

High resolution capillary electrophoresis of carbon nanotubes

Purification of single-walled carbon nanotubes by capillary electrophoresis (CE) is demonstrated. Real-time Raman spectroscopy of the separation process and single-wavelength UV/vis detection show the ability of CE to provide high-resolution separations of nanotube fractions with baseline separation. AFM images of collected fractions demonstrate that separations are based on tube length. The separation method is suggested to be based on alignment of the nanotubes along the separation field.     

Indirect laser-induced fluorescence detection of explosive compounds using capillary electrochromatography and micellar electrokinetic chromatography

Mixtures of nitroaromatic and nitramine explosive compounds and their degradation products were analyzed using electrokinetically driven separations with both indirect laser-induced fluorescence (IDLIF) and UV absorption detection. Complete separations of the 14-component mixture (EPA 8330) were achieved using both capillary electrochromatography (CEC) and micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC). IDLIF detection was performed using an epifluorescence system with excitation provided by a 635 nm diode laser and micromolar concentrations of the dye Cy-5 as the visualizing agent. While the sensitivity of the two detection methods was similar for the nitroaromatic compounds, the nitramines could only be detected using UV absorption due to their low fluorescence quenching efficiency of Cy-5. The detection sensitivity using IDLIF was limited by low frequency oscillations in the fluorescence background. The oscillations increased with higher electric field strength and were attributed to thermal fluctuations caused by Joule heating. Due to the more conductive running buffer and higher separation currents used in MEKC, sensitive IDLIF detection could only be achieved using low (approximately 100 V/cm) field strengths, resulting in long analysis times. CEC separations, which are typically run with low conductivity mobile phases to avoid bubble formation, are less sensitive to this effect. In CEC separations with IDLIF detection a stable fluorescence background using Cy-5 could be established using only a nonporous stationary phase. In capillaries packed with porous silica particles, anomalous migration behavior was observed with charged dye molecules and a stable fluorescence background could not be established under electrokinetic flow. This is the first demonstration of IDLIF in packed channel CEC.     

Migration behavior and separation of active components in Glycyrrhiza uralensis Fisch and its commercial extract by micellar electrokinetic capillary chromatography

1-Anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid (1,8-ANS), 4,4'-dianilino-1,1'-binaphthyl-5,5'-disulfonic acid (bis-ANS) and 2-(p-toluidino)naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid (2,6-TNS) were evaluated as additives in different buffers for the detection of bovine whey proteins using laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) monitoring in capillary electrophoresis (CE). These N-arylaminonaphthalene sulfonates furnish a large fluorescence emission when associated to some proteins whereas their emission in aqueous buffers, such as those used in CE separations, is very small. To select the best detection conditions, the fluorescence of these probes was first compared using experiments carried out in a fluorescence spectrophotometer. Using bovine serum albumin (BSA) as a model protein, it was demonstrated that 2-(N-cyclohexylamino)ethanesulfonic acid (CHES) buffer (pH 8 and pH 10.2) and the fluorescent probe 2,6-TNS gave rise to the highest increase in fluorescence for BSA. When the composition of these separation buffers was optimized for the electrophoretic separations, CHES buffer, pH 10.2 was chosen as the most suitable buffer to detect bovine whey proteins. The limit of detection obtained for some whey proteins in CE separations was about 6.10(-8) M for BSA, 3.10(-7) M for beta-lactoglobulin A (beta-LGA), 3.10(-7) M for beta-lactoglobulin B (beta-LGB), and 3.10(-6) M for alpha-lactalbumin (alpha-LA). These detection limits were compared to those achieved using UV detection under the same separation conditions. The results showed that the detection limits of BSA, beta-LGA and beta-LGB were twice as good using LIF than with UV detection. However, the limit of detection for alpha-LA was better when UV was used. The applicability of LIF detection to CE separation of whey proteins in bovine milk samples was also demonstrated.     

Generation of a miniaturized free-flow electrophoresis chip based on a multi-lamination technique—isoelectric focusing of proteins and a single-stranded DNA fragment

Free-flow electrophoresis techniques have been applied for separations in various areas of chemistry and biochemistry. Here we focus on the generation of a free-flow electrophoresis chip and direct monitoring of the separation of different molecules in the separation bed of the miniaturized chip. We demonstrate a fast and efficient way to generate a low-cost micro-free-flow electrophoresis (μFFE) chip with a filling capacity of 9.5 μL based on a multi-lamination technique. Separating webs realized by two transfer-adhesive tapes avoid the problem of gas bubbles entering the separation area. The chip is characterized by isoelectric focusing markers (IEF markers). The functionality of the chip is demonstrated by free-flow isoelectric focusing (FFIEF) of the proteins BSA (bovine serum albumin) and avidin and a single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) fragment in the pH range 3 to 10. The separation voltage ranges between 167 V cm⁻¹ and 422 V cm⁻¹, depending on the application.