Performance limits of monolithic and packed capillary columns in high-performance liquid chromatography and capillary electrochromatography

A method is proposed for the comprehensive characterization and comparison of columns in the high-performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC) and capillary electrochromatographic (CEC) modes. Using this approach, column parameters such as the number of plates, the eddy-diffusion and mass-transfer contributions to peak broadening, the permeability, and the analysis time are incorporated in a single graph and a comparison in terms of efficiency and speed is obtained. The chromatographic performance of silica-based and polymer-based monolithic capillary columns is discussed and a comparison is made with the performance of packed columns. Also, the potential of ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography is discussed in this context. In the HPLC mode, the best results were obtained with silica monoliths; in the CEC mode, the low-density methacrylate-ester-based monoliths showed the best performance.     

Advances in capillary electrochromatography and micro-high performance liquid chromatography monolithic columns for separation science

Over the last decade, monoliths or continuous beds have emerged as an alternative to traditional packed-bed columns for use in capillary electrochromatography (CEC) and micro-high performance liquid chromatography (micro-HPLC). Monolithic columns can be divided into two categories: silica-based monolithic columns and rigid organic polymer-based monolithic columns resulting from the polymerization of acrylamide, styrene, acrylate or methacrylate monomers. In this paper, the chemistry and most recent applications of these various types of monoliths in both CEC and micro-HPLC are presented.     

Photopolymerized monolithic capillary columns for rapid micro high-performance liquid chromatographic separation of proteins

The preparation of monolithic poly(butyl methacrylate-co-ethylene dimethacrylate) capillary columns using photoinitiated in situ polymerization within 200 microm i.d. capillaries and their application for microHPLC separations of proteins have been studied. The low resistance to flow characteristic of monolithic columns, enabled the use of very high flow rates of up to 100 microL/min representing a flow velocity of 87 mm/s. Very good separations of a model protein mixture consisting of ribonuclease A, cytochrome c, myoglobin, and ovalbumin was achieved in less than 40 s using a very simple single step gradient of the mobile phase. Interestingly, no effect of the pore size on the separations of proteins was observed for these monolithic columns within the size range of 0.66-2.2 microm. The monolithic microHPLC columns are found very robust and no changes in the long term separation performance and back pressure were observed.     

Polymethacrylate monolithic columns for capillary liquid chromatography

In recent years, continuous separation media have attracted considerable attention because of the advantages they offer over packed columns. This research resulted in two useful monolithic material types, the first based on modified silica gel and the second on organic polymers. This work attempts to review advances in the development, characterization, and applications of monolithic columns based on synthetic polymers in capillary chromatography, with the main focus on monolithic beds prepared from methacrylate-ester based monomers. The polymerization conditions used in the production of polymethacrylate monolithic capillary columns are surveyed, with attention being paid to the concentrations of monomers, porogen solvents, and polymerization initiators as the system variables used to control the porous and hydrodynamic properties of the monolithic media. The simplicity of their preparation as well as the possibilities of controlling of their porous properties and surface chemistries are the main benefits of the polymer monolithic capillary columns in comparison to capillary columns packed with particulate materials. The application areas considered in this review concern mainly separations in reversed-phase chromatography, ion-exchange chromatography, hydrophobic and hydrophilic interaction modes; enzyme immobilization and sample preparation in the capillary chromatography format are also addressed.     

Divinylbenzene-based monolithic capillary columns in capillary liquid chromatography

The effect of the conditions of synthesis of divinylbenzene-based monolithic capillary columns on their chromatographic characteristics was studied. It was demonstrated that the porosity and permeability of the column change significantly even at small deviations from the optimum conditions of polymerization of the monolith in the column. By contrast, the minimum value of HETP proved to be only slightly sensitive to the conditions of synthesis, ranging within ～10–20 μm. The conditions of polymerization of the monolith were found to produce more pronounced effect on the slope of the right branch of the van Deemter curve (parameter C), with the flattest curve being observed for columns prepared under optimum conditions. The minimum value of HETP for polymer monolithic capillary columns was found to be similar to that for silica gel monolithic capillary columns, but the latter are characterized by C values approximately an order of magnitude lower.     

Comparison of the chromatographic behavior of monolithic capillary columns in capillary electrochromatography and nano-high-performance liquid chromatography

Porous monoliths based on N,N-dimethylacrylamide (DMAA) or methacrylamide (MAA) were prepared inside fused silica capillaries as stationary phases for nano-chromatography. The columns were characterized in terms of flow rate and backpressure and showed, e.g. differences as a function of the salt concentration added to the polymerization mixture. When the columns were investigated for the separation of uncharged (polar hydroxylated aromatic compounds) and charged (amino acids) analytes under pressure driven conditions (pLC), differences to the previously observed behavior under voltage driven conditions (CEC) were observed. Whereas the non-charged analytes showed similar behavior in both cases--thus, corroborating the previous assumption of a mainly chromatographic separation mode driven by hydrophilic interactions in CEC--the charged amino acids did not. Assuming that the separation was governed by chromatographic phenomena in the pLC mode and by both chromatographic and electrophoretic effects in the CEC mode, the experiments allowed deconvoluting the two contributions. In particular, the charged amino acids appeared to interact with the stationary phases mainly by electrostatic interactions modified by some hydrophilic effects.     

新型亲水整体柱的制备及其在毛细管液相色谱和加压电色谱中的应用

以N,N-二甲基-N-甲基丙烯酰胺基丙基-N,N-二甲基-N-丙烷磺酸内盐(SPP)为单体,季戊四醇三丙烯酸酯(PETA)为交联剂,偶氮二异丁腈(AIBN)为引发剂及两类不同的致孔剂(乙醇/乙二醇和甲醇/1,4-丁二醇)制备了两种新型亲水性整体柱。为了获得理想的柱效、电渗流速度和渗透性,对制备整体柱的各反应物配比进行了研究和优化。比较了两种整体柱在渗透性和分离样品方面的性能,结果表明,以乙醇/乙二醇为致孔剂制备的整体柱在柱效、分离度方面优于以甲醇/1,4-丁二醇为致孔剂制备的整体柱,但在渗透性方面不及后者。探讨了流动相中盐浓度对核苷类样品保留的影响,发现当甲酸铵浓度从10 mmol/L增加到70 mmol/L时,核苷样品的保留因子呈现先增加后减小的状态。将制备的整体柱用于毛细管液相色谱和加压电色谱分别分离胺类、酚类和核苷类样品,获得了理想的分离效果。在分离酚类和核苷类混合样品时,发现加压毛细管电色谱在分离度和分离速度上均优于毛细管液相色谱。     

Polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes as functional monomer to prepare hybrid monolithic columns for capillary electrochromatography and capillary liquid chromatography

A simple approach to fabricate hybrid monolithic column within the confines of fused-silica capillaries (75 μm i.d.) was introduced. A polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes (POSS) reagent containing a methacrylate group was selected as functional monomer, and copolymerized with bisphenol A dimethacrylate (BPADMA) or ethylene dimethacrylate (EDMA) in the presence of porogenic solvents via thermally initiated free radical polymerization. After optimization of the preparation conditions, two POSS-containing hybrid monoliths were successfully prepared and exhibited good permeability and stability. By comparison of the separation efficiencies of the resulting poly(POSS-co-BPADMA) and poly(POSS-co-EDMA) monoliths in capillary electrochromatography (CEC) and capillary liquid chromatography (cLC), it was indicated the former has better column efficiencies for alkylbenzenes, phenols, anilines and PAHs in CEC and cLC than the latter. Particularly, the hybrid poly(POSS-co-BPADMA) monolith is more suitable for separation of PAHs due to π–π interaction between the analytes and aromatic rings in the surface of monolithic stationary phase.     

Non-particulate (continuous bed or monolithic) acrylate-based capillary columns for reversed-phase liquid chromatography and electrochromatography

Three approaches are described to synthesize acrylic non-particulate beds (also called continuous beds or monoliths) in aqueous polymerization media for reversed-phase capillary liquid chromatography/electrochromatography. In the first, hexyl acrylate comonomer was dissolved together with water soluble polar comonomers using a non-ionic detergent. In the second, a new alkyl ammonium salt comonomer, (3-allylamino-2-hydroxypropyl)dodecyldimethylammonium chloride was used, which is water soluble and has detergent properties itself. The alkyl group of this comonomer provides hydrophobicity while the ionic groups generate electroosmosis in the non-particulate bed. In the third approach, the alkyl comonomer was used as a detergent to dissolve another hydrophobic comonomer in an aqueous polymerization medium. All three approaches were evaluated with respect to hydrophobicity, efficiency and electroosmotic properties of the beds. Hydrophobicity expressed as methylene group selectivity for the three types of the beds in 50% methanol mobile phase was 1.86, 1.16 and 1.78, electroosmotic mobility -5.14 x 10(-5), 6.89 x 10(-5) and 6.37 x 10(-5) cm2 V(-1) s(-1) and efficiency for the retained compound (methylparabene) 67,000, 93,000 and 110,000 plates m(-1) correspondingly. The columns were tested using pressure driven capillary chromatography and capillary electrochromatography. The influence of polymerization temperature on hydrodynamic permeability, separation impedance and inverse size exclusion porosimetry characteristics were used to evaluate the separation columns. The increase of the polymerization temperature resulted higher permeability of the bed, separation impedance and lower polymeric skeleton porosity. Further characterisation was provided by examining the separation efficiency observed for a series of benzoic acid esters and alkyl parabens.     

Ring-opening metathesis polymerization-derived monolithic capillary columns for high-performance liquid chromatography. Downscaling and application in medical research

Monolithic capillary columns were prepared via ring-opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) using norborn-2-ene (NBE) and 1, 4, 4a, 5, 8, 8a-hexahydro-1, 4, 5, 8-exo,endo-dimethanonaphthalene (DMN-H6) as monomers. The monolithic polymer was copolymerized with Grubbs-type initiator RuCl(2)(PCy(3))(2)(CHPh) and a suitable porogenic system within the confines of fused silica capillaries of different inner diameter (I.D.). The first part of the study focused on batch-to-batch reproducibility of ROMP-derived capillary monoliths. Capillary monoliths of 200 microm I.D. showed good reproducibility in terms of retention times, with relative standard deviations (RSD) of 1.9% for proteins and 2.2% for peptides. However, the separately synthesized capillary monoliths revealed pronounced variation in back pressure with RSD values of up to 31%. These variations were considerably reduced by cooling of the capillaries during polymerization. Using this optimized preparation procedure capillary monoliths of 100 and 50 microm I.D. were synthesized and the effects of scaling down the column I.D. on the morphology and on the reproducibility of the polymerization process were investigated. In the second part, the applicability of ROMP-derived capillary monoliths to a separation problem common in medical research was assessed. A 200 microm I.D. monolithic column demonstrated excellent separation behavior for insulin and various insulin analogs, showing equivalent separation performance to Vydac C4 and Zorbax C3-based stationary phases. Moreover, the high permeability of monoliths enabled chromatographic separations at higher flow rates, which shortened analysis time to about one third. For the analysis of insulin in human biofluid samples, enhanced sensitivity was achieved by using a 50 microm I.D. ROMP-derived monolith.     

Electron beam triggered, free radical polymerization-derived monolithic capillary columns for high-performance liquid chromatography

Monolithic capillary columns were prepared via electron beam triggered free radical polymerization within the confines of 0.2 and 0.1mm I.D. capillary columns using ethyl methacrylate and trimethylolpropane triacrylate as monomers as well as 2-propanol, 1-dodecanol and toluene as porogenic system. The influence of column diameter on reproducibility and separation performance was investigated. For evaluation, a protein standard consisting of five proteins in the range of 5800-66,000 g mol(-1) was used. Reproducibility was checked by determining the relative standard deviations in retention times, peak widths at half height, asymmetry and resolution. Excellent run-to-run reproducibility was found for both 0.2 and 0.1mm I.D. columns; batch-to-batch reproducibility was good for both column types. In order to enhance the non-polar character of the monolithic columns, lauryl methacrylate-based capillary columns were prepared. These were successfully used for the separation of proteins and a cytochrome c digest.     

Preparation of monolithic silica columns for high-performance liquid chromatography

Preparation methods of monolithic silica columns for HPLC including the surface modification were reviewed. Chemical modification methods recently reported to obtain stationary phases for reversed-phase (RP), chiral, ion-exchange, and hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) separations were discussed. Recent results related to preparation methods of monolithic silica were also covered. The characteristics and properties of silica monoliths and some applications of monolithic silica columns for different analytical and bioanalytical fields will be commented.     

Developments in the use and fabrication of organic monolithic phases for use with high-performance liquid chromatography and capillary electrochromatography

Capillary electrochromatography suffered in its development because of difficulty in producing stable columns with good permeability. Variability in frit characteristics gave rise to non-reproducible capillaries whose fabrication was extremely difficult and time consuming. Monolithic stationary phases gained popularity in the early 1990s due to the fact that they were easy to fabricate and required no retaining frits. They were also able to be manufactured in a wide variety of chemistries which made them very interesting to the analytical chemist who is constantly looking for materials with different selectivity to the popular silica-based stationary phases.     

S-citalopram imprinted monolithic columns for capillary electrochromatography enantioseparations

In this study, the molecular imprinting method was used to separate enantiomeric forms of chiral antidepressant drug, R,S-citalopram (R,S-CIT) in aqueous solution by CEC system combining the advantages of capillary electrophoresis (CE) and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). For that, an amino acid-based molecularly imprinted monolithic capillary column was designed and used as a stationary phase for selective separation of S-citalopram (S-CIT) for the first time. S-CIT was selectively separated from the aqueous solution containing the other enantiomeric form of R-CIT, which is the same in size and shape as the template molecule. Morphology of the molecularly imprinted (MIP S-CIT) and non-imprinted (NIP S-CIT) monolithic capillary columns was observed by scanning electron microscopy. Imprinting efficiency of MIP S-CIT monolithic capillary column used for selective S-CIT separation was verified by comparing with NIP S-CIT and calculated imprinting factor (I.F:1.81) proved the high selectivity of the MIP S-CIT for S-CIT. Cavities formed for S-CIT form enabled selective (α = 2.08) separation of the target molecule from the other enantiomeric R-CIT form. Separation was achieved in a short period of 10 min, with the electrophoretic mobility of 7.68 × 10⁻⁶ m²/Vs for R,S-CIT at pH 7.0 10 mM PB and 50% ACN ratio. The performance of both MIP S-CIT and NIP S-CIT columns was estimated by repeating the R,S-CIT separations with intra-batch and inter-batch studies for reproducibility of retention times of R,S-CITs. Estimated RSD values that are lower than 2% suggest that the monolithic columns separate R,S-CIT enantiomers without losing separation efficiency.     

Preparation and evaluation of rigid porous polyacrylamide-based strong cation-exchange monolithic columns for capillary electrochromatography

A CEC monolithic column with strong cation-exchange (SCX) stationary phase based on hydrophilic monomers was prepared by in situ polymerization of acrylamide, methylenebisacrylamide, and 2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-propanesulfonic acid (AMPS) in a complete organic binary porogenic solvent consisting of DMSO and dodecanol. The sulfonic groups provided by the monomer AMPS on the surface of the stationary phase generate an EOF from anode to cathode, and serve as an SCX stationary phase at the same time. The monolithic stationary phase exhibited normal-phase chromatographic behavior for neutral analytes. For charged analytes, electrostatic interaction/repulsion with the monolith was observed. The strong SCX monolithic column has been successfully employed in the electrochromatographic separation of basic drugs, peptides, and alkaloids extracted from natural products.     

Polyethylenimine-modified metal oxides for fabrication of packed capillary columns for capillary electrochromatography and capillary liquid chromatography

The need for novel packing materials in both capillary electrochromatography (CEC) and capillary liquid chromatography (CLC) is apparent and the development towards more selective, application-oriented chromatographic phases is under progress world-wide. In this study we have synthesized new polyethyleneimine (PEI) functionalized Mn(2)O(3), SiO(2), SnO(2), and ZrO(2) particles for the fabrication of packed capillary columns for CEC and CLC. The nanocasting approach was successful for the preparation of functionalized metal oxide materials with a controlled porosity and morphology. PEI functionalization was done using ethyleneimine monomers to create particles which are positively charged in aqueous solution below pH 9. This functionalization allowed the possibility to have both hydrophobic (due to its alkyl chain) and ionic interactions (due to positively charged amino groups) with selected compounds. For comparison aminopropyl-functionalized silica was also synthesized and tested. Both slurry pressure and electrokinetic packing procedures used gave similar results, but fast sedimentation of the material caused some problems during the packing. The high stability and wide pH range of PEI-functionalized SiO(2) material, with potential for hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions, proved to be useful for the CEC and CLC separation of some model acidic and neutral compounds.     

Simultaneous separation and enantioseparation of thalidomide and its hydroxylated metabolites using high-performance liquid chromatography in common-size columns, capillary liquid chromatography and nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography

The separation of thalidomide (TD) and its hydroxylated metabolites including their simultaneous enantioseparation was studied using three different polysaccharide-type chiral stationary phases (CSPs) in combination with polar organic mobile phases. Three different techniques, high-performance liquid chromatography in common-size columns, capillary LC and nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography were compared in terms of separation. As this study illustrates, polar organic mobile phases represent a valuable extension for less polar and polar aqueous-organic mobile phases in combination with polysaccharide CSPs. Chiralpak AD consisting of 25% of amylose-tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) coated on wide-pore aminopropylsilanized silica gel exhibited higher resolving ability compared to the similar cellulose derivative (Chiralcel OD) as well as to cellulose-tris(4-methylbenzoate) (Chiralcel OJ) CSPs for this particular set of chiral analytes. Baseline separation and simultaneous enantioseparation of all three compounds could be achieved under optimized separation conditions.     

Preparation and characterization of monolithic polymer columns for capillary electrochromatography

A series of micro-monolithic columns with different porosities were prepared for capillary electrochromatography (CEC) by in-situ copolymerization of butyl methacrylate, ethylene glycol dimethacrylate, and 2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-propane-sulfonic acid in the presence of a porogen in fused-silica capillaries of 100 microm I.D. Different column porosities were obtained by changing the ratios of monomers to porogenic solvents. Columns were investigated and evaluated under both pressure-driven (high-performance liquid chromatography, HPLC) and electro-driven (capillary electrochromatography, CEC) conditions. Each column exhibited different efficiency and dependency on flow velocity under electro-driven conditions. Abnormally broad peaks for some relatively bulky molecules were observed. Possible explanations are discussed. The differences in column efficiency and retention behavior between the two eluent-driven modes were studied in detail. In addition, other column properties, such as morphology, porosity, stability and reproducibility, were extensively tested.     

Ionic liquids monolithic columns for protein separation in capillary electrochromatography

A series of ionic liquids (ILs) monolithic capillary columns based on 1-vinyl-3-octylimidazolium (ViOcIm⁺) were prepared by two approaches (“one-pot” approach and “anion-exchange” approach). The effects of different anions (bromide, Br⁻; tetrafluoroborate, BF₄⁻; hexafluorophosphate, PF₆⁻; and bis-trifluoromethanesulfonylimide, NTf₂⁻) on chromatography performance of all the resulting columns were investigated systematically under capillary electrochromatography (CEC) mode. The results indicated that all these columns could generate a stable reversed electroosmotic flow (EOF) over a wide pH range from 2.0 to 12.0. For the columns prepared by “one-pot” approach, the EOF decreased in the order of ViOcIm⁺Br⁻ > ViOcIm⁺BF₄⁻ > ViOcIm⁺PF₆⁻ > ViOcIm⁺NTf₂⁻ under the same CEC conditions; the ViOcIm⁺Br⁻ based column exhibited highest column efficiencies for the test small molecules; the ViOcIm⁺NTf₂⁻ based column possessed the strongest retention for aromatic hydrocarbons; and baseline separation of four standard proteins was achieved on ViOcIm⁺NTf₂⁻ based column corresponding to the highest column efficiency of 479 000 N m⁻¹ for cytochrome c (Cyt c). These results indicated that the property of ILs based columns could be tuned successfully by changing anions, which gave these columns potential to separate both small molecules and macro biomolecules.