Comparison between the loading capacities of columns packed with partially and totally porous fine particles. What is the effective surface area available for adsorption?

The adsorption isotherms of phenol, caffeine, insulin, and lysozyme were measured on two C(18)-bonded silica columns. The first one was packed with classical totally porous particles (3 microm Luna(2)-C(18)from Phenomenex, Torrance, CA, USA), the second one with shell particles (2.7 microm Halo-C(18) from Advanced Materials Technology, Wilmington, DE, USA). The measurements were made at room temperature (T=295+/-1K), using mainly frontal analysis (FA) and also elution by characteristic points (FACP) when necessary. The adsorption energy distributions (AEDs) were estimated by the iterative numerical expectation-maximization (EM) procedure and served to justify the choice of the best adsorption isotherm model for each compound. The best isotherm parameters were derived from either the best fit of the experimental data to a multi-Langmuir isotherm model (MLRA) or from the AED results (equilibrium constants and saturation capacities), when the convergence of the EM program was achieved. The experiments show than the loading capacity of the Luna column is more than twice that of the Halo column for low-molecular-weight compounds. This result was expected; it is in good agreement with the values of the accessible surface area of these two materials, which were calculated from the pore size volume distributions. The pore size volume distributions are validated by the excellent agreement between the calculated and measured exclusion volumes of polystyrene standards by inverse size exclusion chromatography (ISEC). In contrast, the loading capacity ratio of the two columns is 1.5 or less with insulin and lysozyme. This is due to a significant exclusion of these two proteins from the internal pore volumes of the two packing materials. This result raises the problem of the determination of the effective surface area of the packing material, particularly in the case of proteins. This area is about 40 and 30% of the total surface area for insulin and for lysozyme, respectively, based on the pore size volume distribution validated by the ISEC method. The ISEC experiments showed that the largest and the smallest mesopores have rather a cylindrical and a spherical shape, respectively, for both packing materials.     

A chromatographic estimate of the degree of surface heterogeneity of reversed-phase liquid chromatography packing materials. II-Endcapped monomeric C18-bonded stationary phase

In a previous report, the heterogeneity of a non-endcapped C30-bonded stationary phase was investigated, based on the results of the measurements of the adsorption isotherms of two neutral compounds (phenol and caffeine) and two ionizable compounds (sodium naphthalene sulfonate and propranololium chloride) by frontal analysis (FA). The same method is applied here for the characterization of the surface heterogeneity of two new brands of endcapped C18-bonded stationary phases (Gemini and Sunfire). The adsorption isotherms of the same four chemicals were measured by FA and the results confirmed by the independent calculation of the adsorption energy distribution (AED), using the expectation-maximization (EM) method. The effect of the length of the bonded alkyl chain was investigated. Shorter alkyl-bonded-chains (C18 versus C30) and the end-capping of the silica surface contribute to decrease the surface heterogeneity under the same experimental conditions (30% methanol, 25 mM NaCl). The AEDs of phenol and caffeine are bimodal with the C18-bonded columns while they are trimodal and quadrimodal, respectively, with a non-endcapped C30-bonded column. The "supersites" (adsorption energy > 20 kJ/mol) found on the C30-Prontosil column and attributed to a cation exchange mechanism completely disappear on the C18-Gemini and C18-Sunfire, probably because the end-capping of the silica surface eliminates most if not all the ionic interactions.     

Fast and high-resolution ion chromatography at high pH on short columns packed with 1.8 microm surfactant coated silica reverse-phase particles

Rapid ion chromatographic separations of small inorganic anions are performed on columns packed with high-pH resistant Zorbax Extend-C18 1.8 microm silica particles. Seven anions (iodate, chloride, nitrite, bromide, nitrate, phosphate, sulphate) are separated with 1.3 and 2 cm long x 0.46 cm I.D. C18 columns coated with the surfactant didodecyldimethylammonium bromide (DDAB). A 40 s separation is achieved at 2 mL/min with a 2.5 mM 4-hydroxybenzoic acid eluent at pH 10. Finally, the DDAB removal procedure is improved to eliminate the pressure build-up caused by precipitation of the surfactant in the column upon uncoating.     

Investigations into the chromatographic behaviour of silica gels produced from ester silicates

Summary Silica gels produced from ester silicates (ES-gels) are excellent chromatographic supports. In comparison with other silica gels the RP-materials obtained from them show little peak tailing even with polar, and, in particular, with basic compounds. Gels produced by various manufacturing processes have been classified by adsorption with methyl pyridinium chloride. ES-gels yield very low methyl pyridinium chloride values and small asymmetry parameters. The results indicate that there are strongly acidic, structurally-related surface centres which cause peak tailing on most commercial gels. It was shown that surface silanols on silica gels do not, in themselves, lead to peak tailing.     

Effect of the density of the C(18) surface coverage on the adsorption mechanism of a cationic compound and on the silanol activity of the stationary phase in reversed phase liquid chromatography

RPLC columns with different surface coverages (a C(1) endcapped column with a bonding density of 3.92 micromol/m(2) and four C(18)-bonded, endcapped columns, with octadecyl chain densities of 0.42, 1.01, 2.03, and 3.15 micromol/m(2)) were used to investigate the effects of the density of the surface coverage of RPLC columns on the adsorption mechanism of a cationic compound, amitriptyline chloride, and on the silanol activity of these columns. The mobile phases used were acetonitrile-water (30/70, v/v) solutions, buffered at either pH 2.7 or pH 6.9. At pH 2.7, the residual silanol groups are not ionized. At pH 6.9, some of these groups are ionized and these surface anions can strongly interact with the cationic compound. The adsorption isotherms were measured by frontal analysis (FA) at pH 2.7 and by frontal analysis by characteristic points (FACP) at pH 6.9, because the very high retention observed at neutral pH made FA measurements excessively long and poorly accurate. The adsorption energy distributions (AEDs) were calculated when possible, according to the expectation-maximization (EM) algorithm. A bimodal and a trimodal energy distribution were found for all the columns at pH 2.7 and 6.9, respectively. The third site measured at pH 6.9 was attributed to the strong ion-exchange interactions between the ionized silanol groups and the amitriptylinium cation. The contribution of the ionized silanol groups to the overall retention is maximum for the phases with intermediary bonding densities (1.01 and 2.03 micromol/m(2)). The peak tailing is most pronounced for the lowest (C(1) column) and the highest (3.15 micromol/m(2)) surface coverages.     

Facile synthesis and application of poly(ionic liquid)-bonded silica hybrid materials

Facile methods were developed to prepare hybrid poly(ionic liquid)-bonded silica for a wide range of applications, particularly in analytical chemistry. The hybrid material obtained was evaluated by comparing its adsorption capacity with other conventional separation materials. In addition, the hybrid material has the potential for industrial scale production.     

pH dependence of tailing in reversed-phase chromatography of a cationic dye: measurement of the strong adsorption site surface density

A question that has interested Dr. J.J. Kirkland is addressed: what is the nature of the silanols that cause tailing to persist at low pH in reversed-phase chromatography? Chromatograms for a cationic dye, 1,1'-didodecyl-3,3,3'3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine perchlorate (DiI), were studied at varying pH using an Agilent SB-C8 column and 80% ACN/water for six DiI concentrations ranging from 0.9 to 316 microM. The chromatograms showed increased retention and tailing from pH 1 to 5, as expected. Simulations of the chromatograms agreed well with experiment for a bi-Langmuir isotherm with weak (C8) and strong (silica) adsorption sites. The simulation parameters revealed that the number of strong adsorption sites decreases by 40% from pH 1 to 5, which indicates that the silanols causing tailing are in the SiOH, not the SiO-, form. This seems paradoxical because tailing increases with increasing pH. The simulation parameters reveal that this increased tailing from pH 1 to 5 owes to doubling of the partition coefficient for DiI to the strong adsorption site, which more than compensates for the decreasing number of sites. We attribute this increased partition coefficient to increased long-range coulombic interactions with the increasingly abundant SiO- groups at higher pH, which boosts DiI's partition coefficient for both the C8 and SiOH sites. The picture thus emerges that for DiI, higher pH causes increased tailing because the SiO- groups exacerbate tailing that actually originates from adsorption to SiOH groups.     

Physical origin of peak tailing on C18-bonded silica in reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Single component isotherm data of caffeine and phenol were acquired on two different stationary phases for RPLC, using a methanol/water solution (25%, v/v, methanol) as the mobile phase. The columns were the non-endcapped Waters Resolve-C18, and the Waters XTerra MS C18. Both columns exhibit similar C18 -chain densities (2.45 and 2.50 micromol/m2) and differ essentially by the nature of the underivatized solid support (a conventional, highly polar silica made from water glass, hence containing metal impurities, versus a silica-methylsilane hybrid surface with a lower density of less acidic free silanols). Thirty-two adsorption data points were acquired by FA, for caffeine, between 10(-3) and 24 g/l, a dynamic range of 24,000. Twenty-eigth adsorption data points were acquired for phenol, from 0.025 to 75 g/l, a dynamic range of 3000. The expectation-maximization procedure was used to derive the affinity energy distribution (AED) from the raw FA data points, assuming a local Langmuir isotherm. For caffeine, the AEDs converge to a bimodal and a quadrimodal distribution on XTerra MS-C18 and Resolve-C18, respectively. The values of the saturation capacity (q(s,1) approximately equal to 0.80 mol/l and q(s,2) approximately equal to 0.10 mol/l) and the adsorption constant (b1 approximately equal to 3.11/mol and b2 approximately equal to 29.1 l/mol) measured on the two columns for the lowest two energy modes 1 and 2, are comparable. These data are consistent with those previously measured on an endcapped Kromasil-C18 in a 30/70 (v/v), methanol/water solution (q(s,1) = 0.9 mol/l and q(s,2) = 0.10 mol/l, b1 = 2.4 l/mol and b2 = 16.1 l/mol). The presence of two higher energy modes on the Waters Resolve-C18 column (q(s,3) approximately equal to 0.013 mol/l and q(s,4) approximately equal to 2.6 10(-4) mol/l, b3 approximately equal to 252 l/mol and b4 = 13,200 l/mol) and the strong peak tailing of caffeine are explained by the existence of adsorption sites buried inside the C18-bonded layer. It is demonstrated that strong interactions between caffeine and the water protected bare silica surface cannot explain these high-energy sites because the retention of caffeine on an underivatized Resolve silica column is almost zero. Possible hydrogen-bond interactions between caffeine and the non-protected isolated silanol groups remaining after synthesis amidst the C18-chain network cannot explain these high energy interactions because, then, the smaller phenol molecule should exhibit similarly strong interactions with these isolated silanols on the same Resolve-C18 column and, yet, the consequences of such interactions are not observed. These sites are more consistent with the heterogeneity of the local structure of the C18-bonded layer. Regarding the adsorption of phenol, no matter whether the column is endcapped or not, its molecular interactions with the bare silica were negligible. For both columns, the best adsorption isotherm was the Bilangmuir model (with q(s,1) approximately equal to 2 and q(s,2) approximately equal to 0.67 mol/l, b1 0.61 and b2 approximately equal to 10.3 l/mol). These parameters are consistent with those measured previously on an endcapped Kromasil-C18 column under the same conditions (q(s,1) = 1.5 and q(s,2) = 0.71 mol/l, b1 = 1.4 l/mol and b2 = 11.3 l/mol). As for caffeine, the high-energy sites are definitely located within the C18-bonded layer, not on the bare surface of the adsorbent.     

Comparison of conventional microparticulate and a monolithic reversed-phase column for high-efficiency fast liquid chromatography of basic compounds

The effect of mobile phase flow on column efficiency for a neutral compound together with weak and strong bases was compared for conventional microparticulate (3/3.5 microm and 5 microm) silica RP columns and a monolithic silica RP. For benzene, the minimum plate height (Hmin) at optimum flow-rate (mu(opt)) for weak bases was similar for the 5 microm and the monolith phases. However, the monolith generated much flatter Van Deemter curves, such that at high flow-rate (5 ml min(-1)) the plate height was nearly 3.5 times lower on the monolith. For weak bases analysed in unbuffered mobile phases, and stronger bases with acid phosphate buffer, increased tailing was obtained on the monolith compared with the conventional phases. Nevertheless, Van Deemter plots on the monolith still showed some advantages over particulate phases, even when asymmetry factor was included in the calculation of the plate height. However, at pH 7 considerable tailing of strong bases was found using the monolith; it is not clear whether this results from unique features of the monolith structure, or whether it is due merely to usual problems of silica activity. Van Deemter plots for conventional phases may be improved considerably by operating the column at elevated temperatures. At pH 3, these improvements are influenced to a considerable extent by increases in Dm, as shown by measurements of Dm using the Taylor-Aris procedure. However, at pH 7.0, improvements are much too substantial to be explainable wholly on this basis.     

Effect of the endcapping of reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography adsorbents on the adsorption isotherm

The retention mechanisms of n-propylbenzoate, 4-t ert-butylphenol, and caffeine on the endcapped Symmetry-C(18) and the non-endcapped Resolve-C(18) are compared. The adsorption isotherms were measured by frontal analysis (FA), using as the mobile phase mixtures of methanol or acetonitrile and water of various compositions. The isotherm data were modeled and the adsorption energy distributions calculated. The surface heterogeneity increases faster with decreasing methanol concentration on the non-endcapped than on the endcapped adsorbent. For instance, for methanol concentrations exceeding 30% (v/v), the adsorption of caffeine is accounted for by assuming three and two different types of adsorption sites on Resolve-C(18) and Symmetry-C(18), respectively. This is explained by the effect of the mobile phase composition on the structure of the C(18)-bonded layer. The bare surface of bonded silica appears more accessible to solute molecules at high water contents in the mobile phase. On the other hand, replacing methanol by a stronger organic modifier like acetonitrile dampens the differences between non-endcapped and endcapped stationary phase and decreases the degree of surface heterogeneity of the adsorbent. For instance, at acetonitrile concentrations exceeding 20%, the surface appears nearly homogeneous for the adsorption of caffeine.     

Rapid radiochemical separation in neutron activation analysis : Part 1. The use of C18-bonded silica gel and selective complexation for determinations of manganese,copper and zinc in biological materials

A rapid radiochemical separation method based on the removal of metal ions by columns of C₁₈-bonded silica gel after selective complexation by 8-quinolinol, ammonium pyrolidinedithiocarbamate or cupferron is described for the determination of manganese, copper and zinc in neutron-activated biological materials. The removal of the metal ions, either by adsorption or by a combination of filtration and adsorption on columns of C₁₈-bonded silica gel, was investigated to optimise the separation procedure. Analysis of several National Bureau of Standards and International Atomic Energy Agency biological reference materials demonstrated the effectiveness of this technique. The method is simple and reliable and readily adaptable in all radiochemical laboratories. Furthermore, columns of C₁₈-bonded silica gel have been successfully recycled a number of times without deterioration.     

Adsorption mechanism of acids and bases in reversed-phase liquid chromatography in weak buffered mobile phases designed for liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry

The overloaded band profiles of five acido-basic compounds were measured, using weakly buffered mobile phases. Low buffer concentrations were selected to provide a better understanding of the band profiles recorded in LC/MS analyses, which are often carried out at low buffer concentrations. In this work, 10 microL samples of a 50 mM probe solution were injected into C(18)-bonded columns using a series of five buffered mobile phases at (SW)pH between 2 and 12. The retention times and the shapes of the bands were analyzed based on thermodynamic arguments. A new adsorption model that takes into account the simultaneous adsorption of the acidic and the basic species onto the endcapped adsorbent, predicts accurately the complex experimental profiles recorded. The adsorption mechanism of acido-basic compounds onto RPLC phases seems to be consistent with the following microscopic model. No matter whether the acid or the base is the neutral or the basic species, the neutral species adsorbs onto a large number of weak adsorption sites (their saturation capacity is several tens g/L and their equilibrium constant of the order of 0.1 L/g). In contrast, the ionic species adsorbs strongly onto fewer active sites (their saturation capacity is about 1g/L and their equilibrium constant of the order of a few L/g). From a microscopic point of view and in agreement with the adsorption isotherm of the compound measured by frontal analysis (FA) and with the results of Monte-Carlo calculations performed by Schure et al., the first type of adsorption sites are most likely located in between C(18)-bonded chains and the second type of adsorption sites are located deeper in contact with the silica surface. The injected concentration (50 mM) was too low to probe the weakest adsorption sites (saturation capacity of a few hundreds g/L with an equilibrium constant of one hundredth of L/g) that are located at the very interface between the C(18)-bonded layer and the bulk phase.     

Benefits of Innovative and Fully Water-Compatible Stationary Phases of Thin-Film Microextraction (TFME) Blades

Octadecyl (C₁₈) groups are arguably the most popular ligands used for preparation of solid phase microextraction (SPME) devices. However, conventional C₁₈-bonded silica particles are not fully compatible with the nearly 100% aqueous composition of typical biological samples (e.g., plasma, saliva, or urine). This study presents the first evaluation of thin-film SPME devices coated with special water-compatible C₁₈-bonded particles. Device performance was assessed by extracting a mixture of 30 model compounds that exhibited various chemical structures and properties, such as hydrophobicity. Additionally, nine unique compositions of desorption solvents were tested. Thin-film SPME devices coated with C₁₈-bonded silica particles with polar end-capping groups (10 µm) were compared with conventional trimethylsilane end-capped C₁₈-bonded silica particles of various sizes (5, 10, and 45 µm) and characteristics. Polar end-capped particles provided the best extraction efficacy and were characterized by the strongest correlations between the efficacy of the extraction process and the hydrophobicity of the analytes. The results suggest that the original features of octadecyl ligands are best preserved in aqueous conditions by polar end-capped particles, unlike with conventional trimethylsilane end-capped particles that are currently used to prepare SPME devices. The benefits associated with this improved type of coating encourage further implementation of microextractraction as greener alternative to the traditional sample preparation methods.     

Comparison of aqueous and non-aqueous capillary electrochromatography for the separation of basic solutes

The analysis of basic compounds by capillary electrochromatography (CEC) on silica-based materials using conventional HPLC stationary phases has failed to address the problem of severe peak tailing and non-reproducible chromatography. Several new generation stationary phases were evaluated using aqueous and non-aqueous mobile phases. The best results were obtained in the aqueous mode using Waters Symmetry Shield RP-8, a material in which the residual silanol groups were shielded by an octylcarbamate function. For comparison, experiments were carried out using unmodified silica.     

Liquid chromatography at the critical condition: Thermodynamic significance and influence of pore size

Liquid chromatography at the critical condition (LCCC) is a high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) technique that lies between size exclusion chromatography and adsorption-based interaction chromatography, where the elution of polymers becomes independent of polymer molecular weight. At LCCC, the balance between the entropic exclusion and the enthalpic adsorption interactions between polymers and stationary phases results in the simultaneous HPLC elution of polymers regardless of molecular weight. Using C18-bonded silica chromatographic columns with 5 μm particle size and different average pore size (diameter = 300 Å, 120 Å, 100 Å, and 50 Å), we report (1) the thermodynamic significance of LCCC conditions and (2) the influence of column pore size on the determination of critical conditions for linear polymer chains. Specifically, we used mixtures of monodisperse polystyrene samples ranging in molecular weight from 162 to 371,100 g/mol and controlled the temperature of the HPLC columns at a fixed composition of a mobile phase consisting of 57(v/v)% methylene chloride and 43(v/v)% acetonitrile. It was found that, at the fixed mobile phase composition, the temperature of LCCC (T_LCCC) is higher for C18-bonded chromatographic columns with larger average pore size. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym Phys 47: 2533–2540, 2009     

Secondary interactions, an unexpected problem emerged between hydroxyl containing analytes and fused silica capillaries in anion-exchange micro-liquid chromatography

Relevant secondary interactions (hydrogen-bond type), additional to the main anion-exchange mechanism, were found when a method for As, Se and Cr speciation was developed based on microLC-inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) coupling. In order to get the claimed analytical performance characteristics of the microbore columns, microLC systems are equipped with very narrow bore fused silica capillaries. When a mobile phase of NH(4)NO(3) at pH 8.7 was used, a notable tailing was observed for As(III), As(V), MMA and Se(IV), species containing hydroxyl groups in its chemical structure at this pH value. However, additional interactions appeared neither when the fused silica capillaries of the capillary LC system were substituted for polyetheretherketone (PEEK) nor operating at pH below 8.5. A mechanism to explain the additional interaction observed is proposed and tested in this work. It seems that high pH values produce a partial hydrolysis of the siloxane groups of the fused silica capillaries. Under these conditions, degradation products of silica, containing ionized silanol groups, reach the column and interact with the anion-exchange resin. Then, ionized silanol groups, retained on the column, can interact with the hydroxyl moiety of the aforementioned analytes leading to severe peak tailing and broadening. Different strategies were evaluated to solve the problem. The addition of a salt containing hydroxyl groups in the mobile phase such as hydrogen phosphate, the diminution of the pH and the use of PEEK capillaries in the microHPLC system demonstrated to be suitable. Finally, two alternative microHPLC-ICP-MS separations, based on a gradient elution of NH(4)NO(3) at pH 8.0 and NH(4)NO(3)/NH(4)H(2)PO(4) at pH 8.7, were optimized and compared. Results showed better peak shapes for some species when hydrogen phosphate was added to the mobile phase.     

Limits of the numerical estimation of the adsorption energy distribution from adsorption isotherm data using the expectation-maximization method

The limits of the use of the expectation-maximization (EM) method for the study of the heterogeneity of adsorbent surfaces were tested by calculating the adsorption energy distribution of systems having known degrees of heterogeneity. Connecting on-line two different columns allows the simulation of a heterogeneous system. The two columns used were endcapped, C(18)-bonded silica used as stationary phases and having different degrees of C(18) chain coverages (0.42 and 2.03 micromol/m(2)). The adsorption constants of phenol measured by frontal analysis (FA) are significantly different on these two columns. On each column, the adsorption behavior was best accounted for by a bi-Langmuir isotherm model, corresponding to a heterogeneous surface with a bimodal energy distribution. The difference between the adsorption energies on the weak adsorption sites of the two columns is 1.5 kJ/mol. The energy difference of their high energy sites is 2.2 kJ/mol. The EM method can readily distinguish between adsorption sites having energies that differ by more than 5 kJ/mol after more than 10 million iterations, but it cannot distinguish between adsorption sites for which this energy difference is less than 2 kJ/mol, even after 100 million iterations. For highly heterogeneous systems, (e.g., those with more than three different types of adsorption sites), the EM program does not converge necessarily towards the actual energy distribution function but toward a simpler one, having fewer adsorption sites that are almost equally spaced in the energy space. This failure of the EM program is related to the fact that, despite the excellent precision of the FA measurements (<1%), any series of adsorption data can be represented by several distinct AEDs. Thus, the degree of heterogeneity of RPLC adsorbents determined with the EM method might often be minimized, resulting in erroneous values of the isotherm parameters.     

Ion-pair reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography of basic drugs using sulphonic acids

The use of sulphonic acid ion-pair reagents in the thin-layer chromatography of four basic drugs (all secondary amines) on C18-bonded silica gel, paraffin coated silica gel and silica gel itself has been investigated. Effects of the ion-pair reagents were only obtained on C18-bonded silica gel, and only then when the reagents were pre-coated onto the stationary phase. In general the largest reductions in the RF values of the test compounds occurred when sodium dodecylsulphate was coated onto the plates.