A novel FRET approach for in situ investigation of cellulase–cellulose interaction

A novel real-time in situ detection method for the investigation of cellulase–cellulose interactions based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) has been developed. FRET has been widely used in biological and biophysical fields for studies related to proteins, nucleic acids, and small biological molecules. Here, we report the efficient labeling of carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) with donor dye 5-(aminomethyl)fluorescein and its use as a donor in a FRET assay together with an Alexa Fluor 594 (AF594, acceptor)–cellulase conjugate as acceptor. This methodology was successfully employed to investigate the temperature dependency of cellulase binding to cellulose at a molecular level by monitoring the fluorescence emission change of donor (or acceptor) in a homogeneous liquid environment. It also provides a sound base for ongoing cellulase–cellulose study using cellulosic fiber.     

Optimization of pairings and detection conditions for measurement of FRET between cyan and yellow fluorescent proteins.

Detection of F?rster resonance energy transfer (FRET) between cyan and yellow fluorescent proteins is a key method for quantifying dynamic processes inside living cells. To compare the different cyan and yellow fluorescent proteins, FRET efficiencies were measured for a set of the possible donor:acceptor pairs. FRET between monomeric Cerulean and Venus is more efficient than the ECFP:EYFP pair and has a 10% greater F?rster distance. We also compared several live cell microscopy methods for measuring FRET. The greatest contrast for changes in intramolecular FRET is obtained using a combination of ratiometric and spectral imaging. However, this method is not appropriate for establishing the presence of FRET without extra controls. Accurate FRET efficiencies are obtained by fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy, but these measurements are difficult to collect and analyze. Acceptor photobleaching is a common and simple method for measuring FRET efficiencies. However, when applied to cyan to yellow fluorescent protein FRET, this method becomes prone to an artifact that leads to overestimation of FRET efficiency and false positive signals. FRET was also detected by measuring the acceptor fluorescence anisotropy. Although difficult to quantify, this method is exceptional for screening purposes, because it provides high contrast for discriminating FRET.     

Fluorescence energy transfer-sensitized photobleaching of a fluorescent label as a tool to study donor-acceptor distance distributions and dynamics in protein assemblies: studies of a complex of biotinylated IgM with streptavidin and aggregates of concanavalin A

A photokinetic method of detection of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between special fluorescent labels is applied to study time-averaged spatial distribution of labeled proteins in protein assemblies. Prolonged irradiation of a sample at the absorption maximum of the energy donor initiates FRET-sensitized fluorescence photobleaching of the energy acceptor label, which was monitored by steady-state fluorimetric measurements. Kinetics of the acceptor photobleaching and kinetics of decreasing the efficiency of FRET from donors to unbleached acceptors were determined. The FRET efficiency was found from measuring sensitization of acceptor fluorescence. Analysis of the photokinetic data permits to estimate the time-averaged distribution of acceptors on donor-acceptor distances in the range of characteristic distances of FRET. Dynamic processes influencing donor-acceptor distances can be also investigated by the method. Application of the method is demonstrated by the studies of a complex of biotinylated IgM with streptavidin and aggregates composed of concanavalin A and sodium dodecyl sulphate. A new thiadicarbocyanine dye was used as the acceptor label. R-phycoerythrin and tetramethylrhodamine isothiocyanate were the donor labels. In the IgM-streptavidin complex, 16% of acceptors most contributed to FRET provided 90% of FRET efficiency, whereas acceptors made about the same time-averaged contribution to FRET in the concanavalin A aggregates.     

绿色荧光蛋白为传能对的供体光漂白法测定FRET效率的探讨

探讨以两种新荧光蛋白MiCy,mKo为传能对并应用供体光漂白法测量荧光共振能量转移(FRET)效率.首先通过基因工程方法表达纯化了这两种蛋白,并测量了荧光光谱及光漂白性质,表明MiCy极易光漂白而mKo抗光漂白.进一步以Ni-NTA-agarose为FRET模型,在Confocal上对MiCy进行光漂白时间常数的测量,并计算了FRET效率.结果表明MiCy-mKo传能对适合用供体光漂白法测量FRET效率,此传能对将在蛋白质相互作用研究中有广泛应用.     

A PHOTOCHEMICAL TECHNIQUE TO ENHANCE SENSITIVITY OF DETECTION OF FLUORESCENCE RESONANCE ENERGY TRANSFER

Abstract: A photochemical kinetic method of measuring small values of efficiency of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between special probes is proposed. The FRET efficiency (ω) is determined from kinetics of the photochemical reaction of the energy acceptor sensitized by FRET from the energy donor. The choice of an appropriate donor-acceptor pair permits the minimization of background reactions. Application of the method is demonstrated by the detection of FRET from 2,5- bis (5- tert -butyl-2-benzoxasolyl)thiophen (BBOT) to acridine orange (AO) in phospholipid vesicles. Photobleaching of AO in the presence of CBr₄ was applied as a photochemical reaction of the acceptor. The reaction was monitored by steady-state fluorescence measurements. The FRET measurements were carried out by the proposed technique when the probe/lipid ratio and ω were as small as 1.1 × 10⁻⁵ M/M and 0.0017, respectively. Under these conditions, the rate constant of AO photobleaching was increased by 26% as compared with that of the reference sample without BBOT. The results suggest that applications of the technique may be useful in the study of the membrane topography.     

A PHOTOCHEMICAL TECHNIQUE TO ENHANCE SENSITIVITY OF DETECTION OF FLUORESCENCE RESONANCE ENERGY TRANSFER

Abstract –A photochemical kinetic method of measuring small values of efficiency of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between special probes is proposed. The FRET efficiency ( Ω ) is determined from kinetics of the photochemical reaction of the energy acceptor sensitized by FRET from the energy donor. The choice of an appropriate donor-acceptor pair permits the minimization of background reactions. Application of the method is demonstrated by the detection of FRET from 2,5-W.s(5- tert -butyl-2-benzoxasolyl)thiophen (BBOT) to acridine orange (AO) in phospholipid vesicles. Photobleaching of AO in the presence of CBr₄ was applied as a photochemical reaction of the acceptor. The reaction was monitored by steady-state fluorescence measurements. The FRET measurements were carried out by the proposed technique when the probe/lipid ratio and Ω were as small as 1.1 times 10^-5 M/M and 0.0017, respectively. Under these conditions, the rate constant of AO photobleaching was increased by 26% as compared with that of the reference sample without BBOT. The results suggest that applications of the technique may be useful in the study of the membrane topography.     

The study of cell wall structure and cellulose–cellulase interactions through fluorescence microscopy

The efficient decomposition of biomass into carbohydrates for the sustainable generation of biofuels has become the focus of much research. Yet, limited understanding exists on how the enzymes that catalyze the biochemical conversion of biomass, such as cellulases, interact with cellulose microfibrils and how cellulose structure is changed by cellulolytic enzymes. This has spurred the application of high-resolution imaging techniques, such as atomic force microscopy or fluorescence microscopy, to visualize the biomolecular interactions and structural changes that occur at the micro/nanoscale. In particular, fluorescence microscopy offers advantages such as high sensitivity and the ability to monitor species under biologically relevant conditions. Furthermore, the introduction of techniques, such as single molecule or super-resolution fluorescence microscopy, has allowed imaging biomolecules and macromolecular structures with near molecular resolution. These advantages make fluorescence microscopy ideally suited for the study of cell wall structure and cellulose–cellulase interactions. The application of fluorescence microscopy has already yielded key insights into the arrangement of structural polysaccharides in the plant cell wall, the reversibility and binding kinetics of cellulases, their molecular motion on crystalline cellulose, and the structural changes that occur as cellulose is depolymerized by cellulases. Yet, the application of fluorescence to study cellulose–cellulase interactions remains limited. This review aims at (1) providing an overview of fluorescence microscopy techniques suitable for the study of cellulose–cellulase interactions; (2) the applications of these techniques to date and the key insights obtained; and (3) the opportunities for future studies of the interaction of cell wall degrading enzymes with cellulosic materials.     

General and reliable quantitative measurement of fluorescence resonance energy transfer using three fluorescence channels

In this paper, we describe a comprehensive general system adapted for quantitative fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurement using signals from three channels of a fluorescence instrument. The general FRET measurement system involves two established methods, as well as two novel approaches. Unlike the previous measurements, which can be taken correctly only when the quantity of the acceptor is greater than or equal to that of the donor, one of our novel methods can overcome this obstacle and take quantitative FRET measurements when the donor is in excess of the acceptor. Hence the general FRET measurement system allowed one to determine the exact distance when the donor and acceptor were present in different quantities, and integrated the methods for quantitative FRET measurements. The uniformity of measured values and utility of each method were validated using molecular standards based on DNA oligonucleotide rulers. We also discussed and validated the use of a novel method for estimating the relative quantities of the donor and acceptor fluorophores when they were not known before an appropriate method of this system can be selected.     

Reactivities of cellulases from fungi towards ribbon-type bacterial cellulose and band-shaped bacterial cellulose

We have investigated the reactivities of various cellulases onribbon-type bacterial cellulose (BC I) and band-shaped bacterial cellulose (BCII) so as to clarify the properties of different cellulases. BC I waseffectively hydrolyzed by exo-type cellulases from different fungi from twicetofour times as much as BC II, but endo-type cellulases showed little differencein reactivity on those substrates. One of the endo-type cellulases, EG II fromTrichoderma reesei, degraded BC II more rapidly thanexo-type cellulases even in the production of reducing sugars. The degree ofpolymerization (DP) of BC II was rapidly decreased by endo-type cellulases atanearly stage, while exo-type cellulases did not cause the decrease of DP atthe initial stage, though the decrease of DP was observed after an incubation of24 h. All exo-type cellulases adsorbed on BC I and BC II,whileendo-type cellulases except for EG II adsorbed slightly on both substrates. Itwas interesting to observe EG II adsorbed on BC I but not on BC II. It issuggested that the adsorption of enzyme on cellulose is important for thedegradation of BC I, but not for BC II. It is proposed that the ratio of aspecific activity of each enzyme between BC I and BC II represents thedifference in the mode of action of cellulase. Furthermore, the K _RW value, which we can calculate from thedecrease of DP/reducing sugar produced, is effective for discriminating themode of action of cellulase, especially the evaluation of randomness in thehydrolysis of cellulose by endo- and exo-type cellulases.     

Photobleaching pathways in single-molecule FRET experiments

To acquire accurate structural and dynamical information on complex biomolecular machines using single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (sm-FRET), a large flux of donor and acceptor photons is needed. To achieve such fluxes, one may use higher laser excitation intensity; however, this induces increased rates of photobleaching. Anti-oxidant additives have been extensively used for reducing acceptor's photobleaching. Here we focus on deciphering the initial step along the photobleaching pathway. Utilizing an array of recently developed single-molecule and ensemble spectroscopies and doubly labeled Acyl-CoA binding protein and double-stranded DNA as model systems, we study these photobleaching pathways, which place fundamental limitations on sm-FRET experiments. We find that: (i) acceptor photobleaching scales with FRET efficiency, (ii) acceptor photobleaching is enhanced under picosecond-pulsed (vs continuous-wave) excitation, and (iii) acceptor photobleaching scales with the intensity of only the short wavelength (donor) excitation laser. We infer from these findings that the main pathway for acceptor's photobleaching is through absorption of a short wavelength photon from the acceptor's first excited singlet state and that donor's photobleaching is usually not a concern. We conclude by suggesting the use of short pulses for donor excitation, among other possible remedies, for reducing acceptor's photobleaching in sm-FRET measurements.     

Separating structural heterogeneities from stochastic variations in fluorescence resonance energy transfer distributions via photon distribution analysis

We establish a probability distribution analysis (PDA) method for the analysis of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) signals to determine with high precision the originating value of a shot-noise-limited signal distribution. PDA theoretical distributions are calculated explicitly including crosstalk, stochastic variations, and background and represent the minimum width that a FRET distribution must have. In this way an unambiguous distinction is made between shot-noise distributions and distributions broadened by heterogeneities. This method simultaneously and effectively extracts highly resolved information from FRET distributions. The theoretical histograms match the exact profile of histograms generated from constant transfer efficiency experimental data with a chi2 near unity. The chi2 surface suggests an ultimate level of precision with FRET of < 1% of the F?rster radius. Distributions of FRET signals in donor-acceptor-labeled DNA were unambiguously identified as being broader than shot-noise variations could explain. A model describing a Gaussian distribution of distances was tested with the PDA method and demonstrated 5 A inhomogeneities due to dye motions. The capability of this method to recover quantitative information from FRET distributions has potential applications for studying molecular conformations and dynamics. Potential sources for artifacts such as acceptor photobleaching, spectrally different observation volumes, and fluctuations of the F?rster radius are ruled out.     

Multistep energy transfer in single molecular photonic wires

We demonstrate the synthesis and spectroscopic characterization of an unidirectional photonic wire based on four highly efficient fluorescence energy-transfer steps (FRET) between five spectrally different chromophores covalently attached to double-stranded DNA. The DNA-based modular conception enables the introduction of various chromophores at well-defined positions and arbitrary interchromophore distances. While ensemble fluorescence measurements show overall FRET efficiencies between 15 and 30%, single-molecule spectroscopy performed on four spectrally separated detectors easily uncovers subpopulations that exhibit overall FRET efficiencies of up to approximately 90% across a distance of 13.6 nm and a spectral range of approximately 200 nm. Fluorescence trajectories of individual photonic wires show five different fluorescence intensity patterns which can be ascribed to successive photobleaching events.     

Chemoenzymatic synthesis of a bifunctionalized cellohexaoside as a specific substrate for the sensitive assay of cellulase by fluorescence quenching

A new bifunctionalized cellohexaose derivative was synthesized as a specific substrate for continuous assay of cellulases by resonance energy transfer. This cellohexaoside has a naphthalene moiety (EDANS) as a fluorescent energy donor at the reducing end and a 4-(4'-dimethylaminobenzeneazo)-benzene derivative as an acceptor chromophore at the non-reducing end. The key steps for the preparation of the target molecule involved transglycosylation reactions of cellobiosyl and cellotetraosyl fluoride donors onto cellobiosyl acceptors catalysed by the E197A mutant of cellulase Cel7B from Humicola insolens. Upon digestion with various cellulases, the energy transfer was disrupted and an increase of fluorescence was observed.     

Possibilities for recycling cellulases after use in cotton processing: part II: Separation of cellulases from reaction products and released dyestuffs by ultrafiltration

The adsorption and activity of a total cellulase (Trichoderma reesei) was measured and compared on undyed and dyed cotton fabrics. Recovery of enzymes from the reaction mixture and by desorption from the cotton substrate was evaluated. About 80% of the initial protein could be recovered. The removal of released products (soluble reducing sugars and dyes) from the treatment liquor and subsequent concentration of cellulase proteins was performed using an ultrafiltration membrane. Strong protein-dye interactions made it impossible to separate efficiently the dyes from the enzyme-containing treatment liquors. The use of surfactants did not enhance cellulase desorption from cotton fabric. Although anionic surfactants have a deactivating effect on cellulases, this effect seems to be reversible, since after ultrafiltration the cellulase activity was similar to that of enzymes desorbed with buffer only. Humicola insolens cellulases were shown to be much more sensitive to anionic surfactant than T. reesei cellulases. The use of cellulases that bind reversibly to cellulose is suggested for achieving more efficient cellulase recycling and for reducing backstaining by dye-cellulase complexes.     

Quantitative FRET analysis with the EGFP-mCherry fluorescent protein pair

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between fluorescent proteins (FPs) is a powerful tool to investigate protein–protein interaction and even protein modifications in living cells. Here, we analyze the E⁰GFP-mCherry pair and show that it can yield a reproducible quantitative determination of the energy transfer efficiency both in vivo and in vitro . The photophysics of the two proteins is reported and shows good spectral overlap (Förster radius R ₀ = 51 Å), low crosstalk between acceptor and donor channels, and independence of the emission spectra from pH and halide ion concentration. Acceptor photobleaching (APB) and one- and two-photon fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) are used to quantitatively determine FRET efficiency values. A FRET standard is introduced based on a tandem construct comprising donor and acceptor together with a 20 amino acid long cleavable peptidic linker. Reference values are obtained via enzymatic cleavage of the linker and are used as benchmarks for APB and FLIM data. E⁰GFP-mCherry shows ideal properties for FLIM detection of FRET and yields high accuracy both in vitro and in vivo . Furthermore, the recently introduced phasor approach to FLIM is shown to yield straightforward and accurate two-photon FRET efficiency data even in suboptimal experimental conditions. The consistence of these results with the reference method (both in vitro and in vivo ) reveals that this new pair can be used for very effective quantitative FRET imaging.     

Studies of Thermobifida fusca plant cell wall degrading enzymes

SYNOPSIS: I have been studying the Thermobifida fusca cellulose degrading proteins for the past 25 years. In this period, we have purified and characterized the six extracellular cellulases and an intracellular beta- glucosidase used by T. fusca for cellulose degradation, cloned and sequenced the structural genes encoding these enzymes, and helped to determine the 3-dimensional structures of two of the cellulase catalytic domains. This research determined the mechanism of a novel class of cellulase, family 9 processive endoglucanases, and helped to show that there were two types of exocellulases, ones that attacked the non-reducing ends of cellulose and ones that attacked the reducing ends. It also led to the sequencing of the T. fusca genome by the DOE Joint Genome Institute. We have studied the mechanisms that regulate T. fusca cellulases and have shown that cellobiose is the inducer and that cellulase synthesis is repressed by any good carbon source. A regulatory protein (CelR) that functions in the induction control has been purified, characterized, and its structural gene cloned and expressed in E. coli. I have also carried out research on two rumen bacteria, Prevotella ruminicola and Fibrobacter succinogenes, in collaboration with Professor James Russell, helping to arrange for the genomes of these two organisms to be sequenced by TIGR, funded by a USDA grant to the North American Consortium for Genomics of Fibrolytic Ruminal Biology.     

Real-time observation of the swelling and hydrolysis of a single crystalline cellulose fiber catalyzed by cellulase 7B from Trichoderma reesei

The biodegradation of cellulose involves the enzymatic action of cellulases (endoglucanases), cellobiohydrolases (exoglucanases), and β-glucosidases that act synergistically. The rate and efficiency of enzymatic hydrolysis of crystalline cellulose in vitro decline markedly with time, limiting the large-scale, cost-effective production of cellulosic biofuels. Several factors have been suggested to contribute to this phenomenon, but there is considerable disagreement regarding the relative importance of each. These earlier investigations were hampered by the inability to observe the disruption of crystalline cellulose and its subsequent hydrolysis directly. Here, we show the application of high-resolution atomic force microscopy to observe the swelling of a single crystalline cellulose fiber and its-hydrolysis in real time directly as catalyzed by a single cellulase, the industrially important cellulase 7B from Trichoderma reesei. Volume changes, the root-mean-square roughness, and rates of hydrolysis of the surfaces of single fibers were determined directly from the images acquired over time. Hydrolysis dominated the early stage of the experiment, and swelling dominated the later stage. The high-resolution images revealed that the combined action of initial hydrolysis followed by swelling exposed individual microfibrils and bundles of microfibrils, resulting in the loosening of the fiber structure and the exposure of microfibrils at the fiber surface. Both the hydrolysis and swelling were catalyzed by the native cellulase; under the same conditions, its isolated carbohydrate-binding module did not cause changes to crystalline cellulose. We anticipate that the application of our AFM-based analysis on other cellulolytic enzymes, alone and in combination, will provide significant insight into the process of cellulose biodegradation and greatly facilitate its application for the efficient and economical production of cellulosic ethanol.     

A novel design method of ratiometric fluorescent probes based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer switching by spectral overlap integral

A ratiometric measurement, namely, simultaneous recording of the fluorescence intensities at two wavelengths and calculation of their ratio, allows greater precision than measurements at a single wavelength, and is suitable for cellular imaging studies. Here we describe a novel method of designing probes for ratiometric measurement of hydrolytic enzyme activity based on switching of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). This method employs fluorescent probes with a 3'-O,6'-O-protected fluorescein acceptor linked to a coumarin donor through a linker moiety. As there is no spectral overlap integral between the coumarin emission and fluorescein absorption, the fluorescein moiety cannot accept the excitation energy of the donor moiety and the donor fluorescence can be observed. After cleavage of the protective groups by hydrolytic enzymes, the fluorescein moiety shows a strong absorption in the coumarin emission region, and then acceptor fluorescence due to FRET is observed. Based on this mechanism, we have developed novel ratiometric fluorescent probes (1-3) for protein tyrosine phosphatase (PTP) activity. They exhibit a large shift in their emission wavelength after reaction with PTPs. The fluorescence quenching problem that usually occurs with FRET probes is overcome by using the coumarin-cyclohexane-fluorescein FRET cassette moiety, in which close contact of the two dyes is hindered. After study of their chemical and kinetic properties, we have concluded that compounds 1 and 2 bearing a rigid cyclohexane linker are practically useful for the ratiometric measurement of PTPs activity. The design concept described in this paper, using FRET switching by spectral overlap integral and a rigid link that prevents close contact of the two dyes, should also be applicable to other hydrolytic enzymes by introducing other appropriate enzyme-cleavable groups into the fluorescein acceptor.