Overloading of the second-dimension column in comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography

Comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC) is based on a coupling of two GC columns of different characteristics by means of a device that allows portions of the effluent from the primary column to be injected onto the second dimension column for an additional separation. The time available for the separation in the second-dimension column is very short. Thus, this separation should be very efficient. The vast majority of GC x GC practitioners use very narrow bore columns for the second dimension. While this approach is justified in principle, if peaks in the second dimension overload this column, its peak capacity is severely reduced. A series of second-dimension columns of varying internal diameters, but similar phase ratios, were used to study these effects. The results indicate that 250 microm columns often provide comparable second dimension peak widths to 100 microm columns, while at the same time being less prone to overloading, indicating that they may often be a better choice than smaller diameter columns in the second dimension of GC x GC systems.     

Rapid, high-resolution high-performance liquid chromatographic analysis of antibiotics

A HPLC column devised for high separation speed combined with highly practical operating features has been found useful for separating antibiotics. Important characteristics involve compromises in packing particle size, column configuration and support-stationary phase combinations. We determined that these columns are useful for rapid, high-resolution separations with unmodified state-of-the-art HPLC equipment without the extra-column band-broadening effects typical of so-called “fast” HPLC columns. The proposed columns feature efficient sterically-protected monofunctional silane stationary phases that provide good separation reproducibility and high column stability. The combination of these unique bonded silanes and a highly purified, less-acidic silica support give superior peak shapes for antibiotic compounds. The proposed column configuration can halve separation times and double peak heights without loss in resolution, compared to widely used analytical columns. Increased mobile phase flow-rates permit even faster separations of antibiotics with only modest loss in resolution and peak heights for trace analyses in biological systems.     

Stationary phase modulation in liquid chromatography through the serial coupling of columns: A review

Liquid chromatography with single columns often does not succeed in the analysis of complex samples, in terms of resolution and analysis time. A relatively simple solution to enhance chromatographic resolution is the modulation of the stationary phase through the serial coupling of columns. This can be implemented with any type of column using compatible elution conditions and conventional instruments. This review describes the key features of column coupling and published procedures, where two or more columns were coupled in series to solve separation problems. In all reports, the authors could not resolve their samples with single columns, whereas significant enhancement in chromatographic performance was obtained when the columns were combined. Particularly interesting is the reduction in the analysis time in the isocratic mode, which alleviates the “general elution problem” of liquid chromatography, and may represent a stimulus for the proposal of new procedures, especially in combination with mass spectrometric, electrochemical and refractometric detection. Developments proposed to make the serial coupling of columns useful in routine and research laboratories are outlined, including optimisation strategies that facilitate the selection of the appropriate column combination and elution conditions (solvent content, flow rate or temperature) in both isocratic and gradient modes. The availability of zero dead volume couplers, able to connect standard columns, and the commercialisation of short columns with multiple lengths, have expanded the possibilities of success.     

Comprehensive two‐dimensional monolithic liquid chromatography of polar compounds

Two‐dimensional liquid chromatography largely increases the number of separated compounds in a single run, theoretically up to the product of the peaks separated in each dimension on the columns with different selectivities. On‐line coupling of a reversed‐phase column with an aqueous normal‐phase (hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography) column yields orthogonal systems with high peak capacities. Fast on‐line two‐dimensional liquid chromatography needs a capillary or micro‐bore column providing low‐volume effluent fractions transferred to a short efficient second‐dimension column for separation at a high mobile phase flow rate. We prepared polymethacrylate zwitterionic monolithic micro‐columns in fused silica capillaries with structurally different dimethacrylate cross‐linkers. The columns provide dual retention mechanism (hydrophilic interaction and reversed‐phase). Setting the mobile phase composition allows adjusting the separation selectivity for various polar substance classes. Coupling on‐line an organic polymer monolithic capillary column in the first dimension with a short silica‐based monolithic column in the second dimension provides two‐dimensional liquid chromatography systems with high peak capacities. The silica monolithic C₁₈ columns provide higher separation efficiency than the particle‐packed columns at the flow rates as high as 5 mL/min used in the second dimension. Decreasing the diameter of the silica monolithic columns allows using a higher flow rate at the maximum operation pressure and lower fraction volumes transferred from the first, hydrophilic interaction dimension, into the second, reversed‐phase mode, avoiding the mobile phase compatibility issues, improving the resolution, increasing the peak capacity, and the peak production rate.     

Theoretical background of short chromatographic layers. Optimization of gradient elution in short columns

Although linear salt gradient elution ion-exchange chromatography (IEC) of proteins is commonly carried out with relatively short columns, it is still not clear how the column length affects the separation performance and the economics of the process. The separation performance can be adjusted by changing a combination of the column length, the gradient slope and the flow velocity. The same resolution can be obtained with a given column length with different combinations of the gradient slope and the flow velocity. This results in different separation time and elution volume at the same resolution. Based on our previous model, a method for determining the separation time and the elution volume relationship for the same resolution (iso-resolution curve) was developed. The effect of the column length and the mass transfer rate on the iso-resolution curve was examined. A long column and/or high mass transfer rate results in lesser elution volume. The resolution data with porous bead packed columns and monolithic columns were in good agreement with the calculated iso-resolution curves. Although the elution volume can be reduced with increasing column length, the pressure drop limits govern the optimum conditions.     

Comparison of different types of stationary phases for the analysis of soy isoflavones by HPLC

Nowadays, there are new technologies in high-performance liquid chromatography columns available enabling faster and more efficient separations. In this work, we compared three different types of columns for the analysis of main soy isoflavones. The evaluated columns were a conventional reverse phase particle column, a fused-core particle column, and a monolithic column. The comparison was in terms of chromatographic parameters such as resolution, asymmetry, number of theoretical plates, variability of retention time, and peak width. The lower column pressure was provided by the monolithic column, although lower chromatographic performance was achieved. Conventional and fused-core particle columns presented similar pressure. Results also indicate that direct transfer between particle and monolithic columns is not possible requiring adjustment of conditions and a different method optimization strategy. The best chromatographic performance and separation speed were observed for the fused-core particle column. Also, the effect of sample solvent on the separation and peak shape was evaluated and indicated that monolithic column is the most affected especially when using higher concentrations of acetonitrile or ethanol. Sample solvent that showed the lowest effect on the chromatographic performance of the columns was methanol. Overall evaluation of methanol and acetonitrile as mobile phase for the separation of isoflavones indicated higher chromatographic performance of acetonitrile, although methanol may be an attractive alternative. Using acetonitrile as mobile phase resulted in faster, higher resolution, narrower, and more symmetric peaks than methanol with all columns. It also generated the lower column pressure and flatter pressure profile due to mobile phase changes, and therefore, it presents a higher potential to be explored for the development of faster separation methods.     

Separation of phenol‐containing pyrolysis products using comprehensive two‐dimensional chromatography with columns based on pyridinium ionic liquids

We describe the application of columns with highly polar stationary liquid phases based on pyridinium ionic liquids for the two‐dimensional chromatography separation of bio‐oil and product of coal pyrolysis. By using inverse combination columns—a first ionic liquid column and a second nonpolar column—good separation results have been obtained. In the analysis of coal pyrolysis products, the suggested approach provides a much better resolution between components in comparison with a less polar first‐dimension column (based on polyethylene glycol). A good selectivity for the peaks of phenols is observed, and the group of phenols is well detached and separated from the group of diaromatics. A good separation picture was obtained also for bio‐oil, the groups of phenols and guaiacol derivatives are distinguished with good resolution of substances within each group.     

In situ fabrication of microporous organic network coated capillary column for high resolution gas chromatographic separation of hydrocarbons

Microporous organic networks (MONs) are a new class of porous materials synthesized via Sonogashira coupling reactions between organic building blocks. Here we report an in situ synthesis approach to fabricate MONs coated capillary column for high resolution GC separation of hydrocarbons. The McReynolds constant evaluation reveals the MONs coated capillary is a non‐polar column. The MONs coated capillary column shows good resolution for GC separation of diverse important industrial hydrocarbons such as linear and branched alkanes, alkylbenzenes, pinene isomers, ethylbenzene and styrene, cyclohexane and benzene. The MONs coated capillary column gave a high column efficiency of 1542 plates per meter for hexane and good precision for replicate separations of the selected hydrocarbons with the RSDs of 0.2–0.3, 1.5–3.1, and 1.9–3.3% for retention time, peak height and peak area, respectively. The MONs coated capillary also offered better resolution than commercial Inert Cap‐1 and Inert Cap‐5 capillary columns for hexane and heptane isomers. These results reveal the potential of MONs as novel stationary phases in GC.     

Separation of intact proteins on γ‐ray‐induced polymethacrylate monolithic columns: A highly permeable stationary phase with high peak capacity for capillary high‐performance liquid chromatography with high‐resolution mass spectrometry

Polymethacrylate‐based monolithic capillary columns, prepared by γ‐radiation‐induced polymerization, were used to optimize the experimental conditions (nature of the organic modifiers, the content of trifluoroacetic acid and the column temperature) in the separation of nine standard proteins with different hydrophobicities and a wide range of molecular weights. Because of the excellent permeability of the monolithic columns, an ion‐pair reversed‐phase capillary liquid chromatography with high‐resolution mass spectrometry method has been developed by coupling the column directly to the mass spectrometer without a flow‐split and using a standard electrospray interface. Additionally, the high working flow and concomitant high efficiency of these columns allowed us to employ a longer column (up to 50 cm) and achieve a peak capacity value superior to 1000. This work is motivated by the need to develop new materials for high‐resolution chromatographic separation that combine chemical stability at elevated temperatures (up to 75°C) and a broad pH range, with a high peak capacity value. The advantage of the γ‐ray‐induced monolithic column lies in the batch‐to‐batch reproducibility and long‐term high‐temperature stability. Their proven high loading capacity, recovery, good selectivity and high permeability, moreover, compared well with that of a commercially available poly(styrene‐divinylbenzene) monolithic column, which confirms that such monolithic supports might facilitate analysis in proteomics.     

Probability theory for number of mixture components resolved by n independent columns

A general theory is proposed for the probability of different outcomes of success and failure of component resolution, when complex mixtures are partially separated by n independent columns. Such a separation is called an n-column separation. An outcome of particular interest is component resolution by at least one column. Its probability is identified with the probability of component resolution by a single column, thereby defining the effective saturation of the n-column separation. Several trends are deduced from limiting expressions of the effective saturation. In particular, at low saturation the probability that components cluster together as unresolved peaks decreases exponentially with the number of columns, and the probability that components cluster together on addition of another column decreases by a factor equal to twice the column saturation. The probabilities of component resolution by n-column and two-dimensional separations also are compared. The theory is applied by interpreting three sets of previously reported retention indices of the 209 polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), as determined by GC. The origin of column independence is investigated from two perspectives. First, it is suggested that independence exists when the difference between indices of the same compound on two columns is much larger than the interval between indices required for separation. Second, it is suggested that independence exists when the smaller of the two intervals between a compound and its adjacent neighbors is not correlated with its counterpart on another column.     

Separation of positional isomers by the use of coupled shape-selective stationary phase columns

The successful separation of 2- and 3-methyl-substituted positional isomers of butanol, butyl acetate, and butanoic acid and its ethyl ester, is reported. These compounds are of interest in the study of wine flavour, however the separation of the 2- and 3-methyl isomers may present problems, and more so in the presence of the wine matrix components, when single capillary column gas chromatography (GC) is used. The strategy to achieve separation was based on the use of shape-selective cyclodextrin derivative (CDD) capillary columns (commonly referred to as chiral columns). These columns provide simultaneous resolution of the enantiomeric pairs of the 2-methyl isomers, and at the same time the ability to separate the 3-methyl isomer from the 2-methyl is achieved in all but the case of the ( S)-2- and 3-methylbutanol. The advantages of using shape-selective columns to perform this study is demonstrated, with coupling of two CDD columns giving improved separations of these compounds. Although these compounds are relatively volatile, cryogenic modulated comprehensive two-dimensional GC was shown to provide good pulsed peak profiles with chiral separation in the first dimension when a thicker film trapping column segment was employed. The components of interest were well separated from other wine matrix components.     

Selectivity differences for C18 and C8 reversed-phase columns as a function of temperature and gradient steepness. II. Minimizing column reproducibility problems

The choice of T and tG as variables for controlling selectivity and resolution during reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) method development can be used to minimize problems caused by column batch-to-batch irreproducibility. When a new column fails to provide adequate separation of the sample, altered values of T and tG can be predicted that will restore the separation obtained with the previous column. Alternatively, columns from different manufacturers can be tested during method development, in order to find a common set of conditions (T and tG) that provide acceptable separation with two or more of these columns. In this way, any of several columns from different sources become usable for the method. Examples are shown of these different computer-assisted procedures for minimizing problems due to column variability.     

Effect of first-dimension column film thickness on comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatographic separation

In comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC), samples experience two-dimensional separation implemented by a modulator which helps preserve the first-dimension separation and facilitates the second-dimension separation by periodically collecting, focusing and launching the material from the primary column onto the secondary column with a different stationary phase. Column overloading in GC x GC is a considerable problem, aggravated by the fact that two columns are involved. Broad first-dimension peaks of an analyte help produce smaller fractions of the analyte in the second-dimension, reducing the chance of secondary column overloading. One of the means to generate broad peaks in the first-dimension is to use thick film primary columns. A series of primary columns of various film thickness were tested in the study, and the results indicate that when other conditions are kept constant, 1 microm film columns often provide better resolution in both first and second-dimension but at the expense of a much longer separation time; 0.1 microm is clearly inadequate for GC x GC separation; 0.5 and 0.25 microm film columns seem to be the best compromises.     

Effect of chromatographic conditions on resolution in high-performance ion-exchange chromatography of proteins on macroporous anion-exchange resin

We explored chromatographic conditions to obtain high resolution in protein separations by ion-exchange chromatography (IEC) on a macroporous anion-exchange resin of 10 microm in particle diameter. We studied effects of flow-rate, gradient time (steepness of salt concentration gradient) and column length on resolution in wide ranges. It was found that very high resolutions are attainable at long gradient times with long columns. The resolution continuously became higher as the gradient time and the column length became longer except in some special cases. The dependence of resolution on gradient time was particularly great when the column was long and the gradient time for the change of 0-0.5 M NaCl was longer than 2 h. On the other hand, the effect of flow-rate on resolution was very small. Although the separations at long gradient times with long columns have not been popular in high-performance IEC and it takes several hours for one separation, such separations should be advantageous when very high resolutions are required like in proteomics research.     

Chromatographic separation of simulants of nerve and blister agents by combining one‐ and two‐channel columns with different stationary phases

A two‐channel gas chromatography column and a single‐channel column were made by deep reactive‐ion etching technology. The two short columns were coated with different stationary phases, and then linked without a modulator. This is to aim at increasing the sample capacity and achieving a higher separation efficiency in complex environments. The results show that the capacity of the connected column is approximately 4 and 1.5 times larger than that of the single‐ and two‐channel columns, respectively. The linked column was utilized to separate a six‐component mixture, composed of three simulants of nerve and blister agents and three interfering vapors. The results demonstrate that the combined column has a remarkably higher separation efficiency than the individual columns, and an acceptable resolution is achieved although the total length of the linked column is only 1.5 m.     

Serially coupled capillary columns supercritical fluid chromatography with midpoint pressure control

Two capillary columns of different polarities were coupled in series by means of a coupling restrictor. The pressure of the first column and the midpoint pressure (between the coupling restrictor and the second column) were controlled independently of each other using two pumps. The selectivity of this separation system was highly dependent on the pressure difference and could be continuously changed between those of two columns. The pressure difference could be changed even in course of separation for fine tuning of the selectivity. Several examples were shown to demonstrate the utility of this method.     

Development of a fritless packed column for capillary electrochromatography-mass spectrometry

A novel procedure was developed for the fabrication of a fritless packed column for the coupling of capillary electrochromatography (CEC) to mass spectrometry (MS). The process involved the formation of internal tapers on two separate columns. Once the internal tapers are formed and the columns are packed, the untapered ends of each column were joined together by a commercially available connector. Several advantages of the fritless columns are described. First, the design used here eventually eliminates the need for any frits thus reducing the possibility of bubble formation seen with fritted packed columns. In addition, this is the first report in which the internal tapers are formed at both the inlet and outlet column ends making the fritless CEC-MS column more robust compared to only one report with externally tapered counterparts. Second, a comparison of internally tapered single frit packed CEC-MS (previously developed in our laboratory) column versus fritless CEC-MS column reported here shows that the latter provides better efficiency, suggesting no dead volume with equally good sensitivity and chiral resolution of (±)-aminoglutethimide. The fritless column procedure is universal and was used to prepare a series of columns with a variety of commercially available packing material (mixed mode strong cation exchange, SCX; mixed mode strong anion exchange, SAX; C-18) for the separation and MS detection of short chain non-chromophoric polar amines, long chain nonchromophic anionic surfactant as well as oligomers of non-chromophoric non-ionic surfactants, respectively. The fritless columns showed good intra-day repeatability and inter-day reproducibility of retention times, chiral and achiral resolutions and peak areas. Very satisfactory column-to-column and operator-to-operator reproducibility was demonstrated.     

Large diameter open tubular columns in gas chromatographic analysis

Large diameter open tubular columns provide the packed column chromatographer with a simple route to higher resolution gas chromatography. They can be operated in a high-flow (lower resolution) mode that permits their direct substitution for a packed column, or they can be operated in a low-flow (higher resolution) mode that maximizes separation at the cost of longer analysis times. Inlet design and column installation can influence both the chromatographic results and quantiative reliability. Make-up gas is not required in the high-flow mode, and its benefits in the low-flow mode are restricted to enhanced detector sensitivity, provided the outlet end of the column resides in the detector jet (FID). The columns seem fully compatible with all common modes of detection.     

Evaluation of chromatographic columns packed with semi‐ and fully porous particles for benzimidazoles separation

The behavior of 15 benzimidazoles, including their main metabolites, using several C₁₈ columns with standard or narrow‐bore diameters and different particle size and type were evaluated. These commercial columns were selected because their differences could affect separation of benzimidazoles, and so they can be used as alternative columns. A simple screening method for the analysis of benzimidazole residues and their main metabolites was developed. First, the separation of benzimidazoles was optimized using a Kinetex C₁₈ column; later, analytical performances of other columns using the above optimized conditions were compared and then individually re‐optimized. Critical pairs resolution, analysis run time, column type and characteristics, and selectivity were considered for chromatographic columns comparison. Kinetex XB was selected because it provides the shortest analysis time and the best resolution of critical pairs. Using this column, the separation conditions were re‐optimized using a factorial design. Separations obtained with the different columns tested can be applied to the analysis of specific benzimidazoles residues or other applications.     

Towards a comprehensive 2-D-LC-MS separation

A comprehensive 2-D-LC-MS method has been developed by coupling columns of different selectivity. The primary column eluate is alternately trapped and sampled onto the secondary columns through a guard column interface. When one guard column traps the eluate, the other injects the previously trapped components onto a secondary column. This cycle is repeated throughout the chromatogram. The use of dual secondary columns provides the secondary columns with additional time to generate high-speed chromatograms. Each secondary column generates alternate chromatograms which when combined generate the entire chromatogram. The primary column separation is comparable to conventional HPLC, whereas the secondary column separation is fast. With both the columns operating in reverse phase mode, one would expect strong correlation in the two-dimensional retention and hence inefficiency in separation. However, differences in column operation modes, interaction mechanisms, and vendor silica result in a complementary separation. The system was evaluated by comparing it to one-dimensional counterparts and coupled column chromatography. Although some correlations were observed in 2-D-LC-MS, peaks do show two-dimensional distribution with superior UV and MS data as co-elution is minimized. Also, the ease of converting conventional systems to 2-D-LC-MS is discussed.