Probing the kinetic performance limits for ion chromatography. I. Isocratic conditions for small ions

The first use of the kinetic plot method to characterise the performance of ion-exchange columns for separations of small inorganic anions is reported. The influence of analyte type (mono- and divalent), particle size (5 and 9 μm), temperature (30 and 60 °C) and maximum pressure drop upon theoretical extrapolations was investigated using data collected from anion-exchange polymeric particulate columns. The quality of extrapolations was found to depend upon the choice of analyte, but could be verified by coupling a series of columns to demonstrate some practical solutions for ion chromatography separations requiring relatively high efficiency. Separations of small anions yielding 25–40,000 theoretical plates using five serially connected columns (9 μm particles) were obtained and yielded deviations of <15% from the kinetic plot predictions. While this approach for achieving high efficiencies results in a very long analysis time (t₀ = 21 min), separations yielding approximately 10,000 theoretical plates using two serially connected columns (t₀ < 5 min) were shown to be more practically useful for isocratic separations when compared to use of a single column operated at optimum linear velocity (t₀ > 10 min).     

Probing the kinetic performance limits for ion chromatography. II. Gradient conditions for small ions

A gradient kinetic plot method is used for theoretical characterisation of the performance of polymeric particulate anion exchange columns for gradient separations of small inorganic anions. The method employed requires only information obtained from a series of isocratic column performance measurements and in silico predictions of retention time and peak width under gradient conditions. Results obtained under practically constrained conditions provide parameters for the generation of high peak capacities and rapid peak production for fast analysis to be determined. Using this prediction method, a maximum theoretical peak capacity of 84 could be used to achieve separation of 26 components using a 120 min gradient (R_s > 1). This approach provides a highly convenient tool for development of both mono- and multidimensional ion chromatography (IC) methodologies as it yields comprehensive understanding of the influence of gradient slope, analysis time, column length and temperature upon kinetically optimised gradient performance.     

Some solutions to obtain very efficient separations in isocratic and gradient modes using small particles size and ultra-high pressure

The UHPLC strategy which combines sub-2 μm porous particles and ultra-high pressure (>1000 bar) was investigated considering very high resolution criteria in both isocratic and gradient modes, with mobile phase temperatures between 30 and 90 °C. In isocratic mode, experimental conditions to reach the maximal efficiency were determined using the kinetic plot representation for ΔP_max = 1000 bar. It has been first confirmed that the molecular weight of the compounds (MW) was a critical parameter which should be considered in the construction of such curves. With a MW around 1000 g mol⁻¹, efficiencies as high as 300,000 plates could be theoretically attained using UHPLC at 30 °C. By limiting the column length to 450 mm, the maximal plate count was around 100,000. In gradient mode, the longest column does not provide the maximal peak capacity for a given analysis time in UHPLC. This was attributed to the fact that peak capacity is not only related to the plate number but also to column dead time. Therefore, a compromise should be found and a 150 mm column should be preferentially selected for gradient lengths up to 60 min at 30 °C, while the columns coupled in series (3× 150 mm) were attractive only for t_grad > 250 min. Compared to 30 °C, peak capacities were increased by about 20–30% for a constant gradient length at 90 °C and gradient time decreased by 2-fold for an identical peak capacity.     

Towards a solution for viscous heating in ultra-high pressure liquid chromatography using intermediate cooling

A generic solution is proposed for the deleterious viscous heating effects in adiabatic or near-adiabatic systems that can be expected when trying to push the column operating pressures above the currently available range of ultra-high pressures (i.e., 1200 bar). A set of proof-of-principle experiments, mainly using existing commercial equipment, is presented. The solution is based on splitting up a column with given length L into n segments with length L/n, and providing an active cooling to the capillaries connecting the segments. In this way, the viscous heat is removed at a location where the radial heat removal does not lead to an efficiency loss (i.e., in the thin connection capillaries), while the column segments can be operated under near-adiabatic conditions without suffering from an unacceptable rise of the mobile phase temperature. Experimental results indicate that the column segmentation does not lead to a significant efficiency loss (comparing the performance of a 10 cm column with a 2 cm × 5 cm column system), whereas, as expected, the system displays a much improved temperature stability, both in time (because of the shortened temperature transient times) and in space (reduction of the average axial temperature rise by a factor n). The method also prevents a large backflow of heat along the column wall that would lead to large efficiency losses if one would attempt to operate columns at pressures of 1500 bar or more. A real-world pharmaceutical example is given where this improved temperature robustness could help in moderating the changes in selectivity during method transfer from a low to a high pressure operation, although the complex non-linear behavior of the viscous heating and high pressure effects result in lower than expected improvement.     

Characterization of new types of stationary phases for fast and ultra-fast liquid chromatography by signal processing based on AutoCovariance Function: A case study of application to Passiflora incarnata L. extract separations

In this study, a comparative investigation was performed of HPLC Ascentis^® (2.7 μm particles) columns based on fused-core particle technology and Acquity^® (1.7 μm particles) columns requiring UPLC instruments, in comparison with Chromolith™ RP-18e columns. The study was carried out on mother and vegetal tinctures of Passiflora incarnata L. on one single or two coupled columns. The fundamental attributions of the chromatographic profiles are evaluated using a chemometric procedure, based on the AutoCovariance Function (ACVF). Different chromatographic systems are compared in terms of their separation parameters, i.e., number of total chemical components (m_tot), separation efficiency (σ), peak capacity (n_c), overlap degree of peaks and peak purity. The obtained results show the improvements achieved by HPLC columns with narrow size particles in terms of total analysis time and chromatographic efficiency: comparable performance are achieved by Ascentis^® (2.7 μm particle) column and Acquity^® (1.7 μm particle) column requiring UPLC instruments. The ACVF plot is proposed as a simplified tool describing the chromatographic fingerprint to be used for evaluating and comparing chemical composition of plant extracts by using the parameters D% – relative abundance of the deterministic component – and c_EACF – similarity index computed on ACVF.     

Practical assessment of frictional heating effects and thermostat design on the performance of conventional (3 μm and 5 μm) columns in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography

A practical investigation of frictional heating effects in conventional C18 columns was undertaken, to investigate whether problems found for sub-2 μm columns were also present for those of particle size 3 μm and 5 μm and different internal diameter. The influence of a water bath, a still air heater, and a forced air heater on performance was investigated. Heating effects were substantial, with a decrease in k of almost 15% for toluene over the flow rate range ∼0.4–2.3 mL/min with a 15 cm × 0.46 cm ID column packed with 3 μm particles. Heating effects on retention increased with increasing solute k, with increase in the column ID, with decrease in the column particle size, and with decrease in the set column oven temperature. While the water bath minimised axial temperature gradients and thus its effect on k, radial temperature gradients were potentially serious with this system, especially at high mobile phase velocity, even with columns containing 5 μm particles. In contrast to the effects of axial temperature gradients in 4.6 mm columns, very little difference in Van Deemter plots was noted between the three different thermostats with 2 mm ID columns, even when 3 μm particles were used. However, the efficiency of 2 mm columns for peaks of low or moderate k (k < 4) can be compromised by the extra dead volume introduced by the heating systems, even with conventional HPLC systems with otherwise minimised extra column volume.     

Repeatability in column preparation of a reversed-phase C18 monolith and its application to separation of tocopherol homologues

This work investigated the repeatability of column preparation for a reversed-phase C18 monolith, namely stearyl methacrylate-co-ethylene glycol dimethacrylate (SMA-EDMA). The columns were thermally polymerised using three commonly available heating devices (GC oven, hot air oven and water bath) and their chromatographic performance evaluated using micro-liquid chromatography for separation of five test compounds. Precision in terms of %RSD of retention times were 9.0, 6.5, and 12.5 using GC oven, hot air oven and water bath, respectively. Between-batch precision for the hot air oven (n = 3 days) was less than 10.4% for retention time. The SMA-EDMA monolith was applied to the separation of tocopherol homologues by capillary electrochromatography. Usually tocopherol homologues cannot be completely separated by conventional reversed-phase C8- or C18-packed bed or C18-silica based monolithic columns. Polymer monolith has been shown to give remarkable selectivity towards the tocopherols compared to the conventional microparticulate phase and silica based monolith. Successful separation of the tocopherol isomers was achieved on the SMA-EDMA monolith without any column modification.     

Improvement of separation efficiencies of anion-exchange chromatography using monolithic silica capillary columns modified with polyacrylates and polymethacrylates containing tertiary amino or quaternary ammonium groups

Anion-exchange (AEX) columns were prepared by on-column polymerization of acrylates and methacrylates containing tertiary amino or quaternary ammonium groups on monolithic silica in a fused silica capillary modified with anchor groups. The columns provided a plate height (H) of less than 10 μm at optimum linear velocity (u) with keeping their high permeability (K = 9–12 × 10⁻¹⁴ m²). Among seven kinds of AEX columns, a monolithic silica column modified with poly(2-hydroxy-3-(4-methylpiperazin-1-yl)propyl methacrylates) (HMPMA) showed larger retentions and better selectivities for nucleotides and inorganic anions than the others. The HMPMA column of 410 mm length produced 42 000–55 000 theoretical plates (N) at a linear velocity of 0.97 mm/s with a backpressure of 3.8 MPa. The same column could be employed for a fast separation of inorganic anions in 1.8 min at a linear velocity of 5.3 mm/s with a backpressure of 20 MPa. In terms of van Deemter plot and separation impedance, the HMPMA column showed higher performance than a conventional particle-packed AEX column. The HMPMA column showed good recovery of a protein, trypsin inhibitor, and it was applied to the separation of proteins and tryptic digest of bovine serum albumin (BSA) in a gradient elution, to provide better separation compared to a conventional particle-packed AEX column.     

Fast gradient screening of pharmaceuticals with 5 cm long, narrow bore reversed-phase columns packed with sub-3 μm core-shell and sub-2 μm totally porous particles

The performance of 5 cm long narrow-bore columns packed with 2.6-2.7 μm core-shell particles and a column packed with 1.7 μm totally porous particles was compared in very fast gradient separations of polar neutral active pharmaceutical compounds. Peak capacities as a function of flow-rate and gradient time were measured. Peak capacities around 160-170 could be achieved within 25 min with these 5 cm long columns. The highest peak capacity was obtained with the Kinetex column however it was found that as the flow-rate increases, the peak capacity of the new Poroshell-120 column is getting closer to that obtained with the Kinetex column. Considering the column permeability, peak capacity per unit time and per unit pressure was also calculated. In this comparison the advantage of sub-3 μm core-shell particles is more significant compared to sub-2 μm totally porous particles. Moreover it was found that the very similar sized (d_p = 2.7 μm) and structured (ρ = 0.63) new Poroshell-120 and the earlier introduced Ascentis Express particles showed different efficiency. Results obtained showed that the 5 cm long narrow bore columns packed with sub-3 μm core-shell particles offer the chance of very fast and efficient gradient separations, thus these columns can be applied for fast screening measurements of routine pharmaceutical analysis such as cleaning validation.     

Use of a polar ionic liquid as second column for the comprehensive two-dimensional GC separation of PCBs

The orthogonality of three columns coupled in two series was studied for the congener specific comprehensive two-dimensional GC separation of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). A non-polar capillary column coated with poly(5%-phenyl–95%-methyl)siloxane was used as the first (¹D) column in both series. A polar capillary column coated with 70% cyanopropyl-polysilphenylene-siloxane or a capillary column coated with the ionic liquid 1,12-di(tripropylphosphonium)dodecane bis(trifluoromethane-sulfonyl)imide were used as the second (²D) columns. Nine multi-congener standard PCB solutions containing subsets of all native 209 PCBs, a mixture of 209 PCBs as well as Aroclor 1242 and 1260 formulations were used to study the orthogonality of both column series. Retention times of the corresponding PCB congeners on ¹D and ²D columns were used to construct retention time dependences (apex plots) for assessing orthogonality of both columns coupled in series. For a visual assessment of the peak density of PCBs congeners on a retention plane, 2D images were compared. The degree of orthogonality of both column series was, along the visual assessment of distribution of PCBs on the retention plane, evaluated also by Pearson's correlation coefficient, which was found by correlation of retention times t_R,i,2D and t_R,i,1D of corresponding PCB congeners on both column series. It was demonstrated that the apolar + ionic liquid column series is almost orthogonal both for the 2D separation of PCBs present in Aroclor 1242 and 1260 formulations as well as for the separation of all of 209 PCBs. All toxic, dioxin-like PCBs, with the exception of PCB 118 that overlaps with PCB 106, were resolved by the apolar/ionic liquid series while on the apolar/polar column series three toxic PCBs overlapped (105 + 127, 81 + 148 and 118 + 106).     

Comparative study of new shell-type,sub-2 μm fully porous and monolith stationary phases,focusing on mass-transfer resistance

Today sub-2 μm packed columns are very popular to conduct fast chromatographic separations. The mass-transfer resistance depends on the particle size but some practical limits exist not to reach the theoretically expected plate height and mass-transfer resistance. Another approach applies particles with shortened diffusion path to enhance the efficiency of separations. In this study a systematical evaluation of the possibilities of the separations obtained with 5 cm long narrow bore columns packed with new 2.6 μm shell particles (1.9 μm nonporous core surrounded by a 0.35 μm porous shell, Kinetex™, Core-Shell), packed with other shell-type particles (Ascentis Express™, Fused-Core), totally porous sub-2 μm particles and a 5 cm long narrow bore monolith column is presented. The different commercially available columns were compared by using van Deemter, Knox and kinetic plots. Theoretical Poppe plots were constructed for each column to compare their kinetic performance. Data are presented on polar neutral real-life analytes. Comparison of a low molecular weight compounds (MW = 270–430) and a high molecular weight one (MW ∼ 900) was conducted. This study proves that the Kinetex column packed with 2.6 μm shell particles is worthy of rivaling to sub-2 μm columns and other commercially available shell-type packings (Ascentis Express or Halo), both for small and large molecule separation. The Kinetex column offers a very flat C term. Utilizing this feature, high flow rates can be applied to accomplish very fast separations without significant loss in efficiency.     

Kinetic performance optimisation for liquid chromatography: principles and practice

This HPLC tutorial focuses on the preparation and use of kinetic plots to characterise the performance in isocratic and gradient LC. This graphical approach allows the selection of columns (i.e. optimum particle size and column length) and LC conditions (operating pressure and temperature) to generate a specific number of plates or peak capacity in the shortest possible analysis time. Instrument aspects including the influence of extra-column effects (maximum allowable system volume) and thermal operating conditions (oven type) on performance are discussed. In addition, the performance characteristics of porous-shell particle-packed columns and monolithic stationary phases are presented and the potential of future column designs is discussed.     

Separation of intact proteins on porous layer open tubular (PLOT) columns

Porous layer open tubular (PLOT) polystyrene divinylbenzene columns have been used for separating intact proteins with gradient elution. The 10 μm I.D. × 3 m columns were easily coupled to standard liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry (LC–MS) instrumentation with commercially available fittings. Standard proteins separated on PLOT columns appeared as narrow and symmetrical peaks with good resolution. Average peak width increased linearly with gradient time (t_G) from 0.14 to 0.33 min (t_G 20 and 120 min, respectively) using a 3 m column. With shorter columns, peak widths were larger and increased more steeply with gradient time. Theoretical peak capacity (n_c) increased with column length (tested up to 3 m). The n_c increased with t_G until a plateau was reached. The highest peak capacity achieved (n_c = 185) was obtained with a 3 m column, where a plateau was reached with t_G 90 min. The within- and between column retention time repeatabilities were below 0.6% and below 2.5% (relative standard deviation, RSD), respectively. The carry-over following injection of 0.5 ng per protein was less than 1.1%. The retention time dependence on column temperature was investigated in the range 20–50 °C. Proteins in a skimmed milk sample were separated using the method.     

Kinetic performance appraisal of poly(styrene-co-divinylbenzene) monolithic high-performance liquid chromatography columns for biomolecule analysis

A broad appraisal of the kinetic performance of organic polymeric monolithic columns is reported using commercially available poly(styrene-co-divinylbenzene) monolithic columns (Dionex ProSwift™ RP-1S). Analysis of a protein digest sample at elevated temperatures (≥80 °C) indicated no apparent analyte degradation using an inert polymeric stationary phase. Comparison between low molecular weight solute and peptide separations highlighted the markedly different mass transport processes observed on macroporous monolithic beds and an improved C term at elevated temperature in both instances. The current usefulness of this column format for biomolecule analysis was further studied via employment of a kinetic performance characterisation for the first time to provide direction for column development servicing this application.     

Kinetic performance of reversed-phase C18 high-performance liquid chromatography columns compared by means of the Kinetic Plot Method in pharmaceutically relevant applications

Four fully porous C18 columns (Hypersil Gold, ACE3, Xbridge and Gemini NX), widely employed in the pharmaceutical industry, were compared in terms of efficiency and analysis speed with the Kinetic Plot Method. Weakly basic, medium-sized, N-containing pharmaceutical compounds from GlaxoSmithKline Research and Development were used as test molecules. Isocratic elution was carried out at pH 4.5 and pH 8.0 with acetonitrile as organic modifier. The columns under evaluation included highly pure silica supports (Hypersil Gold, ACE3) and hybrid polymer-silica supports (XBridge, Gemini NX). Both types of columns claim for nearly absent secondary interactions with ionized silanol groups and are therefore applicable in a wide pH range. This is an important feature for method development purposes in pharmaceutical industries. The Kinetic Plot Method was used to compare the support characteristics and assess the kinetic performance of the columns in different experimental conditions. Although the evaluated columns have roughly identical particle diameters (from 3.0 to 3.5 μm) according to their manufacturers, large differences in kinetic performance were observed at pH 4.5 that can be accounted for by different flow resistances, porosities and average particle diameters, experimentally determined from scanning electron microscopy and laser light scattering experiments on loose stationary phase material. The ACE3 column was the best performing support among the evaluated columns, due to its excellent efficiency and average flow resistance. The better performance of the ACE3 column was due to its better packing quality, as could be derived from its impedance plot. Kinetic plots of resolution of a critical pair versus analysis time and column length were established at pH 8.0. These plots can be used as a method development tool to tailor the separation conditions to the required resolution of a given critical pair, combining efficiency and selectivity features of the column.     

Effects of pressure drop,particle size and thermal conditions on retention and efficiency in supercritical fluid chromatography

The effects of particle size and thermal insulation on retention and efficiency in packed-column supercritical fluid chromatography with large pressure drops are described for the separation of a series of model n-alkane solutes. The columns were 2.0 mm i.d. × 150 mm long and were packed with 3, 5, or 10-μm porous octylsilica particles. Separations were performed with pure carbon dioxide at 50 °C at average mobile phase densities of 0.47 g/mL (107 bar) and 0.70 g/mL (151 bar). The three principal causes of band broadening were the normal dispersion processes described by the van Deemter equation, changes in the retention factor due to the axial density gradient, and radial temperature gradients associated with expansion of the mobile phase. At the lower density the use of thermal insulation resulted in significant improvements in efficiency and decreased retention times at large pressure drops. The effects are attributed to the elimination of radial temperature gradients and the concurrent enhancement of the axial temperature gradient. Thermal insulation had no significant effect on chromatographic performance at the higher density. A simple expression to predict the onset of excess efficiency loss due to the radial temperature gradient is proposed.     

Semi-micro-monolithic columns using macroporous silica rods with improved performance

Monolithic silica columns in semi-micro-format have been synthesized using poly(acrylic acid) as a phase-separation inducer via a sol–gel route. The absence of a thick skin layer accompanied by deformation of the micrometer-sized gelling skeletons on the outermost part of the macroporous silica rod contributed to improve the efficiency of monolithic silica columns as thick as 2.4 mm in diameter. The kinetic plot analysis revealed that monolithic silica columns with macropore diameter of 1 μm and skeleton thickness of 1 μm with decreased macroporosity behave similarly to columns packed with 3 μm particles with slightly lower back pressure.     

High-efficiency hydrophilic interaction chromatography by coupling 25 cm × 4.6 mm ID × 5 μm silica columns and operation at 80 °C

Recently, hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) has emerged as a valuable orthogonal tool to reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RP-LC) as it allows for resolution of highly polar ionisable compounds. The relationships between separation efficiency, column length and speed of analysis for 4.6 mm ID × 5 μm silica particle columns in HILIC are demonstrated using kinetic plots. The kinetic plots constructed for conventional pressure systems operating at 350 bar and at 30 °C and 80 °C are confirmed using experimental data for different column lengths. Efficiencies of more than 130,000 theoretical plates could be achieved by connecting up to six columns of 25 cm. As expected, a significant gain in analysis speed without loss of efficiency could be obtained by operating at 80 °C compared to 30 °C. The advantages of using long columns in HILIC in combination with elevated column temperature for the pharmaceutical industry are illustrated using test mixtures comprised of commercially available ionisable compounds (including some containing functional groups with potential genotoxic typical structural alerts) as well as real polar ionisable pharmaceuticals.     

Evaluation of 1.0 mm i.d. column performances on ultra high pressure liquid chromatography instrumentation

The present study focuses on the evaluation of 1.0 mm i.d. (internal diameter) columns on a commercial Ultra-High Pressure system. These systems have been developed specifically to operate columns with small volumes, typically 2.1 mm i.d., by reducing extra-column volume dispersion. The use of columns with smaller i.d. results in a reduced solvent consumption and required sample volume. The evaluation of the columns was carried out with samples containing neutral and pharmaceutical compounds. In isocratic mode, the extra-column volume produced additional band broadening leading to poor performances compared to equivalent 2.1 mm i.d. columns. By increasing the length of the column, the influence of the extra-column bandspreading could be reduced and 75,000 plates were obtained when four columns were coupled. In gradient mode, the effect of the extra-column contribution on efficiency was limited and about 80% of the performance of the 2.1 mm i.d. columns was obtained. Optimum conditions in gradient mode were further investigated by changing flow rate, gradient time and column length. A different approach of the calculation of peak capacity was also considered for the comparison of the influence of these different parameters.