Comment on “The electron‐pair origin of anti‐aromaticity: Spectroscopic manifestations”

In the article by Zilberg and Haas, “The Electron‐Pair Origin of Anti‐aromaticity: Spectroscopic Manifestations,” the relative sign of the two Kekulé valence bond functions, R and L, in conjugated cyclic hydrocarbons was discussed. It was proposed that in the ground‐state wave function of aromatic compounds, the two functions contribute with like sign, while in the ground state of anti‐aromatic compounds, the two functions contribute with opposite sign. In this Comment, it is shown that the two functions enter with like sign also into the ground‐state wave function of anti‐aromatic compounds. Furthermore, it was argued that resonance tends to (de)stabilize a symmetric ground‐state geometry in case of the (anti‐)aromatic compounds. The expression derived by Zilberg and Haas for the stabilization energy shows an unusual dependence on the ring size and distortion coordinate. An alternative formula is derived for the stabilization energy, in which the energy depends quadratically on the distortion coordinate. Without further numerical calculations, it is not possible to predict whether this term will (de)stabilize a symmetric geometry of the ground state of (anti‐)aromatic molecules. Rather, we are led to believe that the influence of term in question on the geometric stability may be small, thus not providing the main reason for the geometric distortion of anti‐aromatic compounds. © 2006 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2007     

Vibrationally mediated photodissociation of ammonia: the influence of N-H stretching vibrations on passage through conical intersections

Velocity map ion imaging of the H atoms formed in the photodissociation of vibrationally excited ammonia molecules measures the extent of adiabatic and nonadiabatic dissociation for different vibrations in the electronically excited state. Decomposition of molecules with an excited symmetric N-H stretch produces primarily ground state NH(2) along with a H atom. The kinetic energy release distribution is qualitatively similar to the ones from dissociation of ammonia excited to the electronic origin or to several different levels of the bending vibration and umbrella vibration. The situation is very different for electronically excited molecules containing a quantum of antisymmetric N-H stretch. Decomposition from that state produces almost solely electronically excited NH(2)*, avoiding the conical intersection between the excited state and ground state surfaces. These rotationally resolved measurements agree with our previous inferences from lower resolution Doppler profile measurements. The production of NH(2)* suggests that the antisymmetric stretching excitation in the electronically excited molecule carries it away from the conical intersection that other vibrational states access.     

Quinoidal Oligothiophenes: Towards Biradical Ground‐State Species

A family of quinoidal oligothiophenes, from the dimer to the hexamer, with fused bis(butoxymethyl)cyclopentane groups has been extensively investigated by means of electronic and vibrational spectroscopy, electrochemical measurements, and density functional calculations. The latter predict that the electronic ground state always corresponds to a singlet state and that, for the longest oligomers, this state has biradical character that increases with increasing oligomer length. The shortest oligomers display closed‐shell quinoidal structures. Calculations also predict the existence of very low energy excited triplet states that can be populated at room temperature. Aromatization of the conjugated carbon backbone is the driving force that determines the increasing biradical character of the ground state and the appearance of low‐lying triplet states. UV/Vis, Raman, IR, and electrochemical experiments support the aromatic biradical structures predicted for the ground state of the longest oligomers and reveal that population of the low‐lying triplet state accounts for the magnetic activity displayed by these compounds.     

Ultrafast Exciton Self‐Trapping and Delocalization in Cycloparaphenylenes: The Role of Excited‐State Symmetry in Electron‐Vibrational Coupling

Upon photon absorption, π‐conjugated organics are apt to undergo ultrafast structural reorganization via electron‐vibrational coupling during non‐adiabatic transitions. Ultrafast nuclear motions modulate local planarity and quinoid/benzenoid characters within conjugated backbones, which control primary events in the excited states, such as localization, energy transfer, and so on. Femtosecond broadband fluorescence upconversion measurements were conducted to investigate exciton self‐trapping and delocalization in cycloparaphenylenes as ultrafast structural reorganizations are achieved via excited‐state symmetry‐dependent electron‐vibrational coupling. By accessing two high‐lying excited states, one‐photon and two‐photon allowed states, a clear discrepancy in the initial time‐resolved fluorescence spectra and the temporal dynamics/spectral evolution of fluorescence spectra were monitored. Combined with quantum chemical calculations, a novel insight into the effect of the excited‐state symmetry on ultrafast structural reorganization and exciton self‐trapping in the emerging class of π‐conjugated materials is provided.     

Population and coherence dynamics in large conjugated porphyrin nanorings

In photosynthesis, nature exploits the distinctive electronic properties of chromophores arranged in supramolecular rings for efficient light harvesting. Among synthetic supramolecular cyclic structures, porphyrin nanorings have attracted considerable attention as they have a resemblance to naturally occurring light-harvesting structures but offer the ability to control ring size and the level of disorder. Here, broadband femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy, with pump pulses in resonance with either the high or the low energy sides of the inhomogeneously broadened absorption spectrum, is used to study the population dynamics and ground and excited state vibrational coherence in large porphyrin nanorings. A series of fully conjugated, alkyne bridged, nanorings constituted of between ten and forty porphyrin units is studied. Pump-wavelength dependent fast spectral evolution is found. A fast rise or decay of the stimulated emission is found when large porphyrin nanorings are excited on, respectively, the high or low energy side of the absorption spectrum. Such dynamics are consistent with the hypothesis of a variation in transition dipole moment across the inhomogeneously broadened ground state ensemble. The observed dynamics indicate the interplay of nanoring conformation and oscillator strength. Oscillatory dynamics on the sub-ps time domain are observed in both pumping conditions. A combined analysis of the excitation wavelength-dependent transient spectra along with the amplitude and phase evolution of the oscillations allows assignment to vibrational wavepackets evolving on either ground or excited states electronic potential energy surfaces. Even though porphyrin nanorings support highly delocalized electronic wavefunctions, with coherence length spanning tens of chromophores, the measured vibrational coherences remain localised on the monomers. The main contributions to the beatings are assigned to two vibrational modes localised on the porphyrin cores: a Zn–N stretching mode and a skeletal methinic/pyrrolic C–C stretching and in-plane bending mode.

Pump wavelength-dependent, ultrafast excited state dynamics arising from inhomogeneous broadening and ground and excited state nuclear wavepackets were observed for a series of Zn porphyrin nanorings made of 10 to 40 repeating units.     

The crystal structure and vibrational spectra of two molecules emitting dual fluorescence: 4-(1H-Pyrrol-1-yl)benzonitrile (PBN) and 5-cyano-2-(1pyrrolyl)-pyridine (CPP)

Crystal structures and vibrational spectra are reported for the two title molecules which exhibit dual fluorescence due to the existence of a low lying charge transfer excited state. The data show that in the ground state PBN is twisted whereas CPP is planar, and the crystal structures are quite different. The experimental spectra are in very good agreement with quantum mechanical calculations, which also predict considerable differences between the vibrational spectra of CPP in the ground state and in the charge transfer excited state.     

Vibrational spectrum of Li3 first‐excited electronic doublet state: Geometric‐phase effects and statistical analysis

We present J=0 calculations of all bound and pseudobound vibrational states of Li₃ in its first‐excited electronic doublet state by using a realistic double many‐body expansion potential‐energy surface and a minimum‐residual filter diagonalization technique. The action of the system Hamiltonian on the wave function was evaluated by the spectral transform method in hyperspherical coordinates. Calculations of the vibrational spectra were carried out both without consideration and with consideration of geometric‐phase effects. Dynamic Jahn–Teller and geometric‐phase effects are found to play a significant role, while the calculated fundamental symmetric stretching frequency is larger by 8.3% than its reported experimental value of 326 cm⁻¹. From the neighbor‐spacing distributions of the levels, it is observed that the title vibrational spectrum is quasiregular in the short range and quasi‐irregular in the long range. By the Δ₂ standard defined in this article, it is found that the spectra are more nonuniform than those of the “trough” states for the ground electronic state. ©1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 75: 89–109, 1999     

The potential energy surfaces and the radiationless dynamics of excited states of benzene and pyrazine

The potential energy surfaces of the lowest excited states of benzene and pyrazine are investigated as a function of some of the symmetry-adapted internal coordinates by means of the INDO/S method. A large stabilization of the T₂ (ππ*) state of pyrazine (≈ 0.5 eV) along the S_8b vibrational coordinate is found. The calculated potential energy in some excited states (T₁ in benzene, T₂ and S₂ in pyrazine) is a very flat function of the S_16b vibrational coordinate, leading to a crossing with the potential energy of the ground state at relatively small excess of vibrational energy (≈ 1 eV). Thus the ν_16b vibrational mode is postulated to play an important role in the radiationless relaxation to the ground states of these systems. No such crossing has been found near the “channel three” threshold of benzene.     

The role of the beta-ionone ring in the photochemical reaction of rhodopsin

Time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations on the photoabsorption process of the 11-cis retinal protonated Schiff base (PSB) chromophore show that the Franck-Condon relaxation of the first excited state of the chromophore involves a torsional twist motion of the beta-ionone ring relative to the conjugated retinyl chain. For the ground state, the beta-ionone ring and the retinyl chain of the free retinal PSB chromophore form a -40 degrees dihedral angle as compared to -94 degrees for the first excited state. The double bonds of the retinal are shorter for the fully optimized structure of the excited state than for the ground state suggesting a higher cis-trans isomerization barrier for the excited state than for the ground state. According to the present TDDFT calculations, the excitation of the retinal PSB chromophore does not primarily lead to a reaction along the cis-trans torsional coordinate at the C11-C12 bond. The activation of the isomerization center seems to occur at a later stage of the photo reaction. The results obtained at the TDDFT level are supported by second-order M?ller-Plesset (MP2) and approximate singles and doubles-coupled cluster (CC2) calculations on retinal chromophore models; the MP2 and CC2 calculations yield for them qualitatively the same ground state and excited-state structures as obtained in the density functional theory and TDDFT calculations.     

Point symmetry groups of all distorted configurations of a molecule form a lattice

A generalization of the catchment region point symmetry theorem is given within the framework of lattice theory. The symmetry conditions, formulated in terms of lattice theory, interrelate all stationary and distorted configurations of various ground state and electronic excited state molecular species, transition structures, excimers and exciplexes.     

Theoretical investigation of the photophysics of methyl salicylate isomers

The photophysics of methyl salicylate (MS) isomers has been studied using time-dependent density functional theory and large basis sets. First electronic singlet and triplet excited states energies, structure, and vibrational analysis were calculated for the ketoB, enol, and ketoA isomers. It is demonstrated that the photochemical pathway involving excited state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT) from the ketoB to the enol tautomer agrees well with the dual fluorescence in near-UV (from ketoB) and blue (from enol) wavelengths obtained from experiments. Our calculation confirms the existence of a double minimum in the excited state pathway along the O-H-O coordinate corresponding to two preferred energy regions: (1) the hydrogen belongs to the OH moiety and the structure of methyl salicylate is ketoB; (2) the hydrogen flips to the closest carboxyl entailing electronic rearrangement and tautomerization to the enol structure. This double well in the excited state is highly asymmetric. The Franck-Condon vibrational overlap is calculated and accounts for the broadening of the two bands. It is suggested that forward and backward ESIPT through the barrier separating the two minima is temperature-dependent and affects the intensity of the fluorescence as seen in experiments. When the enol fluoresces and returns to its ground state, a barrier-less back proton transfer repopulates the ground state of methyl salicylate ketoB. It is also demonstrated that the rotamer ketoA is not stable in an excited state close to the desired emission wavelength. This observation eliminates the conjecture that the near-UV emission of the dual fluorescence originates from the ketoA rotamer. New experimental results for pure MS in the liquid state are reported and theoretical results compared to them.     

Comparison of Thiophene–Pyrrole Oligomers with Oligothiophenes: A Joint Experimental and Theoretical Investigation of Their Structural and Spectroscopic Properties

We have prepared a new series of mixed thiophene–pyrrole oligomers to investigate the electronic benefits arising from the combination of these two heterocycles. The oligomers are functionalized with several hexyl and aryl groups to improve both processability and chemical robustness. An analysis of their spectroscopic (absorption and emission), photophysical, electrochemical, solid state, and vibrational properties is performed in combination with quantum‐chemical calculations. This analysis provides relevant information regarding the use of these materials as organic semiconductors. The balance between the high aromatic character of pyrrole and the moderate aromaticity of thiophene allows us to address the impact of the coupling of these heterocycles in conjugated systems. The data are interpreted on the basis of the aromaticity, molecular conformations, ground and excited electronic state structures, frontier orbital topologies and energies, oxidative states, and quinoidal versus aromatic competition.     

Spectroscopic studies of bridge contributions to electronic coupling in a donor-bridge-acceptor biradical system

Variable-temperature electronic absorption and resonance Raman spectroscopies are used to probe the excited state electronic structure of Tp(Cum,Me)Zn(SQ-Ph-NN) (1), a donor-bridge-acceptor (D-B-A) biradical complex and a ground state analogue of the charge-separated excited state formed in photoinduced electron transfer reactions. Strong electronic coupling mediated by the p-phenylene bridge stabilizes the triplet ground state of this molecule. Detailed spectroscopic and bonding calculations elucidate key bridge distortions that are involved in the SQ(π)(SOMO) → NN-Ph (π*)(LUMO) D → A charge transfer (CT) transition. We show that the primary excited state distortion that accompanies this CT is along a vibrational coordinate best described as a symmetric Ph(8a) + SQ(in-plane) linear combination and underscores the dominant role of the phenylene bridge fragment acting as an electron acceptor in the D-B-A charge transfer state. Our results show the importance of the phenylene bridge in promoting (1) electron transfer in D-Ph-A systems and (2) electron transport in biased electrode devices that employ a 1,4-phenylene linkage. We have also developed a relationship between the spin density on the acceptor, as measured via the isotropic NN nitrogen hyperfine interaction, and the strength of the D → A interaction given by the magnitude of the electronic coupling matrix element, H(ab).     

Ab initio calculation of resonance Raman cross sections based on excited state geometry optimization

A method for the calculation of resonance Raman cross sections is presented on the basis of calculation of structural differences between optimized ground and excited state geometries using density functional theory. A vibrational frequency calculation of the molecule is employed to obtain normal coordinate displacements for the modes of vibration. The excited state displacement relative to the ground state can be calculated in the normal coordinate basis by means of a linear transformation from a Cartesian basis to a normal coordinate one. The displacements in normal coordinates are then scaled by root-mean-square displacement of zero point motion to calculate dimensionless displacements for use in the two-time-correlator formalism for the calculation of resonance Raman spectra at an arbitrary temperature. The method is valid for Franck-Condon active modes within the harmonic approximation. The method was validated by calculation of resonance Raman cross sections and absorption spectra for chlorine dioxide, nitrate ion, trans-stilbene, 1,3,5-cycloheptatriene, and the aromatic amino acids. This method permits significant gains in the efficiency of calculating resonance Raman cross sections from first principles and, consequently, permits extension to large systems (>50 atoms).     

Spectroscopy and metastability of CO2 2+ molecular ions

The spectroscopy and metastability of the carbon dioxide doubly charged ion, the CO(2) (2+) dication, have been studied with photoionization experiments: time-of-flight photoelectron photoelectron coincidence (TOF-PEPECO), threshold photoelectrons coincidence (TPEsCO), and threshold photoelectrons and ion coincidence (TPEsCO ion coincidence) spectroscopies. Vibrational structure is observed in TOF-PEPECO and TPEsCO spectra of the ground and first two excited states. The vibrational structure is dominated by the symmetric stretch except in the TPEsCO spectrum of the ground state where an antisymmetric stretch progression is observed. All three vibrational frequencies are deduced for the ground state and symmetric stretch and bending frequencies are deduced for the first two excited states. Some vibrational structure of higher electronic states is also observed. The threshold for double ionization of carbon dioxide is reported as 37.340+/-0.010 eV. The fragmentation of energy selected CO(2) (2+) ions has been investigated with TPEsCO ion coincidence spectroscopy. A band of metastable states from approximately 38.7 to approximately 41 eV above the ground state of neutral CO(2) has been observed in the experimental time window of approximately 0.1-2.3 mus with a tendency towards shorter lifetimes at higher energies. It is proposed that the metastability is due to slow spin forbidden conversion from bound excited singlet states to unbound continuum states of the triplet ground state. Another result of this investigation is the observation of CO(+)+O(+) formation in indirect dissociative double photoionization below the threshold for formation of CO(2) (2+). The threshold for CO(+)+O(+) formation is found to be 35.56+/-0.10 eV or lower, which is more than 2 eV lower than previous measurements.     

Labeling vibrations by light: ultrafast transient 2D-IR spectroscopy tracks vibrational modes during photoinduced charge transfer

We report on a novel ultrafast two-dimensional infrared laser experiment that correlates vibrational bands of reactant and product of a photoreaction. The possibilities of this technique are demonstrated for the metal-to-ligand charge transfer (MLCT) in [Re(CO)3Cl(dmbpy)] (dmbpy = 4,4'-dimethyl-2,2'bipyridine) where we correlated the CO vibrational modes of the ground state and the MLCT state. A distinct vibrational mode is excited in the electronic ground state by an infrared laser pulse. This vibrational label survives the subsequent electronic excitation and can be followed in the excited electronic state. It is shown that the order of the vibrational energy levels is not preserved when exciting the molecule as was commonly assumed in the literature.     

Structures and binding energies of the (dibenzoylmethanato)boron difluoride complexes with aromatic hydrocarbons in the ground and excited states. Density functional theory calculations

Structures of the (dibenzoylmethanato)boron difluoride molecule (DBMBF2) and its complexes with a series of aromatic hydrocarbons (benzene; toluene; o-, m-, and p-xylenes, naphthalene; anthracene; and pyrene) in the ground and the first singlet excited states have been calculated. The calculations have been performed by the density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) for the ground and excited states, respectively, with the empirical dispersion correction. It has been shown that the complexes in the ground and excited states have similar stacking structures and are characterized by short contacts between the F atom of DBMBF2 and H atoms of the hydrocarbon molecule, which decrease on transition from the ground to the excited state. The calculated binding energies in the complexes in the excited state are two to three times higher than those in the ground state. The charge transfer in the ground state of the complexes is insignificant and directed from DBMBF2 to the ligand, while in the excited state it is 0.6–0.8 e and directed from the ligand to DBMBF2.     

The umbrella motion of core-excited CH3 and CD3 methyl radicals

An accurate experimental and theoretical study of the lowest core excitation of CH(3) and CD(3) methyl radicals is presented. The complex vibrational structure of the lowest band of the x-ray absorption spectrum (XAS) is due to the large variation of the molecular geometry, which is planar in the ground state and pyramidal in the core-excited state. The XAS spectra of the two radicals were recorded at high resolution and assigned by theoretical simulations of the spectra, taking into account the coupling of symmetrical stretching and symmetrical bending (umbrellalike) deformations of the radicals. An excellent agreement between experimental and theoretical spectral profiles allowed us to accurately characterize the vibrational structure of the electronic transition. The similarities, as well as the differences, of the peculiar vibrational progression observed for the two radicals are explained by the strong anharmonicity along the umbrella coordinate and by the isotopic variation, leading to a different probing of the double-well potential energy surface of the core excited state during the nuclear motion.