Aminoglycoside microarrays to explore interactions of antibiotics with RNAs and proteins

RNA is an important target for drug discovery efforts. Several clinically used aminoglycoside antibiotics bind to bacterial rRNA and inhibit protein synthesis. Aminoglycosides, however, are losing efficacy due to their inherent toxicity and the increase in antibiotic resistance. Targeting of other RNAs is also becoming more attractive thanks to the discovery of new potential RNA drug targets through genome sequencing and biochemical efforts. Identification of new compounds that target RNA is therefore urgent, and we report here on the development of rapid screening methods to probe binding of low molecular weight ligands to proteins and RNAs. A series of aminoglycosides has been immobilized onto glass microscope slides, and binding to proteins and RNAs has been detected by fluorescence. Construction and analysis of the arrays is completed by standard DNA genechip technology. Binding of immobilized aminoglycosides to proteins that are models for study of aminoglycoside toxicity (DNA polymerase and phospholipase C), small RNA oligonucleotide mimics of aminoglycoside binding sites in the ribosome (rRNA A-site mimics), and a large (approximately 400 nucleotide) group I ribozyme RNA is detected. The ability to screen large RNAs alleviates many complications associated with binding experiments that use isolated truncated regions from larger RNAs. These studies lay the foundation for rapid identification of small organic ligands from combinatorial libraries that exhibit strong and selective RNA binding while displaying decreased affinity to toxicity-causing proteins.     

Discovery of aminoglycoside mimetics by NMR-based screening of Escherichia coli A-site RNA

A method is described for the NMR-based screening for the discovery of aminoglycoside mimetics that bind to Escherichia coli A-site RNA. Although aminoglycosides are clinically useful, they exhibit high nephrotoxicity and ototoxicity, and their overuse has led to the development of resistance to important microbial pathogens. To identify a new series of aminoglycoside mimetics that could potentially overcome the problems associated with toxicities and resistance development observed with the aminoglycosides, we have prepared large quantities of E. coli 16 S A-site RNA and conducted an NMR-based screening of our compound library in search for small-molecule RNA binders against this RNA target. From these studies, several classes of compounds were identified as initial hits with binding affinities in the range of 70 microM to 3 mM. Lead optimization through synthetic modifications of these initial hits led to the discovery of several small-molecule aminoglycoside mimetics that are structurally very different from the known aminoglycosides. Structural models of the A-site RNA/ligand complexes were prepared and compared to the three-dimensional structures of the RNA/aminoglycoside complexes.     

Exploring the use of conformationally locked aminoglycosides as a new strategy to overcome bacterial resistance

The emergence of bacterial resistance to the major classes of antibiotics has become a serious problem over recent years. For aminoglycosides, the major biochemical mechanism for bacterial resistance is the enzymatic modification of the drug. Interestingly, in several cases, the oligosaccharide conformation recognized by the ribosomic RNA and the enzymes responsible for the antibiotic inactivation is remarkably different. This observation suggests a possible structure-based chemical strategy to overcome bacterial resistance; in principle, it should be possible to design a conformationally locked oligosaccharide that still retains antibiotic activity but that is not susceptible to enzymatic inactivation. To explore the scope and limitations of this strategy, we have synthesized several aminoglycoside derivatives locked in the ribosome-bound "bioactive" conformation. The effect of the structural preorganization on RNA binding, together with its influence on the aminoglycoside inactivation by several enzymes involved in bacterial resistance, has been studied. Our results indicate that the conformational constraint has a modest effect on their interaction with ribosomal RNA. In contrast, it may display a large impact on their enzymatic inactivation. Thus, the work presented herein provides a key example of how the conformational differences exhibited by these ligands within the binding pockets of the ribosome and of those enzymes involved in bacterial resistance can, in favorable cases, be exploited for designing new antibiotic derivatives with improved activity in resistant strains.     

Design of novel antibiotics that bind to the ribosomal acyltransfer site

The structure of neamine bound to the A site of the bacterial ribosomal RNA was used in the design of novel aminoglycosides. The design took into account stereo and electronic contributions to interactions between RNA and aminoglycosides, as well as a random search of 273 000 compounds from the Cambridge structural database and the National Cancer Institute 3-D database that would fit in the ribosomal aminoglycoside-binding pocket. A total of seven compounds were designed and subsequently synthesized, with the expectation that they would bind to the A-site RNA. Indeed, all synthetic compounds were found to bind to the target RNA comparably to the parent antibiotic neamine, with dissociation constants in the lower micromolar range. The synthetic compounds were evaluated for antibacterial activity against a set of important pathogenic bacteria. These designer antibiotics showed considerably enhanced antibacterial activities against these pathogens, including organisms that hyperexpressed resistance enzymes to aminoglycosides. Furthermore, analyses of four of the synthetic compounds with two important purified resistance enzymes for aminoglycosides indicated that the compounds were very poor substrates; hence the activity of these synthetic antibiotics does not appear to be compromised by the existing resistance mechanisms, as supported by both in vivo and in vitro experiments. The design principles disclosed herein hold the promise of the generation of a large series of designer antibiotics uncompromised by the existing mechanisms of resistance.     

The complex of a designer antibiotic with a model aminoacyl site of the 30S ribosomal subunit revealed by X-ray crystallography

The ribosome is an important target for aminoglycoside antibiotics; however, the clinical effectiveness of aminoglycosides has diminished due to bacterial resistance mechanisms. Here we report the X-ray structure of a novel synthetic aminoglycoside bound to the A site of the ribosome, its target for manifestation of activity. The structure validates the in silico design paradigms for the antibiotic and reveals the molecular interactions made by this novel antibiotic in prokaryotes.     

Conformational constraint as a means for understanding RNA-aminoglycoside specificity

The lack of high RNA target selectivity displayed by aminoglycoside antibiotics results from both their electrostatically driven binding mode and their conformational adaptability. The inherent flexibility around their glycosidic bonds allows them to easily assume a variety of conformations, permitting them to structurally adapt to diverse RNA targets. This structural promiscuity results in the formation of aminoglycoside complexes with diverse RNA targets in which the antibiotics assume distinct conformations. Such differences suggest that covalently linking individual rings in an aminoglycoside could reduce its available conformations, thereby altering target selectivity. To explore this possibility, conformationally constrained neomycin and paromomycin analogues designed to mimic the A-site bound aminoglycoside structure have been synthesized and their affinities to the TAR and A-site, two therapeutically relevant RNA targets, have been evaluated. As per design, this constraint has minimal deleterious effect on binding to the A-site. Surprisingly, however, preorganizing these neomycin-class antibiotics into a TAR-disfavored structure has no deleterious effect on binding to this HIV-1 RNA sequence. We rationalize these observations by suggesting that the A-site and HIV TAR possess inherently different selectivities toward aminoglycosides. The inherent plasticity of the TAR RNA, coupled to the remaining flexibility within the conformationally constrained analogues, makes this RNA site an accommodating target for such polycationic ligands. In contrast, the deeply encapsulating A-site is a more discriminating RNA target. These observations suggest that future design of novel target selective RNA-based therapeutics will have to consider the inherent "structural" selectivity of the RNA target and not only the selectivity patterns displayed by the low molecular weight ligands.     

Scanning conformational space with a library of stereo- and regiochemically diverse aminoglycoside derivatives: the discovery of new ligands for RNA hairpin sequences

A library of stereo- and regiochemically diverse aminoglycoside derivatives was screened at 1 microM using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) against RNA hairpin models of the bacterial A-site, and the HIV viral TAR and RRE sequences. In order to double the stereochemical diversity of the library, the compounds were screened against both enantiomers of each of these sequences. Remarkably, this initial screen suggested that the same four aminoglycoside derivatives bound most tightly to all three of the RNAs, suggesting that these compounds were good RNA binders which, nonetheless, discriminated poorly between the RNA sequences. The interactions between selected isomeric aminoglycoside derivatives and the RNA hairpins were then studied in more detail using an SPR assay. Three isomeric tight-binding aminoglycoside derivatives, which had been identified from the initial screen, were found to bind more tightly to the RNA hairpins (with K(D) values in the range 0.23 to 4.7 microM) than a fourth isomeric derivative (which had K(D) values in the range 6.0 to 30 microM). The magnitude of the tightest RNA-aminoglycoside interactions stemmed, in large part, from remarkably slow dissociation of the aminoglycosides from the RNA targets. The three tight-binding aminoglycoside derivatives were found, however, to discriminate rather poorly between alternative RNA sequences with, at best, around a twenty-fold difference in affinity for alternative RNA hairpin sequences. Within the aminoglycoside derivative library studied, high affinity for an RNA target was not accompanied by good discrimination between alternative RNA sequences.     

Aminoglycoside Conjugation for RNA Targeting: Antimicrobials and Beyond

Natural aminoglycosides are therapeutically useful antibiotics and very efficient RNA ligands. They are oligosaccharides that contain several ammonium groups able to interfere with the translation process in prokaryotes upon binding to bacterial ribosomal RNA (rRNA), and thus, impairing protein synthesis. Even if aminoglycosides are commonly used in therapy, these RNA binders lack selectivity and are able to bind to a wide number of RNA sequences/structures. This is one of the reasons for their toxicity and limited applications in therapy. At the same time, the ability of aminoglycosides to bind to various RNAs renders them a great source of inspiration for the synthesis of new binders with improved affinity and specificity toward several therapeutically relevant RNA targets. Thus, a number of studies have been performed on these complex and highly functionalized compounds, leading to the development of various synthetic methodologies toward the synthesis of conjugated aminoglycosides. The aim of this review is to highlight recent progress in the field of aminoglycoside conjugation, paying particular attention to modifications performed toward the improvement of affinity and especially to the selectivity of the resulting compounds. This will help readers to understand how to introduce a desired chemical modification for future developments of RNA ligands as antibiotics, antiviral, and anticancer compounds.     

Fluorescence-based approach for detecting and characterizing antibiotic-induced conformational changes in ribosomal RNA: comparing aminoglycoside binding to prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomal RNA sequences

Aminoglycoside antibiotics bind specifically to a conserved sequence of the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) A site and interfere with protein synthesis. One model for the mechanism underlying the deleterious effects of aminoglycosides on protein synthesis invokes a drug-induced conformational change in the rRNA that involves the destacking of two adenine residues (A1492 and A1493 in Escherichia coli) at the A site. We describe here a fluorescence-based approach for detecting and characterizing this drug-induced conformational change in the target rRNA. In this approach, we insert the fluorescent base analogue 2-aminopurine in place of A1492 in an E. coli 16S rRNA A-site model oligonucleotide (EcWT) as well as in a mutant form of this oligomer (A1408G) in which A1408 has been replaced with a guanine. The presence of guanine at 1408 instead of adenine represents one of the major sequence differences between prokaryotic and eukaryotic A sites, with the latter A sites being resistant to the deleterious effects of aminoglycosides. Binding of the aminoglycoside paromomycin to the 2AP-substituted forms of EcWT and A1408G induced changes in fluorescence quantum yield consistent with drug-induced base destacking in EcWT but not A1408G. Isothermal titration calorimetry studies reveal that paromomycin binds to the EcWT duplex with a 31-fold higher affinity than the A1408G duplex, with this differential affinity being enthalpic in origin. In the aggregate, these observations are consistent with both rRNA binding affinity and drug-induced base destacking being important determinants in the prokaryotic specificity of aminoglycosides. Combining fluorescence quantum yield and lifetime data allows for quantification of the extent of drug-induced base destacking, thereby providing a convenient tool for evaluating the relative impacts of both novel and existing A-site targeting ligands on rRNA conformation and potentially for predicting relative antibiotic activities and specificities.     

Synthesis of a protected enantiomerically pure 2-deoxystreptamine derivative from d-allylglycine

A diastereoselective synthetic route from d-allylglycine to the enantiopure (protected) 2-deoxystreptamine derivative 14 is presented. Key steps involve two consecutive chain extensions--with crucial stereodirective roles for the amino protective groups, ring closure by olefin metathesis, face selective dihydroxylation, cyclic sulfate formation and finally opening with azide. The resulting 2-deoxystreptamine derivative is ideally protected for the preparation of 4,5- or 4,6-linked aminoglycoside antibiotics.     

Detecting ligand binding to a small RNA target via saturation transfer difference NMR experiments in D(2)O and H(2)O

A small RNA motif is used as a target for ligand-based NMR-screening by saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR experiments. The prerequisites for using a small RNA target in STD experiments, such as saturation time, frequency, and pulses, are discussed. We also show that it is of advantage to use D2O as solvent instead of H2O due to the reduced R1 relaxation rate in D2O. The 27-nucleotide model of the ribosomal A-site was known to bind the aminoglycoside paromomycin with high affinity. This binding interaction could be detected easily, proving the effectiveness of STD NMR experiments as a screening tool for RNA-ligand interactions.     

Molecular dynamics study of the ribosomal A-site

Many aminoglycosidic antibiotics target the A-site of 16S RNA in the small ribosomal subunit and affect the fidelity of protein translation in bacteria. Upon binding, aminoglycosides displace two adenines (A1492 and A1493 for E. coli numbering) that are involved in tRNA anticodon loop recognition. The major difference in the aminoglycosidic binding site between the prokaryota and eukaryota is an adenine into guanine substitution in the position 1408. This mutation likely affects the dynamics of near A1492 and A1493 and hinders the binding of aminoglycosides to eukaryotic ribosomes. With multiple 20 ns long all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, we study the flexibility of a 22 nucleotide RNA fragment which mimics the aminoglycosidic binding site. Simulations are carried out for both native and A1408G mutated RNA as well as for their complexes with aminoglycosidic representative paromomycin. We observe intra- and extrahelical configurations of A1492 and A1493, which differ between the prokaryotic and the mutated structure. We obtain configurations of the A-site that are also observed in the NMR and crystal structures. Our studies show the differences in the internal mobility of the A-site, as well as that in ion and water density distributions inside of the binding cleft, between the prokaryotic and mutated RNA. We also compare the performance of two force field parameters for RNA, Amber and Charmm.     

Peptidyl-transferase ribozymes: trans reactions,structural characterization and ribosomal RNA-like features

Background: One of the most significant questions in understanding the origin of life concerns the order of appearance of DNA, RNA and protein during early biological evolution. If an ‘RNA world’ was a precursor to extant life, RNA must be able not only to catalyze RNA replication but also to direct peptide synthesis. Iterative Iterative RNA selection previously identified catalytic RNAs (ribozymes) that form amide bonds between RNA and an amino acid or between two amino acids.Results: We characterized peptidyl-transferase reactions catalyzed by two different families of ribozymes that use substrates that mimic A site and P site tRNAs. The family II ribozyme secondary structure was modeled using chemical modification, enzymatic digestion and mutational analysis. Two regions resemble the peptidyl-transferase region of 23S ribosomal RNA in sequence and structural context; these regions are important for peptide-bond formation. A shortened form of this ribozyme was engineered to catalyze intermolecular (‘trans’) peptide-bond formation, with the two amino-acid substrates binding through an attached AMP or oligonucleotide moiety.Conclusions: An in vitro-selected ribozyme can catalyze the same type of peptide-bond formation as a ribosome; the ribozyme resembles the ribosome because a very specific RNA structure is required for substrate binding and catalysis, and both amino acids are attached to nucleotides. It is intriguing that, although there are many different possible peptidyl-transferase ribozymes, the sequence and secondary structure of one is strikingly similar to the ‘helical wheel’ portion of 23S rRNA implicated in ribosomal peptidyl-transferase activity.     

NMR-based analysis of aminoglycoside recognition by the resistance enzyme ANT(4'): the pattern of OH/NH3(+) substitution determines the preferred antibiotic binding mode and is critical for drug inactivation

The most significant mechanism of bacterial resistance to aminoglycosides is the enzymatic inactivation of the drug. Herein, we analyze several key aspects of the aminoglycoside recognition by the resistance enzyme ANT(4') from Staphylococcus aureus, employing NMR complemented with site-directed mutagenesis experiments and measurements of the enzymatic activity on newly synthesized kanamycin derivatives. From a methodological perspective, this analysis provides the first example reported for the use of transferred NOE (trNOE) experiments in the analysis of complex molecular recognition processes, characterized by the existence of simultaneous binding events of the ligand to different regions of a protein receptor. The obtained results show that, in favorable cases, these overlapping binding processes can be isolated employing site-directed mutagenesis and then independently analyzed. From a molecular recognition perspective, this work conclusively shows that the enzyme ANT(4') displays a wide tolerance to conformational variations in the drug. Thus, according to the NMR data, kanamycin-A I/II linkage exhibits an unusual anti-Psi orientation in the ternary complex, which is in qualitative agreement with the previously reported crystallographic complex. In contrast, closely related, kanamycin-B is recognized by the enzyme in the syn-type arrangement for both glycosidic bonds. This observation together with the enzymatic activity displayed by ANT(4') against several synthetic kanamycin derivatives strongly suggests that the spatial distribution of positive charges within the aminoglycoside scaffold is the key feature that governs its preferred binding mode to the protein catalytic region and also the regioselectivity of the adenylation reaction. In contrast, the global shape of the antibiotic does not seem to be a critical factor. This feature represents a qualitative difference between the target A-site RNA and the resistance enzyme ANT(4') as aminoglycoside receptors.     

Two-dimensional combinatorial screening identifies specific aminoglycoside-RNA internal loop partners

Herein is described the identification of RNA internal loops that bind to derivatives of neomycin B, neamine, tobramycin, and kanamycin A. RNA loop-ligand partners were identified by a two-dimensional combinatorial screening (2DCS) platform that probes RNA and chemical spaces simultaneously. In 2DCS, an aminoglycoside library immobilized onto an agarose microarray was probed for binding to a 3 x 3 nucleotide RNA internal loop library (81,920 interactions probed in duplicate in a single experiment). RNAs that bound aminoglycosides were harvested from the array via gel excision. RNA internal loop preferences for three aminoglycosides were identified from statistical analysis of selected structures. This provides consensus RNA internal loops that bind these structures and include: loops with potential GA pairs for the neomycin derivative, loops with potential GG pairs for the tobramycin derivative, and pyrimidine-rich loops for the kanamycin A derivative. Results with the neamine derivative show that it binds a variety of loops, including loops that contain potential GA pairs that also recognize the neomycin B derivative. All studied selected internal loops are specific for the aminoglycoside that they were selected to bind. Specificity was quantified for 16 selected internal loops by studying their binding to each of the arrayed aminoglycosides. Specificities ranged from 2- to 80-fold with an average specificity of 20-fold. These studies show that 2DCS is a unique platform to probe RNA and chemical space simultaneously to identify specific RNA motif-ligand interactions.     

A simple structural-based approach to prevent aminoglycoside inactivation by bacterial defense proteins. Conformational restriction provides effective protection against neomycin-B nucleotidylation by ANT4

Herein, we describe how the conformational differences exhibited by aminoglycosides in the binding pockets of the ribosome and those enzymes involved in bacterial resistance can be exploited in the design of new antibiotic derivatives with improved activity in resistant strains. The simple modification shown in the figure, leading to the conformationally restricted 5, provides an effective protection against aminoglycoside inactivation by Staphylococcus aureus ANT4, both in vivo and in vitro.     

In vitro selection of a viomycin-binding RNA pseudoknot

Background: The peptide antibiotic viomycin inhibits ribosomal protein synthesis, group I intron self-splicing and self-cleavage of the human hepatitis delta virus ribozyme. To understand the molecular basis of RNA binding and recognition by viomycin, we isolated a variety of novel viomycin-binding RNA molecules using in vitro selection.Results: More than 90% of the selected RNA molecules shared one continuous highly conserved region of 14 nucleotides. Mutational analyses, structural probing, together with footprinting experiments by chemical modification, and Pb²⁺-induced cleavage showed that this conserved sequence harbours the antibiotic-binding site and forms a stem-loop structure. Moreover, the loop is engaged in a long-range interaction forming a pseudoknot.Conclusions: A comparison between the novel viomycin-binding motif and the natural RNA target sites for viomycin showed that all these segments form a pseudoknot at the antibiotic-binding site. We therefore conclude that this peptide antibiotic has a strong selectivity for particular RNA pseudoknots.     

NMR-based characterization of phenothiazines as a RNA binding scaffold

Phenothiazines were identified by virtual screening as promising ligands for HIV-1 TAR RNA and A-site ribosomal RNA, and binding in each case was verified experimentally. Consequently, since phenothiazines generally possess high bioavailability and low toxicity, we used several NMR techniques to explore the binding characteristics of acetopromazine with a total of five different RNA constructs: four as potential drug targets plus one control RNA construct. Acetopromazine was able to bind to various internal bulges and terminal loops containing both purines and pyrimidines, but no binding could be detected with double-stranded RNA or tetraloops. Dissociation constants determined via NMR varied from 0.27 to >3 mM. Analysis of differential saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR effects of acetopromazine suggests that the phenothiazine moiety has the closest contact to the binding sites of TAR and A-site RNA while the flexible N,N-dimethylpropylamino side chain contributes less to binding. NMR studies on A-site ribosomal RNA binding by six commercially available phenothiazines, while too few to establish a true structure-activity relationship, revealed a distinct dependence on aromatic ring and side chain substituents. Substituted phenothiazines have low molecular weight, are not highly charged, and have an inherent affinity for irregular tertiary RNA folds, suggesting that they can serve as a novel scaffold for constructing RNA-binding ligands.     

Studying aminoglycoside antibiotic binding to HIV-1 TAR RNA by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The recognition of the aminoglycosides neomycin and streptomycin by HIV-1 TAR RNA was studied by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). Members of the aminoglycoside family of antibiotics are known to target a wide variety of RNA molecules. Neomycin and streptomycin inhibit the formation of the Tat protein–TAR RNA complex, an assembly that is believed to be necessary for HIV replication. The noncovalent complexes formed by the binding of aminoglycosides to TAR RNA and the Tat–TAR complex were detected by ESI-MS. Neomycin has a maximum binding stoichiometry of three and two to TAR RNA and to the Tat–TAR complex, respectively. Data from the ESI-MS experiments suggest that a high affinity binding site of neomycin is located near the three-nucleotide bulge region of TAR RNA. This is consistent with previous solution phase footprinting measurements [H.-Y. Mei et al., Biochemistry 37 (1998) 14204]. Neomycin has a higher affinity toward TAR RNA than streptomycin, as measured by ESI-MS competition binding experiments. A noncovalent complex formed between a small molecule inhibitor of TAR RNA, which has a similar solution binding affinity as the aminoglycosides, and TAR RNA is much less stable than the RNA–aminoglycoside complexes to collisional dissociation in the gas phase. It is believed that the small molecule inhibitor interacts with TAR RNA via hydrophobic interactions, whereas the aminoglycosides bind to RNAs through electrostatic forces. This difference in gas phase stabilities may prove useful for discerning the types of noncovalent forces holding complexes together.     

Crystal structure of a complex between the aminoglycoside tobramycin and an oligonucleotide containing the ribosomal decoding a site

Aminoglycoside antibiotics target the decoding aminoacyl site (A site) on the 16S ribosomal RNA and induce miscoding during translation. Here, we present the crystal structure, at 2.54 A resolution, of an RNA oligonucleotide containing the A site sequence complexed to the 4,6-disubstituted 2-deoxystreptamine aminoglycoside tobramycin. The three aminosugar rings making up tobramycin interact with the deep-groove atoms directly or via water molecules and stabilize a fully bulged-out conformation of adenines A(1492) and A(1493). The comparison between this structure and the one previously solved in the presence of paromomycin confirms the importance of the functional groups on the common neamine part of these two antibiotics for binding to RNA. Furthermore, the analysis of the present structure provides a molecular explanation to some of the resistance mechanisms that have spread among bacteria and rendered aminoglycoside antibiotics inefficient.