Consumer perspectives on genetic testing, research and services for ethnoculturally diverse populations

A panel of individuals from diverse ethnocultural backgrounds and representing a variety of genetic disorders presented their consumer perspectives on genetic programs, testing and services. Their remarks emphasized how misunderstanding and miscommunication between health care professionals and many of the populations for whom they provide services can lead to unfilled genetic service needs. Panelists recommended that health care professionals become more aware and knowledgeable about the diversity of customs, beliefs and cultures of those receiving their services. Only by building a foundation of trust and mutual respect will genetic testing, research and services become more accessible to individuals from diverse populations, their families and their communities.     

The burden of genetic disorders in India and a framework for community control

With a very large population and high birth rate, and consanguineous marriage favoured in many communities, there is a high prevalence of genetic disorders in India. An estimated 495,000 infants with congenital malformations, 390,000 with G6PD deficiency, 21,400 with Down syndrome, 9,000 with beta-thalassaemia, 5,200 with sickle cell disease, and 9,760 with amino acid disorders are born each year. The prevalence of late-onset multi-factorial disorders (including coronary artery disease, hypertension and psychiatric disorders) is also large. Due to inadequate diagnostic, management and rehabilitation facilities, the burden of these disorders is greater than in Western countries. Although genetic diseases receive little attention from the health services, research funding by the government has been liberal. Community control of common disorders like thalassaemia, Down syndrome, neural tube defects, and muscular dystrophies deserves high priority, and genetic services should be integrated into the existing primary health care and medical services. Most genetic counselling would have to be provided through training physicians who staff the district and medical school hospitals. To ensure future progress, there is a need to establish additional departments of medical genetics in medical schools.     

Host genetic factors in the clinical course of HIV-1 infection: chemokines and chemokine receptors

The outcome of HIV-1 infection is highly variable: not all individuals exposed to HIV-1 will become infected, and among individuals who do become infected, the time from seroconversion to AIDS diagnosis is highly variable. Some patients may develop AIDS within 3 years, whereas others may remain asymptomatic for over 15 years. The reasons for these differences are not fully understood, but are thought to reflect the complex interactions between virus and host. In recent years, an important role for host genetic factors in the pathogenesis of HIV-1 infection has increasingly been appreciated. Many novel genetic polymorphisms have been identified and analyzed for their role in HIV-1 transmission and disease progression. In this review, we will give an update of the current knowledge on the role of such polymorphisms in HIV-1 disease. As recent research in this field has focussed on polymorphisms in chemokine and chemokine receptor genes, this will be the main theme of our review.     

Genetics and global health care

OBJECTIVES: To examine an alternative model for funding genetic health care, on a global basis. METHODS: Internet-based national data on gross domestic product (GDP) per capita, health care funding, and public and private elements of health care costs. RESULTS: Wide variation in GDP per capita and in the proportion available for health care funding. Insufficient funds are available in developing countries. CONCLUSIONS: Health care provision for people with genetic disorders is unlikely to be fully funded unless a different approach to management costs is undertaken. Rare genetic disorders could be funded by an insurance model which may be more equitable and which could be developed to cover the total global health care costs of the genetic disorder.     

Genetics in primary care: a USA faculty development initiative

The Genetics in Primary Care (GPC) project is a USA national faculty development initiative with the goal of enhancing the training of medical students and primary care residents by developing primary care faculty expertise in genetics. Educational strategies were developed for the project by an executive committee with input from an advisory committee, comprising individuals with primary care, medical education and genetics expertise. These committees identified the key issues in genetics education for primary care as (1) considering inherited disease in the differential diagnosis of common disorders; (2) using appropriate counseling strategies for genetic testing and diagnosis, and (3) understanding the implications of a genetic diagnosis for family members. The group emphasized the importance of a primary care perspective, which suggests that the clinical utility of genetic information is greatest when it has the potential to improve health outcomes. The group also noted that clinical practice already incorporates the use of family history information, providing a basis for discussing the application of genetic concepts in primary care. Genetics and primary care experts agreed that educational efforts will be most successful if they are integrated into existing primary care teaching programs, and use a case-based teaching format that incorporates both clinical and social dimensions of genetic disorders. Three core clinical skills were identified: (1) interpreting family history; (2) recognizing the variable clinical utility of genetic information, and (3) acquiring cultural competency. Three areas of potential controversy were identified as well: (1) the role of nondirective counseling versus shared decision-making in discussions of genetic testing; (2) the intrinsic value of genetic information when it does not influence health outcomes, and (3) indications for a genetics referral. The project provides an opportunity for ongoing discussion about these important issues.     

Analysis of the population structure in Oman

Knowledge of a population structure can be a unique aid in planning genetic services. In order to facilitate the development of genetic services in the Sultanate of Oman, a tribal data base has been developed. The historic records of the beginning of the 19th century were used as the basis and were updated with contemporary information. The tribal data base includes tribal names, locations, and the main 185 major tribes and their subsections. Tribal data can be used for health care planning and the development of disease-specific genetic registers if the hospital records also include the tribal name. They may also provide a useful aid in genetic screening and disease prevention programmes, as when specific mutations are found in rare diseases, it is likely that these will be found to be exclusive to specific tribes, and laboratory testing will be greatly simplified. It is likely that similar data bases could be developed elsewhere in the Middle East and in the immigrant communities in Western Europe.     

The emergence of biobanks: practical design considerations for large population-based studies of gene-environment interactions

The completion of the human genome project has spurred new thinking about launching large-scale cohort studies; as proposed, these studies will differ from past large-scale cohort studies and will focus primarily on how genetic variation interacts with environmental exposures to affect the risk for common human diseases. There is no single 'best design' for large-scale studies of gene-environment interactions. Some studies are best performed in cohort studies where unbiased information can be collected on individuals years before disease onset. Other studies may be most efficiently done with a case-control design using currently available automated data. Population-based biobanks with nested case-control or case-cohort studies offer distinct advantages to some of the resource-intensive large-scale cohort studies under consideration, and may be more acceptable to many of the countries around the world currently considering such projects.     

Where there's a web,there's a way: commercial genetic testing and the Internet

The Internet has become a "global marketplace", enabling consumers to purchase health care products and services, including genetic testing, through a variety of national and international sources. A web search for commercial (for-profit) genetic testing companies found 12 with a web presence that were offering adult genetic susceptibility testing, of which 3 offered direct-to-consumer access. In this paper, Canada--with its educated population and universal health care system--will serve as a case study for illustrating the social, ethical and policy issues (e.g., information privacy, just access to health care, product safety, and access to unbiased health information) arising with Internet-based access to commercial genetic testing. Health professionals, policy makers and consumers in all developed nations will be faced with complex technical, social and ethical issues, but without further discussion it will not be possible to determine how best to manage and maximise the benefits of this increased accessibility and choice, while minimising the associated personal and social costs.     

United Arab Emirates: communities and community genetics

The UAE society is cosmopolitan, but the indigenous inhabitants are traditional with puritanical values despite their exposure to other vastly different cultures and habits. Marriages between consanguineous couples are still the norm rather than the exception. As a result, there is a high frequency of genetic disorders, particularly autosomal recessive types. Despite the high frequency of genetic disorders like haemoglobinopathies and others characteristically found in this population, genetic services are inadequate. Screening for certain disorders like thalassaemia are not applied on a wide scale. Abortion is illegal, and therefore, prenatal diagnosis or preconception tests are not done. With the absence of a good national database, deficiency of genetic services and absence of preventative alternatives for carrier couples, genetic counsellors find it difficult to advice pragmatic solutions to issues relating to genetic diseases. This paper reviews common genetic problems in the UAE with special emphasis on available genetic services and support to families with children with inherited disorders. Existing barriers to the improvement of clinical services by prenatal counselling are also discussed.     

The Human Genome Project,genetics and health

Three main reasons why a genetic approach is unlikely to be a solution to common diseases in the foreseeable future are discussed. The first is the great importance of environmental circumstances in determining health, the second reason is the great complexity of gene/gene, gene/environment interactions, and the third reason is human behavior with regard to compliance with medical recommendations. Since particular interests are likely to push for a genetic approach to disease, there will be a need to protect the public interest so that premature and inappropriate use of genetics is not made, and so that a balanced opportunity to better the health of all is not missed.     

Application of particle swarm optimization and genetic algorithms to multiobjective damage identification inverse problems with modelling errors

Structural health monitoring has become an important research topic in conjunction with the damage assessment of structures. The use of system identification approaches for damage detection using inverse methods has become more widespread in recent years and their formulation in a multiobjective framework has become more usual. Inverse problems require the use of an initial baseline model of the undamaged structure. Modelling errors in the baseline model whose effects exceed the modal sensitivity to damage are critical and make an accurate estimation of damage impossible. Artificial intelligence techniques based on genetic algorithms are used increasingly as an alternative to more classical techniques to solve this kind of problem especially due to their feasibility for managing multiobjective problems. This paper outlines an understanding of how particle swarm optimization methods operate in damage identification problems based on multiobjective FE updating procedures and takes modelling errors into account. One experimental example is used to show their performance in comparison with genetic algorithms.     

Common autosomal recessive diseases in Oman derived from a hospital-based registry

OBJECTIVES: The local frequencies of genetic disorders in Oman apart from hemoglobinopathies are largely unknown. The aim of the present study was to evaluate birth prevalence of commonly diagnosed autosomal recessive diseases and to estimate needs and priorities of genetic services. METHODS: Analysis of the years 1993-2002 using a hospital-based registry of genetic diseases was attempted. More than 3,000 records were reviewed. Only patients with definite diagnosis were included in the analysis. Genetically determined diseases occurring less frequently than 1 in 50,000 births are not included. RESULTS: A number of rare autosomal recessive diseases are found to have a prevalence at least 1 in 50,000 livebirths. CONCLUSIONS: The data suggest that genetic diseases are important as major contributors to perinatal and childhood mortality and morbidity. The need for preventive genetic service is essential for the health of the community in Oman. Autosomal recessive diseases were frequently concentrated in specific geographical areas, which can be explained by founder effect and genetic drift. However, the hospital-based registry may present incomplete information. Further prospective studies are needed to provide more detailed data.     

Alzheimer's Disease: Genes,Pathogenesis and Risk Prediction

With the aging of western society the contribution to morbidity of diseases of the elderly, such as dementia, will increase exponentially. Thorough preventative and curative strategies are needed to constrain the increasing prevalence of these disabling diseases. Better understanding of the pathogenesis of disease will enable development of therapy, prevention and the identification of high-risk groups in the population. Here, we review the genetic epidemiology of Alzheimer's disease, the most common cause of dementia in the western world. The search for genetic risk factors, though far from completed, has been of major importance for understanding the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease. Although effective therapy is still awaited, these findings have led to new avenues for the development of drugs. Copyright 2002 S. Karger AG, Basel     

Public experiences, knowledge and expectations about medical genetics and the use of genetic information

OBJECTIVE: The objectives of this study were (1) to explore public experiences, genetic knowledge, expectations of future medical genetic developments, and the attitudes towards the use of genetic information, and (2) to determine whether there are subject characteristics associated with these variables. METHODS: Participants (n = 1,308, age > or = 25 years) of a Dutch consumer panel were sent a questionnaire, specifically designed for this study. RESULTS: Response was 63% (817/1,308). A minority of respondents reported to know someone with a hereditary disease (34%) or to have used a genetic test (8%). Overall, 57% perceived a lack of genetic knowledge. In multivariate analyses, high self-rated knowledge, younger age, having heard of genetic testing, high educational level, female gender, having children living at home, being a health professional, and familiarity with genetic testing were positively associated with genetic knowledge. Future expectations of the consequences of developments in medical genetics varied between the subjects. The great majority expected great benefits for medical practice such as an increasing use of genetic aspects of disease for diagnosis or prevention. One fifth, mainly older people, anticipated a negative impact of genetic developments on society. The results also show that most people are reserved to share their genetic information with others, especially with regard to the wider public domain (e.g. industry and insurers) and employers. Remarkably, respondents were more willing to share their genetic information with scientific researchers (68%) than with their relatives (54%). CONCLUSION: This study suggests that although one fifth anticipates negative consequences of genetic developments, the great majority has high expectations about the increasing use of genetics in prevention, diagnosis and treatment of diseases. In developing educational programmes about genetic innovations in medicine, policymakers will have to take into account pre-existing lay knowledge, views and expectations of different groups of citizens towards these developments.     

Genetic services to the latino population in the United States

In 1998 Latinos (Hispanics) in the United States number 30 million persons and account for 11.3% of the total population, while it is predicted that by the year 2020 they will become the largest minority. This article describes the demographics and health profile of the Latino population in the United States. A brief account is given of common cultural traditions and health beliefs that modulate the interaction of this population with the health delivery system in general, and that of genetic services in particular. Further, some problems in the access to, and utilization of genetic services are outlined, and the experience of a project designed to overcome those problems in New York City is described.     

Assessment of two 'low-tech' genetic health care procedures performed by prenatal care providers in Washington state: implications for future policy development activities

Equity in health care demands that patients be treated fairly, impartially and with justice. Health care professionals and others have long been aware of the concept of equity, and the many inequities that exist in our health care system. As part of our analysis of postpartum data collected between 1993 and 1996 by the Washington Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS) from self-administered patient surveys, we explored equity as it pertains to two 'low-tech' prenatal genetic health care procedures: (1) whether or not prenatal care providers asked their patients about a family history of birth defects/genetic disorders, and (2) whether or not prenatal care providers talked to their patients about prenatal testing for birth defects/genetic disorders. Overall, about 80% of pregnant women reported that they had been asked about their family history of birth defects/genetic disorders, and about 85% said that their prenatal care provider(s) had talked to them about prenatal testing. Maternal characteristics associated with a lower likelihood of receiving these two low-tech genetic health care procedures appeared to be young maternal age, and low education and income levels, regardless of where women with these attributes received their prenatal care (e.g. community, migrant, health department or military health care clinics, private physicians, or health maintenance organizations).     

DNA diagnosis of single gene disorders in patients of non-European origin: experience from Kuwait

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to establish genetic DNA-diagnostic service in Kuwait. METHODS: Polymerase chain reaction, restriction fragment length polymorphisms, heteroduplex analysis and DNA sequencing were applied. RESULTS: Direct testing for common mutations had variable success in Kuwaiti patients with different genetic disorders, and additional mutation analysis was required in many cases. Genetic heterogeneity, mutations of Mediterranean, African and Arabic/Middle Eastern origin, and homozygosity by descent are characteristic of patients from Kuwait. CONCLUSIONS: More efforts aimed at the identification of mutations underlying genetic disorders in Kuwait as well as in other Gulf countries are warranted. This can be achieved by focusing genetic research in the academic institutions of Gulf countries towards this goal.     

Implications of genetic testing for the insurance industry: the UK example

This report summarises the controversy of genetic tests and insurance, with a focus on the UK situation during the past decade. UK experience provides insight for future strategies to help people with genetic disadvantages make insurance provision for themselves and their families. Non-disclosure of genetic test results (already carried out for clinical purposes) may not benefit people at risk of genetic disorders or with positive genetic tests. The pressure of geneticists over a decade to prevent disclosure to insurers may have masked opportunities to use insurance to provide help for people with genetic disadvantages. To seize the opportunities now, there must be collaboration, not conflict. Politicians, geneticists, social scientists and all elements of the insurance industry can contribute to wise solutions.