Basis set dependence of solute-solvent interaction energy of benzene in water: a HF/DFT study

Solute-solvent interaction energies for the benzene molecule dissolved in water are computed using Hartree-Fock and B3LYP density functional theories. Explicit solvent molecules up to 14-A away from the dissolved benzene molecule are included in the calculation of interaction energies. Both basis set dependence and basis set superposition errors are carefully examined. It is found that the use of a larger basis set for the region near the solute together with a smaller basis set for the outer region gives results very close to what would have been obtained if the larger basis set had been used for the whole system. It is also shown that a correction for the basis set superposition error is a necessary component in this kind of calculations. With this correction, results obtained with different tested basis sets converge to within 1 kcal/mol.     

Interaction energy of a water molecule with a single-layer graphitic surface modeled by hydrogen- and fluorine-terminated clusters

In ab initio calculations a finite graphitic cluster model is often used to approximate the interaction energy of a water molecule with an infinite single-layer graphitic surface (graphene). In previous studies, the graphitic cluster model is a collection of fused benzene rings terminated by hydrogen atoms. In this study, the effect of using fluorine instead of hydrogen atoms for terminating the cluster model is examined to clarify the role of the boundary. The interaction energy of a water molecule with the graphitic cluster was computed using ab initio methods at the MP2 level of theory and with the 6-31G(d = 0.25) basis set. The interaction energy of a water molecule with graphene is estimated by extrapolation of two series of increasing size graphitic cluster models (C(6n2)H(6n) and C(6n2)F(6n), n = 1-3). Two fixed orientations of water molecule are considered: (a) both hydrogen atoms of water pointing toward the cluster (mode A) and (b) both hydrogen atoms of water pointing away from the cluster (mode B). The interaction energies for water mode A are found to be -2.39 and -2.49 kcal/mol for C(6n2)H(6n) and C(6n2)F(6n) cluster models, respectively. For water mode B, the interaction energies are -2.32 and -2.44 kcal/mol for C(6n2)H(6n) and C(6n2)F(6n) cluster models, respectively.     

Theoretical study of the structure, stability, and infrared spectra of hydrogen-bonded complexes of N-nitrosodiethanolamine (NDELA) with water molecules

A theoretical study of the interaction between the N-nitrosodiethanolamine (NDELA) molecule and one to five water molecules was performed at the B3LYP level using a large polarized basis set. The calculated complexation energies (corrected for BSSE and ZPVE) of NDELA with one, two, three, four, and five water molecules are ?4.62 kcal/mol, ?9.83 kcal/mol, ?15.29 kcal/mol, ?21.60 kcal/mol, and ?25.10 kcal/mol respectively at the B3LYP/6-311++G** level. In all complexes studied, there are red shifts in the vibrational frequencies of the O-Hs of NDELA and water molecules along with increases in the corresponding IR intensities.     

Intermolecular interactions of nitrobenzene-benzene complex and nitrobenzene dimer: significant stabilization of slipped-parallel orientation by dispersion interaction

The CCSD(T) level interaction energies of eight orientations of nitrobenzene-benzene complexes and nine orientations of nitrobenzene dimers at the basis set limit have been estimated. The calculated interaction energy of the most stable slipped-parallel (C(s)) nitrobenzene-benzene complex was -4.51 kcal/mol. That of the most stable slipped-parallel (antiparallel) (C(2h)) nitrobenzene dimer was -6.81 kcal/mol. The interaction energies of these complexes are significantly larger than that of the benzene dimer. The T-shaped complexes are substantially less stable. Although nitrobenzene has a polar nitro group, electrostatic interaction is always considerably weaker than the dispersion interaction. The dispersion interaction in these complexes is larger than that in the benzene dimer, which is the cause of the preference of the slipped-parallel orientation in these complexes.     

Improved interaction potentials for charged residues in proteins

Electrostatic interactions dominate the structure and free energy of biomolecules. To obtain accurate free energies involving charged groups from molecular simulations, OPLS-AA parameters have been reoptimized using Monte Carlo free energy perturbation. New parameters fit a self-consistent, experimental set of hydration free energies for acetate (Asp), propionate (Glu), 4-methylimidazolium (Hip), n-butylammonium (Lys), and n-propylguanidinium (Arg), all resembling charged residue side chains, including beta-carbons. It is shown that OPLS-AA free energies depend critically on the type of water model, TIP4P or TIP3P; i.e., each water model requires specific water-charged molecule interaction potentials. New models (models 1 and 3) are thus described for both water models. Uncertainties in relative free energies of charged residues are approximately 2 kcal/mol with the new parameters, due to variations in system setup (MAEs of ca. 1 kcal/mol) and noise from simulations (ca. 1 kcal/mol). The latter error of approximately 1 kcal/mol contrasts MAEs from standard OPLS-AA of up to 13 kcal/mol for the entire series of charged residues or up to 5 kcal/mol for the cationic series Lys, Arg, and Hip. The new parameters can be used directly in molecular simulations with no modification of neutral residues needed and are envisioned to be particular important in simulations where charged residues change environment.     

High-level ab initio computations of structures and interaction energies of naphthalene dimers: origin of attraction and its directionality

The intermolecular interaction energies of naphthalene dimers have been calculated by using an aromatic intermolecular interaction model (a model chemistry for the evaluation of intermolecular interactions between aromatic molecules). The CCSD(T) (coupled cluster calculations with single and double substitutions with noniterative triple excitations) interaction energy at the basis set limit has been estimated from the second-order M?ller-Plesset perturbation interaction energy near saturation and the CCSD(T) correction term obtained using a medium-size basis set. The estimated interaction energies of the set of geometries explored in this work show that two structures emerge as being the lowest energy, and may effectively be considered as isoenergetic on the basis of the errors inherent in out extrapolation procedure. These structures are the slipped-parallel (Ci) structure (-5.73 kcal/mol) and the cross (D2d) structure (-5.28 kcal/mol). The T-shaped (C2v) and sandwich (D2h) dimers are substantially less stable (-4.34 and -3.78 kcal/mol, respectively). The dispersion interaction is found to be the major source of attraction in the naphthalene dimer. The electrostatic interaction is substantially smaller than the dispersion interaction. The large dispersion interaction is the cause of the large binding energies of the cross and slipped-parallel dimers.     

Accurate interaction energies of hydrogen-bonded nucleic acid base pairs

Hydrogen-bonded nucleic acids base pairs substantially contribute to the structure and stability of nucleic acids. The study presents reference ab initio structures and interaction energies of selected base pairs with binding energies ranging from -5 to -47 kcal/mol. The molecular structures are obtained using the RI-MP2 (resolution of identity MP2) method with extended cc-pVTZ basis set of atomic orbitals. The RI-MP2 method provides results essentially identical with the standard MP2 method. The interaction energies are calculated using the Complete Basis Set (CBS) extrapolation at the RI-MP2 level. For some base pairs, Coupled-Cluster corrections with inclusion of noniterative triple contributions (CCSD(T)) are given. The calculations are compared with selected medium quality methods. The PW91 DFT functional with the 6-31G basis set matches well the RI-MP2/CBS absolute interaction energies and reproduces the relative values of base pairing energies with a maximum relative error of 2.6 kcal/mol when applied with Becke3LYP-optimized geometries. The Becke3LYP DFT functional underestimates the interaction energies by few kcal/mol with relative error of 2.2 kcal/mol. Very good performance of nonpolarizable Cornell et al. force field is confirmed and this indirectly supports the view that H-bonded base pairs are primarily stabilized by electrostatic interactions.     

Ab initio force field for simulations of proteins and nucleic acids

We present a new self-consistent set of ab initio analytical pair potential to predict specific nonbonded interactions of protein with nucleic acid, of protein with protein, and of nucleic acid with nucleic acid. The purpose of this study is to represent the interaction between biological molecules with an accuracy equivalent to the ab initio molecular orbital calculations, which are used as reference data to obtain the pair potentials. Atoms in nucleic acids and proteins are classified according to their chemical environments. An “effective charge,” a modification of a charge obtained from the Mulliken population analysis, is introduced and used to represent the electrostatic energy. More than 30,000 SCF interaction energies have been calculated to provide the reference data for the fitting procedure that we have adopted in the parameterization of the potentials. The standard deviation is 1.61 kcal/mol for interaction energies spanning the range from about ?220 kcal/mol to +20 kcal/mol. Molecular dynamics simulations, using the above new set of force field, have been performed successfully for the systems where adequate treatments of specific interactions are required: The stability of α-helix of C-peptide and the interaction of spermine with oligonucleotide are examined as preliminary examples.     

Theoretical studies on the hydration of formic acid by ab initio and ABEEMσπ fluctuating charge model

The interaction between formic acid (FA) and water was systemically investigated by atom-bond electronegativity equalization method fused into molecular mechanics (ABEEMσπ/MM) and ab initio methods. The geometries of 20 formic acid–water complexes (FA–water) were obtained using B3LYP/aug-cc-pVTZ level optimizations, and the energies were determined at the MP2/aug-cc-pVTZ level with basis set superposition error (BSSE) and zero-point vibrational energy (ZPVE) corrections. The ABEEMσπ potential model gives reasonable properties of these clusters when compared with the present ab initio data. For interaction energies, the root mean square deviation is 0.74 kcal/mol, and the linear coefficient reaches 0.993. Next, FA in aqueous solution was also studied. The hydrogen-bonding pattern due to the interactions with water has been analyzed in detail. Furthermore, the ABEEMσπ charges changed when H₂O interacted with the FA molecule, especially at the sites where the hydrogen bonds form. These results show that the ABEEMσπ fluctuating charge model is fine giving the overall characteristic hydration properties of FA–water systems in good agreement with the high-level ab initio calculations.     

New accurate benchmark energies for large water clusters: DFT is better than expected

In this work, we use MP2 and coupled‐cluster with single, double, and perturbative triple excitations [CCSD(T)] as well as their corresponding explicitly correlated (F12) counterparts to compute the interaction energies of water icosamers. The incremental scheme is used to compute benchmark energies at the CCSD(T)/CBS(45) and CCSD(T)(F12*)/cc‐pVQZ‐F12 level of theory. The four structures, dodecahedron, edge sharing, face sharing, and fused cubes, are part of the WATER27 test set and therefore, highly accurate interaction energies are required. All methods applied in this work lead to new benchmark energies for these four systems. To obtain these values, we carefully analyze the convergence of the interaction energies with respect to the basis set. Furthermore, we investigate the influence of the basis set superposition error and the core‐valence correlation. The interaction energies are: dodecahedron ?198.6 kcal/mol, edge sharing ?209.7 kcal/mol, face sharing ?208.0 kcal/mol, and fused cubes ?208.0 kcal/mol. For water clusters, we recommend to use the PW6B95 density functional of Truhlar in combination with Grimme's dispersion correction (D3), as the mean absolute error is 0.9 and the root mean‐squared deviation is only 1.4 kcal/mol. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Density-functional theory-symmetry-adapted intermolecular perturbation theory with density fitting: a new efficient method to study intermolecular interaction energies

The previously developed DFT-SAPT approach, which combines symmetry-adapted intermolecular perturbation theory (SAPT) with a density-functional theory (DFT) representation of the monomers, has been implemented by using density fitting of two-electron objects. This approach, termed DF-DFT-SAPT, scales with the fifth power of the molecular size and with the third power upon increase of the basis set size for a given dimer, thus drastically reducing the cost of the conventional DFT-SAPT method. The accuracy of the density fitting approximation has been tested for the ethyne dimer. It has been found that the errors in the interaction energies due to density fitting are below 10(-3) kcal/mol with suitable auxiliary basis sets and thus one or two orders of magnitude smaller than the errors due to the use of a limited atomic orbital basis set. An investigation of three prominent structures of the benzene dimer, namely, the T shaped, parallel displaced, and sandwich geometries, employing basis sets of up to augmented quadruple-zeta quality shows that DF-DFT-SAPT outperforms second-order Moller-Plesset theory (MP2) and gives total interaction energies which are close to the best estimates inferred from combining the results of MP2 and coupled-cluster theory with single, double, and perturbative triple excitations.     

A new database and benchmark of the bond energies of noble-gas-containing molecules

We have developed a new database of structures and bond energies of 59 noble-gas-containing molecules. The structures were calculated by CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ methods and the bond energies were obtained using the CCSD(T)/complete basis set method. Many wavefunction-based and density functional theory methods have been benchmarked against the 59 accurate bond energies. Our results show that the MPW1B95, B2GP-PLYP, and DSD-BLYP functionals with the aug-cc-pVTZ basis set excel in predicting the bond energies of noble-gas molecules with mean unsigned errors (MUEs) of 2.0 to 2.1 kcal/mol. When combinations of Dunning's basis sets are used, the MPW1B95, B2GP-PLYP, DSD-BLYP, and BMK functionals give significantly lower MUEs of 1.6 to 1.9 kcal/mol. Doubly hybrid methods using B2GP-PLYP and DSD-BLYP functionals and MP2 calculation also provide satisfactory accuracy with MUEs of 1.4 to 1.5 kcal/mol. If the Ng bond energies and the total atomization energies of a group of 109 main-group molecules are considered at the same time, the MPW1B95/aug-cc-pVTZ single-level method (MUE = 2.7 kcal/mol) and the B2GP-PLYP and DSD-PLYP functionals with combinations of basis sets or using the doubly hybrid method (MUEs = 1.9-2.2 kcal/mol) give the overall best result.     

Cooperative enhancement of water binding to crownophane by multiple hydrogen bonds: analysis by high level ab initio calculations.

The intermolecular interaction energy of the model system of the water-crownophane complex was analyzed. The water molecule has four hydrogen bonds, with the two hydrogen-donating phenolic hydroxy groups and two hydrogen-accepting oxygen atoms of the poly-oxyethylene chain of the crownophane in the complex. The MP2/6-311G(2d,2p) level calculations of the model system of the complex (hydrogen donating unit + hydrogen accepting unit + water) indicate that the binding energy of the water is 21.85 kcal/mol and that the hydrogen bond cooperativity increases the binding energy as much as 3.67 kcal/mol. The calculated interaction energies depend on the basis set, while the basis set dependence of the cooperative increment is negligible. Most of the cooperative increment is covered by the HF level calculation, which suggests that the major source of the hydrogen bond cooperativity in this system has its origin in induction. The BLYP/6-311G** and PW91/6-311G** level interaction energies of the model system are close to the MP2/6-311G** interaction energies, which suggests that the DFT calculations with these functionals are useful methods to evaluated the interactions of hydrogen bonded systems.     

The lithium–thiophene interaction: a critical study using highly correlated electronic structure approaches of quantum chemistry

The fundamental multicentric interaction of a lithium atom with a single thiophene ring is addressed. A systematic study of the interaction energy (IE) and geometry for the Li–T charge-transfer complex is done at the MP2 and CCSD(T) levels using increasingly large basis sets up to aug-cc-pVQZ (AVQZ). Basis set superposition errors (BSSE) are evaluated and shown to have a major impact on the value of the IE. The Fixed-Node Diffusion Monte Carlo (FN-DMC) method is used as an alternative basis-set-free approach to obtain what is likely to be the most accurate estimate of the IE obtained so far. While counterpoise-corrected MP2/AVQZ and CCSD(T)/AVTZ interaction energies are found to be ?3.8 and ?7.5 kcal/mol, the FN-DMC method yields +1.3 ± 1.7 kcal/mol. The slow convergence of the ab initio IE (and some key structural parameters) with respect to basis set quality and the discrepancy with the FN-DMC result is discussed. A visualization of the electron pairing using the electron pair localization function (EPLF) for the Li-doped versus undoped thiophene is also presented.     

Quantum mechanical study of the nonbonded forces in water-methanol complexes

The water-methanol dimer can adopt two possible configurations (WdM or MdW) depending on whether the water or the methanol acts as the hydrogen bond donor. The relative stability between the two configurations is less than 1 kcal/mol, and as a result, this dimer has been a challenging system to investigate using either theoretical or experimental techniques. In this paper, we present a systematic study of the dependence of the geometries, interaction energies, and harmonic frequencies on basis sets and treatment of electron correlation for the two configurations. At the highest theory level, MP2/aug-cc-pVQZ//MP2/aug-cc-pVTZ, interaction energies of -5.72 and -4.95 kcal/mol were determined for the WdM and MdW configurations, respectively, after correcting for basis set superposition error using the Boys-Bernardi counterpoise scheme. Extrapolating to the complete basis set limit resulted in interaction energies of -5.87 for WdM and -5.16 kcal/mol for MdW. The energy difference between the two configurations is larger than the majority of previously reported values, confirming that the WdM complex is preferred, in agreement with experimental observations. The effects that electron correlation have on the geometry were investigated by performing optimization at the MP2(full), MP4, and CCSD levels of theory. The approach trajectories for the formation of each dimer configuration are presented and the importance of these trajectories in the development of parameters for use in classical force fields is discussed.     

Quantum dynamics of vibrationally activated OH-CO reactant complexes

The MP2 complete basis set (CBS) limit for the binding energy of the two low-lying water octamer isomers of D2d and S4 symmetry is estimated at -72.7+/-0.4 kcal/mol using the family of augmented correlation-consistent orbital basis sets of double through quintuple zeta quality. The largest MP2 calculation with the augmented quintuple zeta (aug-cc-pV5Z) basis set produced binding energies of -73.70 (D2d) and -73.67 kcal/mol (S4). The effects of higher correlation, computed at the CCSD(T) level of theory, are estimated at <0.1 kcal/mol. The newly established MP2/CBS limit for the water octamer is reproduced quite accurately by the newly developed all atom polarizable, flexible interaction potential (TTM2-F). The TTM2-F binding energies of -73.21 (D2d) and -73.24 kcal/mol (S4) for the two isomers are just 0.5 kcal/mol (or 0.7%) larger than the MP2/CBS limit.     

Probing phenylalanine/adenine pi-stacking interactions in protein complexes with explicitly correlated and CCSD(T) computations

To examine the effects of pi-stacking interactions between aromatic amino acid side chains and adenine bearing ligands in crystalline protein structures, 26 toluene/(N9-methyl)adenine model configurations have been constructed from protein/ligand crystal structures. Full geometry optimizations with the MP2 method cause the 26 crystal structures to collapse to six unique structures. The complete basis set (CBS) limit of the CCSD(T) interaction energies has been determined for all 32 structures by combining explicitly correlated MP2-R12 computations with a correction for higher-order correlation effects from CCSD(T) calculations. The CCSD(T) CBS limit interaction energies of the 26 crystal structures range from -3.19 to -6.77 kcal mol (-1) and average -5.01 kcal mol (-1). The CCSD(T) CBS limit interaction energies of the optimized complexes increase by roughly 1.5 kcal mol (-1) on average to -6.54 kcal mol (-1) (ranging from -5.93 to -7.05 kcal mol (-1)). Corrections for higher-order correlation effects are extremely important for both sets of structures and are responsible for the modest increase in the interaction energy after optimization. The MP2 method overbinds the crystal structures by 2.31 kcal mol (-1) on average compared to 4.50 kcal mol (-1) for the optimized structures.     

A systematic ab initio study of the water dimer in hierarchies of basis sets and correlation models

A systematic, high-level ab initio investigation of the water dimer has been performed. The oxygen-oxygen bond distance has been estimated to be around 2.90 ?, about 0.05 ? shorter than the experimentally estimated distance, challenging the accuracy of the latter. The interaction energy has been obtained at −5.0±0.1 kcal/mol, which compares favourably with the experimentally estimated value of −5.4±0.7 kcal/mol. The importance of employing basis sets that include diffuse functions in correlated calculations on hydrogen-bonded systems is confirmed. In correlated calculations on the water dimer and the hydrogen fluoride dimer, the counterpoise-corrected interaction energies converge considerably slower towards the basis set limit than do the uncorrected energies, provided that the correlation-consistent basis sets are augmented with diffuse functions. Received: 12 February 1997 / Accepted: 5 June 1997     

Amide–π interactions between formamide and benzene

High‐level ab initio calculations have been carried out using a formamide–benzene model system to evaluate amide–π interactions. The interaction energies were estimated as a sum of the CCSD(T) correlation contribution and the HF energy at the complete basis set limit, for the geometries of the model structures at the energy minimum obtained by potential energy surface (PES) scans. NH/π geometry in a face‐on configuration was found to be the most attractive among the various geometries considered, with interaction energy of ?3.75 kcal/mol. An interaction energy of ?2.08 kcal/mol was calculated for the stacked N/Center type geometry, where the nitrogen atom of formamide points directly toward the center of the aromatic ring. The weakest C?O/π geometry, where a carbonyl oxygen atom points toward the plane of the aromatic ring, was found to have energy minimum at an intermolecular distance of 3.67 Å from the PES, with a repulsive interaction energy less than 1 kcal/mol. However, if there are simultaneous attractive interactions with other parts of the molecule besides the amide group, the weak repulsion could be easily overcome, to give a C?O/π geometry interaction. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Comput Chem, 2009