Radioactive contaminants in the subsurface: the influence of complexing ligands on trace metal speciation

Equilibrium thermodynamics is one of the pillars which support safety analyses of repositories for radioactive waste. The research summarized in this review deals with approaches to resolve the problems related to thermodynamic equilibrium constants and solubility of solid phases in the field of radioactive waste management. The results have been obtained at the Paul Scherrer Institut between 1995 and 2005 and comprise the scientific basis of the author’s habilitation thesis in the field of nuclear environmental chemistry. The topics are grouped according to three different levels of problem solving strategies: (1) Critical and comprehensive reviews of the available literature, which are necessary in order to establish a reliable chemical thermodynamic database that fulfils the requirements for rigorous modeling of the behavior of the actinides and fission products in the environment. (2) In many case studies involving inorganic and simple organic ligands a serious lack of reliable thermodynamic data is encountered. There, a new modeling approach to estimate the effects of these missing data was applied. This so called “backdoor approach” begins with the question, “What total concentration of a ligand is necessary to significantly influence the speciation, and hence the solubility, of a given trace metal?” (3) In the field of natural organics, mainly humic and fulvic acids, we face an ill-defined problem concerning the molecular structure of the ligands. There, a pragmatic approach for performance assessment purposes was applied, the “conservative roof” approach, which does not aim to accurately model all experimental data, but allows estimates of maximum effects on metal complexation by humic substances to be calculated.     

The Ligand-Exchange Reactions of Rod-Like Au25-nMn (M=Au,Ag, Cu,Pd, Pt) Nanoclusters with Cysteine – A Density Functional Theory Study

The atomic precision of ultrasmall noble-metal nanoclusters (NMNs) is fundamental for elucidating structure-property relationships and probing their practical applications. So far, the atomic structure of NMNs protected by organic ligands has been widely elucidated, whereas the precise atomic structure of NMNs protected by water-soluble ligands (such as peptides and nucleic acid), has been rarely reported. With the concept of “precision to precision”, density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed to probe the thermodynamic plausibility and inherent determinants for synthesizing atomically precise, water-soluble NMNs via the framework-maintained two-phase ligand-exchange method. A series of rod-like Au_25-nM_n (M=Au, Ag, Cu, Pd, Pt) NMNs with the same framework but varied ligands and metal compositions was chosen as the modeling reactants, and cysteine was used as the modeling water-soluble ligand. It was found that the acidity of the reaction remarkably affects the thermodynamic facility of the ligand exchange reactions. Ligand effects (structural distortion and acidity) dominate the overall thermodynamic facility of the ligand-exchange reaction, while the number and type of doped metal atom(s) has little influence.     

Complexation of radionuclides with natural polyelectrolytes — proteins, polysaccharides and humic substances

Various approaches to the modeling of metal and radionuclide interactions with macromolecular ligands, proteins, polysaccharides and humic substances in particular, their chemical and sorption equilibria, and the techniques used for their investigation are concisely compared. To predict radionuclide mobility in the natural and semi-natural aqueous environment, the estimation of the effective interaction constants, related to specific species of polyelectrolytes which are linked with the absorbancy or absorbancy ratio in their electronic absorption spectra, should probably be preferred and developed as standard. For characterization of the binding sites of specific molecular forms of polyelectrolyte ligands, the Scatchard plot analysis at macroconcentrations of the metal and also, though not so effectively, the two-phase distribution at trace concentrations of radionuclide or metal can be applied.     

Metal Insertion into C−C Bonds in Solution

What kind of ligated metal center is necessary for insertion into the “hidden” C−C bond? How can one tune the metal center for C−C bond activation by variation of the steric and electronic properties of ligands? What are the possible mechanisms of C−C bond activation in various reaction systems? A systematic look at the available data on C−C bond activation in solution provides some answers to these questions.     

Metal ions binding onto a lignocellulosic substrate extracted from wheat bran: a NICA-Donnan approach

In this study ion binding to solid organic matter was investigated. We used the NICA-Donnan model to describe the interaction between Cu(II), Pb(II), and Cd(II) ions and a lignocellulosic substrate extracted from wheat bran. Such a material represents a very cheap and flexible substrate, which can be used as a natural filter to remove toxic metal ions from industrial effluents or applied in the decontamination and rehabilitation of abandoned industrial sites. Moreover, such a material also represents a very simple model of natural organic matter derived from lignin and cellulose, for which there is now a lack of thermodynamic data as far as their interaction with toxic metal ions is concerned. Experimental results were obtained in various conditions of pH and ionic strength. In our modeling, we used the acidity constants and the concentration of sites that were determined in a previous work. The parameters deduced from the NICA-Donnan model were also compared to thermodynamic data available for other cases of natural organic matter, mainly humic substances.     

Speciation of Neptunium Migration in under Groundwater

The migration of radionuclides with groundwater into the environment of a radioactive waste repository is an important aspect in evaluating the safety assessment of such repositories. The potential transport and fate of these radioactive species are dependent upon their speciation and the geochemical behavior of the predominant ones. The speciation of different valence states of neptunium [Np(IV, V and VI)] and their migration behavior are investigated. The data revealed that the uptake is highly dependent upon pH and the distribution coefficient (K _d) is depressed by the presence of organic ligands. The relative migration velocities (V _n) of the valence states relative to that of groundwater, in the concerned area, clarified that Np(V) is the most mobile species and their transport rates are highly accelerated by the presence of humic acid. Also, a radionuclide dispersion model was applied to elucidate the migration behavior of these radioactive species in the selected site and to quantitatively predict their concentrations at different distances in both x and z directions over long time scales.     

Trace metal speciation by adsorptive stripping voltammetry of metal chelates of solochrome violet RS

Adsorptive stripping voltammetry has become one of the most sensitive methods for trace metal determinations. The growing application of the method to natural water systems prompted an investigation into the fraction of the metal concentration that contributes to the adsorptive stripping response. Recent procedures for trace measurement of iron, titanium and gallium, based on chelation with solochrome violet RS (SVRS) are coupled to systematic ligand competition experiments. Tannic acid, EDTA, NTA, glycine, cysteine, carbonate and chloride ions are used as model natural ligands. It is shown that adsorptive stripping voltammetry measures the free ion and metal displaced from complexes by the “analytical” ligand. The exact fraction of the metal measured thus depends on the thermodynamic stability of the metal-SVRS chelate (compared to that of natural complexes), and on the relative concentrations of the competing ligands. The method offers possible distinction between metal complexes, based on their thermodynamic stabilities. The use ofa large excess of the “analytical” ligand can lead to measurement of the total metal content. Implications of these results relative to the use of this procedure for studying the speciation of trace elements in natural waters are discussed.     

Fe（Ⅱ）-矿物对亚硒酸的还原作用

79Se是核反应过程中产生的长半衰期（T1/2=2.95×105年）裂片产物核素,具有化学和辐射双重毒性,是高放废物地质处置中重点关注的几个放射性核素之一.硒的溶液化学性质比较特殊,以高价态形式存在的硒酸和亚硒酸,几乎不受溶解度控制,并难以被黏土或花岗岩等处置库围岩介质所吸附,迁移性极强,而当其以低价态（0、–I、–II）形式存在时,易形成固体沉淀.因此将高价态的硒还原生成沉淀是阻滞79Se迁移的最主要方式.从另一方面讲,Fe（II）-矿物是自然界中普遍存在的具有还原性的物质.本文对近年来国内外在Fe（II）-矿物还原亚硒酸方面开展的研究工作进行了一个回顾,并从热力学的角度,对这些矿物还原亚硒酸的可行性及控制产物生成的因素进行了分析.     

An alternative view on the kinetics of optical stimulated luminescence decay

In this work, it was made similitude between radioactive decay and luminescence decay. An alternative approach related with the radioactive decay law of successive disintegrations from a composite radioactive material to describe the optical stimulated luminescence (OSL) decay curve was introduced. The modified radioactive decay law was applied to find the individual components of the different synthetic and experimental OSL decay curves. The suggested relation was named as “Active-OSL Approximation”. This work offers an alternative view on the kinetics of OSL decay.     

Review of uranyl mineral solubility measurements

The solubility of uranyl minerals controls the transport and distribution of uranium in many oxidizing environments. Uranyl minerals form as secondary phases within uranium deposits, and they also represent important sinks for uranium and other radionuclides in nuclear waste repository settings and at sites of uranium groundwater contamination. Standard state Gibbs free energies of formation can be used to describe the solubility of uranyl minerals; therefore, models of the distribution and mobility of uranium in the environment require accurate determination of the Gibbs free energies of formation for a wide range of relevant uranyl minerals. Despite decades of study, the thermodynamic properties for many environmentally-important uranyl minerals are still not well constrained. In this review, we describe the necessary elements for rigorous solubility experiments that can be used to define Gibbs free energies of formation; we summarize published solubility data, point out difficulties in conducting uranyl mineral solubility experiments, and identify areas of future research necessary to construct an internally-consistent thermodynamic database for uranyl minerals.     

Predictive cartography of metal binders using generative topographic mapping

Generative topographic mapping (GTM) approach is used to visualize the chemical space of organic molecules (L) with respect to binding a wide range of 41 different metal cations (M) and also to build predictive models for stability constants (logK) of 1:1 (M:L) complexes using “density maps,” “activity landscapes,” and “selectivity landscapes” techniques. A two-dimensional map describing the entire set of 2962 metal binders reveals the selectivity and promiscuity zones with respect to individual metals or groups of metals with similar chemical properties (lanthanides, transition metals, etc). The GTM-based global (for entire set) and local (for selected subsets) models demonstrate a good predictive performance in the cross-validation procedure. It is also shown that the data likelihood could be used as a definition of the applicability domain of GTM-based models. Thus, the GTM approach represents an efficient tool for the predictive cartography of metal binders, which can both visualize their chemical space and predict the affinity profile of metals for new ligands.     

Characterization of groundwater humic and fulvic acids of different origin by GPC with UV/Vis and fluorescence detection

Gel permeation chromatography (GPC) was applied for recognizing the origin of groundwater humic and fulvic acids. GPC was performed with Fraktogel TSK HW-50 in 0.1 M NaCl, pH 8.5 (0.05 M phosphate buffer), 1 mM EDTA, with 10% by volume methanol added. Humic substances from groundwaters and sediments of four different aquifer systems in Germany were isolated, purified and characterized. Both UV/Vis and fluorescence detection were applied. UV/Vis detection was found to be more powerful in identifying differences between the various humic and fulvic acids. The four aquifer systems investigated (“Gorleben”, “Fuhrberg”, “Franconian Albvorland” and “Munich”) differed from one another with respect to hydrological and geochemical conditions. The results showed that the GPC-elution behavior reflects the geochemical environment and origin (source material and generation process) of aquatic humic and fulvic acids.     

Free and bound phenolic compounds in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) flours. evaluation of the extraction capability of different solvent mixtures and pressurized liquid methods by micellar electrokinetic chromatography and spectrophotometry

The solution speciation of metals is a critical parameter controlling the bioavailability, solution-solid phase distribution and transport of metals in soils. The natural metal-complexing ligands that exist in soil solution include inorganic anions, inorganic colloids, organic humic substances, amino acids (notably phytosiderophores and bacterial siderophores) and low-molecular mass organic acids. The latter two groups are of particular significance in the soil surrounding plant roots (the rhizosphere). A number of analytical methodologies, encompassing computational, spectroscopic, physico-chemical and separation techniques, have been applied to the measurement of the solution speciation of metals in the environment. However, perhaps with the exception of the determination of the free metal cation, the majority of these techniques rarely provide species specific information. High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) coupled to a sensitive detection system, such as inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) or electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), offers the possibility of separating and detecting metal-organic acid complexes at the very low concentrations normally found in the soil environment. This review, therefore, critically examines the literature reporting the HPLC separation of metal-organic acid complexes with reference to thermodynamic equilibrium and kinetic considerations. The limitations of HPLC techniques (and the use of thermodynamic equilibrium calculations to validate analytical results) are discussed and the metal complex characteristics necessary for chromatographic separation are described.     

Insights into Modeling Approaches in Chemistry: Assessing Ligand-Protein Binding Thermodynamics Based on Rigid-Flexible Model Molecules

In the field of chemistry, model compounds find extensive use for investigating complex objects. One prime example of such object is the protein-ligand supramolecular interaction. Prediction the enthalpic and entropic contribution to the free energy associated with this process, as well as the structural and dynamic characteristics of protein-ligand complexes poses considerable challenges. This review exemplifies modeling approaches used to study protein-ligand binding (PLB) thermodynamics by employing pairs of conformationally constrained/flexible model molecules. Strategically designing the model molecules can reduce the number of variables that influence thermodynamic parameters. This enables scientists to gain deeper insights into the enthalpy and entropy of PLB, which is relevant for medicinal chemistry and drug design. The model studies reviewed here demonstrate that rigidifying ligands may induce compensating changes in the enthalpy and entropy of binding. Some “rules of thumb” have started to emerge on how to minimize entropy-enthalpy compensation and design efficient rigidified or flexible ligands.     

Solubility of sinapic acid in various (Carbitol + water) systems: computational modeling and solution thermodynamics

Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry - The solubility and solution thermodynamic properties of a “bioactive nutraceutical” sinapic acid (SA) in different...     

Online analysis of europium and gadolinium species complexed or uncomplexed with humic acid by capillary electrophoresis–inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

Detailed information on the geochemical behavior of radioactive and toxic metal ions under environmental conditions (in geological matrices and aquifer systems) is needed in order to assess the long-term safety of waste repositories. This includes knowledge of the mechanisms of relevant geochemical reactions, as well as associated thermodynamic and kinetic data. Several previous studies have shown that humic acid can play an important role in the immobilization or mobilization of metal ions due to complexation and colloid formation. In our project we investigate the complexation behavior of (purified Aldrich) humic acid and its influence on the migration of the lanthanides europium and gadolinium (homologs of the actinides americium and curium) in the ternary system consisting of these heavy metals, humic acid and kaolinite (KGa-1b) under almost natural conditions. Capillary electrophoresis (CE, Beckman Coulter P/ACE MDQ), with its excellent separation performance, was hyphenated with a homemade interface to inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP–MS, VG Elemental PlasmaQuad 3) giving a system that is highly sensitive to the rare-earth element species of europium and gadolinium with humic acid. The humic acid used was also halogenated with iodine, which acted as an ICP–MS marker. To couple CE to ICP–MS, a fused silica CE capillary was flexibly fitted into a MicroMist 50 μl nebulizer with a Cinnabar cyclonic spray chamber in the external homemade interface. The chamber was chilled to a temperature of 4 °C to optimize the sensitivity. 200 ppb of cesium were added to the CE separation buffer so that the capillary flow could be observed. A make-up fluid including 4 ppb Ho as an internal standard was combined with the flow from the capillary within the interface in order to get a fluid throughput high enough to maintain continuous nebulization. Very low detection limits were achieved: 125 ppt for ¹⁵³Eu and 250 ppt for ¹⁵⁸Gd. Using this optimized CE–ICP–MS coupling system it was possible to quantify metal concentrations from the detection limit up to approximately 1 ppm (the linear range). This set-up was used to separate metal/humic acid-species in a 100 mM acetic acid/10 mM acetate buffer system. Using humic acid as the complexing ligand, uncomplexed metal ion species could be separated from metal–humate complexes on a time-resolved scale.      

Actinide speciation in the environment

Nuclear test explosions and nuclear reactor wastes and accidents have released large amounts of radioactivity into the environment. Actinideions in waters often are not in a state of thermodynamic equilibrium and their solubility and migration behavior is related to the form in which the nuclides are introduced into the aquatic system. Chemical speciation, oxidation state, redox reactions, and sorption characteristics are necessary in predicting solubility of the different actinides, their migration behaviors and their potential effects on marine biota. The most significant of these variables is the oxidation state of the metal ion as the simultaneous presence of more than one oxidation state for some actinides in a solution complicates actinide environmental behavior. Both Np(V)O₂ ⁺ and Pu(V)O₂ ⁺, the most significant soluble states in natural oxic waters, are relatively noncomplexing and resistant to hydrolysis and subsequent precipitation. The solubility of NpO₂ ⁺ can be as high as 10⁻⁴M while that of PuO₂ ⁺ is much more limited by reduction to the insoluble tetravalent species, Pu(OH)₄, (pK_sp≥56) but which can be present in the pentavalent form in aqautic phases as colloidal material. The solubility of hexavalent UO₂ ²⁺ in sea water is relatively high due to formation of carbonate complexes. The insoluble trivalent americium hydroxocarbonate, Am(OH)(CO₃) is the limiting species for the solubility of Am(III) in sea water. Thorium(IV) is present as Th(OH)₄, in colloidal form. The chemistry of actinide ions in the environment is reviewed to show the spectrum of reactions that can occur in natural waters which must be considered in assessing the environmental behavior of actinides. Much is understood about sorption of actinides on surfaces, the mode of migration of actinides in such waters and the potential effects of these radioactive species on marine biota, but much more understanding of the behavior of the actinides in the environment is needed to allow proper and reliable modeling needed for disposition of nuclear waste over many thousands of years. This paper has been presented as a Hevesy Medal Award Lecture by the medalist author at the 1st International Nuclear Chemistry Congress (1st-INCC), 22–29 May 2005, Kusadasi, Turkey