Photosensory transduction in unicellular eukaryotes: a comparison between related ciliates Blepharisma japonicum and Stentor coeruleus and photoreceptor cells of higher organisms

Blepharisma japonicum and Stentor coeruleus are related ciliates, conspicuous by their photosensitivity. They are capable of avoiding illuminated areas in the surrounding medium, gathering exclusively in most shaded places (photodispersal). Such behaviour results mainly from motile photophobic response occurring in ciliates. This light-avoiding response is observed during a relatively rapid increase in illumination intensity (light stimulus) and consists of cessation of cell movement, a period of backward movement (ciliary reversal), followed by a forward swimming, usually in a new direction. The photosensitivity of ciliates is ascribed to their photoreceptor system, composed of pigment granules, containing the endogenous photoreceptor -- blepharismin in Blepharisma japonicum, and stentorin in Stentor coeruleus. A light stimulus, applied to both ciliates activates specific stimulus transduction processes leading to the electrical changes at the plasma membrane, correlated with a ciliary reversal during photophobic response. These data indicate that both ciliates Blepharisma japonicum and Stentor coeruleus, the lower eukaryotes, are capable of transducing the perceived light stimuli in a manner taking place in some photoreceptor cells of higher eukaryotes. Similarities and differences concerning particular stages of light transduction in eukaryotes at different evolutional levels are discussed in this article.     

EFFECTS OF K+ AND Ca2+ IONS ON MOTILITY AND PHOTOSENSORY RESPONSES OF STENTOR COERULEUS

Extracellular K⁺ ions above a critical concentration induce ciliary reversal in unstimulated Stentor coeruleus and suppress step-up photophobic response. This threshold concentration of K⁺ ions depends on the extracellular Ca²⁺ concentration, and the subsequent backward gyration and light-sensitivity suppression seem to depend on the relative concentrations of K⁺ and Ca²⁺. The concentration of Ca²⁺ necessary to overcome K⁺-mediated inhibition of phobic response and backward swimming increases non-linearly with increasing K⁺ concentration. The Ca²⁺-blocking agent. D-600, selectively inhibits photophobic responses of Stentor , thus further confirming the role of Ca²⁺ ions in photosensory transduction of this ciliate.     

ACTION SPECTRUM AND ELECTROPHYSIOLOGICAL RESPONSES CORRELATED WITH THE PHOTOPHOBIC RESPONSE OF STENTOR COERULEUS

Abstract— The blue-green ciliate. Stentor coeruleus , is found predominantly in shady places. This concentration occurs because stentor responds when swimming from a shaded area to a lighted area by reversing the direction of its ciliary beat and reorienting its swimming direction until it once again is in the shaded area. A graded receptor potential is recorded from microelectrodes in vacuoles of stentor when the animal is photically stimulated. For all but very weak stimuli this receptor potential is sufficient to elicit a regenerative transmembrane response of variable amplitude in a swimming animal. Suprathreshold electrical stimuli also elicit this regenerative response. In turn the regenerative response is coupled to ciliary reversal. Thus ciliary reversal appears to be produced whenever the photic receptor potential crosses the threshold for elicitation of the regenerative response.
Using the threshold for production of ciliary reversal as a criterion response, an action spectrum was obtained. This action spectrum correlates well with the absorption spectrum of the major pigment of S. coeruleus , stentorin. Stentor bleached of pigment also have an elevated threshold for ciliary reversal. Thus stentorin seems to be the photosensitive pigment in stentor responsible for its photophobic behavior.     

PHOTOSENSORY TRANSDUCTION IN CILIATES. I. AN ANALYSIS OF LIGHT-INDUCED ELECTRICAL AND MOTILE RESPONSES IN Stentor coeruleus

Abstract— Light-induced membrane potantial changes and motile responses have been studied in Stentor cells with intracellular microelectrodes and video microscopy, respectively. Intracellulae microelectrode showed that step-up increase in light induced an electrical membrane response which consisted of an initial membrane depolarization (photoreceptor potential) followed by an action potential and maintaining phase of depolarization (afterdepolarization). The amplitude of the receptor potetial is dependent on the intensity of light stimulus and the action potetials appears with a lag period (latency) after the onset of light stimuklus. The extent of the membrane established between the latency for te action poitential and the onset of ciliary reversal (stop responses). A time correlation was also observed between the duration of the membrane afterdepolarization and the duration of backward swimming. the action spectrum for the photoreceptor potential amplitude of Stentor resembled the action spectra for the latency of ciliary reversal and the photoresponsiveness, iondicating that the photomovement response and membrane potential changes are coupled through the same photosensor system. A hypothesis on the photosensory transduction chain in Stentor is discussed according to ehich the photoreceptors and the ciliary apparatus is mediated by the membrane potential canges.     

Stentor coeruleus SHOWS POSITIVE PHOTOKINESIS

Abstract— Stentor coeruleus responds to a sudden increase in light intensity with a step-up photophobic response (avoiding reaction), and to collimated light with negative phototaxis. The peaks of the action spectra for the photophobic response and for the phototaxis are in common, 610 nm.
5. coeruleus showed changes in its steady-state swimming velocity induced with varying intensities of light (photokinesis). The cells swam fast in light regions but slowly in dark ones (positive photokinesis); the mean velocity of swimming was about 0.6 mm/s at 100 lx but reached about 1.0 mm/s at 50000 lx. The peak of the action spectrum for this photokinesis was about 680 nm.
The organism is the first protozoan cell reported to show three types of photoresponse: photophobic response, phototaxis and photokinesis.     

Contribution of phosphoinositide-dependent signalling to photomotility of Blepharisma ciliate

The effect of experimental procedures designed to modify an intracellular phosphoinositide signalling pathway, which may be instrumental in the photophobic response of the protozoan ciliate Blepharisma japonicum, has been investigated. To assess this issue, the latency time of the photophobic response and the cell photoresponsiveness have been assayed employing newly developed computerized videorecording and standard macro-photographic methods. Cell incubation with neomycin, heparin and Li+, drugs known to greatly impede phosphoinositide turnover, causes evident dose-dependent changes in cell photomotile behaviour. The strongest effect on photoresponses is exerted by neomycin, a potent inhibitor of polyphosphoinositide hydrolysis. The presence of micromolar concentrations of neomycin in the cell medium causes both prolongation of response latency and decrease of cell photoresponsiveness. Neomycin at higher concentrations (> 10 microM) abolishes the cell response to light at the highest applied intensity. A slightly lower inhibition of cell responsiveness to light stimulation and prolongation of response latency are observed in cells incubated in the presence of heparin, an inositol trisphosphate receptor antagonist. Lithium ions, widely known to deplete the intracellular phosphoinositide pathway intermediate, inositol trisphosphate, added to the cell medium at millimolar level, also cause a slowly developing inhibitory effect on cell photoresponses. Mastoparan, a specific G-protein activator, efficiently mimics the effect of light stimulation. In dark-adapted ciliates, it elicits ciliary reversal with the response latency typical for ciliary reversal during the photophobic response. Sustained treatment of Blepharisma cells with mastoparan also suppresses the photoresponsiveness, as in the case of cell adaptation to light during prolonged illumination. The mastoparan-induced responses can be eliminated by pretreatment of the cells with neomycin. Moreover, using antibodies raised against bovine transducin, a cross-reacting protein with an apparent molecular mass of about 55 kDa in the Blepharisma cortex fraction is detected on immunoblots. The obtained results indirectly suggest that the changes in internal inositol trisphosphate level, possibly elicited by G-protein-coupled phospholipase C, might play a role in the photophobic response of Blepharisma. However, further experiments are necessary to clarify the possible coupling between the G-protein and the putative phospholipase C.     

CAFFEINE-ENHANCED PHOTOMOVEMENT IN THE CILIATE, STENTOR COERULEUS

The effects of caffeine, ionophores and calcium flux blockers on the step-up photophobic response, phototactic orientation and the intracellularly recorded, light-induced electrical action potential were studied in the ciliate, Stentor coeruleus . Caffeine alters the absorption and CD spectra and enhances the fluorescence of the photoreceptor pigment, stentorin. Independent of its effects on the spectroscopic properties of the photoreceptor pigment, caffeine shortens the photophobic response time by enhancing the Ca²⁺ conductivity of membranes, while Ca²⁺ flux blockers (LaCI₃ or ruthenium red) prolong it; both effects cancel each other. Evidence is presented that phototactic orientation is brought about by repetitive photophobic responses, since a change in the phobic response time results in a decreased accuracy of phototaxis.     

PHOTORECEPTOR PIGMENT IN Blepharisma: H+ RELEASE FROM RED PIGMENT

In faded cells of Blepharisma kept in a standard saline solution containing bacteria which had been cultured on agar plates containing glucose and polypepton, threshold light intensity for step-up photophobic response elevated. This result suggests that red pigment (blepharismin) contained in Blepharisma cells is involved in the step-up photophobic response. The pH of the aqueous solution of the red pigment was found to decrease when light was applied, indicating that the pigment releases H⁺ in response to light stimulation. However, faded pigment preparation by light irradiation did not show pH decrease. In the living cells faded by light irradiation, threshold light intensity for the step-up photophobic response was raised. Results suggest that H⁺ release from the red pigment induced by light irradiation might be responsible for the step-up photophobic response of the cells.     

PHOTOSENSORY TRANSDUCTION IN CILIATES. III. THE TEMPORAL RELATION BETWEEN MEMBRANE POTENTIALS AND PHOTOMOTILE RESPONSES IN Blepharisma japonic urn

Abstract— Blepharisma japonicum exhibits a step-up photophobic response when subjected to an increase in light stimulus intensity. This response is characterized by the stop reaction after a period of delay followed by backward swimming (lateral rotation). The latency of the stop response decreased and duration of the lateral rotation increased as the intensity of light stimuli was raised. A step-increase in light intensity elicited a graded membrane depolarization (photic receptor potential), as measured by intracellular microelectrode. When the amplitude of receptor potential exceeded a threshold depolarization for membrane excitation (15–25 mV), an all-or-none action potential of 50–65 mV in amplitude was evoked which also occurred with some latency. Light stimuli of higher intensity (suprathreshold) elicited action potential which was followed by a membrane after-depolarization. Increasing the intensity of stimuli caused generation of an action potential with shorter lag period and prolonged after-depolarization. The action spectra for the latency of stop reaction, receptor potential amplitude and cell photoresponsiveness showed maxima at 460, 530 and 580 nm. The analysis of temporal relationships between the electrophysiological responses and the motile events showed that latency of an action potential, induced by the receptor potential, correlates well with the latency of a cell stop response. Also the duration of membrane after-depolarization resembled the time period of the cell's backward swimming (cell rotation). The data obtained indicate that the primary reaction initiated by light absorption in the photoreceptor pigment (blepharismin) is converted into the observed electrical potential changes, which in turn results in the photomotile response of Blepharisma cells.     

LIGHT REACTIONS OF THE CILIATE Stentor coeruleus-A THREE-DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS

A computer-controlled three-dimensional tracking and motion analysis system was developed to study the responses of Stentor coeruleus to short light pulses and to evaluate its distribution patterns. In addition to photokinesis and phototaxis, the step-up photophobic response was analyzed, which includes a gravity-controlled component at higher fluence rates and a light direction-dependent component at lower fluence rates.     

Additional evidence for the cyclic GMP signaling pathway resulting in the photophobic behavior of Stentor coeruleus.

We report that exo- and endogenous guanosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cGMP) specifically influenced the photophobic response. In behavioral experiments the slowly hydrolyzable and membrane-permeable analogs of cGMP (8-bromo-cGMP [Br-cGMP] and N6,2'-o-dibutyryl-cGMP) dramatically prolonged the time for ciliary stop response and decreased the duration of ciliary reversal in a dose-dependent manner. When analogs of adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) (8-bromo-cAMP or N6,2'-o-dibutyryl-cAMP) were used, no essential effects were detected on the kinetics of the photophobic response. Both nonspecific cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase (PDE) activity inhibitors (3-isobutyl-1-methylxanthine [IBMX] and 1,3-dimethylxanthine [theophylline]) and the highly specific cGMP-PDE activity inhibitor 1,4-dihydro-5-[2-propoxyphenyl]-7H-1,2,3-triazolo[4,5-d]pyrimidine-7-one (zaprinast) mimicked the effects of cGMP analogs. Treatment of cells with an inhibitor of guanylate cyclase activity (6-anilino-5,8-quinolinedione [LY 83583]) exerted an effect opposite to that of cGMP analogs and PDE activity inhibitors. The positive physiological effect of LY 83583 was significantly diminished in ciliates that were treated simultaneously with Br-cGMP. In an assay of cell cyclic nucleotide content, the exposure of dark-adapted Stentor to light evoked a transient decrease in the basal level of intracellular cGMP. Alterations in internal cGMP levels were more distinct when the intensity of applied illumination was increased. In the presence of IBMX or theophylline the basal content of cGMP was markedly enhanced, and the photoinduced changes in cGMP level were less pronounced. In this paper the possible whole molecular mechanism by which the ciliary orientation in Stentor is controlled by light is presented.     

BEHAVIORAL RESPONSES IN Paramecium multimicronucleatum TO VISIBLE LIGHT

Specimens of colorless Paramecium multimicronucleatum were found to respond to visible light. They accumulated in the shaded region (photodispersal) of a half-shaded glass tube during 2 min exposure to visible light. The specimens showed avoiding reaction upon both spatial and temporal increase in light intensity (step-up photophobic response). Steady-state swimming velocity (orthokinesis) was higher, while steady-state frequency of spontaneous change in swimming direction (klinokinesis) was lower when the light intensity was kept higher. In a light with wavelength of 440 nm the velocity was highest, while the frequency was lowest. The specimens did not show phototaxis (light direction-oriented locomotion). Spectral sensitivity curves for both the photodispersal and the step-up photophobic response showed a major peak at 520 nm and a minor peak at 680 nm. The photodispersal seems to be caused mainly by the step-up photophobic response exhibited by the specimens at the dark-light border. The photokinetic responses enhance the degree of the photodispersal.     

Localization of Blepharismin Photosensors and Identification of a Photoreceptor Complex Mediating the Step-up Photophobic Response of the Unicellular Organism, Blepharisma

Abstract— Photosensitivity for the step-up photophobic response of Blepharisma is localized in the anterior 1/5 of the cell body. Blepharismin pigment, which is believed to be a photoreceptor pigment mediating the step-up photophobic response of the cells, was separated into five types of blepharismin (BL-1, -2, -3, -4 and -5). Blepharismin-1, -3, -4 and -5 were localized in the posterior 4/5, while BL-2 was located over the entire cell body; the anterior end, which is the photosensitive region, contained only BL-2. The results indicate that a functional photoreceptor pigment mediating the step-up photophobic response is BL-2. Hydroxylapatite chromatography revealed that BL-2 was bound to a 200 kDa membrane protein. We concluded that a photoreceptor mediating the step-up photophobic response was a BL-2/200 kDa protein complex.     

Maristentorin, a novel pigment from the positively phototactic marine ciliate Maristentor dinoferus, is structurally related to hypericin and stentorin

The photoreceptor pigment of the heterotrich ciliate, Maristentor dinoferus, has been characterized. It is structurally similar to those of Stentor coeruleus and Blepharisma japonicum but differs significantly in that it bears no aromatic hydrogens. The structure of the pigment, maristentorin, is based upon the hypericin skeleton, and its spectra are nearly identical to those of hypericin but shifted toward the red. Within experimental error, its fluorescence lifetime is identical to that of hypericin, approximately 5.5 ns in dimethylsulfoxide. It is remarkable that while the pigments are structurally similar in S. coeruleus and M. dinoferus, in the former there is an abrupt photophobic response, whereas in the latter there is a slow response toward light. The roles of the hypericin-like pigments in the heterotrich ciliates are discussed as potentially analogous in Maristentor.     

ISOLATION OF BLEPHARISMIN-BINDING 200 kDa PROTEIN RESPONSIBLE FOR BEHAVIOR IN Blepharisma

Abstract— The ciliated protozoan, Blepharisma, shows an avoidance reaction (step-up photophobic response) in response to light stimulation. A profile of a gel-permeation of a crude detergent-solubilized sample of the cells resulted in several red-colored fractions. Among these blepharismin-containing fractions, the fractions III-V did not contain amino acids. The peak of fraction II monitored by 580 nm absorbance was much smaller. A prominent peak appeared in fraction I, which contained a large amount of amino acids. The absorption spectrum of fraction I was well fitted to the action spectrum of the step-up photophobic response, although free pigment (blepharismin) also fitted. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of this fraction resulted in a thicker band corresponding to molecular mass of 200 kDa. These results suggest that the 200 kDa chromoprotein (blepharismin-protein complex) is responsible for the step-up photophobic response in Blepharisma. The absorption spectrum of free chromophore dissociated from the chromophore-protein complex was identical to free red pigment termed blepharismin. The absorption spectrum of the other fractions agreed with that of thin-layer chromatography-purified red pigment, indicating that the pigments contained in these fractions are free pigment dissociated from the chromophore-protein complex.     

Alterations of ciliate phosducin phosphorylation in Blepharisma japonicum cells

We have previously reported that motile photophobic response in ciliate Blepharisma japonicum correlates with dephosphorylation of a cytosolic 28 kDa phosphoprotein (PP28) exhibiting properties similar to those of phosducin. Here we demonstrate in in vivo phosphorylation assay that the light-elicited dephosphorylation of the PP28 is significantly modified by cell incubation with substances known to modulate protein phosphatase and kinase activities. Immunoblot analyses showed that incubation of ciliates with okadaic acid and calyculin A, potent inhibitors of type 1 or 2A protein phosphatases, distinctly increased phosphorylation of PP28 in dark-adapted cells and markedly weakened dephosphorylation of the ciliate phosducin following cell illumination. An enhancement of PP28 phosphorylation was also observed in dark-adapted ciliates exposed to 8-Br-cAMP and 8-Br-cGMP, slowly hydrolysable cyclic nucleotide analogs and 3-isobutyryl-1-methylxanthine (IBMX), a non-specific cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase (PDEs) inhibitor. Only slight changes in light-evoked dephosphorylation levels of PP28 were observed in cells treated with the cyclic nucleotide analogs and IBMX. Incubation of ciliates with H 89 or KT 5823, highly selective inhibitor of cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) and cGMP-dependent protein kinase (PKG), respectively, decreased PP28 phosphorylation levels in dark-adapted cells, whereas the extent of light-evoked dephosphorylation of the phosphoprotein was only slightly influenced. Cell treatment with higher Ca2+ concentration together with ionophore A23187 in culture medium resulted in marked increase in PP28 phosphorylation levels, while quite an opposite effect was observed in cells exposed to Ca2+ chelators, EGTA or BAPTA/AM as well as calmodulin antagonists, such as trifluoperazine (TFP), W-7 or calmidazolium. Light-dependent dephosphorylation was not considerably affected by these treatments. The experimental findings presented here suggest that an endogenous light-dependent protein kinase-phosphatase system may be engaged in the alteration of phosducin phosphorylation in ciliate B. japonicum thereby to modulate the cell motile photophobic behavior.     

PHOTOTACTIC ORIENTATION BY THE CILIATE, STENTOR COERULEUS

Stentor coeruleus exhibits negative phototaxis to visible light, in addition to a step-up photophobic response. The negative phototaxis was established by demonstrating the swimming of Stentor toward a focused beam away from the light source. The action spectrum showed a maximum at 610–620 nm and is essentially identical to that of the step-up photophobic response. Proton uncouplers such as micromolar concentrations of FCCP and TPMP⁺ inhibited the negative phototaxis.     

ACTION SPECTRA OF THE PHOTOPHOBIC RESPONSE OF BLUE AND RED FORMS OF Blepharisma japonicum

Abstract— When exposed, in the presence of molecular oxygen, to light intensities of the order of3–30 W m^-2, the ciliate Blepharisma japonicum changes its color from red to blue, because of the photooxidation of the photoreceptor pigment, blepharismin, to pxyblepharismin. Both red-and blue-pigmnentes cells show step-up photophobic responses. The action spectra f the light-dependent behaviour of the red and the blue form of Blepharisma have been determined; their structure is very similar to that the photosensing and phototransducing properties of blepharismin are maintained in its photooxidized form. oxyblepharismin.     

PHOTOSENSORY TRANSDUCTION IN CILIATES. II. POSSIBLE ROLE OF G-PROTEIN AND cGMP IN Stentor coeruleus

Abstract— The heterotrichous ciliate, Stentor coerulus , exhibits a welll defines photophobic response to a sudden increase in the intensity of visible light. the phobic reactions usually appear with a latency perios (i.e. a time delay between the onset of the stimulus and the stop response). This latency of phobic response was significatly increased when the cells werw incubated with 8-bromo-guanosine3',5'-cyclic monophospjhate. In the presence of this nucleotide, a reduction of cell responsiveness (i.e. the number of photophobically responding cells) was also observed. similar effects were observed when cells were treated with pertussis toxin, a G-protein activity modulator, and 3'-isobutyl-methylxanthine, an inhibitor of guanosine 3', 5'-cyclic monophosphate (cGMP) phosphodiesterase. the G-protein activator fluoroaluminate and 6-anilino-5,8-quinolinedione (LY 83583) (an effective agent for lowerin cellular cGMP levels) showed opposite effects on hte cell photophobic response. These result indirectly suggesnt that the level of cytoplamic cGMP, possibly modulated by a G-protein-coupled CGMP phosphodiesterase, plays a phototreasducing role in Stentor . In addition, using an antiserum raised against bovine transducin, a cross reacting protein with an apparent molecular mass of 39 kDa was detected on immunoblots. The α-subunits of a Stentor G-protein has also been partially cloned and sequenced. However, the possible coupling between the G-protein and the putative phosphodiesterase remains to be established.     

PHOTOMOVEMENT RESPONSES OF THE HETEROTRICHOUS CILIATE Blepharisma Japonicum

Light-induced movement responses of the heterotrichous ciliate Blepharisma japonicum were studied by physiological experiments. Two photosensory responses could be identified. A step-up photophobic response is observed as a very rapid backward movement. Microbeam irradiations of individual cells showed that only the anterior part of the ciliate is able to perceive the light stimulus that mediates the phobic reaction. The action spectrum peaks at approximately 400 nm, which indicates that a blue light receptor is involved.
Positive photokinesis of Blepharisma could be shown as a forward movement that is accelerated by increasing the applied photon fluence rate. The steady state level of the velocity depends highly on wavelength and photon fluence rate of the actinic light. After specific inhibition of the phobic reaction bv 1 m/W NH₄⁺, photokinesis can be induced by microbeam irradiation at any part of the cell.
We isolated two main pigments by thin layer chromatography and characterized them as hypericin-like compounds: a red pigment that is obviously responsible for the red color of the ciliates (= blepharismin). and a yellow one with maximal absorption near 420 nm. The possible photoreceptor functions of these pigments are discussed.
We could not find in Blepharisma a distinct phototactic behavior which is so typical for the related ciliate Stentor.