Substituent effects on the edge-to-face aromatic interactions

The edge-to-face interactions for either axially or facially substituted benzenes are investigated by using ab initio calculations. The predicted maximum energy difference between substituted and unsubstituted systems is approximately 0.7 kcal/mol (approximately 1.2 kcal/mol if substituents are on both axially and facially substituted positions). In the case of axially substituted aromatic systems, the electron density at the para position is an important stabilizing factor, and thus the stabilization/destabilization by substitution is highly correlated to the electrostatic energy. This results in its subsequent correlation with the polarization and charge transfer. Thus, the stabilization/destabilization by substitution is represented by the sum of electrostatic energy and induction energy. On the other hand, the facially substituted aromatic system depends on not only the electron-donating ability responsible for the electrostatic energy but also the dispersion interaction and exchange repulsion. Although the dispersion energy is the most dominating interaction in both axial and facial substitutions, it is almost canceled by the exchange repulsion in the axial substitution, whereas in the facial substitution, together with the exchange repulsion it augments the electrostatic energy. The systems with electron-accepting substituents (NO2, CN, Br, Cl, F) favor the axial substituent conformation, while those with electron-donating substituents (NH2, CH3, OH) favor the facial substituent conformation. The interactions for the T-shape complex systems of an aromatic ring with other counterpart such as H2, H2O, HCl, and HF are also studied.     

(1)H NMR investigation of solvent effects in aromatic stacking interactions

One of the marquis challenges in modern Organic Chemistry concerns the design and synthesis of abiotic compounds that emulate the exquisite complex structures and/or functions of biological macromolecules. Oligomers possessing the propensity to adopt well-defined compact conformations, or foldamers, have been attained utilizing hydrogen bonding, torsional restriction, and solvophobic interactions.(1) In this laboratory, aromatic electron donor--acceptor interactions have been exploited in the design of aedamers--foldamers that adopt a novel, pleated secondary structure in aqueous solution. Herein is reported detailed (1)H NMR binding studies of aedamer monomers that were carried out in solvents and solvent mixtures covering a broad polarity range. Curve-fitting analysis of the binding data using a model that incorporated the formation of higher order and self-associated complexes yielded a linear free energy relationship between the free energy of complexation and the empirical solvent polarity parameter, E(T)(30). From these studies, the association of electron-rich and electron-deficient aedamer monomers was seen to be driven primarily by hydrophobic interactions in polar solvents. However, the magnitude of these interactions is modulated to a significant extent by the geometry of the donor--acceptor complex, which, in turn, is dictated by the electrostatic complementarity between the electron-deficient and electron-rich aromatic faces of the monomers.     

Substituent effects on edge-to-face aromatic interactions

Chemical double mutant cycles have been used to measure the magnitude of edge-to-face aromatic interactions in hydrogen-bonded zipper complexes as a function of substituents on both aromatic rings. The interaction energies vary depending on the combination of substituents from +1.0 kJ mol-1 (repulsive), to -4.9 kJ mol-1 (attractive). The results correlate with the Hammett substituent constants which indicates that electrostatic interactions are responsible for the observed differences in interaction energy. The experiments can be rationalised based on local electrostatic interactions between the protons on the edge ring and the pi-electron density on the face ring as well as global electrostatic interactions between the overall dipoles on the two aromatic groups.     

Substituent effects on aromatic stacking interactions

Synthetic supramolecular zipper complexes have been used to quantify substituent effects on the free energies of aromatic stacking interactions. The conformational properties of the complexes have been characterised using NMR spectroscopy in CDCl(3), and by comparison with the solid state structures of model compounds. The structural similarity of the complexes makes it possible to apply the double mutant cycle method to evaluate the magnitudes of 24 different aromatic stacking interactions. The major trends in the interaction energy can be rationalised using a simple model based on electrostatic interactions between the pi-faces of the two aromatic rings. However, electrostatic interactions between the substituents of one ring and the pi-face of the other make an additional contribution, due to the slight offset in the stacking geometry. This property makes aromatic stacking interactions particularly sensitive to changes in orientation as well as the nature and location of substituents.     

Substituent effects on non-covalent interactions with aromatic rings: insights from computational chemistry

Non-covalent interactions with aromatic rings pervade modern chemical research. The strength and orientation of these interactions can be tuned and controlled through substituent effects. Computational studies of model complexes have provided a detailed understanding of the origin and nature of these substituent effects, and pinpointed flaws in entrenched models of these interactions in the literature. Here, we provide a brief review of efforts over the last decade to unravel the origin of substituent effects in π-stacking, XH/π, and ion/π interactions through detailed computational studies. We highlight recent progress that has been made, while also uncovering areas where future studies are warranted.     

Photochemical aromatic hydroxylation by aromatic amine N-oxides: remarkable solvent effect on NIH-shift

Photooxygenations of 4-²H-anisole ($\text{3}$) and o-xylene ($\text{5}$) by 3-methylpyridazine 2-oxide ($\text{1}$) or pyridine 1-oxide ($\text{2}$) were studied in a variety of solvents at varying irradiation temperatures. Remarkable solvent effect on NIH-shift coupled with their hydroxylation processes was observed.     

Theoretical investigation of the electronic spectra of aromatic nitrosooxides with allowance for solvent effects

Density functional theory methods correctly describe some properties of nitrosooxides. Electronic spectral data have been calculated for seven para-substituted aromatic nitrosooxides in different solvents using the UB3LYP/6-311+G(d,p) approximation. The calculated positions of maxima in UV spectra correlate with experimental data with high coefficient. Equations are suggested for predicting the positions of absorption maxima for the para-R-C₆H₄-NOO under study.     

Some solvent effects on the solvent extraction of 8-quinolinol

The distribution constants of 8-quinolinol between water and a series of substituted aliphatic hydrocarbons, at 25 degrees , are reported. The results are discussed in terms of dielectric constant and solubility parameter of the solvents. For 8-quinolinol, and possibly for its chelates, bromochloromethane, dibromomethane and chloroform seem to be about the best solvents, in that order. Among the solvents studied, chloroform shows significantly higher values than expected; the deviation may be explained as a specific interaction of the hydrogen- bonding type.     

Free energy simulations: Applications to the study of liquid water,hydrophobic interactions and solvent effects on conformational stability

Free energy simulations using the Metropolis Monte Carlo method and the coupling parameter approach with umbrella sampling are described for several problems of interest in structural biochemistry: the liquid water, the hydrophobic interaction of alkyl and phenyl groups in water, and solvent effects on the conformational stability of the alanine dipeptide and the dimethyl phosphate anion in water. Proximity analysis of the results is employed to identify stabilizing factors. Implications of the result with respect to the structural chemistry of proteins and nucleic acids is considered.     

Reactions of aromatic sulphonyl chlorides with anilines : Studies of solvent effects by the approach of multiparameter empirical correlations

The reaction kinetics of 5-substituted 2-thiophenesulphonyl chlorides with anilines were studied in fourteen pure solvents (protic and aprotic) and in mixed solvents at 25°. The approach of multiparameter equations to describe solvent effects according to the Palm-Koppel and Krygowski-Fawcett models was unsuccessful. Instead satisfactory single parameter linear correlations, one for protic solvents with positive slope and another for aprotic solvents with negative slope, were found by using the dielectric constant ?. An S_AN mechanism for these reactions was proposed, bond-making being the rate-determining step for protic solvents and bond-breaking for aprotic ones. The analysis of some data for the reactions of benzenesulphonyl chloride showed that the mechanism is analogous also for this substrate and the rate-determining step is depending on both solvent and nucleophile. Hammett ρ-values for the reactions of substituted 2-thiophenesulphonyl chlorides with aniline are in accord with the proposed mechanism. ?-Values for the reactions of 2-thiophenesulphonyl chloride with substituted anilines are related to the solvent effects by equation ? = ? 15.7 f(?) + 0.113E + 3.94. The solvent effects on these values can be interpreted by the effect of the dielectric constant and the influence of H-bonding. Mixed solvents are characterized by the presence of a maximum rate.     

Intermolecular interactions in solution: elucidating the influence of the solvent

A new approach for the analysis of intermolecular interactions in a solution is proposed. The changes in the interaction energy components due to the solvent effects are estimated on the basis of the interaction energy calculated in the presence of the electric field induced in a polarizable medium, or in the field of the effective fragment potentials. Obtained results indicate a significant increase in stabilization resulting from electrostatic interactions as a result of the cooperative interactions between interacting subsystems and solvent molecules.     

Catalytic effects of hydrogen-bond acceptor solvent on nucleophilic aromatic substitution reactions in non-polar aprotic solvent: reactions of phenyl 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl ether with amines in benzene-acetonitrile mixtures

The effect of addition of small amounts of hydrogen-bond acceptor solvent, acetonitrile, to the benzene medium of the reactions of phenyl 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl ether with aniline and cyclohexylamine, respectively have been investigated. The addition produced similar effects in the two reactions—continuous rate increase with increasing amounts of acetonitrile. The results are interpreted in terms of the effect of amine-solvent interaction on the nucleophilicity of the amines and are in accord with our expectations based on the effects observed for hydrogen-bond donor solvent, methanol on the same reactions. It is also established from the results that the role of hydrogen-bond acceptor co-solvent could be played by an added more basic non-nucleophilic amine.     

Spectroscopic investigations of solvent effect on chiral interactions

The spectrophotometric method was used to determine the mechanism of chiral interactions between a known chiral selector, tert-butyl carbamoylated quinine (t-BuCQN), and N-derivative amino acids (DNB-Leu). Results obtained on binding constants, free energy of binding (DeltaG), and difference in free energy of binding (DeltaDeltaG) values seem to suggest that there are three possible types of interactions between DNB-Leu and t-BuCQN: electrostatic interaction between the carboxylate group of the DNB-Leu and the ammonium group of the t-BuCQN, the donor-acceptor charge-transfer type of interaction between the (acceptor) aromatic group of the amino acid and the (donor) aromatic group of the t-BuCQN, and the hydrogen-bonding interaction between the amide group of the DNB-Leu and the carbonyl group of t-BuCQN. The strongest interaction will be observed if all of three interactions are in operation as in the case of DNB-Leu. The electrostatic interaction seems to play the dominant role in the interactions. While the charge-transfer interaction is relatively weaker, it seems, however, to be responsible for enantiomeric selectivity, namely, the closer the electron acceptor dinitrophenyl group is to the electron donor quinoline group, the higher is the enantiomeric selectivity. Specifically, in solvent with high polarity, both donor and acceptor are solvated by solvent molecules, thereby preventing them from being close. As a consequence, the interaction will be weaker and, hence, lower enantiomeric selectivity. Solvation will be less in less polar solvent which, in turn, leads to stronger interaction and higher enantiomeric selectivity.     

The influence of solute-solvent interactions on the kinetics and stereospecificity of polymerization-the relevance of aromatic solvent shifts observed on the nmr spectrum of methyl methacrylate

The effect of certain aromatic compounds on the PMR spectrum of methyl methacrylate (MMA) was investigated. The magnitude of observed aromatic-induced shifts decreased in the order benzene ? styrene > chlorobenzene ≈ bromobenzene.Assuming that the interaction arises from a stoichiometric 1:1 complex, equilibrium parameters for the MMA-benzene interaction have been estimated. ΔH ± S.E. (ΔH) = ?(8 ± 4) kJ mol^?1. These effects are likely to have a small influence on the kinetics of copolymerization with aromatic monomers and polymerization in aromatic solvent. The stereochemistry of the solute-solvent interactions suggests that MMA takes a cis-conformation in solution, which is relevant to the mechanism of stereoregular polymerizations of this monomer.     

Kinetic solvent effects on hydrogen abstraction reactions from carbon by the cumyloxyl radical. The importance of solvent hydrogen-bond interactions with the substrate and the abstracting radical

A kinetic study of the hydrogen atom abstraction reactions from propanal (PA) and 2,2-dimethylpropanal (DMPA) by the cumyloxyl radical (CumO?) has been carried out in different solvents (benzene, PhCl, MeCN, t-BuOH, MeOH, and TFE). The corresponding reactions of the benzyloxyl radical (BnO?) have been studied in MeCN. The reaction of CumO? with 1,4-cyclohexadiene (CHD) also has been investigated in TFE solution. With CHD a 3-fold increase in rate constant (k(H)) has been observed on going from benzene, PhCl, and MeCN to TFE. This represents the first observation of a sizable kinetic solvent effect for hydrogen atom abstraction reactions from hydrocarbons by alkoxyl radicals and indicates that strong HBD solvents influence the hydrogen abstraction reactivity of CumO?. With PA and DMPA a significant decrease in k(H) has been observed on going from benzene and PhCl to MeOH and TFE, indicative of hydrogen-bond interactions between the carbonyl lone pair and the solvent in the transition state. The similar k(H) values observed for the reactions of the aldehydes in MeOH and TFE point toward differential hydrogen bond interactions of the latter solvent with the substrate and the radical in the transition state. The small reactivity ratios observed for the reactions of CumO? and BnO? with PA and DMPA (k(H)(BnO?)/k(H)(CumO?) = 1.2 and 1.6, respectively) indicate that with these substrates alkoxyl radical sterics play a minor role.     

Desolvation effects on the dissociation energy of diatomic molecules:Ab initio study of the dissociation of Li-F in polar media

Summary The potential curve of the ground state dissociation of Li-F in water has been studied by a combination of a standardab initio Hartree-Fock procedure and a perturbative reaction field approach. The electrostatic solute-solvent interaction is accounted for by the generalized Born formalism introduced through a perturbation approach. The calculations were carried out at a 6–311+G* basis set level. Diffuse functions ofs symmetry were included to model a desolvation potential. A double well potential curve was obtained for the dissociation of this molecule in the presence of a highly polarizable medium. The first minimum, corresponding to an ion pair, electrostatically bound, is found at aR(Li-F)<6.0 Å distance. As the two ions come together, a desolvation barrier of about 30 kcal/mol is to be overcome before the formation of the neutral Li-F at 1.56 Å. The barrier to ionization towards the ion pair is calculated to be about 14 kcal/mol. The dissociation of the ion pair towards the free ions is discussed in terms of the electrostatic solvation entropy changes.Contribution No 6 from Centro de Mecánica Cuantica Aplicada (CMCA)     

Substituent effects on the aromatic edge-to-face interaction

Substituent effects on the folding equilibrium of molecular torsion balances are rationalised on the basis of changes in the electrostatic interactions, the exchange repulsion, and the dispersive contributions to the interaction free enthalpy.