A characterization of mapping unstructured grids onto structured grids and using multigrid as a preconditioner

Many problems based on unstructured grids provide a natural multigrid framework due to using an adaptive gridding procedure. When the grids are saved, even starting from just a fine grid problem poses no serious theoretical difficulties in applying multigrid. A more difficult case occurs when a highly unstructured grid problem is to be solved with no hints how the grid was produced. Here, there may be no natural multigrid structure and applying such a solver may be quite difficult to do. Since unstructured grids play a vital role in scientific computing, many modifications have been proposed in order to apply a fast, robust multigrid solver. One suggested solution is to map the unstructured grid onto a structured grid and then apply multigrid to a sequence of structured grids as a preconditioner. In this paper, we derive both general upper and lower bounds on the condition number of this procedure in terms of computable grid parameters. We provide examples to illuminate when this preconditioner is a useful (e. g.,p orh-p formulated finite element problems on semi-structured grids) or should be avoided (e.g., typical computational fluid dynamics (CFD) or boundary layer problems). We show that unless great care is taken, this mapping can lead to a system with a high condition number which eliminates the advantage of the multigrid method. This work was partially supported by ONR Grant # N0014-91-J-1576.     

Fourier analysis of a robust multigrid method for convection-diffusion equations

Summary. We consider a two-grid method for solving 2D convection-diffusion problems. The coarse grid correction is based on approximation of the Schur complement. As a preconditioner of the Schur complement we use the exact Schur complement of modified fine grid equations. We assume constant coefficients and periodic boundary conditions and apply Fourier analysis. We prove an upper bound for the spectral radius of the two-grid iteration matrix that is smaller than one and independent of the mesh size, the convection/diffusion ratio and the flow direction; i.e. we have a (strong) robustness result. Numerical results illustrating the robustness of the corresponding multigrid -cycle are given. Received October 14, 1994     

A cascadic multigrid algorithm for semilinear elliptic problems

Summary. We propose a cascadic multigrid algorithm for a semilinear elliptic problem. The nonlinear equations arising from linear finite element discretizations are solved by Newton's method. Given an approximate solution on the coarsest grid on each finer grid we perform exactly one Newton step taking the approximate solution from the previous grid as initial guess. The Newton systems are solved iteratively by an appropriate smoothing method. We prove that the algorithm yields an approximate solution within the discretization error on the finest grid provided that the start approximation is sufficiently accurate and that the initial grid size is sufficiently small. Moreover, we show that the method has multigrid complexity. Received February 12, 1998 / Revised version received July 22, 1999 / Published online June 8, 2000     

Fast and Robust Sixth Order Multigrid Computation for 3D Convection Diffusion Equation

We present a sixth-order explicit compact finite difference scheme to solve the three-dimensional (3D) convection-diffusion equation. We first use a multiscale multigrid method to solve the linear systems arising from a 19-point fourth-order discretization scheme to compute the fourth-order solutions on both a coarse grid and a fine grid. Then an operator-based interpolation scheme combined with an extrapolation technique is used to approximate the sixth-order accurate solution on the fine grid. Since the multigrid method using a standard point relaxation smoother may fail to achieve the optimal grid-independent convergence rate for solving convection-diffusion equations with a high Reynolds number, we implement the plane relaxation smoother in the multigrid solver to achieve better grid independency. Supporting numerical results are presented to demonstrate the efficiency and accuracy of the sixth-order compact (SOC) scheme, compared with the previously published fourth-order compact (FOC) scheme.     

A multigrid method for a Petrov-Galerkin discretization of the Stokes equations

Summary We introduce a multigrid method for the solution of the discrete Stokes equations, arising from a Petrov-Galerkin formulation. The stiffness matrix is nonsymmetric but coercive, hence we consider smoothing iterations which are not suitable for usual indefinite problems. In this report, we prove convergence for a multigrid method with Richardson iteration in the smoothing part.     

The cascadic multigrid method for elliptic problems

Summary. The paper deals with certain adaptive multilevel methods at the confluence of nested multigrid methods and iterative methods based on the cascade principle of [10]. From the multigrid point of view, no correction cycles are needed; from the cascade principle view, a basic iteration method without any preconditioner is used at successive refinement levels. For a prescribed error tolerance on the final level, more iterations must be spent on coarser grids in order to allow for less iterations on finer grids. A first candidate of such a cascadic multigrid method was the recently suggested cascadic conjugate gradient method of [9], in short CCG method, whichused the CG method as basic iteration method on each level. In [18] it has been proven, that the CCG method is accurate with optimal complexity for elliptic problems in 2D and quasi-uniform triangulations. The present paper simplifies that theory and extends it to more general basic iteration methods like the traditional multigrid smoothers. Moreover, an adaptive control strategy for the number of iterations on successive refinement levels for possibly highly non-uniform grids is worked out on the basis of a posteriori estimates. Numerical tests confirm the efficiency and robustness of the cascadic multigrid method. Received November 12, 1994 / Revised version received October 12, 1995     

Error estimates of the lumped mass finite element method for semilinear elliptic problems

We are concerned with the semilinear elliptic problems. We first investigate the L²-error estimate for the lumped mass finite element method. We then use the cascadic multigrid method to solve the corresponding discrete problem. On the basis of the finite element error estimates, we prove the optimality of the proposed multigrid method. We also report some numerical results to support the theory.     

A survey of multilevel preconditioned iterative methods

We survey multilevel iterative methods applied for solving large sparse systems with matrices, which depend on a level parameter, such as arise by the discretization of boundary value problems for partial differential equations when successive refinements of an initial discretization mesh is used to construct a sequence of nested difference or finite element meshes.We discuss various two-level (two-grid) preconditioning techniques, including some for nonsymmetric problems. The generalization of these techniques to the multilevel case is a nontrivial task. We emphasize several ways this can be done including classical multigrid methods and a recently proposed algebraic multilevel preconditioning method. Conditions for which the methods have an optimal order of computational complexity are presented.On leave from the Institute of Mathematics, and Center for Informatics and Computer Technology, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria. The research of the second author reported here was partly supported by the Stichting Mathematisch Centrum, Amsterdam.     

Convergence analysis of a multigrid method for convection–diffusion equations

Summary. This paper is concerned with the convergence analysis of robust multigrid methods for convection-diffusion problems. We consider a finite difference discretization of a 2D model convection-diffusion problem with constant coefficients and Dirichlet boundary conditions. For the approximate solution of this discrete problem a multigrid method based on semicoarsening, matrix-dependent prolongation and restriction and line smoothers is applied. For a multigrid W-cycle we prove an upper bound for the contraction number in the euclidean norm which is smaller than one and independent of the mesh size and the diffusion/convection ratio. For the contraction number of a multigrid V-cycle a bound is proved which is uniform for a class of convection-dominated problems. The analysis is based on linear algebra arguments only. Received April 26, 2000 / Published online June 20, 2001     

High-order discretization and multigrid solution of elliptic nonlinear constrained optimal control problems

High(-mixed)-order finite difference discretization of optimality systems arising from elliptic nonlinear constrained optimal control problems are discussed. For the solution of these systems, an efficient and robust multigrid algorithm is presented. Theoretical and experimental results show the advantages of higher-order discretization and demonstrate that the proposed multigrid scheme is able to solve efficiently constrained optimal control problems also in the limit case of bang-bang control.     

A multigrid method for constrained optimal control problems

We consider the fast and efficient numerical solution of linear-quadratic optimal control problems with additional constraints on the control. Discretization of the first-order conditions leads to an indefinite linear system of saddle point type with additional complementarity conditions due to the control constraints. The complementarity conditions are treated by a primal-dual active set strategy that serves as outer iteration. At each iteration step, a KKT system has to be solved. Here, we develop a multigrid method for its fast solution. To this end, we use a smoother which is based on an inexact constraint preconditioner.We present numerical results which show that the proposed multigrid method possesses convergence rates of the same order as for the underlying (elliptic) PDE problem. Furthermore, when combined with a nested iteration, the solver is of optimal complexity and achieves the solution of the optimization problem at only a small multiple of the cost for the PDE solution.     

The analysis of multigrid algorithms for cell centered finite difference methods

In this paper, we examine multigrid algorithms for cell centered finite difference approximations of second order elliptic boundary value problems. The cell centered application gives rise to one of the simplest non-variational multigrid algorithms. We shall provide an analysis which guarantees that the W-cycle and variable V-cycle multigrid algorithms converge with a rate of iterative convergence which can be bounded independently of the number of multilevel spaces. In contrast, the natural variational multigrid algorithm converges much more slowly.     

Multigrid and multilevel methods for quadratic spline collocation

Multigrid methods are developed and analyzed for quadratic spline collocation equations arising from the discretization of one-dimensional second-order differential equations. The rate of convergence of the two-grid method integrated with a damped Richardson relaxation scheme as smoother is shown to be faster than 1/2, independently of the step-size. The additive multilevel versions of the algorithms are also analyzed. The development of quadratic spline collocation multigrid methods is extended to two-dimensional elliptic partial differential equations. Multigrid methods for quadratic spline collocation methods are not straightforward: because the basis functions used with quadratic spline collocation are not nodal basis functions, the design of efficient restriction and extension operators is nontrivial. Experimental results, with V-cycle and full multigrid, indicate that suitably chosen multigrid iteration is a very efficient solver for the quadratic spline collocation equations. Supported by Communications and Information Technology Ontario (CITO), Canada. Supported by the Mathematical, Information, and Computational Sciences Division subprogram of the Office of Computational and Technology Research, U.S. Department of Energy, under Contract W-31-109-Eng-38.     

Multigrid algorithms for a vertex–centered covolume method for elliptic problems

Summary. We analyze V–cycle multigrid algorithms for a class of perturbed problems whose perturbation in the bilinear form preserves the convergence properties of the multigrid algorithm of the original problem. As an application, we study the convergence of multigrid algorithms for a covolume method or a vertex–centered finite volume element method for variable coefficient elliptic problems on polygonal domains. As in standard finite element methods, the V–cycle algorithm with one pre-smoothing converges with a rate independent of the number of levels. Various types of smoothers including point or line Jacobi, and Gauss-Seidel relaxation are considered. Received August 19, 1999 / Revised version received July 10, 2000 / Published online June 7, 2001     

On the abstract theory of additive and multiplicative Schwarz algorithms

Summary. In recent years, it has been shown that many modern iterative algorithms (multigrid schemes, multilevel preconditioners, domain decomposition methods etc.) for solving problems resulting from the discretization of PDEs can be interpreted as additive (Jacobi-like) or multiplicative (Gauss-Seidel-like) subspace correction methods. The key to their analysis is the study of certain metric properties of the underlying splitting of the discretization space into a sum of subspaces and the splitting of the variational problem on into auxiliary problems on these subspaces. In this paper, we propose a modification of the abstract convergence theory of the additive and multiplicative Schwarz methods, that makes the relation to traditional iteration methods more explicit. The analysis of the additive and multiplicative Schwarz iterations can be carried out in almost the same spirit as in the traditional block-matrix situation, making convergence proofs of multilevel and domain decomposition methods clearer, or, at least, more classical. In addition, we present a new bound for the convergence rate of the appropriately scaled multiplicative Schwarz method directly in terms of the condition number of the corresponding additive Schwarz operator. These results may be viewed as an appendix to the recent surveys [X], [Ys]. Received February 1, 1994 / Revised version received August 1, 1994     

Discretization errors at free boundaries of the Grad-Schlüter-Shafranov equation

Summary The numerical error of standard finite-difference schemes is analyzed at free boundaries of the Grad-Schlüter-Shafranov equation of plasma physics. A simple correction strategy is devised to eliminate (to leading order) the errors which arise as the free boundary crosses the rectangular grid at irregular locations. The resulting scheme can be solved by Gauss-Newton or Inverse iterations, or by multigrid iterations. Extrapolation (from 2^nd to 3^rd order of accuracy) is possible for the new scheme.Dedicated to the memory of Professor Lothar Collatz     

Overlapping Schwarz methods on unstructured meshes using non-matching coarse grids

Summary. We consider two level overlapping Schwarz domain decomposition methods for solving the finite element problems that arise from discretizations of elliptic problems on general unstructured meshes in two and three dimensions. Standard finite element interpolation from the coarse to the fine grid may be used. Our theory requires no assumption on the substructures that constitute the whole domain, so the substructures can be of arbitrary shape and of different size. The global coarse mesh is allowed to be non-nested to the fine grid on which the discrete problem is to be solved, and neither the coarse mesh nor the fine mesh need be quasi-uniform. In addition, the domains defined by the fine and coarse grid need not be identical. The one important constraint is that the closure of the coarse grid must cover any portion of the fine grid boundary for which Neumann boundary conditions are given. In this general setting, our algorithms have the same optimal convergence rate as the usual two level overlapping domain decomposition methods on structured meshes. The condition number of the preconditioned system depends only on the (possibly small) overlap of the substructures and the size of the coarse grid, but is independent of the sizes of the subdomains. Received March 23, 1994 / Revised version received June 2, 1995     

Patch-adaptive multilevel iteration

Themultilevel adaptive iteration is an attempt to improve both the robustness and efficiency of iterative sparse system solvers. Unlike in most other iterative methods, the order of processing and sequence of operations is not determined a priori. The method consists of a relaxation scheme with an active set strategy and can be viewed as an efficient implementation of the Gauß-Southwell relaxation. With this strategy, computational work is focused on where it can efficiently improve the solution quality. To obtain full efficiency, the algorithm must be used on a multilevel structure. This algorithm is then closely related to multigrid or multilevel preconditioning algorithms, and can be shown to have asymptotically optimal convergence. In this paper the focus is on a variant that uses data structures with a locally uniform grid refinement. The resulting grid system consists of a collection of patches where each patch is a uniform rectangular grid and where adaptive refinement is accomplished by arranging the patches flexibly in space. This construction permits improved implementations that better exploit high performance computer designs. This will be demonstrated by numerical examples.     

Convergence of the multigrid full approximation scheme for a class of elliptic mildly nonlinear boundary value problems

Summary The multigrid full approximation scheme (FAS MG) is a well-known solver for nonlinear boundary value problems. In this paper we restrict ourselves to a class of second order elliptic mildly nonlinear problems and we give local conditions, e.g. a local Lipschitz condition on the derivative of the continuous operator, under which the FAS MG with suitably chosen parameters locally converges. We prove quantitative convergence statements and deduce explicit bounds for important quantities such as the radius of a ball of guaranteed convergence, the number of smoothings needed, the number of coarse grid corrections needed and the number of FAS MG iterations needed in a nested iteration. These bounds show well-known features of the FAS MG scheme.     

Two-level hierarchically preconditioned conjugate gradient methods for solving linear elasticity finite element equations

In this paper we study and compare some preconditioned conjugate gradient methods for solving large-scale higher-order finite element schemes approximating two- and three-dimensional linear elasticity boundary value problems. The preconditioners discussed in this paper are derived from hierarchical splitting of the finite element space first proposed by O. Axelsson and I. Gustafsson. We especially focus our attention to the implicit construction of preconditioning operators by means of some fixpoint iteration process including multigrid techniques. Many numerical experiments confirm the efficiency of these preconditioners in comparison with classical direct methods most frequently used in practice up to now.