Electron transfer at self-assembled monolayers measured by scanning electrochemical microscopy

New approaches have been developed for measuring the rates of electron transfer (ET) across self-assembled molecular monolayers by scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM). The developed models can be used to independently measure the rates of ET mediated by monolayer-attached redox moieties and direct ET through the film as well as the rate of a bimolecular ET reaction between the attached and dissolved redox species. By using a high concentration of redox mediator in solution, very fast heterogeneous (10(8) s(-1)) and bimolecular (10(11) mol(-1) cm(3) s(-1)) ET rate constants can be measured. The ET rate constants measured for ferrocene/alkanethiol on gold were in agreement with previously published data. The rates of bimolecular heterogeneous electron transfer between the monolayer-bound ferrocene and water-soluble redox species were measured. SECM was also used to measure the rate of ET through nonelectroactive alkanethiol molecules between substrate gold electrodes and a redox probe (Ru(NH(3))(6)(3+)) freely diffusing in the solution, yielding a tunneling decay constant, beta, of 1.0 per methylene group.     

Anion effect on mediated electron transfer through ferrocene-terminated self-assembled monolayers

Inorganic anions strongly influence the electron transfer rate from the ascorbate to the ferrocene-terminated self-assembled monolayer (SAM) composed of 9-mercaptononyl-5'-ferrocenylpentanoate (Fc(CH2)4COO(CH2)9SH, MNFcP). At the 1 M concentration level of the supporting anion (sodium salt electrolyte), a more than 10-fold increase in the electrocatalytic oxidation rate constant of the ascorbate is observed in the following sequence: PF6-, ClO4-, BF4-, NO3-, Cl-, SO4(2-), NH2SO3- (sulfamate), and F-. The sequence corresponds to the direction of increasing hydration energy of the corresponding anion, suggesting that highly hydrated ions promote electrocatalytic electron transfer to the ferrocene-terminated SAMs, while poorly hydrated ions inhibit it. Fourier transform surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (FT-SERS), in combination with cyclic voltammetry, indicates the formation of surface ion pairs between the ferricinium cation (Fc+) and low hydration energy anions, while, on the contrary, no ion pairs were observed in the electrolytes dominated by the high hydration energy anions. Though it is evident that the ion-pairing ability of hydrophobic anions is directly responsible for the electrocatalytic electron transfer inhibition, an estimate of the free, ion-unpaired Fc+ surface concentration shows that it cannot be directly related to the electron transfer rate. This suggests that the principal reason of the anion-induced electron transfer rate modulation might be related to the molecular level changes of the physical and chemical properties as well as the structure of the self-assembled monolayer.     

Scanning electrochemical microscopy. 51. Studies of self-assembled monolayers of DNA in the absence and presence of metal ions

Scanning electrochemical microscopy was used to examine electron transfer across a self-assembled monolayer of thiol-modified DNA duplexes on a gold electrode. The apparent rate constant for heterogeneous ET from a solution redox probe, Fe(CN)6(3-/4-), to the gold surface through ds-DNA was 4.6 (+/-0.2) x 10(-7) cm/s. With the addition of Zn2+, which resulted in the formation of a metalated DNA (M-DNA) monolayer, the rate constant increased to 5.0 (+/-0.3) x 10(-6) cm/s. Upon treating M-DNA with EDTA, the zinc ions were released from the monolayer and the original rate constant for the DNA duplexes was restored. The enhanced ET rate was also observed at a DNA monolayer treated with Ca2+ or Mg2+, which does not complex by the DNA bases to form M-DNA. The binding of these cations facilitated the monolayer penetration by the probe mediator Fe(CN)6(3-/4-) and accordingly caused an increased redox signal of the mediator at the ds-DNA-modified electrode. Cationic or neutral mediators were not blocked by the ds-DNA monolayer. These results suggest that although the increased electron transport through M-DNA could partially be ascribed to the intrinsic enhancement of electric conductivity of M-DNA, which has been confirmed by photochemical studies, the change in the surface charge of DNA monolayers on the electrode caused by the binding of metal ions to DNA molecules may play a more important role in the enhancement of current with M-DNA.     

Scanning tunneling microscopy observation of self-assembled monolayers of strapped porphyrins

In this paper, we reveal that the free-base and zinc strapped porphyrins possessing long alkyl chains, C 24OPP-HQ and Zn(C 24OPP-HQ), respectively, can be arranged on surfaces. We used scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) to observe alkyl-chain-assisted self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of these strapped porphyrins at the solid-liquid interface. STM images revealed that the strapped benzene moiety was detectable on the porphyrin core: that is, the strapped porphyrins could be differentiated from nonstrapped analogues. We compared the population of the nonstrapped porphyrin (C 24OPP) and either of the strapped porphyrins C 24OPP-HQ or Zn(C 24OPP-HQ) in the mixed SAMs. We then confirmed that Zn(C 24OPP-HQ) is more favorably incorporated in the mixed SAMs than C 24OPP-HQ. From (1)H NMR spectroscopic and X-ray crystallographic analyses, we concluded that the factors increasing the population of Zn(C 24OPP-HQ) in the mixed SAMs are the enhanced rigidity of the porphyrin core by the zinc coordination and the flat structure of the porphyrin moiety in the saddle conformation. This study demonstrates that strapped porphyrins possessing long alkyl chains are available to arrange the functional modules on the surface via chemical modification on the strapped moiety.     

Characterization of carboxylic acid-terminated self-assembled monolayers by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and scanning electrochemical microscopy

Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM) are used to monitor changes in the ionization of monolayers of 11-mercaptoundecanoic acid. When using an anionic redox probe, Fe(CN)6(-4), the charge-transfer resistance of the 11-mercaptoundecanoic acid monolayer-modified interface increases in a sigmoidal fashion as the solution is made basic. The opposite effect is observed when using a cationic redox probe. The inflection points of these two titration curves, however, differ when using the different redox probes. This result is taken as being characteristic of the influence that applied potential has on the ionization of the monolayer. The role of substrate potential on the ionization of the monolayer is further investigated by SECM. The SECM measurement monitors the concentration of Ru(NH3)6(+3) as the potential of the substrate is varied about the potential of zero charge. For monolayers of 11-mercaptoundecanoic acid in solutions buffered near the pKa of the terminal carboxylic acid, potential excursions positive of the PZC cause an increase in the concentration of Ru(NH3)6(+3) local to the interface, and potential excursions negative of the PZC cause a decrease in the local concentration of Ru(NH3)6(+3). Similar experiments conducted with an interface modified with 11-undecanethiol had no impact on the local concentration of Ru(NH3)6(+3). These results are interpreted in terms of the influence that applied potential has on the pH of the solution local to the interface and the impact that this has on the ionization of the monolayer.     

Scanning tunneling microscopy of template-stripped Au surfaces and highly ordered self-assembled monolayers

Template stripping of Au films in ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) produces atomically flat and pristine surfaces that serve as substrates for highly ordered self-assembled monolayer (SAM) formation. Atomic resolution scanning tunneling microscopy of template-stripped (TS) Au stripped in UHV confirms that the stripping process produces a flat, predominantly 111 textured, atomically clean surface. Octanethiol SAMs vapor deposited in situ onto UHV TS Au show a c(4 x 2) superlattice with (square root 3 x square root 3) R30 degrees basic molecular structure having an ordered domain size up to 100 nm wide. These UHV results validate the TS Au surface as a simple, clean and high-quality surface preparation method for SAMs deposited from both vapor phase and solution phase.     

Simultaneous nanoindentation and electron tunneling through alkanethiol self-assembled monolayers

Electrical tunnel junctions consisting of alkanethiol molecules self-assembled on Au-coated Si substrates and contacted with Au-coated atomic force microscopy tips were characterized under varying junction loads in a conducting-probe atomic force microscopy configuration. Junction load was cycled in the fashion of a standard nanoindentation experiment; however, junction conductance rather than probe depth was measured directly. The junction conductance data have been analyzed with typical contact mechanics (Derjaguin-Müller-Toporov) and tunneling equations to extract the monolayer modulus (approximately 50 GPa), the contact transmission (approximately 2 x 10(-6)), contact area, and probe depth as a function of load. The monolayers are shown to undergo significant plastic deformation under compression, yielding indentations approximately 7 Angstroms deep for maximum junction loads of approximately 50 nN. Comparison of mechanical properties for different chain lengths was also performed. The film modulus decreased with the number of carbons in the molecular chain for shorter-chain films. This trend abruptly reversed once 12 carbons were present along the backbone.     

Molecular chirality and charge transfer through self-assembled scaffold monolayers

The effect of molecular chirality on electron transmission is explored by photoelectrochemistry. Thiol-terminated chiral scaffold molecules containing a porphyrin chromophore were self-assembled on gold surfaces to form a monolayer. Incorporation of the SAM-coated gold into an electrochemical cell and illumination with visible light generated a cathodic photocurrent. When using circularly polarized light, the photocurrent displayed an asymmetry (different magnitude of photocurrent for right versus left polarization) that changed with the molecular chirality (left- or right-handedness of the scaffold). A symmetry constraint on the electronic coupling between the porphyrin and the organic scaffold is proposed as a possible mechanism for the photocurrent asymmetry.     

Photoinduced electron transfer in self-assembled monolayers of porphyrin-fullerene dyads on ITO

Two porphyrin-fullerene dyads were synthesized to form self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on indium-tin oxide (ITO) electrode, with either ITO-porphyrin-fullerene or ITO-fullerene-porphyrin orientations. The dyads contain two linkers for connecting the porphyrin and fullerene moieties and enforcing them essentially to similar geometries of the donor-acceptor pair, and two linkers to ensure the attachment of the dyads to the ITO surface with two desired opposite orientations. The transient photovoltage responses (Maxwell displacement charge) were measured for the dyad films covered by insulating LB films, thus ensuring that the dyads interact only with the ITO electrode. The direction of the electron transfer was from the photoexcited dyad to ITO independent of the dyad orientation. The response amplitude for the ITO-fullerene-porphyrin structure, where the primary intramolecular electron-transfer direction coincides with the direction of the final electron transfer from the dyad to ITO, was 25 times stronger than that for the opposite ITO-porphyrin-fullerene orientation of the dyad. Static photocurrent measurements in a liquid electrochemical cell, however, show only a minor orientation effect, indicating that the photocurrent generation is controlled by the processes at the SAM-liquid interface.     

Studying electron transfer through alkanethiol self-assembled monolayers on a hanging mercury drop electrode using potentiometric measurements

A new approach based on measuring the change of the open-circuit potential (OCP) of a hanging mercury drop electrode (HMDE), modified with alkanethiols of different chain length conducted in a solution containing a mixture of Ru(NH3)6(2+) and Ru(NH3)6(3+) is used for studying electron transfer across the monolayer. Following the time dependence of the OCP allowed the extraction of the kinetic parameters, such as the charge transfer resistance (R(ct)) and the electron transfer rate constant (k(et)), for different alkanethiol monolayers. An electron tunneling coefficient, beta, of 0.9 A(-1) was calculated for the monolayers on Hg.     

Separation of pinhole and tunneling electron transfer processes at self-assembled polymeric monolayers on gold electrodes

Self-assembled monolayers of poly(3-alkylthiophene) on gold electrodes are examined by cyclic voltammetry in solutions containing electroactive species. Two well-separated electron transfer processes, namely, electron tunneling through the monolayer and electron exchange at pinholes (defects) of the monolayer are observed. The voltammetric responses of the pinhole electron transfer process take place around the standard potential of the electroactive species and resemble those of a nanoelectrode ensemble of independent individual nanoelectrodes. The voltammetric characteristics of the electron tunneling agree well with predictions of the Marcus theory. Satisfactory values of tunneling coefficient, standard rate constant and organization energy are derived from the voltammetric data.     

Heterogeneous electron transfer processes in self-assembled monolayers of amine terminated conjugated molecular wires

A versatile synthesis of triarylamine and phenothiazine end-capped oligo(phenyleneacetylene) molecular wires which are terminated by thiol functions is described. The repetitive synthesis allows the preparation of molecular wires with different chain length and different substituents attached to the wire backbone. These molecular wires were used to form dense self-assembled monolayers (SAM) on gold substrates as proved by cyclic voltammetry and quartz crystal microbalance measurements. The heterogeneous electron transfer rate constant of these SAMs was measured by impedance spectroscopy between 1 MHz and 0.1 Hz. The rate constants are somewhat larger for the triarylamine terminated systems than for the phenothiazine compound, due to the higher reorganization energy in the latter. While the molecular wires with electron withdrawing substituents display an electron transfer which is slow enough to be measurable with our impedance setup, we were unable to determine the rate of molecular wires with electron donating substituents.     

Switching the electrochemical impedance of low-density self-assembled monolayers

Because the active remodeling of biointerfaces is a paramount feature of nature, it is very likely that future, advanced biomaterials will be required to mimic at least certain aspects of the dynamic properties of natural interfaces. This need has fueled a quest for model surfaces that can undergo reversible switching upon application of external stimuli. Herein, we report the synthesis and characterization of a model system for studying reversibly switching surfaces based on low-density monolayers of mercaptohexadecanoic acid and mercaptoundecanoic acid. These monolayers were assembled on both gold and silver electrodes. When conducting electrochemical impedance spectroscopy under physiological conditions, these monolayers exhibit significant changes in their electrochemical barrier properties upon application of electrical DC potentials below +400 mV with respect to a standard calomel electrode. We further found the impedance switching to be reversible under physiological conditions. Moreover, the impedance can be fine-tuned by changing the magnitude of the applied electrical potential. Before and during impedance switching at pH 7.4 in aqueous buffer solutions, the low-density monolayers showed good stability according to grazing angle infrared spectroscopy data. We anticipate low-density monolayers to be potentially useful model surfaces when designing active biointerfaces for cell-based studies or rechargeable biosensors.     

Communication: Scanning tunneling microscopy study of the reaction of octanethiolate self-assembled monolayers with atomic chlorine

Scanning tunneling microscopy was used to investigate the reaction of octanethiolate self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) with atomic chlorine. We have found that exposing a SAM to low fluxes of radical Cl results primarily in the formation of new defects in areas with close-packed alkanethiolates, but has little to no effect on the domain boundaries of the SAM. Dosing high quantities of atomic chlorine results in the near-complete loss of surface order at room temperature, but not the complete removal of the thiolate monolayer. These observations are in stark contrast to the results of previous measurements of the reaction of atomic hydrogen with alkanethiolate SAMs.     

Surface structure of metal-organic framework grown on self-assembled monolayers revealed by high-resolution atomic force microscopy

The surface structure of an individual metal-organic framework (MOF) microcrystal grown on a functionalized surface has been successfully investigated for the first time in air and vacuum using high-resolution atomic force microscopy. Moreover, this detailed surface analysis has been utilized to optimize the MOF formation procedure to obtain a defect-free surface structure. Comparison of obtained data with recent microscopic studies performed on the same MOF crystal but grown by a conventional procedure clearly shows a much higher quality of crystals produced by surface oriented growth. Importantly, this method of preparing crystals suitable for microscopic analysis is also much faster (3 days compared to 2 years) and, in contrast to the conventional method, produces material suitable for in situ study. These results thus demonstrate for the first time the possibility of nanoscale investigation/modification of MOF surface structure.     

Local desorption of thiols by scanning electrochemical microscopy: patterning and tuning the reactivity of self-assembled monolayers

Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) are widely used in the field of nanotechnologies and (bio)sensors. The monolayer surface properties are tailored by employing several techniques. A large set of SAM post-modification routes are commonly performed to adapt them to a variety of nano-technological and bio-technological studies as well as to several bio-sensoristic applications. Here, we report a procedure to locally modify SAMs by electrochemical desorption of alkanethiols in order to create microsized spots of bare gold area without affecting the surrounding monolayer stability. The tip of the scanning electrochemical microscope (SECM) was employed to draw microstructured pattern according to a defined geometry. The time stability of the pattern was also tested. Furthermore, the patterned surface was post-functionalized using the same alkanethiol or a ferrocene-terminated thiol, in order to tune the surface reactivity of the microstructure. The local surface properties, including reactivity and electron transfer kinetics toward redox mediator reduction, were characterized by SECM.     

Fractional coverage of defects in self-assembled thiol monolayers on gold

Au electrodes are alkylated by self-assembled organic monolayers of octadecanethiol from alcohol solution. The electron tunnelling resistance of a monolayer-coated gold electrode has been investigated by ac impedance. The relation between the fractional coverage of different defects and the corresponding film thickness at these ‘collapsed’ sites has been deduced from electron tunnelling theory. By using the concepts of average film thickness at defect (d_a) and average fractional coverage of defect (θ_a), we have obtained the θ_ad_a plot. The influence of the apparent standard rate constant on the shape of the θ_ad_a plot has been discussed. In our experiments, Fe(CN)₆^3−/4− is used as a redox probe to study the θ_ad_a plot of an octadecanethiol monolayer. The θ_a versus d_a plot indicates that the defects with d_a<6 methylene groups and θ_a<0.1 can increase the apparent standard rate constant from 1.9×10⁻¹⁰ cm s⁻¹, which is the theoretical value calculated from electron tunnelling theory, to 2.9×10⁻⁷ cm s⁻¹. The average thickness of the whole monolayer (ATWM), which is obtained from the θ_a versus d_a plot and which can indicate the blocking property of the monolayer, is 11 methylene groups.     

Ferrocenylalkylthiolate labeling of defects in alkylthiol self-assembled monolayers on gold

Coverage defects in alkylthiol self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) are critically important to function related to electron transfer from soluble redox probes. There is therefore a need for an accurate and direct measurement of the number and type of coverage defect in a range of SAMs. Ferrocenyldodecanethiol (FcC(12)SH) has been assessed as an electrochemically-addressable label of coverage defects. It is shown that short time exposure of a SAM to FcC(12)SH leads to a quantifiable Fc coverage (Gamma(Fc)), with Gamma(Fc) < 1% readily measurable. The voltammetric signature of FcC(12)SH label is also able to differentiate types of defect in a given SAM. A number of SAM preparation conditions are assessed for the density and type of coverage defect. This labeling method therefore will be a useful tool for research into SAM property-function relationships.     

Scanning electrochemical microscopy as a probe of Ag+ binding kinetics at Langmuir phospholipid monolayers

A new method has been developed for measuring local adsorption rates of metal ions at interfaces based on scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM). The technique is illustrated with the example of Ag+ binding at Langmuir phospholipid monolayers formed at the water/air interface. Specifically, an inverted 25 microm diameter silver disc ultramicroelectrode (UME) was positioned in the subphase of a Langmuir trough, close to a dipalmitoyl phosphatidic acid (DPPA) monolayer, and used to generate Ag+ via Ag electro-oxidation. The method involved measuring the transient current-time response at the UME when the electrode was switched to a potential to electrogenerate Ag+. Since the Ag+/Ag couple is reversible, the response is highly sensitive to local mass transfer of Ag+ away from the electrode, which, in turn, is governed by the interaction of Ag+ with the monolayer. The methodology has been used to determine the influence of surface pressure on the adsorption of Ag+ ions at a phospholipid (dipalmitoyl phosphatidic acid) Langmuir monolayer. It is shown that the capacity for metal ion adsorption at the monolayer increased as the density of surface adsorption sites increased (by increasing the surface pressure). A model for mass transport and adsorption in this geometry has been developed to explain and characterise the adsorption process.     

Dynamic and collective electrochemical responses of tetrathiafulvalene derivative self-assembled monolayers

Electroactive tetrathiafulvalene (TTF)-containing alkanethiol self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) were designed and synthesized to elucidate the relationship between electrochemical responses and film structures. Two TTF derivative molecules having one alkanethiol chain (1) and two alkanethiol chains (2) were utilized to modulate the molecular packing arrangements in the SAMs, and the formation and structure of the SAMs were characterized by surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy (SPR). SPR measurements in various contacting media demonstrated loose packing of SAM 1 and close packing of SAM 2 due to the different space fillings of the molecules. Two successive one-electron redox waves were observed for both SAMs by cyclic voltammetry. The peak widths of the redox waves were strongly dependent on the oxidation states of the TTF moieties, the packing arrangement of the SAMs, and the contacting medium. We found that TTF-based SAMs exhibited collective electrochemical responses induced by dynamic structural changes, depending on the degree of freedom for the component molecules in the SAMs. These results imply that the molecular design, taking into account the electrochemical responses, extends the available range of molecular-based functionalities in TTF-based SAMs.