Robust solutions for network design under transportation cost and demand uncertainty

In many applications, the network design problem (NDP) faces significant uncertainty in transportation costs and demand, as it can be difficult to estimate current (and future values) of these quantities. In this paper, we present a robust optimization-based formulation for the NDP under transportation cost and demand uncertainty. We show that solving an approximation to this robust formulation of the NDP can be done efficiently for a network with single origin and destination per commodity and general uncertainty in transportation costs and demand that are independent of each other. For a network with path constraints, we propose an efficient column generation procedure to solve the linear programming relaxation. We also present computational results that show that the approximate robust solution found provides significant savings in the worst case while incurring only minor sub-optimality for specific instances of the uncertainty.     

Optimal inventory policies with two modes of freight transportation

Theoretical inventory models with constant demand rate and two transportation modes are analyzed in this paper. The transportation options are truckloads with fixed costs, a package delivery carrier with a constant cost per unit, or using a combination of both modes simultaneously. Exact algorithms for computing the optimal policies are derived for single stage models over both an infinite and a finite planning horizon.     

Impacts of inventory shortage policies on transportation requirements in two-stage distribution systems

This paper investigates the impacts inventory shortage policies have on transportation costs in base-stock distribution systems under uncertain demand. The model proposed demonstrates how backlogging arrangements can serve to decrease the variability of transportation capacity requirements, and hence the magnitude of transportation costs, when compared with policies that expedite demand shortages. The model shows how inventory policy decisions directly impact expected transportation costs and provides a new method for setting stock levels that jointly minimizes inventory and transportation costs. The model and solution method provide insights into the relationship between inventory decisions and transportation costs and can serve to support delivery policy negotiations between a supplier and customer that must choose between expediting and backlogging demand shortages.     

A production-transportation problem with stochastic demand and concave production costs

Well known extensions of the classical transportation problem are obtained by including fixed costs for the production of goods at the supply points (facility location) and/or by introducing stochastic demand, modeled by convex nonlinear costs, at the demand points (the stochastic transportation problem, [STP]). However, the simultaneous use of concave and convex costs is not very well treated in the literature. Economies of scale often yield concave cost functions other than fixed charges, so in this paper we consider a problem with general concave costs at the supply points, as well as convex costs at the demand points. The objective function can then be represented as the difference of two convex functions, and is therefore called a d.c. function. We propose a solution method which reduces the problem to a d.c. optimization problem in a much smaller space, then solves the latter by a branch and bound procedure in which bounding is based on solving subproblems of the form of [STP]. We prove convergence of the method and report computational tests that indicate that quite large problems can be solved efficiently. Problems up to the size of 100 supply points and 500 demand points are solved. Received October 11, 1993 / Revised version received July 31, 1995 Published online November 24, 1998     

部分联合运输策略下的物流车辆路径优化问题研究

论文分析了物流车辆路径优化问题的特点,提出了企业自营物流和第三方物流协同运输的部分联合运输策略。根据客户需求节点的特点进行了节点分类,建立了以车辆调用成本、车辆运输成本、第三方物流运输成本之和最小为目标的整数线性规划模型。根据部分联合运输策略下各类客户需求点运输方式特点,构造了一种新的变维数矩阵编码结构,并对传统算法中概率选择操作方式进行修改,提出了一种新的智能优化算法并与枚举法和遗传算法的运算结果进行了算法性能对比分析。结果显示,本文提出的逆选择操作蚁群算法具有较快的运算速度和较高的稳定性,是求解此类问题的一种有效算法。     

Notes on the single route lateral transhipment problem

Previous research has analyzed deterministic and stochastic models of lateral transhipments between different retailers in a supply chain. In these models the analysis assumes given fixed transhipment costs and determines under which situations (magnitudes of excess supply and demand at various retailers) the transhipment is profitable. However, in reality, these depend on aspects like the distance between retailers or the transportation mode chosen. In many situations, combining the transhipments may save transportation costs. For instance, one or more vehicle routes may be used to redistribute the inventory of the potential pickup and delivery stations. This can be done in any sequence as long as the vehicle capacity is not violated and there is enough load on the vehicle to satisfy demand. The corresponding problem is an extension of the one-commodity pickup and delivery traveling salesman and the pickup and delivery vehicle routing problem. When ignoring the routing aspect and assuming given fixed costs, transhipment is only profitable if the quantities are higher than a certain threshold. In contrast to that, the selection of visited retailers is dependent on the transportation costs of the tour and therefore the selected retailers are interrelated. Hence the problem also has aspects of a (team) orienteering problem. The main contribution is the discussion of the tour planning aspects for lateral transhipments which may be valuable for in-house planning but also for price negotiations with external contractors. A mixed integer linear program for the single route and single commodity version is presented and an improved LNS framework to heuristically solve the problem is introduced. Furthermore, the effect of very small load capacity on the structure of optimal solutions is discussed.     

Location-allocation on a line with demand-dependent costs

This paper extends the location-allocation formulation by making the cost charged to users by a facility a function of the total number of users patronizing the facility. Users select their facility based on facility charges and transportation costs. We explore equilibria where each customer selects the least expensive facility (cost and transportation) and where the facility is at a point that minimizes travel costs for its customers. The problem in its general form is quite complex. An interesting special case is studied: facilities and customers are located on a finite line segment and demand is distributed on the line by a given density function.     

Synchronizing production and air transportation scheduling using mathematical programming models

Traditional scheduling problems assume that there are always infinitely many resources for delivering finished jobs to their destinations, and no time is needed for their transportation, so that finished products can be transported to customers without delay. So, for coordination of these two different activities in the implementation of a supply chain solution, we studied the problem of synchronizing production and air transportation scheduling using mathematical programming models. The overall problem is decomposed into two sub-problems, which consists of air transportation allocation problem and a single machine scheduling problem which they are considered together. We have taken into consideration different constraints and assumptions in our modeling such as special flights, delivery tardiness and no delivery tardiness. For these purposes, a variety of models have been proposed to minimize supply chain total cost which encompass transportation, makespan, delivery earliness tardiness and departure time earliness tardiness costs.     

Stochastic uncapacitated hub location

We study stochastic uncapacitated hub location problems in which uncertainty is associated to demands and transportation costs. We show that the stochastic problems with uncertain demands or dependent transportation costs are equivalent to their associated deterministic expected value problem (EVP), in which random variables are replaced by their expectations. In the case of uncertain independent transportation costs, the corresponding stochastic problem is not equivalent to its EVP and specific solution methods need to be developed. We describe a Monte-Carlo simulation-based algorithm that integrates a sample average approximation scheme with a Benders decomposition algorithm to solve problems having stochastic independent transportation costs. Numerical results on a set of instances with up to 50 nodes are reported.     

Optimizing Supply Shortage Decisions in Base Stock Distribution Operations

This paper addresses policies and agreements between suppliers and customers for handling supply shortages in base-stock systems under uncertain demand. We investigate the impacts that backlogging and expediting decisions have on inventory and transportation costs in these systems and develop a model for deciding whether a supplier should completely backlog, completely expedite, or employ some combination of backlogging and expediting shortages. Our results indicate that practical cases exist where some combination of both expediting and backlogging supply shortages outperforms either completely expediting or backlogging all shortages. Including transportation costs in our model provides incentive to employ `hybrid' policies that partially expedite and partially backlog excess demands within a given period. Our model demonstrates how inventory policy decisions directly impact transportation costs and provides a heuristic approach for jointly minimizing expected inventory and transportation costs.     

Exact evaluation of (R,Q)-policies for two-level inventory systems with Poisson demand

In this paper we show how to exactly evaluate holding and shortage costs for a two-level inventory system with one warehouse and N different retailers. Lead-times (transportation times) are constant, and the retailers face different Poisson demand processes. All facilities apply continuous review (R, Q)-policies. We express the policy costs as a weighted mean of costs for one-for-one ordering policies.     

Location and allocation for distribution systems with transshipments and transportion economies of scale

Locating transshipment facilities and allocating origins and destinations to transshipment facilities are important decisions for many distribution and logistic systems. Models that treat demand as a continuous density over the service region often assume certain facility locations or a certain allocation of demand. It may be assumed that facility locations lie on a rectangular grid or that demand is allocated to the nearest facility or allocated such that each facility serves an equal amount of demand. These assumptions result in suboptimal distribution systems. This paper compares the transportation cost for suboptimal location and allocation schemes to the optimal cost to determine if suboptimal location and allocation schemes can produce nearly optimal transportation costs. Analytical results for distribution to a continuous demand show that nearly optimal costs can be achieved with suboptimal locations. An example of distribution to discrete demand points indicates the difficulties in applying these results to discrete demand problems.     

Optimal track class assignment for a railroad network

The track class and speed for North American railroads are governed by regulations from the Federal Railroad Administration. Better quality of track permits greater operational speeds and lower transportation cost but also requires greater maintenance expenditure. In this study, we considered the trade-off between maintenance and transportation costs, and developed an optimization framework determining the optimal assignment for track class based upon the characteristics of the track, traffic demand, and maintenance budget. We also presented a solution algorithm by using Lagrangian Relaxation techniques to improve the solution efficiency. This tool can help railroads maintain tracks at their most appropriate level so as to provide reliable and cost-effective services.     

Service network design for freight railway transportation: the Italian case

In this paper, we present a case study on freight railway transportation in Italy, which is a by-product of research collaboration with a major Italian railway company. We highlight the main features of the Italian reality and propose a customized mathematical model to design the service network, that is, the set of origin-destination connections. More specifically, the model suggests the services to provide, the number of trains travelling on each connection, the number of cars and their type. We consider both full and empty freight car movements and take handling costs into account. All decisions are taken in order to minimize the total costs. The quality of service is guaranteed by satisfying all the transportation demand and by implicitly minimizing the waiting time of cars at intermediate railway stations. Our approach yields to a multi-commodity network design problem with a concave cost function. To solve this problem, we implement a specialized tabu search procedure. Computational results on realistic instances show a significant improvement over current practice.     

Dynamic models for person transportation and their relationship to urban structure and change

The main task of this paper is to explore the general problem of building a dynamic transport model in the context of a broader understanding of urban structure and change. The approach explored in detail involves extensions of the entropy-maximizing method and, together with the demand side, also considers supply side dynamics. We show how to embed such a model into a dynamic urban structure model so that we can investigate secondary impacts of transport policy. The main dynamic feature of the model is given by the autonomous updating of the parameters of the transportation model following their relationship to the change of the exogenous variables, which are supposed to be influenced by the actual assignment of the demand of transportation. Such a kind of feed back in terms of travelling costs is the basic innovation introduced in the area of transportation modelling by the paper. An interactive software, called Dyna, is purposely developed and a suitable illustration of the flow-chart is presented.     

Outbound supply chain network design with mode selection,lead times and capacitated vehicle distribution centers

Most distribution network design models considered to date have focused on minimizing fixed costs of facility location and transportation costs. Measures of customer satisfaction driven by the operational dynamics such as lead times have seldom been considered. We consider the design of an outbound supply chain network considering lead times, location of distribution facilities and choice of transportation mode. We present a Lagrangian heuristic that gives excellent solution quality in reasonable computational time. Scenario analyses are conducted on industrial data using this algorithm to observe how the supply chain behaves under different parameter values.     

A production planning model for an unreliable production facility: Case of finite horizon and single demand

We study a two-level inventory system that is subject to failures and repairs. The objective is to minimize the expected total cost so as to determine the production plan for a single quantity demand. The expected total cost consists of the inventory carrying costs for finished and unfinished items, the backlog cost for not meeting the demand due-date, and the planning costs associated with the ordering schedule of unfinished items. The production plan consists of the optimal number of lot sizes, the optimal size for each lot, the optimal ordering schedule for unfinished items, and the optimal due-date to be assigned to the demand. To gain insight, we solve special cases and use their results to device an efficient solution approach for the main model. The models are solved to optimality and the solution is either obtained in closed form or through very efficient algorithms.     

Filtering Policies in Loss Queuing Network Location Problems

In this paper we deal with two stationary loss queuing network location models. We analyze the influence of filtering policies on the locational aspect of the problems. We assume that requests for service are placed at nodes of a transportation network and they arrive in time as independent homogeneous Poisson processes with different input rates. The considered policies only cover a given proportion of requests even if there are idle service units. This proportion is stationary and fixed in advance and only depends on the node where the request is originated. The objective is to find the location of the facilities together with the filtering policy to be applied that minimize the expected total cost per unit time with respect to a given cost structure. Properties and computational results are presented enabling the resolution of these problems efficiently and showing the good performance of filtering policies in terms of both the overall operating costs, and the demand that is served.     

Dynamic dairy facility location and supply chain planning under traffic congestion and demand uncertainty: A case study of Tehran

In this paper, dynamic dairy facility location and supply chain planning are studied through minimizing the costs of facility location, traffic congestion and transportation of raw/processed milk and dairy products under demand uncertainty. The proposed model dynamically incorporates possible changes in transportation network, facility investment costs, monetary value of time and changes in production process. In addition, the time variation and the demand uncertainty for dairy products in each period of the planning horizon is taken into account to determine the optimal facility location and the optimal production volumes. Computational results are presented for the model on a number of test problems. Also, an empirical case study is conducted in order to investigate the dynamic effects of traffic congestion and demand uncertainty on facility location design and total system costs.     

A heuristic solution technique to attain the minimal total cost bounds of transporting a homogeneous product with varying demands and supplies

Transportation of a product from multi-source to multi-destination with minimal total transportation cost plays an important role in logistics and supply chain management. Researchers have given considerable attention in minimizing this cost with fixed supply and demand quantities. However, these quantities may vary within a certain range in a period due to the variation of the global economy. So, the concerned parties might be more interested in finding the lower and the upper bounds of the minimal total costs with varying supplies and demands within their respective ranges for proper decision making. This type of transportation problem has received attention of only one researcher, who formulated the problem and solved it by LINGO. We demonstrate that this method fails to obtain the correct upper bound solution always. Then we extend this model to include the inventory costs during transportation and at destinations, as they are interrelated factors. The number of choices of supplies and demands within their respective ranges increases enormously as the number of suppliers and buyers increases. In such a situation, although the lower bound solution can be obtained methodologically, determination of the upper bound solution becomes an NP hard problem. Here we carry out theoretical analyses on developing the lower and the upper bound heuristic solution techniques to the extended model. A comparative study on solutions of small size numerical problems shows promising performance of the current upper bound technique. Another comparative study on results of numerical problems demonstrates the effect of inclusion of the inventory costs.