Hyperlayer separation in hollow fiber flow field-flow fractionation: effect of membrane materials on resolution and selectivity

Hollow fiber flow FFF (HF FlFFF) has recently shown its capability to separate and characterize the size of submicrometer particles and has demonstrated the potential to be developed into a disposable flow FFF channel. In this work, HF FlFFF was used for the hyperlayer separation of micron-sized particles and the separation capability was examined by using various hollow fiber membrane materials (Polysulfones, cPVC, and PAN). From the experiments, PAN (polyacrylonitriles) showed an outstanding performance in particle separation compared to the other membranes. By orienting the fiber module in an upright direction, the upstream flow migration reduced band broadening of eluted peaks. When the efficiency of the PAN hollow fiber system was tested by varying the ratio of outflow-rate to radial flow-rate, it was found that optimum separation in hyperlayer HF FlFFF can be obtained at the ratio of about 6–7. From the examination of retention at or around steric inversion diameter, it was observed that experiments showed a good agreement with predictions by semi-empirical calculation. In hyperlayer HF FlFFF the diameter based selectivity values were shown to be 1.2–1.7 depending on the type of membranes and the field strength (the radial flow-rate) conditions.     

Different elution modes and field programming in gravitational field-flow fractionation. IV. Field programming achieved with channels of non-constant cross-sections

Force field programming provided increased speed of separation with an improved resolution and detection capability in many field-flow fractionation (FFF) techniques. Gravitational field-flow fractionation (GFFF) uses the Earth's gravitational field to cause the settlement of particles towards the channel accumulation wall. Although this field is constant and relatively weak, there are different ways to implement force field programming in GFFF. Because hydrodynamic lift forces (HLF) participate in the separation process in focusing (hyperlayer) elution mode, they can control the resulting force field acting on particles via changes in flow-velocity. These changes can be accomplished by a programmable pump or with channels of non-constant cross-sections. This work is focused on flow-velocity programming accomplished with channels of non-constant cross-sections. Three trapezoidal channels of decreasing breadth and two channels of decreasing height (along the longitudinal axis) are tested as tools for optimization of the separation of a model silica gel particle mixture. The trapezoidal channels yielded reduced separation times. However, taking into account both speed of separation and resolution, the optimization effect was lower compared with the flow-rate gradients generated by a programmable pump. The channels of non-constant height did not yield advantageous separations.     

Osmolarity effects on red blood cell elution in sedimentation field-flow fractionation.

Field-flow fractionation (FFF) is an analytical technique particularly suitable for the separation, isolation, and characterization of macromolecules and micrometer- or submicrometer-sized particles. This chromatographic-like methodology can modulate the retention of micron-sized species according to an elution mode described to date as "steric hyperlayer". In such a model, differences in sample species size, density, or other physical parameters make particle selective elution possible depending on the configuration and the operating conditions of the FFF system. Elution characteristics of micron-sized particles of biological origin, such as cells, can be modified using media and carrier phases of different osmolarities. In these media, a cells average size, density, and shape are modified. Therefore, systematic studies of a single reference cell population, red blood cells (RBCs), are performed with 2 sedimentation FFF systems using either gravity (GrFFF) or a centrifugational field (SdFFF). However, in all cases, normal erythrocyte in isotonic suspension elutes as a single peak when fractionated in these systems. With carrier phases of different osmolarities, FFF elution characteristics of RBCs are modified. Retention modifications are qualitatively consistent with the "steric-hyperlayer" model. Such systematic studies confirm the key role of size, density, and shape in the elution mode of RBCs in sedimentation FFF for living, micronsized biological species. Using polymers as an analogy, the RBC population is described as highly "polydisperse". However, this definition must be reconsidered depending on the parameters under concern, leading to a matricial concept: multipolydispersity. It is observed that multipolydispersity modifications of a given RBC population are qualitatively correlated to the eluted sample band width.     

Different elution modes and field programming in gravitational field-flow fractionation. Effect of channel angle

Gravitational field-flow fractionation (GrFFF) has been shown to be useful for separation and characterization of various types of micrometer-sized particles. It has been recognized however that GrFFF is less versatile than other members of FFF because the external field (Earth's gravity) in GrFFF is relatively weak and is not tunable (constant), which makes the force acting on the particles constant. A few approaches have been suggested to control the force acting on particles in GrFFF. They include (1) changing the angle between the Earth's gravitational field and the longitudinal axis of the channel, and (2) the use of carrier liquid having different densities. In the hyperlayer mode of GrFFF, the hydrodynamic lift force (HLF) also act on particles. The existence of HLF allows other means of changing the force acting on the particles in GrFFF. They include (1) the flow rate programming, or (2) the use of channels having non-constant cross-section. In this study, with polystyrene latex beads used as model particles, the channel angle was varied to study its effect on elution parameters (such as selectivity, band broadening and resolution) in the steric or in the hyperlayer mode of GrFFF. In addition, the effects of the channel thickness and the flow rate on the elution parameters were also investigated. It was found that, in the steric mode, the resolution decreases as the flow rate increases due to increased zone broadening despite of the increase in the selectivity. At a constant volumetric flow rate, both the zone broadening and the selectivity increase as the channel thickness increases, resulting in the net increase in the resolution. It was also found that the retention time decreases as the channel angle increases in both up- and down-flow positions. The zone broadening tends to increase almost linearly with the channel angle, while no particular trends were found in selectivity. As a result, the resolution decreases as the channel angle increases.     

Asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation technique for separation and characterization of biopolymers and bioparticles

Field-flow fractionation (FFF) is one of the most versatile separation techniques in the field of analytical separation sciences, capable of separating macromolecules in the range 10³–10¹⁵ g mol⁻¹ and/or particles with 1 nm–100 μm in diameter. The most universal and most frequently used FFF technique, flow FFF, includes three types of techniques, namely symmetrical flow FFF, hollow fiber flow FFF, and asymmetrical flow FFF which is most established variant among them. This review provides a brief look at the theoretical background of analyte retention and separation efficiency in FFF, followed by a comprehensive overview of the current status of asymmetrical flow FFF with selected applications in the field of biopolymers and bioparticles.     

Sedimentation field-flow-fractionation: emergence of a new cell separation methodology

Field flow fractionation (FFF) methods were conceptualised in the late 1960s by J.C Giddings. These techniques are particularly suited for the retention and separation of micron and sub-micron sized particles. Systematic technological development as well as methodological procedures were established to achieve separations over the last 30 years. The elution mechanism of micron sized species is now known as 'steric/hyperlayer'. Cells are micron sized particles of life science interest, in particular those living in suspension. The separation of cells according to differences in their biophysical characteristics is therefore possible using the FFF principle. In the first part of this report, characteristics of classical cell separation methodologies are recounted as well as the specific features of FFF. In the second part, a review of cell separations or purifications obtained with sedimentation FFF techniques is given and FFF trends in cell separation is developed.     

Particle size analyses of porous silica and hybrid silica chromatographic support particles. Comparison of flow/hyperlayer field-flow fractionation with scanning electron microscopy, electrical sensing zone, and static light scattering

Porous silica and hybrid silica chromatographic support particles having particle diameters ranging approximately from 1 microm to 15 microm have been characterized by flow/hyperlayer field-flow fractionation (FFF). The particle size accuracy has been improved significantly in this work by a second-order polynomial calibration. Very good agreement between the FFF data and scanning electron microscopic (SEM) results has been achieved. The effects of particle porosity, pore sizes, and particle sizes on the particle size accuracy in electrical sensing zone (ESZ) analyses have been discussed. It has been demonstrated by computer simulation and experimental measurements that false peaks can be generated in certain particle size regions when the static light scattering (SLS) technique is applied to tightly distributed spherical chromatographic support particles.     

Separation of carbon nanotubes by frit inlet asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation

Flow field-flow fractionation (flow FFF), a separation technique for particles and macromolecules, has been used to separate carbon nanotubes (CNT). The carbon nanotube ropes that were purified from a raw carbon nanotube mixture by acidic reflux followed by cross-flow filtration using a hollow fiber module were cut into shorter lengths by sonication under a concentrated acid mixture. The cut carbon nanotubes were separated by using a modified flow FFF channel system, frit inlet asymmetrical flow FFF (FI AFIFFF) channel, which was useful in the continuous flow operation during injection and separation. Carbon nanotubes, before and after the cutting process, were clearly distinguished by their retention profiles. The narrow volume fractions of CNT collected during flow FFF runs were confirmed by field emission scanning electron microscopy and Raman spectroscopy. Experimentally, it was found that retention of carbon nanotubes in flow FFF was dependent on the use of surfactant for CNT dispersion and for the carrier solution in flow FFF. In this work, the use of flow FFF for the size differentiation of carbon nanotubes in the process of preparation or purification was demonstrated.     

Theoretical analysis of the local orientation effect and the lift‐hyperlayer mode of rodlike particles in field‐flow fractionation

We investigated theoretically the effects of the cross‐stream migration and the local average orientation of rodlike particles on the shape‐based separation using field‐flow fractionation. The separation behavior was analyzed by comparing the retention ratios of spheres and rods. The retention ratio of a rod was evaluated through the derivation of its cross‐sectional concentration profile by considering the rod migration and the local average orientation. Our study in various flow conditions showed that the rod migration, caused by the hydrodynamic interaction with a wall, can affect the separation behavior as a lift‐hyperlayer mode. We also demonstrated that the local average orientation, which is a function of a local shear rate and a rotational diffusivity, results in the transverse diffusivity that is different from its perpendicular diffusivity. These results suggest that the experimental separation behaviors of rods in field‐flow fractionation may not be fully explained by the current theory based on the normal mode and the steric mode. We also characterized each condition where one of the normal mode, the steric mode of spheres, and the lift‐hyperlayer mode of rods is dominant.     

Field-flow fractionation: Analytical and micropreparative methodology

Since the introduction of the general concept, field-flow fractionation (FFF) was developed to a complex of separation methods that differ by the fundamental processes underlying and accompanying the separation. In this review, the basic principles on which this separation methodology lies are presented, the most important methods and techniques applicable for analytical and preparative fractionations are described, the first approximation theoretical treatment of the separation processes is outlined, and typical applications for analytical and micropreparative purposes are demonstrated. The main goal is to show that FFF represents an interesting and competitive option of the separation methods applicable in analytical chemistry. The existence of some conflicting opinions concerning the theory as well as the experiments does not prohibit the analytical and preparative use of FFF. If not regarded only as a routine analytical tool, it should stimulate the research and development efforts. On the other hand, when used as an analytical tool, even if the approximate theoretical models are not fully supported by the experiments, the correct analytical result can be obtained from FFF (as well as from any other analytical separation method) by using a calibration procedure and an appropriate treatment and interpretation of the raw experimental data.     

Study on the discrete dielectrophoresis for particle–cell separation

This paper presents the application of the discrete dielectrophoretic force to separate polystyrene particles from red blood cells. The separation process employs a simple microfluidic device that is composed of interdigitated electrodes and a microchannel. The discrete dielectrophoretic force is generated by adjusting the duty cycle of the applied voltage. The electrodes make a tilt angle with the microchannel to change the moving direction of the red blood cells. By adjusting the voltage magnitude and duty cycle, we investigate the deflection of red blood cells and the variation of cell velocity along electrode edge under positive dielectrophoresis. The experiments with polystyrene particles show that the enrichment of the particles is greater than 150 times. The maximum separation efficiency is 97% for particle-to-cell number ratio equal to 1:2000 in the sample having high cell concentration. Using the appropriate applied voltage magnitude and duty cycle, the discrete dielectrophoretic force can prevent the clogging of microchannel while successfully separating the particles from the cells with high enrichment and efficiency. The proposed principle can be readily applied to dielectrophoresis-based devices for biomedical sample preparation or diagnosis such as the separation of rare or infected cells from a blood sample.     

Advances in field-flow fractionation for the analysis of biomolecules: instrument design and hyphenation

Field-flow fractionation (FFF) separates analytes by use of an axial channel-flow and a cross-field. Its soft separation capability makes it an ideal tool for initial fractionation of complex mixtures, but large elution volumes and high flow rates have limited its applicability without significant user handling. Recent advances in instrumentation and miniaturization have successfully reduced channel size and elution speed, and thus the volume of each fraction, making it possible to conveniently couple FFF with orthogonal separation techniques for improved resolution. More detailed analysis can also be performed on the fractions generated by FFF by use of diverse analytical techniques, including MS, NMR, and even X-ray scattering. These developmental trends have given FFF more power in the analysis of different types of molecule, and will be the direction of choice for further advances in FFF technology.     

Methods for continuous flow fractionation of microparticles: Outlooks and fields of application

The development of new methods for fractionating particles of a different nature is becoming more important in solving some scientific and technological problems. This paper presents a brief review in the theory and practice of the most common techniques for microparticle fractionation (0.1–100 μm). These are dry and wet sieving, elutriation, sequential filtration, split-flow thin fractionation (SPLITT system), field-flow fractionation (FFF), membrane filtration, and capillary electrophoresis. Special attention is paid to the FFF technique, which offers a unique potential for the separation of different materials, from biopolymers and microorganisms to colloidal and solid particles, and the estimation of their physical properties. An alternative version of sedimentation FFF is described, namely, the fractionation of microparticles in rotating coiled columns. The main advantages and limitations of the methods are revealed and their outlooks and fields of applications are envisaged.     

Dielectrophoretic field‐flow fractionation of electroporated cells

We describe the development and testing of a setup that allows for DEP field‐flow fractionation (DEP‐FFF) of irreversibly electroporated, reversibly electroporated, and nonelectroporated cells based on their different polarizabilities. We first optimized the channel and electrode dimensions, flow rate, and electric field parameters for efficient DEP‐FFF separation of moderately heat‐treated CHO cells (50°C for 15 min) from untreated ones, with the former used as a uniform and stable model of electroporated cells. We then used CHO cells exposed to electric field pulses with amplitudes from 1200 to 2800 V/cm, yielding six groups containing various fractions of nonporated, reversibly porated, and irreversibly porated cells, testing their fractionation in the chamber. DEP‐FFF at 65 kHz resulted in distinctive flow rates for nonporated and each of the porated cell groups. At lower frequencies, the efficiency of fractionation deteriorated, while at higher frequencies the separation of individual elution profiles was further improved, but at the cost of cell flow rate slowdown in all the cell groups, implying undesired transition from negative into positive DEP, where the cells are pulled toward the electrodes. Our results demonstrate that fractionation of irreversibly electroporated, reversibly electroporated, and nonelectroporated cells is feasible at a properly selected frequency.     

Hollow-fiber flow/hyperlayer field-flow fractionation for the size characterization of airborne particle fractions obtained by SPLITT fractionation

Hollow-fiber flow field-flow fractionation (HF FlFFF) was applied for the separation and size characterization of airborne particles which were collected in a municipal area and prefractionated into four different-diameter intervals >5.0, 2.5-5.0, 1.5-2.5, <1.5 microm) by continuous split-flow thin (SPLIIT) fractionation. Experiments demonstrated the possibility of utilizing a hollow-fiber module for the high-performance separation of supramicron-sized airborne particles at steric/hyperlayer operating mode of HF FlFFF. Eluting particles during HF FlFFF separation were collected at short time intervals (approximately 10 s) for the microscopic examination. It showed that particle size and size distributions of all SPLITT fractions of airborne particles can be readily obtained using a calibration and that HF FlFFF can be utilized for the size confirmation of the sorted particle fraction during SPLITT fractionation.     

非对称流场流分离技术的现状及发展趋势

场流分离是生物分析领域一项成熟的技术,将流体与外场联合作用于待分离物质,利用分析物某些理化参数上的差异进行分离。非对称流场流是其重要的分支之一,所施加的外力场为垂直方向的液流,分离过程于开放型的通道中在某种组成的载液迁移推动下进行,主要根据分析物与垂直施加的第二维液流之间的相互作用完成分离。非对称流场流在蛋白质、蛋白质复合物、衍生纳米级/微米级粒子、亚细胞单元和聚合物等分离中的应用日益广泛,主要归功于其直接应用于生物样品时可进行无损分离,因此生物分析物如蛋白质可以在生物友好型的环境中完成分离而不改变其构型,也无需使用降解载液。分离设备便于保持无菌状态,分析物可在生物友好的环境中维持其自然状态。该文简要描述了场流分离原理并罗列出其在生物分析领域一些卓越的发展和应用。     

无固定相分离-电感耦合等离子体质谱法在环境中痕量金属纳米颗粒分析中的应用

环境中金属纳米颗粒的分析检测不仅需要关注其浓度和化学组成,还需要对其形状、粒径和表面电荷等进行表征。此外,环境中金属纳米颗粒的分析需要解决其低赋存浓度以及复杂基质干扰的难题。无固定相分离技术与电感耦合等离子体质谱(ICP-MS)的在线联用,具有较强的颗粒分离能力和较低的元素检出限,能够快速准确地提供金属纳米颗粒的粒径分布、化学组成等信息,在金属纳米颗粒的分离检测方面表现出极大的潜能。但这一联用技术尚无法获得金属纳米颗粒物的颗粒数浓度和单个颗粒的元素信息,难以判断金属纳米颗粒涂层厚度、纯度以及颗粒的均相/异相团聚行为等。新兴的单颗粒-电感耦合等离子体质谱(SP-ICP-MS)与无固定相分离技术的在线联用,可以获得金属纳米颗粒的流体动力学粒径、元素质量计算粒径和颗粒数浓度等信息,进而弥补无固定相分离与ICP-MS在线联用技术的不足。该文介绍了流体动力色谱、毛细管电泳和场流分离3种常用无固定相分离技术的分离机制和适用检测器,着重综述了无固定相分离技术与ICP-MS/SP-ICP-MS在线联用技术的特点及其在环境金属纳米颗粒分析中的应用。关于场流分离,主要介绍了可以与ICP-MS联用的沉降场流分离和流场流分离。该文还对流体动力色谱、毛细管电泳和流场流分离与ICP-MS在线联用技术的特点进行了比较。最后,该文对无固定相分离技术与ICP-MS/SP-ICP-MS在线联用技术的发展提出了展望。     

Feasibility study of red blood cell debulking by magnetic field-flow fractionation with step-programmed flow

Emerging applications of rare cell separation and analysis, such as separation of mature red blood cells from hematopoietic cell cultures, require efficient methods of red blood cell (RBC) debulking. We have tested the feasibility of magnetic RBC separation as an alternative to centrifugal separation using an approach based on the mechanism of magnetic field-flow fractionation (MgFFF). A specially designed permanent magnet assembly generated a quadrupole field having a maximum field of 1.68 T at the magnet pole tips, zero field at the aperture axis, and a nearly constant radial field gradient of 1.75 T/mm (with a negligible angular component) inside a cylindrical aperture of 1.9 mm (diameter) and 76 mm (length). The cell samples included high-spin hemoglobin RBCs obtained by chemical conversion of hemoglobin to methemoglobin (met RBC) or by exposure to anoxic conditions (deoxy RBC), low-spin hemoglobin obtained by exposure of RBC suspension to ambient air (oxy RBC), and mixtures of deoxy RBC and cells from a KG-1a white blood cell (WBC) line. The observation that met RBCs did not elute from the channel at the lower flow rate of 0.05 mL/min applied for 15 min but quickly eluted at the subsequent higher flow rate of 2.0 mL/min was in agreement with FFF theory. The well-defined experimental conditions (precise field and flow characteristics) and a well-established FFF theory verified by studies with model cell systems provided us with a strong basis for making predictions about potential practical applications of the magnetic RBC separation.

Comparison of polymer resolution in thermal field-flow fractionation and size-exclusion chromatography

A comparison of the resolving power of themal field-flow fractionation (thermal FFF) and size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) has been made by the experimental operation of a high-resolution system from each category. For the experimental systems used, the measured resolution for thermal FFF was found to be higher than that for SEC for three different binary polymer mixtures. Only for a single low-molecular-weight mixture falling outside the optimal operating range of thermal FFF did SEC show better resolution. The experimental resolution values were broken down into selectivity and column efficiency parameters. While selectivity was easily obtained, column efficiency required a correction for polydispersity effects. With the polydispersity correction made on the basis of thermal FFF data, true resolution values were calculated to replace the apparent or experimental resolution levels. Overall, the corrected resolution values showed that thermal FFF had a significant advantage over SEC. Prospects for future advances in these two techniques are discussed.