Characterization of Ligand Binding by Saturation Transfer Difference NMR Spectroscopy

Fast identification of binding activity directly from mixtures of potential ligands is possible with the NMR method described, which is based on saturation transfer to molecules in direct contact to a protein. In addition, the ligand's binding epitope is easily identified. High sensitivity and ease of use are the principal advantages of this method. The picture shows the normal 1D NMR spectrum of a mixture and the spectrum obtained by applying the STD method, which exclusively shows signals from molecules with binding affinity.     

Detecting ligand binding to a small RNA target via saturation transfer difference NMR experiments in D(2)O and H(2)O

A small RNA motif is used as a target for ligand-based NMR-screening by saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR experiments. The prerequisites for using a small RNA target in STD experiments, such as saturation time, frequency, and pulses, are discussed. We also show that it is of advantage to use D2O as solvent instead of H2O due to the reduced R1 relaxation rate in D2O. The 27-nucleotide model of the ribosomal A-site was known to bind the aminoglycoside paromomycin with high affinity. This binding interaction could be detected easily, proving the effectiveness of STD NMR experiments as a screening tool for RNA-ligand interactions.     

Direct observation of ligand binding to membrane proteins in living cells by a saturation transfer double difference (STDD) NMR spectroscopy method shows a significantly higher affinity of integrin alpha(IIb)beta3 in native platelets than in liposomes

About 30% of the proteins in mammalian systems are membrane bound or integrated (e.g., GPCRs). It is inherently difficult to investigate receptor-ligand interactions on a molecular level in their natural membrane environment. Here, we present a new method based on saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR to characterize at an atomic level binding interactions of cell surface proteins in living cells. Implemented as a double difference technique, STD NMR allows the direct observation of binding events and the definition of the binding epitopes of ligands. The binding of the pentapeptide cyclo(RGDfV) to the surface glycoprotein integrin alpha(IIb)beta3 of intact human blood platelets can be detected by saturation transfer double difference (STDD) NMR in less than an hour. A 5-fold higher STD response reflects a significantly higher affinity of integrin alpha(IIb)beta3 in native platelets than in liposomes, which demonstrates the importance of studying membrane proteins in their natural environment. Also, the binding mode of cyclo(RGDfV) in the arginine glycine region is slightly different when interacting with native integrin in platelets compared to integrin reintegrated into liposomes.     

Saturation transfer double-difference NMR spectroscopy using a dual solenoid microcoil difference probe

An experiment designed to collect a saturation transfer double difference (STDD) NMR spectrum using a solenoid microcoil NMR difference probe is reported. STDD-NMR allows the investigation of ligand-biomolecule binding, with moderate concentration requirements for unlabeled molecular targets and the ability to discern binding events in the presence of non-binding ligands. The NMR difference probe acquires the signals from two different samples at once, and cancels common signals automatically through a mechanism of switching between parallel excitation and serial acquisition of the sample signals. STDD spectra were acquired on a system consisting of human serum albumin and two ligands, octanoic acid and glucose. The non-binding ligand, glucose, was cancelled internally through phase cycling, while the protein signal was subtracted automatically by the difference probe. The proton NMR resonance signal from octanoic acid remained in the double difference spectrum. This work demonstrates that the double difference can be performed both internally and automatically through the utilization of the solenoid microcoil NMR difference probe and STDD-NMR pulse sequence, resulting in a clean signal from the binding ligand with good protein background subtraction and an overall favorable result when compared to the conventional approach.     

Competition STD NMR for the detection of high-affinity ligands and NMR-based screening

The reported competition STD NMR method combines saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR with competition binding experiments to allow the detection of high-affinity ligands that undergo slow chemical exchange on the NMR time-scale. With this technique, the presence of a competing high-affinity ligand in the compound mixture can be detected by the disappearance or reduction of the STD signals of a low-affinity indicator ligand. This is demonstrated on a BACE1 (beta-site amyloid precursor protein cleaving enzyme 1) protein-inhibitor system. This method can also be used to derive an approximate value, or a lower limit, for the dissociation constant of the potential ligand based on the reduction of the signal intensity of the STD indicator, which is illustrated on an HSA (human serum albumin) model system. This leads to important applications of the competition STD NMR method for lead discovery: it can be used (i) for compound library screening against a broad range of drug targets to identify both high- and low-affinity ligands and (ii) to rank order analogs rapidly and derive structure-activity relationships, which are used to optimize these NMR hits into viable drug leads.     

Ligand–Receptor Binding Affinities from Saturation Transfer Difference (STD) NMR Spectroscopy: The Binding Isotherm of STD Initial Growth Rates

The direct evaluation of dissociation constants (K_D) from the variation of saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR spectroscopy values with the receptor–ligand ratio is not feasible due to the complex dependence of STD intensities on the spectral properties of the observed signals. Indirect evaluation, by competition experiments, allows the determination of K_D, as long as a ligand of known affinity is available for the protein under study. Herein, we present a novel protocol based on STD NMR spectroscopy for the direct measurements of receptor–ligand dissociation constants (K_D) from single‐ligand titration experiments. The influence of several experimental factors on STD values has been studied in detail, confirming the marked impact on standard determinations of protein–ligand affinities by STD NMR spectroscopy. These factors, namely, STD saturation time, ligand residence time in the complex, and the intensity of the signal, affect the accumulation of saturation in the free ligand by processes closely related to fast protein–ligand rebinding and longitudinal relaxation of the ligand signals. The proposed method avoids the dependence of the magnitudes of ligand STD signals at a given saturation time on spurious factors by constructing the binding isotherms using the initial growth rates of the STD amplification factors, in a similar way to the use of NOE growing rates to estimate cross relaxation rates for distance evaluations. Herein, it is demonstrated that the effects of these factors are cancelled out by analyzing the protein–ligand association curve using STD values at the limit of zero saturation time, when virtually no ligand rebinding or relaxation takes place. The approach is validated for two well‐studied protein–ligand systems: the binding of the saccharides GlcNAc and GlcNAcβ1,4GlcNAc (chitobiose) to the wheat germ agglutinin (WGA) lectin, and the interaction of the amino acid L ‐tryptophan to bovine serum albumin (BSA). In all cases, the experimental K_D measured under different experimental conditions converged to the thermodynamic values. The proposed protocol allows accurate determinations of protein–ligand dissociation constants, extending the applicability of the STD NMR spectroscopy for affinity measurements, which is of particular relevance for those proteins for which a ligand of known affinity is not available.     

Probing the binding of propranolol enantiomers to alpha1-acid glycoprotein with ligand-detected NMR experiments

Mapping the interactions of a small molecule ligand with a protein can provide information important for biochemical studies and for drug design and development. This information can be determined using the ligand-detected (1)H NMR experiments T(1rho)-NOESY, diffusion, and saturation transfer difference (STD). This work compares the results of these experiments and examines their ability to distinguish the binding epitopes of propranolol enantiomers with alpha 1-acid glycoprotein (AGP). The epitope maps for the propranolol enantiomers are fairly similar, as expected from their similar binding affinities; however, the STD epitope maps provide unique insights into the different orientations of the enantiomers with respect to the AGP binding pocket. Our results suggest that it is best to consider the data provided by several NMR epitope mapping experiments in drawing conclusions about ligand-protein binding interactions.     

13C‐NMR detection of STD spectra

We have investigated the use of ¹³C for the detection of saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR spectra. By detecting the STD spectrum in the ¹³C channel it is possible to eliminate the residual water signal in the STD‐NMR spectrum. We have employed an INEPT transfer in order to shift the magnetization from the proton channel to ¹³C. As a sample system to check our method we have used human serum albumin and phenylalanine. We have shown that such a transfer can be accomplished and gives reasonable signal intensities. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Selective Targeting of Dendritic Cell‐Specific Intercellular Adhesion Molecule‐3‐Grabbing Nonintegrin (DC‐SIGN) with Mannose‐Based Glycomimetics: Synthesis and Interaction Studies of Bis(benzylamide) Derivatives of a Pseudomannobioside

Dendritic cell‐specific intercellular adhesion molecule‐3‐grabbing nonintegrin (DC‐SIGN) and Langerin are C‐type lectins of dendritic cells (DCs) that share a specificity for mannose and are involved in pathogen recognition. HIV is known to use DC‐SIGN on DCs to facilitate transinfection of T‐cells. Langerin, on the contrary, contributes to virus elimination; therefore, the inhibition of this latter receptor is undesired. Glycomimetic molecules targeting DC‐SIGN have been reported as promising agents for the inhibition of viral infections and for the modulation of immune responses mediated by DC‐SIGN. We show here for the first time that glycomimetics based on a mannose anchor can be tuned to selectively inhibit DC‐SIGN over Langerin. Based on structural and binding studies of a mannobioside mimic previously described by us ( 2 ), a focused library of derivatives was designed. The optimized synthesis gave fast and efficient access to a group of bis(amides), decorated with an azide‐terminated tether allowing further conjugation. SPR inhibition tests showed improvements over the parent pseudomannobioside by a factor of 3–4. A dimeric, macrocyclic structure ( 11 ) was also serendipitously obtained, which afforded a 30‐fold gain over the starting compound ( 2 ). The same ligands were tested against Langerin and found to exhibit high selectivity towards DC‐SIGN. Structural studies using saturation transfer difference NMR spectroscopy (STD‐NMR) were performed to analyze the binding mode of one representative library member with DC‐SIGN. Despite the overlap of some signals, it was established that the new ligand interacts with the protein in the same fashion as the parent pseudodisaccharide. The two aromatic amide moieties showed relatively high saturation in the STD spectrum, which suggests that the improved potency of the bis(amides) over the parent dimethyl ester can be attributed to lipophilic interactions between the aromatic groups of the ligand and the binding site of DC‐SIGN.     

Synthesis and optimization of peptidomimetics as HIV entry inhibitors against the receptor protein CD4 using STD NMR and ligand docking

We recently described the design and synthesis of a novel CD4 binding peptidomimetic as a potential HIV entry inhibitor with a KD value of approximately 35 microM and a high proteolytic stability [A. T. Neffe and B. Meyer, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed., 2004, 43, 2937-2940]. Based on saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR analyses and docking studies of peptidomimetics we now report the rational design, synthesis, and binding properties of 11 compounds with improved binding affinity. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) resulted in a KD = 10 microM for the best peptidomimetic XI, whose binding affinity is confirmed by STD NMR (KD = 9 microM). The STD NMR determined binding epitope of the ligand indicates a very similar binding mode as that of the lead structure. The binding studies provide structure activity relationships and demonstrate the utility of this approach.     

Virus-ligand interactions: identification and characterization of ligand binding by NMR spectroscopy

We demonstrate the detection and characterization of ligand binding to viruses via NMR. To illustrate the methodology, the interaction of an antiviral compound with human rhinovirus serotype 2 (HRV2) was investigated. Specific interaction of a capsid-binding inhibitor and native HRV2 was monitored utilizing saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR. STD NMR experiments at atomic resolution allowed those regions of the ligand that are involved in the interaction with the virus to be determined. The approach allows for (i) the fast and robust assessment of binding, (ii) the determination of the ligand binding epitope at atomic resolution without the necessity to crystallize virus-ligand complexes, and (iii) the reuse of the virus in subsequent assays. This methodology enables one to easily identify binding of drugs, peptides, and receptor or antibody fragments to the viral capsid.     

Sensitivity enhancement in saturation transfer difference (STD) experiments through optimized excitation schemes

Investigation of ligand-protein interactions by the saturation transfer difference (STD) experiment has been well established in the drug discovery process through numerous examples. Thus, binding epitopes may be mapped by comparing signals of the ligand with and without saturation of the protein. Herein, it is shown that a less selective process allows more protons to assist in the saturation of the protein, thereby considerably enhancing the sensitivity of the STD experiment. Increasing the saturation power entails a greater risk of perturbing the ligand; however, an amplitude modulation of the waveform assists this procedure by distributing the applied energy in sidebands.     

Characterization of heparin–protein interaction by saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR

The binding affinity and specificity of heparin to proteins is widely recognized to be sulfation-pattern dependent. However, for the majority of heparin-binding proteins (HBPs), it still remains unclear what moieties are involved in the specific binding interaction. Here, we report our study using saturation transfer difference (STD) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to map out the interactions of synthetic heparin oligosaccharides with HBPs, such as basic fibroblast growth factor (FGF2) and fibroblast growth factor 10 (FGF10), to provide insight into the critical epitopes of heparin ligands involved. The irradiation frequency of STD NMR was carefully chosen to excite the methylene protons so that enhanced sensitivity was obtained for the heparin–protein complex. We believe this approach opens up additional application avenues to further investigate heparin–protein interactions.     

Temperature dependence of ligand-protein complex formation as reflected by saturation transfer difference NMR experiments

We show that temperature is an important parameter for the sensitivity of saturation transfer difference (STD) spectroscopy. A decreased intensity of STD signals is observed for lactose binding to growth-regulatory galectin7 (p53-induced gene 1), as well as for nucleotide binding to annexin A6, when the temperature is increased from 281 to 298-310 K. Opposite temperature effects on STD intensity are observed for S-peptide binding to S-protein to reconstitute RNase S. However, the STD signals for tryptophan binding to downstream regulatory element antagonist modulator of the human prodynorphin gene (DREAM)are relatively unaffected between 281 and 298 K. The known kinetics of the binding of ATP by the uncoupling protein from brown adipose tissue mitochondria (UCP1) predicted an observable STD at 310 K, but rapid sample degradation limits the experiments to much lower temperatures. Temperature strongly influences the kinetics and affinity constant of various types of complex formation and in so doing influences the observed STD effects. Therefore, temperature can be exploited to facilitate the optimization of STD-based applications, and at the same time minimize the number of test samples. STD-based screening protocols to detect new target-specific compounds may yield a larger number of potential ligands if screened at various temperatures.     

Targeting Bacterial Membranes: NMR Spectroscopy Characterization of Substrate Recognition and Binding Requirements of D‐Arabinose‐5‐Phosphate Isomerase

Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) is an essential component of the outer membrane of Gram‐negative bacteria and consists of three elements: lipid A, the core oligosaccharide, and the O‐antigen. The inner‐core region is highly conserved and contains at least one residue of 3‐deoxy‐D ‐manno‐octulosonate (Kdo). Arabinose‐5‐phosphate isomerase (API) is an aldo–keto isomerase catalyzing the reversible isomerization of D ‐ribulose‐5‐phosphate (Ru5P) to D ‐arabinose‐5‐phosphate (A5P), the first step of Kdo biosynthesis. By exploiting saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR spectroscopy, the structural requirements necessary for API substrate recognition and binding were identified, with the aim of designing new API inhibitors. In addition, simple experimental conditions for the STD experiments to perform a fast, robust, and efficient screening of small libraries of potential API inhibitors, allowing the identification of new potential leads, were set up. Due to the essential role of API enzymes in LPS biosynthesis and Gram‐negative bacteria survival, by exploiting these data, a new generation of potent antibacterial drugs could be developed.     

Group epitope mapping by saturation transfer difference NMR to identify segments of a ligand in direct contact with a protein receptor.

A protocol based on saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR spectra was developed to characterize the binding interactions at an atom level, termed group epitope mapping (GEM). As an example we chose the well-studied system of galactose binding to the 120-kDa lectin Ricinus communis agglutinin I (RCA(120)). As ligands we used methyl beta-D-galactoside and a biantennary decasaccharide. Analysis of the saturation transfer effects of methyl beta-D-galactoside showed that the H2, H3, and H4 protons are saturated to the highest degree, giving evidence of their close proximity to protons of the RCA(120) lectin. The direct interaction of the lectin with this region of the galactose is in excellent agreement with results obtained from the analysis of the binding specificities of many chemically modified galactose derivatives (Bhattacharyya, L.; Brewer, C. F. Eur. J. Biochem. 1988, 176, 207-212). This new NMR technique can identify the binding epitope of even complex ligands very quickly, which is a great improvement over time-consuming chemical modifications. Efficient GEM benefits from a relatively high off rate of the ligand and a large excess of the ligand over the receptor. Even for a ligand like the biantennary decasaccharide with micromolar binding affinity, the binding epitopes could easily be mapped to the terminal beta-D-Gal-(1-4)-beta-D-GlcNAc (beta-D-GlcNAc = N-acetyl-D-glucosamine) residues located at the nonreducing end of the two carbohydrate chains. The binding contribution of the terminal galactose residue is stronger than those of the penultimate GlcNAc residues. We could show that the GlcNAc residues bind "edge-on" with the region from H2 to H4, making contact with the protein. Analysis of STD NMR experiments performed under competitive conditions proved that the two saccharides studied bind at the same receptor site, thereby ruling out unspecific binding.     

Direct NMR detection of the binding of functional ligands to the human sweet receptor, a heterodimeric family 3 GPCR

We present a robust method for monitoring the binding of ligands to the heterodimeric (T1R2+T1R3) human sweet receptor (a family 3 GPCR receptor). The approach utilizes saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR spectroscopy with receptor proteins expressed on the surface of human epithelial kidney cells. The preparation investigated by NMR can contain either live cells or membranes isolated from these cells containing the receptor. We have used this approach to confirm the noncompetitive binding of alitame and cyclamate to the receptor and to determine that greatly reduced receptor binding affinity compared to wild-type brazzein explains the lack of sweetness of brazzein mutant A16C17. This approach opens new avenues for research on the mechanism of action of the sweet receptor and for the design of new noncalorigenic sweeteners.     

Heteronuclear saturation transfer difference (HSTD) experiment for detection of ligand binding to proteins

This report presents a modified saturation transfer difference experiment for protein–ligand binding studies. A heteronuclear saturation transfer difference (HSTD) is suggested, where in a hetero atom, such as carbon is utilized for monitoring the binding instead of proton. This method is free from some of the problems associated with proton STD experiment, such as lack of sufficient number of protons at the binding site or crowding of spectra due to smaller chemical shift dispersion. The present method has been demonstrated on three systems namely caffeine–HSA, salicylic acid–HSA and glucose–lysozyme, illustrating the utility of the method.     

Ligand-observed in-tube NMR in natural products research: A review on enzymatic biotransformations,protein–ligand interactions,and in-cell NMR spectroscopy

Natural product-observed NMR methods have considerably expanded the potentialities for in-tube NMR monitoring of complex enzymatic biotransformations and investigation of protein-natural product interactions even in living cells. We review, herein, the significant advantages of ligand-observed in-situ NMR monitoring of enzymatic biotransformations without restoring to laborious and time-consuming chromatographic methods. Emphasis will be given to the potentialities of the use of the NMR bioreactor: (i) to investigate through saturation transfer difference (STD), the capacity of natural products to serve as enzyme substrates, (ii) to monitor multiple biotransformation products of natural products with the use of immobilized enzymes and (iii) to investigate interactions of biotransformed products with protein targets. The use of STD and its variants, transfer effect Noes for PHArmacophore Mapping (INPHARMA) NMR, in conjunction with computational methods, can provide excellent tools in investigating competitive binding modes even in proteins with multiple binding sites. The method has been successfully applied in the study of unsaturated free fatty acids (UFFAs)-serum albumin complexes in which the location and conformational states of UFFAs could not be determined accurately, despite numerous X-ray structural studies, due to conformational averaging. This combined method, thus, may find promising applications in the field of protein-natural product recognition research. The emerging concept of in-cell NMR and recent applications will be discussed since they can provide atomic level insights into natural product-protein interactions in living cells without the need of isotope labelled techniques.