Thermal field-flow fractionation of colloidal materials: Methylmethacrylate-styrene linear di-block copolymers

Summary Model methylmethacrylate-styrene, linear di-block, copolymers were used to investigate the respective influnnces of temperature, of molar mass and of chemical composition on their Soret coefficient, s_T, by means of thermal field-flow fractionation (thermal FFF) in toluene and in THF. A recently developed thermal FFF retention model, which takes into account the variation of the basic FFF parameter λ with temperature, is applied to investigate the dependence of the Soret coefficient on temperature. It is found that the coefficient decreases approximately linearly with increasing temperature. At constant chemical composition and temperature, s_T exhibits a power law dependence on molar mass with an exponent é ? 0.55. At constant molar mass and temperature, s_T decreases monotonously with increasing weight percent styrene in the copolymer composition. At 300 K, s_T values are slightly larger in THF than in toluene. Presented at the 21^st ISC held in Stuttgart, Germany, 15^th–20^th September, 1996.     

Properties of decalin as a solvent in thermal field-flow fractionation

Summary Cis-trans-decahydronaphthalene (67.85% trans+ 32.15% cis, here briefly referred to ascis-trans-decalin) as a possible solvent for thermal field-flow fractionation is proposed. Different features such as solvent properties with respect to low polarity polymers, availability of basic physicochemical data (viscosity and thermal conductivity in a convenient temperature range), low toxicity and low cost are emphasized. Retention data over a wide range of cold wall temperatures and thermal gradients were collected. Thev correction factor and λ retention data were determined for polystyrene samples over a relative molecular mass range of 11,300–3,950,000 g mol⁻¹. From these data, selectivity values were determined and compared to the commonly found values for polystyrene in different solvent systems. The average value of −0.6 found here forcis-trans-decalin falls in the optimum selectivity solvent-domain.Cis-trans-decalin is thus fully proven as an optimum solvent for ThFFF.     

A novel approach to improve operation and performance in flow field-flow fractionation

A new system design and setup are proposed for the combined use of asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) and hollow-fiber flow field-flow fractionation (HF5) within the same instrumentation. To this purpose, three innovations are presented: (a) a new flow control scheme where focusing flow rates are measured in real time allowing to adjust the flow rate ratio as desired; (b) a new HF5 channel design consisting of two sets of ferrule, gasket and cap nut used to mount the fiber inside a tube. This design provides a mechanism for effective and straightforward sealing of the fiber; (c) a new AF4 channel design with only two fluid connections on the upper plate. Only one pump is needed to deliver the necessary flow rates. In the focusing/relaxation step the two parts of the focusing flow and a bypass flow flushing the detectors are created with two splits of the flow from the pump. In the elution mode the cross-flow is measured and controlled with a flow controller device. This leads to reduced pressure pulsations in the channel and improves signal to noise ratio in the detectors. Experimental results of the separation of bovine serum albumin (BSA) and of a mix of four proteins demonstrate a significant improvement in the HF5 separation performance, in terms of efficiency, resolution, and run-to-run reproducibility compared to what has been reported in the literature. Separation performance in HF5 mode is shown to be comparable to the performance in AF4 mode using a channel with two connections in the upper plate.     

Composition and molecular weight analysis of styrene-acrylic copolymers using thermal field-flow fractionation

Thermal field-flow fractionation coupled with online multiangle light scattering, differential refractive index and quasielastic light scattering (ThFFF-MALS/dRI/QELS) was used to simultaneously determine the molecular weight (MW) and composition of polystyrene-poly(n-butyl acrylate) (PS-PBA) and polystyrene-poly(methyl acrylate) (PS-PMA) copolymers. The online measurement of the normal diffusion coefficient (D) by QELS allowed calculation of the copolymer thermal diffusion coefficient (D(T)) of sample components as they eluted from the ThFFF channel. DT was found to be independent of MW for copolymers with similar compositions and dependent on composition for copolymers with similar MW in a non-selective solvent. By using a solvent that is non-selective to both blocks of the copolymer, it was possible to establish a universal calibration plot of DT versus mole fraction of one of the monomer chemistries comprising the copolymer. PS-PBA and PS-PMA linear diblock polymers were determined to vary in composition from 100/0 to 20/80 wt% PS/acrylate and ranged in MWs between 30 and 360 kDa. The analysis of a PS-PBA miktoarm star copolymer revealed a polydisperse material with a weight percent PBA of 50-75% and MW ranging from 100 to 900 kDa. The presented ThFFF-MALS/dRI/QELS method allowed rapid characterization of polymers with MW and chemical distributions in a single analysis.     

Thermal diffusion and molecular weight calibration of poly(ethylene-co-vinyl acetate)s by thermal field-flow fractionation

Copolymer characterization is accomplished with respect to measurement of thermal diffusion coefficient (D_T) and molecular weight determination by thermal field-flow fractionation. The examined copolymers are the eight poly(ethylene-co-vinyl acetate)s [P(E-V)] having different compositions of vinyl acetate ranging from 25 to 70% and the molecular weight from 110,000 to 285,000, and three polyvinyl acetate standards as component homopolymer. The carrier solvents are tetrahydrofuran, toluene, and chlorobenzene which have different viscosities and thermal conductivities. Measured D_T values vary from 1.36 × 10^?8 to 5.97 × 10_?8 cm²/(s . K) which are dependent on the composition of copolymers and types of carriers. These values increase linearly with the increase of weight percent of vinyl acetate. It is possible to estimate D_T values of polyethylene from the extrapolated intercept in the plots of D_T vs. vinyl acetate wt % of copolymer. Tetrahydrofuran is found to be the appropriate carrier solvent for the separation of P(E-V) copolymers since D_T varies greatly with the increase of wt % in THF. Attempts are made to correlate the measured retention data with molecular sizes of copolymers for the construction of the molecular weight calibration curve. Good correlations (r² ≥ 0.931) are found in which D/D_T values of polymers vary inversely with the product of hydrodynamic volume by weight ratio of vinyl acetate. Based on this relationship, the unknown molecular weight of copolymer sample can be determined from component homopolymers for which standards are readily available. © 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Practical experience with organic solvent flow field-flow fractionation

Summary Several types of membrane have been tested for use in organic solvent flow field-flow fractionation in an asymmetric channel. The practical problems most commonly encountered were leakage of air and solvent through the support layer on which the membranes are cast, and unequal swelling of the membrane and the support layer in the organic solvent, leading to ridging of the membrane in the channel. Three types of membrane were found suitable for the separation of polystyrene standards with tetrahydrofuran as solvent. The best results were obtained with a fluoropolymer membrane. Fair agreement was found between theory and practice for the dependence of retention times on the relative molecular mass of the standards and on the flow regime. Use of scanning electron microscopy revealed that for a number of the membrane materials some pores were much larger than expected on the basis of the indicated molecular weight cut-off. Whereas these materials could not be used for the fractionation of soluble polymers, they could be applied with some success to the separation of solid latex and silica particles. A PTFE membrane could be used for the separation of latexes and silica particles suspended in acetonitrile as carrier liquid. In general, however, the retention times of these particles were shorter than theoretically predicted.     

Tandem hollow-fiber flow field-flow fractionation

Reinjection of one ore more collected fractions of eluted samples is recognized as a useful procedure in analytical separation techniques, among which field-flow fractionation (FFF), to improve the actual separation of complex samples. Hollow-fiber flow FFF (HF5) is a micro-channel subset of flow FFF (F4), which has recently reached a performance comparable to that of standard, flat-channel F4. To further improve HF5 of complex protein samples, we present a new device and method for in-line, reinjection HF5 that we call tandem HF5 (HF5/HF5). HF5 is ideally suited for tandem operation because (1) small channel volume and low operation flow rates allow reducing dilution and volume of the collected fractions, and (2) the relaxation/focusing step that takes place between the 1st and 2nd run (refocusing) allows reestablishing the volume and concentration of the sample plug before the 2nd elution. HF5/HF5 proves particularly effective in the case of oligomeric proteins since it allows collecting and reinjecting the bands that correspond to each separated oligomeric form. This provides information on the dynamic equilibria between the different oligomers. For HF5/HF5 operations, a modified, prototype HF5 instrumentation is presented which includes a "trap" constituted of a four-port, two-way valve positioned downstream the UV detector and a collection loop. The effect of refocusing conditions on HF5/HF5 performance is investigated by varying refocusing time. With a complex protein samples such as blood serum, HF5/HF5 can improve detectability of the low abundance components since overloading effects due to high-abundance components are reduced. This is shown for serum lipoproteins: while after the 1st run high density lipoproteins (HDLs) are not separated from high-abundance serum proteins, after the 2nd run it is shown possible to separate the HDL subclasses.     

Thermal aggregation of bovine serum albumin studied by asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation

The use of asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AsFlFFF) in the study of heat-induced aggregation of proteins is demonstrated with bovine serum albumin (BSA) as a model analyte. The hydrodynamic diameter (d_h), the molar mass of heat-induced aggregates, and the radius of gyration (R_g) were calculated in order to get more detailed understanding of the conformational changes of BSA upon heating. The hydrodynamic diameter of native BSA at ambient temperature was ∼7 nm. The particle size was relatively stable up to 60 °C; above 63 °C, however, BSA underwent aggregation (growth of hydrodynamic diameter). The hydrodynamic diameters of the aggregated particles, heated to 80 °C, ranged from 15 to 149 nm depending on the BSA concentration, duration of incubation, and the ionic strength of the solvent. Heating of BSA in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (1.7 or 17 mM) did not lead to aggregation. The heat-induced aggregates were characterized in terms of their molar mass and particle size together with their respective distributions with a hyphenated technique consisting of an asymmetrical field-flow fractionation device and a multi-angle light scattering detector and a UV-detector. The carrier solution comprised 8.5 mM phosphate and 150 mM sodium chloride at pH 7.4. The weight-average molar mass (M_w) of native BSA at ambient temperature is 6.6 × 10⁴ g mol⁻¹. Incubation of solutions with BSA concentrations of 1.0 and 2.5 mg mL⁻¹ at 80 °C for 1 h resulted in aggregates with M_w 1.2 × 10⁶ and 1.9 × 10⁶ g mol⁻¹, respectively. The average radius of gyration and the average hydrodynamic radius of the heat-induced aggregate samples were calculated and compared to the values obtained from the size distributions measured by AsFlFFF. For comparison static light scattering measurements were carried out and the corresponding average molar mass distributions of solutions with BSA concentrations of 1.0 and 2.5 mg mL⁻¹ at 80 °C for 1 h gave aggregates with M_w 1.7 × 10⁶ and 3.5 × 10⁶ g mol⁻¹, respectively.     

Rapid detection of compositional drift of polydisperse copolymers using thermal field-flow fractionation and multi-angle light scattering

Summary The use of thermal field-flow fractionation (ThFFF) with multi-angle light scattering (MALS) for the rapid detection of compositional heterogeneity in random copolymers is demonstrated. Soret coefficients were directly calculated from the ThFFF retention times while the MALS detector provided the polymer's radius of gyration (R _g) distribution. FromR _g, the diffusion coefficient (D) could be calculated and this allowed, in combination with the Soret coefficient, the calculation of the thermal diffusion coefficient (D _T). It was shown that theD _T distribution can serve as a measure for the chemical composition distribution of random styrene acrylonitrile copolymers. Comparison of ThFFF-MALS results with literature data from ThFFF-hydrodynamic chromatography (HDC) cross-fractionation experiments showed a fair agreement.     

Experimental study of the concentration dependence of the soret coefficient by thermal field-flow fractionation: the case of polystyrene in decalin

Summary Thermal field-flow fractionation separates polymers with high selectivity according to their Soret coefficient,S _τ, hence, according to their molar mass, and therefore consitutes an efficeint physicochemical tool for the determination of the Soret coefficient of a given polymer in the carrier liquid from its retention time. However, the polymer concentration in the sample influences the retention time and, hence, the value ofS _τ derived from it. An experimental study of the influence of sample concentration on retention,S _τ, and peak shape was performed for the polystyrene-decalin system over a relatively large temperature domain and for various molar masses. It is found that the retention time and the value ofS _τ increase with increasing sample concentration, the more so as the cold wall temperature is lower. This appears to be in contradiction with the general non-equilibrium thermodynamic expression derived for polymer-solvent systems with positive second virial coefficients, such as the present system over the temperature range investigated. There seems to be a temperature for which the dependence ofS _τ on sample concentration vanishes. This temperature is about 375 K for the polystyrene-decalin system. As the sample concentration increases, the peak barycentre and the standard deviation increases. As the peaks are fronting, the skewness is negative and becomes more negative as the sample concentration increases. The peak skewness appears to be a good indicator of the onset of sample concentration effects. The threshold concentration, for which these effects begin to become significant, decreases with increasing molar mass.     

Gravitational field-flow fractionation of human hemopoietic stem cells

New cell sorting methodologies, which are simple, fast, non-invasive, and able to isolate homogeneous cell populations, are needed for applications ranging from gene expression analysis to cell-based therapy. In particular, in the forefront of stem cell isolation, progenitor cells have to be separated under mild experimental conditions from complex heterogeneous mixtures prepared from human tissues. Most of the methodologies now employed make use of immunological markers. However, it is widely acknowledged that specific markers for pluripotent stem cells are not as yet available, and cell labelling may interfere with the differentiation process. This work presents for the first time gravitational field-flow fractionation (GrFFF), as a tool for tag-less, direct selection of human hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells from cell samples obtained by peripheral blood aphaeresis. These cells are responsible to repopulate the hemopoietic system and they are used in transplantation therapies. Blood aphaeresis sample were injected into a GrFFF system and collected fractions were characterized by flow cytometry for CD34 and CD45 expression, and then tested for viability and multi-differentiation potential. The developed GrFFF method allowed obtaining high enrichment levels of viable, multi-potent hematopoietic stem cells in specific fraction and it showed to fulfil major requirements of analytical performance, such as selectivity and reproducibility of the fractionation process and high sample recovery.     

Influence of operational parameters on retention of ultra-high molecular weight polystyrenes in thermal field-flow fractionation

Summary The influence of various parameters (concentration of the injected polymer solution, flow rate, temperature gradient, relaxation conditions) on the retention and shape of the fractogram of ultra-high molecular weight polystyrenes in thermal field-flow fractionation was investigated. Under the operating conditions adopted, reproducible oscillations in the peak shape are observed for molecular weights larger than a few millions, especially at relatively high polymer concentration. They are attributed to some hydrodynamic instabilities. The retention of ultra-high molecular weight polystyrenes at high flow rate is strongly dependent on the initial relaxation period. All of the investigated operational variables have a complex effect on the resulting shape of the fractogram. Consequently, the confirmation of the shear-induced focusing of macromolecules across the channel thickness requires further study. Experiments on reinjection of fractions collected after an initial high speed pass through the separation system leads to the conclusion that shear degradation of the ultra-high molecular weight polymers did not occur under the investigated experimental conditions even at the highest flow rates.     

Coupling gravitational and flow field-flow fractionation, and size-distribution analysis of whole yeast cells

This work continues the project on field-flow fractionation characterisation of whole wine-making yeast cells reported in previous papers. When yeast cells are fractionated by gravitational field-flow fractionation and cell sizing of the collected fractions is achieved by the electrosensing zone technique (Coulter counter), it is shown that yeast cell retention depends on differences between physical indexes of yeast cells other than size. Scanning electron microscopy on collected fractions actually shows co-elution of yeast cells of different size and shape. Otherwise, the observed agreement between the particle size distribution analysis obtained by means of the Coulter counter and by flow field-flow fractionation, which employs a second mobile phase flow as applied field instead of Earths gravity, indicates that yeast cell density can play a major role in the gravitational field-flow fractionation retention mechanism of yeast cells, in which flow field-flow fractionation retention is independent of particle density. Flow field-flow fractionation is then coupled off-line to gravitational field-flow fractionation for more accurate characterisation of the doubly-fractionated cells. Coupling gravitational and flow field-flow fractionation eventually furnishes more information on the multipolydispersity indexes of yeast cells, in particular on their shape and density polydispersity.     

Magnetic field-flow fractionation using capillary tubing

Summary Separation of paramagnetic substances under the field of magnetic gradient by using capillary tubing was attempted. Teflon tubing of 0.5 mm i.d. and 270 cm in length was placed on the outside of one pole of an electric magnet which had 9 K gauss at 30 V. The Samples were bovine serum albumin, egg albumin, and EDTA, and their complexes with Ni ion. The mobile phase was water at a flow rate of 20 μl/min. Samples without Ni ion had the same retention volume irrespective of the existence of magnetic gradient. Samples which formed complexes with Ni ion showed retardation under the field of magnetic gradient, although the difference of retention volumes obtained with and without the magnetic field was not large.     

Standardless method for quantitative particle-size distribution studies by gravitational field-flow fractionation. Application to silica particles

Summary Gravitational field-flow fractionation is a separative analytical technique which has already proved suitable for quantitative particle-size distribution analysis. One of the most attractive aspects of the technique is that it can allow for direct conversion of fractograms into size distributions of the samples, although retention exhibits substantial dependence on flow rate, compared to other field-flow fractionation methods. It is shown here that conversion of fractograms into quantitative, size-distribution profiles of micron-sized silica particles is possible through gravitational field-flow fractionation in standardless mode. Standardless means that the conversion of fractograms is performed by single-run analysis because all the parameters necessary for the calculations can be obtained, from sample specifications and previous instrumental calibration, by means of semiempirical models. Work partially presented at FFF’98-7^th International Symposium on Field-Flow Fractionation, Salt Lake City, Utah (USA), February 8–11, 1998     

Potential barrier gravitational field-flow fractionation based on the variation of the pH solution for the analysis of colloidal materials

Summary Potential barrier gravitational field-flow fractionation (PBGFFF) is a new technique for the separation and characterization of colloidal materials. It consists in changing the potential energy of interaction between the colloidal particles and the channel wall by varying the solution ionic strength or the Hamaker constant and the surface potential of the particles. In this work the PBGFFF technique based on the particles' surface potential variation, by varying the pH, is presented. Polydisperse colloidal particles of the sulphide CuZnS (with molar ratio Cu/Zn-10/90) are used as a model sample. Comparison of the results obtained by PBGFFF with those given by conventional gravitational fieldflow fractionation and laser counter measurements, shows that one could use PBGFFF not only for the separation and characterization of colloidal materials, but also for the investigation of the interactions between colloids and solid surfaces.     

Characterization of humic materials by flow field-flow fractionation

Several humic materials are characterized by flow field-flow fractionation, including humic acids, a fulvic acid, and aqueous leachates from compost. Hydrophilic and hydrophobic fractions of a compost leachate were also examined. After characterizing molecular weight distributions, the effect of pH and salt concentration on hydrodynamic size is studied. In general, the hydrodynamic size decreases as the pH is lowered. However, humic acids form large aggregates below pH 5. Small amounts of sodium chloride have little effect on the size distributions. In contrast, a little calcium chloride reduces the hydrodynamic size of individual molecules while inducing the formation of oligomers, although severe aggregation is absent. With further additions of calcium chloride, the decrease in hydrodynamic size continues but oligomer formation subsides. Precise characterization of the unaggregated material is hindered by sample penetration through the channel membrane.     

Laser-induced breakdown detection combined with asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation: application to iron oxi/hydroxide colloid characterization

The combination of asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AsFlFFF) with the laser-induced breakdown detection (LIBD) is presented as a powerful tool for the determination of colloid size distribution at trace particle concentrations. Detection limits (D1) of 1, 4, and 20 microg/L have been determined for a mixture of polystyrene reference particles with 20, 50, and 100 nm in size, respectively. This corresponds to injected masses of 1, 4, and 20 pg, which is lower than found in a previous study with the symmetrical FlFFF (SyFlFFF). The improvement is mainly due to the lower colloid background discharged from the AsFlFFF channel. The combined method of AsFlFFF-LIBD is then applied to the analysis of iron oxi/hydroxide colloids being considered as potential carriers for the radionuclide migration from a nuclear waste repository. Our LIBD arrangement is less sensitive for iron colloid detection as compared to reference polystyrene particles which results in a detection limit of approximately 240 microg/L FeOOH for the AsFlFFF-LIBD analysis. This is superior to the detection via UV-Vis absorbance and comparable to ICP-MS detection. Size information (mean size 11-18 nm) for different iron oxi/hydroxide colloids supplied by the present method is comparable to that obtained by sequential ultrafiltration and dynamic light scattering. A combined on-line ICP-MS detection is used to gain insight into the colloid-borne main and trace elements.     

Relative velocity profile and flow-rate in sedimentation field-flow fractionation

Although the classical retention theory is used for interpreting data or optimizing separations in sedimentation field-flow fractionation (SedFFF), as in most other field-flow fractionation techniques, the assumption of a parabolic flow profile on which this theory is based is not rigorously correct in SedFFF because of the curvature of the channel walls. In order to examine quantitatively the influence of this effect, the relative velocity profile in SedFFF is obtained by solving the Navier-Stokes equation in cylindrical coordinates. Discrepancies found in the literature about the definition of the mean velocity in such channels are discussed. Relationships between mean velocity, flow-rate and pressure gradient are given. Approximating the velocity profile by a third-degree polynomial of the radial coordinate which provides the same slope as the exact profile at a reference wall, for small values of δ, the curvature ratio (ratio of the channel thickness to the mean curvature radius), shows that the adjustable parameter of the approximate profile, ν, is equal to ± δ/3, the sign depending on whether the reference wall is the inner or outer wall. The curvature ratio appears to be a good indicator of the error made on retention when using the straight channel approximation in retention theory. The error is quite small for typical SedFFF channels. It may have to be taken into account for precise determinations if thicker channels and/or miniaturized systems are used.     

非对称流场流分离技术的现状及发展趋势

场流分离是生物分析领域一项成熟的技术,将流体与外场联合作用于待分离物质,利用分析物某些理化参数上的差异进行分离。非对称流场流是其重要的分支之一,所施加的外力场为垂直方向的液流,分离过程于开放型的通道中在某种组成的载液迁移推动下进行,主要根据分析物与垂直施加的第二维液流之间的相互作用完成分离。非对称流场流在蛋白质、蛋白质复合物、衍生纳米级/微米级粒子、亚细胞单元和聚合物等分离中的应用日益广泛,主要归功于其直接应用于生物样品时可进行无损分离,因此生物分析物如蛋白质可以在生物友好型的环境中完成分离而不改变其构型,也无需使用降解载液。分离设备便于保持无菌状态,分析物可在生物友好的环境中维持其自然状态。该文简要描述了场流分离原理并罗列出其在生物分析领域一些卓越的发展和应用。