Modelling light stabilizers as thermal antioxidants

Light stabilizers often display some degree of antioxidant activity against thermal degradation of polymers both in the solid state and the melt. Although this capacity to date has been documented in some instances such features have not been kinetically modelled for many light stabilizers. An understanding of the mechanisms of this activity is crucial in polymer materials due to the close link between prior thermal behaviour and post stabilisation.This paper considers the potential antioxidant activity of three representative UV stabilizers using a model system initiated (2,2′-azo-bisisobutyronitrile, AIBN) cumene oxidation. Kinetic measurements of oxidation rates in the presence of the stabilizers showed that the antioxidant activity as well as the mechanism and mode of inhibition was different for each of the stabilizers. Thus, whilst a triazine UV absorber (Cyasorb UV 1164) did not display any antioxidant activity, a hindered phenol (Cyasorb UV 2908) operated as a peroxy radical acceptor, and a hindered amine (Cyasorb 3529) retarded the model reaction without an induction period like many HAS stabilizers.The Cyasorb 2908 revealed weak antioxidant activity with a rate constant for the addition of cumylperoxy RO₂ radicals to the functional group of the stabilizer k₇ = 10^6.2±0.1 e^{−(3900±600)/RT}, however, the inhibition index f (80 °C) is significantly higher than that of the commercial phenolic antioxidant Irganox 1076. Oxidation rate profiles in the presence of Cyasorb 3529 displayed a strong retarding activity by the stabilizer under conditions of the model experiments. The rates were found to depend linearly on the reciprocal square root of the concentration of the stabilizer over a sufficiently wide range thereby fitting the mechanism for the addition of cumylalkyl R radicals to the Cyasorb molecules. The rate constants for the addition of cumyl R radicals to the Cyasorb were determined to be k_(333-353 K) = (2.0 ± 0.8) × 10⁸ M⁻¹ s⁻¹. This value surpasses even the rate constants for other related HAS Chimassorb [Zeynalov EB, Allen NS. Effect of micron and nano-grade titanium dioxides on the efficiency of hindered piperidine stabilizers in a model oxidative reaction. Polym Degrad Stab 2006;91(4):931-9.] stabilizers and it follows that Cyasorb 3529 is a powerful retarder of thermal oxidation.     

Identification and quantification of (polymeric) hindered-amine light stabilizers in polymers using pyrolysis-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry and liquid chromatography-ultraviolet absorbance detection-evaporative light scattering detection

Direct analysis of polymers containing polymeric hindered amine light stabilizers (HALS) by using pyrolysis coupled to GC-MS is applied successfully for fast and straightforward identification of these HALS additives. Each of the HALS additives shows different pyrolysis gas chromatograms containing characteristic pyrolysis products. As a result, HALS additives with very similar chemical structures, e.g. Chimassorb 944 and Chimassorb 2020, can be distinguished. A HPLC method with both ultraviolet (UV) and evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD) is developed to quantify the various HALS additives in extracts of polymers. The critical factor of the HPLC method is the use of a basic amine, like n-hexylamine, as a solvent additive to facilitate the elution of HALS additives. The various HALS additives can be distinguished according to retention time and peak shape and by using different detection methods. The suitability of the developed methods is demonstrated by the analytical performance of the HPLC method and the identification and determination of the actual content of HALS additives in polyolefines using pyrolysis GC-MS and HPLC. The HPLC method can also be used for the determination of the specific migration of HALS additives from food contact materials.     

Effect of several variables in the polymer toys additive migration to saliva

Capacity to migrate of a representative group of polymeric additives, dyes, antioxidants, hindered amine light stabilizers (HALS) or antistatics, from plastic toys to saliva was analyzed to protect children in their habits of sucking and biting. Most of target additives appear no-regulated in toys normative but adverse effects on human health of some of them have been demonstrated and their presence in others commercial articles normative has been included.In order to offer an effective and easy tool to perform these controls, migration tests by dynamic and static contact, followed by a preconcentration step by liquid-liquid extraction (LLE) and ultra performance liquid chromatographic analysis with ultraviolet-visible and evaporative light scattering detections (UPLC-UV/Vis-ELSD) have been optimized to evaluate the migrated amounts of the additives in saliva simulant. The detection limits of the migration methodologies were ranged from 8.68 × 10⁻² to 1.30 × 10⁻³ mg migrated (L simulant)⁻¹.Influence of several variables on this mass transport, as time, temperature and friction, was also analyzed to achieve the most aggressive methodology to protect consumers.Migration of several studied additives, whose presence has been demonstrated in several purchased commercial toys, has been observed.     

Various silyl-substituted cyclopentadienyl titanium complexes [CpSi(CH3)2X]TiCl3 as catalysts for syndiotactic polystyrene

Three silyl-substituted titanium trichloride complexes [CpSi(CH₃)₂X]TiCl₃ [X=Cl(1), Me(2), PhOMe(3)] were tested as catalyst precursors for the syndiospecific polymerization of styrene. The catalytic activity increased in the order 1 > 2 > 3. The highest activity was 2.42 × 10⁷ g s-PS/mol Ti mol S h using complex 1/MAO catalytic system at molar ratio of Al/Ti=2000. The effects of variation on polymerization temperature and Al/Ti ratio on the polymerization of styrene were also studied.     

Controlling selectivity: from Markovnikov to anti-Markovnikov hydroamination of alkynes

Depending on the catalyst a remarkable control of regioselectivity is achieved for the titanium-catalyzed intermolecular hydroamination of various alkynes. Proper choice of sterically hindered phenol ligands such as 1 and 4 enables a selectivity switch from the Markovnikov to the anti-Markovnikov products from M:anti-M = > 90:10 to > 10:90.     

Effect of stabilizer and pigment on photodegradation of polypropylene as revealed by macromolecule scission and crosslinking measurements

Photodegradation depth-profiles have been generated using computer-aided molecular weight distribution analysis for 3 mm thick polypropylene injection moldings containing (i) a stabilizing package that included hindered amine light stabilizers and a phenolic stabilizer, (ii) titanium dioxide pigment and (iii) both the pigment and the stabilizing package. The inhibiting effect of the additives has been determined quantitatively by comparing macromolecule scission and crosslinking rates with those in samples containing no stabilizer or pigment. TiO₂ pigment gave more effective protection against molecular degradation than the stabilizer package; there was very little advantage to be gained by adding stabilizer when the pigment was present. The inhibition caused by having pigment or stabilizer present was measured to be very large: degradation was reduced by at least a factor of 10 and often by a factor of several hundred times. The relative amount of scission and crosslinking differed according to the additives present and the depth from the exposed surface: high reaction rates favoured scission and lower reaction rates resulted in a higher relative crosslinking concentration.     

A catenated anion receptor based on indolocarbazole

A catenated anion receptor 7 comprising two indolocarbazole units was prepared by olefin ring-closing metathesis using Grubbs’ catalyst. Receptor 7 possesses a cage-like cavity where anions are encapsulated by forming four hydrogen bonds in the order of Cl⁻ > AcO⁻ >  >  > Br⁻ >  > I⁻ ≈  in 1% H₂O/acetone.     

Synthesis of new substituted cyclopentadienyl titanium monomethoxydifluorides with BF3 · OEt2 as fluorinating reagent and their use in syndiotactic polymerization of styrene

Five substituted cyclopentadienyl titanium trimethoxide complexes, RCpTi(OMe)₃ (R=Me (2b), ⁱPr (2c), Me₃Si (2d), allyl (2e), PhCH₂ (2f)), were prepared. By reacting RCpTi(OMe)₃ with BF₃OMe₂, six RCpTiF₂(OMe) (R=H (3a), Me (3b), ⁱPr (3c), Me₃Si (3d), allyl (3e), PhCH₂ (3f)) were obtained. When activated with methylaluminoxane (MAO), the activities of RCpTiF₂(OMe) system were less than those of RCpTi(OMe)₃ system in solution polymerization of styrene, but the polymers made by RCpTiF₂(OMe) exhibited higher Mw and melting point than those by RCpTi(OMe)₃. Both systems produced polymers with similar syndiotacticities in the range 92.4-97.6%. Introduction of a substituent group into the Cp-ligand enhanced the melting points of the polymers, and meanwhile decreased the catalytic activities of RCpTi(OMe)₃/MAO and RCpTiF₂(OMe)/MAO systems, where the order of activity was RCp=Cp > MeCp > ⁱPrCp > Me₃SiCp > CH₂CHCH₂Cp > PhCH₂Cp. Complexes 2a (CpTi(OMe)₃) and 3a showed the highest activities respectively for both systems, and are three to four times more active than CpTiCl₃. In bulk polymerization, the difference of activities between RCpTi(OMe)₃/MAO and RCpTiF₂(OMe)/MAO systems became small, where complexes 2e and 3e exhibited remarkably higher activities compared with their solution polymerization activities. The maximum polymerization activities were found at the polymerization temperature of 50 °C for most of the complexes. The influence of the polymerization time (t_P), polymerization temperature (T_P) and Al/Ti ratio on the activities of complexes 2b and 3b were investigated. It was observed that the initial rate of propagation of complex 2b was higher than that of complex 3b and the highest activities of both catalysts were reached at the relatively low Al/Ti ratio of 150 and decrease for larger ratios.     

Synthesis, characterization, and catalytic activities in syndiospecific polymerization of styrene for half-sandwich titanium complexes with non-Cp tridentate dianionic ligands MeN(CH2CR2O)2

New half-titanocenes, Cp^∗TiCl[(OCR₂CH₂)NMe(CH₂CR^′₂O)] [R,R′ = H (1), R,R′ = Me, H, (2), R,R′ = Me (3)], were prepared from Cp^∗TiCl₃ (4) with the corresponding alcohols in the presence of triethylamine. X-ray analysis shows that 1 has slightly distorted trigonal bipyramidal geometry around Ti. These complexes exhibited moderate catalytic activities for syndiospecific styrene polymerization in the presence of MAO and the activity increased in the order: 2 > 1 > 4 > 3 (at 50 °C), 1 > 2 > 4 > 3 (at 70 °C and 90 °C).     

Synthesis, characterisation and catalytic activities of manganese(III) complexes of pyridoxal-based ONNO donor tetradenatate ligands

Reaction of Mn^II(CH₃COO)₂ with dibasic tetradentate ligands, N,N′-ethylenebis(pyridoxylideneiminato) (H₂pydx-en, I), N,N′-propylenebis(pyridoxylideneiminato) (H₂pydx-1,3-pn, II) and 1-methyl-N,N′-ethylenebis(pyridoxylideneiminato) (H₂pydx-1,2-pn, III) followed by aerial oxidation in the presence of LiCl gives complexes [Mn^III(pydx-en)Cl(H₂O)] (1) [Mn^III(pydx-1,3-pn)Cl(CH₃OH)] (2) and [Mn^III(pydx-1,2-pn)Cl(H₂O)] (3), respectively. Crystal and molecular structures of [Mn(pydx-en)Cl(H₂O)] (1) and [Mn(pydx-1,3-pn)Cl(CH₃OH)] (2) confirm their octahedral geometry and the coordination of ligands through ONNO(2-) form. Reaction of manganese(II)-exchanged zeolite-Y with these ligands in refluxing methanol followed by aerial oxidation in the presence of NaCl leads to the formation of the corresponding zeolite-Y encapsulated complexes, abbreviated herein as [Mn^III(pydx-en)]-Y (4), [Mn^III(pydx-1,3-pn)]-Y (5) and [Mn^III(pydx-1,2-pn)]-Y (6). These encapsulated complexes are used as catalysts for the oxidation, by H₂O₂, of methyl phenyl sulfide, styrene and benzoin efficiently. Oxidation of methyl phenyl sulfide under the optimized reaction conditions gave ca. 86% conversion with two major products methyl phenyl sulfoxide and methyl phenyl sulfone in the ca. 70% and 30% selectivity, respectively. Oxidation of styrene catalyzed by these complexes gave at least five products namely styrene oxide, benzaldehyde, benzoic acid, 1-phenylethane-1,2-diol and phenylacetaldehyde with a maximum of 76.9% conversion of styrene by 4, 76.3% by 5 and 76.0% by 6 under optimized conditions. The selectivity of the obtained products followed the order: benzaldehyde > benzoic acid > styrene oxide > phenylacetaldehyde > 1-phenylethane-1,2-diol. Similarly, ca. 93% conversion of benzoin was obtained by these catalysts, where the selectivity of the products followed the order benzil > benzoic acid > benzaldehyde-dimethylacetal. Tests for the recyclability and heterogeneity of the reactions have also been carried. Neat complexes are equally active. However, the recycle ability of encapsulated complexes makes them better over neat ones.     

Thermo-oxidative dehydrochlorination of rigid and plasticised poly(vinyl chloride)/poly(methyl methacrylate) blends

The aim of this work was to study the thermo-oxidative dehydrochlorination of rigid and plasticised poly(vinyl chloride)/poly(methyl methacrylate) blends. For that purpose, blends of variable compositions from 0 to 100 wt% were prepared in the presence (15, 30 and 50 wt%) and in the absence of diethyl-2-hexyl phthalate as plasticiser. Their miscibility was investigated by using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). Their thermo-oxidative degradation at 180 ± 1 °C was studied and the amount of HCl released from PVC was measured by a continuous potentiometric method. Degraded samples were characterised, after purification, by FTIR spectroscopy and UV-visible spectroscopy. The results showed that the two polymers are miscible up to 60 wt% of poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA). This miscibility is due to a specific interaction of hydrogen bonding type between carbonyl groups (CO) of PMMA and hydrogen (CHCl) groups of PVC as shown by FTIR analysis. On the other hand, PMMA exerted a stabilizing effect on the thermal degradation of PVC by reducing the zip dehydrochlorination, leading to the formation of shorter polyenes.     

Thermal behaviour of hexanuclear titanium(IV) oxo isopropoxide carboxylates,and their usability as a single-source TiO2 CVD precursors

Hexanuclear oxo titanium(IV) isopropoxide carboxylates, of the general formula [Ti₆O₆(OPrⁱ)₆(O₂CR)₆] (R = Bu^t (1), CH₂Bu^t (2)) and [Ti₆O₆(OPrⁱ)₆(O₂CC(CH₃)₂Et)₆] · 0.5(C₇H₈) (3), have been synthesized as polycrystalline powders in order to study their thermal properties and usability as TiO₂ CVD precursors. Analysis of thermogravimetric and variable temperature (VT-IR) data shows that the thermal stability of the synthesized complexes decreases as follows 3 > 2 > 1. The composition of the vapors formed during the thermolysis of 1–3 were qualitatively analysed with VT-IR methods and mass spectrometry (MS-EI). According to obtained results, the decomposition of 1 and 2 proceeds with a partial decomposition and the formation of a volatile and stable titanium species, sufficient for their transport in vapors. The formation of volatile titanium-containing derivatives is an important factor that decides the application of 1 and 2 as precursors in CVD experiments. The high stability of 3 causes the thermal decomposition of this complex to be observed just above 573 K, and volatile titanium-containing derivatives were not detected in vapors. These results indicate that 3 could not be used as a precursor in CVD processes.     

Comparison of galactomannan crosslinking with organotitanates and borates

Water-soluble polymers crosslinked with metal ions form stable gels that are used in oil and gas production processes. We present an investigation of the chemistry of the binding between guar galactomannans and both borates and titanates using NMR and dynamic light scattering. The two monosaccharides comprising guar — methyl--D-galactopyranoside and methyl--D-mannopyranoside — have been studied as model compounds. High resolution¹³C NMR detected complexation of the sugars with borate but displayed no sign of complexation with either of the two titanates even at high titanate concentrations. Dynamic light scattering studies demonstrated the existence of colloidal titanium dioxide particles for both titanate crosslinkers. The loss of free titanium to the colloidal particles reduces the concentration of titanium crosslinking sites to below the detectable limits of NMR. The role of colloidal titanium dioxide colloids in these crosslinking reactions has not been reported previously. Data are presented following the growth of these particles with time as a function of pH and salt concentration. The observed particle growth kinetics explains the observed sensitivity of the guar gelation process to these variables.     

A new intramolecular charge transfer receptor as a selective ratiometric ‘off-on’ sensor for Zn

A new intramolecular charge transfer (ICT) probe 3 is found to display a highly selective photophysical response in the presence of Zn²⁺, among various biologically significant metal ions examined. The absorption band of 3 is red shifted by 84 nm and the fluorescence intensity increases 13-fold in the presence of Zn²⁺. The binding interaction follows the order Zn²⁺ > Cd²⁺ > Mg²⁺ > Ba²⁺ > Ca²⁺ > K⁺ ≅ Na⁺ ≅ Li⁺ and the stability constant for 3 + Zn²⁺ is over an order of magnitude higher compared to biologically competing Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺.     

Synthesis and properties of thermally cross-linkable main-chain azobenzene polymers containing diacetylene moieties

A series of main chain azobenzene polymers containing diacetylene moieties with different lengths of the spacer {-[CC-CH₂-O-C₆H₄-OCO-(CH₂)_m-O-C₆H₄-NN-C₆H₄-O-(CH₂)_m-OCO-C₆H₄-O-CH₂-CC]_n-, where m = 3, 6, 11} were synthesized by oxidative coupling polymerization. These polymers had molecular weights of 17,600-68,600 and polydispersity indices of 1.2-1.8 as determined by gel permeation chromatography using polystyrene as a standard. Their structures and properties were characterized and evaluated with NMR, FT-IR, X-ray diffraction (XRD), thermogravimetry (TG), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and nonlinear optical (NLO) analyses. All the polymers could be cross-linked at the elevated temperatures due to the polymerization reactions of the diacetylene groups in the polymer backbone, and the cross-linked polymers showed dramatically modified properties, such as thermal stability and solvent resistance. The third-order nonlinear susceptibilities of the cross-linked polymers were evaluated by means of the Z-scan technique and calculated to be 3.60 × 10⁻⁹, 2.73 × 10⁻⁹, 2.28 × 10⁻⁹ esu, respectively, whereas the un-cross-linked polymers showed no obvious NLO property.     

Organotin compounds: an ionophore system for fluoride ion recognition

Ion-selective properties were established for membrane electrodes prepared by using organotin compounds of type (L^CNRSnF₂)_n, (R = n-Bu (I), = Ph (II)) and (L^CNSnF₃)_n (III) (L^CN = C₆H₄(CH₂NMe₂)-2). Electrodes formulated with the optimized membranes containing the organotin compounds I-III as ionophores and sodium tetraphenylborate (10-30%) exhibited high selectivity for fluoride over other anions. An electrode prepared with ionophore II using dibutyl phthalate as the plasticizer and 15% sodium tetraphenylborate (NaTPB) as anion additive, possesses the best potentiometric response characteristics. It shows a detection limit of 7.9 × 10⁻⁷ M with a slope of 62.7 mV decade⁻¹ of activity in buffer solutions of pH 5.5. The interference from other anions is suppressed under this optimized measurement conditions. An entirely non-Hofmeister selectivity sequence (F⁻ > CH₃COO⁻ > Cl⁻ > I⁻ ∼ Br⁻ >ClO₄⁻ > NO₂⁻ > NO₃⁻ > SCN⁻) with remarkable preference towards fluoride is obtained. The influence on the electrode performances by anion additive was studied, and the possible response mechanism was investigated by UV-vis spectra. The electrode has been used for direct determination of fluoride in drinking mineral water with satisfactory results.     

Organometallic dithiolene complexes of benzenedithiolate analogues with π-coordinating and π-interacting Cp* ligand

Organometallic dithiolene complexes, which were formulated as [Cp*M(dcbdt)] and [Cp*M(dcdmp)] (M = Co, Rh, Ir; Cp* = η⁵-pentamethylcyclopentadienyl, dcbdt = 4,5-dicyanobenzene-1,2-dithiolate, dcdmp = 2,3-dicyano-5,6-dimercaptopyrazine) were prepared from a low valent Cp*Co^I or high valent Cp*M^III species (M^III = Co^III, Rh^III, Ir^III). The UV-Vis absorption spectral and electrochemical data of them were obtained. The lowest absorption (HOMO-LUMO) energies of them became redshift in order of the Co > Rh > Ir complexes. The reduction potentials suggested that the central metal modifies their LUMO levels. The molecular and crystal structures of [Cp*Co(dcbdt)] (3a), [Cp*Co(dcdmp)] (4a) and [Cp*Rh(dcdmp)] (4b) were determined by X-ray diffraction studies. The cobalt complexes 3a and 4a were monomeric, formally 16-electron complexes and have two-legged piano-stool geometries. The crystal structure of 3a indicated some plane-to-plane intermolecular interactions such as benzene?benzene interaction on the dcbdt ligand and two Cp*?benzene π-π stackings. 4a showed plane-to-plane interaction with a pseudo-4-fold-symmetry arrangement between the pyrazine moieties on the dcdmp ligand. The rhodium complex 4b was dimeric in the crystal to form a criss-cross arrangement and had a three-legged piano-stool geometry, but it was monomerized in solution. The dimer of 3b was observed in the oxidation process of the cyclic voltammogram.     

Effect of ketimide ligand for ethylene polymerization and ethylene/norbornene copolymerization catalyzed by (cyclopentadienyl)(ketimide)titanium complexes-MAO catalyst systems: Structural analysis for CpTiCl2(NCPh2)

Ligand effects on the catalytic activity [and norbornene (NBE) incorporation] for both ethylene polymerization and ethylene/NBE copolymerization using half-titanocenes (titanium half-sandwich complexes) containing ketimide ligand of type Cp′TiCl₂[NC(R¹)R²] [Cp′ = Cp (1), C⁵Me⁵ (Cp^∗, 2); R¹,R² = ^tBu,^tBu (a), ^tBu,Ph (b), Ph,Ph (c)]-methylaluminoxane (MAO) catalyst systems have been investigated. CpTiCl₂[NC(^tBu)Ph] (1b) CpTiCl₂(NCPh₂) (1c), and Cp^∗TiCl₂(NCPh₂) (2c) were prepared and identified; the structure of Cp^∗TiCl₂(NCPh₂) (2c) was determined by X-ray crystallography. The catalytic activity for ethylene polymerization increased in the order: 1a > 1b > 1c, suggesting that an electronic nature of the ketimide ligand affects the activity. However, molecular weight distributions for resultant (co)polymers prepared by 1b,c and by 2c-MAO catalyst systems were bi- or multi-modal, suggesting that the ketimide substituent plays a key role in order for these (co)polymerizations to proceed with single catalytically-active species. CpTiCl₂(NC^tBu₂) (1a) exhibited both remarkable catalytic activity and efficient NBE incorporation for ethylene/NBE copolymerization.     

Liquid crystalline and photoactive poly[4,4′-stilbeneoxy]alkylbiphenylphosphates

A series of liquid crystalline and photoactive polymers were synthesized from biphenylphosphorodichloridate with various 4,4′-bis(m-hydroxyalkyloxy)stilbenes (m = 2, 4, 6, 8, 10) in chloroform by solution polycondensation method using an acid scavenger. The resultant polymers were characterized by inherent viscosity, FT-IR, ¹H, ¹³C and ³¹P NMR spectroscopies. The liquid crystalline (LC) properties were studied using HOPM and DSC and it was inferred that out of the five polymers synthesized, higher methylene chain containing polymers (m = 6, 8, 10) exhibited LC properties. Thermogravimetric analysis revealed that all the polymers were stable in between 290 and 367 °C and underwent degradation thereafter. The thermal stability and char yield of the polymers decreased with increase in flexible methylene chain. The photochemical properties of these polymers were investigated by UV and fluorescence spectroscopy. Crosslinking proceeds via 2π-2π cycloaddition reaction of the -CHCH- of the stilbene moieties. The rate of crosslinking increases with increase in methylene chain length in the polymer backbone. The fluorescence spectra showed that the longer methylene spacer containing polymers exhibited larger red-shifts than the shorter spacer containing polymers.     

Simultaneous multi-element analysis of total As, Se and Sb on titanium dioxide by slurry sampling-graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry

A simple and rapid method for simultaneous determination of As, Se and Sb was studied by graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry (GFAAS). Titanium dioxide adsorbing As, Se and Sb was separated from sample solution (100 ml) with a membrane filtration (0.45 μm), and then prepared to be slurry (5.0 ml) by adding ultrapure water. The behavior and influence of titanium dioxide on determination of As, Se and Sb were investigated in this experiment. The optimal conditions of a furnace for these elements were chosen as follows: pyrolysis temperature was 150 °C, and atomization temperature was 2300 °C. The optimal conditions of adsorption for As, Se and Sb on titanium dioxide were listed: pH 2.0 in sample solution; 10 min of stirring time; and 20.0 mg titanium dioxide. The difference of the chemical valence of each element had no effect on the recovery of each element at the same optimal conditions. Limits of detection (3σ) for As, Se and Sb were found to be 0.21 μg l⁻¹, 0.15 μg l⁻¹ and 0.15 μg l⁻¹, respectively, with enrichment rate of 20, when 20 μl of slurry was injected into a Zr-coating tube. The proposed method was applied to tap water and river water.