Influence of intermolecular interaction with the eluent on the retention and selectivity in liquid chromatography

Summary The influence of substance — eluent (water-isopropanol mixture) intermolecular interaction on the retention and selectivity of separation in liquid chromatography on silica gel with silanized surface has been investigated for benzene and toluene derivatives. The interaction greatly depends on the nature of the polar functional groups, their position in the benzene ring and the existence of intramolecular interaction.     

Intermolecular interactions in liquid adsorption chromatography

Summary For the investigation of intermolecular interactions in adsorption from solution, which are the basis of selectivity in molecular liquid chromatography (LC), it is convenient to use the LC method itself. Using this method the Henry's constants, K₁, and other thermodynamic adsorption characteristics of hydrocarbons and of a series of polar substances on hydroxylated silica surface were determined from aqueous solutions. On the basis of the adsorption of hydrocarbons from water solutions the structure of the chemically modifying layers formed by different hydrocarbon groups on the silica surface is considered. The role of conformation ability of straight-chain bonded phases is demonstrated. Hydrocarbons are adsorbed on the hydroxylated silica surface more strongly from aqueous solutions than from solutions in saturated hydrocarbons and their retention increases with the increase in the number of carbon atoms in the molecule. The retention in LC is determined by the intermolecular interaction of the solute and solvent molecules with the adsorbent, as well by the contribution of the intermolecular interaction, between the solute and the solvent.The thermodynamic characteristics of adsorption of cymarin from water-ethanol solutions on hydroxylated silica gel and on silica gel surface modified by diphenylsilyl groups is compared. The solubility of silica gel modified by diphenylsilyl groups at different composition of water-ethanol eluent at different temperatures is investigated.Enlarged text of a paper presented at the Sixteenth International Symposium on Advances in Chromatography, Barcelona, Spain, September 28–October 1, 1981.     

On the mechanism of solute retention in RP-HPLC systems with B+AB1+AB2 type eluents

Summary Intermolecular interactions between the solute and the moieties constituting the mobile phase significantly contribute to the overall retention pattern of a given solute in a given chromatographic system. In this paper retention of solute is discussed in the case of the B+AB₁+AB₂ type mobile phase, which, in a quasithermodynamic way, can be divided into seven individual moieties. One evaluates the influence of each moiety on solute retention, and refers these regularities to the polarity of the solutes.     

Retention and selectivity effects caused by bonding of a polar urea-type ligand to silica: a study on mixed-mode retention mechanisms and the pivotal role of solute-silanol interactions in the hydrophilic interaction chromatography elution mode

The separation properties of five silica packings bonded with 1-[3-(trimethoxysilyl)propyl]urea in the range of 0–3.67 μmol m⁻² were investigated in the hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) elution mode. An increase of the ligand surface density promoted retention of non-charged polar compounds and even more so for acids. An opposite trend was observed for bases, while the amphoteric compound tyrosine exhibited a U-shaped response profile. An overall partitioning retention mechanism was incompatible with these observations; rather, the substantial involvement of adsorptive interactions was implicated. Support for the latter was provided by column-specific changes in analyte retention and concomitant selectivity effects due to variations of salt concentration, type of salt, pH value, organic modifier content, and column temperature. Silica was more selective for separating compounds differing in charge state (e.g. tyramine vs. 4-hydroxybenzoic acid), while in cases where structural differences of solutes resided in non-charged polar groups (e.g. tyramine vs. 5-hydroxydopamine, nucleoside vs. nucleobase) more selective separations were obtained on bonded phases. Hierarchical cluster analysis of the home-made urea-type and three commercial amide-type bonded packings evinced considerable differences in separation properties. The present data emphasise that the role of the packing material under HILIC elution conditions is hardly just the polar support for a dynamic coating with a water-enriched layer. Three major retention mechanisms are claimed to be relevant on bare silica and the urea-type bonded packings: (i) HILIC-type partitioning, (ii) HILIC-type weak adsorption such as hydrogen bonding between solutes and ligands or solutes and silanols (potentially influenced by individual degrees of solvation, salt bridging, etc.), (iii) strong electrostatic (ionic) solute–silanol interactions (attractive/repulsive). Even when non-charged polar bonded phases are used, solute–silanol interactions should not be discounted, which makes them a prime parameter to be characterised by HILIC column tests. Multi/mixed-mode type separations seem to be common under HILIC elution conditions, associated with a great deal of selectivity increments. They are accessible and controllable by a careful choice of the type of packing, the mobile phase composition, and the temperature.     

Comparison of retention on traditional alkyl, polar endcapped, and polar embedded group stationary phases

The development of new RP stationary phases containing polar groups has provided the chromatographer with a variety of stationary phase choices with differing selectivities. Polar endcapped and polar embedded group stationary phases have found use in solving a wide variety of separation problems, especially for the efficient separation of organic bases as well as separations necessitating the use of highly aqueous mobile phases. In this report, the retention thermodynamics of small, nonpolar solutes on traditional alkyl, polar endcapped, and polar embedded group stationary phases are compared. It is found that the nonpolar (methylene) transfer enthalpy is less favorable when polar embedded group phases are used, when compared to traditional or polar endcapped phases. In contrast, the transfer enthalpy of a phenyl group is found to be more favorable when a polar endcapped phase is used. In addition, the retention characteristics of these phases are compared using a set of solutes with differing solvatochromic parameters. Hydrogen-bond acids appear to have enhanced retention on polar embedded group phases, while hydrogen-bond bases have enhanced retention on polar endcapped phases.     

Interconversion of gradient and isocratic retention data in reversed-phase liquid chromatography: Effect of the uptake of eluent modifier on the retention of analytes

The experimental technique of mass spectrometric tracer pulse chromatography was used to study the effect of the sorption of eluent components by a C₁₈-bonded silica RPLC packing on the retention of a series of test analytes during isocratic and gradient elution experiments. The analytes of interest were a substituted phenol, a substituted nitroaniline, an anti-malaria drug, tetrahydrofuran, and methanol. The eluent used was a mixture of acetonitrile and water. The solutes and isotopically labeled eluent components were injected at fixed time intervals during each gradient run. The mass specific detector allowed the assignment of individual analyte peaks even when there was overlap in the chromatograms from successive injections. Thus, the retention time of each analyte could be determined as a function of gradient slope and initial eluent composition at the time of each injection. Experimental gradient retention time data were then compared with the calculated results from two theoretical models. The first model assumed the velocity of the mobile phase and eluent were equal. The second and most realistic model assumed the velocity of the eluent was less than the velocity of the mobile phase due to the uptake of eluent by the stationary phase. Gradient retention times predicted by the two models were reasonably accurate with the sorption model giving slightly more accurate values. Inverse calculations, i.e., calculation of isocratic retention factors from gradient elution data were also carried out with very similar results. That is, the model allowing for the uptake of eluent was slightly more accurate than the model assuming no eluent-stationary phase interaction.     

Theoretical studies on the adsorption from non-ideal binary liquid mixtures on heterogeneous surfaces involving difference in molecular sizes of components

An equation for the phenomenon of competetive adsorption from binary liquid mixtures onto solids has been derived using the kinetic approach. In this equation the difference of the molecular sizes, the non-ideality of both bulk surface phases, and the energetic heterogeneity of the solid surface have been taken into account.

---

Theoretische Untersuchungen zur Adsorption aus nichtidealen binären Lösungsmittelgemischen an heterogene Oberflächen fester Körper unter Berücksichtigung der Unterschiede in den molekularen Größen der Komponenten

Zusammenfassung Auf Grund kinetischer Erwägungen wurde eine Gleichung, die die Konkurrenzadsorption aus binären Lösungsmittelgemischen an den Oberflächen fester Körper beschreibt, aufgestellt. In der Gleichung wurde der Größenunterschied der Teilchen, die Nichtidealität der Lösung in der Volumen- und Oberflächenphase, sowie die energetische Heterogenität der Oberfläche des festen Körpers berücksichtigt.

     

Thin-layer adsorption chromatography with mixed mobile phases. 2. Effects of solute-solvent interactions and energetic heterogeneity of surfaces with regard to admolecules in TLC

In the Part 1 of this series a new equation for determining the R_m values in TLC with mixed mobile phases was proposed and examined by using the parameter m, which is a measure of energetic heterogeneity of the adsorbent surface with regard to the adsorbing molecules (admolecules). The numerical values of m, evaluated for 13 chromatographic systems, have been compared with that of the O?cik's parameter A, which characterizes solute-solvent interactions.     

Attachment of nanoparticles to the AFM tips for direct measurements of interaction between a single nanoparticle and surfaces

Here we report a universal method of attachment/functionalization of tips for atomic force microscope (AFM) with nanoparticles. The particles of interest are glued to the AFM tip with epoxy. While the gluing of micron size particles with epoxy has been known, attachment of nanoparticles was a problem. The suggested method can be used for attachment of virtually any solid nanoparticles. Approximately every other tip prepared with this method has a single nanoparticle terminated apex. We demonstrate the force measurements between a single approximately 50 nm ceria nanoparticle and flat silica surface in aqueous media of different acidity (pH 4-9). Comparing forces measured with larger ceria particles ( approximately 500 nm), we show that the interaction with nanoparticles is qualitatively different from the interaction with larger particles.     

Physico-chemical applications of liquid chromatography I. Investigation of the adsorption of cardiac glycosides from water-ethanol solutions on silanized silica

Summary Using the cardiac glycoside cymarin as the example the application of liquid chromatography for the study of adsorption from solutions and the determination of the corresponding thermodynamic characteristics was investigated. The adsorption isotherm of cymarin at small concentrations from a water-ethanol solvent on silica gel modified by dimethyldichlorosilane was measured under static conditions using analytical LC to determine the concentrations of solutions after adsorption. The values of the Henry constants were obtained by extrapolating the slope of the adsorption isotherm down to zero concentration. The specific retention volumes for different but small sample sizes of cymarin in the chromatographic column were measured, the adsorbent and the water-ethanol eluent being the same as in the static conditions. The specific retention volume for a small (zero) sample size determined by liquid chromatography experiment coincides with the Henry constant of cymarin adsorption determined in static conditions. In favourable cases liquid chromatography can be used to determine the equilibrium constants for adsorption from solution. The dependence of the Henry constants on temperature was investigated for several cardiac glycosides. The influence of the modification of the adsorbent surface on the separation of the cardiac glycosides was also studied.     

Adsorption from solutions of nonelectrolytes on heterogeneous solid surfaces: A four-parameter equation for the excess adsorption isotherm

A four-parameter single-solute adsorption isotherm equation is generalized to the adsorption of binary liquid mixtures of nonelectrolytes. This equation comprises all isotherms being a simple extension of theEverett isotherm to liquid adsorption on heterogeneous solid surfaces. The benzene—cyclohexane excess adsorption data on silica gel are studied by using this new equation.

---

Adsorption aus Lösungen von Nichtelektrolyten an heterogenen festen Oberflächen: Eine Vierparametergleichung für die Excess-Adsorptions-Isotherme

Zusammenfassung Es wird eine Vierparameter-Isothermengleichung für binäre Lösungen von Nichtelektrolyten diskutiert. Diese Gleichung umfaßt alle Isothermen vom Typ der einfachen Erweiterung derEverett-Isotherme für Flüssig-Adsorption auf heterogenen festen Oberflächen. Die Daten für die Adsorption von Benzol—Cyclohexan werden mittels dieser neuen Gleichung behandelt.

     

The retention behaviour of polar compounds on zirconia based stationary phases under hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography conditions

The most separations in HILIC mode are performed on silica-based supports. Nevertheless, recently published results have indicated that the metal oxides stationary phases also possess the ability to interact with hydrophilic compounds under HILIC conditions. This paper primarily describes the retention behaviour of model hydrophilic analytes (4-aminobenzene sulfonic acid, 4-aminobenzoic acid, 4-hydroxybenzoic acid, 3,4-diaminobenzoic acid, 3-aminophenol and 3-nitrophenol) on the polybutadine modified zirconia in HILIC. The results were simultaneously compared with a bare zirconia and a silica-based HILIC phase. The mobile phase strength, pH and the column temperature were systematically modified to assess their impact on the retention of model compounds. It was found that the retention of our model hydrophilic analytes on both zirconia phases was mainly governed by adsorption while on the silica-based HILIC phase partitioning was primarily involved. The ability of ligand-exchange interactions of zirconia surface with a carboxylic moiety influenced substantially the response of carboxylic acids on the elevated temperature as well as to the change of the mobile phase pH in contrast to the silica phase. However, no or negligible ligand-exchange interactions were observed for sulfanilic acid. The results of this study clearly demonstrated the ability of modified zirconia phase to retain polar acidic compounds under HILIC conditions, which might substantially enlarge the application area of the zirconia-based stationary phases.     

Dependence of selectivity and resolution upon composition of the binary mobile phase in LSC

The recently derived general equation for the capacity ratio has been utilized to study the dependence of selectivity and resolution upon mobile phase composition. This equation accounts for differences in molecular size of solutes and solvents, and for the energetic heterogeneity of the adscrbent surface. Model calculations illustrating the influence of these factors on the selectivity and resolution are presented and discussed.     

Influence of column characteristics on retention and selectivity in RP-HPLC

Summary Eight commercially available reversed-phase (RP) columns of widely different characteristics were evaluated and compared using the linear solvation energy relationships (LSER). Retention factors of 32 solutes of different types were determined under isocratic conditions using an acetonitrile-water (30∶70) mobile phase. Stationary phase properties were compared by the fitting coefficients of the LSER-based regression equations which are characteristic of the individual stationary phases and represent the extent of various molecular interactions contributing to the retention process. The good agreement between the calculated and measured logk values for different type of compounds support the adequacy and applicability of the LSER model to describe chromatographic retention. Characterization of column performance for the separation of various type of compounds was established by the determination of the different selectivity factors representing hydrophobic selectivity, polar selectivity and specific selectivity.     

Influence of chemical modification of polymeric resin on retention of polar compounds in solid-phase extraction

Summary Three polymeric adsorbents, two of which had been chemically modified with different hydrophilic functional moieties and the third, which was the corresponding unmodified polystyrene-divinylbenzene (PSDVB) resin, were compared for solid-phase extraction (SPE) of several polar pesticides and phenolic compounds from water samples. The SPE system was online coupled to a liquid chromatograph with UV detector. Chemical modification of the PS-DVB resin with either 2-carboxy-3/4-nitrobenzoyl or 2,4-dicarboxybenzoyl, improved the efficiency of the SPE process by increasing polar interactions with the analytes. The adsorbent with the nitro group gave higher recoveries, mainly for the most polar analytes. This adsorbent enabled 100 mL river water to be preconcentrated to determine the target analytes in this matrix.     

Thermodynamic evaluation of the interaction of fatty acid methyl esters with polar and non-polar stationary phases,based on their retention indices

Summary Kovát retention indices are used to determine the partial molar free energies of solution of 39 methyl esters of saturated (normal and branched), mono- and poly-unsaturated higher fatty acids in the non-polar phase Se-30 and the polar phase SILAR 5CP. Contributions of double bonds as a function of their number and position in the acid chain to the partial molar free energies of solution (G) are evaluated quantitatively. Linear equations are suggested for the calculation of G of any compounds from their retention indices measured in columns with SE-30 and SILAR 5CP.     

Application of the electrostatic interaction concept for the study of the retention behaviour of peropyrene-type polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Summary Capacity factors of peropyrene-type polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons were measured using 15 different liquid chromatographic reversed phase systems. On the basis of the retention data the electric interaction indices have been calculated. Application of these indices for structure-retention studies on peropyrene-type polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons is demonstrated.     

Study of the retention behavior of small polar molecules on different types of stationary phases used in hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography

The retention behavior of a large group of analytes (35) with varied properties (pK_a and logP) was studied on eight hydrophilic interaction LC columns with different surfaces, stationary phase chemistries, and types of particles. The acetonitrile content (5–95%), buffer concentration (0.5–200 mM), and pH of the mobile phase (3.8 and 6.8) were evaluated for their effects on the retention behavior. The type of stationary phase had a significant impact on the selectivity and retention time of the tested analytes. Completely different selectivity was observed on the aminopropyl stationary phase. In this study, the influence of the buffer concentration was similar for all tested columns, except for the aminopropyl stationary phase. Increasing the buffer concentration led to decreased retention times for the basic compounds and increased retention times for the acidic compounds, while the inverse behavior was observed on the aminopropyl stationary phase. The selectivity of the individual stationary phases was evaluated at pH 3.8 and 6.8. Much lower selectivity differences between the stationary phases were observed at pH 6.8 than pH 3.8. Bare silica stationary phases were used in the comparison of the particles (fused‐core and fully porous particles of 3 and 1.7 μm) and the columns provided by different manufacturers.     

Thin-layer adsorption chromatography with mixed mobile phases. 1. Characterization of chromatographic systems showing energetic heterogeneity of adsorbent surfaces with regard to admolecules of solvents and solutes

Thin-layer adsorption chromatography with a multicomponent mobile phase is discussed. A new equation for predicting R_M-values in TLC with mixed mobile phases using the R_M-ValUeS obtained for pure solvents is proposed. This equation takes into account effects of energetic heterogeneity of the adsorbent surface with regard to adsorbed molecules of solvents and solutes. Experimental verification of this equation is presented for R_M-data obtained by TLC using a binary mobile phase.