Comparison of hydrophilic-interaction, reversed-phase and porous graphitic carbon chromatography for glycan analysis

Hydrophilic-interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC), reversed-phase chromatography (RPC) and porous graphitic carbon (PGC) chromatography are typically applied for liquid chromatographic separations of protein N-glycans. Hence the performances of these chromatography modes for the separation of fluorescently labeled standard glycan samples (monoclonal antibody, fetuin, ribonuclease-B) covering high-mannose and a broad range of complex type glycans were investigated. In RPC the retention of sialylated glycans was enhanced by adding an ion-pairing agent to the mobile phase, resulting in improved peak shapes for sialylated glycans compared to methods recently reported in literature. For ion pairing RPC (IP-RPC) and HILIC ultra-high performance stationary phases were utilized to maximize the peak capacity and thus the resolution. But due to the shallow gradient in RPC the peak capacity was lower than on PGC. Retention times in HILIC and IP-RPC could be correlated to the monosaccharide compositions of the glycans by multiple linear regression, whereas no adequate model was obtained for PGC chromatography, indicating the significance of the three-dimensional structure of the analytes for retention in this method. Generally low correlations were observed between the chromatography methods, indicating their orthogonality. The high selectivities, as well as the commercial availability of ultra-high performance stationary phases render HILIC the chromatography method of choice for the analysis of glycans. Even though for complete characterization of complex glycan samples a combination of chromatography methods may be necessary.     

HILIC analysis of fluorescence-labeled N-glycans from recombinant biopharmaceuticals

In contrast with conventional drugs, biopharmaceuticals are highly complex molecules with remarkable heterogeneity. Protein glycosylation is an inherent source of this heterogeneity and also affects the safety, efficacy, and serum half-life of therapeutic glycoproteins. Therefore analysis of the glycan pattern is an important issue for characterization and quality control in the biopharmaceutical industry. In this publication we describe a complete workflow for the analysis of protein N-glycans. The sample-preparation procedure, consisting of the release of the N-glycans by PNGase-F, followed by fluorescence labeling with 2-aminobenzamide and removal of excess label, was optimized to avoid alteration of the glycan sample. Subsequently, labeled glycans were analyzed by hydrophilic-interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) with fluorescence detection. The developed method was validated for analysis of antibody N-glycans. To demonstrate the accuracy of the method an antibody sample was additionally analyzed by an orthogonal method. The antibody was digested with lysyl endopeptidase and the (glyco-)peptides were analyzed by RP-HPLC–MS. The consistency of the results between these two methods demonstrates the reliability of the glycan analysis method introduced herein.     

利用β-N-乙酰氨基葡萄糖苷酶快速酶切分析中国仓鼠卵巢细胞表达的西妥昔单抗抗原结合区的聚糖比例

西妥昔单抗具有较复杂的糖基化修饰,在抗原结合片段(Fab)和可结晶片段(Fc)的重链上都含有2个N-糖基化位点,其中Fab段的糖基化最为复杂,要研究清楚该位点的糖基化修饰,开发专一性切糖技术和稳定的聚糖比例分析方法是当前迫切需要解决的难题。以中国仓鼠卵巢(CHO)细胞表达的西妥昔单抗为研究对象,使用β-N-乙酰氨基葡萄糖苷酶(Endo F2)开发了一种快速Fab段聚糖释放的方法,利用超高效液相色谱-高分辨质谱(UPLC-HRMS)进行了定性和聚糖比例分析。第一步对抗体原液进行非变性酶切,抗体原液经超纯水稀释后,加入糖苷酶Endo F2进行酶切,通过质谱对质量数的解析,结果表明Endo F2酶切时间5 min, Fab段的聚糖就能完全切除,而Fc段的聚糖不受影响,实现了快速酶切,而且切糖具有很好的专一性。第二步对Fab段聚糖进行比例分析,将释放的聚糖经对氨基苯甲酰胺(2-AB)荧光标记后使用超高效液相色谱联用荧光检测器(FLR)进行检测,在亲水作用色谱(HILIC)柱上得到良好的分离并可以进行稳定地聚糖比例分析。3次独立试验结果表明,酶切后的质谱图基本一致,且聚糖的比例结果也基本一致,表明Endo F2酶切方法和聚糖比例分析方法都具有较好的稳定性和可靠性。此外,通过测定来自两个不同工艺生产的样品,数据显示两者的糖谱上具有非常明显的差异,表明利用开发的方法可以实现对抗体生产工艺进行监测研究,对抗体生产工艺的评估具有非常重要的意义。     

Targeted analysis of glycomics liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry data

Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS) is appropriate for all native and reductively aminated glycan classes. HILIC carries the advantage that retention times vary predictably according to oligosaccharide composition. Chromatographic conditions are compatible with sensitive and reproducible glycomics analysis of large numbers of samples. The data are extremely useful for quantitative profiling of glycans expressed in biological tissues. With these analytical developments, the rate-limiting factor for widespread use of HILIC LC/MS in glycomics is the analysis of the data. In order to eliminate this problem, a Java-based open source software tool, Manatee, was developed for targeted analysis of HILIC LC/MS glycan datasets. This tool uses user-defined lists of compositions that specify the glycan chemical space in a given biological context. The program accepts high-resolution LC/MS data using the public mzXML format and is capable of processing a large data file in a few minutes on a standard desktop computer. The program allows mining of HILIC LC/MS data with an output compatible with multivariate statistical analysis. It is envisaged that the Manatee tool will complement more computationally intensive LC/MS processing tools based on deconvolution and deisotoping of LC/MS data. The capabilities of the tool were demonstrated using a set of HILIC LC/MS data on organ-specific heparan sulfates.     

Online coupling of reverse-phase and hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography for protein and glycoprotein characterization

We have developed a novel system for coupling reverse-phase (RP) and hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) online in a micro-flow scheme. In this approach, the inherent solvent incompatibility between RP and HILIC is overcome through the use of constant-pressure online solvent mixing, which allows our system to perform efficient separations of both hydrophilic and hydrophobic compounds for mass spectrometry-based proteomics applications. When analyzing the tryptic digests of bovine serum albumin, ribonuclease B, and horseradish peroxidase, we observed near-identical coverage of peptides and glycopeptides when using online RP-HILIC—with only a single sample injection event—as we did from two separate RP and HILIC analyses. The coupled system was also capable of concurrently characterizing the peptide and glycan portions of deglycosylated glycoproteins from one injection event, as confirmed, for example, through our detection of 23 novel glycans from turkey ovalbumin. Finally, we validated the applicability of using RP-HILIC for the analysis of highly complex biological samples (mouse chondrocyte lysate, deglycosylated human serum). The enhanced coverage and efficiency of online RP-HILIC makes it a viable technique for the comprehensive separation of components displaying dramatically different hydrophobicities, such as peptides, glycopeptides, and glycans.     

Characterization of Minor N-linked Glycans on Antibodies Using Endo H Release and MALDI–Mass Spectrometry

Abstract

A MALDI mass spectrometry method using Bruker Daltonic's LIFT technology for MS/MS analysis has been developed for profiling and characterizing low abundant N-glycans from recombinant immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies. In this method, Endoglycosidase H (Endo H) released N-glycans are derivatized at their reducing end with 2-aminobenzamide (2-AB) and separated by normal phase chromatography. Endo H hydrolyses the bond between the two GlcNAc residues of the trimannosyl core of high mannose and hybrid N-linked glycans, leaving the core GlcNAc attached to the protein. High mannose and hybrid type N-glycans are released from the glycoprotein whereas the more abundant, complex biantennary type oligosaccharide structures are unaffected. Analysis of Endo H treated glycan moieties by MALDI mass spectrometry identified several minor species of high mannose and hybrid type glycans. Subsequent MALDI TOF MS/MS analysis of the resulting products yielded information about structural features of the high mannose and hybrid type glycans. This study involving Endo H treatment followed by MALDI mass spectrometry coupled with LIFT technology for MS/MS analysis offers a specific and sensitive technique for visualizing, and characterizing minor glycan species.     

LC-MS/MS Peptide Mapping with Automated Data Processing for Routine Profiling of N-Glycans in Immunoglobulins

Protein N-Glycan analysis is traditionally performed by high pH anion exchange chromatography (HPAEC), reversed phase liquid chromatography (RPLC), or hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) on fluorescence-labeled glycans enzymatically released from the glycoprotein. These methods require time-consuming sample preparations and do not provide site-specific glycosylation information. Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) peptide mapping is frequently used for protein structural characterization and, as a bonus, can potentially provide glycan profile on each individual glycosylation site. In this work, a recently developed glycopeptide fragmentation model was used for automated identification, based on their MS/MS, of N-glycopeptides from proteolytic digestion of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). Experimental conditions were optimized to achieve accurate profiling of glycoforms. Glycan profiles obtained from LC-MS/MS peptide mapping were compared with those obtained from HPAEC, RPLC, and HILIC analyses of released glycans for several mAb molecules. Accuracy, reproducibility, and linearity of the LC-MS/MS peptide mapping method for glycan profiling were evaluated. The LC-MS/MS peptide mapping method with fully automated data analysis requires less sample preparation, provides site-specific information, and may serve as an alternative method for routine profiling of N-glycans on immunoglobulins as well as other glycoproteins with simple N-glycans.

Mass spectrometric characterization of glycosylation of hepatitis C virus E2 envelope glycoprotein reveals extended microheterogeneity of N-glycans

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) causes acute and chronic liver disease in humans, including chronic hepatitis, cirrhosis, and hepatocellular carcinoma. The polyprotein encoded in the HCV genome is co- and post-translationally processed by host and viral peptidases, generating the structural proteins Core, E1, E2, and p7, and five nonstructural proteins. The two envelope proteins E1 and E2 are heavily glycosylated. Studying the glycan moieties attached to the envelope E2 glycoprotein is important because the N-linked glycans on E2 envelope protein are involved in the interaction with some human neutralizing antibodies, and may also have a direct or indirect effect on protein folding. In the present study, we report the mass spectrometric characterization of the glycan moieties attached to the E2 glycoprotein. The mass spectrometric analysis clearly identified the nature, composition, and microheterogeneity of the sugars attached to the E2 glycopeptides. All 11 sites of glycosylation on E2 protein were characterized, and the majority of these sites proved to be occupied by high mannose glycans. However, complex type oligosaccharides, which have not been previously identified, were exclusively observed at two N-linked sites, and their identity and heterogeneity were determined.     

The effects of abundant plasma protein depletion on global glycan profiling using NanoLC FT-ICR mass spectrometry

We report the results of abundant plasma protein depletion on the analysis of underivatized N-linked glycans derived from plasma proteins by nanoLC Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry. N-linked glycan profiles were compared between plasma samples where the six most abundant plasma proteins were depleted (n = 3) through a solid-phase immunoaffinity column and undepleted plasma samples (n = 3). Three exogenous glycan standards were spiked into all samples which allowed for normalization of the N-glycan abundances. The abundances of 20 glycans varying in type, structure, composition, and molecular weight (1,200–3,700 Da) were compared between the two sets of samples. Small fucosylated non-sialylated complex glycans were found to decrease in abundance in the depleted samples (greater than or equal to tenfold) relative to the undepleted samples. Protein depletion was found to marginally effect (less than threefold) the abundance of high mannose, hybrid, and large highly sialylated complex species. The significance of these findings in terms of future biomarker discovery experiments via global glycan profiling is discussed.     

Zwitterionic-type hydrophilic interaction nano-liquid chromatography of complex and high mannose glycans coupled with electrospray ionisation high resolution time of flight mass spectrometry

In this study we describe a new method for rapid and sensitive analysis of reduced high mannose and complex glycans using zwitterionic-type hydrophilic interaction nano-liquid chromatography (nano ZIC-HILIC, 75 μm I.D.×150 mm) coupled with high resolution nanoelectrospray ionisation time of flight mass spectrometry (nano ESI-TOF-MS). The retention of neutral glycans increases with increasing molecular weight and is higher for high mannose glycans than for complex-type glycans. The selectivity of ZIC-HILIC for sialylated glycans differs from that for the neutral glycans and is believed to involve electrostatic repulsion; therefore, charged glycans are eluted earlier than neutral glycans with comparable molecular weight. Due to the improved sensitivity achieved by employing a ZIC-HILIC nano-column, a range of less common complex glycans has been studied and the high resolution mass spectrometry enabled confirmation of glycan composition for the proposed structures. Good sensitivity for glycans was achieved without prior fluorescent labelling, and the time of the analysis was significantly reduced compared to the separation of glycans on a conventional-size column. The proposed method offers a fast and sensitive approach for glycan profiling applied to analysis of biopharmaceuticals.     

Recent advances in hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) for structural glycomics

This review presents recent progress in employing hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) for glycan and glycopeptides analysis. After an introduction of this technique, the following themes are addressed: (i) implementation of HILIC in large-scale studies for analyzing the human plasma N-glycome; (ii) the use of HILIC UPLC (ultrahigh pressure liquid chromatography) for fast high-resolution runs and its successful application with online MS for glycan and glycopeptide analysis; (iii) high-throughput profiling using HILIC solid-phase extraction in combination with MS detection; (iv) HILIC sample preparation for CE and CGE; (v) the latest glycoproteomic approaches implementing HILIC separation; (vi) future perspectives of HILIC including its use in large-scale glycoproteomics studies such as the analysis of entire glycoproteomes at the glycopeptide level.     

BOLD--a biological O-linked glycan database

Glycans can be O-linked to proteins via the hydroxyl group of serine, threonine, tyrosine, hydroxylysine or hydroxyproline. Sometimes the glycan is O-linked to the hydroxyl group via a phosphodiester bond. The core monosaccharide residue may be N-acetylgalactosamine, N-acetylglucosamine, galactose, glucose, fucose, mannose, xylose or arabinose. These O-linked glycans can remain as a monosaccharide, but often a complex structure is built up by stepwise addition of monosaccharides. Monosaccharides known to be added include galactose, N-acetylglucosamine, fucose, N-acetylneuraminic acid, N-glycolylneuraminic acid and 2-keto-3-deoxynonulosonic acid. O-linked glycans can also contain sulfate and phosphate residues. This leads to the possibility of the existence of numerous O-glycan structures. The biological O-linked database (BOLD) is a relational database that contains information on O-linked glycan structures, their biological sources (with a link to the SWISS-PROT protein database), the references in which the glycan was described (with a link to MEDLINE), and the methods used to determine the glycan structure. The database provides a valuable resource for glycobiology researchers interested in O-linked oligosaccharide structures that have been previously described on proteins from different species and tissues.     

Hydrophilic interaction 10 microm I.D. porous layer open tubular columns for ultratrace glycan analysis by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry

The sensitivity of glycan analysis using nano-liquid chromatography interfaced with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) increases with the decrease of the mobile phase flow rate, accompanied by reduced ion suppression. In this study, we describe the preparation and performance of high efficiency 10 microm I.D. amine-bonded poly(vinylbenzyl chloride-divinylbenzene) hydrophilic interaction (HILIC) porous layer open tubular (PLOT) columns operated at 20 nL/min for the separation and analysis of glycan mixtures. HILIC-PLOT columns with a uniform porous polymer layer were reproducibly prepared ( approximately 4% RSD in retention time from column-to-column) via in situ polymerization, followed by one step modification with ethylenediamine. When coupled on-line with negative ESI-MS, low detection limits (0.3fmol) for a 3-sialyl-tetrasaccharide were achieved using a 2.5mx10 microm I.D. HILIC-PLOT column. A dextran ladder standard was used to evaluate the performance of the column, and high efficiency separation was achieved with detection of the dextrans up to G22 from approximately 50 fmol amounts injected. As an example of the high sensitivity of the column, MS(6) characterization of glycan structures was possible from the injection of 10 fmol of a neutral and sialylated glycan. As another example of high sensitivity LC-MS analysis of 3 ng of a PNGase F digest of ovalbumin allowed 28 N-linked glycans to be confidently identified from a single analysis. High quality MS/MS spectra for each ovalbumin glycan were acquired and manually interpreted for structure analysis. The HILIC-PLOT column is a very promising approach for LC-MS analysis of glycans at the ultratrace level.     

用于寡糖链分析的HPLC柱前衍生化方法研究进展

糖复合物中的糖链具有广泛的生理和病理作用. 在研究糖复合物中糖链的功能时, 需要解析其化学结构, 以便进一步研究结构与功能的关系. 糖链的释放常采用化学法或酶法, 如何纯化释放的糖链对结构解析至关重要, 目前常用的方法是高效液相色谱法(HPLC), 为提高检测的灵敏度, 往往需要对糖链衍生化. 对糖链的HPLC柱前衍生化方法进行综述和评价.     

Breaking the Limits in Analyzing Carbohydrate Recognition by NMR Spectroscopy: Resolving Branch‐Selective Interaction of a Tetra‐Antennary N‐Glycan with Lectins

The biological recognition of complex‐type N ‐glycans is part of many key physiological and pathological events. Despite their importance, the structural characterization of these events remains unsolved. The inherent flexibility of N ‐glycans hampers crystallization and the chemical equivalence of individual branches precludes their NMR characterization. By using a chemoenzymatically synthesized tetra‐antennary N ‐glycan conjugated to a lanthanide binding tag, the NMR signals under paramagnetic conditions discriminated all four N ‐acetyl lactosamine antennae with unprecedented resolution. The NMR data revealed the conformation of the N ‐glycan and permitted for the first time the direct identification of individual branches involved in the recognition by two N ‐acetyllactosamine‐binding lectins, Datura stramonium seed lectin (DSL) and Ricinus Communis agglutinin (RCA120).     

Analysis of glycans derived from glycoconjugates by capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry

The high structural variation of glycan derived from glycoconjugates, which substantially increases with the molecular size of a protein, contributes to the complexity of glycosylation patterns commonly associated with glycoconjugates. In the case of glycoproteins, such variation originates from the multiple glycosylation sites of proteins and the number of glycan structures associated with each site (microheterogeneity). The ability to comprehensively characterize highly complex mixture of glycans has been analytically stimulating and challenging. Although the most powerful MS and MS/MS techniques are capable of providing a wealth of structural information, they are still not able to readily identify isomeric glycan structures without high-order MS/MS (MS(n) ). The analysis of isomeric glycan structures has been attained using several separation methods, including high-pH anion-exchange chromatography, hydrophilic interaction chromatography and GC. However, CE and microfluidics CE (MCE) offer high separation efficiency and resolutions, allowing the separation of closely related glycan structures. Therefore, interfacing CE and MCE to MS is a powerful analytical approach, allowing potentially comprehensive and sensitive analysis of complex glycan samples. This review describes and discusses the utility of different CE and MCE approaches in the structural characterization of glycoproteins and the feasibility of interfacing these approaches to MS.     

基于固相萃取的微量糖蛋白糖基化修饰表征技术的建立

结合自制亲水固相萃取富集柱和生物质谱鉴定技术,实现了糖基化蛋白质核糖核酸酶B的糖含量测定、糖基化位点确认、聚糖富集及结构表征,以及不同糖型相对丰度分析。结果表明:其糖含量8.47%,糖基化位点为34位的Asn,糖链主要为5种高甘露糖型结构(Man5-9GlcNAc2)。所建立的HILIC富集技术,有利于针对微量生物样本,如生物工程药物糖蛋白及重要功能糖蛋白,开展位点特异性糖链结构解析,为糖蛋白质的药效或功能研究提供线索。     

A metabolically engineered spin-labeling approach for studying glycans on cells

Metabolic glycan engineering (MGE) coupled with nitroxide spin-labeling (SL) was utilized to investigate the heterogeneous environment of cell surface glycans in select cancer and normal cells. This approach exploited the incorporation of azides into cell surface glycans followed by a click reaction with a new nitroxide spin label. Both sialic acid and N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc) were targeted for spin labelling. Although each of these moieties experiences a diverse and heterogeneous glycan environment, their EPR spectra and hence mobility are both characterized as a linear combination of two distinct spectra where one component reflects a highly mobile or uncrowded micro-environment with the second component reflecting more restricted motion, reflective of increased crowding and packing within the glycocalyx. What differs among the spectra of the targeted glycans is the relative percentage of each component, with sialic acid moieties experiencing on average an ∼80% less crowded environment, where conversely GlcNAc/GalNAz labeled sites reported on average a ∼50% more crowded environment. These distinct environments are consistent with the organization of sugar moieties within cellular glycans where some residues occur close to the cell membrane/protein backbone (i.e. more restricted) and others are more terminal in the glycan (i.e. more mobile). Strikingly, different cell lines displayed varied relative populations of these two components, suggesting distinctive glycan packing, organization, and composition of different cells. This work demonstrates the capability of SDSL EPR to be a broadly useful tool for studying glycans on cells, and interpretation of the results provides insights for distinguishing the differences and changes in the local organization and heterogeneity of the cellular glycocalyx.

Metabolic glycan engineering (MGE) coupled with nitroxide spin-labeling (SL) was utilized to investigate the heterogeneous environment of cell surface glycans in select cancer and normal cells.     

Application of Lectin Microarrays for Biomarker Discovery

Many proteins in living organisms are glycosylated. As their glycan patterns exhibit protein-, cell-, and tissue-specific heterogeneity, changes in the glycosylation levels could serve as useful indicators of various pathological and physiological states. Thus, the identification of glycoprotein biomarkers from specific changes in the glycan profiles of glycoproteins is a trending field. Lectin microarrays provide a new glycan analysis platform, which enables rapid and sensitive analysis of complex glycans without requiring the release of glycans from the protein. Recent developments in lectin microarray technology enable high-throughput analysis of glycans in complex biological samples. In this review, we will discuss the basic concepts and recent progress in lectin microarray technology, the application of lectin microarrays in biomarker discovery, and the challenges and future development of this technology. Given the tremendous technical advancements that have been made, lectin microarrays will become an indispensable tool for the discovery of glycoprotein biomarkers.     

Glycan-modified interfaces in biosensing: an electrochemical approach

Glycans (complex carbohydrates) attached to various interfacial layers represent a simple but functional model of a cellular surface, which is covered densely by glycans. In this review, we discuss interactions of surface-confined glycans with various glycan-binding proteins, viruses, or pathogenic bacteria. Such glycan receptive interfaces can be applied for biosensing of these analytes. In this review, we focus on the application of glycan interfaces for label-free electrochemical biosensing.