Light scattering and dielectric relaxation studies of glass forming liquids

Extended Abstract: Glass forming organic liquids and polymers exhibit long range density fluctuations with correlation length ξ in the range of 10–300 nm at temperatures above T_g (1 - 6). This follows from dynamic and static light scattering experiments revealing some unexpected features, which cannot be explained on the basis of conventional liquid state theories: (i) In static light scattering the intensity I(q → 0) is no longer proportional to the isothermal compressibility, (ii) This excess scattering I_exc shows a strong q-dependence (q = (4π/Λ.)sin(θ/2)) corresponding to a correlation length ξ in the above mentioned range, (iii) The Landau-Placzek ratio I_Rayleigh/2I_Brillouin is much too high compared with the results of light scattering theories, (iv) In photon correlation spectroscopy a new ultraslow hydrodynamic mode (Γ ˜ q²) is detected with relaxation rates Γ about 10⁻⁶ to 10⁻⁹ lower than those of the α-process at a given temperature. In order to explain these observations, a two-state fluid model is proposed, which starts from the coexistence of “liquid-like” and “aperiodic solid-like” regions within the liquids. Such ideas have been discussed many times before, so for example A.R. Ubbelohde (7) speculates about “anticrystalline” clusters in liquids. Molecular dynamics simulations of atomic liquids showed that long range orientational fluctuations appear upon supercooling (8). A preferred icosahedral ordering is observed (9) and the number of icosahedral clusters increases with decreasing temperature (10). In connection with the interpretation of the dynamics of supercooled liquids different “two-state” models have been proposed (11 - 15). For the explanation of the light scattering results we propose that the molecules in the different dynamic states (“liquid” or “solid”) aggregate during annealing of the liquid at temperatures above T_g. Experiments showed that the equilibration times can be rather long (3 - 5), but nevertheless the liquids exhibiting long range density fluctuations are in the state of lowest free energy. We claim that our observations are the first experimental proof of the existence of such different dynamic states, which have been discussed many times before. The extended secondary clusters can also be detected by ultra small angle X-ray scattering.     

Dielectric and conductivity relaxations in poly(hema) and of water in its hydrogel

The dielectric permittivity ε′ and loss ε″ of anhydrous poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate) and its 38.6 w/w% hydrogel have been measured in the frequency range from 12 Hz to 200 kHz and the temperature range from 77 to 273 K. The former has a sub-T_g relaxation with a half-width of 4.5 decades for the loss spectra, whose strength increases with temperature, and an activation energy of 62.5 kJ/mol. The dielectric relaxation time of the α process of supercooled water in the hydrogel is 53 s at its calorimetric T_g of 135 K. The half-width of the relaxation spectrum is 2.85 decades and, in the narrow temperature range, its apparent activation energy is 60.8 kJ/mol. Heating of the hydrogel causes crystallization of water which begins at about 207 K and becomes readily detectable as a second dielectric loss peak at about 230 K. For each temperature between 207 and 267 K, supercooled water in the hydrogel coexists with its crystallized form, with the amount of the crystallized solid increasing with increasing temperature. These results are discussed in terms of “bound” and “free” states of water in the hydrogel.     

Orientational dynamics and energy landscape features of thermotropic liquid crystals: An analogy with supercooled liquids

Recent optical kerr effect (OKE) studies have revealed that orientational relaxation of rodlike nematogens near the isotropic-nematic (I-N) phase boundary and also in the nematic phase exhibit temporal power law decay at intermediate times. Such behaviour has drawn an intriguing analogy with supercooled liquids. Here, we have investigated the single-particle and collective orientational dynamics of a family of model system of thermotropic liquid crystals using extensive computer simulations. Several remarkable features of glassy dynamics are on display including non-exponential relaxation, dynamical heterogeneity, and non-Arrhenius temperature dependence of the orientational relaxation time. Over a temperature range near the I-N phase boundary, the system behaves like a fragile glass-forming liquid. Using proper scaling, we construct the usual relaxation time versus inverse temperature plot and explicitly demonstrate that one can successfully define a density dependent fragility of liquid crystals. The fragility of liquid crystals shows a temperature and density dependence which is remarkably similar to the fragility of glass forming supercooled liquids. Energy landscape analysis of inherent structures shows that the breakdown of the Arrhenius temperature dependence of relaxation rate occurs at a temperature that marks the onset of the growth of the depth of the potential energy minima explored by the system.     

Dynamics in supercooled ionic organic liquids and mode coupling theory analysis

Optically heterodyne-detected optical Kerr effect experiments are applied to study the orientational dynamics of the supercooled ionic organic liquids N-propyl-3-methylpyridinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide (PMPIm) and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tosylate (EMImTOS). The orientational dynamics are complex with relaxation involving several power law decays followed by a final exponential decay. A mode coupling theory (MCT) schematic model, the Sj?gren model, was able to reproduce the PMPIm data very successfully over a wide range of times from 1 ps to hundreds of ns for all temperatures studied. Over the temperature range from room temperature down to the critical temperature Tc of 231 K, the OHD-OKE signal of PMPIm is characterized by the intermediate power law t(-1.00+/-0.04) at short times, a von Schweidler power law t(-0.51+/-0.03) at intermediate times, and a highly temperature-dependent exponential (alpha relaxation) at long times. This form of the decay is identical to the form observed previously for a large number of organic van der Waals liquids. MCT analysis indicates that the theory can explain the experimental data very well for a range of temperatures above Tc, but as might be expected, there are some deviations from the theoretical modeling at temperatures close to Tc. For EMImTOS, the orientational dynamics were studied on the ps time scale in the deeply supercooled region near its glass transition temperature. The orientational relaxation of EMImTOS clearly displays the feature associated with the boson peak at approximately 2 ps, which is the first time domain evidence of the boson peak in ionic organic liquids. Overall, all the dynamical features observed earlier for organic van der Waals liquids using the same experimental technique are also observed for organic ionic liquids.     

Superdipole liquid scenario for the dielectric primary relaxation in supercooled polar liquids

We propose a dynamic structure of coupled dynamic molecular strings for supercooled small polar molecule liquids and accordingly we obtain the Hamiltonian of the rotational degrees of freedom of the system. From the Hamiltonian, the strongly correlated supercooled polar liquid state is renormalized to a normal superdipole liquid state. This scenario describes the following main features of the primary or alpha-relaxation dynamics in supercooled polar liquids: (1) the average relaxation time evolves from a high temperature Arrhenius to a low temperature non-Arrhenius or super-Arrhenius behavior; (2) the relaxation function crosses over from the high temperature exponential to low temperature nonexponential form; and (3) the temperature dependence of the relaxation strength shows non-Curie features. According to the present model, the crossover phenomena of the first two characteristics arise from the transition between the superdipole gas and the superdipole liquid. The model predictions are quantitatively compared with the experimental results of glycerol, a typical glass former.     

Anisotropy of local relaxation properties of macromolecules. Spin-lattice relaxation of 13C nuclei,the nuclear overhauser effect and the estimation of parameters of an equivalent ellipsoid for kinetic segments of polymer chains

The expressions for the functions of spectral density at different orientations of the components of the internuclear vector with respect to the chain backbone, the frequency dependences of the spin-lattice relaxation time of ¹³C nuclei (T_1C) and the values of the nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) were obtained for the tetrahedral lattice model of a polymer chain with three-unit kinetic elements. It was shown that peculiar features of the behavior of T_1C and NOE reflect the characteristic properties of the spectra of relaxation (correlation) times for “longitudinal” and “transverse” components of the internuclear vector. It was established that in the range of relatively short times of the relaxation spectrum the dynamics of an anisotropic kinetic segment of the chain may be described with the aid of a simple model of an elongated ellipsoid of rotation with an axial ratio of about 10. It is shown that the equivalent-ellipsoid model leads to significant differences from a more specific model of chain dynamics when a broad frequency range is considered.     

Orientational and translational dynamics in room temperature ionic liquids

The authors investigate the dynamics of a series of room temperature ionic liquids, based on the same 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium cation with different anions, by means of broadband (10(-6)-10(9) Hz) dielectric spectroscopy and depolarized light scattering in the temperature range from 400 K down to 35 K. Typical ionic conductivity is observed above the glass transition temperature Tg. Below Tg the authors detect relaxation processes that exhibit characteristics of secondary relaxations, as typically observed in molecular glasses. At high temperatures, the characteristic times of cation reorientation, deduced from the light scattering data, are approximately equal to the electric modulus relaxation times related to ionic conductivity. In the supercooled regime and close to Tg, the authors observe decoupling of conductivity from structural relaxation. Overall, room temperature ionic liquids exhibit typical glass transition dynamics, apparently unaltered by Coulomb interactions.     

Comparative study of temperature dependent orientational relaxation in a model thermotropic liquid crystal and in a model supercooled liquid

Recent optical Kerr effect experiments have revealed a power law decay of the measured signal with a temperature independent exponent at short-to-intermediate times for a number of liquid crystals in the isotropic phase near the isotropic-nematic transition and supercooled molecular liquids above the mode coupling theory critical temperature. In this work, the authors investigate the temperature dependence of short-to-intermediate time orientational relaxation in a model thermotropic liquid crystal across the isotropic-nematic transition and in a binary mixture across the supercooled liquid regime in molecular dynamics simulations. The measure of the experimentally observable optical Kerr effect signal is found to follow a power law decay at short-to-intermediate times for both systems in agreement with recent experiments. In addition, the temperature dependence of the power law exponent is found to be rather weak. As the model liquid crystalline system settles into the nematic phase upon cooling, the decay of the single-particle second-rank orientational time correlation function exhibits a pattern that is similar to what has been observed for supercooled liquids.     

Glass Transition Temperature and Value of the Relaxation Time at Tg in Vitreous Polymers

Summary: Many works focused on glassy polymers determine values of glass transition temperature (T_g) and an overview of the literature shows that depending on the method used, values of T_g are found different for the same material. In this paper, a review of data collected on different materials are used and interpreted in term of molecular mobility characterized by relaxation time functions. By using three independent experimental procedures (dielectric, thermally depolarized current and calorimetric), we show that the value of the glass transition and the value of the relaxation time at T_g can be correctly determined. It is also shown that the assumption: τ _(Tg) = 100 s is constant, is not correct. The protocol proposed also allows the determination of the value of the fragility index “m” of the glass forming liquid with a great accuracy.     

Aging of the Johari-Goldstein relaxation in the glass-forming liquids sorbitol and xylitol

Employing frequency-dependent dielectric susceptibility we characterize the aging in two supercooled liquids, sorbitol and xylitol, below their calorimetric glass transition temperatures. In addition to the alpha relaxation that tracks the structural dynamics, the susceptibility of both liquids possesses a secondary Johari-Goldstein relaxation at higher frequencies. Following a quench through the glass transition, the susceptibility slowly approaches the equilibrium behavior. For both liquids, the magnitude of the Johari-Goldstein relaxation displays a dependence on the time since the quench, or aging time, that is quantitatively very similar to the age dependence of the alpha peak frequency. The Johari-Goldstein relaxation time remains constant during aging for sorbitol while it decreases slightly with age for xylitol. Hence, one cannot sensibly assign a fictive temperature to the Johari-Goldstein relaxation. This behavior contrasts with that of liquids lacking distinct Johari-Goldstein peaks for which the excess wing of the alpha peak tracks the main part of the peak during aging, enabling the assignment of a single fictive temperature to the entire spectrum. The aging behavior of the Johari-Goldstein relaxation time further calls into question the possibility that the relaxation time possesses stronger temperature dependence in equilibrium than is observed in the out-of-equilibrium state below the glass transition.     

Nonexponential relaxation and fragility in a model system and in supercooled liquids

Among the outstanding problems in the theory of supercooled liquids are the reasons for the rapid increase in their viscosity and relaxation times as the temperature is lowered towards the glass transition temperature Tg, the nonexponential time dependence of the relaxation, and the possible connection between these two properties. The ferromagnetic Potts model on a square latice is a simple system that is found to exhibit these properties. Our calculations show that in this system the connection between them is associated with the dependence on temperature and time of the average environment of the sites. Some of the consequences of this for understanding the behavior of supercooled liquids are discussed.     

Comment on: "Disentangling density and temperature effects in the viscous slowing down of glass forming liquids" [J. Chem. Phys. 120, 6135 (2004)

Recently, Tarjus et al. [G. Tarjus, D. Kivelson, S. Mossa, and C. Alba-Simionesco, J. Chem. Phys. 120, 6135 (2004)] concluded from a review of data for a variety of glass formers that the supercooled dynamics are almost invariably dominated by temperature T, rather than by density rho. By including additional published data into such a compilation, we show that for van der Waals molecular liquids, the dynamics near T(g) are in fact governed as much by density as by temperature. Moreover, relaxation times measured at various temperatures and pressures can be superimposed by plotting as a function rho(gamma)/T. This scaling form can arise from an assumed inverse power law for the intermolecular repulsive potential, with gamma a material constant. (c) 2004 American Institute of Physics.     

Pancakes

The equilibrium state of a microdroplet spreading spontaneously on a solid surface is usually expected to be a compact monolayer if the liquid is nonvolatile, i.e., if the temperature is well below the 2-dimensional critical temperature T_2C. More recently, it has been shown by de Gennes that this picture does not hold any more close to the wetting transition, where the initial spreading tension S₀ tends to vanish. Thicker, stable layers are predicted, the famous “pancakes”, the thickness of which diverges at the wetting transition. There is another case where the monolayer picture fails: some liquids composed of amphiphilic molecules, although they do not wet the substrate, build an autophobic film on it. On hydrophobic surfaces, this film is a perfectly organized bilayer of molecules. We give examples of the three situations, with the following nicknames: “French pancake” for the compact monolayer, “Swedish pancake” for the bilayer, “American pancake” for the thick film.     

Analysis of Thermodynamic Parameters of Glass Forming Polymeric Melts

The temperature dependence of the Gibbs free energy difference (ΔG), enthalpy difference (ΔH) and entropy difference (ΔS) between the undercooled meltand the corresponding equilibrium solid has been analysed for glass forming polymeric materials by calculating ΔG, ΔH and ΔS within the framework of the hole theory of liquids. The study is made for nine samples of glass forming polymeric melts; polypropylene oxide (PPO), polyamid-6 (PA-6), polytetramethylene oxide (PTMO), polyethylene oxide (PEO), polystyrene (PS), polypropylene (PP), polyethylene (PE), polyethylene terephthalate (PET) and polybutadiene (PB) and three simple organic liquids: tri-α-naphthyl benzene (tri-α-NB), o-terphenyl (o-ter) and phenyl salicylate (salol) in the entire temperature range T _m (melting temperature) to T _g (glass transition temperature). The ideal glass transition temperature (T _K) and the residual entropy (ΔS _R) of these samples have also been studied due to their important role in the study of the glass forming ability of materials. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Study of free volume in high-vinyl polybutadiene/cis-polyisoprene blends using positron annihilation spectroscopy

High-Vinyl Polybutadiene (HVBD)/cis-Polyisoprene (CPI) blends were characterized by Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) and Positron Annihilation Lifetime Spectroscopy (PALS). A single DSC glass transition temperature T_g is observed, whose composition dependence strongly deviates from additivity, and shows an apparent cusp when the weight fraction of HVBD ≈ 0.75. The free-volume hole size, V_h, and the scaled fractional free volume, h_ps/C, = I₃V_h were determined by PALS from the orthopositronium (o-Ps) intensities, I₃, and lifetimes, τ₃, over a temperature range encompassing T_g and the temperature at which “positronium bubble” formation occurs. In the glass, V_h and h_ps/C are smaller for CPI than for HVBD, but the thermal expansion coefficient for hole volume, α_f, is larger in the melt for CPI than for HVBD; thus, an iso-hole volume temperature occurs in these blends at T_iso ≈ −34°C. Above and below T_iso, V_h and h_ps/C each show a negative departure from additivity. A quantitative interpretation of the cusp in the composition dependence of T_g can be obtained, via a modified analysis of Kovacs, using free-volume quantities from PALS, with the ratio of scaling constants C_CPI/C_HVBD as an adjustable parameter. At high temperatures, the positron bubble size is smaller in CPI than in HVBD. This agrees with the observation that the thermal expansivity of hole volume, and, hence the internal pressure are larger in the equilibrium melt of CPI. The effect of e⁺-irradiation on the o-Ps intensity was investigated. I₃ decreases more rapidly in the melt as T → T_g, and then more slowly in the glass, suggesting that the effect is due to trapping of radical or ionic species which inhibit o-Ps formation. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Polym Sci B: Polym Phys 36: 861–871, 1998     

Theoretical temperature dependence of relaxation rate between widely spaced levels,due to gas or liquid fluctuations

In describing relaxation of a small system whose quantum level spacing ?_μ1, exceeds k_BT, one must treat the heat bath quantally even when it is a “classical” fluid. A simple gas model illustrates this, with possible implications for liquids.     

Solvent crazing of “dry” polystyrene and “dry” crazing of plasticized polystyrene

The critical strain ε_c for crazing of polystyrene in each of a variety of organic liquids has been measured along with the degree of swelling of the polymer by the liquid and the attendant reduction in the glass transition temperature T_g of the polymer. The critical strain for the crazing in air and the T_g of each of a set of specimens molded from mixtures of o-dichlorobenzene and polystyrene have also been determined. Correlations of ε_c with T_g in the two cases are identical within experimental error for the first 40°C of T_g reduction; these results imply (1) that organic liquids do not exercise a significant surface energy role in solvent crazing and (2) that their only roles are associated with flow processes. Correlation of solvent crazing ε_c with solubility parameter of the crazing fluid is very poor for several reasons that are discussed.     

Kinetics of structural relaxation of poly(ethylene terephthalate)

The results of an experimental study of the kinetics of structural relaxation of amorphous poly(ethylene terephthalate) are reported. Samples were prepared by ultraquenching the melt on rotating stainless-steel discs. Two types of measurements by differential scanning calorimetry were made: (1) the dependence of the “fictive” (or “structural”) temperature T_f(q^?) introduced by Tool, on the cooling rate q^? and (2) the dependence of the glass transition temperature T_g on the heating rate q⁺. In this way the value x = 0.47 was obtained for the dimensionless parameter proposed by Narayanaswamy.     

Retardation and relaxation behaviour of poly (ether-block-amide)s (PEBA) copolymers by thermally stimulated creep (TSCr) and current (TSCu)

The retardation and relaxation behaviour of poly(ether-block-amide)s PEBA copolymers was investigated as a function of hard polyamide sequence length by using thermally stimulated creep (TSCr) and Current (TSCu). Two primary TSCr and TSCu peaks, called ß_PE and ß_PA were observed in the temperature range 150–300 K. The “low temperature” peak ß_PE was characterized by a peak position T ß_PE which depends poorly upon hard segment content as the corresponding DSC glass transition temperature Tg_PE. The peak position Tß_PA of the “high temperature” relaxation showed a progressive shift towards higher temperatures as the hard segment average length was increased as it is observed in series of pure polyamide oligomers. So, complex spectra suggest that an amorphous phase separation occurs in PEBA copolymers. The TSCr ß_PE and ß_PA modes were analysed by thermal sampling method (TS). The elementary TSCr processes isolated in the ß_PE and ß_PA distributed retardation modes were characterized by retardation times following a compensation law. The comparison of activation and compensation parameters confirmed the existence of a biphasic amorphous phase in PEBA. In TSCr spectra, an additional peak, noted α, is observed at a temperature close to the DSC melting point T_mPE of the poly(tetramethylene glycol) segments.