Instrumental validation in capillary electrophoresis and checkpoints for method validation

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) is increasingly being used in regulated and testing environments which demand validation. The design, development and production of CE instrumentation should be governed by qualifications which ensure the quality of the finished product. The vendor should therefore provide guidelines and procedures which assist the user in ensuring the adequate operation of the instrumentation and especially in designing installation qualification (IQ) and operational qualification/performance verification (OQ/PV) procedures. OQ/PV should test those functions of an instrument which directly affect the CE analysis, i.e. voltage, temperature, injection precision and detector function. In validation of CE methods care should be taken that those aspects which directly affect the precision of peak parameters are appreciated. The relationship between CE instrumentation, chemistry and validation parameters is discussed and guidelines are presented for definition of a CE method for submission to regulatory authorities.     

Recent Trends in Validation of Bioanalytical Methods

Abstract

The assessment of the quality levels of pharmaceutical formulations is done through various validation parameters. Validation of these analytical test procedures is the process by which it is established that the test methods meet the requirements for the intended analytical application. The validation criterion also applies to bioanalytical methods used for non‐human pharmacology/toxicology studies and preclinical studies. Bioanalytical method validation includes all the procedures, which demonstrate that a particular method used for quantitative measurement of analytes in a given biological matrix, such as blood, plasma, serum, or urine, is reliable and reproducible for the intended use.     

Ruggedness testing in analytical chemistry

Very high standards of accuracy and precision are currently expected from analytical methods. This is particularly true for pharmaceutical applications, due not only to the potential toxicity of drugs but also to the strict controls of regulatory bodies. This paper deals with the validation of methods by testing ruggedness to changes in the analytical method conditions. As a ruggedness test examines a number of variables simultaneously and hence a large experimental response surface, the design has to be carefully chosen. Advice is offered on the test design, including the selection of factors and the levels at which to test them. Some results are shown for high-performance liquid chromatography methods.     

Validation of a computer program for atomic absorption analysis

 The approach to validation of a computer program for an analytical instrument as a component of the analytical method (using this instrument with the program) is discussed. This approach was used for validating a new program for atomic absorption analysis. The validation plan derived from this approach was based on minimising the influence of all steps of the analytical procedure on the analytical results obtained by the method. In this way significant changes in the results may be caused only by replacement of the previous program by the new one. The positive validation conclusion was based on the comparison of the results of the analysis of suitable reference materials obtained with the new program and with its precursor in the same conditions, and also on comparison of their deviations from the accepted reference values for these materials, with the corresponding uncertainties. Received: 25 January 1997 Accepted: 14 March 1997     

Selectivity and specificity in analytical chemistry. General considerations and attempt of a definition and quantification

Selectivity and specificity are performance characteristics of analytical methods which are frequently used in analytical literature. In general, the terms are applied verbally and a quantification of selectivity and specificity is given rarely. Excepted are methods like chromatography and ISE sensoring which use individual quantities such as selectivity coefficients, indices and other parameters to characterize analytical procedures and systems. Here a proposal is given to characterize selectivity and specificity quantitatively by relative values in a range of 0 to 1 expressing so a certain degree of selectivity and specificity. By examples it will be shown that the derived quantities characterize analytical methods and problems in a plausible way.     

Selectivity and specificity in analytical chemistry. General considerations and attempt of a definition and quantification

Selectivity and specificity are performance characteristics of analytical methods which are frequently used in analytical literature. In general, the terms are applied verbally and a quantification of selectivity and specificity is given rarely. Excepted are methods like chromatography and ISE sensoring which use individual quantities such as selectivity coefficients, indices and other parameters to characterize analytical procedures and systems. Here a proposal is given to characterize selectivity and specificity quantitatively by relative values in a range of 0 to 1 expressing so a certain degree of selectivity and specificity. By examples it will be shown that the derived quantities characterize analytical methods and problems in a plausible way.     

Rapid determination of lithium in serum samples by capillary electrophoresis

Lithium salts are still one of the most popular therapeutic approaches to the treatment of bipolar disorders, notwithstanding the introduction of more modern, less toxic drugs. Because of a narrow therapeutic range, lithium serum concentrations must be strictly monitored during the treatment to avoid life-threatening neurotoxicity. For this purpose, methods based on flame photometry or ion-selective electrodes are usually applied. The aim of the present work was to develop and validate a simple method for the determination of lithium in serum based on capillary zone electrophoresis with indirect detection. A validation of the method was carried out, including a comparison with an automated routine method based on ion-selective electrodes.     

Validation of analytical methods involved in dissolution assays: Acceptance limits and decision methodologies

Dissolution tests are key elements to ensure continuing product quality and performance. The ultimate goal of these tests is to assure consistent product quality within a defined set of specification criteria. Validation of an analytical method aimed at assessing the dissolution profile of products or at verifying pharmacopoeias compliance should demonstrate that this analytical method is able to correctly declare two dissolution profiles as similar or drug products as compliant with respect to their specifications. It is essential to ensure that these analytical methods are fit for their purpose. Method validation is aimed at providing this guarantee. However, even in the ICHQ2 guideline there is no information explaining how to decide whether the method under validation is valid for its final purpose or not. Are the entire validation criterion needed to ensure that a Quality Control (QC) analytical method for dissolution test is valid? What acceptance limits should be set on these criteria? How to decide about method's validity? These are the questions that this work aims at answering. Focus is made to comply with the current implementation of the Quality by Design (QbD) principles in the pharmaceutical industry in order to allow to correctly defining the Analytical Target Profile (ATP) of analytical methods involved in dissolution tests. Analytical method validation is then the natural demonstration that the developed methods are fit for their intended purpose and is not any more the inconsiderate checklist validation approach still generally performed to complete the filing required to obtain product marketing authorization.     

Automation and validation of HPLC-systems

Summary The automation of chromatographic systems is of increasing interest to industry and research laboratories in routine applications. Besides potentially saving time or making better use of available instrumentation, automation also improves the quality of results by producing more precise and more reproducible HPLC data. The need for the validation of methods and qualification of instruments is increasingly recognised in order to ensure compliance with legal requirements (e.g. in the pharmaceutical industry) and to ensure the reliability of analytical results. Possibilities and requirements for automated HPLC systems are elaborated. Emphasis is placed on defining the goals of validation and on discussing different aspects of the validation of LC methods, system suitability tests, ruggedness of methods and the transfer of LC methods from laboratory to laboratory. Adequate strategies of HPLC method development provide very useful information on the validation and ruggedness of LC methods.     

Use of the Eurachem guide on method validation for determination of uranium in environmental samples

Three analytical methods for determination of uranium in environmental samples by a fluorescence technique have been validated and compared in accordance with the Eurachem Guide on method validation. The first method depends on uranium separation from iron using the mercury anode technique; in the other two methods uranium is separated from iron on an anion exchange column by use of either a solution of hydrochloric acid containing ascorbic acid and hydrazine hydrate or a dilute sulfuric acid solution. Detection limits, repeatability, reproducibility, and recovery coefficient were the main validation characteristics. The results showed that better statistical values can be achieved by using the third method. Control charts for in-house control samples and international intercomparison samples have also shown that the third method is more statistically stable with time. In addition, uncertainties of measurement were estimated and compared for the three methods. It was found that the Eurachem Guide and comparison of quality statistical validation data can be good tools for selection of the appropriate method for an application.     

Production and stability testing of incurred reference materials for the anabolic steroid trenbolone in bovine urine.

The production of stable reference materials with incurred residues of veterinary drugs is necessary for the validation of methods of analysis, including the determination of critical performance characteristics. A reference material for trenbolone in bovine urine was produced and the long-term stability was tested. From a pilot 16 week stability study on seven batches containing different additives it was concluded that the use of preservatives does not improve the stability of the residue. A final batch of reference material of 800 vials each containing 5 ml of urine with a target concentration of 5 micrograms l-1 was prepared. The homogeneity and long-term stability of the material were tested. The material was found to be homogeneous. Based on the results of a 52 week stability study it was concluded that the material is stable, using the current analytical methodology. For the development of reference materials, highly accurate and precise analytical methods are necessary. However, the current analytical methodology is not suitable for full evaluation and certification. Currently, a new LC-MS method is being developed. After validation of this method, the stability and homogeneity study will be repeated.     

Signal processing techniques in analytical instruments

Signal processing is a unifying principle useful in understanding the operation of analytical instrumentation. Through it new modes of operation may be found for existing analytical methods and entirely new methods may be discovered.     

Development and application of a fully automated,battery-operated,computerized field-based fluoride monitor

An automated, portable, battery-operated, computerized field-based monitor for the determination of fluoride based on the use of ion-selective electrode (ISE) potentiometry has been developed with the aid of low-powered complementary metal oxide semiconductor (CMOS) devices. The whole analytical cycle involving the rinsing of the cell, sampling, stirring, dosing of standards to the sample and data acquisition and manipulation is under microprocessor control. The modular instrument consists of pumps, valves, a flow-through cell containing a reference electrode, a fluoride ISE, a temperature probe and a stirrer, a microprocessor with a real-time clock, a pump-valve-stirrer interface, a portable terminal and a 12-V lead-acid battery to power all the instrumentation. The software for the application and monitoring functions for the instrument is written at assembler level and programmed into a CMOS erasable programmable read only memory (EPROM). The instrument is currently designed to determine fluoride in natural and fluoridated waters and is based on a double standard addition method, although the monitor can be modified easily to suit other appropriate ISE systems. Instrumental performance was evaluated with synthetic and real water samples both in the batch and continuous modes. The monitor can be used to carry out on-line fluoride determinations of water samples continuously for 1 week without anyone being attendance.     

A long-term validation of the modernised DC-ARC-OES solid-sample method

The validation procedure based on ISO 17025 standard has been used to study and illustrate both the longterm stability of the calibration process of the DC-ARC solid sample spectrometric method and the main validation criteria of the method. In the calculation of the validation characteristics depending on the linearity(calibration), also the fulfilment of predetermining criteria such as normality and homoscedasticity was checked. In order to decide whether there are any trends in the time-variation of the analytical signal or not, also the Neumann test of trend was applied and evaluated. Finally, a comparison with similar validation data of the ETV-ICP-OES method was carried out.     

Applications of Thermal Analysis and Coupled Techniques in Pharmaceutical Industry

Thermal analysis methods are well-established techniques in research laboratories of pharmaceutical industry. The robustness and sensitivity of instrumentation, the introduction of automation and of reliable software according to the industrial needs widened considerably the areas of applications in the last decade. Calibration of instruments and validation of results follow the state of the art of cGMP as for other analytical techniques. Thermal analysis techniques are especially useful for the study of the behavior of the poly-phasic systems drug substances and excipients and find a unique place for new delivery systems. Since change of temperature and moisture occur by processing and storage, changes of the solid state may have a considerable effect on activity, toxicity and stability of compounds. Current requirements of the International Conference of Harmonisation for the characterization and the quantitation of polymorphism in new entities re-enforce the position of thermal analysis techniques. This challenging task needs the use of complementary methods. Combined techniques and microcalorimetry demonstrate their advantages. This article reviews the current use of thermal analysis and combined techniques in research and development and in production. The advantage of commercially coupled techniques to thermogravimetry is emphasized with some examples. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Determination of analytical limits in solid sampling ETAAS: a new approach towards the characterization of analytical quality in rapid methods

In the present study the lower analytical limits of solid sampling electrothermal atomization atomic absorption spectrometry (SS-ETAAS) were characterized by means of blank measurements and – for the first time – by means of the calibration curve method, where a calibration near the range of these limits (limit of decision, detection and quantification) was performed. The limit of decision as derived from blank measurements was calculated according to the 3σ-criterion to be 0.003 and 0.019 ng for Cd and Pb, respectively. For Pb and Cd a roughly threefold increase of these limits was observed when the calibration method according to DIN 32 645 was applied. When solid reference material was used, only a slight increase could be observed. The analytical limits were 2 to 20 times lower than reported for sample decomposition methods. The blank measurement and conventional calibration curve method, however, do not account for factors relating to solid sampling such as sample mass and matrix. Therefore, the calibration curve model was applied to data derived from comparisons between direct solid sampling ETAAS and a compound reference method (ETAAS following sample homogenization and digestion). The observed analytical limits were not found to be substantially increased if enough samples with low element contents were available for calibration. Coupling of the calibration curve model with the comparison of methods included real test samples and thus the relevant maximum sample mass and analyte content in the range of the lower analytical limits. As validation procedures frequently include comparisons of methods, the present approach might prove to be of some general interest for the characterization of analytical quality in rapid methods.     

Determination of analytical limits in solid sampling ETAAS: a new approach towards the characterization of analytical quality in rapid methods

In the present study the lower analytical limits of solid sampling electrothermal atomization atomic absorption spectrometry (SS-ETAAS) were characterized by means of blank measurements and--for the first time--by means of the calibration curve method, where a calibration near the range of these limits (limit of decision, detection and quantification) was performed. The limit of decision as derived from blank measurements was calculated according to the 3sigma-criterion to be 0.003 and 0.019 ng for Cd and Pb, respectively. For Pb and Cd a roughly three-fold increase of these limits was observed when the calibration method according to DIN 32 645 was applied. When solid reference material was used, only a slight increase could be observed. The analytical limits were 2 to 20 times lower than reported for sample decomposition methods. The blank measurement and conventional calibration curve method, however, do not account for factors relating to solid sampling such as sample mass and matrix. Therefore, the calibration curve model was applied to data derived from comparisons between direct solid sampling ETAAS and a compound reference method (ETAAS following sample homogenization and digestion). The observed analytical limits were not found to be substantially increased if enough samples with low element contents were available for calibration. Coupling of the calibration curve model with the comparison of methods included real test samples and thus the relevant maximum sample mass and analyte content in the range of the lower analytical limits. As validation procedures frequently include comparisons of methods, the present approach might prove to be of some general interest for the characterization of analytical quality in rapid methods.     

化学分析方法验证和确认的应用研究

分析方法的验证/确认是实验室引进新方法时必做的工作,也是实验室技术工作的重点和难点之一。对实验室采用分析方法的验证和确认工作进行归纳总结,详述了分析方法选择性、测量范围、线性范围、检出限和定量限、精密度、准确度的验证/确认方法及结果判定方式。适用于实验室引进的标准方法(包括标准变更)和非标准方法(实验室设计/制定的方法、超出预定范围使用的标准方法、扩充和修改过的标准方法)的验证和确认。     

Determination of furosine in food products by capillary zone electrophoresis-tandem mass spectrometry

A new method for qualitative and quantitative analysis of furosine in food products by capillary electrophoresis coupled to tandem mass spectrometry (CE-MS(2) ) has been optimized and validated. In analytical conditions, the pH value of the run buffer was similar to that of the hydrolyzed samples, which helps in avoiding interactions of the analyte with silanol groups of the inner wall of the fused silica capillary. In all previous CE methods proposed in literature, no SPE treatment has been used. The method has been applied to the analysis of food products, such as flour, having low amounts of furosine. Flour samples of different origin (wheat, chestnut, lupin, einkorn, chickpeas) have been investigated. Different food products such as pasta, milk, and tigelle bread (a typical Italian unleavened bread) were also analyzed. Some of the samples have also been analyzed by reversed-phase HPLC, and when compared to CE-MS, data obtained showed good agreement. CE-MS, in comparison to HPLC, showed advantages in terms of time of analysis and cost. The validation procedure provided good values for LOD and LOQ (respectively 0.07 and 0.25 mg L(-1) ), recovery (77 and 97%), and precision investigated in terms of intraday repeatability (RSD%: 4-6% for peak areas; 1-2% for migration times) and intermediate precision (below 16% for peak areas, and below 7% for migration times). Therefore, the technique reported can be proposed as a powerful analytical method and a valid alternative to common traditional analytical techniques.