Ab initio and analytic intermolecular potentials for Ar-CF4

Ab initio calculations at the CCSD(T) level of theory were performed to characterize the Ar + CF4 intermolecular potential. Potential energy curves were calculated with the aug-cc-pVTZ basis set, and with and without a correction for basis set superposition error (BSSE). Additional calculations were performed with other correlation consistent basis sets to extrapolate the Ar-CF4 potential energy minimum to the complete basis set (CBS) limit. Both the size of the basis set and BSSE have substantial effects on the Ar + CF4 potential. Calculations with the aug-cc-pVTZ basis set, and with a BSSE correction, appear to give a good representation of the BSSE corrected potential at the CBS limit. In addition, MP2 theory is found to give potential energies in very good agreement with those determined by the much higher level CCSD(T) theory. Two model analytic potential energy functions were determined for Ar + CF4. One is a fit to the aug-cc-pVTZ calculations with a BSSE correction. The second was derived by fitting an average BSSE corrected potential, which is an average of the CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ potentials with and without a BSSE correction. These analytic functions are written as a sum of two-body potentials and excellent fits to the ab initio potentials are obtained by representing each two-body interaction as a Buckingham potential.     

A theoretical study of nonlinearity in heterocyclic hydrogen-bonded complexes

Ab initio calculations are performed at the MP2/6-311++G(d,p) and DFT/B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) theoretical levels to obtain geometries, H-bond energies and harmonic infrared vibrational properties for the Cs symmetry structures of heterocyclic hydrogen-bonded complexes, CnHmY-HX. The H-bond lengths in DFT/B3LYP calculation level are in better agreement with the experimental values than the MP2 results. The geometry optimization are interpreted in terms of hydrogen bond nonlinearity represented by theta; and phi angles, once the hydrogen bond is formed among n-electrons pairs of the heteroatom in heterocyclic and the hydrogen atom in HX. The hydrogen bond energy after of the zero-point vibrational energy (ZPE) and basis set superposition error (BSSE) corrections are overestimated at DFT/B3LYP, whereas the MP2 BSSE corrections are very large than corresponding DFT/B3LYP. For example, the BSSE corrections for the C2H4S-HNC complex are 7.60 and 0.09 kJ mol(-1) in MP2 and DFT/B3LYP calculations levels, respectively. The new vibrational modes in infrared harmonic spectrum arising from complexation show several interesting features, especially the intermolecular stretching mode.     

Theoretical study on intermolecular interaction of epoxyethane dimer

Ab initio calculations at Hartree–Fock and fourth‐order Mø ller–Plesset (MP4) correlation correction levels with 6‐31G* basis set have been performed on the epoxyethane dimer. Dimer binding energies have been corrected for the basis set superposition error (BSSE) and the zero‐point energy. The greatest corrected dimer binding energy is −8.36 kJ/mol at the MP4/6‐31G*//HF/6‐31G* level. The natural bond orbital analysis has been performed to trace the origin of the weak interactions that stabilize dimer. © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 78: 94–98, 2000     

Intermolecular potential for thermal H2O-He collisions

Theoretical potentials for rotational excitation of H2O by He were constructed via several methods, all of which start with a large basis set SCF interaction. The semiempirical Hartree-Fock with damped dispersion (HFD) model adds a damped long-range attraction with parameters adjusted to fit experimental total differential cross sections. Purely ab initio potentials add correlation energies obtained via perturbation theory (MP2 and MP4) or a variational method (ICF1). Scattering calculations were performed on all surfaces to compare with available beam scattering and pressure broadening data and to assess sensitivity of state-to-state rates to uncertainties in the potential. From comparison with the limited experimental data, the ICF1 surface appears to be marginally better than the MP4 surface. Thermal rates calculated from this surface should be accurate to better than 50%, at least for the larger, more important rates.     

Rapid evaluation of the binding energies between peptide amide and DNA base

The binding energies and the equilibrium hydrogen bond distances as well as the potential energy curves of 20 hydrogen‐bonded amide–base dimers are evaluated from the analytic potential energy function established in our laboratory recently. The analytic potential energy function is used to calculate the N? H···N, N? H···O?C, C? H···N, and C? H···O?C dipole–dipole attractive interaction energies and C?O···O?C, N? H···H? N, and N? H···H? C dipole–dipole repulsive interaction energies in the 20 dimers composed of DNA bases adenine, guanine, cytosine, or thymine and peptide amide. The calculation results show that the potential energy curves obtained from the analytic potential energy function are in good agreement with those obtained from MP2/6‐311+G** calculations by including the basis set superposition error (BSSE) correction. For all the 20 dimers, the analytic potential energy function yields the binding energies of the MP2/6‐311+G** with BSSE correction within the error limits of 0.50 kcal/mol for 19 dimers, only one difference is larger than 0.50 kcal/mol and the difference is only 0.61 kcal/mol. The analytic potential energy function produces the equilibrium hydrogen bond distances of the MP2/6‐311+G** with BSSE correction within the error limits of 0.030 Å for all the 20 dimers. The analytic potential energy function is further applied to four more complicated DNA base‐peptide amide systems involving amino acid side chain and β‐sheet. The values of the binding energies and equilibrium hydrogen bond distances obtained from the analytic potential energy function are also in good agreement with those obtained from MP2 calculations with the BSSE correction. These results demonstrate that the analytic potential energy function can be used to evaluate the binding energies in hydrogen‐bonded peptide amide–DNA base dimers quickly and accurately. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Comput Chem, 2011     

Comparison of basis set superposition error corrected perturbation theories for calculating intermolecular interaction energies

Recently, two different but conceptually similar basis set superposition error (BSSE) free second‐order perturbation theoretical schemes were developed by us that are being based on the chemical Hamiltonian approach (CHA). Using these CHA‐MP2 and CHA‐PT2 methods, a comparison is made between the a posteriori and a priori BSSE correction schemes at the correlated level. Sample calculations are presented for four hydrogen bonded complexes (HFH₃N, HFH₂O, H₂SHF, and H₂OHCl) in nine different basis sets (from 6–31G to TZV**++). The results show that the BSSE content is very significant in the interaction energy if electron correlation is accounted for, so removing the BSSE is very important. The differences of the two perturbational theories discussed are connected solely with the different one electron orbital sets used for building up the unperturbed single determinant wave function. ©1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Comput Chem 20: 274–283, 1999     

Is spin-component scaled second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory an appropriate method for the study of noncovalent interactions in molecules?

Testing of the spin-component scaled second-order M?ller-Plesset (SCS-MP2) method for the computation of noncovalent interaction energies is done with a database of 165 biologically relevant complexes. The effects of the spin-scaling procedure (i.e., MP2 vs SCS-MP2), the basis set size, and the corrections for basis set superposition error (BSSE) are systematically examined. When using two-point basis set extrapolations for the correlation energy, augmentation of the atomic orbital basis with computationally costly diffuse functions is found to be obsolete. In general, SCS-MP2 also improves results for noncovalent interactions statistically on MP2, and significant outliers are removed. Moreover, it is shown that effects of BSSE and one-particle basis set incompleteness almost cancel each other in the case of triple-zeta sets (SCS-MP2/TZVPP or SCS-MP2/cc-pVTZ without counterpoise correction), which opens a practical route to efficient computations for large systems. We recommend SCS-MP2 as the preferred quantum chemical wave function based method for the noncovalent interactions in large biologically relevant systems when reasonable coupled-cluster with single and double and perturbative triple excitations (CCSD(T)) calculations cannot be performed anymore. A comparison to MP2 and CCSD(T) interaction energies for n-alkane dimers, however, indicates (and this also holds to a lesser extent for hydrogen-bonded systems) limitations of SCS-MP2 when treating chemically "saturated" interactions. The different behavior of second-order perturbation theory for saturated and for stacked pi-systems is discussed.     

A scheme for rapid prediction of cooperativity in hydrogen bond chains of formamides,acetamides, and N‐methylformamides

A scheme is proposed in this article to predict the cooperativity in hydrogen bond chains of formamides, acetamides, and N‐methylformamides. The parameters needed in the scheme are derived from fitting to the hydrogen bonding energies of MP2/6‐31+G** with basis set superposition error (BSSE) correction of the hydrogen bond chains of formamides containing from two to eight monomeric units. The scheme is then used to calculate the individual hydrogen bonding energies in the chains of formamides containing 9 and 12 monomeric units, in the chains of acetamides containing from two to seven monomeric units, in the chains of N‐methylformamides containing from two to seven monomeric units. The calculation results show that the cooperativity predicted by the scheme proposed in this paper is in good agreement with those obtained from MP2/6‐31+G** calculations by including the BSSE correction, demonstrating that the scheme proposed in this article is reasonable. Based on our scheme, a cooperativity effect of almost 240% of the dimer hydrogen bonding energy in long hydrogen bond formamide chains, a cooperativity effect of almost 190% of the dimer hydrogen bonding energy in long hydrogen bond acetamide chains, and a cooperativity effect of almost 210% of the dimer hydrogen bonding energy in long hydrogen bond N‐methylformamide chains are predicted. The scheme is further applied to some heterogeneous chains containing formamide, acetamide, and N‐methylformamide. The individual hydrogen bonding energies in these heterogeneous chains predicted by our scheme are also in good agreement with those obtained from Møller‐Plesset calculations including BSSE correction. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Comput Chem, 2010     

Ab initio study on adsorption of hydrated Na+ and Cu+ cations on the Cu(111) surface

The interactions of Na+ and Cu+ cations with a Cu(111) surface in the presence and absence of water molecules were investigated using cluster models and ab initio methods. Adsorption in aqueous solution was modeled with one to five water molecules around the adsorbing cation. The Cu surface was described with Cu10 and Cu18 cluster models and the computational method was MP2/RECP/6-31+G. The effect of the basis set superposition error (BSSE) was taken into account with counterpoise (CP) correction, and the accuracy of HF-level results was examined. The interactions between Na+ and the Cu surface were found to be primarily electrostatic, and the energy differences among the different adsorption sites were small. The largest CP-corrected MP2 adsorption energy for the Cu18 cluster was -188 kJ/mol. When water molecules were added around it, Na+ receded from the Cu surface and finally was surrounded totally by the water molecules. The interactions between Cu+ and the Cu surface were dominated by orbital interactions, and Cu+ preferred to adsorb on sites where it could bind to more than one surface atom. The largest CP-corrected MP2 adsorption energy for the Cu18 cluster was -447 kJ/mol. Adding water molecules around it did not cause Cu+ to draw away from the surface, but instead the water molecules began to form hydrogen bonds with one another. The magnitude of BSSE was substantial in most cases. CP corrections did not, however, have a significant impact on the relative trends among the interaction energies.     

Rapid evaluation of the binding energies in hydrogen-bonded amide-thymine and amide-uracil dimers in gas phase

The binding energies and the equilibrium hydrogen bond distances as well as the potential energy curves of 48 hydrogen‐bonded amide–thymine and amide–uracil dimers are evaluated from the analytic potential energy function established in our lab recently. The calculation results show that the potential energy curves obtained from the analytic potential energy function are in good agreement with those obtained from MP2/6‐311+G** calculations by including the BSSE correction. For all the 48 dimers, the analytic potential energy function yields the binding energies of the MP2/6‐311+G** with BSSE correction within the error limits of 0.50 kcal/mol for 46 dimers, only two differences are larger than 0.50 kcal/mol and the largest one is only 0.60 kcal/mol. The analytic potential energy function produces the equilibrium hydrogen bond distances of the MP2/6‐311+G** with BSSE correction within the error limits of 0.050 Å for all the 48 dimers. The analytic potential energy function is further applied to four more complicated hydrogen‐bonded amide–base systems involving amino acid side chain and β‐sheet. The values of the binding energies and equilibrium hydrogen bond distances obtained from the analytic potential energy function are also in good agreement with those obtained from MP2 calculations with the BSSE correction. These results demonstrate that the analytic potential energy function can be used to evaluate the binding energies in hydrogen‐bonded amide–base dimers quickly and accurately. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Comput Chem, 2011     

Counterpoise correction is not useful for short and Van der Waals distances but may be useful at long range

This article investigates the errors in supermolecule calculations for the helium dimer. In a full CI calculation, there are two errors. One is the basis set superposition error (BSSE), the other is the basis set convergence error (BSCE). Both of the errors arise from the incompleteness of the basis set. These two errors make opposite contributions to the interaction energies. The BSCE is by far the largest error in the short range and larger than (but much closer to) BSSE around the Van der Waals minimum. Only at the long range, the BSSE becomes the larger error. The BSCE and BSSE largely cancel each other over the Van der Waals well. Accordingly, it may be recommended to not include the BSSE for the calculation of the potential energy curve from short distance till well beyond the Van der Waals minimum, but it may be recommended to include the BSSE correction if an accurate tail behavior is required. Only if the calculation has used a very large basis set, one can refrain from including the counterpoise correction in the full potential range. These results are based on full CI calculations with the aug-cc-pVXZ (X = D, T, Q, 5) basis sets.     

Bond functions,covalent potential curves,and the basis set superposition error

In the current practice of quantum chemistry, it is not clear whether corrections for basis set superposition errors should be applied to the calculation of potential energy curves, in order to improve agreement with experimental data. To examine this question, spectroscopic parameters derived from theoretical potential curves are reported for the homonuclear diatomics C₂, N₂, O₂, and F₂, using a configuration interaction method. Three different basis sets were used, including double zeta plus polarization, triple zeta plus double polarization, and double zeta polarization augmented by bond functions. The bond function basis sets, which were optimized in the preceding paper to obtain accurate dissociation energies, also gave the most accurate parameters. The potential curves were then corrected for basis set superposition error using the counterpoise correction, and the spectroscopic parameters were computed again. The BSSE-corrected curves showed worse agreement with experiment for all properties than the original (uncorrected) curves. The reasons for this finding are discussed. In addition to the numerical results, some problems in the application of the BSSE correction to basis sets containing bond functions are shown. In particular, there is an overcounting of the lowering due to the bond functions, regardless of which type of correction is applied. Also, genuine BSSE affects cannot be separated from energy-lowering effects due to basis set incompleteness, and we postulate that it is the latter which is strongly dominant in the calculation of covalent potential curves. Based on these arguments, two conclusions follow: (1) application of BSSE corrections to potential curves should not be routinely applied in situations where the bonding is strong, and (2) appropriate use of bond functions can lead to systematic improvement in the quality of potential curves.     

Comparison of the intermolecular energy surfaces of amino acids: orientation-dependent chiral discrimination

In the present work, we compare the intermolecular energy surfaces of the alanine molecule in its neutral and zwitterionic state using ab initio theory (HF/6-311++G) as a function of mutual orientation. Starting from the optimized structures of the nonbonded homochiral (l-l) and heterochiral (d-l) pairs of molecules, the energy surfaces are studied with rigid geometry by varying the distance and orientation. The potential energy surfaces of the l-l and d-l pairs are found to be dissimilar and reflect the underlying chirality of the homochiral pair and racemic nature of the heterochiral pair. The intermolecular energy surface of the l-l pair is more favorable than the corresponding energy surface of the d-l pair. The study, for the first time, reveals clear homochiral preference without use of parameters, which was unobserved in previous detailed simulations but predicted by theory. The electrostatic interaction further augments the chiral discrimination. The basis set superposition error (BSSE) corrected results show enhanced discrimination. Use of higher-level M?ller-Plesset perturbation theory (MP2) and further BSSE correction do not change the conclusions made at the Hartree-Fock (HF) level. The major conclusions based on HF and MP2 level calculations remain unaltered when the calculations of the potential energy surfaces for the neutral and zwitterionic pairs are repeated using the density functional theory (DFT) (B3LYP/6-311++G). The observed orientation dependence has significance in the biological chiral recognition as well as peptide synthesis at the peptidyl transferase center where the amino terminal and peptidyl terminal undergo mutual rotatory motion.     

Correlated ab initio quantum chemical calculations of di- and trisaccharide conformations

High level correlated quantum chemical calculations, using MP2 and local MP2 theory, have been performed for conformations of the disaccharide, beta-maltose, and the trisaccharide, 3,6-di-O-(alpha-D-mannopyranosyl)-alpha-D-mannopyranose. For beta-maltose, MP2 and local MP2 calculations using the 6-311++G** basis set are in good agreement, predicting a global minimum gas-phase conformation with a counterclockwise hydrogen bond network and the experimentally-observed intersaccharide hydrogen bonding arrangement. For conformations of 3,6-di-O-(alpha-D-mannopyranosyl)-alpha-D-mannopyranose, MP2/6-311++G**, and local MP2/6-311++G** calculations do not provide a consensus prediction of relative energetics, with the MP2 method finding large differences in stability between extended and folded trisaccharide conformations. Local MP2 calculations, less susceptible to intramolecular basis set superposition errors, predict a narrower range of trisaccharide energetics, in line with estimates from Hartree-Fock theory and B3LYP and BP86 density functionals. All levels of theory predict compact, highly hydrogen-bonded conformations as lowest in energy on the in vacuo potential energy surface of the trisaccharide. These high level, correlated local MP2/6-311++G** calculations of di- and trisaccharide energetics constitute potential reference data in the development and testing of improved empirical and semiempirical potentials for modeling of carbohydrates in the condensed phase.     

Calculation of intermolecular interactions in the benzene dimer using coupled-cluster and local electron correlation methods

Potential energy curves for the parallel-displaced, T-shaped and sandwich structures of the benzene dimer are computed with density fitted local second-order M?ller-Plesset perturbation theory (DF-LMP2) as well as with the spin-component scaled (SCS) variant of DF-LMP2. While DF-LMP2 strongly overestimates the dispersion interaction, in common with canonical MP2, the DF-SCS-LMP2 interaction energies are in excellent agreement with the best available literature values along the entire potential energy curves. The DF-SCS-LMP2 dissociation energies for the three structures are also compared with new complete basis set estimates of the interaction energies obtained from accurate coupled cluster (CCSD(T)) and DF-SCS-MP2 calculations. Since LMP2 is essentially free of basis set superposition errors, counterpoise corrections are not required. As a result, DF-SCS-LMP2 is computationally inexpensive and represents an attractive method for the study of larger pi-stacked systems such as truncated sections of DNA.     

Evaluation of the intramolecular basis set superposition error in the calculations of larger molecules: [n]helicenes and Phe-Gly-Phe tripeptide

Correlated ab initio calculations on large systems, such as the popular MP2 (or RI-MP2) method, suffer from the intramolecular basis set superposition error (BSSE). This error is typically manifested in molecules with folded structures, characterized by intramolecular dispersion interactions. It can dramatically affect the energy differences between various conformers as well as intramolecular stabilities, and it can even impair the accuracy of the predictions of the equilibrium molecular structures. In this study, we will present two extreme cases of intramolecular BSSE, the internal stability of [n]helicene molecules and the relative energies of various conformers of phenylalanyl-glycyl-phenylalanine tripeptide (Phe-Gly-Phe), and compare the calculated data with benchmark values (experimental or high-level theoretical data). As a practical and cheap solution to the accurate treatment of the systems with large anticipated value of intramolecular BSSE, the recently developed density functional method augmented with an empirical dispersion term (DFT-D) is proposed and shown to provide very good results in both of the above described representative cases.     

Comparison of ab initio and DFT electronic structure methods for peptides containing an aromatic ring: effect of dispersion and BSSE

We establish that routine B3LYP and MP2 methods give qualitatively wrong conformations for flexible organic systems containing pi systems and that recently developed methods can overcome the known inadequacies of these methods. This is illustrated for a molecule (a conformer of the Tyr-Gly dipeptide) for which B3LYP/6-31+G(d) and MP2/6-31+G(d) geometry optimizations yield strikingly different structures [Mol. Phys. 2006, 104, 559-570]: MP2 predicts a folded "closed-book" conformer with the glycine residue located above the tyrosine ring, whereas B3LYP predicts a more open conformation. By employing different levels of theory, including the local electron correlation methods LMP2 (local MP2) and LCCSD(T0) (local coupled cluster with single, double, and noniterative local triple excitations) and large basis sets (aug-cc-pVnZ, n=D, T, Q), it is shown that the folded MP2 minimum is an artifact caused by large intramolecular BSSE (basis set superposition error) effects in the MP2/6-31+G(d) calculations. The B3LYP functional gives the correct minimum, but the potential energy apparently rises too steeply when the glycine and tyrosine residues approach each other, presumably due to missing dispersion effects in the B3LYP calculations. The PWB6K and M05-2X functionals, designed to give good results for weak interactions, remedy this to some extent. The reduced BSSE in the LMP2 calculations leads to faster convergence with increasing basis set quality, and accurate results can be obtained with smaller basis sets as compared to canonical MP2. We propose LMP2 as a suitable method to study interactions with pi-electron clouds.     

Ab initio investigation of structure and cohesive energy of crystalline urea

The structure and cohesive energy of crystalline urea have been investigated at the ab initio level of calculation. The performance of different Hamiltonians in dealing with a hydrogen-bonded molecular crystal as crystalline urea is assessed. Detailed calculations carried out by adopting both HF and some of the most popular DFT methods in solid-state chemistry are reported. Local, gradient-corrected, and hybrid functionals have been adopted: SVWN, PW91, PBE, B3LYP, and PBE0. First, a 6-31G(d,p) basis set has been adopted, and then the basis set dependence of computed results has been investigated at the B3LYP level. All calculations were carried out by using a development version of the periodic ab initio code CRYSTAL06, which allows full optimization of lattice parameters and atomic coordinates. With the 6-31G(d,p) basis set, structural features are well reproduced by hybrid methods and GGA. LDA gives lattice parameters and hydrogen-bond distances that are too small relative to experiment, while at the HF level the opposite trend is observed. Results show that hybrid methods are more accurate than HF and both LDA and GGA functionals, with a trend in the computed properties similar to that of hydrogen-bonded molecular complexes. When BSSE and ZPE are taken into account, all methods, except LDA, give computed cohesive energies that are underestimated with respect to the experimental sublimation enthalpy. Dispersion energy, not properly taken into account by DFT methods, plays a crucial role. Such a deficiency also affects dramatically the computed crystalline structure, especially when large basis sets are adopted. We show that this is an artifact due to the BSSE. Indeed, with small basis sets the BSSE gives an extra-binding that compensates for the missing dispersion forces, thus yielding structures in fortuitous agreement with experiment.     

Pi-pi interaction in pyridine

pi-pi Interaction in pyridine dimer and trimer has been investigated in different geometries and orientations at the ab initio (HF, MP2) and DFT (B3LYP) levels of theory using various basis sets (6-31G, 6-31G, 6-311++G) and corrected for basis set superposition error (BSSE). While the HF and DFT calculations show the pyridine dimer and the trimer to be unstable with respect to the monomer, the MP2 calculations show them to be clearly stable, thus emphasizing the need to include electron correlation while determining stacking interaction in such systems. The calculated MP2/6-311++G binding energy (100% BSSE corrected) of the parallel-sandwich, antiparallel-sandwich, parallel-displaced, antiparallel-displaced, T-up and T-down geometries for pyridine dimer are 1.53, 3.05, 2.39, 3.97, 1.91, 1.47 kcal/mol, respectively. The results show the antiparallel-displaced geometry to be the most stable. The binding energies for the trimer in parallel-sandwich, antiparallel-sandwich, and antiparallel-displaced geometry are found to be 3.18, 6.14, and 8.04 kcal/mol, respectively.     

Accurate ab initio binding energies of alkaline earth metal clusters

The effects of basis set superposition error (BSSE) and core-correlation on the electronic binding energies of alkaline earth metal clusters Y(n) (Y = Be, Mg, Ca; n = 2-4) at the Moller-Plesset second-order perturbation theory (MP2) and the single and double coupled cluster method with perturbative triples correction (CCSD(T)) levels are examined using the correlation consistent basis sets cc-pVXZ and cc-pCVXZ (X = D, T, Q, 5). It is found that, while BSSE has a negligible effect for valence-electron-only-correlated calculations for most basis sets, its magnitude becomes more pronounced for all-electron-correlated calculations, including core electrons. By utilizing the negligible effect of BSSE on the binding energies for valence-electron-only-correlated calculations, in combination with the negligible core-correlation effect at the CCSD(T) level, accurate binding energies of these clusters up to pentamers (octamers in the case of the Be clusters) are estimated via the basis set extrapolation of ab initio CCSD(T) correlation energies of the monomer and cluster with only the cc-pVDZ and cc-pVTZ sets, using the basis set and correlation-dependent extrapolation formula recently devised. A comparison between the CCSD(T) and density functional theory (DFT) binding energies is made to identify the most appropriate DFT method for the study of these clusters.