Multi‐Stimuli‐Responsive Polymer Materials: Particles,Films, and Bulk Gels

Stimuli‐responsive polymers have received tremendous attention from scientists and engineers for several decades due to the wide applications of these smart materials in biotechnology and nanotechnology. Driven by the complex functions of living systems, multi‐stimuli‐responsive polymer materials have been designed and developed in recent years. Compared with conventional single‐ or dual‐stimuli‐based polymer materials, multi‐stimuli‐responsive polymer materials would be more intriguing since more functions and finer modulations can be achieved through more parameters. This critical review highlights the recent advances in this area and focuses on three types of multi‐stimuli‐responsive polymer materials, namely, multi‐stimuli‐responsive particles (micelles, micro/nanogels, vesicles, and hybrid particles), multi‐stimuli‐responsive films (polymer brushes, layer‐by‐layer polymer films, and porous membranes), and multi‐stimuli‐responsive bulk gels (hydrogels, organogels, and metallogels) from recent publications. Various stimuli, such as light, temperature, pH, reduction/oxidation, enzymes, ions, glucose, ultrasound, magnetic fields, mechanical stress, solvent, voltage, and electrochemistry, have been combined to switch the functions of polymers. The polymer design, preparation, and function of multi‐stimuli‐responsive particles, films, and bulk gels are comprehensively discussed here.     

Stimulus‐Responsive Metal–Organic Frameworks

Materials that can recognize the changes in their local environment and respond by altering their inherent physical and/or chemical properties are strong candidates for future “smart” technology materials. Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) have attracted a great deal of attention in recent years owing to their designable architecture, host–guest chemistry, and softness as porous materials. Despite this fact, studies on the tuning of the properties of MOFs by external stimuli are still rare. This review highlights the recent developments in the field of stimulus‐responsive MOFs or so‐called smart MOFs. In particular, the various stimuli used and the utility of stimulus‐responsive smart MOFs for various applications such as gas storage and separation, sensing, clean energy, catalysis, molecular motors, and biomedical applications are highlighted by using representative examples. Future directions in the developments of stimulus‐responsive smart MOFs and their applications are proposed from a personal perspective.     

A Multi‐Addressable Switch Based on the Dimethyldihydropyrene Photochrome with Remarkable Proton‐Triggered Photo‐opening Efficiency

A series of photochromic derivatives based on the trans‐10b,10c‐dimethyl‐10b,10c‐dihydropyrene (DHP, “closed form”) skeleton has been synthesized and their photoisomerization leading to the corresponding cyclophanediene (CPD, “open form”) isomers has been investigated by UV/Vis and ¹H NMR spectroscopies. Substitution of the DHP core with electron‐withdrawing pyridinium groups was found to have major effects on the photoisomerization efficiency, the most remarkable examples being to enhance the quantum yield of the opening reaction and to allow fast and quantitative conversions at much lower radiant energies. This effect was rationalized by theoretical calculations. We also show that the reverse reaction, that is, going from the open form to the closed form, can be electrochemically triggered by oxidation of the CPD unit and that the photo‐opening properties of pyridine‐substituted DHPs can be efficiently tuned by protonation, the system behaving as a multi‐addressable molecular switch. These multi‐addressable photochromes show promise for the development of responsive materials.     

Multi‐Stimuli‐Responsive Polymeric Prodrug for Enhanced Cancer Treatment

Accomplishing efficient delivery of a nanomedicine to the tumor site will encounter two contradictions as follows: 1) a contradiction between prolonged circulation time and endocytosis by cancer cells; 2) a dilemma between the stability of nanomedicine during blood circulation and intracellular drug release. While developing a nanomedicine which can solve the above two contradictions simultaneously is still a challenge, here, a multi‐stimuli‐responsive polymeric prodrug (PLys‐co‐(PLys‐DA)‐co‐(PLys‐SS‐PTX))‐b‐PLGLAG‐mPEG (P‐PEP‐SS‐PTX‐DA) is synthesized which is multi‐sensitive to overexpressed matrix metalloproteinase‐2 (MMP‐2), low pH, and high concentration of glutathione in tumors. The P‐PEP‐SS‐PTX‐DA can be dePEGylated and reversed from negative at normal physiological pH to positive charge at tumor extracellular microenvironment; in this way, it can solve the contradiction between prolonged circulation time and endocytosis by cancer cells. Owing to the high reductive conditions in cancer cells, P‐PEP‐SS‐PTX‐DA is ruptured to release paclitaxel (PTX) intracellular efficiently; therefore, it can resolve the dilemma between the stability of nanomedicine during blood circulation and intracellular drug release. These indicate that the multi‐stimuli‐responsive polymeric prodrug has potential application prospects in drug delivery and cancer therapy.     

Multistimuli‐Responsive Supramolecular Organogels Formed by Low‐Molecular‐Weight Peptides Bearing Side‐Chain Azobenzene Moieties

This work demonstrates that the incorporation of azobenzene residues into the side chain of low‐molecular‐weight peptides can modulate their self‐assembly process in organic solvents leading to the formation of stimuli responsive physical organogels. The major driving forces for the gelation process are hydrogen bonding and π–π interactions, which can be triggered either by thermal or ultrasound external stimuli, affording materials having virtually the same properties. In addition, a predictive model for gelation of polar protic solvent was developed by using Kamlet–Taft solvent parameters and experimental data. The obtained viscoelastic materials exhibited interconnected multistimuli responsive behaviors including thermal‐, photo‐, chemo‐ and mechanical responses. All of them displayed thermoreversability with gel‐to‐sol transition temperatures established between 33–80 °C and gelation times from minutes to several hours. Structure–property relationship studies of a designed peptide library have demonstrated that the presence and position of the azobenzene residue can be operated as a versatile regulator to reduce the critical gelation concentration and enhance both the thermal stability and mechanical strength of the gels, as demonstrated by comparative dynamic rheology. The presence of N‐Boc protecting group in the peptides showed also a remarkable effect on the formation and properties of the gels. Despite numerous examples of peptide‐based gelators known in the literature, this is the first time in which low‐molecular‐weight peptides bearing side chain azobenzene units are used for the synthesis of “intelligent” supramolecular organogels. Compared with other approaches, this strategy is advantageous in terms of structural flexibility since it is compatible with a free, unprotected amino terminus and allows placement of the chromophore at any position of the peptide sequence.     

Multistimuli‐Responsive Luminescence Switching of Pyrazine Derivative Based Donor–Acceptor–Donor Luminophores

Three symmetrical donor–acceptor–donor (D–A–D) luminophores ( C1 , C2 , and C3 ) with pyrazine derivatives as electron‐withdrawing groups have been developed for multistimuli‐responsive luminescence switching. For comparison, reference compounds R1 and R2 without the pyrazine moiety have also been synthesized. Intramolecular charge transfer (ICT) interactions can be found for all D–A–D luminophores owing to the electron‐withdrawing properties of the two imine nitrogen atoms in the pyrazine ring and the electron‐donating properties of the other two amine nitrogen atoms in the two triphenylamine units. Moreover, luminophores C1 , C2 , and C3 exhibit “on–off–on” luminescence switching properties in mixtures of water/tetrahydrofuran with increasing water content, which is different from the “on–off” switching for typical aggregation‐caused quenching (ACQ) materials and “off–on” switching for traditional aggregation‐induced emission (AIE) materials. Additionally, upon grinding the pristine samples, luminophores C1 , C2 , and C3 display bathochromically shifted photoluminescence maxima that can be recovered by either solvent fuming or thermal annealing treatments. The piezofluorochromic (PFC) properties are more pronounced than those for reference compounds R1 and R2 , which indicates that D–A molecules have the ability to amplify the PFC effect by tuning the ICT interactions upon tiny structural changes under pressure. Furthermore, the target luminophores demonstrate acid‐responsive photoluminescence spectra that can be recovered in either basic or ambient environments. These results suggest that D–A complexes are potential candidates for multistimuli‐responsive luminescence switching because their ICT profiles can be facilely tuned with tiny external stimuli.     

Bioinspired Actuators Based on Stimuli‐Responsive Polymers

Organisms exhibit strong environmental adaptability by controllably adjusting their morphologies or fast locomotion; thus providing constant inspiration for scientists to develop artificial actuators that not only have diverse and sophisticated shape‐morphing capabilities, but can also further transfer dynamic and reversible shape deformations into macroscopic motion under the following principles: asymmetric friction, the Marangoni effect, and counteracting forces of the surrounding conditions. Among numerous available materials for fabricating bioinspired artificial actuators, stimuli‐responsive polymers are superior in their flexible features and the ability to change their physicochemical properties dynamically under external stimuli, such as temperature, pH, light, and ionic strength. Herein, different mechanisms, working principles, and applications of stimuli‐responsive polymeric actuators are comprehensively introduced. Furthermore, perspectives on existing challenges and future directions of this field are provided.     

Synthesis and Characterization of PEG‐Based Drug‐Responsive Biohybrid Hydrogels

Interactive materials being responsive to a biocompatible stimulus represent a promising approach for future therapeutic applications. In this study, we present a novel biohybrid material synthesized from biocompatible components being stimulus‐responsive to the pharmaceutically approved small‐molecule novobiocin. The hydrogel design is based on the gyrase B (GyrB) protein, which is covalently grafted to multi‐arm polyethylene glycol (PEG) using a Michael‐type addition reaction. Upon addition of the GyrB‐dimerizing substance coumermycin, stable hydrogels form which can be dissolved in a dose‐adjustable manner by the antibiotic novobiocin. The switchable properties of this PEG‐based hydrogel are favorable for future applications in tissue engineering and as externally controlled drug depot.     

Liquid‐Crystalline Ordering as a Concept in Materials Science: From Semiconductors to Stimuli‐Responsive Devices

While the unique optical properties of liquid crystals (LCs) are already well exploited for flat‐panel displays, their intrinsic ability to self‐organize into ordered mesophases, which are intermediate states between crystal and liquid, gives rise to a broad variety of additional applications. The high degree of molecular order, the possibility for large scale orientation, and the structural motif of the aromatic subunits recommend liquid‐crystalline materials as organic semiconductors, which are solvent‐processable and can easily be deposited on a substrate. The anisotropy of liquid crystals can further cause a stimuli‐responsive macroscopic shape change of cross‐linked polymer networks, which act as reversibly contracting artificial muscles. After illustrating the concept of liquid‐crystalline order in this Review, emphasis will be placed on synthetic strategies for novel classes of LC materials, and the design and fabrication of active devices.     

Stimuli‐Responsive Supramolecular Hydrogels and Their Applications in Regenerative Medicine

Supramolecular hydrogels are a class of self‐assembled network structures formed via non‐covalent interactions of the hydrogelators. These hydrogels capable of responding to external stimuli are considered to be smart materials due to their ability to undergo sol–gel and/or gel–sol transition upon subtle changes in their surroundings. Such stimuli‐responsive hydrogels are intriguing biomaterials with applications in tissue engineering, delivery of cells and drugs, modulating tissue environment to promote innate tissue repair, and imaging for medical diagnostics among others. This review summarizes the recent developments in stimuli‐responsive supramolecular hydrogels and their potential applications in regenerative medicine. Specifically, various structural aspects of supramolecular hydrogelators involved in self‐assembly, the role of external stimuli in tuning/controlling their phase transitions, and how these functions could be harnessed to advance applications in regenerative medicine are focused on. Finally, the key challenges and future prospects for these versatile materials are briefly described.     

A Multi‐Stimuli‐Responsive Oxazine Molecular Switch: A Strategy for the Design of Electrochromic Materials

A multi‐state and multi‐stimuli‐responsive oxazine molecular switch that combines an electro‐base property and sensitive base/acid‐responsive properties was designed and synthesized. The multi‐state structures of the molecular switch, with different colors, were predicted by comparing the optical properties with reference molecules and confirmed by using NMR spectroscopy. The color‐switching mechanism under stimulation with acids and bases was investigated by using DFT calculations. Three single states can be obtained and the switching is unidirectional under acid and base stimulation. The electrochromic phenomenon of the molecular switch, which combines its electro‐base and base‐sensitive properties, was demonstrated. An electrochromic device that exhibited good electrochromic properties with excellent reversibility (2000 cycles) and high coloration efficiency (804 cm² C^?1) was successfully constructed.     

Stimuli‐Responsive Water‐Soluble Fullerene (C60) Polymeric Systems

This review documents the advances in stimuli‐responsive water‐soluble fullerene (C₆₀) polymeric systems. Stimuli‐responsive polymers, when grafted onto C₆₀ impart “smart” and “responsive” characteristics, and these novel materials adopt various morphologies when subjected to external stimuli, such as pH, temperature, and salt. Various synthetic approaches for producing C₆₀‐polymers are outlined and discussed. The responsive behavior, water solubility, and self‐assembly characteristics of these C₆₀‐polymers make them attractive for applications such as drug delivery, temperature sensors, and personal care.     

Photo‐Controlled Reversible Microtubule Assembly Mediated by Paclitaxel‐Modified Cyclodextrin

The design and construction of multi‐stimuli‐responsive supramolecular nanoassemblies that can mimic and regulate the fundamental biological processes have become a focus of interest in supramolecular chemistry. In this work, a perfect combination has been achieved between naturally occurring microtubules and artificially macrocyclic receptors. The self‐assembling morphology of microtubules can be photo‐tuned by the host–guest interaction of paclitaxel‐modified β‐cyclodextrin (PTX‐CD) and photochromic arylazopyrazole (PTX‐AAP). Moreover, the supramolecularly aggregated microtubules in a cellular environment can induce a pronounced cell morphological change and cell death. This supramolecular approach based on the secondary PTX‐AAP?PTX‐CD complexation provides us a facile method to reversibly control the intertubular aggregation behaviors of microtubules, which may bring new perspectives in the treatment of diseases related to improper protein aggregation.     

Amino‐Acid‐Based Block Copolymers by RAFT Polymerization

This review summarizes recent advances in the design and synthesis of amino‐acid‐based block copolymers by reversible addition–fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization of amino‐acid‐bearing monomers. We will mainly focus on stimuli‐responsive block copolymers, such as pH‐, thermo‐, and dual‐stimuli‐responsive block copolymers, and self‐assembled block copolymers, including amphiphilic and double‐hydrophilic block copolymers having tunable chiroptical properties. We will also highlight recent results in RAFT synthesis of amino‐acid‐based copolymers having various properties, such as catalytic and optoelectronic properties, cross‐linked block copolymer micelles, unimolecular micelles, and organic–inorganic hybrids.     

Self‐assembly of supramolecular polymers into tunable helical structures

There is growing interest in the design of synthetic molecules that are able to self‐assemble into a polymeric chain with compact helical conformations, which is analogous to the folded state of natural proteins. Herein, we highlight supramolecular approach to the formation of helical architectures and their conformational changes driven by external stimuli. Helical organization in synthetic self‐assembling systems can be achieved by the various types of noncovalent interactions, which include hydrogen bonding, solvophobic effects, and metal‐ligand interactions. Since the external environment can have a large influence on the strength and configuration of noncovalent interactions between the individual components, stimulus‐induced alterations in the intramolecular noncovalent interactions can result in dynamic conformational change of the supramolecular helical structure thus, driving significant changes in the properties of the materials. Therefore, these supramolecular helices hold great promise as stimuli‐responsive materials. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 46: 1925–1935, 2008     

Stimuli‐responsive amphiphilic PDMAEMA‐b‐PLMA copolymers and their cationic and zwitterionic analogs

In this work, the synthesis and characterization of novel amphiphilic diblock copolymers of poly(2‐dimethylamino ethyl methacrylate)‐b‐poly(lauryl methacrylate), PDMAEMA‐b‐PLMA, using the reversible addition‐fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization technique, are reported. The diblocks were successfully derivatized to cationic and zwitterionic block polyelectrolytes by quaternization and sulfobetainization of the PDMAEMA block, respectively. Furthermore, their molecular and physicochemical characterization was performed by using characterization techniques such as NMR and FTIR, size exclusion chromatography, light scattering techniques, and transmission electron microscopy. The structure of the diblock micelles, their behavior, and properties in aqueous solution were investigated under the effect of pH, temperature, and ionic strength, as PDMAEMA and its derivatives are stimuli‐responsive polymers and exhibit responses to variations of at least one of these physicochemical parameters. These new families of stimuli‐responsive block copolymers respond to changes of their environment giving interesting nanostructures, behavioral motifs, and properties, rendering them useful as nanocarriers for drug delivery and gene therapy. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2018 , 56, 598–610     

Synthesis and properties of chitosan‐based thermo‐ and pH‐responsive nanoparticles and application in drug release

In this research, thermo‐ and pH‐responsive nanoparticles with an average diameter of about 50–200 nm were synthesized via the surfactant‐free emulsion polymerization. The thermal/pH dual responsive properties of these nanoparticles were designed by the addition of a pH sensitive monomer, acrylic acid (AA), to be copolymerized with N‐isopropylacrylamide (NIPAAm) in a chitosan (CS) solution. The molar ratio of CS/AA/NIPAAm in the feed was changed to investigate its effect on structure, morphology, thermal‐ and pH‐responsive properties of the nanoparticles. It was found that CS‐PAA‐PNIPAAm nanoparticles could be well dispersed in the aqueous solution and carried positive charges on the surface. The addition of thermal‐sensitive NIPAAm monomer affected the polymerization mechanism and interactions between CS and AA. The particle size of the nanoparticles was found to be varied with the composition of NIPAAm monomer in the feed. The synthesized nanoparticles exhibited stimuli‐responsive properties, and their mean diameter thus could be manipulated by changing pH value and temperature of the environment. The nanoparticles showed a continuous release of the encapsulated doxycycline hyclate up to 10 days during an in vitro release experiment. The environmentally responsive nanoparticles are expected to be used in many fields such as drug delivery system. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 47: 2798–2810, 2009     

Triple redox/temperature responsive diselenide‐containing homopolypeptide micelles and supramolecular hydrogels thereof

Stimuli‐responsive polypeptides are receiving much attention for drug delivery systems and tissue engineering scaffolds; however, it is challenging to construct multiple‐responsive polypeptides and one‐component polymeric hydrogels. Herein, a novel type of triple redox/temperature‐responsive diselenide‐containing poly(methoxydiethylene glycol‐l ‐glutamate) homopolypeptide was facilely synthesized by selenocystamine‐initiated ring‐opening polymerization in DMF at 30 °C, and their chemical structures and physical properties were fully characterized by means of ¹H NMR, GPC, FT‐IR, WAXD, and CD. They self‐assembled into spherical micelles in aqueous solution, which possess a lower critical solution temperature, redox‐responsiveness inherited from diselenide bond, and the triple stimuli‐sensitive self‐assembly behaviors, as characterized by means of turbidity, DLS, TEM, and zeta potential measurements. The diselenide‐containing homopolypeptides formed supramolecular hydrogels at room temperature, exhibiting a thermal gel–sol transition. The rheological tests evidence that the mechanical modulus of the hydrogel is independent of angular frequency within 100 rad/s and at 25 °C, in which the storage modulus of G′ is order of magnitude greater than the loss modulus of G″, displaying a solid‐like elastic behavior. Moreover, the mechanical modulus of the hydrogel can be tuned by changing the chain length of the homopolypeptide, the 10‐mM 1,4‐dithiothreitol (DTT) reduction, and 1 mM H₂O₂ oxidation, respectively. Consequently, this work provides a simple strategy to fabricate triple‐stimuli responsive polypeptide micelles and one‐component hydrogels. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2018 , 56, 1067–1077     

Facile synthesis of triple‐stimuli (photo/pH/thermo) responsive copolymers of 2‐diazo‐1,2‐naphthoquinone‐mediated poly(N‐isopropylacrylamide‐co‐N‐hydroxymethylacrylamide)

A series of poly(N‐isopropylacrylamide‐co‐N‐hydroxymethylacrylamide) P(NIPAM‐co‐NHMA) copolymers were firstly synthesized via free radical polymerization. Then, the hydrophobic, photosensitive 2‐diazo‐1,2‐naphthoquinone (DNQ) molecules were partially and randomly grafted onto P(NIPAM‐co‐NHMA) backbone through esterification to obtain a triple‐stimuli (photo/pH/thermo) responsive copolymers of P(NIPAM‐co‐NHMA‐co‐DNQMA). UV‐vis spectra showed that the lower critical solution temperature (LCST) of P(NIPAM‐co‐NHMA) ascended with increasing hydrophilic comonomer NHMA molar fraction and can be tailored by pH variation as well. The LCST of the P(NIPAM‐co‐NHMA) went down firstly after DNQ modification and subsequently shifted to higher value after UV irradiation. Meanwhile, the phase transition profile of P(NIPAM‐co‐NHMA‐co‐DNQMA) could be triggered by pH and UV light as expected. Thus, a triple‐stimuli responsive copolymer whose solution properties could be, respectively, modulated by temperature, light, and pH, has been achieved. These stimuli‐responsive properties should be very important for controlled release delivery system. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 47: 2763–2773, 2009