Using synthetic multi-element standards (SMELS) for calibration and quality control of the irradiation facilities in the BR1 reactor

The thermal to epithermal neutron flux ratio (f) and the deviation of the epithermal neutron spectrum from the 1/E shape (α) are essential parameters for the correct application of k ₀-standardized neutron activation analysis. Several methods are applied for the determination of f and α. They are based on Cd-covered multi-monitor or on bare-irradiations methods. The recently developed and characterized synthetic multi-element standards (SMELS) were designed as a validation tool for the proper implementation of the k ₀-NAA method in a laboratory. In particular, SMELS Type III contains Au and Zr, thus allowing the direct determination of f and α. It could, therefore, replace the traditional flux monitors. Furthermore, it could be used as a quality control material to monitor the stability of the irradiation facility and the detector. This paper presents the accuracy of the f and α determination and the feasibility of quality control using SMELS for irradiation channel Y4 of the BR1 reactor.     

Implementation of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript>-NAA method by using <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript>-IAEA software and the NAA#3 irradiation hole at the HANARO research reactor

This study intended to demonstrate the use of k ₀-IAEA software with the NAA#3 irradiation hole in the HANARO research reactor and the gamma-ray spectrometers at the NAA laboratory in the Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI). NIST SRM 2586-Soil was chosen as a sample to validate the analytical protocol by using the k ₀-IAEA software. Twenty four elements were determined and the resultant deviations between the experimental results and the certified values were all within 10% except for Dy. In addition, an analysis of three types of synthetic multielement standards (SMELS) prepared by the Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM) and Institute of Nuclear Science (INW) in Belgium was executed. The analytical results agreed well with the assigned values and the U-scores for most of the elements were lower than 2.     

Radiation stability tests of the SMELS materials in the LVR-15 experimental reactor at Řež

Radiation stability of a set of three synthetic multielement standards (SMELS) designed for validation of k ₀-standardization in neutron activation analysis was tested by monitoring mass and element content changes following irradiation at a high neutron fluence rate (up to 9^.10¹³ n^.cm^-2.s^-1) for stepwise increased periods of time. No mass changes were detected and for all the 26 elements investigated only a chlorine content loss was observed. Thus, radiation stability of the SMELS materials for the given purpose and their suitability for use also in high-power reactors was demonstrated.     

Development of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript>-based cyclic neutron activation analysis for short-lived radionuclides

The k ₀-based cyclic neutron activation analysis (k ₀-CNAA) technique has been studied to explore the applicability at the Portuguese research reactor (RPI). In particular, for the determination of elements which form short-lived radionuclides, particularly fluorine (²⁰F, 11.16 s half-life) and selenium (^77mSe, 17.36 s half-life) in polymer, biological and environmental samples. The detection limits obtained for F and Se were about 50 and 0.01 mg kg⁻¹, respectively, in the investigated materials. The timing parameters for the procedure were 10 to 20 s for irradiation, 5 s decay, 10 to 20 s counting, 5 s waiting and performed with eight cycles. The k ₀-IAEA program was modified to use millisecond time resolution for irradiation, decay and counting times as needed for interpreting k ₀-CNAA data in terms of concentration, accuracy and detection limit. The quality control of the procedure was performed by preparing a standard solution containing fluorine with different contents as well as using the certified reference materials containing selenium from which the bias between the results and the certified values were within 15% for most elements at the investigated content ranges. The analytical results for several other elements producing short-lived or detectable radionuclides, e.g., Al, Ca, Cl, Cu, Dy, I, Mg, Mn, Ti, and V were also obtained by the k ₀-CNAA procedure with accuracy within 12%.     

Determination of major and trace elements in iron reference materials using k0-NAA

Major and trace element contents in iron ore reference materials were investigated using k ₀-instrumental neutron activation analysis (k ₀-INAA). To avoid iron interferences, radiochemical separation was developed (k ₀-RNAA). The determination of the investigated elements in the inorganic phase from hydrochloric acid solution was performed after radiochemical separation of iron by diisopropyl ether. It was found that after the Fe elimination, the limit of detection for some elements was much lower that enables their direct determination. The distribution of 39 elements (with intermediate/medium and long half-life radionuclides) after Fe removal was investigated.     

Analysis of SMELS by k 0-based IM-NAA method using PFTS position of KAMINI reactor for quality control exercise

As a part of QA/QC of k ₀-based internal monostandard neutron activation analysis (IM-NAA), three types of synthetic multielement standards (SMELS) were analyzed using pneumatic fast transfer system irradiation position of KAMINI reactor, IGCAR. Radioactive assay of activation products was carried out by high resolution gamma ray spectrometry. IM-NAA was used to determine relative concentration ratios of 22 elements with respect to gold internal monostandard. Absolute concentrations were calculated using assigned concentration of Au in all the types of SMELS. Z-score values within ±1 at 95.5 % confidence level and percentage deviations within ±5 % indicated good quality of the results by IM-NAA in most of the cases. Using this methodology, an ilmenite mineral sample was analyzed and concentrations of 14 elements were determined using Sc as monostandard.     

The use of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript>-IAEA program in NIRR-1 NAA laboratory

The k ₀-IAEA program developed for implementation of the single comparator instrumental neutron activation analysis method (k ₀-INAA) has been used for elemental analysis with NIRR-1 irradiation and counting facilities. The existing experimental protocols for routine analysis based on the relative method were used to test the capability and reliability of the program for the analyses of geological and biological samples. The Synthetic Multi-element Standards (SMELS) types I, II and III recommended by the international k ₀ user community for the validation of k ₀-NAA method in NAA laboratories, furthermore, the following standard reference materials: NIST-1633b (Coal Fly Ash) and IAEA-336 (Lichen) were analyzed. Results obtained with the version 3.12 of the k ₀-IAEA program were found to be in good agreement with the data obtained with the established relative method using WINSPAN-2004 software. Detection limits for elemental analysis of geological and biological samples with NIRR-1 facilities are provided.     

Elemental analysis of topaz from northern areas of Pakistan and assessment of induced radioactivity level after neutron irradiation for color induction

To study the impurity elements, which render color-induced topaz long lived radionuclides, three samples of topaz, from three different cities of the Northern Pakistan (Baltistan, Gilgit and Mardan) were analyzed using k ₀ instrumental neutron activation analysis (k ₀-INAA). The samples were irradiated in Pakistan Research Reactor-1 (PARR-1) and PARR-2 at Pakistan Institute of Nuclear Science & Technology (PINSTECH), Islamabad. The method was validated by analyzing IAEA-S7 reference material. In three samples a total of 22 trace level impurity elements were quantified. Among impurities, 10 elements including As, Ce, Ga, Ge, La, Na, Sb, Sc, U and Zn were common in topaz of all the three places. The storage time has been calculated for each sample required to bring the induced radioactivity down to permissible level given by US National Regulatory Commission.     

Accelerating <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript>

Combining the powers of a fast pneumatic transport system and the Automatic Activation Analyzer (AAA) of the Atominstitut in Vienna with the newest version of the IAEA k ₀-Software, the application of the k ₀-method to the determination of short-lived radionuclides becomes easily possible. By calculating Asp-values with the IAEA software, the often expensive and time-consuming measurement of Asp-values using certified reference materials is reduced to quality control checks. Measurements clearly show that the two approaches are equivalent, especially since both take self-absorption and neutron self-shielding into account. In this way it is possible to expand the library of the AAA with many hitherto unobtainable Asp-values. At the same time, using highly accurate Asp-values already measured for many short-lived radionuclides, k ₀-values for those can be produced with a simple procedure.     

Quality assessment on airborne particulate matter of k0-INAA

The analysis of airborne particulate matter (APM) by k ₀-NAA was assessed using: (1) BCR reference material (RM) simulated air-filters, (2) synthetic air-filters prepared by spiking blank filters with standard solutions, and (3) real APM filters. k ₀-INAA is a suitable technique for the analysis of APM, delivering accurate and precise results. However, the quality assessment of APM analysis appears to be a difficult task.     

Measurement and evaluation of k0 factors for PGA at JAERI

In order to determine multiple elements by k ₀ standardization-based neutron induced prompt gamma-ray analysis (PGA), measurements and evaluation of k ₀ factors for the elements have been performed. The k ₀ factors using Cl as a comparator for 27 elements, which are effective for the analysis by PGA, were measured with precision almost less than 3% using the cold and thermal guided neutron beams at JRR-3M. The accuracy of the k ₀ factors were better than 10% except for the non-1/v elements of Cd and Sm. Neutron spectrum correction is necessary for common use of k ₀ factors of the non-1/v elements.     

Calibration of the B54X channel and implementation of k 0-NAA at the RA3-reactor,Ezeiza, Argentina

The B54X position of the 8 MW RA3 research reactor at the Ezeiza Atomic Centre of the Argentine National Atomic Energy Commission is currently being used for NAA irradiations. The facility with a nominal average fluence of 5 × 10¹³ cm^?2 s^?1 is dedicated to long irradiations of up to 5 h. Samples are being measured after a decay of typically 7 and 30 days. With the aim of implementing the k ₀-NAA method at the Nuclear Analytical Techniques Laboratory of the Centre, the reactor parameters α and f were estimated applying multi monitor methods using the Kayzero for Windows software. After a careful recalibration of the HPGe detector, SMELS III, NIST SRM 1633b and several other matrix RM’s were analyzed using the k ₀ standardization in order to verify the proper implementation of the k ₀-NAA approach. The found accuracy and associated uncertainties are discussed. In general, good agreement was obtained between results of this work and the reference values of the individual reference materials, thus proving successful first implementation of the above method and trueness of the results achieved. The obtained detection limits for several elements were evaluated.     

Standardization of NAA Using the Activation Equation and Isotope-Related Constants

A standardization method for NAA has been developed based on the activation equation and on isotope-related k _i -values that are composite nuclear constants. This approach combines the simplicity of the absolute methods with nearly the same accuracy as that obtained by the relative ones. The k _i -constants are calculated from the well measured k ₀-factors and the neutron flux is determined as with the k ₀-method. A computer program was developed for the determination of the neutron flux parameters and the concentration of the trace element. These calculations start with the measured activity of the radionuclides.     

Comparison of 14 MeV-NAA, k0-NAA and ED-XRF for air pollution bio-monitoring

In this paper the performances and the limitations of three multi-elementary analysis techniques are compared applied to a study of air pollution biomonitoring in Morocco. These techniques are: (1) 14 MeV neutron activation analysis (14 MeV-NAA), (2) thermal neutron activation analysis using the k ₀ quasi-absolute method (k ₀-NAA) and (3) energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence analysis (ED-XRF). The experimental procedures and the control of the analytical results using certified reference materials are described and discussed. The three methods were confronted for the analysis of lichens, mosses and tree-barks. The complementarity of these methods enabled us to determine 43 elements in different samples. The most suitable method for each element was selected according to the sensitivity and selectivity necessitating the minimum corrections of the matrix effects and/or the interfering reactions.     

k0-NAA quality assessment by analysis of different certified reference materials using the KAYZERO/SOLCOI software

A suite of natural matrix reference materials (RMs) were used to assess the quality of analytical results obtained by k ₀-instrumental neutron activation analysis (k ₀-INAA) at the Joef Stefan Institute (IJS). Five certified reference materials (CRMs) from the Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM), two standard reference materials (SRMs) from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), three RMs from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and one RM from IJS were analyzed. Altogether, results for twenty-four elements in inorganic matrices and twenty-nine elements in organic matrices, obtained by k ₀-INAA, were compared to certified values. Results obtained show good agreement with certified or assigned values except for Fe, La, Nd, Sm and U in inorganic matrices, and Ag, Al and Cr in organic matrices.     

k0 Standardization Approach in Neutron-Induced Prompt Gamma-Ray Analysis at JAERI

The k ₀ standardization method has been studied and applied at JAERI for the accurate determination of multielements by neutron-induced prompt gamma-ray analysis (PGA). The k ₀ factors for 26 elements using Cl as a comparator were measured by the cold and thermal neutron guided beams of JRR-3M with an uncertainty less than 3% except for a few elements. The k ₀ factors for most elements obtained with both cold and thermal neutrons agreed within 3%, and agreed also with those measured at other cold and thermal neutron guided beams within 10%, except for a few elements. Multielement determinations in reference materials were performed using the k ₀ factors obtained to evaluate the accuracy and precision of this work.     

Validation of the k0_IAEA software using SMELS material at CDTN/CNEN, Brazil

The Laboratory for Neutron Activation Analysis at CDTN/CNEN, Brazil, acquired the k0_IAEA software package during the Workshop on Nuclear Data for Activation Analysis, 2005, held at the Abdus Salam International Centre for Theoretical Physics, Italy. The IAEA distributed the software to several laboratories and has accepted suggestions from the users about the performance of the program. This paper describes the validation procedure carried out aiming at the validation of the software package. The procedure was to analyze the SMELS samples and to compare the results obtained by this software to the commercial KayWin software package, already established at CDTN/CNEN. The results were compared to the values obtained by the Jožef Stefan Institute, Slovenia. The laboratories applied the same software: k0_IAEA and KayWin. The overall results pointed out that the k0_IAEA software set up at CDTN/CNEN, Brazil, is working properly. The u-score test showed that all results, except data in SMELS Type III for Se obtained at the JSI, are within 95% confidence interval once setting up u-score as 1.96 (P = 95% or ±2σ).     

Element profiles of onion producing districts in Japan, as determined using INAA and PGA

We carried out instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA) as well as k ₀-based prompt gamma-ray analysis (k ₀-PGA) to measure the amount of the elements in onions and studied whether the onions collected from different sites can be categorized based on the elemental concentration profile. Six elements (Na, Mg, Cl, K, Ca, Mn) and 3 elements (B, S, Cl) were measured by INAA and PGA in the onions grown in two districts, Hokkaido and Saga, in Japan, respectively. After principal component analysis, it was found that Cl was an important element to feature the producing districts of onions.     

Determination of trace elements in cigarette tobacco with the <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript>-based NAA method using Es-Salam research reactor

The k ₀-standardization method of NAA is known as one of the most remarkable progress of NAA with its many advantages. Recently, our laboratory is highly involved in various areas of application of k ₀-NAA. This paper focuses on the application of the k ₀-NAA method in Nutritional and Health-Related Environmental field. Tobacco holds a leading position among different commodities of human consumption. The adverse health effects of toxic and trace elements in tobacco smoke on smokers and non-smokers are a special concern. In the present study, the concentration of 24 trace elements in cigarette tobacco of five different brands of Algerian and American cigarettes have been determined by k ₀-based INAA method. The results were compared with those obtained for samples from Iranian, Turkish, Brazilian and Mexican cigarettes tobacco. To evaluate the accurate of the results the SRM IAEA-140/TM was executed. The analytical results showed that the relative error of most of the elements was less than 10%.     

Monitoring of environmental contaminants: 10 years of application of k0-I INAA

Examples of the application of k ₀ standardized instrumental neutron activation analysis (k ₀ -INAA) to aerosols and biological monitors in the last 10 years at Instituto Tecnológico e Nuclear (ITN) are given. As an analytical technique, INAA, in association with the k ₀ method was applied to these materials in four different projects, aiming at monitoring concentrations of heavy metals and others elements in the atmosphere in the Portuguese territory. In these studies we analysed the lichen Parmelia sulcata Taylor and olive tree bark as monitors as well as aerosol samples. For each project some representative results are presented, followed by a discussion of the application of this technique to environmental studies.