Dielectric and shear mechanical relaxations in glass-forming liquids: a test of the Gemant-DiMarzio-Bishop model

The Gemant-DiMarzio-Bishop model, which connects the frequency-dependent shear modulus to the frequency-dependent dielectric constant, is reviewed and a new consistent macroscopic formulation is derived. It is moreover shown that this version of the model can be tested without fitting parameters. The reformulated version of the model is analyzed and experimentally tested. It is demonstrated that the model has several nontrivial qualitative predictions: the existence of an elastic contribution to the high-frequency limit of the dielectric constant, a shift of the shear modulus loss peak frequency to higher frequencies compared with the loss peak frequency of the dielectric constant, a broader alpha peak, and a more pronounced beta peak in the shear modulus when compared with the dielectric constant. It is shown that these predictions generally agree with experimental findings and it is therefore suggested that the Gemant-DiMarzio-Bishop model is correct on a qualitative level. The quantitative agreement between the model and the data is on the other hand moderate to poor. It is discussed if a model-free comparison between the dielectric and shear mechanical relaxations is relevant, and it is concluded that the shear modulus should be compared with the rotational dielectric modulus, 1(epsilon(omega)-n2), which is extracted from the Gemant-DiMarzio-Bishop model, rather than to the dielectric susceptibility or the conventional dielectric modulus M=1epsilon(omega).     

Fragility of glass-forming polymer liquids

The fragility of polymeric glass-forming liquids is calculated as a function of molecular structural parameters from a generalized entropy theory of polymer glass-formation that combines the Adam-Gibbs (AG) model for the rate of structural relaxation with the lattice cluster theory (LCT) for polymer melt thermodynamics. Our generalized entropy theory predicts the existence of distinct high and low temperature regimes of glass-formation that are separated by a thermodynamically well-defined crossover temperature T(I) at which the product of the configurational entropy and the temperature has an inflection point. Since the predicted temperature dependence of the configurational entropy and structural relaxation time are quite different in these temperature regimes, we introduce separate definitions of fragility for each regime. Experimentally established trends in the fragility of polymer melts with respect to variations in polymer microstructure and pressure are interpreted within our theory in terms of the accompanying changes in the chain packing efficiency.     

Non-Debye response for the structural relaxation in glass-forming liquids: test of the Avramov model

The experimentally observed characteristic features of the alpha-relaxation process in glass-forming liquids are the non-Arrhenius behavior of the structural relaxation times and the non-Debye character of the macroscopic relaxation function. The Avramov model in which relaxation is considered as an energy activation process of surmounting random barriers in liquid energy landscape was successfully applied to describe the temperature and pressure dependences of the macroscopic relaxation times or viscosity. In this paper, we consider the dielectric spectrum associated with Avramov model. The asymmetrical broadening of the loss spectra was found to be related directly to dispersion of the energy barrier distribution. However, it turns out that temperature dependence of the spectrum broadening as predicted by the Avromov model is at odds to experimental observation in glass-forming liquids.     

Exponential probe rotation in glass-forming liquids

Using time resolved optical depolarization, we have studied the rotational behavior of molecular probes in supercooled liquids near the glass transition temperature T(g). Simultaneously, the dynamics of the liquid immediately surrounding these rigid probes is measured by triplet state solvation experiments. This direct comparison of solute and solvent dynamics is particularly suited for assessing the origin of exponential orientational correlation functions of probe molecules embedded in liquids which exhibit highly nonexponential structural relaxation. Polarization angle dependent Stokes shift correlation functions demonstrate that probe rotation time and solvent response time are locally correlated quantities in the case of smaller probe molecules. Varying the size of both guest and host molecules shows that the size ratio determines the rotational behavior of the probes. The results are indicative of time averaging being at the origin of exponential rotation of probes whose rotational time constant is slower than solvent relaxation by a factor of 20 or more.     

Fragility and thermodynamics in nonpolymeric glass-forming liquids

For nonpolymeric supercooled liquids, the empirical correlation m = 56Tg DeltaCp(Tg)/DeltaHm provides a reliable means of correlating dynamic and thermodynamic variables. The dynamics are characterized by the fragility or steepness index m and the glass transition temperature Tg, while thermodynamics enter in terms of the heat capacity step DeltaCp at Tg and the melting enthalpy DeltaHm. The combination of the above correlation with the 23 rule for the Tg/Tm ratio yields an expression, m = 40DeltaCp(Tg)/DeltaSm, which was rationalized as the correlation of the thermodynamic and kinetic fragilities. Defining a thermodynamic fragility via DeltaCp(Tg)/DeltaSm also reveals that the slopes in Kauzmann's original DeltaS(T)/DeltaSm versus T/Tm plot reflect the fragility concept [Chem. Rev. 43, 219 (1948)], so long as Tm/Tg = 1.5. For the many liquids whose excess heat capacity is a hyperbolic function of temperature, we deduce that the fragility cannot exceed m = 170, unless the Tg/Tm = 2/3 rule breaks down.     

Interfacial effects on vitrification of confined glass-forming liquids

Mesoporous silica phases, with uniform pores of dimensions in the 2-30 nm range, offer a uniquely well-defined environment for the study of the effects of two-dimensional spatial confinement on the properties of glass-forming liquids. We report observations by differential scanning calorimetry of the vitrification of o-terphenyl (OTP), salol, and glycerol in hexagonal mesoporous silica (MCM-41 and SBA-15) in a wide range of pore sizes from 2.6 to 26.4 nm. In agreement with previous studies, where a controlled porous glass is used as a solid matrix, the glass transition temperature for o-terphenyl diminishes with decreasing pore size. In contrast to OTP, glycerol shows a gradual increase in glass transition temperature, while in salol a slight reduction of glass transition temperature is observed, followed by an increase, which results in glass transition temperature indistinguishable from that of the bulk for the smallest pores. These results are discussed in terms of liquid-surface interactions in an interfacial layer, monitored by Fourier-transformed infrared spectroscopy in the study. The hydrogen bonding with silica surface silanols dominates the glass transition trends observed in salol and glycerol.     

An upper limit to kinetic fragility in glass-forming liquids

The kinetic fragility of a liquid is correlated to the magnitude of enthalpy hysteresis in various glass-forming materials during thermal cycling across the glass transition. While the lower bound of liquid fragility is well known, there has been little research into the possibility of an inherent upper limit to fragility. In this paper, we present a theoretical argument for the existence of a maximum fragility and show that the correlation between fragility and enthalpy hysteresis allows for an empirical evaluation of the upper limit of fragility. This upper limit occurs as the enthalpy hysteresis involved in thermal cycling about the glass transition approaches zero, leading to m(max)≈175. This result agrees remarkably well with our previous estimate. The dynamics of maximum fragility liquids are discussed, and a critical temperature of ～1.5 T(g) (where T(g) is the glass transition temperature) is revealed where a transition from nonexponential to exponential structural relaxation occurs.     

Nature of long-range correlations of density fluctuations in glass-forming liquids

Based on a concise review of the experimental data, a theory of the structural, kinetic, and dynamic features of the Fischer cluster is put forward. This theory is based on the idea of heterophase fluctuations of glass-forming liquids. According to these ideas in a one-component liquid the solidlike and fluidlike transient associations of molecules (fluctuons) are formed. The fluctuons differ in the short-range order and, consequently, in the free energy. They form a random free energy landscape. The random field free energy functional of the Ginzburg-Landau type, which accounts for the free energy landscape, is deduced. Based on this, the phase equilibrium, critical behavior, and ordering phenomena of the heterophase liquid are considered. It is shown that in the critical region an effective attractive interaction of the fluctuons results in their gravitation and formation of correlated fractal aggregations. The aggregation consists of the fluctuons of similar short-range order. The fractal aggregation formation is a special structural state of the liquid above the glass transition temperature. The condition at which the aggregations are formed is formulated. Thus it is shown that the Fischer cluster is an array of fractal aggregations of fluctuons. The growth kinetics and dynamics of the Fischer cluster are described. The experimental data are analyzed and discussed using the theory that is put forward.     

Liquid–liquid transition in polymers and glass-forming liquids

It is shown that many simple glass-forming liquids exhibit a phenomenon known in the area of polymer science as the liquid–liquid transition. The phenomenon manifests itself as a third-order transition in the equilibrium liquid-specific heat data around approximately 1.2 T_g and also as a bifurcation of the liquid relaxation into primary and secondry processes. It is stressed that the above phenomenon is due to a smooth changeover of the liquid from one dynamic regime to the other and hence is not due to any real phase transition. It is suggested that a liquid cluster kind of picture for the supercooled liquid regime, is capable of explaining the above phenomenon and is consistent with observation made on polymers and monomeric liquids. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Correlation between thermodynamic and kinetic fragilities in nonpolymeric glass-forming liquids

A phenomenological relationship between reduced excess heat capacity of supercooled liquid DeltaC(p)(exc)(T(g))DeltaS(m) at the glass transition temperature T(g), fragility index m, and reduced glass transition temperature T(rg)=T(g)T(m), where T(m) is the melting (liquidus) temperature, was derived for fragile nonpolymeric glass-forming liquids under the assumptions that the fragile behavior of these liquids is described by the Vogel-Fulcher-Tammann (VFT) equation; the excess heat capacity of liquid is inversely proportional to the absolute temperature and the VFT temperature T(0) is equal to the Kauzmann temperature T(K). It was found that DeltaC(p)(exc)(T(g))DeltaS(m) is a composite function of m and T(rg), which indicates that the empirical correlation DeltaC(p)(exc)(T(g))DeltaS(m)=0.025m recently identified by Wang et al. [J. Chem Phys. 125, 074505 (2006)] is probably valid only for liquids which have nearly the same values of T(rg).     

The impact of the stretching exponent on fragility of glass-forming liquids

The paper compared two factors governing fragility. The first one is thermodynamic, depending on the change in configurational entropy. The second one is kinetic and is determined by the stretching exponent β. Using a simple mathematical development, we show that the kinetic term \(m_{\text{K}} = f( {\beta_{{T_{\text{g}} }} } )\partial \ln \beta \left( T \right)/\partial \ln T|_{{T = T_{\text{g}} }}\) is always smaller than 1, where T _g is the glass transition temperature and \(f( {\beta_{{T_{\text{g}} }} } )\) is the given functions of the stretching exponent at T = T _g. As a result, the contribution of the kinetic term on the fragility of strong glasses is <6 %. Fragile glasses have a larger value of fragility index m, and for them, the influence of the kinetic term is significantly smaller. In any case, the thermodynamic term plays the main role in fragility and the kinetic one can be neglected.     

Examination of dynamic facilitation in molecular dynamics simulations of glass-forming liquids

Using data from molecular dynamics computer simulations of the one-component Dzugutov liquid and of BKS silica in metastable equilibrium supercooled states, we examine ideas introduced by Garrahan and Chandler (GC) in their dynamic facilitation (DF) model of the glass transition. Utilizing a recently introduced measure of DF, we find that DF is important for particle motion in both the supercooled Dzugutov liquid and in the BKS silica melt, that mobility propagates continuously, and that this effect becomes increasingly pronounced with decreasing T. We show that, in both systems, dynamic facilitation is strongest on the time scale of the late-beta relaxation, where clusters of highly mobile neighboring particles escaping from their cages are largest and, except for the silicon atoms in BKS silica, stringlike motion is most prominent. By comparing the two systems, we show that the temperature dependence of one measure of DF as the mode-coupling temperature is approached from high temperature is similar, once the temperature dependence of the structural relaxation time in each system is scaled out.     

Cooperative rearranging regions in polymeric materials: Relationship with the fragility of glass-forming liquids

From measurements performed on different polymeric glass-forming liquids using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), we determined the values of the fragility index m according to the concept proposed by Angell. We calculated the average size of a cooperative rearranging region (CRR) at the glass transition i.e. z(T_g), according to the definition proposed by Solunov. This quantity is linked to the Kauzmann temperature which was determined from dielectric spectroscopy or viscosimetry measurements performed on different samples including three-dimensional polymeric networks and linear polymer families with variable lateral chain lengths. By using our experimental data and others collected in the literature in order to scan a large domain of fragility values, we show that the fragility index m, characterising the glass-forming liquid, can be correlated to z(T_g) which characterises the glass formed.     

Thermodynamic basis for cluster kinetics: Prediction of the fragility of marginal metallic glass-forming liquids

Due to the inaccessibility of the supercooled region of marginal metallic glasses (MMGs) within the experimental time window, we study the cluster kinetics above the liquidus temperature, Tl, to acquire information on the fragility of the MMG systems. The thermodynamic basis for the stability of locally ordered structure in the MMG liquids is discussed in terms of the two-order-parameter model. It is found that the Arrhenius activation energy of clusters, Deltah, is proportional to the chemical mixing enthalpy of alloys, DeltaH(chem). Fragility of the MMG forming liquids can be described by the ratio of the absolute DeltaH(chem) value to the glass transition temperature, Tg. The manner of vitrification during rapid solidification is an important factor for the discrepancy between the data presented in this paper and the prediction of the two-order-parameter model concerning the relation between Delta h and the liquid fragility.     

Direct computation of characteristic temperatures and relaxation times for glass-forming polymer liquids

Characteristic temperatures and structural relaxation times for different classes of glass-forming polymer liquids are computed using a revised entropy theory of glass formation that permits the chain backbone and the side groups to have different rigidities. The theory is applied to glass formation at constant pressure or constant temperature. Our calculations provide new insights into physical factors influencing the breadth of the glass transition and the associated growth of relaxation times.     

Aging of the Johari-Goldstein relaxation in the glass-forming liquids sorbitol and xylitol

Employing frequency-dependent dielectric susceptibility we characterize the aging in two supercooled liquids, sorbitol and xylitol, below their calorimetric glass transition temperatures. In addition to the alpha relaxation that tracks the structural dynamics, the susceptibility of both liquids possesses a secondary Johari-Goldstein relaxation at higher frequencies. Following a quench through the glass transition, the susceptibility slowly approaches the equilibrium behavior. For both liquids, the magnitude of the Johari-Goldstein relaxation displays a dependence on the time since the quench, or aging time, that is quantitatively very similar to the age dependence of the alpha peak frequency. The Johari-Goldstein relaxation time remains constant during aging for sorbitol while it decreases slightly with age for xylitol. Hence, one cannot sensibly assign a fictive temperature to the Johari-Goldstein relaxation. This behavior contrasts with that of liquids lacking distinct Johari-Goldstein peaks for which the excess wing of the alpha peak tracks the main part of the peak during aging, enabling the assignment of a single fictive temperature to the entire spectrum. The aging behavior of the Johari-Goldstein relaxation time further calls into question the possibility that the relaxation time possesses stronger temperature dependence in equilibrium than is observed in the out-of-equilibrium state below the glass transition.     

Analysis of dielectric and conductive dispersion above Tg in glass-forming molecular liquids

Dynamics of the nonassociated supercooled liquids N-methyl-epsilon-caprolactam (NMEC) and glycerol in the frequency domain are investigated using full complex-nonlinear-least-squares fitting of immittance spectroscopy data for appreciable temperature ranges above the glass transition. Such fitting, not previously used for these materials, helps to identify physical processes responsible for the data and elements of their common behavior. Several different fitting models were applied to find a physically plausible best-fitting one to distinguish quantitatively between the dielectric effects of dipoles and the conductive effects of mobile ions. The utility of many composite fitting models was investigated, and although a pure conductive-system dispersive (CSD) fitting model led to good but physically unrealistic fits of all data sets, the dielectric-system dispersive (DSD) Davidson-Cole model best fitted the alpha-dispersion part of the responses. Nevertheless, the series combination of such a DSD model and a separate CSD model (one not associated with electrode effects) was found to yield much better fitting of the data for both materials. Although the CSD model plays somewhat the role of the conventional parallel DSD Johari-Goldstein beta-response, it is here in series and arises from mobile impurity-ion effects rather than from dipolar ones. Previous analyses of data of the present and other molecular materials have often involved two DSD models in parallel, but fitting with such a composite model led here to less physically plausible parameter values and ones with appreciably more uncertainties. Surprisingly, the series DSD and CSD composite-model fits led to comparable estimated values of the NMEC and glycerol dielectric strength parameters, as well as to the nearly equal small thermal activation energies of these parameters.     

Dynamics of glass-forming liquids. XI. Fluctuating environments by dielectric spectroscopy

The dielectric relaxation of a 1 wt % mixture of di-n-butylether in 3-methylpentane has been measured across a range of eight decades, in which the characteristic relaxation time varies from 5 s to 50 ns. Each loss spectrum is a superposition of the dispersive solvent peak and a Debye peak which is one decade slower and readily assigned to the larger and more dipolar solute molecules. Fluctuating environments or rate exchange is made responsible for the Debye nature of probe rotation, implying that the environmental relaxation times fluctuate on time scales which are faster than the rotational correlation decay of the probe molecule. Within the experimental range from 2.2 s to 42 ns regarding the mean alpha-relaxation time, the results are consistent with the exchange time matching the upper limit of structural relaxation times or two to three times their average value. As T(g) is approached, no indication for a variation in exchange behavior or for slower environmental fluctuations is found.