Comparative investigation of ruthenium-based metathesis catalysts bearing N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligands

Exchange of one PCy3 unit of the classical Grubbs catalyst 1 by N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligands leads to "second-generation" metathesis catalysts of superior reactivity and increased stability. Several complexes of this type have been prepared and fully characterized, six of them by X-ray crystallography. These include the unique chelate complexes 13 and 14 in which the NHC- and the Ru-CR entities are tethered to form a metallacycle. A particularly favorable design feature is that the reactivity of such catalysts can be easily adjusted by changing the electronic and steric properties of the NHC ligands. The catalytic activity also strongly depends on the solvent used; NMR investigations provide a tentative explanation of this effect. Applications of the "second-generation" catalysts to ring closing alkene metathesis and intramolecular enyne cycloisomerization reactions provide insights into their catalytic performance. From these comparative studies it is deduced that no single catalyst is optimal for different types of applications. The search for the most reactive catalyst for a specific transformation is facilitated by IR thermography allowing a rapid and semi-quantitative ranking among a given set of catalysts.     

In an attempt to provide a user's guide to the galaxy of benzylidene, alkoxybenzylidene, and indenylidene ruthenium olefin metathesis catalysts

The data reported in this paper demonstrate that great care must be taken when choosing an appropriate catalyst for a given metathesis reaction. First-generation catalysts were found to be useful in the metathesis of sterically unhindered substrates. Second-generation catalysts (under optimised conditions) showed good to excellent activities toward sterically hindered and electron-withdrawing group (EWG)-substituted alkenes that do not react using the first-generation complexes. A strong temperature effect was noted on all of the reactions tested. Interestingly, attempts to force a reaction by increasing the catalyst loading were much less effective. Therefore, when possible, it is suggested that metathesis transformations should be carried out with a second-generation catalyst at 70 degrees C in toluene. However, different second-generation catalysts proved to be optimal for different applications and no single catalyst outperformed all others in all cases. Nevertheless, some empirical rules can be deduced from the model experiments, providing preliminary hints for the selection of the optimal catalysts.     

Improvement in olefin metathesis using a new generation of ruthenium catalyst bearing an imidazolylidene ligand: synthesis of heterocycles

A number of heterocycles have been prepared in very good yields using 1,3-dimesitylimidazol-2-ylidene ruthenium benzylidene 1. This catalyst displays increased activity for ring-closing metathesis of some hindered heterodienes which did not cyclize using the Grubbs catalyst 2. The scope of the olefin metathesis has been expanded.     

A Fast‐Initiating Ionically Tagged Ruthenium Complex: A Robust Supported Pre‐catalyst for Batch‐Process and Continuous‐Flow Olefin Metathesis

In this study, a new pyridinium‐tagged Ru complex was designed and anchored onto sulfonated silica, thereby forming a robust and highly active supported olefin‐metathesis pre‐catalyst for applications under batch and continuous‐flow conditions. The involvement of an oxazine–benzylidene ligand allowed the reactivity of the formed Ru pre‐catalyst to be efficiently controlled through both steric and electronic activation. The oxazine scaffold facilitated the introduction of the pyridinium tag, thereby affording the corresponding cationic pre‐catalyst in good yield. Excellent activities in ring‐closing (RCM), cross (CM), and enyne metathesis were observed with only 0.5 mol % loading of the pre‐catalyst. When this powerful pre‐catalyst was immobilized onto a silica‐based cationic‐exchange resin, a versatile catalytically active material for batch reactions was generated that also served as fixed‐bed material for flow reactors. This system could be reused at 1 mol % loading to afford metathesis products in high purity with very low ruthenium contamination under batch conditions (below 5 ppm). Scavenging procedures for both batch and flow processes were conducted, which led to a lowering of the ruthenium content to as little as one tenth of the original values.     

A new stable Hoveyda-Grubbs catalyst with mixed anionic ligands

The synthesis and characterisation of a new highly active Hoveyda-Grubbs 2nd generation type catalyst is described. Substitution of one chloride ligand with a partially fluorinated trialkoxysilyl substituted carboxylate leads to the stable monocarboxylate ruthenium catalyst (3). This catalyst represents the first example of a stable and isolable mono-chloride exchanged carboxylate complex suitable for both homogeneous and heterogeneous metathesis. The reactivity of the new catalyst was tested in representative metathesis reactions and offers an activity comparable to the parent dichloride system (1).     

Efficient synthesis of 16-28 membered macrocyclic crown amides via ring closing metathesis

Ring closing metathesis of suitable diamides containing 1,ω-dienes led to efficient synthetic approaches towards macrocylic polyoxadiamides 1-18 with 16-28 membered ring sizes in good to excellent yields using Grubbs' catalyst.     

Activity and stereoselectivity of Ru-based catalyst bearing a fluorinated imidazolinium ligand

Grubbs II generation catalyst (3), bearing a fluorinated imidazolinium ligand, was investigated in cross metathesis (CM), ring closing metathesis (RCM) and ring opening polymerization metathesis (ROMP) for a variety of substrates. Kinetic studies showed reduced stability of the catalyst in methylene chloride following the first 15 minutes of reaction preventing a higher efficiency despite the very high activity. Beneficial solvent effects on the catalyst stability were observed by performing RCM in C₆F₆.      

A fluorous-tagged linker from which small molecules are released by ring-closing metathesis

A fluorous-tagged linker for the parallel synthesis of small- and medium-ring and macrocyclic nitrogen heterocycles using ring-closing metathesis is described. The linker was designed such that "cyclization-release" of the cyclic heterocyclic products was coupled with liberation of the active catalyst. The design of the linker was validated using a non-fluorous-tagged model. A wide range of unsaturated alcohols were used as reagents to functionalize a fluorous-tagged sulfonamide, (Z)-{N-[4-(2-(N'-3,3,4,4,5,5,6,6,7,7,8,8,9,9,10,10,10-heptadecafluorodecyl)-4-methylsulfonamido)methylallyloxy]but-2-enyl}-2-nitrobenzenesulfonamide, using Fukuyama-Mitsunobu reactions; in each case, fluorous-solid-phase extraction (F-SPE) was used to purify the functionalized linker from the excess reagents. In general, the "cyclization-release" of cyclic products was triggered using a light-fluorous tagged derivative of the Grubbs-Hoveyda second-generation catalyst. After the metathesis step, F-SPE was used to purify released cyclic compounds from the fluorous-tagged linker and the fluorous-tagged catalyst. The scope and limitations of the approach were determined using a range of substrates which probed different aspects of the functionalization and metathesis steps. In the study as a whole, a wide range of small- and medium-ring and macrocyclic nitrogen heterocycles were prepared using polyene and polyenyne metathesis cascades.     

One-pot enyne metathesis/Diels-Alder reaction for the construction of highly functionalized novel polycyclic aza-compounds

Various tricyclic dienes were synthesized via enyne metathesis using the first generation Grubbs catalyst. The enyne metathesis proceeded smoothly in refluxing CH₂Cl₂ with a low catalyst loading (3.0 mol %), giving good yields (72-89%) of the tricyclic products 6 and 16. The resulting 1,3-dienes are suitable precursors of polycyclic structures via a Diels-Alder process. One-pot RCM/Diels-Alder reactions of the enyne products with dienophiles proceeded smoothly to afford polycyclic compounds as a single cycloadduct. The structures of the Diels-Alder adducts were determined by ¹H NMR spectra and X-ray analysis. The cycloadducts were formed via the approach of the dienophiles towards the diene in endo mode.     

Ene-yne-ene and ene-yne-yne metathesis of norbornene derivatives

Norbornene derivatives 4 and 5 containing sidechains bearing an internal alkyne and either a terminal alkene or a terminal alkyne were found to undergo a cascade of metathesis reactions when treated with ruthenium based metathesis catalysts to form highly functionalised pentacyclic products. The reactions illustrate an interesting difference in reactivity between Grubbs’ catalyst and the second generation catalyst, with the former being more reactive for the early steps of the cascade.     

Cross-metathesis assisted by microwave irradiation

Microwave irradiation effectively accelerates cross-coupling metathesis reactions between deactivated olefins. Reactions have been carried out with the phosphine-free Hoveyda-Grubbs catalyst and the "second generation Grubbs' catalyst." While there have been reports that a "microwave effect" is observed in various transformations, the accelerations we observe are due to the efficient and rapid heating and increased pressure in the microwave apparatus.     

Synthesis of nonracemic allylic hydroxy phosphonates via alkene cross metathesis

Allylic hydroxy phosphonates and their derivatives can be interconverted by using cross metathesis with second generation Grubbs catalyst. The absolute stereochemistry of the starting phosphonate is conserved in the product. Cross metathesis reaction of the acrolein-derived phosphonate 2a yields a series of functionalized allylic hydroxy phosphonates. However, the cross metathesis reaction is often accompanied by competing dimerization and alkene migration reactions leading to a reduction in yield. The cinnamaldehyde- and crotonaldehyde-derived phosphonates 2b and 2c were also examined. In general, the metathesis reactions of phosphonates 2b and 2c are considerably slower than those for phosphonate 2a leading to mixtures. Several hydroxyl-protected derivatives of the phosphonate 2a (methyl carbonate 3a, acetate 4a, N-tosyl carbamate 5a, TBDMS 6a, and acetoacetate 7a) undergo metathesis without competing side reactions to give substituted allylic phosphonates in good to excellent yield.     

A fine-tuned molybdenum hexacarbonyl/phenol initiator for alkyne metathesis

A new, highly potent activator for molybdenum hexacarbonyl and 2-fluorophenol is described. An "instant"catalyst formed in situ from molybdenum hexacarbonyl and 2-fluorophenol shows high activity for cross- and ring-closing alkyne metathesis reaction. The use of 2-fluorophenol can be combined with other activation methods to allow alkyne metathesis at relatively low temperature (80 degrees C).     

Concise synthesis of (S,S)-(+)-dehydrohomoancepsenolide

A concise total synthesis of the bis-butenolide 3 in optically active form is reported. Key steps are a zinc-mediated "three-component coupling" with formation of dienyne 9 which undergoes ring closing metathesis (RCM) on treatment with (PCy(3))(2)Cl(2)Ru=CHPh. Dimerization of the resulting butenolide 11 is then achieved via alkyne metathesis using (tBuO)(3)W&tbd1;CCMe(3) as the catalyst. A Lindlar reduction completes this synthesis which delivers product 3 in only five steps with an overall yield of 25%.     

Refining of plant oils to chemicals by olefin metathesis

Plant oils are attractive substrates for the chemical industry. Their scope for the production of chemicals can be expanded by sophisticated catalytic conversions. Olefin metathesis is an example, which also illustrates generic issues of "biorefining" to chemicals. Utilization on a large scale requires high catalyst activities, which influences the choice of the metathesis reaction. The mixture of different fatty acids composing a technical-grade plant oil substrate gives rise to a range of products. This decisively determines possible process schemes, and potentially provides novel chemicals and intermediates not employed to date.     

Kinetically controlled ring-closing metathesis: synthesis of a potential scaffold for 12-membered salicylic macrolides

For the synthesis of a 12-membered salicylic macrolide scaffold, ring-closing metathesis (RCM) of a omega-diene compound was planned. The stereochemical outcome of the RCM reaction changed depending on the type of Ru catalyst that was used; a "first-generation" Grubbs catalyst produced exclusively the E isomer and "second-generation" catalysts provided a mixture of the E and Z isomers under kinetic control (not thermodynamic control). Considerations for the E/Z selectivity are described.     

Sustainable concepts in olefin metathesis

Ruthenium-catalyzed olefin metathesis reactions represent an attractive and powerful transformation for the formation of new carbon-carbon double bonds. This area is now quite familiar to most chemists as numerous catalysts are available that enable a plethora of olefin metathesis reactions. Nevertheless, with the exception of uses in polymerization reactions, only a limited number of industrial processes use olefin metathesis. This is mainly due to difficulties associated with removing ruthenium from the final products. In this context, a number of studies have been carried out to develop procedures for the removal of the catalyst or the products of catalyst decomposition, however, none are universally attractive so far. This situation has resulted in tremendous activity in the area dealing with supported or tagged versions of homogeneous catalysts. This Review summarizes the numerous studies focused on developing cleaner ruthenium-catalyzed metathesis processes.     

Ring-closing olefin metathesis in the aqueous phase of amphiphilic conetworks consisting of fluorophilic and hydrophilic compartments

A Grubbs-Hoveyda-Type metathesis catalyst bearing a tris(perfluoroalkyl)silyl tag was immobilized in the fluorophilic phase of amphiphilic conetworks (APCNs). This catalytic system was applied to ring-closing metathesis (RCM) reactions in aqueous media. Different substrates were evaluated and with 10 mol% of catalyst at 60 °C good conversions were observed. Reuse of the catalytic system was possible, but resulted generally in lower conversions.     

Understanding the effect of allylic methyls in olefin cross-metathesis

A series of NMR spectroscopy experiments have been conducted with both the model compound, 3-methyl-1-pentene and the corresponding ADMET monomer 3,6,9-trimethylundeca-1,10-diene (11) to better understand the effect of allylic methyls during olefin metathesis chemistry. Traditional ADMET catalysts such as Schrock’s molybdenum (1), and Grubbs’ ruthenium 1st and 2nd generation (2 and 3) were examined under cross-metathesis and ADMET conditions. Regardless of catalyst selection, 50% or less metathesis conversion was observed for all reactions, especially in the case of the more sterically encumbered diene. With Schrock’s molybdenum catalyst 1, the reaction leads to an accumulation of the non-productive metallacyclobutane, trapping the catalyst in an inactive form. With Grubbs’ ruthenium catalysts 2 and 3, the substrate coordinates to the metal center primarily to yield non-productive metathesis, which results in a build-up of the methylidene complex leading to catalyst decomposition. These results are directly correlated to the orientation of the substrate’s bulk during the metallacyclobutane formation, the alkyl branch being adjacent to the metal center in the case of the molybdenum catalyst 1, and opposite to it in the case of ruthenium catalyst 2 and 3.     

Zirconium-mediated metathesis of imines: a study of the scope, longevity, and mechanism of a complicated catalytic system

By kinetically stabilizing imidozirconocene complexes through the use of a sterically demanding ligand, or by generating a more thermodynamically stable resting state with addition of diphenylacetylene, we have developed transition metal-catalyzed imine metathesis reactions that are mechanistically analogous to olefin metathesis reactions catalyzed by metal carbene complexes. When 5 mol % of Cp*Cp(THF)Zr=N(t)Bu is used as the catalyst precursor in the metathesis reaction between PhCH=NPh and p-TolCH=N-p-Tol, a 1:1:1:1 equilibrium mixture with the two mixed imines p-TolCH=NPh and PhCH=N-p-Tol is generated in C(6)D(6) at 105 degrees C. The catalyst was still active after 20 days with an estimated 847 turnovers (t(1/2) 170 m; TON = 1.77 h(-1)). When the azametallacyclobutene Cp(2)Zr(N(Tol)C(Ph)=C(Ph)) is used as the catalyst precursor under similar reaction conditions, a total of 410 turnovers are obtained after 4 days (t(1/2) 170 m; TON = 4.3 h(-1)). An extensive kinetic and equilibrium analysis of the metallacyclobutene-catalyzed metathesis of PhCH=N-p-Tol and p-F-C(6)H(4)CH=N-p-F-C(6)H(4) was carried out by monitoring the concentrations of imines and observable metal-containing intermediates over time. Numerical integration methods were used to fit these data to a detailed mechanism involving coordinatively unsaturated (16-electron) imido complexes as critical intermediates. Examination of the scope of reaction between different organic imines revealed characteristic selectivity that appears to be unique to the zirconium-mediated system. Several zirconocene complexes that could generate the catalytically active "CpCp'Zr=NAr" (Cp' = Cp or Cp*) species in situ were found to be effective agents in the metathetical exchange between different N-aryl imines. N-Alkyl aldimines were found to be completely unreactive toward metathesis with N-aryl aldimines, and metathesis reactions involving the two N-alkyl imines TolCH=NPr and PhCH=NMe gave slow or erratic results, depending on the catalyst used. Metathesis was observed between N-aryl ketimines and N-aryl aldimines, but for N-aryl ketimine substrates, the catalyst resting state consists of zirconocene enamido complexes, generated by the formal C-H activation of the alpha position of the ketimine substrates.