Cold denaturation of the hammerhead ribozyme

Cold denaturation is a thermodynamic phenomenon resulting from a difference in the heat capacities, DeltaCp, of the folded and unfolded states of a macromolecule. Whereas this phenomenon has been extensively studied in proteins, it has been thought not to occur in nucleic acids due to a negligible DeltaCp of folding. Questioning the validity of this assumption, the low-temperature structure of the hammerhead ribozyme, a small catalytic RNA, was investigated by circular dichroism spectroscopy. In the presence of 10 mM Mg2+ at pH 5.0 and 40% methanol, a cold unfolding event likely corresponding to tertiary structure loss was observed with a Tm of -20 degrees C. In 500 mM NaCl at pH 6.6, and 40% methanol, large-scale unfolding of the ribozyme at both hot (Tm = 53 degrees C) and cold (Tm = -1 degrees C) temperatures occurred. Fitting of these data to a two-state model allowed determination of DeltaCp = 3.4 kJ mol-1 K-1, corresponding to >/=0.18 kJ K-1 (mol base pair)-1, in good agreement with recently published calorimetric values for DNA duplexes. These results constitute the first direct observation of cold denaturation of a nucleic acid, and point to the importance of DeltaCp terms in the thermodynamics of nucleic acid folding.     

Solvent structure and hammerhead ribozyme catalysis

Although the hammerhead ribozyme is regarded as a prototype for understanding RNA catalysis, the mechanistic roles of associated metal ions and water molecules in the cleavage reaction remain controversial. We have investigated the catalytic potential of observed divalent metal ions and water molecules bound to a 2 A structure of the full-length hammerhead ribozyme by using X-ray crystallography in combination with molecular dynamics simulations. A single Mn(2+) is observed to bind directly to the A9 phosphate in the active site, accompanying a hydrogen-bond network involving a well-ordered water molecule spanning N1 of G12 (the general base) and 2'-O of G8 (previously implicated in general acid catalysis) that we propose, based on molecular dynamics calculations, facilitates proton transfer in the cleavage reaction. Phosphate-bridging metal interactions and other mechanistic hypotheses are also tested with this approach.     

Steric interference modification of the hammerhead ribozyme

Although the structure of the hammerhead ribozyme is well characterized, many questions remain about its catalytic mechanism. Extensive evidence suggests the necessity of a conformational change en route to the transition state. We report a steric interference modification approach for investigating this change. By placing large 2' modifications at residues insensitive to structurally conservative 2'-deoxy modifications, we hoped to discover structural effects distal to the site of modification. Of twenty residues tested, six were identified where the addition of 2' bulk inhibits cleavage, even though these bulky modifications could be accommodated in the crystal structure without steric clash. It is proposed that these 2'-modifications inhibit cleavage by preventing formation of the alternate, active conformation. Since these 2' effects are present in both domain I and domain II of the hammerhead, the entire catalytic core must undergo conformational changes during catalysis.     

Probing general base catalysis in the hammerhead ribozyme

Recent structural and computational studies have shed new light on the catalytic mechanism and active site structure of the RNA cleaving hammerhead ribozyme. Consequently, specific ribozyme functional groups have been hypothesized to be directly involved in general/acid base catalysis. In order to test this hypothesis, we have developed an affinity label to identify the functional general base in the S. mansoni hammerhead ribozyme. The ribozyme was reacted with a substrate analogue bearing a 2'-bromoacetamide group in place of the nucleophilic 2'-hydroxyl group which would normally be deprotonated by a general base. The electrophilic 2'-bromoacetamide group is poised to alkylate the general base, which is subsequently identified by footprinting analysis. Herein, we demonstrate alkylation of N1 of G12 in the hammerhead ribozyme in a pH and [Mg(2+)] dependent manner that is consistent with the native cleavage reaction. These results provide substantial evidence that deprotonated N1 of G12 functions directly as a general base in the hammerhead ribozyme; moreover, our experiments provide evidence that the pKa of G12 is perturbed downward in the context of the active site structure. We also observed other pH-independent alkylations, which do not appear to reflect the catalytic mechanism, but offer further insight into ribozyme conformation and structure.     

Deciphering RNA recognition: aminoglycoside binding to the hammerhead ribozyme

Aminoglycoside antibiotics inhibit protein biosynthesis and various ribozymes. Structural electrostatic complementarity can explain the inhibition mechanism of the hammerhead ribozyme: positively charged ammonium groups match the negatively charged metalion-binding pockets created by the RNA fold's electrostatic field.     

Role of Mg2+ in hammerhead ribozyme catalysis from molecular simulation

Molecular dynamics simulations have been performed to investigate the role of Mg2+ in the full-length hammerhead ribozyme cleavage reaction. In particular, the aim of this work is to characterize the binding mode and conformational events that give rise to catalytically active conformations and stabilization of the transition state. Toward this end, a series of eight 12 ns molecular dynamics simulations have been performed with different divalent metal binding occupations for the reactant, early and late transition state using recently developed force field parameters for metal ions and reactive intermediates in RNA catalysis. In addition, hybrid QM/MM calculations of the early and late transition state were performed to study the proton-transfer step in general acid catalysis that is facilitated by the catalytic Mg2+ ion. The simulations suggest that Mg2+ is profoundly involved in the hammerhead ribozyme mechanism both at structural and catalytic levels. Binding of Mg2+ in the active site plays a key structural role in the stabilization of stem I and II and to facilitate formation of near attack conformations and interactions between the nucleophile and G12, the implicated general base catalyst. In the transition state, Mg2+ binds in a bridging position where it stabilizes the accumulated charge of the leaving group while interacting with the 2'OH of G8, the implicated general acid catalyst. The QM/MM simulations provide support that, in the late transition state, the 2'OH of G8 can transfer a proton to the leaving group while directly coordinating the bridging Mg2+ ion. The present study provides evidence for the role of Mg2+ in hammerhead ribozyme catalysis. The proposed simulation model reconciles the interpretation of available experimental structural and biochemical data, and provides a starting point for more detailed investigation of the chemical reaction path with combined QM/MM methods.     

A reappraisal,based on (31)P NMR,of the direct coordination of a metal ion with the phosphoryl oxygen at the cleavage site of a hammerhead ribozyme

It has been generally accepted, on the basis of kinetic studies with phosphorothioate-containing substrates and analyses by NMR spectroscopy, that a divalent metal ion interacts directly with the pro-Rp oxygen at the cleavage site in reactions catalyzed by hammerhead ribozymes. However, results of our recent kinetic studies (Zhou, D.-M.; Kumar, P. K. R.; Zhang. L. H.; Taira, K. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1996, 118, 8969-8970. Yoshinari, K.; Taira, K. Nucleic Acids Res. 2000, 28, 1730-1742) demonstrated that a Cd(2+) ion does not interact with the sulfur atom at the Rp position of the scissile phosphate (P1.1) in the ground state or in the transition state. Therefore, in the present study, we attempted to determine by (31)P NMR spectroscopy whether a Cd(2+) ion binds to the P1.1 phosphorothioate at the cleavage site in solution. In the case of the R32-S11S (ribozyme-substrate) complex, neither the Rp- nor the Sp-phosphorothioate signal from the S11S substrate at the cleavage site was perturbed (the change was less than 0.1 ppm) upon the addition of Cd(2+) ions (19 equiv) at pH 5.9 and 8.5. By contrast, we detected the significant perturbation of the P9 phosphorothioate signal from another known metal-binding site (the A9/G10.1 metal-binding motif). The Rp-phosphorothioate signal from A9/G10.1 was shifted by about 10 ppm in the higher field direction upon the addition of Cd(2+) ions. These observations support the results of our kinetic analysis and indicate that a Cd(2+) ion interacts with the sulfur atom of the phosphorothioate at the A9/G10.1 site (P9) but that a Cd(2+) ion does not interact with the sulfur atom at the Rp- or at the Sp-position of the scissile phosphate (P1.1) in the ground state.     

Separate metal requirements for loop interactions and catalysis in the extended hammerhead ribozyme

An extended hammerhead ribozyme derived from Schistosoma mansoni, including conserved loops in stems I and II, has been examined to directly monitor the relationship between docking of loops and its activity using site-directed spin labeling (SDSL) and EPR spectroscopy. Dynamics with EPR spectroscopy and fast-quench kinetics measurements have shown that the docking of stems I and II occurs at low Mg2+ concentrations ([Mg2+]1/2,dock = 0.7 mM, 0.1 M NaCl), but a much weaker Mg2+ interaction ([Mg2+]1/2,cat approximately 90 mM) increases activity to very high maximum rates of approximately 1 s-1 at 0.1 M Na+ and pH 7.0.     

Theoretical examination of Mg(2+)-mediated hydrolysis of a phosphodiester linkage as proposed for the hammerhead ribozyme

The hammerhead ribozyme is an RNA molecule capable of self-cleavage at a unique site within its sequence. Hydrolysis of this phosphodiester linkage has been proposed to occur via an in-line attack geometry for nucleophilic displacement by the 2'-hydroxyl on the adjoining phosphorus to generate a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate ester with elimination of the 5'-hydroxyl group, requiring a divalent metal ion under physiological conditions. The proposed S(N)2(P) reaction mechanism was investigated using density functional theory calculations incorporating the hybrid functional B3LYP to study this metal ion-dependent reaction with a tetraaquo magnesium (II)-bound hydroxide ion. For the Mg(2+)-catalyzed reaction, the gas-phase geometry optimized calculations predict two transition states with a kinetically insignificant, yet clearly defined, pentacoordinate intermediate. The first transition state located for the reaction is characterized by internal nucleophilic attack coupled to proton transfer. The second transition state, the rate-determining step, involves breaking of the exocyclic P-O bond where a metal-ligated water molecule assists in the departure of the leaving group. These calculations demonstrate that the reaction mechanism incorporating a single metal ion, serving as a Lewis acid, functions as a general base and can afford the necessary stabilization to the leaving group by orienting a water molecule for catalysis.     

Coordination environment of a site-bound metal ion in the hammerhead ribozyme determined by 15N and 2H ESEEM spectroscopy

Although site-bound Mg2+ ions have been proposed to influence RNA structure and function, establishing the molecular properties of such sites has been challenging due largely to the unique electrostatic properties of the RNA biopolymer. We have previously determined that, in solution, the hammerhead ribozyme (a self-cleaving RNA) has a high-affinity metal ion binding site characterized by a K(d,app) < 10 microM for Mn2+ in 1 M NaCl and speculated that this site has functional importance in the ribozyme cleavage reaction. Here we determine both the precise location and the hydration level of Mn2+ in this site using ESEEM (electron spin-echo envelope modulation) spectroscopy. Definitive assignment of the high-affinity site to the activity-sensitive A9/G10.1 region is achieved by site-specific labeling of G10.1 with 15N guanine. The coordinated metal ion retains four water ligands as measured by 2H ESEEM spectroscopy. The results presented here show that a functionally important, specific metal binding site is uniquely populated in the hammerhead ribozyme even in a background of high ionic strength. Although it has a relatively high thermodynamic affinity, this ion remains partially hydrated and is chelated to the RNA by just two ligands.     

Detection of a proton-transfer process by kinetic solvent isotope effects in NH(4)(+)-mediated reactions catalyzed by a hammerhead ribozyme

Hammerhead ribozymes have been considered to be metalloenzymes. However, this proposal was recently questioned by the finding that the reaction proceeds in the presence of high concentrations of monovalent ions such as NH(4)(+) ions and in the absence of any divalent metal ions. Our present analysis based on solvent isotope effects indicates that (1) a proton transfer(s) occurs only in the NH(4)(+)-mediated reaction but not in metal-ion-mediated reactions such as Mg(2+)- and Li(+)-mediated reactions, (2) the catalyst that stabilizes the 5' leaving group in the NH(4)(+)-mediated reaction is different from that in the metal-ion-mediated HH ribozyme reactions, (3) an NH(4)(+) ion seems to act as a general acid catalyst, and (4) a nucleobase alone should not be the catalyst.     

Relationship between catalytic activity and secondary structure of a hammerhead ribozyme: A study using thermodynamic parameters for RNA structure prediction

Abstract

The stabilization energy for the secondary structures of wild-type hammerhead and mutant ribozymes has been calculated at different salt conditions and temperatures by using the thermodynamic parameters for RNA structure prediction. The most stable structure at each condition has been searched and the obtained secondary structure is compared with the structure suggested phylogenetically or experimentally. The results indicate that the hammerhead-type secondary structure of the ribozyme and its reactivity correlate with each other. The multibranched loop containing the self-cleavage site of the ribozyme particularly should be a key structure in the hammerhead ribozyme reaction. The predicted secondary structures also suggest that the reactivity of the hammerhead ribozyme should be very much lower at 10°C than that at 37°C.     

Chemical synthesis of an artificially branched hairpin ribozyme variant with RNA cleavage activity

Due to the development in the field of RNA synthesis over the past decade of years, preparation of RNA oligonucleotides longer than 50 nucleotides is possible today. In this report, we describe the chemical preparation of a branched RNA molecule with RNA cleavage activity consisting of 81 nucleotides. It is derived from the hairpin ribozyme, a small catalytic RNA occurring in nature. The hairpin ribozyme consists of two separately folded domains (loop A and loop B domain), which can be joined in a number of different ways without loss of activity. In the construct presented here, 2′-deoxy-N4-(6-hydroxyhexyl)-5-methylcytidine was introduced to connect the loop B domain with the loop A domain via an artificial branch. The synthesized branched RNA is able to catalyze the cleavage of a number of suitable substrates. Compared with the corresponding non-branched reverse-joined ribozyme it cleaves its substrates only 5-fold slower. Surprisingly, no ligation activity could be detected.     

NMR-based reappraisal of the coordination of a metal ion at the pro-Rp oxygen of the A9/G10.1 site in a hammerhead ribozyme

In the identification of a metal-binding site within enzymes, kinetic analyses based on thio-effects and Cd(2+)-rescues are widely used. In those analyses, kinetic studies using a phosphorothioate have been discussed on the premise that the substitution by a sulfur atom does not change the conformation of a ribozyme. However, our present NMR structural analysis demonstrates the change of the conformation at the metal-binding site by Rp-sulfur but not by Sp-sulfur substitution and warns against incautious interpretations of thio-effects and rescue phenomena in kinetic studies using a phosphorothioate. Our analysis further demonstrates that, in solution, a Cd(2+) ion can interact with an Rp-phosphorothioate (in support of the controversial McKay's structure, Nature 1994, 372, 68-74) and with an Sp-phosphorothioate (in support of the controversial Scott's structure, Cell 1995, 81, 991-1002) at the metal-binding A9/G10.1 site and that, in the former case, the bound Cd(2+) ion can return the ribozyme to an active conformation and rescue its enzymatic activity.     

Molecular dynamics analysis of Mg2+-dependent cleavage of a pistol ribozyme reveals a fail-safe secondary ion for catalysis

Pistol ribozymes comprise a class of small, self-cleaving RNAs discovered via comparative genomic analysis. Prior work in the field has probed the kinetics of the cleavage reaction, as well as the influence of various metal ion cofactors that accelerate the process. In the current study, we performed unbiased and unconstrained molecular dynamics simulations from two current high-resolution pistol crystal structures, and we analyzed trajectory data within the context of the currently accepted ribozyme mechanistic framework. Root-mean-squared deviations, radial distribution functions, and distributions of nucleophilic angle-of-attack reveal insights into the potential roles of three magnesium ions with respect to catalysis and overall conformational stability of the molecule. A series of simulation trajectories containing in silico mutations reveal the relatively flexible and partially interchangeable roles of two particular magnesium ions within solvated hydrogen-bonding distances from the catalytic center.     

Probing the binding of Tb(III) and Eu(III) to the hammerhead ribozyme using luminescence spectroscopy

BACKGROUND: Divalent metal ions serve as structural as well as catalytic cofactors in the hammerhead ribozyme reaction. The natural cofactor in these reactions is Mg(II), but its spectroscopic silence makes it difficult to study. We previously showed that a single Tb(III) ion inhibits the hammerhead ribozyme by site-specific competition for a Mg(II) ion and therefore can be used as a spectroscopic probe for the Mg(II) it replaces. RESULTS: Lanthanide luminescence spectroscopy was used to study the coordination environment around Tb(III) and Eu(III) ions bound to the structurally well-characterized site on the hammerhead ribozyme. Sensitized emission and direct excitation experiments show that a single lanthanide ion binds to the ribozyme under these conditions and that three waters of hydration are displaced from the Tb(III) upon binding the RNA. Furthermore, we show that these techniques allow the comparison of binding affinities for a series of ions to this site. The binding affinities for ions at the G5 site correlates linearly with the function Z(2)/r of the aqua ion (where Z is the charge and r is the radius of the ion). CONCLUSIONS: This study compares the crystallographic nature of the G5 metal-binding site with solution measurements and gives a clearer picture of the coordination environment of this ion. These results provide one of the best characterized metal-binding sites from a ribozyme, so we use this information to compare the RNA site with that of typical metalloproteins.     

Origin of mutational effects at the C3 and G8 positions on hammerhead ribozyme catalysis from molecular dynamics simulations

A series of ten 60 ns molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the native and mutated full length hammerhead ribozymes in the reactant state and in an activated precursor state (G8:2'OH deprotonated) are reported. Mutant simulations include the C3U, G8A, and G8I single mutants and a C3U/G8A double mutant that exhibits an experimental rescue effect. The results provide critical details into the origin of the observed mutation effects and support a mechanism where the 2'OH of G8 acts as a general acid catalyst that is held in position through Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding between G8 and C3.