Ensuring the reliability of stable isotope ratio data—beyond the principle of identical treatment

The need for inter-laboratory comparability is crucial to facilitate the globalisation of scientific networks and the development of international databases to support scientific and criminal investigations. This article considers what lessons can be learned from a series of inter-laboratory comparison exercises organised by the Forensic Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometry (FIRMS) network in terms of reference materials (RMs), the management of data quality, and technical limitations. The results showed that within-laboratory precision (repeatability) was generally good but between-laboratory accuracy (reproducibility) called for improvements. This review considers how stable isotope laboratories can establish a system of quality control (QC) and quality assurance (QA), emphasising issues of repeatability and reproducibility. For results to be comparable between laboratories, measurements must be traceable to the international δ-scales and, because isotope ratio measurements are reported relative to standards, a key aspect is the correct selection, calibration, and use of international and in-house RMs. The authors identify four principles which promote good laboratory practice. The principle of identical treatment by which samples and RMs are processed in an identical manner and which incorporates three further principles; the principle of identical correction (by which necessary corrections are identified and evenly applied), the principle of identical scaling (by which data are shifted and stretched to the international δ-scales), and the principle of error detection by which QC and QA results are monitored and acted upon. To achieve both good repeatability and good reproducibility it is essential to obtain RMs with internationally agreed δ-values. These RMs will act as the basis for QC and can be used to calibrate further in-house QC RMs tailored to the activities of specific laboratories. In-house QA standards must also be developed to ensure that QC-based calibrations and corrections lead to accurate results for samples. The δ-values assigned to RMs must be recorded and reported with all data. Reference materials must be used to determine what corrections are necessary for measured data. Each analytical sequence of samples must include both QC and QA materials which are subject to identical treatment during measurement and data processing. Results for these materials must be plotted, monitored, and acted upon. Periodically international RMs should be analysed as an in-house proficiency test to demonstrate results are accurate.     

Anchored Mediator Enabling Shuttle-Free Redox Mediation in Lithium-Oxygen Batteries

Redox mediators (RMs) are considered an effective countermeasure to reduce the large polarization in lithium-oxygen batteries. Nevertheless, achieving sufficient enhancement of the cyclability is limited by the trade-offs of freely mobile RMs, which are beneficial for charge transport but also trigger the shuttling phenomenon. Here, we successfully decoupled the charge-carrying redox property of RMs and shuttling phenomenon by anchoring the RMs in polymer form, where physical RM migration was replaced by charge transfer along polymer chains. Using PTMA (poly(2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-1-piperidinyloxy-4-yl methacrylate)) as a polymer model system based on the well-known RM tetramethylpiperidinyloxyl (TEMPO), it is demonstrated that PTMA can function as stationary RM, preserving the redox activity of TEMPO. The efficiency of RM-mediated Li₂O₂ decomposition remains remarkably stable without the consumption of oxidized RMs or degradation of the lithium anode, resulting in an improved performance of the lithium-oxygen cell.     

BCR reference materials for food and agricultural analysis: an overview

Summary The BCR is a research programme of the European Communities having the broad aim of improving accuracy and measurement harmony in areas of concern at Community level. Much of the work is directly relevant to the removal of trading and other obstacles as is necessary for the achievement of a single European market by 1992.The presentation provides an overview of the sector of the programme concerned with Reference Materials (RMs) for food and agricultural analyses.Summarises are given of activities for inorganic, trace organic and nutritional analyses, for calibration of rapid methods (NMR, NIR, XRF and Immuno-assay techniques) and technological measurements (industrial quality of cereals, food colour, water-sorption and detection of fraudulent addition of sugar during wine making by NMR). An alphabetic listing of analytes and properties studied during the programme is given.

---

BCR-Referenzmaterialien für die Lebensmittel- und landwirtschaftliche Analyse — Ein Überblick

     

Anchored Mediator Enabling Shuttle‐Free Redox Mediation in Lithium‐Oxygen Batteries

Redox mediators (RMs) are considered an effective countermeasure to reduce the large polarization in lithium‐oxygen batteries. Nevertheless, achieving sufficient enhancement of the cyclability is limited by the trade‐offs of freely mobile RMs, which are beneficial for charge transport but also trigger the shuttling phenomenon. Here, we successfully decoupled the charge‐carrying redox property of RMs and shuttling phenomenon by anchoring the RMs in polymer form, where physical RM migration was replaced by charge transfer along polymer chains. Using PTMA (poly(2,2,6,6‐tetramethyl‐1‐piperidinyloxy‐4‐yl methacrylate)) as a polymer model system based on the well‐known RM tetramethylpiperidinyloxyl (TEMPO), it is demonstrated that PTMA can function as stationary RM, preserving the redox activity of TEMPO. The efficiency of RM‐mediated Li₂O₂ decomposition remains remarkably stable without the consumption of oxidized RMs or degradation of the lithium anode, resulting in an improved performance of the lithium‐oxygen cell.     

Review of neutron activation analysis in the standardization and study of reference materials, including its application to radionuclide reference materials

Summary Neutron activation analysis (NAA) plays a very important role in the certification of reference materials (RMs) and their characterization, including homogeneity testing. The features of the method are briefly reviewed, particularly aspects relating to its completely independent nuclear basis, its virtual freedom from blank problems, and its capacity for self-verification. This last aspect, arising from the essentially isotopic character of NAA, can be exploited by using different nuclear reactions and induced nuclides, and the possibility of employing two modes, one instrumental (nondestructive), the other radiochemical (destructive). This enables the derivation of essentially independent analytical information and the unique capacity of NAA for self-validation. The application of NAA to quantify natural or man-made radionuclides such as uranium, thorium, ²³⁷Np, ¹²⁹I and ²³⁰Th is discussed, including its advantages over conventional radiometric methods, and its usefulness in providing independent data for nuclides where other confirmatory analyses are impossible, or are only recently becoming available through newer atom counting techniques. Certain additional, prospective uses of NAA in the study of RMs and potential RMs are mentioned, including transmutation reactions, creation of endogenously radiolabelled matrices for production and study of RMs (such as dissolution and leaching tests, use as incorporated radiotracers for chemical recovery correction), and the possibility of molecular activation analysis for speciation.     

Nanoscale Control Over Interfacial Properties in Mixed Reverse Micelles Formulated by Using Sodium 1,4‐bis‐2‐ethylhexylsulfosuccinate and Tri‐n‐octyl Phosphine Oxide Surfactants

The interfacial properties of pure reverse micelles (RMs) are a consequence of the magnitude and nature of noncovalent interactions between confined water and the surfactant polar head. Addition of a second surfactant to form mixed RMs is expected to influence these interactions and thus affect these properties at the nanoscale level. Herein, pure and mixed RMs stabilized by sodium 1,4‐bis‐2‐ethylhexylsulfosuccinate and tri‐n‐octyl phosphine oxide (TOPO) surfactants in n‐heptane were formulated and studied by varying both the water content and the TOPO mole fraction. The microenvironment generated was sensed by following the solvatochromic behavior of the 1‐methyl‐8‐oxyquinolinium betaine probe and ³¹P NMR spectroscopy. The results reveal unique properties of mixed RMs and we give experimental evidence that free water can be detected in the polar core of the mixed RMs at very low water content. We anticipate that these findings will have an impact on the use of such media as nanoreactors for many types of chemical reactions, such as enzymatic reactions and nanoparticle synthesis.     

Effect of the Cationic Surfactant Moiety on the Structure of Water Entrapped in Two Catanionic Reverse Micelles Created from Ionic Liquid‐Like Surfactants

The behavior of water entrapped in reverse micelles (RMs) formed by two catanionic ionic liquid‐like surfactants, benzyl‐n‐hexadecyldimethylammonium 1,4‐bis‐2‐ethylhexylsulfosuccinate (AOT‐BHD) and cetyltrimethylammonium 1,4‐bis‐2‐ethylhexylsulfosuccinate (AOT‐CTA), was investigated by using dynamic (DLS) and static (SLS) light scattering, FTIR, and ¹H NMR spectroscopy techniques. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report in which AOT‐CTA has been used to create RMs and encapsulate water. DLS and SLS results revealed the formation of RMs in benzene and the interaction of water with the RM interface. From FTIR and ¹H NMR spectroscopy data, a difference in the magnitude of the water–catanionic surfactant interaction at the interface is observed. For the AOT‐BHD RMs, a strong water–surfactant interaction can be invoked whereas for AOT‐CTA this interaction seems to be weaker. Consequently, more water molecules interact with the interface in AOT‐BHD RMs with a completely disrupted hydrogen‐bond network, than in AOT‐CTA RMs in which the water structure is partially preserved. We suggest that the benzyl group present in the BHD⁺ moiety in AOT‐BHD is responsible for the behavior of the catanionic interface in comparison with the interface created in AOT‐CTA. These results show that a simple change in the cationic component in the catanionic surfactant promotes remarkable changes in the RMs interface with interesting consequences, in particular when using the systems as nanoreactors.     

New insights on the photophysical behavior of PRODAN in anionic and cationic reverse micelles: from which state or states does it emit?

6-propionyl-2-(N,N-dimethyl)aminonaphtahalene, PRODAN, is widely used as a fluorescent molecular probe because of its significant Stokes shift in polar solvents. It is an aromatic compound with intramolecular charge-transfer states (ICT) that can be particularly useful as a sensor. The nature of the emissive states has not yet been established despite the detailed experimental and theoretical investigations done on this fluorophore. In this work, we performed absorption, steady-state, time-resolved fluorescence (TRES) and time-resolved area normalized emission (TRANES) spectroscopies on the molecular probe PRODAN in the anionic water/sodium 1,4-bis-2-ethylhexylsulfosuccinate (AOT)/n-heptane and the cationic water/benzyl-n-hexadecyl dimethylammonium chloride (BHDC)/benzene reverse micelles (RMs). The experiments were done by varying the surfactant concentrations at a fixed molar ratio (W = [H2O]/[Surfactant]) and changing the water content at a constant surfactant concentration. The results obtained varying the surfactant concentration at W = 0 show a bathochromic shift and an increase in the intensity of the PRODAN emission band due to the PRODAN partition process between the external solvent and the RMs interface. The partition constants, Kp, are quantified from the changes in the PRODAN emission spectra and the steady-state anisotropy () with the surfactant concentration in both RMs. The Kp value is larger in the BHDC than the AOT RMs, probably due to the interaction between the cationic polar head of the surfactant and the aromatic ring of PRODAN. The partition process is confirmed with the TRES experiments, where the data fit to a continuous model, and with the time-resolved area normalized emission spectroscopy (TRANES) spectra, where only one isoemissive point is detected. On the other hand, the emission spectra at W = 10 and 20 show a dual fluorescence with a new band that emerges in the low-energy region of the spectra, a band that was previously assigned to the PRODAN emission from the water pool of RMs. Our studies demonstrate that this band is due to the emission from an ICT state of the molecular probe PRODAN located at the interface of the RMs. These results are also confirmed by the lifetime measurements, the TRES experiments where the results fit to a two-state model, and the time-resolved area normalized emission spectroscopy (TRANES) spectra where three or two isoemissive points are detected in the AOT and BHDC RMs, respectively. In the AOT RMs, Kp values obtained at W = 10 and 20 are almost independent of the water content; the values are higher for the BHDC RMs due to the higher micropolarity of this interface.     

Cationic Reverse Micelles Create Water with Super Hydrogen‐Bond‐Donor Capacity for Enzymatic Catalysis: Hydrolysis of 2‐Naphthyl Acetate by α‐Chymotrypsin

Reverse micelles (RMs) are very good nanoreactors because they can create a unique microenvironment for carrying out a variety of chemical and biochemical reactions. The aim of the present work is to determine the influence of different RM interfaces on the hydrolysis of 2‐naphthyl acetate (2‐NA) by α‐chymotrypsin (α‐CT). The reaction was studied in water/benzyl‐n‐hexadecyldimethylammonium chloride (BHDC)/benzene RMs and, its efficiency compared with that observed in pure water and in sodium 1,4‐bis‐2‐ethylhexylsulfosuccinate (AOT) RMs. Thus, the hydrolysis rates of 2‐NA catalyzed by α‐CT were determined by spectroscopic measurements. In addition, the method used allows the joint evaluation of the substrate partition constant K_p between the organic and the micellar pseudophase and the kinetic parameters: catalytic rate constant k_cat, and the Michaelis constant K_M of the enzymatic reaction. The effect of the surfactant concentration on the kinetics parameters was determined at constant W₀=[H₂O]/[surfactant], and the variation of W₀ with surfactant constant concentration was investigated. The results show that the classical Michaelis–Menten mechanism is valid for α‐CT in all of the RMs systems studied and that the reaction takes place at both RM interfaces. Moreover, the catalytic efficiency values k_cat/K_M obtained in the RMs systems are higher than that reported in water. Furthermore, there is a remarkable increase in α‐CT efficiency in the cationic RMs in comparison with the anionic system, presumably due to the unique water properties found in these confined media. The results show that in cationic RMs the hydrogen‐bond donor capacity of water is enhanced due to its interaction with the cationic interface. Hence, entrapped water can be converted into “super‐water” for the enzymatic reaction studied in this work.     

Surfactant charge effects on the location, vibrational spectra, and relaxation dynamics of cyanoferrates in reverse micelles

Ultrafast infrared spectroscopy has been used to measure vibrational energy relaxation (VER) and reorientation (Tr) times for the high frequency CN stretches of potassium ferrocyanide and ferricyanide and the NO stretch of sodium nitroprusside (SNP) in several reverse micelle (RM) systems using cationic, anionic, and nonionic surfactants. The confinement effects on anion vibrational spectra and dynamics in aqueous RMs depend on the charge of the surfactant that is used to form the RMs. Spectra and VER dynamics of ferrocyanide are not significantly altered in the limited number of RMs in which it could be solubilized. The static spectra of ferricyanide suggest an environment that is most bulklike in anionic RMs and least bulklike in cationic RMs. The dynamics of ferricyanide are slower in cationic RMs and indistinguishable from the bulk in nonionic RMs. The VER dynamics and static spectra of SNP are indistinguishable from the bulk in anionic RMs, but much slower in cationic RMs. This suggests a strong surfactant-solute repulsion in the former and an attraction in the latter. Broad static spectra and probe frequency dependent dynamics are seen for SNP in nonionic RMs, indicating an inhomogeneous distribution of environments. Similar measurements were carried out for SNP in mixtures of water and a model compound containing only the hydrophilic portion of the nonionic surfactants in which RMs are not formed. The results closely resemble those observed for SNP in nonionic RMs and provide evidence that in the latter water penetrates the interface and hydrates the ethylene oxide groups before forming a water pool. The results are consistent with the explanation that Coulombic forces determine the anion location. The anions are repelled to the interior of the water pool, which has a bulklike environment in anionic RMs, and are attracted to the interface in cationic RMs, resulting in a strong interaction with the surfactant. The solute location in the nonionic RMs depends on the hydrophilic nature of the probe, with ferrocyanide and ferricyanide being more hydrophilic than SNP. These results and the dependence on surfactant charge are similar to those reported for azide.     

Dediazoniation in SDS/BuOH/H2O reverse micelles: structural parameters, kinetics, and mechanism of the reaction

Dediazoniation of o-methylbenzenediazonium tetrafluoroborate was investigated in SDS/BuOH/H2O (SDS = sodium dodecyl sulfate) reverse micelles, RMs, and, for comparison, in binary BuOH/H2O mixtures by employing a combination of spectrophotometric and chromatographic techniques. RMs were characterized by steady-state fluorescence; the data indicate that the aggregation number of the RMs increase upon increasing [SDS], while the radius of the water pool is mainly controlled by the amount of water in the system, and that the thickness of the interfacial region increases upon increasing the amount of BuOH in the system, in agreement with literature reports. Experimental evidence suggests that dediazoniation mainly takes place in the interfacial region of the RMs. Kinetic data show that a turnover from the heterolytic to the homolytic mechanism takes place about pH = 5; the variation of the observed rate constants, k(obs,) with pH following an S-shaped curve. At pH approximately 2, k(obs) values are insensitive to solvent composition both in RMs and in the binary mixture; however, k(obs) values in RMs are slightly lower than those in BuOH/H2O, probably due to the presence of SDS. High-performance liquid chromatography analyses of the reaction mixture indicate, in both RMs and in binary mixtures, the main dediazoniation products are the heterolytic ArOH and ArOBu, their yields depending on the composition of the system, and only small (<10%) amounts of the reduction ArH product were detected. The data at low pH are interpreted in terms of a DN + AN dediazoniation mechanism, i.e., a rate-limiting formation of an extremely reactive aryl cation that further reacts with available nucleophiles in the solvation shell.     

Some considerations regarding reference materials and their role in environmental monitoring. Plenary lecture.

After a brief introduction indicating the principal function of reference materials (RMs) in ensuring that the analytical measurement programme is performing reliably, the availability, different types and sources of information on RMs are described. Next, the correspondence of available RMs to present sample demands is discussed, particularly with regard to the adequacy of matrices and analytes, the availability of RMs for 'difficult' trace elements, and the preparation and certification of speciation RMs. The role of RMs in quality control is indicated, and their usage and certain problems which can thereby arise, including total dissolution, homogeneity and their representativeness in relation to samples, are discussed. The application of truly representative RMs in low-level trace element work, as a means of quality control of sampling and storage procedures, is mentioned. Strategies open to the analyst in the total absence of certified RMs are presented, and the importance of publication of independent results by alternative methods for such materials, as a means of establishing consensus values, is stressed. In the situation where results for a particular analyte obtained by different groups for the same (but not identical) biomedical or environmental system differ markedly, a progressive multi-stage exchange scheme is proposed, which is designed to reveal whether the differences arise from analytical factors, sampling effects or real system differences.     

Global perspectives for secondary reference materials for analysis of food and related biological samples

Primary, secondary and tertiary reference materials (RM) play an important role in quality controls of analytical measurements. Logistics of preparation and proper use of primary and secondary RMs are presented. Tertiary (i.e. in-house) control materials are useful as substitutes in the absence of recognized primary or secondary RMs. The lack of interdisciplinary interaction during development of RMs (e.g. in specific areas such as foods), has an important impact on limiting the usefulness of certain types of RMs. The abundance of RMs in some countries and regions appears to have little effect on the existing paucity in RMs in other regions, and the underlying causes are outlined. The ability of a laboratory to produce good quality in-house RMs traceable to recognized primary or secondary RMs is a direct measure of its quest for reliable analytical data. Therefore many laboratories should be encouraged to engage in secondary and tertiary RM activities designed to answer specific measurement problems. In this context, assistance (e.g. practical training opportunities) in identifying simple methods of analyses for their efficacy in determining specific analytes is a source of help that can be extended to countries experiencing limitations in laboratory instrumentation.     

Development of reference materials for microbiological analysis

The reliability of reference materials (RMs) depends on properties such as fitness, robustness, commutability, stability and homogeneity. The development of RMs for microbiological analysis is especially challenged through questions around the stabilisation and recovery of viable cells, the dispersion of precise numbers of cells, matrix effects and, when using molecular techniques, the presence of nucleic acids (e.g. DNA) of dead and live target organisms. However, RMs are indispensable tools for quality control in microbiological analysis. The Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM), as part of the European Commission, concentrates its efforts on the development of RMs to support the development, implementation and monitoring of EU legislation. A special focus is given to highly precise RMs for presence/absence and enumeration tests in microbiological food and water analysis. Another group of new RMs certified by the IRMM comprise DNA-based materials to control the identity of micro-organisms in qualitative assays. All of these activities serve to improve quality control in microbiological analysis. Presented at ‘BERM-10’, April 2006, Charleston, SC, USA.     

Size-selective poorly soluble particulate reference materials for evaluation of quantitative analytical methods

Owing to the absence of readily available certified particulate reference materials (RMs), most analytical methods used to determine particulate contaminant levels in workplace or other environments are validated using solution RMs, which do not assess the robustness of the digestion step for all forms and sizes of particles in a sample. A library of particulate RMs having a range of chemical forms and particle sizes is needed to support a shift in method evaluation strategies to include both solution and particulate RMs. In support of creating this library, we characterized bulk and physically size separated fractions of beryllium oxide (BeO) particles recovered from the machining fluid sludge of an industrial ceramic products grinding operation. Particles were large agglomerates of compact, crystalline BeO primary particles having diameters on the order of several micrometers. As expected, the particle surface area was independent of sieve size, with a range from 3.61 m(2)/g (53-63-microm fraction) to 4.82 m(2)/g (355-600-microm fraction). The density was near the theoretical value (3.01 g/cm(3)). The data support more detailed characterization of the sludge materials for use as size-selective RMs. This work illustrates an approach that can be used to develop RMs that are difficult to digest.     

Reference materials in the Russian system of accreditation of analytical laboratories

 This article is devoted to the role of reference materials (RMs) in chemical analysis and their main applications in analytical laboratories. The principal requirements of the RMs used in accredited laboratories in the Russian Analytical Laboratories Accreditation System (SAAL) are presented. These include the basic regulatory and metrological requirements of RMs. Finally, a review of the provision of RMs used for the analytical control of various test objects is presented. Received: 9 August 1998 / Accepted: 9 November 1998     

Vibrational relaxation of azide in formamide reverse micelles

Static and ultrafast infrared spectroscopy have been used to measure absorption spectra and vibrational energy relaxation (VER) times for the antisymmetric stretching vibrational band of azide, N(3)(-), in formamide-containing reverse micelles (RMs). RMs were formed in n-heptane using the surfactant AOT, sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl) sulfosuccinate. The VER times were found to be significantly longer than in bulk formamide. The VER times became longer as the molar ratio of formamide to AOT, omega(F), was decreased. Decreasing omega(F) also resulted in substantial blue shifts of the azide static absorption band compared to the frequency in bulk formamide. The omega(F) dependent studies are consistent with expected size trends, where a larger RM results in more bulklike polar solvent and faster VER rates. These results are in contrast to aqueous AOT RMs where VER times were indistinguishable from those in the bulk and the static spectral shifts were much smaller. The differences between the static and dynamic behavior in aqueous and formamide RMs are related to differences in structural changes upon confinement in RMs.     

Comparability of reference values

Summary Harmonization of certified values in Reference Materials (RMs) can be carried out by applying nuclear analytical techniques to RMs of various matrix types and concentration levels. Although RMs generally should not be used as primary standards the cross evaluation of concentrations in RMs leads to better compatibility of reference values and thus to a greater agreement between analytical results from different laboratories using these RMs for instrument calibration and quality assurance.     

Effect of Confinement on the Properties of Sequestered Mixed Polar Solvents: Enzymatic Catalysis in Nonaqueous 1,4‐Bis‐2‐ethylhexylsulfosuccinate Reverse Micelles

The influence of different glycerol, N,N‐dimethylformamide (DMF) and water mixtures encapsulated in 1,4‐bis‐2‐ethylhexylsulfosuccinate (AOT)/n‐heptane reverse micelles (RMs) on the enzymatic hydrolysis of 2‐naphthyl acetate by α‐chymotrypsin is demonstrated. In the case of the mixtures with DMF and protic solvents it has been previously shown, using absorption, emission and dynamic light‐scattering techniques, that solvents are segregated inside the polar core of the RMs. Protic solvents anchor to the AOT, whereas DMF locates to the polar core of the aggregate. Thus, DMF not only helps to solubilize the hydrophobic substrate, increasing its effective concentrations but surprisingly, it does not affect the enzyme activity. The importance of ensuring the presence of RMs, encapsulation of the polar solvents and the corrections by substrate partitioning in order to obtain reliable conclusions is highlighted. Moreover, the effect of a constrained environment on solvent–solvent interactions in homogenous media and its impact on the use of RMs as nanoreactors is stressed.     

Determination of anions in extracts from fresh homogenized environmental specimen bank materials by ion chromatography

Summary Ion chromatography has been applied to extracts of cryogenically homogenized biological materials from the German Environmental Specimen Bank (ESB) for the determination of a number of anions (F^–, Cl^–, Br^–, I^–, NO ₃ ^– , PO ₄ ^3– , SO ₄ ^2– , formate, and acetate). For quality assurance in speciation analysis appropriate Reference Materials (RMs) certified for extractable anions are needed. Third generation RMs, as provided by the ESBs, might be a suitable approach to achieve this goal.