On duality in multiple objective linear programming

In this paper we present two approaches to duality in multiple objective linear programming. The first approach is based on a duality relation between maximal elements of a set and minimal elements of its complement. It offers a general duality scheme which unifies a number of known dual constructions and improves several existing duality relations. The second approach utilizes polarity between a convex polyhedral set and the epigraph of its support function. It leads to a parametric dual problem and yields strong duality relations, including those of geometric duality.     

An exact method for computing the nadir values in multiple objective linear programming

In this paper we propose a new method to determine the exact nadir (minimum) criterion values over the efficient set in multiple objective linear programming (MOLP). The basic idea of the method is to determine, for each criterion, the region of the weight space associated with the efficient solutions that have a value in that criterion below the minimum already known (by default, the minimum in the payoff table). If this region is empty, the nadir value has been found. Otherwise, a new efficient solution is computed using a weight vector picked from the delimited region and a new iteration is performed. The method is able to find the nadir values in MOLP problems with any number of objective functions, although the computational effort increases significantly with the number of objectives. Computational experiments are described and discussed, comparing two slightly different versions of the method.     

Robust aspects of solutions in deterministic multiple objective linear programming

We study questions of robustness of linear multiple objective problems in the sense of post-optimal analysis, that is, we study conditions under which a given efficient solution remains efficient when the criteria/objective matrix undergoes some alterations. We consider addition or removal of certain criteria, convex combination with another criteria matrix, or small perturbations of its entries. We provide a necessary and sufficient condition for robustness in a verifiable form and give two formulae to compute the radius of robustness.     

PROMISE: A DSS for multiple objective stochastic linear programming problems

Most of the multiple objective linear programming (MOLP) methods which have been proposed in the last fifteen years suppose deterministic contexts, but because many real problems imply uncertainty, some methods have been recently developed to deal with MOLP problems in stochastic contexts. In order to help the decision maker (DM) who is placed before such stochastic MOLP problems, we have built a Decision Support System called PROMISE. On the one hand, our DSS enables the DM to identify many current stochastic contexts: risky situations and also situations of partial uncertainty. On the other hand, according to the nature of the uncertainty, our DSS enables the DM to choose the most appropriate interactive stochastic MOLP method among the available methods, if such a method exists, and to solve his problem via the chosen method.     

Sensitivity analysis on the priority of the objective functions in lexicographic multiple objective linear programs

This paper deals with a class of multiple objective linear programs (MOLP) called lexicographic multiple objective linear programs (LMOLP). In this paper, by providing an efficient algorithm which employs the preceding computations as well, it is shown how we can solve the LMOLP problem if the priority of the objective functions is changed. In fact, the proposed algorithm is a kind of sensitivity analysis on the priority of the objective functions in the LMOLP problems.     

Approximating the Pareto optimal set using a reduced set of objective functions

Real-world applications of multi-objective optimization often involve numerous objective functions. But while such problems are in general computationally intractable, it is seldom necessary to determine the Pareto optimal set exactly. A significantly smaller computational burden thus motivates the loss of precision if the size of the loss can be estimated. We describe a method for finding an optimal reduction of the set of objectives yielding a smaller problem whose Pareto optimal set w.r.t. a discrete subset of the decision space is as close as possible to that of the original set of objectives. Utilizing a new characterization of Pareto optimality and presuming a finite decision space, we derive a program whose solution represents an optimal reduction. We also propose an approximate, computationally less demanding formulation which utilizes correlations between the objectives and separates into two parts. Numerical results from an industrial instance concerning the configuration of heavy-duty trucks are also reported, demonstrating the usefulness of the method developed. The results show that multi-objective optimization problems can be significantly simplified with an induced error which can be measured.     

A geometrical analysis of the efficient outcome set in multiple objective convex programs with linear criterion functions

This article performs a geometrical analysis of the efficient outcome setY _E of a multiple objective convex program (MLC) with linear criterion functions. The analysis elucidates the facial structure ofY _E and of its pre-image, the efficient decision setX _E . The results show thatY _E often has a significantly-simpler structure thanX _E . For instance, although both sets are generally nonconvex and their maximal efficient faces are always in one-to-one correspondence, large numbers of extreme points and faces inX _E can map into non-facial subsets of faces inY _E , but not vice versa. Simple tests for the efficiency of faces in the decision and outcome sets are derived, and certain types of faces in the decision set are studied that are immune to a common phenomenon called collapsing. The results seem to indicate that significant computational benefits may potentially be derived if algorithms for problem (MLC) were to work directly with the outcome set of the problem to find points and faces ofY _E , rather than with the decision set.     

Random problem generation and the computation of efficient extreme points in multiple objective linear programming

This paper looks at the task of computing efficient extreme points in multiple objective linear programming. Vector maximization software is reviewed and the ADBASE solver for computing all efficient extreme points of a multiple objective linear program is described. To create MOLP test problems, models for random problem generation are discussed. In the computational part of the paper, the numbers of efficient extreme points possessed by MOLPs (including multiple objective transportation problems) of different sizes are reported. In addition, the way the utility values of the efficient extreme points might be distributed over the efficient set for different types of utility functions is investigated. Not surprisingly, results show that it should be easier to find good near-optimal solutions with linear utility functions than with, for instance, Tchebycheff types of utility functions.Dedicated to Professor George B. Dantzig on the occasion of his eightieth birthday.     

Calculus of convex polyhedra and polyhedral convex functions by utilizing a multiple objective linear programming solver

ABSTRACT

The article deals with operations defined on convex polyhedra or polyhedral convex functions. Given two convex polyhedra, operations like Minkowski sum, intersection and closed convex hull of the union are considered. Basic operations for one convex polyhedron are, for example, the polar, the conical hull and the image under affine transformation. The concept of a P-representation of a convex polyhedron is introduced. It is shown that many polyhedral calculus operations can be expressed explicitly in terms of P-representations. We point out that all the relevant computational effort for polyhedral calculus consists in computing projections of convex polyhedra. In order to compute projections we use a recent result saying that multiple objective linear programming (MOLP) is equivalent to the polyhedral projection problem. Based on the MOLP solver bensolve a polyhedral calculus toolbox for Matlab and GNU Octave is developed. Some numerical experiments are discussed.     

Using support vector machines to learn the efficient set in multiple objective discrete optimization

We propose using support vector machines (SVMs) to learn the efficient set in multiple objective discrete optimization (MODO). We conjecture that a surface generated by SVM could provide a good approximation of the efficient set. As one way of testing this idea, we embed the SVM-approximated efficient set information into a Genetic Algorithm (GA). This is accomplished by using a SVM-based fitness function that guides the GA search. We implement our SVM-guided GA on the multiple objective knapsack and assignment problems. We observe that using SVM improves the performance of the GA compared to a benchmark distance based fitness function and may provide competitive results.     

A compromise procedure for the multiple objective linear fractional programming problem

A generalization of a well-known multiple objective linear fractional programming (MOLFP) problem, the multiple objective fractional programming (MOFP) problem, is formulated. A concept of multiple objective programming (MOP) problem corresponding to MOFP is introduced and some relations between those problems are examined. Based on these results, a compromise procedure for MOLFP problem is proposed. A numerical example is given to show how the procedure works.     

Determination of the efficient set in multiobjective linear programming

This paper develops a method for finding the whole set of efficient points of a multiobjective linear problem. Two algorithms are presented; the first one describes the set of all efficient vertices and all efficient rays of the constraint polyhedron, while the second one generates the set of all efficient faces. The method has been tested on several examples for which numerical results are reported.The authors are grateful to Professor W. Stadler and an anonymous referee for their helpful comments and corrections.     

On the nucleolus of NTU-games defined by multiple objective linear programs

In this article we derive a class of cooperative games with non-transferable utility from multiple objective linear programs. This is done in order to introduce the nucleolus, a solution concept from cooperative game theory, as a solution to multiple objective linear problems.We show that the nucleolus of such a game is a singleton, which is characterized by inclusion in the least core and the reduced game property. Furthermore the nucleolus satisfies efficiency, anonymity and strategic equivalence.We also present a polynomially bounded algorithm for computation of the nucleolus. Letn be the number of objective functions. The nucleolus is obtained by solving at most2n linear programs. Initially the ideal point is computed by solvingn linear programs. Then a sequence of at mostn linear programs is solved, and the nucleolus is obtained as the unique solution of the last program.Financial support from Nordic Academy for Advanced Study (NorFA) is gratefully acknowledged. Part of this work was done during autumn 1993 at Institute of Finance and Management Science, Norwegian School of Economics and Business Administration.     

A method for finding well-dispersed subsets of non-dominated vectors for multiple objective mixed integer linear programs

We present an algorithm for generating a subset of non-dominated vectors of multiple objective mixed integer linear programming. Starting from an initial non-dominated vector, the procedure finds at each iteration a new one that maximizes the infinity-norm distance from the set dominated by the previously found solutions. When all variables are integer, it can generate the whole set of non-dominated vectors.     

A weight set decomposition algorithm for finding all efficient extreme points in the outcome set of a multiple objective linear program

Various computational difficulties arise in using decision set-based vector maximization methods to solve multiple objective linear programming problems. As a result, several researchers have begun to explore the possibility of solving these problems by examining subsets of their outcome sets, rather than of their decision sets. In this article, we present and validate a basic weight set decomposition approach for generating the set of all efficient extreme points in the outcome set of a multiple objective linear program. Based upon this approach, we then develop an algorithm, called the Weight Set Decomposition Algorithm, for generating this set. A sample problem is solved using this algorithm, and the main potential computational and practical advantages of the algorithm are indicated.     

A taxonomy and an empirical analysis of multiple objective ant colony optimization algorithms for the bi-criteria TSP

The difficulty to solve multiple objective combinatorial optimization problems with traditional techniques has urged researchers to look for alternative, better performing approaches for them. Recently, several algorithms have been proposed which are based on the ant colony optimization metaheuristic. In this contribution, the existing algorithms of this kind are reviewed and a proposal of a taxonomy for them is presented. In addition, an empirical analysis is developed by analyzing their performance on several instances of the bi-criteria traveling salesman problem in comparison with two well-known multi-objective genetic algorithms.