EPR Detection of Free Radicals in UV-lrradiated Skin: Mouse Versus Human

Abstract— Ultraviolet radiation produces free radicals in Skh-1 mouse skin, contributing to photoaging and carcinogenesis. If a mouse model is a general indicator of free radical processes in human skin photobiology, then radical production observed in mouse and human skin should be directly comparative. In this work we show that UV radiation (Λ > 300 nm, 14 μW/cm² UVB; 3.5 mW/cm² UVA) increases the ascorbate free radical (Asc^.-) electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) signal in both Skh-1 mouse skin (45%) and human facial skin biopsies (340%). Visible light (Λ > 400 nm; 0.23 mW/cm² UVA) also increased the Asc^.- signal in human skin samples (45%) but did not increase baseline mouse Asc^.-, indicating that human skin is more susceptible to free radical formation and that a chromophore for visible light may be present. Using EPR spin-trapping techniques, UV radiation produced spin adducts consistent with trapping lipid alkyl radicals in mouse skin (α-[4-pyridyl 1-oxide]-N-tert-butyl nitrone/alkyl radical adduct; a^N= 15.56 G and a^H= 2.70 G) and lipid alkoxyl radicals in human skin (5,5-dimethylpyrroline-l-oxide/alkoxyl radical adduct; a^N= 14.54 G and a^H= 16.0 G). Topical application of the iron chelator Desferal to human skin significantly decreases these radicals (±50%), indicating a role for iron in lipid peroxidation; Desferal has previously been shown to decrease radical production in mouse skin. This work supports the use of the Skh-1 mouse as a predictive tool for free radical formation in human skin. These results provide the first direct evidence for UV radiation-induced free radical formation at near physiological temperatures in human skin and suggest that iron chelators may be useful as photoprotective agents.     

Kinetics and mechanism of protection of thymine from phosphate radical anion under anoxic conditions

The rates of photooxidation of thymine in the presence of peroxydiphosphate (PDP) have been determined by measuring the absorbance of thymine at 264 nm spectrophotometrically. The rates and the quantum yields (φ) of oxidation of thymine by phosphate radical anion have been determined in the presence of different concentrations of dithiothreitol (DTT). An increase in DTT is found to decrease the rate of oxidation of thymine, suggesting that DTT acts as an efficient scavenger of PO₄^·2? and protects thymine from it. Phosphate radical anion competes for thymine as well as DTT; the rate constant for the phosphate radical anion with DTT has been calculated to be 2.21 × 10⁹ dm³ mol^?1 s^?1, assuming the rate constant of phosphate radical anion reaction with thymine as 9.6 × 10⁷ dm³ mol^?1 s^?1. The quantum yields of photooxidation of thymine have been calculated from the rates of oxidation of thymine and the light intensity absorbed by PDP at 254 nm, the wavelength at which PDP is activated to phosphate radical anion. From the results of experimentally determined quantum yields (φ_exptl) and the quantum yields calculated (φ_cl), assuming DTT acts only as a scavenger of PO₄^·2? radicals, show that φ_exptl values are lower than φ_cl values. The φ′ values, which are experimentally found quantum yield values at each DTT concentration and corrected for PO₄^·2? scavenging by DTT, are also found to be greater than φ_exptl values. These observations suggest that the thymine radicals are repaired by DTT in addition to scavenging of phosphate radical anions. © 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Chem Kinet 33: 271–275, 2001     

Kinetics of polymeric radical oxidation with molecular oxygen in poly(methyl methacrylate) films

In poly(methyl methacrylate) films, the kinetics of the oxidation of polymeric radicals and azobenzenenitrenes with molecular oxygen dissolved in the polymer is studied. The free radicals are produced at 77 K by irradiating the polymer with UV light, fast electrons, or γ rays. The concentration of oxygen is varied from 4.5 × 10¹⁸ to 3.1 × 10¹⁹ cm^?3; the temperature of the reaction, from 90 to 130 K. The reaction is carried out in excess oxygen. The kinetics of radical oxidation is shown to be independent of the type of radiation that stimulates the formation of radicals and coincides with the kinetics of the oxidation of azobenzenenitrenes, which are uniformly dissolved in the polymer. It is concluded that the structure of the polymer in the vicinity of the radicals is virtually the same as the structure of the polymer bulk. The activation energy of the oxygen diffusion coefficient calculated according to the radical oxidation kinetics amounts to ～30 kJ/mol.     

Kinetics and mechanism of protection of thymine from sulphate radical anion under anoxic conditions

The rates of photooxidation of thymine in presence of peroxydisulphate (PDS) have been determined by measuring the absorbance of thymine at 264 nm spectrophotometrically. The rates and the quantum yields (φ) of oxidation of thymine by sulphate radical anion have been determined in the presence of different concentrations of caffeic acid. Increase in [caffeic acid] is found to decrease the rate of oxidation of thymine suggesting that caffeic acid acts as an efficient scavenger of SO ₄ ^•- and protects thymine from it. Sulphate radical anion competes for thymine as well as for caffeic acid. The rate constant of sulphate radical anion with caffeic acid has been calculated to be 1.24 x 10¹⁰ dm³ mol^-1s^-1. The quantum yields of photooxidation of thymine have been calculated from the rates of oxidation of thymine and the light intensity absorbed by PDS at 254 nm, the wavelength at which PDS is activated to sulphate radical anion. From the results of experimentally determined quantum yields (φ_expt1) and the quantum yields calculated (φ_cl) assuming caffeic acid acting only as a scavenger of SO ₄ ^•- radicals show that φ_expt1 values are lower than φ_cl values. The φ ’ values, which are experimentally found quantum yield values at each caffeic acid concentration and corrected for SO ₄ ^•- scavenging by caffeic acid, are also found to be greater than φ_expt1 values. These observations suggest that the thymine radicals are repaired by caffeic acid in addition to scavenging of sulphate radical anions.     

Pulse radiolysis study on the free radical scavenging activities of puerarin

Free radical theory of biology and medicine suggests that free radicals are involved in the happening of many chronic diseases including cancers and cardiovascular diseases, and natural antioxidants play positive effect in the prevention of such diseases[1]. This theory leads to much interest in the free radical scavenging activities of the pharmacologically active components in herbal medicines. Puerarin (fig. 1), a compound of isoflavone, is isolated from Chinese herbal medicine radix puera…     

Degradation of n-butylparaben and 4-tert-octylphenol in H2O2/UV system

The degradation of two endocrine disrupting compounds: n-butylparaben (BP) and 4-tert-octylphenol (OP) in the H₂O₂/UV system was studied. The effect of operating variables: initial hydrogen peroxide concentration, initial substrate concentration, pH of the reaction solution and photon fluency rate of radiation at 254 nm on reaction rate was investigated. The influence of hydroxyl radical scavengers, humic acid and nitrate anion on reaction course was also studied. A very weak scavenging effect during BP degradation was observed indicating reactions different from hydroxyl radical oxidation. The second-order rate constants of BP and OP with OH radicals were estimated to be 4.8×10⁹ and 4.2×10⁹ M^?1 s^?1, respectively. For BP the rate constant equal to 2.0×10¹⁰ M^?1 s^?1was also determined using water radiolysis as a source of hydroxyl radicals.     

Influence of dose on particle size of colloidal silver nanoparticles synthesized by gamma radiation

Colloidal silver nanoparticles were synthesized by γ-irradiation-induced reduction method of an aqueous solution containing silver nitrate as a precursor in various concentrations between 7.40×10^?4 and 1.84×10^?3 M, polyvinyl pyrrolidone for capping colloidal nanoparticles, isopropanol as radical scavenger of hydroxyl radicals and deionised water as a solvent. The irradiations were carried out in a ⁶⁰Co γ source chamber at doses up to 70 kGy. The optical absorption spectra were measured using UV–vis spectrophotometer and used to study the particle distribution and electronic structure of silver nanoparticles. As the radiation dose increases from 10 to 70 kGy, the absorption intensity increases with increasing dose. The absorption peak λ_max blue shifted from 410 to 403 nm correspond to the increase of absorption conduction electron energy from 3.02 to 3.08 eV, indicating the particle size decreases with increasing dose. The particle size was determined by photon cross correlation spectroscopy and the results showed that the particle diameter decreases exponentially with the increase of dose. The transmission electron microscopy images were taken at doses of 20 and 60 kGy and the results confirmed that as the dose increases the diameter of colloidal silver nanoparticle decreases and the particle distribution increases.     

Free radical inactivation of trypsin

Reactivities of free radical oxidants, ^.OH, Br^-·₂ and Cl₃COO^. and a reductant, CO^-·₂, with trypsin and reactive protein components were determined by pulse radiolysis of aqueous solutions at pH 7, 20°C. Highly reactive free radicals, ^.OH, Br^-·₂ and CO^-·₂, react with trypsin at diffusion controlled rates, k(^.OH + trypsin) = 8.2 × 10¹⁰ M^-1 s^-1, k(Br^-·₂ + trypsin) = 2.55 × 10⁹ M^-1 s^-1 and k(CO^-·₂ + trypsin) = 2.6 × 10⁹ M^-1 s^-1. Moderately reactive trichloroperoxy radical, k(Cl₃COO^. + trypsin) = 3 × 10⁸ M^-1 s^-1, preferentially oxidizes histidine residues. The efficiency of inactivation of trypsin by free radicals is inversely proportional to their reactivity. The yields of inactivation of trypsin by ^.OH, Br^-·₂ and CO^-·₂ are low, G(inactivation) = 0.6-0.8, which corresponds to ∾ 10% of the initially produced radicals. In contrast, Cl₃COO^. inactivates trypsin with ∾ 50% efficiency, i.e. G(inactivation) = 3.2.     

Structural factors controlling the action of UV light in nucleic acids

Abstract— UV light induced conformational effects of different deoxyoligonucleotides and deoxypolynucleotides containing thymine and adenine residues are investigated by means of CD measurements and quantum yield calculations. UV-irradiation at the wavelengths 254 , 280 and 313 nm indicate that unsensitized irradiation at low doses leads to thymine photoproduct formation of non-cyclobutane type. In contrast to that irradiation at 313 nm in the presence of acetophenone causes different changes in the CD spectra due to the formation of thymine dimers of the cyclobutane type structure. Quantum yield calculations demonstrate a pronounced dependence of the photoproduct formation on the nucleotide sequence of the oligomers. Thus, clustering of thymine dimer formation can be neglected. Adenine photoproducts in the (A.T) containing oligomers are only formed at higher fluences. > 1.5 × 10⁴ J/m² and are biological less important events.     

Reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (RONS) scavenging reactions of o-vanillin: Pulse radiolysis and stopped flow studies

Reactions of peroxyl radicals and peroxynitrite with o-vanillin (2-hydroxy 3-methoxy benzaldehyde), a positional isomer of the well-known dietary compound vanillin, were studied to understand the mechanisms of its free radical scavenging action. Trichloromethylperoxyl radicals (CCl₃O ₂ ^· ) were used as model peroxyl radicals and their reactions with o-vanillin were studied using nanosecond pulse radiolysis technique with absorption detection. The reaction produced a transient with a bimolecular rate constant of approx. 10⁵ M⁻¹s⁻¹, having absorption in the 400–500 nm region with a maximum at 450 nm. This spectrum looked significantly different from that of phenoxyl radicals of o-vanillin produced by the one-electron oxidation by azide radicals. The spectra and decay kinetics suggest that peroxyl radical reacts with o-vanillin mainly by forming a radical adduct. Peroxynitrite reactions with o-vanillin at pH 6.8 were studied using a stopped-flow spectrophotometer. o-Vanillin reacts with peroxynitrite with a bimolecular rate constant of 3 × 10³ M⁻¹s⁻¹. The reaction produced an intermediate having absorption in the wavelength region of 300–500 nm with a absorption maximum at 420 nm, that subsequently decayed in 20 s with a first-order decay constant of 0.09 s⁻¹. The studies indicate that o-vanillin is a very efficient scavenger of peroxynitrite, but not a very good scavenger of peroxyl radical. The reactions take place through the aldehyde and the phenolic OH group and are significantly different from other phenolic compounds.     

ULTRAVIOLET LIGHT-INDUCED FREE RADICAL FORMATION IN SKIN: AN ELECTRON PARAMAGNETIC RESONANCE STUDY

It has been suggested that ultraviolet light induces free radical formation in skin, leading to photoaging and cancer. We have demonstrated by electron paramagnetic resonance that the ascorbate free radical is naturally present in unexposed skin at a very low steady state level. When a section of SKH-1 hairless mouse skin in an EPR cavity is exposed to UV light (4,500 J m⁻²−1, Xe lamp, 305 nm cutoff and IR filters), the ascorbate free radical signal intensity increases. These results indicate that UV light increases free radical oxidative stress, consistent with ascorbate's role as the terminal, small-molecule antioxidant. The initial radicals produced by UV light would have very short lifetimes at room temperature; thus, we have applied EPR spin trapping techniques to detect these radicals. Using α-[4-pyridyl 1-oxide]-N- tert -butyl nitrone (POBN), we have for the first time spin trapped a UV light-produced carbon-centered free radical from intact skin. The EPR spectra exhibited hyperfine splittings that are characteristic of POBN/alkyl radicals, a^N= 15.56 G and a^H= 2.70 G, possibly generated from membrane lipids as a result of β-scission of lipid alkoxyl radicals. Iron can act as a catalyst for free radical oxidative reactions; chronic exposure of skin to UV radiation causes increased iron deposition. Using our spin trapping system, we have shown that topical application of the iron-chelator, Desferal, to a section of skin reduces the UV light-induced POBN adduct radical signal. These results provide direct evidence for free radical generation and a role for iron in UV light-induced dermatopathology. We suggest that iron chelators can serve as photoprotective agents by preventing these oxidations.     

γ-radiolysis of acetylated cotton cellulose: An ESR study

The nature and behavior of free radicals induced in acetylated cotton celluloses irradiated with γ-rays have been studied by electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy. Dehydrogenation and deacetylation appear to be responsible for the free radicals observed from samples irradiated at 77°K. The degree of substitution enhanced the yield of acetyl radicals when the samples were irradiated at 77°K and adversely affected the overall radical concentration when irradiation was done at 300°K. In addition, the ESR spectra of samples irradiated under vacuum at 300°K were more intense than those obtained from samples irradiated in air. The nature, yield, and post-irradiation behavior of the primary radicals are discussed in the light of the ultimate chemical effects observed.     

A spectrokinetic study of CH2I and CH2IO2 radicals

The UV absorption spectrum and kinetics of CH₂I and CH₂IO₂ radicals have been studied in the gasphase at 295 K using a pulse radiolysis UV absorption spectroscopic technique. UV absorption spectra of CH₂I and CH₂IO₂ radicals were quantified in the range 220–400 nm. The spectrum of CH₂I has absorption maxima at 280 nm and 337.5 nm. The absorption cross-section for the CH₂I radicals at 337.5 nm was (4.1 ± 0.9) × 10^?18 cm² molecule^?1. The UV spectrum of CH₂IO₂ radicals is broad. The absorption cross-section at 370 nm was (2.1 ± 0.5) × 10^?18 cm² molecule^?1. The rate constant for the self reaction of CH₂I radicals, k = 4 × 10^?11 cm³ molecule^?1 s^?1 at 1000 mbar total pressure of SF₆, was derived by kinetic modelling of experimental absorbance transients. The observed self-reaction rate constant for CH₂IO₂ radicals was estimated also by modelling to k = 9 × 10^?11 cm³ molecule^?1 s^?1. As part of this work a rate constant of (2.0 ± 0.3) × 10^?10 cm³ molecule^?1 s^?1 was measured for the reaction of F atoms with CH₃I. The branching ratios of this reaction for abstraction of an I atom and a H atom were determined to (64 ± 6)% and (36 ± 6)%, respectively. © 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Relative concentrations and relaxation properties of isomeric alkyl radicals in γ-irradiated n-alkane single crystals

The relative concentrations of alkyl radicals CH₃C?HCH₂R(I) and R'CH₂C?HCH₂R''(II) were measured at low microwave power in some n-alkane single crystals γ-irradiated at 77 K to a dose of 1 Mrad. The relative concentration of radical (II) increased as the number of carbon atoms became larger. The amount of radical (I) was in agreement with a mechanism where all CH bonds in an n-alkane molecule are raptured with the same probability followed by an isomerization of primary alkyl radicals to radical (I). In n-decane for instance this mechanism predicts 45.5% of radical (I) compared to the experimental value of 45.5%. Saturation measurements of radical (I) and radical (II) under slow passage condition showed that the spin-lattice relaxation time T₁ is shorter for radical (I) (ca. 3 × 10^?4s) than for radical (II) (ca. 80 × 10^?4s), while the spin-spin relaxation times T₂ are similar (ca. 2 × 10^?8s). The relatively short relaxation time T₁ in radical (I) is thought to originate from higher mobility of the end of the alkane chain, where the unpaired electron is localized, and also a modulation of the hyperfine coupling from protons in the nearby rotating methyl group. The broad linewidth in irradiated protiated cyrstals was by comparison with results from deuterated matrices concluded to depend on slightly distorted radicals in damaged regions (spurs, short tracks, blobs) and not on electron dipole-dipole interactions. Unresolved γ-proton couplings in radical (I) are thought to cause the spin-flip transitions at high microwave power.     

PHOTOCHEMICAL SENSITIZATION BY AZATHIOPRINE AND ITS METABOLITES. PART 3. A DIRECT EPR AND SPIN-TRAPPING STUDY OF LIGHT-INDUCED FREE RADICALS FROM 6-MERCAPTOPURINE AND ITS OXIDATION PRODUCTS

Abstract Sunlight has been implicated in the high incidence of skin cancer found in patients receiving 6-mercaptopurine (PSH) in the form of its pro-drug azathioprine. In this study we have used EPR spectroscopy in conjunction with the spin-trapping technique to determine whether PSH and its metabolic or photochemical oxidation products generate highly reactive free radicals upon UV irradiation. When an aqueous anaerobic solution (pH 5 or 9) of PSH (pK₂= 7.7) and either 2-methyl-2-nitrosopropane (MNP) or nitromethane (NM) were irradiated (λ > 300 nm) with a Xe arc lamp, the corresponding purin-6-thiyl (PS^.) radical adduct and the reduced form of the spin trap (MNPIH’or CH₃N0₂) were observed. However, no radical adducts were detected when PSH and 5,5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline-N-oxide (DMPO) were irradiated (λ= 320 nrn) in oxygen-free buffer. These findings suggest that PSH does not photoionize but that instead MNP and NM are reduced by direct electron transfer from excited state PSH, ^1,3(PSH)*. In aerobic solution, oxygen can act as an electron acceptor and the O₂*- and PS radicals are formed and trapped by DMPO. 6-Mercaptopurine did photoionize when irradiated with a Nd:YAG laser at 355 nm as evidenced by the appearance of the DMPO/H (e_eq+ H⁺) adduct, which decreased in intensity in the presence of N₂O. ^1,3(6-Mercap-topurine)* oxidized ascorbate, formate and reduced glutathione to the corresponding ascorbyl, CO₂.- or glutathiyl radicals. The photochemical behavior of 6-thioxanthine and 6-thiouric acid was similar to PSH. However, the excited states of these metabolic oxidation products exhibited stronger reducing properties than ^1,3(PSH)*. Photolysis of PSH photoproducts purine-6-sulfonate or purine-6-sulfinate resulted in homolysis of the C-S bond and the appearance of the SO₃′- and SO₂^?_-- radicals, respectively, which were detected by direct EPR. These studies demonstrate that UV irradiation of PSH, its photoproducts and metabolites generates a variety of free radicals that may be involved in the etiology of skin cancer induced by azathioprine.     

Kinetics of one-electron oxidation by the ClO radical

Pulse radiolysis studies were carried out to determine the rate constants for reactions of ClO radicals in aqueous solution. These radicals were produced by the reaction of OH with hypochlorite ions in N₂O saturated solutions. The rate constants for their reactions with several compounds were determined by following the build up of the product radical absorption and in several cases by competition kinetics. ClO was found to be a powerful oxidant which reacts very rapidly with phenoxide ions to form phenoxyl radicals and with dimethoxybenzenes to form the cation radicals (k = 7 × 10⁸ −2 × 10⁹ M^-1 s^-1). ClO also oxidizes ClO^-₂ and N^-₃ ions rapidly (9.4 × 10⁸ and 2.5 × 10⁸ M^-1 s^-1, respectively), but its reactions with formate and benzoate ions were too slow to measure. ClO does not oxidize carbonate but the CO^-₃ radical reacts with ClO^- slowly (k = 5.1 × 10⁵ M^-1 s^-1).     

ON THE PHOTOCHEMISTRY OF X-RAY PRODUCED RADICALS TRAPPED IN FROZEN ETHANOL MATRICES

Abstract— Ethanol and ethanol-water matrices were exposed to X-rays at 77K and the photochemistry and paths of radical conversion were investigated by EPR methods. The main X-ray induced radical, CH3ĊHOH, is probably photoionized by 254 nm light. The following radicals are produced during prolonged UV-irradiation of CH₃ĊHOH radicals: ĊH₃, ĊHO, H and 2 types of radicals giving singlet EPR spectra. One of these radicals (d) is bleachable with 580 nm light, ĊH₃ and ĊH₃ĊHOH being formed during the bleaching, the other one (e) is unbleachable and the most stable radical in the matrix during annealing. The CH₃ radicals decay at 77 K (τ∽ 10 min) and produce CH₃-CHOH radicals and the unbleachable radical (e). Stable H-atom signals were seen in X-irradiated ethanol-water mixtures (volume ratio 2:1) at 77 K. The H-atom signals increased during photobleaching of the trapped electrons in the matrix and during UV-photolysis of CH₃CHOH radicals.     

NMR and ESR studies of the solid-state polymerization of vinyl monomers. I. Acrylamide

The kinetics of the solid-state polymerization of acrylamide, γ-irradiated at 77°K, has been studied by wide line NMR and by ESR at temperatures above 300°K. This reaction may be followed by the growth of a narrow line superimposed on the NMR spectrum of the monomer. The amplitude of this narrow line has been found to be proportional to the polymer yield. By long continued annealing, the conversion yield approaches a limiting value, generally lower than 50% under most of our experimental conditions. The activation energy of post-polymerization is 19 ± 1 kcal/mole. The radiochemical yield of radicals, determined by ESR, is 0.27 ± 0.03 at 77°K before warming. In the course of annealing above 300°K, the overall concentration of radicals is reduced to about one tenth of its initial value at 77°K. However, the local concentration of the remaining radicals is constant and equal to 1.2 × 10¹⁹ spins/g, i.e., more than 100 times their overall concentration. The recombination of radicals does not seem to intervene in the kinetics of post-polymerization, so that it may be assumed that only the radicals remaining after annealing, have actually contributed to the reaction.     

The acetyl radical studied by flash photolysis and kinetic spectroscopy

The acetyl radical absorption spectrum is a broad band with maximum decadic extinction coefficient of (1.0 ± 0.1) × 10⁴ ? mole^?1 cm^?1 at 215 nm and an oscillator strength of 0.23 ± 0.03. Absolute rate constants were estimated as 4.5 × 10¹⁰ ? mole^?1 s^?1 for the mutual interaction of acetyl radicals, and as 7.5 × 10¹⁰ ? mole^?1 s^?1 for the cross interaction of acetyl and methyl radicals.     

An EPR study of thermally and photochemically generated oxygen radicals on hydrated and dehydrated titania surfaces

The formation of a series of oxygen-centred radicals on different TiO₂ samples (P25 and two different rutile materials) under various conditions was investigated using X-band c.w. Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. The radicals were formed either on thermally-reduced TiO₂, or by UV irradiation of the oxide under an oxygen atmosphere. The nature and stability of the radicals was also explored as a function of surface hydration. On thermally reduced TiO₂, containing surface and bulk Ti³⁺ centres, oxygen adsorption at 300 K results in the preferential formation and stabilisation of O₂ ^- anions on the P25 surface, but O^- and O₃ ^- anions are generated on the rutile surfaces. Superoxide anions (O^-) and trapped holes (O₂ ^-) were also identified after photo-irradiation of the thoroughly dehydrated TiO₂ samples under oxygen. The O^- anions were only visible at low temperatures under continuous irradiation, while the O₂ ^- anions were stable for days at 300 K. By comparison, on fully hydrated surfaces, no stable oxygen centred radicals could be detected on P25, while O₂ ^- anions were easily observed on the rutile surfaces. On partially hydrated P25, the O^-, O₂ ^- and HO₂ anions were detected after UV irradiation at 77 K; all radicals decayed upon warming to 298 K. On partially hydrated rutile, the O^- and O₂ ^- anions were detected and, unlike the case for P25, were found to be stable for days under the same conditions. The results illustrate the varied formation and stability of the oxygen centred radicals on TiO₂ surfaces depending on the pretreatment conditions.