Novel 2D triple-resonance NMR experiments for sequential resonance assignments of proteins

We present 2D versions of the popular triple resonance HN(CO) CACB, HN(COCA)CACB, HN(CO)CAHA, and HN(COCA) CAHA experiments, commonly used for sequential resonance assignments of proteins. These experiments provide information about correlations between amino proton and nitrogen chemical shifts and the alpha- and beta-carbon and alpha-proton chemical shifts within and between amino acid residues. Using these 2D spectra, sequential resonance assignments of H(N), N, C(alpha), C(beta), and H(alpha) nuclei are easily achieved. The resolution of these spectra is identical to the well-resolved 2D (15)N-(1)H HSQC and H(NCO)CA spectra, with slightly reduced sensitivity compared to their 3D and 4D versions. These types of spectra are ideally suited for exploitation in automated assignment procedures and thereby constitute a fast and efficient means for NMR structural determination of small and medium-sized proteins in solution in structural genomics programs.     

Triple resonance solid state NMR experiments with reduced dimensionality evolution periods

Two solid state NMR triple resonance experiments which utilize the simultaneous incrementation of two chemical shift evolution periods to obtain a spectrum with reduced dimensionality are described. The CO N CA experiment establishes the correlation of (13)C(i-1) to (13)C alpha(i) and (15)N(i) by simultaneously encoding the (13)CO(i-1) and (15)N(i) chemical shifts. The CA N COCA experiment establishes the correlation (13)Ca(i) and (15)CO(i) to (13)C alpha(i-1) and (15)N(i-1) within a single experiment by simultaneous encoding of the (13)C alpha(i) and (15)N(i) chemical shifts. This experiment establishes sequential amino acid correlations in close analogy to the solution state HNCA experiment. Reduced dimensionality 2D experiments are a practical alternative to recording multiple 3D data sets for the purpose of obtaining sequence-specific resonance assignments of peptides and proteins in the solid state.     

Very simple combination of TROSY, CRINEPT and multiple quantum coherence for signal enhancement in an HN(CO)CA experiment for large proteins

Sensitivity enhancement in liquid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) triple resonance experiments for the sequential assignment of proteins is important for the investigation of large proteins or protein complexes. We present here the 3D TROSY-MQ/CRINEPT-HN(CO)CA which makes use of a 1?N-1H-TROSY element and a 13C'-13CA CRINEPT step combined with a multiple quantum coherence during the 13CA evolution period. Because of the introduction of these relaxation-optimized elements and 10 less pulses required, when compared with the conventional TROSY-HN(CO)CA experiment an average signal enhancement of a factor of 1.8 was observed for the membrane protein-detergent complex KcsA with a rotational correlation time τ(c) of around 60 ns.     

Determination of multiple ***φ***-torsion angles in proteins by selective and extensive (13)C labeling and two-dimensional solid-state NMR.

We describe an approach to efficiently determine the backbone conformation of solid proteins that utilizes selective and extensive (13)C labeling in conjunction with two-dimensional magic-angle-spinning NMR. The selective (13)C labeling approach aims to reduce line broadening and other multispin complications encountered in solid-state NMR of uniformly labeled proteins while still enhancing the sensitivity of NMR spectra. It is achieved by using specifically labeled glucose or glycerol as the sole carbon source in the protein expression medium. For amino acids synthesized in the linear part of the biosynthetic pathways, [1-(13)C]glucose preferentially labels the ends of the side chains, while [2-(13)C]glycerol labels the C(alpha) of these residues. Amino acids produced from the citric-acid cycle are labeled in a more complex manner. Information on the secondary structure of such a labeled protein was obtained by measuring multiple backbone torsion angles phi; simultaneously, using an isotropic-anisotropic 2D correlation technique, the HNCH experiment. Initial experiments for resonance assignment of a selectively (13)C labeled protein were performed using (15)N-(13)C 2D correlation spectroscopy. From the time dependence of the (15)N-(13)C dipolar coherence transfer, both intraresidue and interresidue connectivities can be observed, thus yielding partial sequential assignment. We demonstrate the selective (13)C labeling and these 2D NMR experiments on a 8.5-kDa model protein, ubiquitin. This isotope-edited NMR approach is expected to facilitate the structure determination of proteins in the solid state.     

Evaluation and optimization of coherence transfer in high molecular weight systems

For very large proteins in the highest magnetic fields, the large chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) of carbonyl carbon deteriorates coherence transfer efficiency in experiments designed for unambiguous sequential backbone assignment. In this communication, coherence throughput of several TROSY experiments is evaluated. Two new experiments, MP-HNCA and HN(CO)CANH, are also introduced as attractive alternatives for sequential assignment purposes of large proteins with correlation time over 50 ns. Their theoretical coherence transfer efficiencies for the interresidual (13)C(alpha) correlations are significantly better than in recently introduced MP-CT-HNCA and sequential HNCA experiments. The improvement with the new experiments is observed already on 60.8 kDa homodimer of protein Cel6A at 800 (1)H MHz.     

Intraresidue HNCA and COHNCA experiments for protein backbone resonance assignment

Two novel experiments, intra-HNCA and intra-COHNCA, are presented for sequential backbone resonance assignment of (13)C, (15)N labeled proteins. The advantage with respect to conventional pulse schemes is the suppression of the sequential (15)N-->(13)C(alpha) coherence transfer pathway, which can be separately obtained from a HNCOCA correlation experiment. This results in a two-fold reduction of the number of detected correlation peaks. Spectral simplification is especially important for efficient automated assignment protocols as required in the context of high-throughput protein studies by NMR. The performance of the new experiments is demonstrated on an 18-kDa protein fragment of the E. coli sulfite reductase and compared to conventional techniques in terms of sensitivity and resolution.     

A set of BEST triple-resonance experiments for time-optimized protein resonance assignment

A series of sequential, intra-residue, and bi-directional BEST H-N-CA, H-N-CO, and H-N-CB pulse sequences is presented that extends the BEST concept introduced recently for fast multidimensional protein NMR [Schanda et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 128 (2006) 9042] to the complete set of experiments required for sequential resonance assignment. We demonstrate for the protein ubiquitin that 3D BEST H-N-C correlation spectra can be recorded on a 600MHz NMR spectrometer equipped with a cryogenic probe in only a few minutes of acquisition time with sufficient sensitivity to detect all expected cross peaks.     

The DQ-HN[CACB] and DQ-HN(CO)[CACB] sequences with evolution of double quantum Calpha-Cbeta coherences

The new variant of known HNCACB and HN(CO)CACB techniques is proposed that employs excitation and evolution of double quantum Calpha-Cbeta coherences. The most important features of the new method are: increased signal dispersion, lack of splittings due to 1J(Calpha-Cbeta) spin-spin couplings, and absence of accidental cancellations of positive and negative signals. The acquisition of both DQ-HN[CACB] and DQ-HN(CO)[CACB] techniques enables sequential assignment of protein backbone, using only Calpha-Cbeta DQ-frequencies. The determination of all Calpha and Cbeta chemical shifts requires, however, a comparison with HN(CO)CA or HNCA spectra. Examples of applications of the DQ-HN[CACB] and DQ-HN(CO)[CACB] experiments are presented, employing the 2D Reduced Dimensionality approach for 13C, 15N-labeled ubiquitin, and the 3D acquisition for 13C, 15N-double labeled Ca2+ -binding bovine S100A1 protein in the apo state (21 kDa) with overall correlation time of 8.1 ns.     

Three-dimensional correlated accordion NMR spectroscopy of proteins

A major step toward the protein structure determination by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is the assignment of multidimensional NMR signals that provide through-bond and through-space inter-atomic correlations. Ambiguities often occur during the assignment process due to resonance degeneracy, which challenges high resolution and larger size protein structure determination. Here, we present a method that will significantly improve the efficiency and accuracy of the NMR signal assignment. The method is based on a correlated accordion principle that, when incorporated into conventional three-dimensional (3D) heteronuclear NMR experiments, allows the retrieval of additional frequency correlation information at high resolution. We show that 3D spectra derived from this method are as effective as the impractical high resolution four-dimensional (4D) spectra with substantially reduced signal ambiguity as compared to their conventional counterparts. The approach promises increased accuracy and size of protein structures determined by NMR.     

Use of the Carbonyl Chemical Shift to Relieve Degeneracies in Triple-Resonance Assignment Experiments

We illustrate an approach that uses the backbone carbonyl chemical shift to relieve resonance overlaps in triple-resonance assignment experiments conducted on protein samples. We apply this approach to two cases of simultaneous overlaps: those of ((1)H(N), (15)N) spin pairs and those of ((1)H(alpha), (13)C(alpha)) spin pairs in residues preceding prolines. For these cases we employed respectively CBCACO(N)H and H(CA)CON experiments, simple variants of the commonly used CBCA(CO)NH and HCA(CO)N experiments obtained by replacing one of the indirect dimensions with a carbonyl dimension. We present data collected on ribosomal protein S4 using these experiments, along with overlap statistics for four other polypeptides ranging in size from 76 to 263 residues. These data indicate that the CBCACO(N)H, in combination with the CBCA(CO)NH, can relieve >83% of the ((1)H(N), (15)N) and ((1)H(N), (13)C') overlaps for these proteins. The data also reveal how the H(CA)CON experiment successfully completed the assignment of triply and quadruply degenerate X-Pro spin systems in a mobile, proline-rich region of S4, even when X was a glycine. Finally, we discuss the relative sensitivities of these experiments compared to those of existing sequences, an analysis that reinforces the usefulness of these experiments in assigning extensively overlapped and/or proline-rich sequences in proteins.     

Spin-state-selective excitation in selective 1D inverse NMR experiments

A general and very simple strategy for achieving clean spin-state-selective excitation with full sensitivity in carbon-selective gradient-enhanced 1D HMQC and HSQC pulse schemes is presented. The incorporation of an additional hard 90 degrees (13)C pulse applied along a specific orthogonal axis just prior to acquisition into the conventional sequences allows us to select a simultaneous coherence transfer pathway which usually is not detected. The superimposition of this resulting antiphase magnetization to the conventional in-phase magnetization gives the exclusive excitation of the directly attached proton showing only the alpha or beta spin state of the passive (13)C nucleus. The propagation of this particular spin state to other protons can be accomplished by adding any homonuclear mixing process just after this supplementary pulse. Such an approach affords a suite of powerful selective 1D (13)C-edited NMR experiments which are helpful for resonance assignment purposes in overcrowded proton spin systems and also for the accurate determination of the magnitude and sign of long-range proton-carbon coupling constants in CH spin sytems for samples at natural abundance. Such measurements are performed by measuring the relative displacement of relayed signals in the corresponding alpha and beta 1D subspectra.     

Multi-dimensional 1H-13C HETCOR and FSLG-HETCOR NMR study of sphingomyelin bilayers containing cholesterol in the gel and liquid crystalline states

(13)C cross polarization magic angle spinning (CP-MAS) and (1)H MAS NMR spectra were collected on egg sphingomyelin (SM) bilayers containing cholesterol above and below the liquid crystalline phase transition temperature (T(m)). Two-dimensional (2D) dipolar heteronuclear correlation (HETCOR) spectra were obtained on SM bilayers in the liquid crystalline (L(alpha)) state for the first time and display improved resolution and chemical shift dispersion compared to the individual (1)H and (13)C spectra and significantly aid in spectral assignment. In the gel (L(beta)) state, the (1)H dimension suffers from line broadening due to the (1)H-(1)H homonuclear dipolar coupling that is not completely averaged by the combination of lipid mobility and MAS. This line broadening is significantly suppressed by implementing frequency switched Lee-Goldburg (FSLG) homonuclear (1)H decoupling during the evolution period. In the liquid crystalline (L(alpha)) phase, no improvement in line width is observed when FSLG is employed. All of the observed resonances are assignable to cholesterol and SM environments. This study demonstrates the ability to obtain 2D heteronuclear correlation experiments in the gel state for biomembranes, expands on previous SM assignments, and presents a comprehensive (1)H/(13)C NMR assignment of SM bilayers containing cholesterol. Comparisons are made to a previous report on cholesterol chemical shifts in dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) bilayers. A number of similarities and some differences are observed and discussed.     

A solid-state NMR application of the anomeric effect in carbohydrates: galactosamine, glucosamine, and N-acetyl-glucosamine

Simple 2D 13C/15N heteronuclear correlation solid-state NMR spectroscopy was implemented to resolve the 15N resonances of the alpha and beta anomers of three amino monosaccharides: galactosamine (GalN), glucosamine hydrochloride (GlcN), and N-acetyl-glucosamine (GlcNAc) labeled specifically with 13C1/15N spin pairs. Although the 15N resonances could not be distinguished in normal 1D spectra, they were well resolved in 2D double CP/MAS correlation spectra by taking advantage of the 13C spectral resolution. The alpha and beta resonances shifted apart by 3-5 ppm in their 13C chemical shifts, and differed by 1-2 ppm in the extended 15N dimension. Aside from this, the detection of other 13C/15N correlations over short distances was also achieved arising from the C2, C3 and CO carbons present in natural abundance. 2D double CP/MAS chemical shift correlation NMR spectroscopy is a simple and powerful technique to characterize the anomeric effect of amino monosaccharides. Applications of the 2D method reveal well-resolved 15N and 13C chemical shifts might be useful for structural determination on carbohydrates of biological significance, such as glycopeptide or glycolipids.     

3D 13C–13C–13C correlation NMR for de novo distance determination of solid proteins and application to a human α-defensin

The de novo structure of an antimicrobial protein, human α-defensin 1 (HNP-1), is determined by combining a 3D ¹³C–¹³C–¹³C (CCC) magic-angle spinning (MAS) correlation experiment with standard resonance assignment experiments. Using a short spin diffusion mixing time to assign intra-residue cross peaks and a long mixing time to detect inter-residue correlation peaks, we show that the 3D CCC experiment not only reduces the ambiguity of resonance assignment, but more importantly yields two orders of magnitude more long-range distances without recourse to existing crystal structures. Most of these distance constraints could not be obtained in a de novo fashion from 2D correlation spectra due to significant resonance overlap. Combining the distance constraints from the 3D CCC experiment and the chemical-shift-derived torsion angles, we obtained a de novo high-resolution NMR structure of HNP-1, with a heavy-atom RMSD of 3.4 Å from the crystal structure of the analogous HNP-3. The average energy of the minimum-energy ensemble is less than of 40 kcal/mol. Thus, the 3D CCC experiment provides a reliable means of restraining the three-dimensional structure of insoluble proteins with unknown conformations.     

Determination of three-bond scalar coupling between 13C' and 1H(alpha) in proteins using an iHN(CA),CO(alpha/beta-J-COHA) experiment

Triple-resonance NMR experiments for measuring three-bond scalar coupling constant between 13C' (i-1) and 1H(alpha)(i) spins, defining the dihedral angle phi, are presented. The novel experiments enable the measurement of 3JC'H(alpha)) from simple two (or three)-dimensional 13C', (15N/13C(alpha)), 1H(N) correlation spectra with minimal resonance overlap, thanks to solely intraresidual coherence transfer pathway and spin-state-selection. The 3J(C'H(alpha)) values measured in human ubiquitin using the proposed intraresidual iHN(CA),CO(alpha/beta-J-COHA) TROSY method were compared with those determined previously utilizing the HCAN[C'] experiment.     

Determination of backbone angle psi in proteins using a TROSY-based alpha/beta-HN(CO)CA-J experiment

Transverse relaxation-optimized NMR experiment (TROSY) for the measurement of three-bond scalar coupling constant between (1)H(alpha)(i-1) and (15)N(i) defining the dihedral angle psi is described. The triple-spin-state-selective experiment allows measurement of (3)J(H(alpha)N) from (13)C(alpha), (15)N, and (1)H(N) correlation spectra H(2)O with minimum resonance overlap. Transverse relaxation of (13)C(alpha) spin is minimized by using spin-state-selective filtering and by acquiring a signal longer in (15)N-dimension in a manner of semi-constant-time TROSY evolution. The (3)J(H(alpha))(N) values obtained with the proposed alpha/beta-HN(CO)CA-J TROSY scheme are in good agreement with the values measured earlier from ubiquitin in D(2)O using the HCACO[N] experiment.     

Sparsely sampled high-resolution 4-D experiments for efficient backbone resonance assignment of disordered proteins

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) play important roles in many critical cellular processes. Due to their limited chemical shift dispersion, IDPs often require four pairs of resonance connectivities (H(α), C(α), C(β) and CO) for establishing sequential backbone assignment. Because most conventional 4-D triple-resonance experiments share an overlapping C(α) evolution period, combining existing 4-D experiments does not offer an optimal solution for non-redundant collection of a complete set of backbone resonances. Using alternative chemical shift evolution schemes, we propose a new pair of 4-D triple-resonance experiments--HA(CA)CO(CA)NH/HA(CA)CONH--that complement the 4-D HNCACB/HN(CO)CACB experiments to provide complete backbone resonance information. Collection of high-resolution 4-D spectra with sparse sampling and FFT-CLEAN processing enables efficient acquisition and assignment of complete backbone resonances of IDPs. Importantly, because the CLEAN procedure iteratively identifies resonance signals and removes their associating aliasing artifacts, it greatly reduces the dependence of the reconstruction quality on sampling schemes and produces high-quality spectra even with less-than-optimal sampling schemes.     

Frontiers in 2D NMR of paramagnetic metalloproteins

The possibilities and the limitations of 2D NMR for the structural characterization of paramagnetic metalloproteins are reviewed. We survey the general strategies for 2D¹H NMR investigations of hyperfine shifted signals. Careful adaptation of classical 2D NMR experiments to fast relaxing systems results in the detection of previously not observed scalar and dipolar connectivities, thus leading to the specific assignment of selected resonances. The approach is of general applicability for paramagnetic metalloproteins. We report here on the application of the application of the method to an iron sulfur protein and a heme protein. In both cases specific assignment of several hyperfine shifted signals, corresponding to active site protons, were obtained; this allowed significant insight into the structure-function relationships of these metalloproteins.     

Assessment of protein alignment using 1H-1H residual dipolar coupling measurements

A quick and accurate method is described for assessing protein alignment from residual dipolar coupling (RDC) measurements. In contrast to observing D(2)O resonance splitting, which reflects the orientational order of the alignment medium, the degree of alignment of a protein of interest can be estimated directly from (1)H-(1)H RDCs. In this study, RDCs between aromatic protons in unlabeled Cp-rubredoxin were measured from proton homonuclear J-resolved experiments with high sensitivity, and the alignment was assessed without the need of extensive resonance assignment. Since labeled proteins are not needed, this method provides an efficient way for screening alignment media. In situations where the protein structure is known, as in the case of Cp-rubredoxin, a full set of order tensor parameters can be determined, allowing further studies, such as those of ligand alignment relative to a target protein.     

Sensitivity-enhanced MQ-HCN-CCH-TOCSY and MQ-HCN-CCH-COSY pulse schemes for (13)C/(15)N labeled RNA oligonucleotides

Sensitivity enhanced multiple-quantum 3D HCN-CCH-TOCSY and HCN-CCH-COSY experiments are presented for the ribose resonance assignment of (13)C/(15)N-labeled RNA sample. The experiments make use of the chemical shift dispersion of N1/N9 of pyrimidine/purine to distinguish the ribose spin systems. They provide a complementary approach for the assignment of ribose resonance to the currently used HCCH-COSY and HCCH-TOCSY type experiments in which either (13)C or (1)H is utilized to separate the different ribose spin systems. The pulse schemes have been demonstrated on a 23-mer (13)C/(15)N-labeled RNA aptamer complexed with neomycin and tested on a 32-mer RNA complexed with a 23-residue peptide.