Isothermal titration calorimetry as a new tool to investigate chiral interactions at crystal surfaces

In this communication we describe for the first time the use of isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to measure the energetics of adsorption of enantiomers from aqueous onto chiral crystal surfaces. Our results demonstrate that ITC can be used to measure chiral interactions at crystal surfaces.     

Disappearing Enantiomorphs: Single Handedness in Racemate Crystals

Although crystallization is the most important method for the separation of enantiomers of chiral molecules in the chemical industry, the chiral recognition involved in this process is poorly understood at the molecular level. We report on the initial steps in the formation of layered racemate crystals from a racemic mixture, as observed by STM at submolecular resolution. Grown on a copper single‐crystal surface, the chiral hydrocarbon heptahelicene formed chiral racemic lattice structures within the first layer. In the second layer, enantiomerically pure domains were observed, underneath which the first layer contained exclusively the other enantiomer. Hence, the system changed from a 2D racemate into a 3D racemate with enantiomerically pure layers after exceeding monolayer‐saturation coverage. A chiral bias in form of a small enantiomeric excess suppressed the crystallization of one double‐layer enantiomorph so that the pure minor enantiomer crystallized only in the second layer.     

Processes To Separate Enantiomers

The provision of pure enantiomers is of increasing importance not only for the pharmaceutical industry but also for agrochemistry and biotechnology. In general, there are two rival approaches to provide pure enantiomers. The “chiral” approach is based on developing an asymmetric synthesis of just one of the enantiomers, while the “racemic” approach is based on separating mixtures of the two enantiomers. In the last few years remarkable progress has been achieved in the latter area. This Review focuses in particular on enantioselective crystallization processes and preparative chromatography, including hybrid processes and the incorporation of racemization steps. Several examples from our research are used for illustration purposes.     

Molecular-level chiral discrimination and induction

The review describes the mechanism of chiral discrimination of racemic amines upon crystallization and the induction of chirality in organic reactions by using them as chiral auxiliaries. In order to form conglomerates, which can be resolved into the two enantiomers upon alternative seeding, both formation and packing of 2₁-columns are essentially very important. On the other hand, in order to achieve high efficiency in resolution through diastereomeric salt formation, which is the most practical method, one of a pair of diastereomeric salts derived from a racemic amine and an enantiomerically pure resolving agent should at least have two 2₁-columns and planar boundary surfaces in its crystal structure. On the basis of this knowledge, we developed several artificial chiral auxiliaries such as erythro-2-amino-1,2-diphenylethanol,cis-2-amino-1-acenaphthenol, andcis-2-amino-3,3-dimethyl-1-indanol. These were found to be very efficient chiral auxiliaries in asymmetric inductions: alkylation of chiral imines, catalytic borane-reduction, and alkylation of chiral N-acylated oxazolidinone.     

Self-assembled monolayer protection of chiral-imprinted mesoporous platinum electrodes for highly enantioselective synthesis

In modern chemistry, chiral (electro)catalysis is a powerful strategy to produce enantiomerically pure compounds (EPC). However, it still struggles with uncontrollable stereochemistry due to side reactions, eventually producing a racemic mixture. To overcome this important challenge, a well-controlled design of chiral catalyst materials is mandatory to produce enantiomers with acceptable purity. In this context, we propose the synergetic combination of two strategies, namely the elaboration of mesoporous Pt films, imprinted with chiral recognition sites, together with the spatially controlled formation of a self-assembled monolayer. Chiral imprinted metals have been previously suggested as electrode materials for enantioselective recognition, separation and synthesis. However, the outermost surface of such electrodes is lacking chiral information and thus leads to unspecific reactions. Functionalising selectively this part of the electrode with a monolayer of organosulfur ligands allows an almost total suppression of undesired side reactions and thus leads to a boost of enantiomeric excess to values of over 90% when using these surfaces in the frame of enantioselective electrosynthesis. In addition, this strategy also decreases the total reaction time by one order of magnitude. The study therefore opens up promising perspectives for the development of heterogeneous enantioselective electrocatalysis strategies.

Highly enantioselective electrosynthesis with up to 90% ee and short reaction times can be achieved with alkanethiol protected chiral imprinted mesoporous Pt surfaces.     

Isolation, absolute configuration, and chiral crystallization of optically active seleninic acid

An optically pure seleninic acid was isolated as stable crystals for the first time by chiral crystallization. The relationship between the absolute configurations and the circular dichroism spectra of the enantiomers could be determined by X-ray crystallographic analysis.     

Stereospecific polymerization and chiral initiation,chiral crystallization and chiral nucleation

Helical macromolecules which are configurationally and conformationally specific can now be synthesized. Monomer structures must be selected that demand spacial restriction for monomer addition. High specificity of monomer addition during polymerization has parallels in crystallization of some inorganic salts from aqueous solution. Initiation of highly specific polymerizations with chiral initiators give helical polymers with substantial one-handedness. Nucleation of certain inorganic salts with chiral nucleating agents, the enantiomers of the salts produce enantiomerically pure chiral salts.     

Localized Crystallization of Enantiomeric Organic Compounds on Chiral Micro‐patterns from Various Organic Solutions

The controlled crystallization of enantiomers of an organic compound (a cyclic phosphoric acid derivative) on templated micro‐patterned functionalised surfaces is demonstrated. Areas where a complementary chiral thiol has been located were effective heterogeneous nucleation centres when a solution of the compound is evaporated slowly. Various organic solvents were employed, which present a challenge with respect to other examples when water is used. The solvent and the crystallization method have an important influence on the crystal growth of these compounds. When chloroform was employed, well‐defined crystals grow away from the surface, whereas crystals grow in the plane from solutions in isopropanol. In both cases, nucleation is confined to the polar patterned regions of the surface, and for isopropanol growth is largely limited within the pattern, which shows the importance of surface chemistry for nucleation and growth. The apparent dependence on the enantiomer used in the latter case could imply stereo‐differentiation as a result of short‐range interactions (the templating monolayer is disordered, even at the nanometre scale). The size of the pattern of chiral monolayer also determines the outcome of the crystallization; 5 μm dots are most effective. Despite the low surface tension of the samples (relative to the high surface tension of water), differential solvation of the polar and hydrophobic layers of the solvents allows crystallization in the polar regions of the monolayer, therefore the polarity of the regions in which heterogeneous nucleation takes place is indeed very important. Despite the complex nature of the crystallization process, these results are an important step towards to the use of patterned surfaces for heterogeneous selective nucleation of enantiomers.     

Chiral Thin Films of Metal Oxide

In this paper, we describe for the first time the synthesis of new chiral nanosized metal oxide surfaces based on chiral self‐assembled monolayers (SAMs) coated with metal oxide (TiO₂) nanolayers. In this new type of nanosize chiral surface, the metal oxide nanolayers enable the protection of the chiral self‐assembled monolayers while preserving their enantioselective nature. The chiral nature of the SAM/TiO₂ films was characterized by variety of unique techniques, such as second‐harmonic generation circular dichroism (SHG‐CD), quartz crystal microbalance, and chiral adsorption measurements with circular dichroism spectroscopy. The chiral resolution abilities of the SAMs coated with metal oxide (TiO₂) nanolayers were investigated in the crystallization of a racemic mixture of threonine and glutamic acid. Our proposed methodology for the preparation of nanoscale chiral surfaces described in this article could open up opportunities in other fields of chemistry, such as chiral catalysis.     

Influence of a Change in Helical Twisting Power of Photoresponsive Chiral Dopants on Rotational Manipulation of Micro‐Objects on the Surface of Chiral Nematic Liquid Crystalline Films

Herein we report a group of five planar chiral molecules as photon‐mode chiral switches for the reversible control of the self‐assembled superstructures of doped chiral nematic liquid crystals. The chiral switches are composed of an asymmetrically substituted aromatic moiety and a photoisomerizing azobenzene unit connected in a cyclic manner through methylene spacers of varying lengths. All the molecules show conformational restriction in the rotation of the asymmetrically substituted aromatic moiety in both the E and Z states of the azobenzene units resulting in planar chirality with separable enantiomers. Our newly synthesized compounds in pure enantiomeric form show high helical twisting power (HTP) in addition to an improved change in HTP between the E and Z states. The molecule with a diphenylnaphthalene unit shows the highest ever known initial helical twisting power among chiral dopants with planar chirality. In addition to the reversible tuning of reflection colors, we employed the enantiomers of these five compounds in combination with four nematic liquid crystalline hosts to study their properties as molecular machines; the change in HTP of the chiral dopant upon photoisomerization induces rotation of the texture of the liquid crystal surfaces. Importantly, this study has revealed a linear dependence of the ratio of the difference between HTPs before and after irradiation against the absolute value of the initial HTP, not the absolute value of the change in helical twisting power between two states, on the angle of rotation of micro‐objects on chiral nematic liquid crystalline films. This study has also revealed that a change in irradiation intensity does not affect the maximum angle of rotation, but it does affect the speed of rotational reorganization of the cholesteric helix.     

Self‐Reporting Inhibitors: A Single Crystallization Process To Obtain Two Optically Pure Enantiomers

Collection of two optically pure enantiomers in a single crystallization process can significantly increase the chiral separation efficiency but this is difficult to realize. Now a self‐reporting strategy is presented for visualizing the crystallization process by a dyed self‐assembled inhibitor made from the copolymers with tri(ethylene glycol)‐grafting polymethylsiloxane as the main chain and poly(N⁶‐methacryloyl‐l ‐lysine) as side chains. When applied with seeds together for the fractional crystallization of conglomerates, the inhibitors can label the formation of the secondary crystals and guide the complete separation process of two enantiomers with colorless crystals as the first product and red crystals as the second. This method leads to high optical purity of d /l ‐Asn?H₂O (99.9 % ee for d ‐crystals and 99.5 % for l ‐crystals) in a single crystallization process. It requires a small amount of additives and shows excellent recyclability.     

Anti-fouling chemistry of chiral monolayers: enhancing biofilm resistance on racemic surface

This work reports the resistance to protein adsorption and bacterial biofilm formation by chiral monolayers of polyol-terminated alkanethiols surrounding micrometer-sized patterns of methyl-terminated alkanethiols on gold films. We discover that patterned surfaces surrounded by chiral polyol monolayers can distinguish different stages of biofilm formation. After inoculation on the surfaces, bacteria first reversibly attached on the chiral polyol monolayers. Over time, the bacteria detached from the polyol surfaces, and attached on the hydrophobic micropatterns to form biofilms. Interestingly, while both enantiomers of gulitol- and mannonamide-terminated monolayer resisted adsorption of proteins (bovine serum albumin, lysozyme, and fibrinogen) and confined biofilms formed on the micropatterns, the monolayers formed by the racemic mixture of either pair of enantiomers exhibited stronger antifouling chemistry against both protein adsorption and biofilm formation than monolayers formed by one enantiomer alone. These results reveal the different chemistries that separate the different stages of biofilm formation, and the stereochemical influence on resisting biofoulings at a molecular-level.     

Probing chiral interfaces by infrared spectroscopic methods

Biological homochirality on earth and its tremendous consequences for pharmaceutical science and technology has led to an ever increasing interest in the selective production, the resolution and the detection of enantiomers of a chiral compound. Chiral surfaces and interfaces that can distinguish between enantiomers play a key role in this respect as enantioselective catalysts as well as for separation purposes. Despite the impressive progress in these areas in the last decade, molecular-level understanding of the interactions that are at the origin of enantiodiscrimination are lagging behind due to the lack of powerful experimental techniques to spot these interactions selectively with high sensitivity. In this article, techniques based on infrared spectroscopy are highlighted that are able to selectively target the chiral properties of interfaces. In particular, these methods are the combination of Attenuated Total Reflection InfraRed (ATR-IR) with Modulation Excitation Spectroscopy (MES) to probe enantiodiscriminating interactions at chiral solid-liquid interfaces and Vibrational Circular Dichroism (VCD), which is used to probe the structure of chirally-modified metal nanoparticles. The former technique aims at suppressing signals arising from non-selective interactions, which may completely hide the signals of interest due to enantiodiscriminating interactions. Recently, this method was successfully applied to investigate enantiodiscrimination at self-assembled monolayers of chiral thiols on gold surfaces. The nanometer size analogues of the latter--gold nanoparticles protected by a monolayer of a chiral thiol--are amenable to VCD spectroscopy. It is shown that this technique yields detailed structural information on the adsorption mode and the conformation of the adsorbed thiol. This may also turn out to be useful to clarify how chirality can be bestowed onto the metal core itself and the nature of the chirality of the latter, which is manifested in the metal-based circular dichroism activity of these nanoparticles.     

Comparison of resolution methods for racemic 8-(phenylsulfinyl)-1-naphthoic acid

Despite of the fact that resolution is an extremely important process in the pharmaceutical and agrochemical industries, the development of the separation of enantiomers is still based on trial-and-error experiments. In order to compare the different procedures, the resolution of 8-(phenylsulfinyl)-1-naphthoic acid 1 was carried out by chiral organic bases using heat facilitated diastereomeric crystallization, enantioselective liquid–liquid extraction and chiroselective transport. The results give valuable information about the interactions in the racemate/resolving agent/solvent system, which helps with the understanding and development of resolution processes. Diastereomeric crystallization with brucine as a resolving agent afforded enantiomerically pure (?)-1.     

Enantiomer analysis of chiral carboxylic acids by AIE molecules bearing optically pure aminol groups

Pure enantiomers of carboxylic acids are a class of important biomolecules, chiral drugs, chiral reagents, etc. Analysis of the enantiomers usually needs expensive instrument or complex chiral receptors. However, to develop simple and reliable methods for the enantiomer analysis of acids is difficult. In this paper, chiral recognition of 2,3-dibenzoyltartaric acid and mandelic acid was first carried out by aggregation-induced emission molecules bearing optically pure aminol group, which was easily synthesized. The chiral recognition is not only seen by naked eyes but also measured by fluorophotometer. The difference of fluorescence intensity between the two enantiomers of the acids aroused by the aggregation-induced emission molecules was up to 598. The chiral recognition could be applied to quantitative analysis of enantiomer content of chiral acids. More chiral AIE amines need to be developed for enantiomer analysis of more carboxylic acids.     

Selective growth and distribution of crystalline enantiomers in hydrogels

The crystallization of sodium chlorate (NaClO3) is a classic example of spontaneous chirality, since it is achiral in solution but adopts a chiral form in the solid state. While crystal growth of NaClO3 from pure aqueous solutions yields a 50:50 statistical distribution of d- and l-crystals, large enantiomeric excesses of either d- and l-crystals can be achieved by crystal growth in agarose gel, a naturally occurring chiral polysaccharide. The influence of gel density (0.1-0.75 wt %), temperature, and the diffusion of cosolvents on crystal distribution was discerned from statistical data obtained from 752 gel-mediated crystallization experiments yielding 12,384 individual crystals. These studies demonstrate that the magnitude and direction of the bias can be selectively engineered toward either d- or l-forms by changing the gelation conditions. Aqueous agarose gels infused with 48 wt % NaClO3 at 6 degrees C, favored the growth of d-NaClO3 crystals, with ee's reaching 22% at the highest gel concentrations. Crystal growth under methanol diffusion favored deposition of the opposite enantiomorph, l-NaClO3. The bias in the crystal distribution is enhanced at higher temperatures. Aqueous gels at 24 degrees C infused with methanol cosolvent favored l-NaClO3, with ee's reaching 53%. The changing magnitude and direction of the enantiomorph bias can be ascribed to differences in the agarose conformation and intermolecular interactions between the gel and crystal surfaces that inhibit the formation of the two enantiomers to different extents.     

Enantiomer separation on monolithic silica HPLC columns using chemically bonded methylated and methylated/acetylated 6-O-tert-butyldimethylsilylated beta-cyclodextrin

A new 2,3-methylated 3*-monoacetylated 6-O-tert-butyldimethylsilylated beta-CD derivative was synthesized and chemically bonded onto aminopropyl derivatized monolithic silica HPLC columns. In this CD derivative, only one of seven methyl groups in 3-position was substituted by an acetyl group. Its applicability as a chiral stationary phase for HPLC was tested and compared with exclusively 2,3-methylated 6-O-tert-butyldimethylsilylated beta-CD immobilized onto aminopropyl-modified monoliths. Thirty-two chiral compounds from different chemical classes and different functionalities were tested under RP conditions. Fourteen compounds were resolved into their enantiomers by methylated 6-O-tert-butyldimethylsilylated beta-CD. By use of methylated/acetylated 6-O-tert-butyldimethylsilylated beta-CD as the chiral stationary phase 7 analytes were successfully stereodifferentiated.     

Resolution and chiroptical properties of the neurotoxin 1-trichloromethyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydro-β-carboline (TaClo) and related compounds: quantum chemical CD calculations and X-ray diffraction analysis

Separation and stereochemical attribution of the two enantiomers of the neurotoxin 1-trichloromethyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydro-β-carboline (TaClo) has been achieved by applying chromatography on a chiral phase HPLC column in hyphenation with circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy (LC-CD coupling). Assignment of the absolute configuration of TaClo and its N-methyl analog has been achieved by quantum chemical CD calculations and has finally been confirmed by single-crystal X-ray diffraction analyses of the two enantiomers of N-formyl-TaClo as obtained in enantiomerically pure form by crystallization.     

Chiral capillary electrophoresis as predictor for separation of drug enantiomers in continuous flow zone electrophoresis

Separation of the enantiomers of chlorpheniramine and methadone in acidic buffers containing carboxymethyl-betacyclodextrin (CMCD) as chiral selector was investigated by capillary zone electrophoresis. For a range of pH and CMCD concentrations, the mobility difference and resolution of the enantiomers were determined. Then, conditions known to provide well resolved enantiomers and optimized chiral separation were applied to chiral continuous flow electrophoresis. In that approach, a thin film of fluid flowing between two parallel plates is employed as carrier for electrophoresis. The electrolytes and the sample are continuously admitted at one end of the electrophoresis chamber and are fractionated by an array of outlet tubes at the other. The number of pure enantiomeric fractions obtained by chiral continuous flow electrophoresis was found to be directly dependent on the enantiomeric mobility difference. For racemic chlorpheniramine separated in a betaine-acetic acid buffer at a total throughput of 5 mg/h, complete enantiomeric separation is shown to require a mobility difference of about 3 x 10(-9) m2/V s. Furthermore, compared to the previous investigations with hydroxypropyl-beta-cyclodextrin, CMCD was found to permit improved fractionation of methadone enantiomers. With a total racemic drug throughput of about 15 mg/h, continuous flow zone electrophoresis processing with CMCD as chiral selector is shown to have the potential of providing pure enantiomers on a mg/h scale. The results indicate that chiral capillary zone electrophoresis data can be employed as predictor for preparative scale chiral separations based upon continuous flow zone electrophoresis.