Exploring SCC-DFTB paths for mapping QM/MM reaction mechanisms

A new first-order procedure for locating transition structures (TS) that employs hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) potentials has been developed. This new technique (RPATh+RESD) combines the replica path method (RPATh) and standard reaction coordinate driving (RCD) techniques in an approach that both efficiently determines reaction barriers and successfully eliminates two key weaknesses of RCD calculations (i.e., hysteresis/discontinuities in the path and the sequential nature of the RCD procedure). In addition, we have extended CHARMM's QM/MM reaction pathway methods, the RPATh and nudged elastic band (NEB) methods, to incorporate SCC-DFTB wave functions. This newly added functionality has been applied to the chorismate mutase-catalyzed interconversion of chorismate to prephenate, which is a key step in the shikimate pathway of bacteria, fungi, and other higher plants. The RPATh+RESD barrier height (DeltaE=5.7 kcal/mol) is in good agreement with previous results from full-energy surface mapping studies (Zhang, X.; Zhang, X.; Bruice, T. C. Biochemistry 2005, 44, 10443-10448). Full reaction paths were independently mapped with RPATh and NEB methods and showed good agreement with the final transition state from the RPATh+RESD "gold standard" and previous high-level QM/MM transition states (Woodcock, H. L.; Hodoscek, M.; Gilbert, T. B.; Gill, P. M. W.; Schaefer, H. F.; Brooks, B. R. J. Comput. Chem. 2007, 28, 1485-1502). The SCC-DFTB TS geometry most closely approximates the MP2/6-31+G(d) QM/MM result. However, the barrier height is underestimated and possibly points to an area for improvement in SCC-DFTB parametrization. In addition, the steepest descents (SD) minimizer for the NEB method was modified to uncouple the in-path and off-path degrees of freedom during the minimization, which significantly improved performance. The convergence behavior of the RPATh and NEB was examined for SCC-DFTB wave functions, and it was determined that, in general, both methods converge at about the same rate, although the techniques used for convergence may be different. For instance, RPATh can effectively use the adopted basis Newton-Raphson (ABNR) minimizer, where NEB seems to require a combination of SD and ABNR.     

QM/MM study of the absorption spectra of DsRed.M1 chromophores

We report geometries and vertical excitation energies for the red and green chromophores of the DsRed.M1 protein in the gas phase and in the solvated protein environment. Geometries are optimized using density functional theory (DFT, B3LYP functional) for the isolated chromophores and combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) methods for the protein (B3LYP/MM). Vertical excitation energies are computed using DFT/MRCI, OM2/MRCI, and TDDFT as QM methods. In the case of the red chromophore, there is a general blue shift in the excitation energies when going from the isolated chromophore to the protein, which is caused both by structural changes and by electrostatic interactions with the environment. For the lowest ππ* transition, these two factors contribute to a similar extent to the overall DFT/MRCI shift of 0.4 eV. An enlargement of the QM region to include active‐site residues does not change the DFT/MRCI excitation energies much. The DFT/MRCI results are closest to experiment for both chromophores. OM2/MRCI and TDDFT overestimate the first vertical excitation energy by 0.3–0.5 and 0.2–0.4 eV, respectively, relative to the experimental or DFT/MRCI values. The experimental gap of 0.35 eV between the lowest ππ* excitation energies of the red (cis‐acylimine) and green (trans‐peptide) forms is well reproduced by DFT/MRCI and TDDFT (0.32 and 0.37 eV, respectively). A histogram spectrum for an equal mixture of the two forms, generated by OM2/MRCI calculations on 450 snapshots along molecular dynamics trajectories, matches the experimental spectrum quite well, with a gap of 0.23 eV and an overall blue shift of about 0.3 eV. DFT/MRCI appears as an attractive choice for calculating excitation energies in fluorescent proteins, without the shortcomings of TDDFT and computationally more affordable than CASSCF‐based approaches. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Comput Chem, 2010     

Prediction and rationalization of protein pKa values using QM and QM/MM methods

We describe the development and application of a computational method for the prediction and rationalization of pKa values of ionizable residues in proteins, based on ab initio quantum mechanics (QM) and the effective fragment potential (EFPs) method (a hybrid QM/MM method). The theoretical developments include (1) a covalent boundary method based on frozen localized orbitals, (2) divide-and-conquer methods for the ab initio computation of protein EFPs consisting of multipoles up to octupoles and dipole polarizability tensors, (3) a method for computing vibrational free energies for a localized molecular region, and (4) solutions of the polarized continuum model of bulk solvation equations for protein-sized systems. The QM-based pKa prediction method is one of the most accurate methods currently available and can be used in cases where other pKa prediction methods fail. Preliminary analysis of the computed results indicate that many pKa values (1) are primarily determined by hydrogen bonds rather than long-range charge-charge interactions and (2) are relatively insensitive to large-scale dynamical fluctuations of the protein structure.     

Exploring the interstitial atom in the FeMo cofactor of nitrogenase: insights from QM and QM/MM calculations

Density functional theory and combined quantum mechanics and molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations have been used to explore structural features of the FeMo cofactor with an interstitial atom X (X = N, C, or O) and its interactions with CO and N 2. Predicted frequencies of the metal-bound CO, QM/MM-optimized geometries, and calculated redox potentials of the FeMo cofactor with different central ligands show that the oxygen atom is the candidate for the interstitial atom. Calculations on the interactions of the FeMo cofactor with CO and N 2 reveal that there is a remarkable dependence of the binding energy on the binding site and the interstitial atom. Generally, the Fe2 site of the FeMo cofactor has stronger interactions with CO and N 2 than Fe6, and both the Fe2 and Fe6 sites in the N-centered and O-centered clusters of the FeMo cofactor can effectively bind N 2 while the coordination of N 2 to the Fe6 site of the C-centered active cluster is unfavorable energetically. Present results indicate that the protein environment is important for computational characterization of the structure of the FeMo cofactor and properties of the metal-bound CO and N 2 are sensitive to the interstitial atom.     

Binding affinities by alchemical perturbation using QM/MM with a large QM system and polarizable MM model

The most general way to improve the accuracy of binding‐affinity calculations for protein–ligand systems is to use quantum‐mechanical (QM) methods together with rigorous alchemical‐perturbation (AP) methods. We explore this approach by calculating the relative binding free energy of two synthetic disaccharides binding to galectin‐3 at a reasonably high QM level (dispersion‐corrected density functional theory with a triple‐zeta basis set) and with a sufficiently large QM system to include all short‐range interactions with the ligand (744–748 atoms). The rest of the protein is treated as a collection of atomic multipoles (up to quadrupoles) and polarizabilities. Several methods for evaluating the binding free energy from the 3600 QM calculations are investigated in terms of stability and accuracy. In particular, methods using QM calculations only at the endpoints of the transformation are compared with the recently proposed non‐Boltzmann Bennett acceptance ratio (NBB) method that uses QM calculations at several stages of the transformation. Unfortunately, none of the rigorous approaches give sufficient statistical precision. However, a novel approximate method, involving the direct use of QM energies in the Bennett acceptance ratio method, gives similar results as NBB but with better precision, ～3 kJ/mol. The statistical error can be further reduced by performing a greater number of QM calculations. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Dual-topology/dual-coordinate free-energy simulation using QM/MM force field

We have developed a dual-topology/dual-coordinate free-energy simulation method for use with a QM/MM force field. By combining two parallel processes into one alchemical process, we are able to compute the double free-energy difference (delta deltaF) within a single simulation, which eliminates half of the expensive quantum-mechanical simulation in general. The method has been tested in computing the solvation free-energy differences of several molecular pairs and shows close agreement with experimental results.     

Transition structure selectivity in enzyme catalysis: a QM/MM study of chorismate mutase

Two different transition structures (TSs) have been located and characterized for the chorismate conversion to prephenate in Bacillus subtilis chorismate mutase by means of hybrid quantum-mechanical/molecular-mechanical (QM/MM) calculations. GRACE software, combined with an AM1/CHARMM24/TIP3P potential, has been used involving full gradient relaxation of the position of ca. 3300 atoms. These TSs have been connected with their respective reactants and products by the intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC) procedure carried out in the presence of the protein environment, thus obtaining for the first time a realistic enzymatic reaction path for this reaction. Similar QM/MM computational schemes have been applied to study the chemical reaction solvated by ca. 500 water molecules. Comparison of these results together with gas phase calculations has allowed understanding of the catalytic efficiency of the protein. The enzyme stabilizes one of the TSs (TS_OHout) by means of specific hydrogen bond interactions, while the other TS (TS_OHin) is the preferred one in vacuum and in water. The enzyme TS is effectively more polarized but less dissociative than the corresponding solvent and gas phase TSs. Electrostatic stabilization and an intramolecular charge-transfer process can explain this enzymatically induced change. Our theoretical results provide new information on an important enzymatic transformation and the key factors responsible for efficient selectivity are clarified. Received: 25 March 2000 / Accepted: 7 August 2000 / Published online: 23 November 2000     

Flexible-boundary QM/MM calculations: II. Partial charge transfer across the QM/MM boundary that passes through a covalent bond

Recently, based on the principle of electronic chemical potential equalization and the principle of charge conservation, we proposed a flexible-boundary scheme that allows both partial charge transfer and self-consistent polarization between the quantum mechanical (QM) and molecular mechanical (MM) subsystems in QM/MM calculations; the scheme was applied to study the atomic charges in selected ion–solvent complexes. In the present contribution, we further extend the flexible-boundary treatment to handle the QM/MM boundary passing through covalent bonds. We find that the flexible-boundary redistributed charge and dipole schemes yield reasonable agreement with full-QM calculations for a number of molecular ions and amino acids with charged side chains. Using the full-QM results as reference, the mean unsigned deviations are computed to be 0.06 e for atomic partial charges of the QM atoms, 0.11 e for the amounts of charge transfer between the QM and MM subsystems, and 0.016 Å for the lengths of the covalent bonds that directly connect the QM and MM subsystems. The results indicate the importance of accounting for partial charge transfer across the QM/MM boundary when the QM subsystems are charged.     

Exploring structure and dynamics of the diaquotriamminezinc(II) complex by QM/MM MD simulation

The structural and dynamical properties of the cis-(O-Zn-O angle approximately 90 degrees) and trans-(O-Zn-O angle approximately 180 degrees) isomers of the model diaquotriamminezinc(II) complex in aqueous solution have been evaluated using the hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical molecular dynamics simulation approach at ab initio Hartree-Fock level. In both complexes, the first hydration shell contains five ligands (two water and three ammonia molecules) arranged in a trigonal bipyramidal geometry. In the metastable cis-isomer two different bond lengths of 2.34 and 2.13 A are observed for the Zn-Oax and Zn-Oeq bonds, respectively. The trans-isomer shows the maximum of the Zn-O distance at 2.26 A. The Zn-N bond distances in both cases are approximately 2.12 A. A geometrical transformation of the cis-isomer into the trans-isomer was observed after 11.5 ps of simulation, and the trans-isomer then remained stable throughout the whole simulation time of 30 ps. A comparative study for both isomers has been performed in terms of radial distribution functions, coordination number distributions, angular distribution functions, tilt and theta angle distributions, ligands' mean residence time, ion-ligand stretching frequencies, and the vibrational and librational motions of water ligands. The results are compared with the data for the previously studied zinc-monoamine and -diamine complexes.     

QM/MM study of the taxadiene synthase mechanism

Combined quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations were used to investigate the reaction mechanism of taxadiene synthase (TXS). TXS catalyzes the cyclization of geranylgeranyl diphosphate (GGPP) to taxadiene (T) and four minor cyclic products. All these products originate from the deprotonation of carbocation intermediates. The reaction profiles for the conversion of GGPP to T as well as to minor products were calculated for different configurations of relevant TXS carbocation complexes. The QM region was treated at the M06-2X/TZVP level, while the CHARMM27 force field was used to describe the MM region. The QM/MM calculations suggest a reaction pathway for the conversion of GGPP to T, which slightly differs from previous proposals regarding the number of reaction steps and the conformation of the carbocations. The QM/MM results also indicate that the formation of minor products via water-assisted deprotonation of the carbocations is highly exothermic, by about −7 to −23 kcal/mol. Curiously, however, the computed barriers and reaction energies indicate that the formation of some of the minor products is more facile than the formation of T. Thus, the present QM/MM calculations provide detailed insights into possible reaction pathways and into the origin of the promiscuity of TXS, but they do not reproduce the product distribution observed experimentally. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Insight into enzymatic C-F bond formation from QM and QM/MM calculations

The C-F bond-forming step in the fluorinase, the only native fluorination enzyme characterized to date, has been studied. The enzyme catalyzes the reaction between S-adenosyl-L-methionine (SAM) and fluoride ions to form 5'-fluoro-5'-deoxyadenosine (5'-FDA) and L-methionine. To obtain an insight into the mechanism of this unusual enzymatic reaction and to elucidate the role of the enzyme in catalysis, we have explored the conformational energetics of SAM and the intrinsic reactivity patterns of SAM and fluoride with DFT (BP86) and continuum solvent methods, before investigating the full enzymatic system with combined DFT/CHARMM calculations. We find that the enzymatic reaction follows an S(N)2 reaction mechanism, concurring with the intrinsic reactivity preferences in solution. The formation of sulfur ylides is thermodynamically strongly disfavored, and an alternative elimination-addition mechanism involving the concerted anti-Markovnikov addition of HF to an enol ether is energetically viable, but kinetically prohibitive. The S(N)2 activation energy is 92 (112) kJ mol(-)(1) in solution, but only 53 (63) kJ mol(-1) in the enzyme, and the reaction energy in the enzyme is -25 (-34) kJ mol(-1) (values in parentheses are B3LYP single-point energies). The fluorinase thus lowers the barrier for C-F bond formation by 39 (49) kJ mol(-)(1). A decomposition analysis shows that the major role of the enzyme is in the preparation and positioning of the substrates.     

Quantifying Electronic Effects in QM and QM/MM Biomolecular Modeling with the Fukui Function

Multi-scale quantum-mechanical/molecular-mechanical(QM/MM) and large-scale QM simulation provide valuable insight into enzyme mechanism and structure-property relationships. Analysis of the electron density afforded through these methods can enhance our understanding of how the enzyme environment modulates reactivity at the enzyme active site. From this perspective, tools from conceptual density functional theory to interrogate electron densities can provide added insight into enzyme function. We recently introduced the highly parallelizable Fukui shift analysis(FSA) method, which identifies how frontier states of an active site are altered by the presence of an additional QM residue to identify when QM treatment of a residue is essential as a result of quantum-mechanically affecting the behavior of the active site. We now demonstrate and analyze distance and residue dependence of Fukui function shifts in pairs of residues representing different non-covalent interactions. We also show how the interpretation of the Fukui function as a measure of relative nucleophilicity provides insight into enzymes that carry out S_N2 methyl transfer. The FSA method represents a promising approach for the systematic, unbiased determination of quantum mechanical effects in enzymes and for other complex systems that necessitate multi-scale modeling.     

MM and QM/MM Modeling of Threonyl-tRNA Synthetase: Model Testing and Simulations

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are centrally important enzymes in protein synthesis. We have investigated threonyl-tRNA synthetase from E. coli, complexed with reactants, using molecular mechanics and combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) techniques. These modeling methods have the potential to provide molecular level understanding of enzyme catalytic processes. Modeling of this enzyme presents a number of challenges. The procedure of system preparation and testing is described in detail. For example, the number of metal ions at the active site, and their positions, were investigated. Molecular dynamics simulations suggest that the system is most stable when it contains only one magnesium ion, and the zinc ion is removed. Two different QM/MM methods were tested in models based on the findings of MM molecular dynamics simulations. AM1/CHARMM calculations resulted in unrealistic structures for the phosphates in this system. This is apparently due to an error of AM1. PM3/CHARMM calculations proved to be more suitable for this enzyme system. These results will provide a useful basis for future modeling investigations of the enzyme mechanism and dynamics.     

Chaperoned alchemical free energy simulations: a general method for QM, MM, and QM/MM potentials

A general method for alchemical free energy simulations using QM, MM, and QM/MM potential is developed by introducing "chaperones" to restrain the structures, particularly near the end points. A calculation of the free energy difference between two triazole tautomers in aqueous solution is used to illustrate the method.     

pKa calculations in solution and proteins with QM/MM free energy perturbation simulations: a quantitative test of QM/MM protocols

The accuracy of biological simulations depends, in large part, on the treatment of electrostatics. Due to the availability of accurate experimental values, calculation of pKa provides stringent evaluation of computational methods. The generalized solvent boundary potential (GSBP) and Ewald summation electrostatic treatments were recently implemented for combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanics (QM/MM) simulations by our group. These approaches were tested by calculating pKa shifts due to differences in electronic structure and electrostatic environment; the shifts were determined for a series of small molecules in solution, using various electrostatic treatments, and two residues (His 31, Lys 102) in the M102K T4-lysozyme mutant with large pKa shifts, using the GSBP approach. The calculations utilized a free energy perturbation scheme with the QM/MM potential function involving the self-consistent charge density functional tight binding (SCC-DFTB) and CHARMM as the QM and MM methods, respectively. The study of small molecules demonstrated that inconsistent electrostatic models produced results that were difficult to correct in a robust manner; by contrast, extended electrostatics, GSBP, and Ewald simulations produced consistent results once a bulk solvation contribution was carefully chosen. In addition to the electrostatic treatment, the pKa shifts were also sensitive to the level of the QM method and the scheme of treating QM/MM Coulombic interactions; however, simple perturbative corrections based on SCC-DFTB/CHARMM trajectories and higher level single point energy calculations were found to give satisfactory results. Combining all factors gave a root-mean-square difference of 0.7 pKa units for the relative pKa values of the small molecules compared to experiment. For the residues in the lysozyme, an accurate pKa shift was obtained for His 31 with multiple nanosecond simulations. For Lys 102, however, the pKa shift was estimated to be too large, even after more than 10 nanosecond simulations for each lambda window; the difficulty was due to the significant, but slow, reorganization of the protein and water structure when Lys 102 was protonated. The simulations support that Lys 102 is deprotonated in the X-ray structure and the protein is highly destabilized when this residue is protonated.     

量子力学和分子力学组合方法及其应用

QM/MM组合方法在研究凝聚态中的化学反应及生物大分子的结构和活性之间的关系等方面已取得重要进展。这一方法的要点在于将大体系配分成几部分,根据需要对不同部分进行不同级别的处理,因此既利用了量子力学的精确性,又利用了分子力学的高效性。对QM/MM组合理论及其一些最新进展作一简单介绍,并以最近进行了几个工作为例说明QM、MM组合方法的应用。     

量子力学和分子力学组合方法及其应用

QM/MM组合方法在研究凝聚态中的化学反应及生物大分子的结构和活性之间的关系等方面已取得重要进展。这一方法的要点在于将大体系配分成几部分,根据需要对不同部分进行不同级别的处理,因此既利用了量子力学的精确性,又利用了分子力学的高效性。对QM/MM组合理论及其一些最新进展作一简单介绍,并以最近进行了几个工作为例说明QM、MM组合方法的应用。     

A critical evaluation of different QM/MM frontier treatments with SCC-DFTB as the QM method

The performance of different link atom based frontier treatments in QM/MM simulations was evaluated critically with SCC-DFTB as the QM method. In addition to the analysis of gas-phase molecules as in previous studies, an important element of the present work is that chemical reactions in realistic enzyme systems were also examined. The schemes tested include all options available in the program CHARMM for SCC-DFTB/MM simulation, which treat electrostatic interactions due to the MM atoms close to the QM/MM boundary in different ways. In addition, a new approach, the divided frontier charge (DIV), has been implemented in which the partial charge associated with the frontier MM atom ("link host") is evenly distributed to the other MM atoms in the same group. The performance of these schemes was evaluated based on properties including proton affinities, deprotonation energies, dipole moments, and energetics of proton transfer reactions. Similar to previous work, it was found that calculated proton affinities and deprotonation energies of alcohols, carbonic acids, amino acids, and model DNA bases are very sensitive to the link atom scheme; the commonly used single link atom approach often gives error on the order of 15 to 20 kcal/mol. Other schemes give better and, on average, mutually comparable results. For proton transfer reactions, encouragingly, both activation barriers and reaction energies are fairly insensitive (within a typical range of 2-4 kcal/mol) to the link atom scheme due to error cancellation, and this was observed for both gas-phase and enzyme systems. Therefore, the effect of using different link atom schemes in QM/MM simulations is rather small for chemical reactions that conserve the total charge. Although the current study used an approximate DFT method as the QM level, the observed trends are expected to be applicable to QM/MM methods with use of other QM approaches. This observation does not mean to encourage QM/MM simulations without careful benchmark in the study of specific systems, rather it emphasizes that other technical details, such as the treatment of long-range electrostatics, tend to play a more important role and need to be handled carefully.     

QM/MM study of the active species of the human cytochrome P450 3A4, and the influence thereof of the multiple substrate binding

Cytochrome P450 3A4 is involved in the metabolism of 50% of all swallowed drugs. The enzyme functions by means of a high-valent iron-oxo species, called compound I (Cpd I), which is formed after entrance of the substrate to the active site. We explored the features of Cpd I using hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical calculations on various models that are either substrate-free or containing one and two molecules of diazepam as a substrate. M?ssbauer parameters of Cpd I were computed. Our major finding shows that without the substrate, Cpd I tends to elongate its Fe-S bond, localize the radical on the sulfur, and form hydrogen bonds with A305 and T309, which may hypothetically lead to Cpd I consumption by H-abstraction. However, the positioning of diazepam close to Cpd I, as enforced by the effector molecule, was found to strengthen the NH...S interactions of the conserved I443 and G444 residues with the proximal cysteinate ligand. These interactions are known to stabilize the Fe-S bond, and as such, the presence of the substrate leads to a shorter Fe-S bond and it prevents the localization of the radical on the sulfur. This diazepam-Cpd I stabilization was manifested in the 1W0E conformer. The effector substrate did not influence Cpd I directly but rather by positioning the active substrate close to Cpd I, thus displacing the hydrogen bonds with A305 and T309, and thereby giving preference to substrate oxidation. It is hypothesized that these effects on Cpd I, promoted by the restrained substrate, may be behind the special metabolic behavior observed in cases of multiple substrate binding (also called cooperative binding). This restraint constitutes a mechanism whereby substrates stabilize Cpd I sufficiently long to affect monooxygenation by P450s at the expense of Cpd I destruction by the protein residues.     

Combined QM/MM study of the opsin shift in bacteriorhodopsin

Combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) calculations and molecular dynamics simulations of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in the membrane matrix have been carried out to determine the factors that make significant contributions to the opsin shift. We found that both solvation and interactions with the protein significantly shifts the absorption maximum of the retinal protonated Schiff base, but the effects are much more pronounced in polar solvents such as methanol, acetonitrile, and water than in the protein environment. The differential solvatochromic shifts of PSB in methanol and in bR leads to a bathochromic shift of about 1800 cm(-1). Because the combined QM/MM configuration interaction calculation is essentially a point charge model, this contribution is attributed to the extended point-charge model of Honig and Nakanishi. The incorporation of retinal in bR is accompanied by a change in retinal conformation from the 6-s-cis form in solution to the 6-s-trans configuration in bR. The extension of the pi-conjugated system further increases the red-shift by 2400 cm(-1). The remaining factors are due to the change in dispersion interactions. Using an estimate of about 1000 cm(-1) in the dispersion contribution by Houjou et al., we obtained a theoretical opsin shift of 5200 cm(-1) in bR, which is in excellent agreement with the experimental value of 5100 cm(-1). Structural analysis of the PSB binding site revealed the specific interactions that make contributions to the observed opsin shift. The combined QM/MM method used in the present study provides an opportunity to accurately model the photoisomerization and proton transfer reactions in bR.