Effect of thermal treatment, ionic strength, and pH on the short-term and long-term coalescence stability of beta-lactoglobulin emulsions

We present experimental results about the effects of thermal treatment, ionic strength, and pH on the protein adsorption and coalescence stability of freshly prepared (2 h after emulsification) and 6-day-stored emulsions, stabilized by the globular protein beta-lactoglobulin (BLG). In all emulsions studied, the volume fraction of the dispersed soybean oil is 30% and the mean drop diameter is d(32) approximately 40 microm. The protein concentration, C(BLG), is varied between 0.02 and 0.1 wt %, the electrolyte concentration, C(EL), between 1.5 mM and 1 M, and pH between 4.0 and 7.0. The emulsion heating is performed at 85 degrees C, which is above the denaturing temperature of BLG. The results show that, at C(BLG) > or = 0.04 wt %, C(EL) > or = 150 mM, and pH > or = 6.2, the heating leads to higher protein adsorption and to irreversible attachment of the adsorbed molecules, which results in enhanced steric repulsion between the protein adsorption multilayers and to higher emulsion stability. At low electrolyte concentration, C(EL) < or = 10 mM, the emulsion stability is determined by electrostatic interactions and is not affected significantly by the emulsion heating. The latter result is explained by electrostatic repulsion between the adsorbed protein molecules, which keeps them separated from each other and thus precludes the formation of disulfide covalent bonds in the protein adsorption layer. The coalescence stability of heated and nonheated emulsions is practically the same and does not depend on C(EL), when pH is around the isoelectric point (IEP) of the protein molecules. This is explained with the adsorption of uncharged BLG molecules, in compact conformation, which stores the reactive sulfhydryl groups hidden inside the molecule interior, thus preventing the formation of covalent intermolecular bonds upon heating. We studied also the effect of storage time on the stability of heated and nonheated emulsions. The stability of nonheated emulsions (C(BLG) = 0.1 wt %, C(EL) > or = 150 mM, and pH = 6.2) significantly decreases after 1 day of storage (aging effect). In contrast, no aging effect is observed after emulsion heating. FTIR spectra of heated and nonheated, fresh and aged emulsions suggest that the aging effect is caused by slow conformational changes of the protein molecules in the adsorption layer, accompanied with partial loss of the ordered secondary structure of the protein and with the formation of lateral noncovalent bonds (H-bonds and hydrophobic interactions) between the adsorbed molecules. After thermal treatment of the BLG emulsions, the molecules preserve their original secondary structure upon storage, which eliminates the aging effect.     

Role of surfactant type and concentration for the mean drop size during emulsification in turbulent flow

A systematic experimental study of the effect of several factors on the mean drop diameter, d32, during emulsification, is performed with soybean oil-in-water emulsions. These factors are (1) type of used emulsifier; (2) emulsifier concentration, CS; and (3) ionic strength of the aqueous solution. Three different types of emulsifier, anionic (sodium dodecyl sulfate, SDS), nonionic (polyoxyethylene-20 cetyl ether, Brij 58), and protein (whey protein concentrate), are studied. For all of the studied systems, two well-defined regions are observed in the dependence of d32 on CS: at low surfactant concentration, d32 increases significantly with the decrease of CS (region 1), whereas d32 does not depend on CS at high surfactant concentration (region 2). The model, proposed by Tcholakova et al. (Langmuir 2003, 19, 5640), is found to describe well the dependence of d32 on CS in region 1 for the nonionic surfactant and for the protein emulsifier at high electrolyte concentration, 150 mM NaCl. According to this model, a well defined minimal surfactant adsorption (close to that of the dense adsorption monolayer) is needed for obtaining an emulsion. On the other hand, this model is found inapplicable to emulsions stabilized by the ionic surfactant, SDS, and by the nonionic surfactant, Brij 58, at low electrolyte concentration. The performed theoretical analysis of drop-drop interactions, in the emulsification equipment, shows that a strong electrostatic repulsion between the colliding drops impedes the drop-drop coalescence in the latter systems, so that smaller emulsion drops are obtained in comparison with the theoretically predicted ones. The results for SDS-stabilized emulsions in region 1 are explained by a quantitative consideration of this electrostatic repulsion. The drop size in region 2 (surfactant-rich regime) is described very well by the Kolmogorov-Hinze theory of turbulent emulsification.     

Synergistic stabilization of emulsions by a mixture of surface-active nanoparticles and surfactant

The stability and rheology of tricaprylin oil-in-water emulsions containing a mixture of surface-active hydrophilic silica nanoparticles and pure nonionic surfactant molecules are reported and compared with those of emulsions stabilized by each emulsifier alone. The importance of the preparation protocol is highlighted. Addition of particles to a surfactant-stabilized emulsion results in the appearance of a small population of large drops due to coalescence, possibly by bridging of adsorbed particles. Addition of surfactant to a particle-stabilized emulsion surprisingly led to increased coalescence too, although the resistance to creaming increased mainly due to an increase in viscosity. Simultaneous emulsification of particles and surfactant led to synergistic stabilization at intermediate concentrations of surfactant; emulsions completely stable to both creaming and coalescence exist at low overall emulsifier concentration. Using the adsorption isotherm of surfactant on particles and the viscosity and optical density of aqueous particle dispersions, we show that the most stable emulsions are formed from dispersions of flocculated, partially hydrophobic particles. From equilibrium contact angle and oil-water interfacial tension measurements, the calculated free energy of adsorption E of a silica particle to the oil-water interface passes through a maximum with respect to surfactant concentration, in line with the emulsion stability optimum. This results from a competition between the influence of particle hydrophobicity and interfacial tension on the magnitude of E.     

Influence of interfacial rheology on foam and emulsion properties

Foams and emulsions are stabilized by surfactant monolayers that adsorb at the air-water and oil-water interfaces, respectively. As a result of monolayer adsorption, the interfaces become viscoelastic. We will describe experiments showing that foaming, emulsification, foam and emulsion stability, are strongly dependent upon the value of compression elasticity and viscosity. This will include excited surface wave devices for the measurement of surface viscoelasticity and thin film videointerferometry for the study of model films between air bubbles and emulsion drops.     

Ethanol-in-oil emulsion (E/O) stabilized by polyglycerol polyricinoleate: A potential delivery system for ethanolic extract

This study evaluated how variations in polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR) concentration and ethanol dispersed phase content affect the stability of ethanol-in-oil (E/O) emulsions. Results indicate that the stable 10?wt% E/O emulsions can be produced using 2?wt% PGPR. Increasing the ethanol dispersed phased content at constant PGPR concentration caused instability in emulsion. These emulsions remained stable to droplet flocculation and coalescence in the presence of Centella asiatica ethanol extract. PGPR does not greatly decrease the interfacial tension of the ethanol–oil interface. However, it adsorbed at the interface and stabilized the ethanol droplets in the emulsion via steric mechanism.     

Towards predicting the stability of protein-stabilized emulsions

The protein concentration is known to determine the stability against coalescence during formation of emulsions. Recently, it was observed that the protein concentration also influences the stability of formed emulsions against flocculation as a result of changes in the ionic strength. In both cases, the stability was postulated to be the result of a complete (i.e. saturated) coverage of the interface. By combining the current views on emulsion stability against coalescence and flocculation with new experimental data, an empiric model is established to predict emulsion stability based on protein molecular properties such as exposed hydrophobicity and charge. It was shown that besides protein concentration, the adsorbed layer (i.e. maximum adsorbed amount and interfacial area) dominates emulsion stability against coalescence and flocculation. Surprisingly, the emulsion stability was also affected by the adsorption rate. From these observations, it was concluded that a completely covered interface indeed ensures the stability of an emulsion against coalescence and flocculation. The contribution of adsorption rate and adsorbed amount on the stability of emulsions was combined in a surface coverage model. For this model, the adsorbed amount was predicted from the protein radius, surface charge and ionic strength. Moreover, the adsorption rate, which depends on the protein charge and exposed hydrophobicity, was approximated by the relative exposed hydrophobicity (Q_H). The model in the current state already showed good correspondence with the experimental data, and was furthermore shown to be applicable to describe data obtained from literature.     

Effect of varying the oil phase on the behavior of pH-responsive latex-based emulsifiers: demulsification versus transitional phase inversion

Sterically stabilized polystyrene latexes (previously described by Amalvy, J. I.; et al. Chem. Commun. 2003, 1826) were evaluated as pH-responsive particulate emulsifiers for the preparation of both oil-in-water and water-in-oil emulsions. The steric stabilizer was a well-defined AB diblock copolymer where A is poly(2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) and B is poly(methyl methacrylate). Several parameters were varied during the emulsion preparation, including the polarity of the oil phase, the latex concentration, surface concentration of copolymer stabilizer, and solution pH. Nonpolar oils such as n-dodecane gave oil-in-water emulsions, and polar oils such as 1-undecanol produced water-in-oil emulsions. In both cases, these emulsions proved to be stimulus-responsive: demulsification occurred rapidly on adjusting the solution pH. Oils of intermediate polarity such as methyl myristate or cineole led to emulsions that underwent transitional inversion on adjusting the solution pH. All emulsions were polydisperse and typically ranged from 40 to 400 microm diameter, as judged by optical microscopy and Malvern Mastersizer measurements. Critical point drying of the emulsion droplets, followed by scanning electron microscopy studies, confirmed that the latex particles were adsorbed as a single monolayer at the oil/water interface, as anticipated.     

Silica particle-stabilized emulsions of silicone oil and water: aspects of emulsification

A study of the emulsification of silicone oil and water in the presence of partially hydrophobic, monodisperse silica nanoparticles is described. Emulsification involves the fragmentation of bulk liquids and the resulting large drops and the coalescence of some of those drops. The influence of particle concentration, oil/water ratio, and emulsification time on the relative extents of fragmentation and coalescence during the formation of emulsions, prepared using either batch or continuous methods, has been investigated. For batch emulsions, the average drop diameter decreases with increasing particle concentration as the extent of limited coalescence is reduced. Increasing the oil volume fraction in the emulsion at fixed aqueous particle concentration results in an increase in the average drop diameter together with a dramatic lowering of the uniformity of the drop size distribution as coalescence becomes increasingly significant until catastrophic phase inversion occurs. For low oil volume fractions (phi(o)), fragmentation dominates during emulsification since the mean drop size decreases with emulsification time. For higher phi(o) close to conditions of phase inversion, coalescence becomes more prevalent and the drop size increases with time with stable multiple emulsions forming as a result.     

Effect of electrolyte in silicone oil-in-water emulsions stabilised by fumed silica particles

Partially hydrophobised fumed silica particles are used to make silicone oil-in-water emulsions at natural pH of the aqueous phase. The stability and rheological properties of the emulsions and suspensions are studied at NaCl concentrations in the range 0-100 mM. It is found that all emulsions are very stable to coalescence irrespective of the NaCl concentration. However, a strong effect of electrolyte on the creaming and rheological properties is observed and linked to the particle interactions in aqueous suspensions. The creaming rate and extent are large at low electrolyte concentrations but both abruptly decrease at salt concentrations exceeding the critical flocculation concentration of the suspension (approximately 1 mM NaCl). The drastic improvement of the stability to creaming is attributed to the formation of a visco-elastic three-dimensional network of interconnected particles and emulsion droplets.     

Flaxseed Oil-In-Water Emulsions Stabilized by Multilayer Membranes: Oxidative Stability and the Effects of pH

The investigation of the effect of multilayer membranes on the stability of flaxseed oil-in-water (o/w) emulsions was the main goal of this study. The primary emulsion was prepared by homogenizing the oil phase (10 wt%) with an aqueous sodium caseinate solution (90 wt% and a pH 6.8) using a high-pressure microfluidizer. This emulsion was mixed with a pectin solution to form a secondary emulsion at a pH 6.8 and then adjusted to a pH to 3 for the adsorption of anionic pectin molecules on the surface of the cationic droplet surfaces. The pH effect on the physical stability of the emulsions was evaluated by measuring the mean particle diameter, ζ-potential, creaming index, and visualization of the microstructure. Also, the oxidative stability was determined by monitoring the lipid hydroperoxides and thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances (TBARs) at 55°C. The results of this study indicate that a multilayer structure had a positive effect on the improvement of the physical and oxidative stability of the conventional emulsions under certain pH conditions and limited storage period.     

Emulsification of caraway essential oil in water by lecithin and beta-lactoglobulin: emulsion stability and properties of the formed oil-aqueous interface

The stability and droplet size of protein and lipid stabilised emulsions of caraway essential oil as well as the amount of protein on the emulsion droplets have been investigated. The amount of added protein (beta-lactoglobulin) and lipid (phosphatidylcholine from soybean (sb-PC)) were varied and the results compared with those obtained with emulsions of a purified olive oil. In general, emulsions with triglyceride oil proved to be more stable compared with those made with caraway essential oil as the dispersed phase. However, the stability of the emulsions can be improved considerably by adding sb-PC. An increase in the protein concentration also promoted emulsion stability. We will also present how ellipsometry can be used to study the adsorption of the lipid from the oil and the protein from the aqueous phase at the oil-water interface. Independently of the used concentration, close to monolayer coverage of sb-PC was observed at the caraway oil-aqueous interface. On the other hand, at the olive oil-aqueous interface, the presence of only a small amount of sb-PC lead to an exponential increase of the layer thickness with time beyond monolayer coverage. The amounts of beta-lactoglobulin adsorbed at the caraway oil-aqueous interface and at the olive oil-aqueous interface were similar, corresponding roughly to a protein monolayer coverage.     

Effect of dispersion pH on the formation and stability of Pickering emulsions stabilized by layered double hydroxides particles

Using positively charged plate-like layered double hydroxides (LDHs) particles as emulsifier, liquid paraffin-in-water emulsions stabilized solely by such particles are successfully prepared. The effects of the pH of LDHs aqueous dispersions on the formation and stability of the emulsions are investigated here. The properties of the LDHs dispersions at different pHs are described, including particle zeta potential, particle aggregation, particle contact angle, flow behavior of the dispersions and particle adsorption at a planar oil/water interface. The zeta potential decreases with increasing pH, leading to the aggregation of LDHs particles into large flocs. The structural strength of LDHs dispersions is enhanced by increasing pH and particle concentration. The three-phase contact angle of LDHs also increases with increasing pH, but the variation is very small. Visual observation and SEM images of the interfacial particle layers show that the adsorption behavior of LDHs particles at the planar oil/water interface is controlled by dispersion pH. We consider that the particle-particle (at the interface) and particle-interface electrostatic interactions are well controlled by adjusting the dispersion pH, leading to pH-tailored colloid adsorption. The formation of an adsorbed particle layer around the oil drops is crucial for the formation and stability of the emulsions. Emulsion stability improves with increasing pH and particle concentration because more particles are available to be adsorbed at the oil/water interface. The structural strength of LDHs dispersions and the gel-like structure of emulsions also influence the stability of the emulsions, but they are not necessary for the formation of emulsions. The emulsions cannot be demulsified by adjusting emulsion pH due to the irreversible adsorption of LDHs particles at the oil/water interface. TEM images of the emulsion drops show that a thick particle layer forms around the oil drops, confirming that Pickering emulsions are stabilized by the adsorbed particle layers. The thick adsorbed particle layer may be composed of a stable inner particle layer which is in direct contact with the oil phase and a relatively unstable outer particle layer surrounding the inner layer.     

Influence of ionic calcium on stability of sodium caseinate emulsions

The stability of fine sodium caseinate emulsions (1 wt.% protein, 25 vol.% n-tetradecane, 20 mM imidazole, pH 7) containing various concentrations of calcium chloride has been investigated under perikinetic and orthokinetic conditions by measuring time-dependent changes in droplet-size distribution. Under quiescent storage conditions at 20°C, samples containing at least 10 mM ionic calcium added after emulsification were found to exhibit an increasing average droplet size with time and a developing bimodal droplet-size distribution. Under turbulent conditions of intense shearing, these same emulsions exhibited time-dependent flocculation and coalescence. This interpretation was confirmed by light microscopy. Emulsions prepared with up to 6 mM Ca²⁺ present during emulsification were stable in the presence or absence of flow, but satisfactory emulsions could not be prepared containing more than 6 mM ionic calcium. The results show that the emulsion stability is sensitive to whether the calcium ion content is adjusted before or after homogenization.     

Effect of silica particles on stability of highly concentrated water-in-oil emulsions with non-ionic surfactant

Water-in-oil, high internal phase emulsion made of super-cooled aqueous solution containing a mixture of inorganic salts and stabilized with non-ionic surfactant (sorbitan monooleate) alone was investigated. It was not possible to produce a highly concentrated emulsion (with aqueous phase fraction = 94 wt %), stabilized with surface-treated silica, solely: we were able to form an emulsion with a maximal aqueous phase mass fraction of 85 wt % (emulsion inverts/breaks above this concentration). The inversion point is dependent on the silica particle concentration, presence of salt in the aqueous phase, and does not depend on the pH of the dispersed phase. All emulsions stabilized by the nanoparticles solely were unstable to shear. So, the rheological properties and stability of the emulsions containing super-cooled dispersed phase, with regards to crystallization, were determined for an emulsion stabilized by non-ionic surfactant only. The results were compared to the properties obtained for emulsions stabilized by surface treated (relatively hydrophobic) silica nanoparticles as a co-surfactant to sorbitan monooleate. The influence of the particle concentration, type of silica surface treatment, particle/surfactant ratio on emulsification and emulsion rheological properties was studied. The presence of the particles as a co-stabilizer increases the stability of all emulsions. Also, it was found that the particle/surfactant ratio is important since the most stable emulsions are those where particles dominate over the surfactant, when the surfactant’s role is to create bridging flocculation of the particles. The combination of the two types of hydrophobic silica particles as co-surfactants is: one that resides at the water/oil interface and provides a steric boundary and another that remains in the oil phase creating a 3D-network throughout the oil phase, which is even more beneficiary in terms of the emulsion stability.     

Impact on Morphological Characterization and Emulsion Stability of Lactoferrin–Beet Pectin Electrostatic Complexes

Interfacial protein–polysaccharide complexes can be utilized in emulsion-based delivery system and contained functional component or medical ingredient. In the present work, the interaction of lactoferrin (LF, 0.2 wt%) with beet pectin (BP, 0–0.15 wt%) was researched in aqueous solutions at different pH (2–9) and ionic strength (0–800 mM) to provide the information about properties of complexes. A simulative environment was created to explore the optimal concentration of BP to formulate LF-coated stabilized emulsion and how the emulsion responded to the changing environmental pH (2–9) and ionic strength (0–500 mM). Particle size, particle distribution index, zeta-potential, turbidity, Turbiscan stability index,, and peak thickness were used to characterize the physical stability of emulsions. The confocal laser scanning microscopy was used to derive the microscopy images of droplets. The results indicated that 0.4 wt% was the optimal concentration to formulate emulsions, and the LF-BP-coated bilayer emulsion has a preferable stability in more extensive range than the pure LF-stabilized emulsions under the environmental stresses through electrostatic interactions. The results of this study will play an important role in facilitating the utilization of LF-BP complexes as an emulsifier in the development of incorporating functional component or medical ingredient into commercial products.     

Stability of Emulsions Containing Both Sodium Caseinate and Tween 20

The creaming and rheology of oil-in-water emulsions (30 vol% n-tetradecane, pH 6.8) stabilized by a mixture of commercial sodium caseinate and the non-ionic emulsifier polyoxyethylene sorbitan monolaurate (Tween 20) has been investigated at 21 degrees C. The presence of sufficient Tween 20 to displace most of the protein from the emulsion droplet surface leads to greatly enhanced emulsion creaming (and strongly non-Newtonian rheology) which is indicative of depletion flocculation by nonadsorbed surface-active material (protein and emulsifier). In emulsions containing a constant amount of surface-active material, the replacement of a very small fraction of Tween 20 by caseinate in a stable pure Tween 20 emulsion leads to enhanced creaming for a small fraction of the droplets, and this fraction increases with increasing replacement of emulsifier by protein. This behavior is probably due to depletion flocculation, although an alternative bridging mechanism is also a possibility. The overall stability of these sets of emulsions can be represented in terms of a global stability diagram containing regions of bridging flocculation and coalescence (low content of surface-active material), stability (intermediate content), and depletion flocculation (high content). Copyright 1999 Academic Press.     

Ostwald ripening of protein-stabilized emulsions: effect of transglutaminase crosslinking

Ostwald ripening in n-alkane oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by sodium caseinate at neutral pH has been studied by monitoring time-dependent changes in the number-average droplet diameter and the droplet-size distribution. In qualitative agreement with theory, the destabilization rate has been shown to increase with reduction of the n-alkane chain length and on addition of ethanol to the aqueous phase. Replacement of caseinate by β-lactoglobulin also leads to improved stability, but addition of calcium ions does not. The potential use of transglutaminase-induced crosslinking of adsorbed protein as a way of inhibiting the Ostwald ripening of caseinate-stabilized emulsions has been examined. It is shown that enzymic crosslinking before emulsification can lead to a modest reduction in the coarsening rate at long storage times. Crosslinking of caseinate after emulsification produces enhanced stability at short times, but there is a catastrophic loss of stability at long times due to droplet coalescence.     

Synergistic effect of silica nanoparticles and charged surfactants in the formation and stability of submicron oil-in-water emulsions

The influence of hydrophilic silica nanoparticles on the emulsification of a triglyceride oil (Miglyol812) in the presence of charged surfactants (lecithin or oleylamine) and the long term stability of the resultant oil-in-water emulsions are reported. A synergistic effect of nanoparticles and surfactants in improving emulsification and stability to coalescence is evident only when the silica nanoparticles are initially added to the oil phase. When nanoparticles are included from the water phase, no synergistic stabilisation was observed due to electrostatic bridging or unfavourable attachment due to the repulsive electrostatic and hydration forces. Free energies of adsorption for silica nanoparticles at the oil-water interface calculated from experimentally determined interfacial tensions and three phase contact angles can be correlated to long-term emulsion stability only when silica is added from oil phase.     

Adsorption behaviour of lactoferrin in oil-in-water emulsions as influenced by interactions with beta-lactoglobulin

Oil-in-water emulsions (pH 7.0 or pH 3.0) containing 30 wt% soya oil and various concentrations of lactoferrin were made in a two-stage valve homogenizer. The average droplet size (d32), the surface protein coverage (mg/m2) and composition, and the zeta-potential of the emulsions were determined. The value of d32 decreased with increasing lactoferrin concentration up to 1%, and then was almost independent of lactoferrin concentration beyond 1% at both pH 7.0 and pH 3.0. The surface protein coverage of the emulsions made at pH 7.0 increased almost linearly with increasing lactoferrin concentration from 0.3 to 3%, but increased only slightly in emulsions made at pH 3.0 at lactoferrin concentrations >1%. The surface protein coverage of the emulsions made at pH 3.0 was lower than that of the emulsions made at pH 7.0 at a given protein concentration. The emulsion droplets had a strong positive charge at both pH 7.0 and pH 3.0, indicating that stable cationic emulsion droplets could be formed by lactoferrin alone. When emulsions were formed with a mixture of lactoferrin and beta-lactoglobulin (beta-lg) (1:1 by weight), the charge of the emulsion droplets was neutralized at pH 7.0 suggesting the formation of electrostatic complexes between the two proteins. The composition of the droplet surface layer showed that both proteins were adsorbed, presumably as complexes, from the aqueous phase at pH 7.0 in equal proportions, whereas competitive adsorption occurred between lactoferrin and beta-lg at pH 3.0. At this pH, beta-lg was adsorbed in preference to lactoferrin at low protein concentrations (1%), whereas lactoferrin appeared to be adsorbed in preference to beta-lg at high protein concentrations.     

Surfactant-Free Multiple Pickering Emulsions Stabilized by Combining Hydrophobic and Hydrophilic Nanoparticles

A series of W/O/W or O/W/O emulsion stabilized solely by two different types of solid nanoparticles were prepared by a two-step method. We explored the option of particular emulsifiers for the multiple Pickering emulsions, and a variety of nanoparticles (silica, iron oxide, and clay) only differing in their wettability was used. The primary W/O emulsion was obtained by the hydrophobic nanoparticles, and then the hydrophilic nanoparticles were used as emulsifier in the secondary emulsification to prepare the W/O/W emulsion. In a similar way, the primary O/W emulsion of the O/W/O emulsion was stabilized by the hydrophilic nanoparticles, while the secondary emulsification to prepare the O/W/O emulsion was effected with the hydrophobic nanoparticles. The resultant multiple Pickering emulsion was stable to coalescence for more than 3 months, except the W/O/W emulsions of which the secondary emulsion stabilized by clay nanoparticles became a simple O/W emulsion in a day after preparation. Moreover, the temperature and pH sensitive poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-methacrylic acid) (P(NIPAm-co-MAA)) microgels were introduced as an emulsifier for the secondary emulsification to obtain the stimulus-responsive multiple W/O/W emulsion. Such microgel-stabilized multiple emulsions could realize the efficient controlled release of water-soluble dye, Rhodamine B (RB) on demand in a multiple-emulsion delivery system.