On multistage Stochastic Integer Programming for incorporating logical constraints in asset and liability management under uncertainty

We present a model for optimizing a mean-risk function of the terminal wealth for a fixed income asset portfolio restructuring with uncertainty in the interest rate path and the liabilities along a given time horizon. Some logical constraints are considered to be satisfied by the assets portfolio. Uncertainty is represented by a scenario tree and is dealt with by a multistage stochastic mixed 0-1 model with complete recourse. The problem is modelled as a splitting variable representation of the Deterministic Equivalent Model for the stochastic model, where the 0-1 variables and the continuous variables appear at any stage. A Branch-and-Fix Coordination approach for the multistage 0–1 program solving is proposed. Some computational experience is reported.      

Tracking error: a multistage portfolio model

We study multistage tracking error problems. Different tracking error measures, commonly used in static models, are discussed as well as some problems which arise when we move from static to dynamic models. We are interested in dynamically replicating a benchmark using only a small subset of assets, considering transaction costs due to rebalancing and introducing a liquidity component in the portfolio. We formulate and solve a multistage tracking error model in a stochastic programming framework. We numerically test our model by dynamically replicating the MSCI Euro index. We consider an increasing number of scenarios and assets and show the superior performance of the dynamically optimized tracking portfolio over static strategies.     

Market neutral portfolios

In this paper we consider the problem of constructing a market neutral portfolio. This is a portfolio of financial assets that (ideally) exhibits performance independent from that of an underlying market as represented by a benchmark index. We formulate this problem as a mixed-integer nonlinear program, minimising the absolute value of the correlation between portfolio return and index return. Our model is a flexible one that incorporates decisions as to both long and short positions in assets. Computational results, obtained using the software package Minotaur, are given for constructing market neutral portfolios for eleven different problem instances derived from universes defined by S&P international equity indices. We also compare our approach against an alternative approach based on minimising the absolute value of regression slope (the zero-beta approach).     

A mixed integer programming model for multistage mean–variance post-tax optimization

In this paper, we introduce a mixed integer stochastic programming approach to mean–variance post-tax portfolio management. This approach takes into account of risk in a multistage setting and allows general withdrawals from original capital. The uncertainty on asset returns is specified as a scenario tree. The risk across scenarios is addressed using the probabilistic approach of classical stochastic programming. The tax rules are used with stochastic linear and mixed integer quadratic programming models to compute an overall tax and return-risk efficient multistage portfolio. The incorporation of the risk term in the model provides robustness and leads to diversification over wrappers and assets within each wrapper. General withdrawals and risk aversion have an impact on the distribution of assets among wrappers. Computational results are presented using a study with different scenario trees in order to show the performance of these models.     

Robust portfolio choice with CVaR and VaR under distribution and mean return ambiguity

We consider the problem of optimal portfolio choice using the Conditional Value-at-Risk (CVaR) and Value-at-Risk (VaR) measures for a market consisting of n risky assets and a riskless asset and where short positions are allowed. When the distribution of returns of risky assets is unknown but the mean return vector and variance/covariance matrix of the risky assets are fixed, we derive the distributionally robust portfolio rules. Then, we address uncertainty (ambiguity) in the mean return vector in addition to distribution ambiguity, and derive the optimal portfolio rules when the uncertainty in the return vector is modeled via an ellipsoidal uncertainty set. In the presence of a riskless asset, the robust CVaR and VaR measures, coupled with a minimum mean return constraint, yield simple, mean-variance efficient optimal portfolio rules. In a market without the riskless asset, we obtain a closed-form portfolio rule that generalizes earlier results, without a minimum mean return restriction.     

Portfolio optimization with linear and fixed transaction costs

We consider the problem of portfolio selection, with transaction costs and constraints on exposure to risk. Linear transaction costs, bounds on the variance of the return, and bounds on different shortfall probabilities are efficiently handled by convex optimization methods. For such problems, the globally optimal portfolio can be computed very rapidly. Portfolio optimization problems with transaction costs that include a fixed fee, or discount breakpoints, cannot be directly solved by convex optimization. We describe a relaxation method which yields an easily computable upper bound via convex optimization. We also describe a heuristic method for finding a suboptimal portfolio, which is based on solving a small number of convex optimization problems (and hence can be done efficiently). Thus, we produce a suboptimal solution, and also an upper bound on the optimal solution. Numerical experiments suggest that for practical problems the gap between the two is small, even for large problems involving hundreds of assets. The same approach can be used for related problems, such as that of tracking an index with a portfolio consisting of a small number of assets.     

Optimal impulse control of a portfolio with a fixed transaction cost

The aim of this work is to investigate a portfolio optimization problem in presence of fixed transaction costs. We consider an economy with two assets: one risky, modeled by a geometric Brownian motion, and one risk-free which grows at a certain fixed rate. The agent is fully described by his/her utility function and the objective is to maximize the expected utility from the liquidation of wealth at a terminal date. We deal with different forms of utility functions (power, logarithmic and exponential utility), describing in each case how the fixed transaction costs influence the agent’s behavior. We show when it is optimal to recalibrate his/her portfolio and which are the best adjusted portfolios. We also analyze how the optimal strategy is influenced by the risk-aversion, as well as other model parameters.     

On an investment-consumption model with transaction costs: an asymptotic analysis

In this paper we examine the Akian, Menaldi and Sulem (1996) model for the optimal management of a portfolio, when there are transaction costs which are equal to a fixed percentage of the amount transacted. We analyse this model in the realistic limit of small transaction costs. Although the full problem is a free boundary diffusion problem in as many dimensions as there are assets in the portfolio, we find explicit solutions for the optimal trading policy in this limit. This makes the solution for a realistically large number of assets a practical possibility.     

Capital structure of real estate assets: Theory and empirical evidence

This paper presents a model which intends to explain the capital structure of real estate assets. The model is cast in classical portfolio choice framework, but special attention is paid to the liquidity constraint. The test of this model on two assets with different capital structures (new housing and old housing in France) revealed the importance of return indicators as well as liquidity constraint in the household's financing decisions.     

Testing the structure of multistage stochastic programs

A fixed topology of stages and/or a fixed branching scheme are common assumptions for applications and numerical solution of scenario based multistage stochastic programs. Using contamination technique to test this structure, we extend the results of Dupačová (Contamination for multistage stochastic programs. In: Hušková M, Janžura M (eds) Prague stochastics. Matfyzpress, Praha, pp 91–101, 2006a) to stochastic programs with multistage polyhedral risk objectives. The ideas are exemplified by bond portfolio management problems and complemented by illustrative numerical results.     

Household risk aversion and portfolio choices

In practice, stock investment is one of the most important decisions made by households. The primary goal of this paper is to explain family investment decisions under the assumptions of household member’s preferences and efficient risk sharing based on the collective household model. In particular, by examining the absolute (relative) risk aversion of the household welfare function, we demonstrate how household’s portfolio allocation in stocks changes with family wealth. We examine two types of preference heterogeneity between family members: parameter heterogeneity and functional form heterogeneity. This study offers an alternative explanation of household portfolio choice corresponding with the observation that wealthier households tend to hold greater share of their wealth in risky assets. Specifically, if two decision-makers have standard constant relative risk aversion preference with different relative risk aversions in a household, family’s relative risk aversion decreases as household wealth increases (decreasing relative risk aversion).     

Portfolio adjusting optimization with added assets and transaction costs based on credibility measures

In response to changeful financial markets and investor’s capital, we discuss a portfolio adjusting problem with additional risk assets and a riskless asset based on credibility theory. We propose two credibilistic mean–variance portfolio adjusting models with general fuzzy returns, which take lending, borrowing, transaction cost, additional risk assets and capital into consideration in portfolio adjusting process. We present crisp forms of the models when the returns of risk assets are some deterministic fuzzy variables such as trapezoidal, triangular and interval types. We also employ a quadratic programming solution algorithm for obtaining optimal adjusting strategy. The comparisons of numeral results from different models illustrate the efficiency of the proposed models and the algorithm.     

Warm-Start Heuristic for Stochastic Portfolio Optimization with Fixed and Proportional Transaction Costs

We consider a probabilistic portfolio optimization model including fixed and proportional transaction costs. We derive a deterministic equivalent of the probabilistic model for fat-tailed portfolio returns. We develop a method which finds provably near-optimal solutions in minimal amount of time for industry-sized (up to 2000 assets) problems. To solve the mixed-integer nonlinear programming (MINLP) deterministic formulation equivalent to the stochastic problem, we design a mathematical programming-based warm-start heuristic. The tests show the computational efficiency of the heuristic which is more than an order of magnitude faster than Cplex in finding high-quality solutions.     

A Review on Ambiguity in Stochastic Portfolio Optimization

In mean-risk portfolio optimization, it is typically assumed that the assets follow a known distribution P ₀, which is estimated from observed data. Aiming at an investment strategy which is robust against possible misspecification of P ₀, the portfolio selection problem is solved with respect to the worst-case distribution within a Wasserstein-neighborhood of P ₀. We review tractable formulations of the portfolio selection problem under model ambiguity, as it is called in the literature. For instance, it is known that high model ambiguity leads to equally-weighted portfolio diversification. However, it often happens that the marginal distributions of the assets can be estimated with high accuracy, whereas the dependence structure between the assets remains ambiguous. This leads to the problem of portfolio selection under dependence uncertainty. We show that in this case portfolio concentration becomes optimal as the uncertainty with respect to the estimated dependence structure increases. Hence, distributionally robust portfolio optimization can have two very distinct implications: Diversification on the one hand and concentration on the other hand.     

Filter‐based portfolio strategies in an HMM setting with varying correlation parametrizations

We consider portfolio optimization in a regime‐switching market. The assets of the portfolio are modeled through a hidden Markov model (HMM) in discrete time, where drift and volatility of the single assets are allowed to switch between different states. We consider different parametrizations of the involved asset covariances: statewise uncorrelated assets (though linked through the common Markov chain), assets correlated in a state‐independent way, and assets where the correlation varies from state to state. As a benchmark, we also consider a model without regime switches. We utilize a filter‐based expectation‐maximization (EM) algorithm to obtain optimal parameter estimates within this multivariate HMM and present parameter estimators in all three HMM settings. We discuss the impact of these different models on the performance of several portfolio strategies. Our findings show that for simulated returns, our strategies in many settings outperform naïve investment strategies, like the equal weights strategy. Information criteria can be used to detect the best model for estimation as well as for portfolio optimization. A second study using real data confirms these findings.     

破产控制约束下组合投资:两阶段MiniMax模型

以绝对偏差函数作为风险测度,考虑不允许卖空约束条件下基于MiniMax的多期证券组合选择问题。为了避免在投资周期内破产事件的发生,增加了风险控制约束。利用动态规划和拉格朗日乘子法,给出了两阶段MiniMax投资组合模型最优解析策略。本文所提出策略可以为需要同时资产管理和破产控制的投资者提供决策依据。     

A dynamic stochastic programming model for international portfolio management

We develop a multi-stage stochastic programming model for international portfolio management in a dynamic setting. We model uncertainty in asset prices and exchange rates in terms of scenario trees that reflect the empirical distributions implied by market data. The model takes a holistic view of the problem. It considers portfolio rebalancing decisions over multiple periods in accordance with the contingencies of the scenario tree. The solution jointly determines capital allocations to international markets, the selection of assets within each market, and appropriate currency hedging levels. We investigate the performance of alternative hedging strategies through extensive numerical tests with real market data. We show that appropriate selection of currency forward contracts materially reduces risk in international portfolios. We further find that multi-stage models consistently outperform single-stage models. Our results demonstrate that the stochastic programming framework provides a flexible and effective decision support tool for international portfolio management.     

Solving multistage asset investment problems by the sample average approximation method

The vast size of real world stochastic programming instances requires sampling to make them practically solvable. In this paper we extend the understanding of how sampling affects the solution quality of multistage stochastic programming problems. We present a new heuristic for determining good feasible solutions for a multistage decision problem. For power and log-utility functions we address the question of how tree structures, number of stages, number of outcomes and number of assets affect the solution quality. We also present a new method for evaluating the quality of first stage decisions.     

Equal Risk Bounding is better than Risk Parity for portfolio selection

Risk Parity (RP), also called equally weighted risk contribution, is a recent approach to risk diversification for portfolio selection. RP is based on the principle that the fractions of the capital invested in each asset should be chosen so as to make the total risk contributions of all assets equal among them. We show here that the Risk Parity approach is theoretically dominated by an alternative similar approach that does not actually require equally weighted risk contribution of all assets but only an equal upper bound on all such risks. This alternative approach, called Equal Risk Bounding (ERB), requires the solution of a nonconvex quadratically constrained optimization problem. The ERB approach, while starting from different requirements, turns out to be strictly linked to the RP approach. Indeed, when short selling is allowed, we prove that an ERB portfolio is actually an RP portfolio with minimum variance. When short selling is not allowed, there is a unique RP portfolio and it contains all assets in the market. In this case, the ERB approach might lead to the RP portfolio or it might lead to portfolios with smaller variance that do not contain all assets, and where the risk contributions of each asset included in the portfolio is strictly smaller than in the RP portfolio. We define a new riskiness index for assets that allows to identify those assets that are more likely to be excluded from the ERB portfolio. With these tools we then provide an exact method for small size nonconvex ERB models and a very efficient and accurate heuristic for larger problems of this type. In the case of a common constant pairwise correlation among all assets, a closed form solution to the ERB model is obtained and used to perform a parametric analysis when varying the level of correlation. The practical advantages of the ERB approach over the RP strategy are illustrated with some numerical examples. Computational experience on real-world and on simulated data confirms accuracy and efficiency of our heuristic approach to the ERB model also in comparison with some state-of-the-art local and global optimization codes.     

基于CvaR的融入期权的投资组合模型

把期权作为一种投资对象融入到投资组合中,而不仅仅是作为风险对冲工具.用条件风险价值(CVaR)刻画组合风险,并求出最小化风险下的最优鲁棒投资组合策略.最后通过数值算例证明了模型的有效性,并得到融入期权后有效地提高了组合的收益,特别是当标的资产出现大的波动时,期权在组合中的表现更突出.