Quantitative analysis of shape-specific interactions of Rev response element with a positively charged Rev peptide by capillary electrophoresis

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Rev protein is known to regulate the expression of proteins via binding to an RNA site termed the HIV Rev response element (RRE) presumably with a defined shape, mediated mainly by electrostatic interactions. We have developed a quantitative method based on CE-LIF detection for a systematic evaluation of interactions between a truncated RRE (tRRE) RNA and an HIV-1 Rev peptide. Employing a fluorescently labeled HIV-1 Rev protein fragment (RevF) as a probe, buffers were evaluated for the separation and detection as well as for the RNA shape-specific formation of the complex. Selection of an optimal buffer condition allowed us to perform quantitation of the tRRE-RevF complex formation and determine its dissociation constant. In addition, competitive inhibitions of the RNA-peptide interaction by some aminoglycosides were evaluated quantitatively by monitoring the complex peak, resulting in determination of IC(50) values. This sensitive and reliable CE-LIF-based method would be of interest in developing various screening systems for RNA interference in drug discovery.     

Targeted cleavage of HIV RRE RNA by Rev-coupled transition metal chelates

A series of compounds that target reactive metal chelates to the HIV-1 Rev response element (RRE) mRNA have been synthesized. Dissociation constants and chemical reactivity toward HIV RRE RNA have been determined and evaluated in terms of reduction potential, coordination unsaturation, and overall charge associated with the metal-chelate-Rev complex. Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA), diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (DTPA), and 1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetraacetic acid (DOTA) were linked to a lysine side chain of a Rev-derived peptide by either EDC/NHS or isothiocyanate coupling. The resulting chelate-Rev (EDTA-Rev, DTPA-Rev, NTA-Rev, and DOTA-Rev) conjugates were used to form coordination complexes with Fe(2+), Co(2+), Ni(2+), and Cu(2+) such that the arginine-rich Rev peptide could mediate localization of the metal chelates to the Rev peptide's high-affinity mRNA binding partner, RRE stem loop IIB. Metal complexes of the extended peptides GGH-Rev and KGHK-Rev, which also contain N-terminal peptidic chelators (ATCUN motifs), were studied for comparison. A fluorescence titration assay revealed high-affinity RRE RNA binding by all 22 metal-chelate-Rev species, with K(D) values ranging from ~0.2 to 16 nM, indicating little to no loss of RNA affinity due to the coupling of the metal chelates to the Rev peptide. Dissociation constants for binding at a previously unobserved low-affinity site are also reported. Rates of RNA modification by each metal-chelate-Rev species were determined and varied from ~0.28 to 4.9 nM/min but were optimal for Cu(2+)-NTA-Rev. Metal-chelate reduction potentials were determined and varied from -228 to +1111 mV vs NHE under similar solution conditions, allowing direct comparison of reactivity with redox thermodynamics. Optimal activity was observed when the reduction potential for the metal center was poised between those of the two principal co-reagents for metal-promoted formation of reactive oxygen species: E°(ascorbate/ascorbyl radical) = -66 mV and E°(H(2)O(2)/hydroxyl radical) = 380 mV. Given the variety of oxidative activities of these metal complexes and their high-affinity binding to the targeted RRE mRNA following coupling to the Rev peptide, this class of metal-chelate-Rev derivatives constitutes a promising step toward development of multiple-turnover reagents for selective eradication of HIV-1 RRE mRNA.     

Quantum-dot-based nanosensor for RRE IIB RNA-Rev peptide interaction assay

Rev is an important HIV-1 regulatory protein that binds the Rev responsive element (RRE) within the env gene of HIV-1 RNA genome; the binding of Rev to RRE is essential for the expression of the structural genes, gag-pol and env, and for HIV replication. Here we report a quantum-dot (QD)-based nanosensor that can be used in fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) assays of RRE IIB RNA-Rev peptide interactions. In comparison with conventional fluorescent dye-based methods, this QD-based nanosensor offers the distinct advantages of not inhibiting the Rev-RRE interaction, high sensitivity, improved accuracy, and simultaneous FRET-related two-parameter detection. This QD-based nanosensor provides a new approach to study the effects of inhibitors upon Rev-RRE interaction, and it may have a wide applicability in the development of new drugs against HIV-1 infection.     

Stepwise molding of a highly selective ribonucleopeptide receptor

The structural characteristics of RNA-peptide (RNP) complexes are suitable for molding of a ligand-binding pocket of the RNP complex in a stepwise manner. The first step involves molding of the RNA subunit by in vitro selection of an RNP pool originating from an RNA library and the peptide, as previously reported for the construction of an ATP-binding RNP complex from an RRE RNA-Rev peptide complex. The second step involves selection from an RNP library consisting of Rev peptides with randomized amino acid residues and the RNA subunit selected in the first molding. The ATP-binding pocket produced by sequential molding of RNA and peptide subunits shows higher affinity to ATP and a distinct specificity for ATP versus dATP as compared to the ATP-binding RNP receptor in which only the RNA subunit has been molded. The second step selection from the peptide-based RNP library allows expansion of the ATP recognition surface, consisting of both RNA and peptide subunits, to enhance the affinity and selectivity to discriminate ATP against dATP. Our approach of stepwise molding offers the advantage of increasing the diversity of the RNP library by utilizing characteristics of different biopolymers. The ribonucleopeptide-based, multi-subunit approach is also extendable to other biomacromolecular assemblies, which may yield artificial receptors and enzymes with increased specificity and more diverse chemical activities.     

Structural characterization of the complex of the Rev response element RNA with a selected peptide

INTRODUCTION: The RSG-1.2 peptide was selected for specific binding to the Rev response element RNA, as the natural Rev peptide does. The RSG-1.2 sequence has features incompatible with the helical structure of the bound Rev peptide, indicating that it must bind in a different conformation. RESULTS: The binding of the RSG-1.2 peptide to the Rev response element RNA was characterized using multinuclear, multidimensional NMR. The RSG-1.2 peptide is shown to bind with the N-terminal segment of the peptide along the major groove in an extended conformation and turn preceding a C-terminal helical segment, which crosses the RNA groove in the region widened by the presence of purine-purine base pairs. These features make the details of the bound state rather different than that of the Rev peptide which targets the same RNA sequence binding as a single helix along the groove axis. CONCLUSIONS: These studies further demonstrate the versatility of arginine-rich peptides in recognition of specific RNA elements and the lack of conserved structural features in the bound state.     

Helical cyclic pentapeptides constrain HIV-1 Rev peptide for enhanced RNA binding

HIV-1 Rev is a 116 residue transporter protein that enters the host cell nucleus and uses its 17 amino acid segment (Rev_34–50) to bind and capture a specific piece of RNA, the Rev Response Element (RRE), for transport to the cytoplasm. This is critical for HIV replication. In isolation, Rev_34–50 shows negligible structure in water, but is alpha helical in a mixture of water and 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) or when bound to RRE. Here we report that helix-constrained cyclic pentapeptides, either appended to the N-terminus or incorporated within Rev_34–50, are efficient helix nucleators in water. They induce up to 90% alpha helicity for isolated Rev peptides in water and confer high RNA-binding affinity.     

DNA nuclease activity of Rev-coupled transition metal chelates

Artificial nucleases containing Rev-coupled metal chelates based on combinations of the transition metals Fe(2+), Co(2+), Ni(2+), and Cu(2+) and the chelators DOTA, DTPA, EDTA, NTA, tripeptide GGH, and tetrapeptide KGHK have been tested for DNA nuclease activity. Originally designed to target reactive transition metal chelates (M-chelates) to the HIV-1 Rev response element mRNA, attachment to the arginine-rich Rev peptide also increases DNA-binding affinity for the attached M-chelates. Apparent K(D) values ranging from 1.7 to 3.6 μM base pairs for binding of supercoiled pUC19 plasmid DNA by Ni-chelate-Rev complexes were observed, as a result of electrostatic attraction between the positively-charged Rev peptide and negatively-charged DNA. Attachment of M-chelates to the Rev peptide resulted in enhancements of DNA nuclease activity ranging from 1-fold (no enhancement) to at least 13-fold (for Cu-DTPA-Rev), for the rate of DNA nicking, with second order rate constants for conversion of DNA(supercoiled) to DNA(nicked) up to 6 × 10(6) M(-1) min(-1), and for conversion of DNA(nicked) to DNA(linear) up to 1 × 10(5) M(-1) min(-1). Freifelder-Trumbo analysis and the ratios of linearization and nicking rate constants (k(lin)/k(nick)) revealed concerted mechanisms for nicking and subsequent linearization of plasmid DNA for all of the Rev-coupled M-chelates, consistent with higher DNA residency times for the Rev-coupled M-chelates. Observed rates for Rev-coupled M-chelates were less skewed by differing DNA-binding affinities than for M-chelates lacking Rev, as a result of the narrow range of DNA-binding affinities observed, and therefore relationships between DNA nuclease activity and other catalyst properties, such as coordination unsaturation, the ability to consume ascorbic acid and generate diffusible radicals, and the identity of the metal center, are now clearly illustrated in light of the similar DNA-binding affinities of all M-chelate-Rev complexes. This work paints a clearer picture of the factors governing DNA nuclease activity by redox active M-chelates than was previously possible. The results demonstrate enhancement of DNA cleavage by use of a targeting sequence, but also clearly underscore that significant orientational factors are required for optimal reactivity at the metal center. Moreover, the studies confirm high selectivity for the target HIV RRE RNA at the most likely dosage concentrations, lending further support to the feasibility of designing and applying targeted catalytic metallodrugs.     

In vitro selection of ATP-binding receptors using a ribonucleopeptide complex

A recently described three-dimensional structure of the ribosome provides a sense of remarkable diversity of RNA-protein complexes. We have designed a new class of scaffold for artificial receptors, in which a short peptide and RNA with a randomized nucleotide region form a stable and specific complex. The randomized nucleotide region was placed next to the HIV-1 Rev response element to enable the formation of "ribonucleopeptide" pools in the presence of the Rev peptide. In vitro selection of RNA oligonucleotides from the randomized pool afforded a ribonucleopeptide receptor specific for ATP. The ATP-binding ribonucleopeptide did not share the known consensus nucleotide sequence for ATP aptamers and completely lost its ATP-binding ability in the absence of the Rev peptide. The ATP-binding activity of the ribonucleopeptide was increased by a substitution of the N-terminal amino acid of the Rev peptide. These results demonstrate directly that the peptide is incorporated in the functional structure of RNA and suggest that amino acids outside the RNA-binding region of the peptide modulate the ATP-binding of ribonucleopeptide. Our approach would provide an alternative strategy for the design of "tailor-made" ribonucleopeptide receptors and enzymes.     

Structure-activity studies on the fluorescent indicator in a displacement assay for the screening of small molecules binding to RNA

A series of xanthone and thioxanthone derivatives with aminoalkoxy substituents were synthesized as fluorescent indicators for a displacement assay in the study of small-molecule-RNA interactions. The RNA-binding properties of these molecules were investigated in terms of the improved binding selectivity to the loop region in the RNA secondary structure relative to 2,7-bis(2-aminoethoxy)xanthone (X2S) by fluorimetric titration and displacement assay. An 11-mer double-stranded RNA and a hairpin RNA mimicking the stem loop IIB of Rev response element (RRE) RNA of HIV-1 mRNA were used. The X2S derivatives with longer aminoalkyl substituents showed a higher affinity to the double-stranded RNA than the parent molecule. Introduction of a methyl group on the aminoethoxy moiety of X2S effectively modulated the selectivity to the RNA secondary structure. Methyl group substitution at the C1' position suppressed the binding to the loop regions. Substitution with two methyl groups on the amino nitrogen atom resulted in reducing the affinity to the double-stranded region by a factor of 40%. The effect of methyl substitution on the amino nitrogen atom was also observed for a thioxanthone derivative. Titration experiments, however, suggested that thioxanthone derivatives showed a more prominent tendency of multiple binding to RNA than xanthone derivatives. The selectivity index calculated from the affinity to the double-stranded and loop regions suggested that the N,N-dimethyl derivative of X2S would be suitable for the screening of small molecules binding to RRE.     

Structure–Activity Studies on the Fluorescent Indicator in a Displacement Assay for the Screening of Small Molecules Binding to RNA

A series of xanthone and thioxanthone derivatives with aminoalkoxy substituents were synthesized as fluorescent indicators for a displacement assay in the study of small‐molecule–RNA interactions. The RNA‐binding properties of these molecules were investigated in terms of the improved binding selectivity to the loop region in the RNA secondary structure relative to 2,7‐bis(2‐aminoethoxy)xanthone (X2S) by fluorimetric titration and displacement assay. An 11‐mer double‐stranded RNA and a hairpin RNA mimicking the stem loop IIB of Rev response element (RRE) RNA of HIV‐1 mRNA were used. The X2S derivatives with longer aminoalkyl substituents showed a higher affinity to the double‐stranded RNA than the parent molecule. Introduction of a methyl group on the aminoethoxy moiety of X2S effectively modulated the selectivity to the RNA secondary structure. Methyl group substitution at the C1′ position suppressed the binding to the loop regions. Substitution with two methyl groups on the amino nitrogen atom resulted in reducing the affinity to the double‐stranded region by a factor of 40 %. The effect of methyl substitution on the amino nitrogen atom was also observed for a thioxanthone derivative. Titration experiments, however, suggested that thioxanthone derivatives showed a more prominent tendency of multiple binding to RNA than xanthone derivatives. The selectivity index calculated from the affinity to the double‐stranded and loop regions suggested that the N,N‐dimethyl derivative of X2S would be suitable for the screening of small molecules binding to RRE.     

Nonionic side chains modulate the affinity and specificity of binding between functionalized polyamines and structured RNA

This Communication introduces side-chain-bearing polyamines as molecules for selective recognition of folded RNA structures. The complex folded structures associated with RNA create binding pockets for proteins, and also binding sites for small molecules. Developing organic molecules that can bind RNA with high affinity and specificity is a challenge that must be overcome for RNA to be considered a viable drug target. In this work, six polyamines with different side chains were synthesized to test for effects on binding affinity and specificity to TAR RNA and RRE RNA of HIV. Binding interactions between polyamines and RNAs were examined using two footprinting assays, based on terbium-induced cleavage and magnesium-catalyzed cleavage at higher pH. The binding constants and the binding specificity were highly dependent on the side chains of the polyamines, demonstrating that this class of molecules is a very promising starting point for development of highly selective RNA-binding ligands.     

RNA architecture dictates the conformations of a bound peptide.

BACKGROUND: The biological function of several viral and bacteriophage proteins, and their arginine-rich subdomains, involves RNA-mediated interactions. It has been shown recently that bound peptides adopt either beta-hairpin or alpha-helical conformations in viral and phage peptide-RNA complexes. We have compared the structures of the arginine-rich peptide domain of HIV-1 Rev bound to two RNA aptamers to determine whether RNA architecture can dictate the conformations of a bound peptide. RESULTS: The core-binding segment of the HIV-1 Rev peptide class II RNA aptamer complex spans the two-base bulge and hairpin loop of the bound RNA and the carboxy-terminal segment of the bound peptide. The bound peptide is anchored in place by backbone and sidechain intermolecular hydrogen bonding and van der Waals stacking interactions. One of the bulge bases participates in U*(A*U) base triple formation, whereas the other is looped out and flaps over the bound peptide in the complex. The seven-residue hairpin loop is closed by a sheared G*A mismatch pair with several pyrimidines looped out of the hairpin fold. CONCLUSIONS: Our structural studies establish that RNA architecture dictates whether the same HIV-1 Rev peptide folds into an extended or alpha-helical conformation on complex formation. Arginine-rich peptides can therefore adapt distinct secondary folds to complement the tertiary folds of their RNA targets. This contrasts with protein-RNA complexes in which elements of RNA secondary structure adapt to fit within the tertiary folds of their protein targets.     

Displacement of Mn2+ from RNA by K+, Mg2+, neomycin B,and an arginine-rich peptide: indirect detection of nucleic acid/ligand interactions using phosphorus relaxation enhancement

We have developed a novel method to study the interactions of nucleic acids with cationic species. The method, called phosphorus relaxation enhancement (PhoRE), uses (1)H-detected (31)P NMR of exogenous probe ions to monitor changes in the equilibrium between free Mn(2+) and Mn(2+) bound to the RNA. To demonstrate the technique, we describe the interactions of four RNA molecules with metal ions (K(+) and Mg(2+)), a small molecule drug (neomycin b), and a cationic peptide (RSG1.2). In each case, cationic ligand binding caused Mn(2+) to be displaced from the RNA. Free Mn(2+) was determined from its effect on the T(2) NMR relaxation rate of either phosphite (HPO(3)(2-)) or methyl phosphite (MeOPH, CH(3)OP(H)O(2-)). Using this method, the effects of [RNA] as low as 1 microM could be measured in 20 min of accumulation using a low field (200 MHz) instrument without pulsed field gradients. Cation association behavior was sequence and [RNA] dependent. At low [K(+)], Mn(2+) association with each of the RNAs decreased with increasing [K(+)] until approximately 40 mM, where saturation was reached. While saturating K(+) displaced all the bound Mn(2+) from a 31-nucleotide poly-uridine (U(31)), Mn(2+) remained bound to each of three hairpin-forming sequences (A-site, RRE1, and RRE2), even at 150 mM K(+). Bound Mn(2+) was displaced from each of the hairpins by Mg(2+), allowing determination of Mg(2+) dissociation constants (K(d,Mg)) ranging from 50 to 500 microM, depending on the RNA sequence and [K(+)]. Both neomycin b and RSG1.2 displaced Mn(2+) upon binding the hairpins. At [RNA] approximately 3 microM, RRE1 bound a single equivalent of RSG1.2, whereas neither RRE2 nor A-site bound the peptide. These behaviors were confirmed by fluorescence polarization using TAMRA-labeled peptide. At 2.7 microM RNA, the A-site hairpin bound a single neomycin b molecule. The selectivity of RSG1.2 binding was greatly diminished at higher [RNA]. Similarly, each hairpin bound multiple equivalents of neomycin at the higher [RNA]. These results demonstrate the utility of the PhoRE method for characterizing metal binding behaviors of nucleic acids and for studying RNA/ligand interactions.     

Targeted cleavage of HIV rev response element RNA by metallopeptide complexes

Stoichiometric targeting and site-specific cleavage of HIV RRE RNA is demonstrated under physiologically relevant conditions by use of a metallopeptide that combines a specific RNA recognition sequence with a metal binding domain. Mass spectrometric analysis of cleavage products following treatment of target RNA with the metallopeptide, ascorbate, and dioxygen are consistent with C-1'H or C-4'H oxidative cleavage paths with an apparent second-order rate constant k2 approximately 700 M-1 min-1.     

Protein ligand design: from phage display to synthetic protein epitope mimetics in human antibody Fc-binding peptidomimetics

Phage display is a powerful method for selecting peptides with novel binding functions. Synthetic peptidomimetic chemistry is a powerful tool for creating structural diversity in ligands as a means to establish structure-activity relationships. Here we illustrate a method of bridging these two methodologies, by starting with a disulfide bridged phage display peptide which binds a human antibody Fc fragment (Delano et al. Science 2000, 287, 1279) and creating a backbone cyclic beta-hairpin peptidomimetic with 80-fold higher affinity for the Fc domain. The peptidomimetic is shown to adopt a well-defined beta-hairpin conformation in aqueous solution, with a bulge in one beta-strand, as seen in the crystal structure of the phage peptide bound to the Fc domain. The higher binding affinity of the peptidomimetic presumably reflects the effect of constraining the free ligand into the conformation required for binding, thus highlighting in this example the influence that ligand flexibility has on the binding energy. Since phage display peptides against a wide variety of different proteins are now accessible, this approach to synthetic ligand design might be applied to many other medicinally and biotechnologically interesting target proteins.     

Highly specific affinities of short peptides against synthetic polymers

We investigated polymer-binding 7-mer peptides that recognize differences in the polymer stereoregularity of all-purpose poly(methyl methacrylate)s (PMMAs) with simple chemical structures. Quantitative surface plasmon resonance measurements detected association/dissociation processes of the peptides against PMMA film surfaces, followed by an estimation of kinetic parameters such as association/dissociation rate constants and affinity constants. Greater association and smaller dissociation constants of the peptides were observed against a target isotactic PMMA than the structurally similar reference syndiotactic PMMA, followed by greater affinity constants against the target. A c02 peptide composed of the Glu-Leu-Trp-Arg-Pro-Thr-Arg sequence showed the greatest affinity constant (2.8x10(5) M(-1)) for the target, which was 41-fold greater than that for the reference, thus demonstrating extremely high peptide specificities. The substitution of each amino acid of the c02 peptide to Ala (Ala scanning) clearly revealed the essential amino acids for the affinity constants; the essential order was Pro5>Thr6>Arg7>Glu1>Arg4. In fact, the shorter 4-mer peptide composed of the C-terminal Arg-Pro-Thr-Arg sequence of the c02 peptide still demonstrated strong target specificity, although the N-terminal 4-mer peptide Glu-Leu-Trp-Arg completely lost its specificity. The possible conformations modeled with Molecular Mechanics supported the significance of the Arg-Pro-Thr-Arg sequence. The thermodynamic parameters of the c02 peptide suggested an induced fit mechanism for the specific affinity. The present affinity analyses of polymer-recognizing peptides revealed significant and general information that was essential for potential applications in peptidyl nanomaterials.     

Structural mimicry of retroviral tat proteins by constrained beta-hairpin peptidomimetics: ligands with high affinity and selectivity for viral TAR RNA regulatory elements

An approach is described to the design of beta-hairpin peptidomimetic ligands for bovine immunodeficiency virus (BIV) Tat protein, which inhibit binding to its transactivator response element (TAR) RNA. A library of peptidomimetics was derived by grafting onto a hairpin-inducing d-Pro-l-Pro template sequences related to the RNA recognition element in Tat. One hairpin mimetic was identified that binds tightly (K(d) approximately 150 nM) to BIV TAR, and another that binds also to HIV-1 TAR RNA (K(d) approximately 1-2 microM). (In the same assay, the wild-type BIV Tat(65-81) peptide binds to BIV TAR with K(d) approximately 50 nM.) The high-affinity BIV-Tat mimetic was shown to adopt a stable beta-hairpin conformation in free solution by NMR methods. Amino acid substitutions in this mimetic were shown to impact on the hairpin structure and to disrupt binding to the RNA. This family of conformationally constrained peptidomimetics affords insights into the structural requirements for binding to TAR RNA and provides a basis for the design of new ligands with increased inhibitory activity and specificity to both BIV and HIV TAR RNAs.     

An efficient thermally induced RNA conformational switch as a framework for the functionalization of RNA nanostructures

RNA offers a variety of interactions and dynamic conformational switches not available with DNA that may be exploited for the construction of nanomolecular structures. Here, we show how the RNA loop-loop, or "kissing", interaction can be used to construct specific circular RNA arrangements that are capable of thermal isomerization to alternative structures. We also show how this thermally induced structural rearrangement can be used to unmask a functional RNA structure, in this case, a peptide-binding RNA structure, the Rev-response element (RRE) of HIV, thereby acting as a functional peptide-binding switch. The relative ease with which the RRE could be engineered into the RNA substrates suggested that a variety of functional RNA structures may be introduced. In addition, the structural rearrangement was extremely efficient, showing that the "kissing" complexes described in this study may provide a useful framework for the construction of functional RNA-based nanostructures, as well as aid in our understanding of the way RNA functions in biological systems.     

Selective recognition of HIV RNA by dinuclear metallic ligands

We describe the development of dinuclear metallic ligands to target specific HIV RNA structures. Two series of dipyridinyl-N bridged dinuclear metal complexes were synthesized and their binding activities toward TAR and RRE RNA were studied both experimentally and theoretically.