Single and Sequential Extraction in Sediments and Soils

Abstract

The determination of extractable trace metal contents in soils and sediments is currently performed in many laboratories to assess the bioavailable metal fraction (and related potential phyto-toxic effects) and the importance and possibility of mobilization of trace metals from polluted soil, sludge and sediment upon landfill application. Single and sequential extraction schemes are used for the assessment of the different “forms” of trace metals (e.g. “mobile/bioavailable”, “carbonate-bound” etc.). The lack of uniformity in the different extraction procedures used throughout the world does not allow the results to be compared or the procedures to be validated which has led to many criticisms in the past few years. Moreover, the lack of suitable reference materials for this type of operationally defined determinations did not enable the quality of the measurements to be controlled. Owing to the need for establishing common schemes for single and sequential extractions as well as for the improvement of the quality of extractable trace metal determinations in soil and sediments, the Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) has organised a project which results along with the state of the art of extractable trace metal determinations, use and applicability of extraction schemes and analytical limitations were decided to be thoroughly discussed in a workshop. This paper presents its main conclusions.     

Preparation of candidate certified reference materials for the quality control of EDTA-and acetic acid-extractable trace metal determinations in sewage sludge-amended soil and terra rossa soil

The determination of extractable trace metal contents in soil using single extraction procedures is currently performed in many laboratories to assess the bioavailable metal fraction (and related phytotoxic effects) and the accessability to the environment (e.g. contamination of ground waters). Owing to the need for validation of the extraction schemes used and of the analytical techniques, the EC Measurements and Testing Programme (formerly BCR) has organized a project for improving the quality of determination of extractable trace metal contents in soil, the first step being an interlaboratory study to adopt common extraction procedures and the second being a certification campaign to certify two soils for their extractable trace element contents following these procedures. This paper gives a brief overview of the project organisation and describes the preparation, homogeneity and stability studies of two soil candidate reference materials (sewage sludge-amended and terra rossa soils).     

Adoption of Common Schemes for Single and Sequential Extractions of Trace Metal in Soils and Sediments

Abstract

The various methods for determining the mode of occurrence of trace metals in sediments and soils have a long history which dates back to the determinations of the availability of metals for plant nutrition performed earlier. Various methods have been developed in the 70′s and 80′s dealing with both single and sequential extraction schemes. Although some schemes received wide acceptance, none of them developed into a commonly accepted procedure. As a result, the information obtained was site-specific and the interpretation of the results scientist-specific. The workshop on single and sequential extraction in sediments and soils held at Sitges     

Speciation of Heavy Metals in Soils and Sediments. An Account of the Improvement and Harmonization of Extraction Techniques Undertaken Under the Auspices of the BCR of the Commission of the European Communities

Abstract

An account is presented of a series of investigations and collaborative studies, initiated by BCR, on current methods of metal speciation by extraction of soils and sediments with chemical reagents. It was established by extensive consultation with European experts that the diverse procedures used could be harmonized into agreed methods. These methods, including both single extractant and sequential extraction procedures were subjected to collaborative, interlaboratory trials and the results, presented briefly here, showed that it was both possible and desirable that reference soils and sediments, characterised by certified values for extractable contents, be prepared. As a consequence of these studies two soils have been prepared and will shortly be the subject of interlaboratory analysis with a view to certification of their EDTA and acetic acid extractable contents of some heavy metals. Following this workshop a feasibility study of the agreed sequential extraction procedure will, it is believed, shortly lead to certification of sediments for contents extractable by a defined sequential extraction procedure.     

Kinetic approach to heavy metal mobilization assessment in sediments: choose of kinetic equations and models to achieve maximum information

Studies of trace metal mobilization in sediments are generally performed using sequential extraction schemes at equilibrium. In the present work, a kinetic fractionation of trace metals in sediments has been developed to assess that information. The extraction rate data have been obtained using a single extraction scheme with EDTA and following a protocol previously optimized. Two kinetic equations and two kinetic models were used to fit the experimental data. The two constants equation fits well the extraction rate data used in this work but does not present any physico-chemical meaning. The diffusion model and the two first-order reactions model allow determining which parameter (the reaction between the metal M and the EDTA or the diffusion of the complex M/EDTA) is rate limiting in the trace metal extraction by EDTA. It appears that the two first-order reactions model is more efficient than the diffusion model to fit the present extraction rate data so it can be deduced that the diffusion of the complex M/EDTA is not the limiting step of the trace metal extraction by EDTA in estuarine sediments. In a second part, relationships between the fraction of metals determined with the two first-order reactions model and the sediments composition were established.     

Improvement of Analytical Measurements within the BCR-Programme: Single and Sequential Extraction Procedures Applied to Soil and Sediment Analysis

Abstract

The determination of extractable trace metal contents in soil and sediment, using respectively single and sequential extraction procedures, is currently performed in many laboratories to assess the bioavailable metal fraction (and related phyto-toxic effects) and the accessability to the environment (e.g. contamination of ground waters).

Owing to the need for validation of the extraction schemes used and of the analytical techniques, the Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) decided to organize a project for the improvement of the quality of determinations of extractable trace metal contents in soil and sediment. The implementation of this project follows a stepwise approach involving feasibility studies, intercomparisons to detect and remove sources of errors in the application of the analytical methods, and the certification of the extractable compounds. This paper describes the organization of the work completed so far (feasibility studies and first intercomparison) and discusses its further development.     

Effect of chloride on heavy metal mobility of harbour sediments

To evaluate the environmental impact of polluted sediments, several operationally defined sequential extraction procedures (SEPs) have been described. Salinity has long been recognised as an important variable determining the physicochemical behaviour of heavy metals in marine sediments. Thus, in the present paper, the modified BCR-SEP has been applied to harbour sediments in order to assess to what extent trace metal mobility (Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn) could be influenced by chloride content in sediments. For this, washed (W) and non-washed (NW) sediments were compared. The relative mobility order observed for the six trace metals studied was not seen to be influenced by the presence of chloride in the sediments, but an increase of mobility was observed for Cd and Zn (the most mobile metals) when chloride was present in the sediments. Characterisation of the sediments and of the pseudo-total metal contents by means of an aqua regia extraction was also assessed.     

A new quality control material for marine environmental analysis

The implementation of the European Water Framework Directive (WFD) and of the sediment-quality criteria related to the potential disposal of dredged materials is expected to involve a substantial increase in the number of chemical analyses performed in marine environmental control laboratories. The chemical characterization of sediments (metals, elemental composition, etc.) and the potential release of metals under changing environmental conditions are relevant when dealing with risk assessment. The present paper describes the preparation of a quality control material (QCM) harbor sediment carried out in a specifically equipped laboratory at the University of Barcelona. The results of homogeneity and stability studies for total metal content (Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn), extractable metal following the BCR three-step sequential extraction procedure (BCR-SEP), and total carbon content show the suitability of QCM for multi-parameter routine quality control (QC) in marine environmental laboratories.     

Mercury determination in solid phases from application of the modified BCR-sequential extraction procedure: a valuable tool for assessing its mobility in sediments

The present paper presents a feasibility study for the evaluation of mercury mobility in sediments by application of the modified BCR three-step sequential extraction procedure (BCR-SEP). The aim of the study was to evaluate the effect of acidification, reduction and oxidation processes on mercury mobility from sediments, once the SEP was validated with other trace metals.As extractable mercury amounts were mostly found below detection limits of the advanced mercury analyser (AMA-254) used for measuring the extracts (L.D.<0.5 ng), the use of a solid sampling atomic absorption spectrometer with a specially designed furnace for Hg atomisation was found to be an optimal technique to quantify Hg in the solid residues coming from the SEP.With this approach, mercury was found to be hardly mobile and only for one of the moderately polluted sediments (BCR CRM 320), extractable mercury (exchangeable fraction, BCR procedure step 1) has been found. An oxidation step with H(2)O(2) was required to obtain extractability up to 64% of the total content in a highly polluted lagoon sediment.     

Extraction procedures for the determination of heavy metals in contaminated soil and sediment

Extraction tests are commonly used to study the mobility of metals in soils and sediments by mimicking different environmental conditions or dramatic changes on them. The results obtained by determining the extractable elements are dependent on the extraction procedure applied. The paper summarises state of the art extraction procedures used for heavy metal determination in contaminated soil and sediments. Two types of extraction are considered: single and sequential. Special attention is paid to the Standard, Measurement and Testing projects from the European Commission which focused on the harmonisation of the extraction procedures and on preparing soil and sediment certified reference materials for extractable heavy metal contents.     

氧化与还原条件下伊通河长春区段沉积物重金属形态特征的对比研究

利用改进的Tessier连续萃取法研究了伊通河长春市自由大桥处不同深度沉积物样品在氧化及还原条件下Cu,Pb,Zn和Ni的形态变化规律,同时分析了沉积物样品中酸可挥发性硫(Acid volatile sulfide,AVS)和同时提取重金属(Simultaneous extract metals,SEM)的含量. 实验结果表明，样品经干燥、研磨处理后,Cu有机/硫化物结合态比例减少40%,锰氧化物结合态的比例显著增加; Pb,Zn和Ni 3种元素有机/硫化物结合态比例均略有下降,变化幅度小于Cu,并重新分配到不同的化学相中. 通过SEM中各金属含量与有机/硫化物结合态中金属含量的对比可知,还原性沉积物中Cu除了与硫化物结合外,很大一部分是以有机物形态存在的,Pb,Zn,Ni,Fe和Mn则主要以硫化物形态存在,各元素形态分析均不同程度地受到萃取剂的影响.     

Certified reference materials for the quality control of EDTA- and acetic acid-extractable contents of trace elements in sewage sludge amended soils (CRMs 483 and 484)

 The ecotoxicity and mobility of trace elements in soils are often evaluated through analytical results resulting from operationally-defined determinations (single and sequential extractions), e.g. based on EDTA, acetic acid etc. extractions. The significance and comparability of these results is highly dependent on the procedures used (standardized protocols or standards adopted by international bodies) and their quality control relies on the availability of reference materials certified following these strictly applied procedures. Recognizing the need to harmonize some of the extraction schemes currently used for soil analysis, the Measurements and Testing Programme (formerly BCR) has organized a series of interlaboratory studies, the first aim of which was to evaluate EDTA- and acetic acid-extraction procedures and the second objective was to certify reference materials for their extractable trace element contents. Two sewage amended soils have been prepared for this purpose, originating respectively from Scotland and Catalonia. This paper describes the preparation, homogeneity and stability studies, and gives an overview of the certification campaign. Received: 6 May 1996/Revised: 14 June 1996/Accepted: 27 June 1996     

Operationally defined extraction procedures for soil and sediment analysis: II. Certified reference materials

Single or sequential extraction procedures are often used for soil and sediment studies to determine forms or phases of elements (e.g. `bioavailable' forms of elements). The significance of the analytical results is highly dependent on the extraction procedures used, owing to the `operationally defined' character of these schemes which requires the adoption of standardized protocols. The first part of the present review discusses the aspects of standardization of leaching and extraction schemes as applied to environmental analysis. This second part focuses on the validation aspects of such procedures and describes the preparation and certification of soil and sediment reference materials certified for their extractable trace element contents, following standardized single and sequential extraction procedures.     

New Sediment and Soil CRMs for Extractable Trace Metal Content

Abstract

The lack of uniformity in leaching procedures used to measure broadly defined forms of heavy metals does not allow the results to be compared world-wide nor the methods to be validated since the results obtained are “operationally defined”. An attempt was made to certify several mineral soils CRMs for single extraction by using acetic acid, EDTA and DTPA for Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn. Recently, to complete the series of soil CRMs, an organically enriched soil was prepared SO25. For sediments a CRM 601 was produced and certified for metals extractable by using the BCR three step sequential extraction. Not all the trace elements were certified and only indicative values were given for some of them due to poor reproducibility. We performed a systematic study of the effect of the variables identified as potential sources of uncertainty in the use of this scheme. With this study the sources of uncertainty were revealed and an optimised version of the protocol was proposed. With this new version it was possible to certify all the trace elements studied. New sediment material S33 is now proposed for certification and additional data are given for the sediment CRM 601. This modified procedure was also applied to a soil CRM 483 and good results were obtained. This procedure may thus be applied to polluted soils.     

Microanalytical flow-through method for assessment of the bioavailability of toxic metals in environmental samples

The application of a recently proposed microanalytical flow-through system for on-line sequential extraction of heavy metals from solid samples of environmental interest is described. Using various extraction schemes (a nitric acid scheme, a two-stage extraction scheme using two reagents applied in the BCR procedure) and comparison with the common batch sequential BCR procedure, the suitability of the system for fast screening of solid environmental samples is demonstrated. By pumping leaching agents sequentially through the sample held in a micro cartridge, the different metal fractions present can be assessed in less than an hour. Method evaluation was performed using SRM 1648 urban particulate matter and BCR 701 lake sediment reference material certified for extractable metals. The need for and design of laboratory internal reference material suitable for simulating the natural (dynamic) processes of metal release into the environment is also discussed. For the first time correlation is sought between fractionation techniques and physiologically based methods for assessment of the bioaccessibility of metals in biomatrices.     

Metal Speciation - General Concepts and Applications

Abstract

Several aspects of metal speciation in sediments are reviewed: (1) Due to the instability of polluted solid materials, sample handling and storage prior to analysis is problematic. In particular, changes from reducing to oxidizing conditions, which involve transformations of sulfides and a shift to more acid conditions, increase the mobility of critical metals. (2) Simple “standard” leaching tests can be used for easily soluble components such as halides or sulfates, but in most cases are not adequate for assessing mobility of trace metals. With sequential extraction procedures rearrangements of specific solid “phases” can be evaluated prior to their actual remobilisation. (3) Estimation of long-term release of metals from solids can be made using a test procedure, which combines data from column experiments applying controlled intensivation of parameters such as pH-value, redox potential and temperature with results from sequential extraction of the contaminated solids before and after exposure. (4) Partitioning studies on materials from core profiles are particularly useful, since they provide information on relative variations of elemental phases irrespective of the method applied, and thereby an insight into diagenetic processes taking place after deposition of the sediment components. (5) The leachable fraction does not necessarily correspond to the amount available to biota. Studies on the prediction of the trace metal levels in benthic organisms have shown, that the prognostic value of sequential extraction data is improved, when the trace metal concentrations are normalized with respect to the iron (hydrous oxide) and/or organic content of the sediments.     

Comparison of the standard SM&T sequential extraction method with small-scale ultrasound-assisted single extractions for metal partitioning in sediments

A single extraction method based on the reagents employed in the SM&T (standards, measurement and testing programme) sequential extraction scheme for partitioning of Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, and Pb in sediments has been developed. Small-scale extractions adapted to electrothermal atomic absorption spectrometric determinations (i.e. 25 mg mass in 1 mL extractant) have been used for the first time in conjunction with selective reagents using conventional operating conditions (i.e. conductive heating, magnetic stirring) or ultrasound-assisted extraction. Small-scale slurry preparations were implemented for determination of the residual/total metal content. The methodology developed enabled drastic reduction of extraction times, yielding extractable contents in accordance with those obtained by application of the conventional SM&T method, which can be regarded as a standard method. An important saving in the amount of sample and reagents is also achieved with small-scale extractions. Homogeneity of sediments at the mg level proved acceptable - precision was similar for between-batch and within-batch measurements. Method development was performed with CRM BCR 601 lake sediment for which extractable amounts of several metals are known. An application to a "real-world" sediment is also presented.     

Determination of trace metals in the River Ye?il?rmak sediments in Tokat, Turkey using sequential extraction procedure

Sequential extraction procedure (acid extractable, reducible, oxidizable, and residual) proposed by BCR was applied for the determination of trace metals in the River Yesilirmak sediments, Tokat, Turkey. The determination of trace metals in sediment samples was performed by flame atomic absorption spectrometry. The proposed method showed satisfactory recovery, detection limits and standard deviation for trace metals determination in sediment samples. Generally, most of the elements were found in the oxidizable and residual fractions. The total concentrations of trace metals analyzed were found to be (mg/kg) Cu: 37.9, Mn: 392.2, Zn: 126.2, Fe: 3726, and Pb: 29.6, respectively. Results obtained are in agreement with data reported in the literature.     

Operationally defined extraction procedures for soil and sediment analysis: II. Certified reference materials

Single or sequential extraction procedures are often used for soil and sediment studies to determine forms or phases of elements (e.g. ‘bioavailable' forms of elements). The significance of the analytical results is highly dependent on the extraction procedures used, owing to the ‘operationally defined' character of these schemes which requires the adoption of standardized protocols. The first part of the present review discusses the aspects of standardization of leaching and extraction schemes as applied to environmental analysis. This second part focuses on the validation aspects of such procedures and describes the preparation and certification of soil and sediment reference materials certified for their extractable trace element contents, following standardized single and sequential extraction procedures.     

Different strategies to assess Cu and Pb mobilization in polluted river sediments

Summary For studying the mechanisms of trace metal mobilization in sediments several strategies have been employed, such as single extraction, sequential extractions, ion exchange, or progressive acidification. Several authors assert that sequential extraction is the best option. In this study two procedures are used in order to assess the mobility of copper and lead in heavily polluted river sediments: sequential extraction using a modified Tessier procedure, and progressive acidification, using an automated method. Six heavily polluted sediment samples are studied by applying the two procedures. The amount of metal released at different pH-values (pH 5 and pH 2) is compared with the resulting distribution when the sequential extraction procedure is applied. The information obtained from the two different approaches is discussed. For both metals a different behaviour is observed when applying each of the two procedures. Thus, copper is more easily released than lead when progressive acidification is followed, whereas an inverse situation is observed when sequential extraction is applied.