Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mechanism revisited

Although matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) was developed more than a decade ago and broad applications have been successfully demonstrated, detailed mechanism of MALDI is still not well understood. Two major models; namely photochemical ionization (PI) and cluster ionization (CI) mechanisms have been proposed to explain many of experimental results. With the photochemical ionization model, analyte ions are considered to be produced from a protonation or deprotonation process involving an analyte molecule colliding with a matrix ion in the gas phase. With the cluster ionization model, charged particles are desorbed with a strong photoabsorption by matrix molecules. Analyte ions are subsequently produced by desolvation of matrix from cluster ions. Nevertheless, many observations still cannot be explained by these two models. In this work, we consider a pseudo proton transfer process during crystallization as a primary mechanism for producing analyte ions in MALDI. We propose an energy transfer induced disproportionation (ETID) model to explain the observation of an equal amount of positive and negative ions produced in MALDI for large biomolecules. Some experimental results are used for comparisons of various models.     

A perspective on MALDI alternatives—total solvent‐free analysis and electron transfer dissociation of highly charged ions by laserspray ionization

Progress in research is hindered by analytical limitations, especially in biological areas in which sensitivity and dynamic range are critical to success. Inherent difficulties of characterization associated with complexity arising from heterogeneity of various materials including topologies (isomeric composition) and insolubility also limit progress. For this reason, we are developing methods for total solvent‐free analysis by mass spectrometry consisting of solvent‐free ionization followed by solvent‐free gas‐phase separation. We also recently constructed a novel matrix‐assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) source that provides a simple, practical and sensitive way of producing highly charged ions by laserspray ionization (LSI) or singly charged ions commonly observed with MALDI by choice of matrix or matrix preparation. This is the first ionization source with such freedom—an extremely powerful analytical ‘switch’. Multiply charged LSI ions allow molecules exceeding the mass‐to‐charge range of the instrument to be observed and permit for the first time electron transfer dissociation fragment ion analysis. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Laserspray ionization (LSI) ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) mass spectrometry

A simple device is described for desolvation of highly charged matrix/analyte clusters produced by laser ablation leading to multiply charged ions that are analyzed by ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry. Thus, for example, highly charged ions of ubiquitin and lysozyme are cleanly separated in the gas phase according to size and mass (shape and molecular weight) as well as charge using Tri-Wave ion mobility technology coupled to mass spectrometry. This contribution confirms the mechanistic argument that desolvation is necessary to produce multiply charged matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) ions and points to how these ions can be routinely formed on any atmospheric pressure mass spectrometer.     

Production and fragmentation of multiply charged ions in 'electron-free' matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization

An unusually large fraction of multiply charged ions is observed in 'electron-free' matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI). Here we investigate how the yield of multiply charged ions depends on experimental parameters in MALDI. It is found to increase if measures are taken to limit the number of electrons in the plume, for example, by using non-metallic MALDI targets or low laser pulse energies. The ionization energy of the matrix is another important parameter that affects the yield of multiply charged ions: matrices with high ionization energies lead to greater intensities of multiply charged ions. It is furthermore proposed that some of the fragment ions observed in MALDI are due to reactions of analyte with electrons in the plume. The possibility of electron capture dissociation of multiply charged ions produced by MALDI is shown.     

Unusual Analyte-Matrix Adduct Ions and Mechanism of Their Formation in MALDI TOF MS of Benzene-1,3,5-Tricarboxamide and Urea Compounds

Analyte-matrix adducts are normally absent under typical matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI TOF MS) conditions. Interestingly, though, in the analysis of several types of organic compounds synthesized in our laboratory, analyte-matrix adduct ion peaks were always recorded when common MALDI matrices such as 4-hydroxy-α-cyanocinnamic acid (CHCA) were used. These compounds are mainly those with a benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamide (BTA) or urea moiety, which are important building blocks to make new functional supramolecular materials. The possible mechanism of the adduct formation was investigated. A shared feature of the compounds studied is that they can form intermolecular hydrogen bonding with matrices like CHCA. The intermolecular hydrogen bonding will make the association between analyte ions and matrix molecules stronger. As a result, the analyte ions and matrix molecules in MALDI clusters will become more difficult to be separated from each other. Furthermore, it was found that analyte ions were mainly adducted with matrix salts, which is probably due to the much lower volatility of the salts compared with that of their corresponding matrix acids. It seems that the analyte-matrix adduct formation for our compounds are caused by the incomplete evaporation of matrix molecules from the MALDI clusters because of the combined effects of enhanced intermolecular interaction between analyte-matrix and of the low volatility of matrix salts. Based on these findings, strategies to suppress the analyte-matrix adduction are briefly discussed. In return, the positive results of using these strategies support the proposed mechanism of the analyte-matrix adduct formation.

A Mechanism for Ionization of Nonvolatile Compounds in Mass Spectrometry: Considerations from MALDI and Inlet Ionization

Mechanistic arguments relative to matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry (MS) address observations that predominately singly charged ions are detected. However, recently a matrix assisted laser ablation method, laserspray ionization (LSI), was introduced that can use the same sample preparation and laser as MALDI, but produce highly charged ions from proteins. In MALDI, ions are generated from neutral molecules by the photon energy provided to a matrix, while in LSI ions are produced inside a heated inlet tube linking atmospheric pressure and the first vacuum region of the mass spectrometer. Some LSI matrices also produce highly charged ions with MALDI ion sources operated at intermediate pressure or high vacuum. The operational similarity of LSI to MALDI, and the large difference in charge states observed by these methods, provides information of fundamental importance to proposed ionization mechanisms for LSI and MALDI. Here, we present data suggesting that the prompt and delayed ionization reported for vacuum MALDI are both fast processes relative to producing highly charged ions by LSI. The energy supplied to produce these charged clusters/droplets as well as their size and time available for desolvation are determining factors in the charge states of the ions observed. Further, charged droplets/clusters may be a common link for ionization of nonvolatile compounds by a variety of MS ionization methods, including MALDI and LSI.     

Gas-phase ionization/desolvation processes and their effect on protein charge state distribution under matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization conditions

The charge state distribution of proteins was studied as a function of experimental conditions, to improve the understanding of the matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mechanisms. The relative abundances of the multiply-charged ions appear to be a function of the matrix chosen, the laser fluence and the matrix-to-analyte molar ratio. A correlation is found between the matrix proton affinity and the yield of singly- versus multiply-charged ions. These results are in good agreement with a model in which gas-phase intracluster reactions play a significant role in analyte ion formation. A new model for endothermic desolvation processes in ultraviolet/MALDI is presented and discussed. It is based upon the existence of highly-charged precursor clusters and, complementary to the ion survivor model of Karas et al., assumes that two energy-dependent processes exist: (i) a soft desolvation involving consecutive losses of neutral matrix molecules, leading to a multiply-charged analyte and (ii) hard desolvation leading to a low charge state analyte, by consecutive losses of charged matrix molecules. These desolvations pathways are discussed in terms of kinetically limited processes. The efficiency of the two competitive desolvation processes seems related to the internal energy carried away by clusters during ablation.     

Formation of Metal-Related Ions in Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption Ionization

In a study of the metal-related ion generation mechanism in matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI), crystals of matrix used in MALDI were grown from matrix- and salt-containing solutions. The intensities of metal ion and metal adducts of the matrix ion obtained from unwashed crystals were higher than those from crystals washed with deionized water, indicating that metal ions and metal adducts of the matrix ions are mainly generated from the surface of crystals. The contributions of preformed metal ions and metal adducts of the matrix ions inside the matrix crystals were minor. Metal adducts of the matrix and analyte ion intensities generated from a mixture of dried matrix, salt, and analyte powders were similar to or higher than those generated from the powder of dried droplet crystals, indicating that the contributions of the preformed metal adducts of the matrix and analyte ions were insignificant. Correlation between metal-related ion intensity fluctuation and protonated ion intensity fluctuation was observed, indicating that the generation mechanism of the metal-related ions is similar to that of the protonated ions. Because the thermally induced proton transfer model effectively describes the generation of the protonated ions, we suggest that metal-related ions are mainly generated from the salt dissolution in the matrix melted by the laser.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract ?

     

Matrix suppression and analyte suppression effects of quaternary ammonium salts in matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry: an investigation of suppression mechanism

In the matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry (MALDI TOF MS) analysis of some quaternary ammonium salts (QASs), very clean spectra of the quaternary ammonium ions were recorded with a strong matrix suppression effect (MSE). The QASs also showed a considerable analyte suppression effect (ASE). It was demonstrated that the MSE and ASE of the QASs can be explained well by the cluster ionization model. According to this model, MALDI ions are formed from charged matrix/analyte clusters. Various analyte ions and matrix ions might coexist in the cluster, and they will compete for the limited number of net charges available. If enough quaternary ammonium ions are present in the cluster, they will take away the net charges, thus resulting in the MSE and ASE. Our results also suggest that ‘the cluster ionization model’ is not in conflict with ‘the theory of ionization via secondary gas‐phase reactions’. The initial MALDI ions produced from charged matrix/analyte clusters will collide with other molecules or ions in the MALDI plume. Depending on the properties of the initial ions and the composition of the MALDI plume, secondary gas‐phase reactions might result from these collisions. The final ions observed are the combined results of ‘cluster ionization’ and ‘ionization via secondary gas‐phase reactions’. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Compelling Evidence for Lucky Survivor and Gas Phase Protonation: The Unified MALDI Analyte Protonation Mechanism

This work experimentally verifies and proves the two long since postulated matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) analyte protonation pathways known as the Lucky Survivor and the gas phase protonation model. Experimental differentiation between the predicted mechanisms becomes possible by the use of deuterated matrix esters as MALDI matrices, which are stable under typical sample preparation conditions and generate deuteronated reagent ions, including the deuterated and deuteronated free matrix acid, only upon laser irradiation in the MALDI process. While the generation of deuteronated analyte ions proves the gas phase protonation model, the detection of protonated analytes by application of deuterated matrix compounds without acidic hydrogens proves the survival of analytes precharged from solution in accordance with the predictions from the Lucky Survivor model. The observed ratio of the two analyte ionization processes depends on the applied experimental parameters as well as the nature of analyte and matrix. Increasing laser fluences and lower matrix proton affinities favor gas phase protonation, whereas more quantitative analyte protonation in solution and intramolecular ion stabilization leads to more Lucky Survivors. The presented results allow for a deeper understanding of the fundamental processes causing analyte ionization in MALDI and may alleviate future efforts for increasing the analyte ion yield.     

Alkali cation attachment to derivatized fullerenes studied by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization

The complexation of alkali metal ions with amphiphilic fullerene derivatives has been investigated by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometry. The formation of analyte ions occurs via two competing mechanisms including electron transfer from matrix-derived ions and metal ion attachment. The interplay of these processes has been examined by laser fluence dependent sample activation and by variation of the target composition. The attachment of metal ions has been established as the gentler and thus more efficient route towards the formation of intact analyte ions. Investigations into the metal ion complexation have been conducted to reveal the reactivity order of the alkali metals in these reactions and to elucidate the influence of structural differences of the analytes, as well as to unravel effects caused by the anionic counter ion of the metal. The experimental data have been derived by two complementary approaches. Competing reactants were either studied simultaneously, so that the product distribution would provide direct insight into the reactivity pattern, and/or product distributions were obtained in a large variety of separate experiments and normalized for reliable comparison. It has been found that the extent to which complexation is observed follows the charge density order of the alkali metal ions. The structural features of the fullerene-attached ligands were of profound influence on the attachment of the metal ion, inducing enhanced selectivity for the complexation with less reactive metals. The metal ion attachment is reduced with the use of smaller anionic counter ions. Rationalization of these findings is provided within the framework of the mechanisms of ion formation in MALDI.     

9,10‐Diphenylanthracene as a matrix for MALDI‐MS electron transfer secondary reactions

The most common secondary‐ionization mechanism in positive ion matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) involves a proton transfer reaction to ionize the analyte. Peptides and proteins are molecules that have basic (and acidic) sites that make them susceptible to proton transfer. However, non‐polar, aprotic compounds that lack basic sites are more difficult to protonate, and creating charged forms of this type of analyte can pose a problem when conventional MALDI matrices are employed. In this case, forming a radical molecular ion through electron transfer is a viable alternative, and certain matrices may facilitate the process. In this work, we investigate the performance of a newly developed electron‐transfer secondary reaction matrix: 9,10‐diphenylanthracene (9,10‐DPA). The use of 9,10‐DPA as matrix for MALDI analysis has been tested using several model compounds. It appears to promote ionization through electron transfer in a highly efficient manner as compared to other potential matrices. Thermodynamic aspects of the observed electron transfers in secondary‐ionization reactions were also considered, as was the possibility for kinetically controlled/endothermic, electron‐transfer reactions in the MALDI plume. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Quantitative reproducibility of mass spectra in matrix‐assisted laser desorption ionization and unraveling of the mechanism for gas‐phase peptide ion formation

In a previous study on matrix‐assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) of peptides using α‐cyano‐4‐hydroxycinnamic acid (CHCA) as a matrix, we found that the patterns of single‐shot spectra obtained under different experimental conditions became similar upon temperature selection. In this paper, we report that absolute ion abundances are also similar in temperature‐selected MALDI spectra, even when laser fluence is varied. The result that has been obtained using CHCA and 2,5‐dihydroxybenzoic acid as matrices is in disagreement with the hypothesis of laser‐induced ionization of matrix as the mechanism for primary ion formation in MALDI. We also report that the total number of ions in such a spectrum is unaffected by the identity, concentration and number of analytes, i.e. it is the same as that in the spectrum of pure matrix. We propose that the generation of gas‐phase ions in MALDI can be explained in terms of two thermal reactions, i.e. the autoprotolysis of matrix molecules and the matrix‐to‐analyte proton transfer, both of which are in quasi‐equilibrium in the early matrix plume. Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Degree of Ionization in MALDI of Peptides: Thermal Explanation for the Gas-Phase Ion Formation

Degree of ionization (DI) in matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) was measured for five peptides using α-cyano-4-hydroxycinnanmic acid (CHCA) as the matrix. DIs were low 10(-4) for peptides and 10(-7) for CHCA. Total number of ions (i.e., peptide plus matrix) was the same regardless of peptides and their concentration, setting the number of gas-phase ions generated from a pure matrix as the upper limit to that of peptide ions. Positively charged cluster ions were too weak to support the ion formation via such ions. The total number of gas-phase ions generated by MALDI, and that from pure CHCA, was unaffected by the laser pulse energy, invalidating laser-induced ionization of matrix molecules as the mechanism for the primary ion formation. Instead, the excitation of matrix by laser is simply a way of supplying thermal energy to the sample. Accepting strong Coulomb attraction felt by cations in a solid sample, we propose three hypotheses for gas-phase peptide ion formation. In Hypothesis 1, they originate from the dielectrically screened peptide ions in the sample. In Hypothesis 2, the preformed peptide ions are released as part of neutral ion pairs, which generate gas-phase peptide ions via reaction with matrix-derived cations. In Hypothesis 3, neutral peptides released by ablation get protonated via reaction with matrix-derived cations.     

Charge-remote fragmentation of lithiated fatty acids on a TOF-TOF instrument using matrix-ionization

In numerous studies charge remote fragmentation (CRF) has been shown to be a powerful technique for determination of primary structure by allowing location of double bonds, various functional groups, and branching in a variety of compound types directly by mass spectrometry. Instrumentation and ionization methods traditionally used for CRF, however, are becoming rare, in large part because ESI and MALDI have to a significant extent replaced them. Here we demonstrate that by selecting a matrix that promotes rather than suppresses ionization of fatty acids (FA) by lithium ion adduction, and using a TOF-TOF mass spectrometer for high-energy collisional activation, CRF ions are produced that allow location of double-bond and branching positions. Further, we show that by using solvent-free MALDI sample preparation methods, thus eliminating the inherent segregation of the hydrophobic fatty acid from the hydrophilic LiCl that can occur during the evaporation of solvent, the desired [FA-H+2Li](+) ions are greatly enhanced. Because FAs can be vaporized using laser desorption, matrix assistance in desorption of the fatty acid may occur, but is not necessary. However, the matrix plays a crucial role in enhancing or suppressing ionization. For example, matrix materials with acid (e.g., 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid) or hydroxy groups (e.g., dithranol) compete with the FA for Li(+) and because of the high ratio of matrix to analyte, FA lithium adduction is minimized. However, highly electron-deficient matrix materials (e.g., TCNQ) readily donate Li(+) to FAs because of the instability associated with being positively charged.     

Adduct-ion formation in trapped ion mobility spectrometry as a potential tool for studying molecular structures and conformations

Recent developments in the field of ion mobility spectrometry provide new possibilities to explore and understand gas-phase ion chemistry. In this study, hyphenated trapped ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (TIMS-MS) was applied to investigate analyte ion mobility as function of adduct ion formation for twelve pharmaceutically relevant molecules, and for tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) and its isomer cannabidiol (CBD). Samples were introduced by direct infusion and ions were generated with positive electrospray ionization (ESI+) observing protonated and sodiated ions. Measurements were performed with and without addition of cesium-, lithium-, silver- and sodium ions to the samples. For the tested compounds, metal adduct ions with the same m/z but with different mobility and collision cross section (CCSs) were observed, indicating different molecular conformations. Formation of analyte dimers was also observed, which could be associated with molecular geometry of the compounds. By optimizing the range and speed of the electric field gradient and ramp, respectively, the separation of THC and CBD was achieved by employing the adduct formation. This study demonstrates that the favorable resolution of TIMS combined with the ability to detect weakly bound counter ions is a valuable means for rapid detection, separation and structural assignment of molecular isomers and analyte conformations.     

Characterization of charge separation in the array of Micromachined UltraSonic Electrospray (AMUSE) ion source for mass spectrometry

An initial investigation into the effects of charge separation in the Array of Micromachined UltraSonic Electrospray (AMUSE) ion source is reported to gain understanding of ionization mechanisms and to improve analyte ionization efficiency and operation stability. In RF-only mode, AMUSE ejects, on average, an equal number of slightly positive and slightly negative charged droplets due to random charge fluctuations, providing inefficient analyte ionization. Charge separation at the nozzle orifice is achieved by the application of an external electric field. By bringing the counter electrode close to the nozzle array, strong electric fields can be applied at relatively low DC potentials. It has been demonstrated, through a number of electrode/electrical potential configurations, that increasing charge separation leads to improvement in signal abundance, signal-to-noise ratio, and signal stability.     

The nature of collision-induced dissociation processes of doubly protonated peptides: comparative study for the future use of matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization on a hybrid quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer in proteomics.

Comparative MS/MS studies of singly and doubly charged electrospray ionization (ESI) and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) precursor peptide ions are described. The spectra from these experiments have been evaluated with particular emphasis on the data quality for subsequent data processing and protein/amino acid sequence identification. It is shown that, once peptide ions are formed by ESI or MALDI, their charge state, as well as the collision energy, is the main parameter determining the quality of collision-induced dissociation (CID) MS/MS fragmentation spectra of a given peptide. CID-MS/MS spectra of singly charged peptides obtained on a hybrid quadrupole orthogonal time-of-flight mass spectrometer resemble very closely spectra obtained by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization post-source decay time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-PSD-TOFMS). On the other hand, comparison of CID-MS/MS spectra of either singly or doubly charged ion species shows no dependence on whether ions have been formed by ESI or MALDI. This observation confirms that, at the time of precursor ion selection, further mass analysis is effectively decoupled from the desorption/ionization event. Since MALDI ions are predominantly formed as singly charged species and ESI ions as doubly charged, the associated difference in the spectral quality of MS/MS spectra as described here imposes direct consequences on data processing, database searching using ion fragmentation data, and de novo sequencing when ionization techniques are changed.     

Fragmentation of organic ions bearing fixed multiple charges observed in MALDI MS

Matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry (MALDI TOF MS) was used to analyze a series of synthetic organic ions bearing fixed multiple charges. Despite the multiple intrinsic charges, only singly charged ions were recorded in each case. In addition to the pseudo‐molecular ions formed by counterion adduction, deprotonation and electron capture, a number of fragment ions were also observed. Charge splitting by fragmentation was found to be a viable route for charge reduction leading to the formation of the observed singly charged fragment ions. Unlike multivalent metal ions, organic ions can rearrange and/or fragment during charge reduction. This fragmentation process will evidently complicate the interpretation of the MALDI MS spectrum. Because MALDI MS is usually considered as a soft ionization technique, the fragment ion peaks can easily be erroneously interpreted as impurities. Therefore, the awareness and understanding of the underlying MALDI‐induced fragmentation pathways is essential for a proper interpretation of the corresponding mass spectra. Due to the fragment ions generated during charge reduction, special care should be taken in the MALDI MS analysis of multiply charged ions. In this work, the possible mechanisms by which the organic ions bearing fixed multiple charges fragment are investigated. With an improved understanding of the fragmentation mechanisms, MALDI TOF MS should still be a useful technique for the characterization of organic ions with fixed multiple charges.     

Reduction of organic dyes in matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization and desorption/ionization on porous silicon

Reduction of analytes in matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) often obscures the actual determination of molecular structure. To address the redox reactions in laser desorption/ionization processes, the organic dyes Methylene Blue, Janus Green B, Crystal Violet and Rhodamine B were analyzed by MALDI or by desorption/ionization on porous silicon (DIOS). Susceptibility to reduction in MALDI was dependent on both the reduction potentials of analytes and the molar ratio of analyte to matrix molecules. Addition of Cu(II) ions as an electron scavenger suppressed the reduction of Methylene Blue in MALDI. The results suggested that electron transfer to analytes from the sample target and/or from the matrix contributed to the reduction. In DIOS, the reductions of organic dyes were more prominent than in MALDI, and were not prevented by Cu(II) ion doping, probably due to direct contact of the analytes with silicon which had little electric resistance.